To support underprivileged students visit: lmesfoundation.com ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Find your Career interest at pickmycareer.in Email: support@pickmycareer.in Find Premanand Sethurajan's career Report link at pickmycareer.in/posts -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- PIckmycareer is free for Government school students. if you are a government school student check the video and register for free: ruclips.net/video/uSGYg4qbgqM/видео.html
I think this system could be better if the school take it seriously mainly the middle and secondary stage are more important for the future of the students.
I am a professor. With my personal experience as a teacher and as a student, I can tell u that 99% of the students understand their skills and interests only after their 22-25th age. This is y u can able to see many serious carrier switches like doctor to IPS, IT professional to farmer, musician and so on... I even used to say that voters right age must be postponed to 25 from 18. Students won't have enough idea about their future in their school age. Please don't compare foreign countries as their college going % is very less. Their college dropout % is also too high. In the u.s the scientists from NASA and other engineers and doctors used to visit school students to motivate them to study doctor or engineer in the future. This will happen here as well...
yes, u r right... usually in a society, all the students arent naturally genius... 99.9 percent students are like normal students who understandts it lately after 22 as u said... But think about that remaining 0.1 percent naturally curious little genius students. Those are the few who make big things!!!... The nation which makes those 0.1% to achieve their goals will shine at all... we cant make everybody genius, and THERE IS NO NEED to make everybody genius!!!. Make those 0.1% to shine, then their philosophy or inventions or ability will make entire world to shine... but namma India maathiri countries la, ellarayum arivaali aakanum nu solli, oru mokkayaana, mandhamaana education policy a uruvaaki, atha ella students ayum follow panna vaikuraanga🤦🤦. ithanaala muttaal aa irukkura pasanga and curiousity ye illama irukura pasanga ellarum oaralavuku average students aa maaridaraan, but adhe samayam "thiramayaana pasangalum avanga kooda seanthu kadaisi varaikum AVERAGE aave irunthidaraan"..😢 this is why india la ennathaan koadi koadiya padichaalum oruthanum shine aaga maatikiran, and sports la sollave thevai illa, 125 crore population, but single olympic medal vaanga mukkurom... its because our education system makes everybody as average...
sundar pichai maathiri oru student a india vaala vechi iruntha, inniki avan latcham indians a vaala vechirupaan. elon musk maathiri oru student a africa use panni iruntha, inniki satellite launch panna solli america kitta kenja veandiya nilamai south africa ku vanthu irukaathu...
Yes sir. You right . 18 years old students little unable to think Enjoyed the right to vote value. This is not Age problem its problem of society sir. So, we teach them " why we vote ? " first of all we learn that " why we vote & what is real value on vote " And your very right . Motivation most important think to students for engaged the our own dreams. & Thank you sir.
orton cap sundar pichai is outcome of our earlier education system and that said 0.1 percent will do even without this vayula vada sudura education policy
Qualified teachers are there but no mechanism to monitor them in real time. Government should form a sperate department to monitor the performance of every teacher and should give KRA for every month. Problem with our government is simply going behind 'Vote politics' that's why playing a safe game with government employees.
எங்க அம்மா அப்பா இத எங்களோட சின்ன வயசுல பண்ணாங்க... அம்மா அப்பா தெலுங்கு வீட்ல பேசுவாங்க... ஆனா எங்க கிட்ட தமிழ் தான் பேசுவாங்க...நங்க reason கேட்ட அப்ப படிக்கும் போது நீங்க confuse ஆக கூடாதுனு தான் நாங்க தமிழ் choose பண்ணோம் அப்டின்னு சொன்னாங்க... Now I'm a IT professional , still i will learn everything by using Tamil which helps me to understand well...
Prem அண்ணா சொன்ன ஒரு point ரொம்ப சரி. Japan ல நான் கொஞ்ச நாள் இருந்தேன். நாம் எப்படி UPSC எழுதி IAS try பன்றமோ . அங்க அந்த அளவு calibre அஹ் ஒரு teacher test பண்ணுவாங்க . இங்க ஒரு IAS officer கு கிடைக்கும் respect Salary Japan ல இருக்கும் teacher கு கிடைக்கும். சோ திறமையான ஒரு தர் தான் டீச்சர் ஆக முடியும். அவங்க நல்ல students develop பண்ணுவாங்க. 130 கோடி மக்கள் இருந்தும் இன்னும் france ட weapon வாங்கும் இழிவு நிலை இத நாள் தான். Teacher UPSC வச்சு எடுத்து போடணும். நல்ல Respect salary தரணும். நாடு நிச்சயம் முன்னேறும். Edit 1: எனக்கு நிறைய பேர் govt teachers நிறைய salary vanguranga னு reply பண்ணி இருக்கீங்க Yes உண்மை தான். I admit. என்னோட point என்ன நா . Government teachers are highly paid. சொன்ன மாதி அத சும்மா குடுக்காமா. அவ்ளோ salary வாங்குற ஒருத்தர் proper Upsc screening pona தான் சரி னு சொல்றன். Just like that ஒரு IAS ஆகிட முடியாது அதே போல் ல டீச்சர் ஆகிட முடியாது. ஒரு பெரிய trend ல change வரணும். School கூட நண்பன் film CLIMAX ல வர மாதி Practical and application based அஹ் கொண்டுவரனும். Ground reality ல நிச்சயம் முடியும். அப்புறம் இந்தியா ல தெருக்கு தெரு வள்ளுவர், சுந்தர் பிச்சை, einstein , Newton இருப்பாங்க.
Government school teachers are highly paid... For more than What they deliver.... Private school teachers are paid less... Most of them deliver more than what they are paid... One more is reservations in teaching profession....
@@lakshmipathyduraiswamy6973 govt school teachers are highly paid.. This thing I accept.. But what is that "than what they deliver"... Don't talk commonly abt all govt school teachers. I have seen many sincere govt school teachers who have sent their students to top colleges.. Think and talk..
Then quality teacher is also required and reservation is also required. I think both can't come together. If reservation is based on economy basis, it will be good.
Need to improve teacher skills is very more important and also teacher need to explain the concept by the way of easily reaching the students mind... 99% has hate the education that should be changed..Make the students as interested candidates on education.. Every day they should learn something from school.. These way our future kids are more intelligence than ourselves #jaihind
correct bro. But you said waiting the implementation process how is going on nu. ஆன பிஜேபி ப்னிஸிங் எப்பவுமே சரி இருக்காது(got knowledge from previous schemes)... Demonetisation big example every point having some hidden reasons too...
Valid point: Teacher's must be very talanted and have periodic appraisal for their knowledge updation. I personally saw while my schooling. Most of the staffs (Not all few staffs are good teachers too) are not updated and spending time unnecessary in Govt. Schools.
@@deepanraj6585 பார்த்தேன் சகோ. புதிய கல்வி கொள்கை வரைவு கிடைக்குமா? அவர் அவர் அவர்களுக்கு தெரிந்த விஷயங்களை கூறுகின்றனர். நாம் முழுமையாக பார்க்க வேண்டும்.
I read the 60 page NEP 2020 report and this is exactly how I felt! On paper, everything about India is good. Even the Indian healthcare system is the best on paper (not many countries give free medicines/drugs along with free healthcare) But when the implementation gets screwed up on so many levels, it is almost impossible to execute them in practice. Underprivileged/rural students have more to lose. When there is no uniform education in the country how can one think that the uniform examination/evaluation is FAIR. The playing field was never even! Thanks for your video
After decades of "Independence" as of 2012, those languishing below the poverty line is said to be 170 million people! And we are talking about uniform examination while encouraging different types of schools - for the poor, for the middle class, for the rich, for the opulent rich...
Well said LMES. I, as a government school teacher, agree with you. I welcome the New Education Policy. Though there are a few unacceptable factors (like board exam for 3rd and 5 th std pupils, unified entrance exam) and practically improbable (at this point of time) points, the Policy, overall, gives satisfaction for many of us. I expect more emphasis to mother tongue, infrastructure development in future... One of the heartening things for me is testing teacher's ability in regular intervals. The major disappointment on Govt School teacher is their ability. But in fact, they have already proven their ability by passing TRB, TET exams. But many of the teachers don't update themselves. The New Policy will force them updated for sure. That's a good sign. Those lazy, incapable teachers' quality will be upgraded so that the quality of Govt School education will develop. As you said, the victory lies on implementation of the Policy.... Let's wait and see. Let's educate all... 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
Don't worry about the Board Exams for 3rd, 5th and 8th students. They may be called as Board Exams and may get External Invigilation but the students will all be the same and won't bother much about their marks. Moreover the teachers also won't care much about those small fry board exams. And by the time they all get to the 12th Boards, which indeed is serious exam, they all will be accustomed to the Board Exam stress and atmosphere. The suicide rates of 12th students will significantly reduce as by the time they reach 12th they wouldn't bother much about scoring less marks.
@@saiyaninjafromvillagehidde8115 Yes sir. But Board Exam to 8 years old kids is too much... We used to see our rural school children daily. Most of them aren't able to hold their plates... How will they handle the mental pressure created by their parents, teachers, etc.. The society still look at marks as talent.... I agree your words that by the time they reach 12th, they will know how to manage things. But how about the early pressure...? Let's see... Time has answer for everything... 😂😂😂
@@AnandCd Our society is really not that foolish. They will not really put too much pressure upon the 8yr olds to score marks. What I'm trying to say is that the concept of Board Exam won't be a big deal anymore for the students as they already have got exposed to it from younger ages. The society will also stop making a big fuss about BOARD EXAMS and it will be looked at just like another exam. The mature or the previlaged (that is a matter of luck) ones will ace the exams while the others will also pass. Meaningless final moment stress and student suicide rates will also drastically reduce.
@@saiyaninjafromvillagehidde8115 Rightly said sir. What all our wish is this... We should give our future masters the best education without any prejudice... Hope we'll achive it...
@Sam Ram Govt of India, no matter what era, has always tried to provide equality as much as possible, but still our people find some loopholes in their plans and thus nothing has ever gone exactly according to the Govt's plans. But despite of that India has made some good progress and is better at something than many countries. If the Govt tries to become strict with it's actions then the greedy opposition and some foolish people start calling it as DICTATORSHIP LAW ENFORCEMENT and VIOLATION OF RIGHTS. This has been the major problem with our society. And of course this is one of the primary reasons why rural area people haven't developed enough yet that they get equal opportunities as the people in the cities. This education system will be successful but it'll take time. Govt will also start making new reforms to give the underprevilaged better chances. But for this all to happen the politicians and unoptimistic researchers must keep their mouth shut for a while and let the others cooperate with the Govt and it's plan for a while. This system has more positives than negatives and yes this is far better than the previous one. Slowly but surely courses like engineering (anybody's course these days) will start getting more value and only the capable will get to study engineering.
As a student, I firmly oppose your stand here. NEP promises a bright policy, but the effects could be quite the opposite. Nep has several disadvantages such as uniform entrance exam, board exam for class 3,5,8, mother tongue education, etc. And what about the diploma offered when you don't complete your degree? According to Nep, students who do not complete the 4 year term of their degree can get a diploma for the number of Years they attended college. This is a huge drawback which will noticeably increase the dropout rate. 2:58 : In case of education in the mother tongue, it is highly impossible for a diverse country like India to implement, because if children move from one state to another, them adapting to the language of that state is a huge challenge. This will definitely undermine their learning if they switch states. 3:22 Teaching english only as a language and not as the medium would decrease the proficiency of their presenting and communication skills, much needed when they move out for jobs all over the country or to international platforms. English is an accepted international language for communication, and teaching in that medium would make kids easily adapt to society after finishing school. 3:58 as said above, India has many languages. The countries you've mentioned have largely only one language nationwide, so that system is applicable for them. 5:44 I firmly oppose your statement here, because as you know, the nep policy says there will board exams for class 3,5, 8, and so on, and if ever they fail in the 5th board exam, it would definitely lead them to choose the vocational training, while it is a very early age for deciding a child's potential and the job, and this doesn't consider a space for late blomers. This will surely lead to more dropouts, especially in rural areas and poor families, and India has 27% of people living below poverty line. 7:30 Multidisciplinary study might lead to students learning a mixture of irrelevant subjects. Each group in the existing system has access to specific jobs the child would want to persue. In the existing system we already have freedom to choose subjects in the Optional. Also according to nep, students with a non- science background in higher secondary can opt for medical courses in college. The effects of this can be dangerous. 7:48 This is absolutely UNACCEPTABLE. Please understand that many students today opt for their streams based on their interests and not based on score. As a student I see others study science while having low score and commerce students having more than 70%. Please step out of your stigma. Overall, Nep is a highly impossible policy, let alone acceptable. The outcome might even be the exact opposite of what it promises.
Your 1st, 2nd and 3rd are contradicting on it's own when you say English is international language then why can't it be used to communicate with other states?😂😂😅
First they must bring an upgrade training & improving skills of teachers ( millions of teachers) to implement this policy. Without doing, 80% of teachers will not be able create strong fundamentals for students. This will create confusion and ineffectiveness in the education system. They have to improve the teachers standard before bringing this change
7.45 I accept becoz after 10th I was denied for science group though I took above 75% overall and 55% in science then I took tc joined in other school science group got medicine seat now infected with covid 19 due to covid duty last week.
City students have lots of option for any kind of coaching to score high compated to village schools of all over India. On this Please consider all over india.this is completely against poor students those who are coming from rural villages.
Well said, exactly what I have felt on this system. Ofcourse there might be some challenges while implementing but if it is successfully implemented it will greatly improve the next generations vision on all kinds of jobs and rather than a stress kids will enjoy doing and parent (our generation) also can motivate them in all kinds of jobs. The implementation part like you said, is the challenging ine, it should be implemented in a way where foreign universities have professors who are scientists too, and this should be distributed all over the state/country and many visiting teachers should be encouraged which will never supress the students from asking questions. Rather than being a business education should now atleast become a necessity that government should handle. I beleive future india will be so intelligent if the vision is implemented unanimously. Hoping to see the future 🤞
I feel that before implementing new policy for student education, govt should implement new policy for teachers ( about qualification, updating their knowledge, exams for teachers)
வணக்கம் பிரேம் அண்ணா, புதிய கல்விக் கொள்கை பற்றி ஒரு சிறப்பான காணொளி அளித்துள்ளீர்கள், சில சந்தேகங்கள் மற்றும் எதிர்மறை பார்வைகளுக்கு நல்ல விளக்கமும் அளித்துள்ளீர்கள் சிறப்பு. உதாரணமாக: படிநிலை பள்ளி முறை, 6-8 வகுப்புகளில் தொழிற்கல்வி போன்றவற்றை கூறலாம். இது ஒரு மாற்றுக்கல்விக்கான வரைவாக இருந்தாலும் இந்த கல்வி முறை ஒன்றிய அளவில் பொதுமை படுத்தப்படும் போது அந்தந்த மாநிலத்தின் சமூக நிலை மற்றும் வரலாறு சார்ந்த கல்வியில் எத்தகைய முன்னுரிமை கொடுக்கப்படும்? ஏனெனில் தற்போது உள்ள நிலையிலேயே வரலாறு வடக்கிருந்துதான் தொடங்குகிறது இக்கொள்கையின் முடிவு எத்தகைய விளைவை ஏற்படுத்தும்? அடிப்படை கல்வி என்பது தாய்மொழியில் கற்பது எவ்வளவு நன்மையோ அதோபோல் தானே அந்த கல்வியின் தரத்தை நிர்ணயிக்கும் உரிமையும், அப்படியானால் மாநிலங்களுக்கு வழிகாட்டும் வரைவாகத்தானே இக்கொள்கை இருக்கவேண்டும்? மாறாக அது ஒன்றிய அதிகார குவிப்பிற்க்கான கொள்கையாக உள்ளதே அல்லது பார்க்கப்படுகின்றது ஏன்? அப்படி இல்லை இது அனைத்துதரப்பு மாநிலங்களுக்கும் மக்களுக்கும் பொதுவானதே இதில் எந்த எதிர்மறை மற்றும் மக்களுக்கு முரணான விதிகள் இல்லை என்றால் ஏன் ஒரு பொது விவாதமின்றி சட்டமன்ற பாராளுமன்ற விவாதமின்றி கல்வியாளர்கள் மற்றும் பொதுமக்களால் அனுப்பட்ட கேள்விகள், சந்தேகங்களுக்கு பதிலேதும்மின்றி அவசர கதியில் ஏதோ அரசியல் சார் முடிவுபோல் அமல்படுத்தப்பட்டுள்ளது? இது மேலோட்டமாக சுவைக்க தேன் போல் தெரிந்தாலும் அதன் அடியாழத்தில் மறைமுக விஷங்கள் உள்ளனவோ என்ற ஐயம் உள்ளன... அதனாலேயே நீட் எனும் போலி சமப்பந்தி முறையில் கொள்கை வரைவோ என்று சந்தேகமும் விழைகின்றது. உங்கள் பதிலுக்காக....
Ganesan Saravanan, இப்போது இந்த காணொளியைக் கண்டேன். சிறப்பான உங்களது response க்கு பாராட்டுக்கள். இப்படிப் பட்ட கேள்விகள் தாம் இவ் விஷயம் பற்றிய ஒரு அறிவு பூர்வமான, ஆக்க பூர்வமான விவாதம், பரிசீலனை க்கு வழி வகுக்கும். வெறுமனே உணர்ச்சி வசப்படாமல், நமக்கு வேண்டிய மாற்றங்கள் என்ன, அவற்றை எப்படி அடைவது என்று சிந்திக்க வைக்கும். நன்றி. தொடரட்டும் உங்களது follow-up.
தங்களது உரை சிறப்பு,நீங்கள் கடைசி யாக கூறிய பொது தேர்வு முறை , மிக மிக ஆழமான ஆதிக்க சிந்தனையோடு உருவாக்கியது,பொதுகல்வி முறை இல்லாத நாட்டில் பொது தேர்வுமுறை என்ன நீதி? இந்திய அளவில் அனைவருக்கும் தாய்மொழிவழியில் சமச்சீர் கல்வி திட்டத்தை நடைமுறைப்படுத்தி ,போதுமான ஆசிரியர்களை நியமனம் செய்து அனைத்து கட்டமைப்பு களையும் சரிசெய்வதே முதல் தேவையும், சீர்திருத்தமாகும். தற்போதைய சீரமைப்பு (பொது தேர்வு) என்பது அடிதட்டுமக்களை கல்வியிலிருந்து வெளியேற்ற செய்யும் குல கல்வி திட்டமேயாகும். .
@@dhassyestak3693 பல மொழி சமூகங்கள் வாழும் நம் நாட்டில் கல்வி என்பது அந்தந்த மொழிச்சமூகத்தி கையில் இருப்பதுதான் அச்சமூகத்தை வளர்ச்சியடைய செய்யும். நமக்கான அதிகாரம் நமது கையில்தான் இருக்க வேண்டும்.
@UC78lOsQy2WQ4450iihkkCLA உங்கள் நம்பிக்கை நல்ல சிந்தனைதான் சகோ! ஆனால் நாம் தேர்வு என்றொரு அறியாமையில் இருட்டில் இருக்கிறோம், ஆசிரியர்களுக்கு கொடுக்க நடத்தப்பட வேண்டியது திறன் மேம்பாட்டு பயிற்சியே தவிர தேர்வு அல்ல, காரணம் பொதுவாக தேர்வு என்பது ஒரு சிலருக்கு வெற்றியை அளிக்க உதவுமே தவிர அணைவரின் திறனையும் மேம்படுத்துமா என்றால் இல்லை என்றுதான் கூற முடியும். ஆனால் ஆண்டுக்கு ஒரு அல்லது பருவ அடிப்படையில் திறன் மேம்பாட்டு பயிற்சி அளிப்பதின் மூலம் உங்களது என்னத்தின் தீர்வையும் அடையமுடியும் மாணவர்களின் கல்வியையும் மேம்படுத்த முடியும், ஆனால் இவை அனைத்து கல்வியின் உரிமை மாநில அரசிடம் இருந்தால் மட்டுமே அந்தந்த மொழிச்சமுகத்திற்க்கு உதவி முன்னேற்ற முடியுமே தவிர இந்த கல்வி அதிகாம் ஒன்றிய அரசின் கைகளுக்கு சென்றால் அது நிதிச்சுமை என்ற நிலையில் அரசின் கைகளை விட்டு விலகி தனியாரிடம் முழுமையாக தாரை வார்க்கப்படும் பின் நீங்கள் கோரும் எந்த தரத்தையும் முதலாளிய தனியார் நிறுவனம் நிச்சயம் தராது, இன்றும் ஓன்றிய மற்றும் மாநில அளவில் சிறந்த கல்வி மற்றும் கல்விக்கட்டமைப்பை வழங்குவதில் அரசு பல்கலைக்கழகங்கள் மற்றும் கல்லூரிகளே முன்னிலையில் உள்ளன என்பது நம் புரிதலுக்குள்ளாக வேண்டும்.
Really appreciate all the important points discussed in the video. Especially the one highlighting the lack of talent in teaching line which is truly a cause for concern.
புதிய கல்வி கொள்கை நம் நாட்டின் எதிர்காலத்தை தீர்மானிக்கும் என்பது மறுக்க முடியாத உண்மை. ஆனால் இவற்றை சரியான முறையில் நாம் செயல்படுத்தினால் மட்டுமே சாத்தியம்..... தங்களின் இந்த அற்புதமான பதிவிற்கு மீண்டும் நன்றி வாழ்த்துக்கள் ... தோழரே..
I am equally happy and worried about my 2yr old kid's education. Happy about practical and skill based learning like in Japan, worried about board exams at early age and one additional local language
Sir ... don’t worry my kid is currently in 5 th std from 3 rd std they have 3 languages ( English, Hindi & Kannada) ... They don’t find it difficult... They pick up.. I am from Bangalore...
Déjà vu LMES. What you have been mentioning so long is suddenly implemented into a policy. Despite the shortfalls, this does look like a giant step forward. Congratulations to LMES for championing the education system. Board exam, subject group, and mugging mentality must end.
O mugging mentality will gone ....how .....3 5 8 10 11 12 board exam and after entrance exam foe colleges .....how it improve ....it increase school dropouts and create low coat labourers
So many schools don't have even toilet facilities which is the most basic requirement. No proper lab facility in many schools, This is nice to hear but very difficult to implement
Faizal Basha manam irunthal margam undu. This will take years to correct mistakes of the past. Even in TN government schools were the best schools till 1980. Only after the advent of private schools & tuition classes quality of government schools went down. I wish they ban government teachers from making money on the sides and rather pay them based on success of their students
@@SivaPrasathTR Bro ippo government school la padichavan neettuku padichu oru 250-280 eduthu pass agetannu vachukunga, avanukku private colleges tha kedaikum, so avanala college sera mudiyathu Itheve oru well settled parentsoda paiyan only 220-240 eduthu passagi private collegela sernthuruvan. Ithula enga equality irukunnu sollunga??? money irukaravanukku tha inga seattu.
Thank you very much! After seeing so much stupidity in internet. Finally some one has come up with the correct analysis. Of course if you are not, who will.
அருமை தெளிவான விளக்கம் . மூன்றாம் மொழி கட்டாயம் என்பது ஏற்றுக்கொள்ள முடியாது விருப்பம் உள்ளவர்கள் படிக்கட்டும் அது ஹிந்தியாக இருந்தாலும் பரவாயில்லை அது அவர்கள் விருப்பம்.
@@kruphashankar8715 ICPC ( International Collegiate Programming Contest) => Olympic in competitive programming Redcoder : something like grandmaster in competitive programming In codeforces website if you have rating higher than 2400 you will become redcoder This rating is Calculated based on your performance in the contests conducted by this website It is an russian website Worlds top competitive programmers are also participate in this contests
இது எல்லாம் பணம் இருக்கிறவனுக்கும் தனியார் பள்ளிகளில் தான் இந்த வசதிகள் இருக்கும் இவர்களுக்கு தான் புதிய கல்வி கொள்கை நல்ல இருக்கும் எங்களை போல ஏழைகளுக்கு நடுத்தர குடுபங்களுக்கு அரசாங்கம் பள்ளிகளில் திறமைமிக்க ஆசிரியர்கள் வசதிகள் இருக்க மாட்டார்கள் இதை எல்லாம் நடைமுறை சாத்திய படுத்துவது கடினம் நம்ம ஊரு அரசாங்க பள்ளி கூடங்களை பார்த்தாலே தெரியும்
Good take LMES: My biggest concern against this policy and hope they consider and change is: 1. 3 language = burden 2. Common entrance after 12th. We should rather adopt de centralised approach of exams or application. 3. Board exams for 5th,8th etc shud be removed. That too National level exam adds pressure. Maybe 12th board alone is okay that too state level. 4. Say of State govt in Education ?? 5. How much of government role in school education is not addressed completely. LMES pls talk about point 3,4 & 5.
Your points are far better than those of Lmes. Very shocked lmes didn't talk abt these and more minuses of this policy. First minus starts at the first stage that foundation starts at 3yrs of age. What a stupidity. And I pity those who have commented that they want to learn under this policy.
Mr Premanand sethurajan bro, Yengha Oor Village la Nengha solra AI, IoT technology yellam illa, appo idhu yeppadi Sathiyam... pottery, Gardening is there... Itha patha kula kalvi thitam mari than theriyudhu..... North la innum padippu arivu illama irukan, adhukku avangha namma yeppadi mela vanthom nu follow pannallam, Namma mella irukkum so, we can go for advancement in our education.
There is a point on starting coding from standard 6. As a software engineer I welcome this. This will definitely Improve interest in software engineering
are really software engineers do coding? in india's service based IT companies,95% percentage of indian it companies are clerk service companies for core companies and those employees works as unskilled clerks in the name of software engineer
இது எல்லாம் பணம் இருக்கிறவனுக்கும் தனியார் பள்ளிகளில் தான் இந்த வசதிகள் இருக்கும் இவர்களுக்கு தான் புதிய கல்வி கொள்கை நல்ல இருக்கும் எங்களை போல ஏழைகளுக்கு நடுத்தர குடுபங்களுக்கு அரசாங்கம் பள்ளிகளில் திறமைமிக்க ஆசிரியர்கள் வசதிகள் இருக்க மாட்டார்கள் இதை எல்லாம் நடைமுறை சாத்திய படுத்துவது கடினம் நம்ம ஊரு அரசாங்க பள்ளி கூடங்களை பார்த்தாலே தெரியும்
unknown world Indian software engineer are doing coding dood and creating products that is used all over the world and definitely we are not doing just clerk work ...what u say is old saying
@@unknownworld711 95% is a really wrong number. There are people who do clerical Work but the number would be lower. There are also people who work for huge tech giants and there are lot of new entrepreneurs who create their own world class companies. All this is inspite of majority of our students having little or no coding knowledge until college. Teaching coding at school level would definitely improve quality of engineers from India
Your analysis is appreciable. I hav always admired ur clarity of expression. One thing that i differ is, as an educationist for 25 yrs, running a village school , our students have had three languages from age 6 and it has worked well so three lang is a good idea i feel
I'm a student of grade 11 and I don't agree with you opinion. 3rd, 5th, and 8th graders when faced with the big task called "board exams" they would DEFINITELY undergo lot of pressure in such a yound age. And also, your support for students learning in their own language cannot be followed in a country like India that has diverse range of people speaking various languages. Countries like Japan, China, Korea can do so because they have the same language all over the nation but ours does not have a single language. And what if there is a student who is transferred to another state and doesn't know the regional language, how will that student learn? Wouldn't that make it harder for the students?
As a doctor I agree with everything you said ; also higher education has become a business , like you said the entrance examinations favour students who had the money to go to coaching centres and learn. As a PG aspirant it's very tough to get a seat of my choice through NEET exam without coaching although I was a topper in school.
First the selection of teachers is very important to effect this NEP. For that our political system is great interference. Only qualified people must be posted w/o adopting the persent recruitment system. For the post of teachers, doctors and advocates quality is very important. For other jobs the present system of recruitment can be followed. Will it work in the present political synorio? Children can cope up with 3 languages. No problem at all. I welcome the NEP as it is.
How can a child who is 10 year old can choose the vocational course are they matured enough to choose the course will the talent of the child be found within grade 5 till now students are struggling to find the talent inside them how can you make a child choose the course in grade 5 Nep wants board exams in grade 3 how can a child attend an board exam in grade 3 wouldn't that make more psychological pressure to the student will the student play in the park or prepare for the board exams. Ok even though Nep is implemented education comes with under state list wouldn't it create an big confusion between the states. How can this policy be implemented
Everybody here focusing only about negative points mentioned by him. Understand he has supported many other aspects as well. Life is not 0 or 1. Everything is not good or bad. There is good AND bad. Pls learn to accept and give credit where it's due
உண்மை தான் ஆனால் அதில் உள்ள எதிர் கருத்துக்களை அறிந்து நேர்மறையாக மாற்றுவது தான் சிறந்தது...ஒருவன் நேர்மறையாக இருப்பவனை விட எதிர்மறையான சிந்தனைகளை நேர்மறையான மாற்றுபவர்களே திறமைசாலிகள்...
இது எல்லாம் பணம் இருக்கிறவனுக்கும் தனியார் பள்ளிகளில் தான் இந்த வசதிகள் இருக்கும் இவர்களுக்கு தான் புதிய கல்வி கொள்கை நல்ல இருக்கும் எங்களை போல ஏழைகளுக்கு நடுத்தர குடுபங்களுக்கு அரசாங்கம் பள்ளிகளில் திறமைமிக்க ஆசிரியர்கள் வசதிகள் இருக்க மாட்டார்கள் இதை எல்லாம் நடைமுறை சாத்திய படுத்துவது கடினம் நம்ம ஊரு அரசாங்க பள்ளி கூடங்களை பார்த்தாலே தெரியும்
Neenga soldrathaa patha Intha policy nalla than irukku But itha schls and teachers ozhunga pannanum....so that we can get more intelligence students....🔥🔥🔥
இது எல்லாம் பணம் இருக்கிறவனுக்கும் தனியார் பள்ளிகளில் தான் இந்த வசதிகள் இருக்கும் இவர்களுக்கு தான் புதிய கல்வி கொள்கை நல்ல இருக்கும் எங்களை போல ஏழைகளுக்கு நடுத்தர குடுபங்களுக்கு அரசாங்கம் பள்ளிகளில் திறமைமிக்க ஆசிரியர்கள் வசதிகள் இருக்க மாட்டார்கள் இதை எல்லாம் நடைமுறை சாத்திய படுத்துவது கடினம் நம்ம ஊரு அரசாங்க பள்ளி கூடங்களை பார்த்தாலே தெரியும்
Good to see positive comments on New Education Policy despite some concerns. Just because it is brought by BJP, some people r opposing it. Shashi Taroor from Congress too welcomed the move. Hope Kalam's dream will come true 💓
I don't belong to any party. I would say all party should stop advertising their party in each policy. Regarding this education policy it is good move indeed, are we addressing teachers and government schools enhancements. I strongly feel education and health care should be run by government if not fully at least 60-70 percent with all facility equal to private at subsidised cost. Else people will suffer whatever the policy be, private will turn it to their profit. I expect school fees rise once this policy Is implemented
@@baburaj-zv4cb Of course, Private Schools will b on looting spree as usual. Most of the private schools are run by politicians or their binamies. So they will not bring norms to control the fee structure..
I got jealous when i hearing this policy because still now i didn't get what is my passion and stuck in career growth. But, this policy definitely makes the students more intelligent.
Bro ipavum entha prob um illa unga passion ahh ipavum follow pannala age is not a limit ofcourse sila risks iruku economical ahh but edu thu paarunga backup oda jus give it a try:)
Nice Video Anna..i am also thinking the same..having some disadvantages (many exams & 3rd language ) and many positives..but implications, we have to wait and see🤝👍
In my opinion 3rd language is not wrong at all. I'm a person who actually knows 4 languages. Learning languages from young ages has a lot of positive impact in the IQ and Emotional Quotient of a person. Moreover it also makes our communication skills more effective. We should not consider learning new languages as a stress to the children at all. And I personally feel that Hindi is a language we Tamilians must also learn as I have seen people struggling to communicate in the North due to their non Hindi background. We must also keep in mind that the English that we all learn is itself a foreign language but we oppose when we are told to learn Hindi, which is an Indian language. When Indian Govt says that Hindi is must learn language our politicians say that they are IMPOSING Hindi upon us but they seldom remember that English, which is a non Indian language, was itself FORCIBLY IMPOSED upon us Indians BY THE BRITISHERS.
Thank you for the brief explanation.. The policy is good but I don’t think we have qualified teachers to understand the new policy and shape the students.. As a standard,a tool like pick my career and feedback of teachers should be compared, based on this students should be able to understand or visualise their passion..
Bro India la naraya courses ku perusa scope illa bro. Government should need to change this. In USA u can earn 2500$(Rs. 2L) per month if you studied Bsc.Physics. because USA focuses research based things more. But in India aracha maavaye araikaranga. New policy super ah irukku. Naan kastapatta maari en kozhandhainga kastapada maatanga😀.
@@karthikeyan53 mm bro... USA, UK la engineering kum,bsc phy, chem, mat la nalla scope irukka vaippu irukku bro...salary better a irukkum india va compare panna nu nenaikren bro......
உங்கள் கருத்தும் கணிப்பும் மிக சரியே . மாற்றங்கள் வேண்டும் அதை செய்ய தகுதியும் வாய்ப்பும் இருக்கின்றதா என்பது சந்தேகம் . இங்கு கல்வி மிகப்பெரிய பணம் கொழிக்கும் தொழிலாக மாறிவிட்டது . உங்கள் சிந்தனை படி மும்மொழி கொள்கை தேவை அற்றது என்பது உண்மைதான் . நீங்கள் சொல்லும் திருத்தந்தை செய்தால் சிறப்பாக இருக்கும் . மகிழ்ச்சியே
It has many flaw .....we can feel sad that we missed it but feel 3 5 8 10 11 12 this much board exam ..the amount pressure and entrance exam preparation after school ....
Coding from 6th!!! Best idea! Engineering students ae coding theriyama struggle panranga... Middle school la padichirndha kavalaye illa...90skids 2k kids paavam.
Coding ??? You make English optional in the primary class and coding from sixth ?you think everyone has the facilities for that???? Moreover this policy also talks about vocational courses ?? Which UC rich person will send their kid for these courses??? The people from the Dalit and backward communities only they will end up in these courses ,and what's the logic behind bringing in foreign universities ??the rich kids will go abroad and study ,but why you bringing it here 🤷♀️then again the policy talks about more "autonomy " for universities which is again a dangerous proposition for social justice ,again making English optional is a foolish idea ,then what's the relevance of sanskrit now? This policy will only benefit the upper castes elites and the private institutes and coaching institutes
வணக்கம்! கல்விக் கொள்கை குறித்த எனது எண்ணங்களையும், விருப்பங்களையும் தொகுத்து கீழ்கண்டவாறு கொடுத்துள்ளேன். இதனை செயல்முறை படுத்த ஆவன செய்து நம் கல்வியையும், அதன் வாயிலாக நாட்டையும் செம்மை படுத்த வேண்டுகிறேன். அனைவருக்கும் அரசு கல்வி வழங்குதல் வேண்டும் எந்தவித ஏற்றத்தாழ்வுகளும், பிரிவினைகளும் அற்ற கல்வி 10ஆம் வகுப்பு வரை வேண்டும். இது அனைத்து அடிப்படை அறிவு அனைவர்க்கும் தர வழி செய்யும். கட்டாயம் கல்வியை அரசு மட்டுமே தர வேண்டும். புதிய தனியார் கல்வி நிலையங்களுக்கு அனுமதி மறுத்து, தற்போது உள்ள தனியார் கல்வி நிலையங்களை குறைந்த கால எல்லைக்குள் அரசுடைமை ஆக்குதல் வேண்டும். கல்வியில் ஏற்றத்தாழ்வு தவிர்க்கப்படவும் அனைவர்க்கும் கல்வி வழங்கப்படவும், அனைவருக்கும் சமமான வாய்ப்பு வழங்கவும், கல்வியை இலவசமாக வழங்குதல் வேண்டும். கல்விக் கொள்கைகளுக்கு மாநிலங்களின் பங்களிப்புடன் உடன்பட்டு அனைத்து வகையான கருத்துக்களையும் நன்கு பரிசீலித்து முடிவெடுக்க படவேண்டும். மண் சார்ந்த அறிவு தர மாநிலங்களின் பங்களிப்பே முதன்மையாகும். அனைவர்க்கும் தாய்மொழி வழி கல்வி பயில தளங்களை உருவாக்கி தரவேண்டும். தாய் மொழி வழி கல்வியால் செழுமையான சிந்தனை கொண்ட அடுத்த தலைமுறை மாணவர்களை உருவாக்க முடியம். எளிமையான முறையில் விளங்கிக்கொள்ளவும், புரிந்தவற்றை கொண்டு மேலும் சிந்தனை தூண்டப்பட்டு அடுத்த நிலைக்கு செல்லவும் இதுவே முதன்மை வழி. ஒரு மொழி கொண்டே பல்துறை திறன் வளர்த்தல் எளிமையாக நிகழுவதால் மும்மொழி கொள்கை தேவையற்றது. கல்விதான் ஒரு நாட்டின் மக்களின் எதிர்காலமாக உள்ளதால், கல்வியை அரசியல் படுத்தவேண்டாம். தமிழர்க்கு எக்காலத்திலும் இந்தி வேண்டாம். அதை ஒன்றிய அரசு ஒரு போதும் கட்டாய படுத்தவோ, திணிக்கவோ, பரிந்துரை செய்யவோ வேண்டாம். விருப்பம் உள்ளவர்களும் தேவை உள்ளவர்களும் தாமாக முன்வந்து கற்பர். நுனிப்புல் மேய்வது ஒருகாலும் சிறந்த கல்வி ஆகாது, கல்வியின் அகல ஆழம் காண தாய்மொழி வழி கல்வியே தேவையானது. தாய்மொழி செளுமையுற்றால் சிந்தையும், திறமும், செயலும் சிறப்புறும். உலகம் மாறிவரும் தொழில்நுட்ப திறத்தால் ஓர் மொழியே மாந்தர்க்கு போதும், மற்றவற்றை தொழில்நுட்பம் நிரப்பும். மொழிமாற்றம், மொழிபெயர்ப்பு யாவற்றையும் தொழில்நுட்பம் கைக்கொள்ளும். தொடர்புக்காக என தனிமொழி கற்று நேரத்தை விரயம் செய்ய தேவையில்லை அனைத்து துறை சார்ந்த சொற்களையும், தகவல்களையும் தாய் மொழி வழியாக பயிலும் வண்ணமும், பயிற்றுவிக்கும் வண்ணமும் சொல்லியில் மற்றும் துறையில் ஆய்வுகள் நடத்தி எளிமையாக கையாளுதல் வேண்டும். கல்வி கற்பிக்கும் முறை, ஆசிரியர் மாணவர் உறவு, பாடநூலுக்கு வெளிய உள்ள கல்வி, ஆசிரியர்களுக்கு தொடர் கல்வியியல் சார்ந்த உள்ளீடு என கற்பிக்கும் முறையில் அன்றாடம் புதுமை புகுத்துதல் என மாணாக்கரின் ஆர்வத்தினையும் உந்துசத்தியினையும் உற்சாகத்தினையும் தன்னம்பிக்கையையும் அளிப்பதன் மூலம் வளமான சமூகத்தை வளர்த்தெடுக்க போராடவேண்டும். மதிப்பெண் மையமாக உள்ள கல்வியில் இருந்து மாறுபட்டு சிந்தனை மற்றும் செயல் திறன் மையமாக கல்வி அமைத்தல் வேண்டும். இடைநிற்றல் என்ற முறை ஒழிக்கப்பட்டு, எவ்வண்ணம் மாணாக்கரை முன்னழைத்து செல்வது என்ற சிந்தனை தேவை. குழந்தைகளுக்கு பொது தேர்வு போன்ற அச்சுறுத்தல்களை ஒளித்து. அவர்களின் இயல்புகளை உணர்ந்து கல்வி பயணம் மேற்கொள்ள வழிவகை செய்யவேண்டும். கல்லூரி செல்ல ஊக்குவிப்பும், உறுதுணையுமே செய்யவேண்டும், அதை தவிர்த்து நுழைவு தேர்வு போன்றவற்றை இனி தொடராது என்ற உறுதிப்பாடு வேண்டும். சமூக நீதி, இட ஒதுக்கீடு, நிதி உதவி, போன்றவற்றை மேலும் வலுப்படுத்தி மக்கள் வாழ்வும், வளமும் பெறுக வழி செய்யதல் வேண்டும். உலகின் சிறந்த கல்விக் கொள்கைகளை ஆராய்ந்து அதை முறைப்படுத்த ஒரு சிறந்த குழு அமைத்தல் வேண்டும். கல்விக் குழுவிற்கு சிறந்த கல்வி ஆலோசகர்கள், சிறந்த கல்வியாளர்கள் என அனைவரையும் ஒன்று திரட்டி ஆலோசனை நடத்தி முடிவெடுத்தல் வேண்டும். அறம், நீதிநெறி, இயற்கை சார்ந்த விழிப்புணர்வு, சுற்றுசூழல்பராமரிப்பு, சுய சிந்தனை, சுய முன்னேற்றம், கலை, அறிவியல், இலக்கியம், பண்பாடு, விளையாட்டு, சமகால நிகழ்வுகள், உலகை நோக்கின பார்வை/புரிதல், அரசியல், பொருளாதாரம், மனிதநேயம் என அனைத்து முதன்மையான விடையங்களையும் கருத்தில் கொண்டு கல்வி அமைத்தல் வேண்டும்
I am a student of grade 11 and i would like to say that i disagree with your stance and i would like to state my opinions and reasons why i do not stand with the proposed education system by nep: 1. 2:00 i think 5th graders are far away from not knowing how to read or write or do simple calculations. And also i think interactive classes DO take place for students below grade 5, so i do not take this point as for something 'newly' implemented by nep. 2. 3:22 students in english medium schools can speak well in their own mother tongue and understand better as it is a language used often in their surroundings, i dont think it is necessary for it to be completely changed to it to understand better. 3. 3:40 "english to be taught as a language" - students have already adapted to their subjects being taught in school in english and if it is switched to regional language wont it be harder for them to adapt to this huge change?? 4. 3:56 comparing india to other countries like japan, south korea, china, etc, they only have english+ their one regional language. In india each state has many language speakers, so this point makes your statement irrelevant. 5. 5:26 i do not think drop percentage will be affected only by a few percentage (like u stated 1-2%) and plus isnt the 'internship' just changing the mindset of students themselves to be discouraged in certain ways? 6. 5:26 drop percentage also plays a huge role in thid point as board exams for grades 3,5 and 8 just puts a LOT of pressure on students at that young age? even 10th graders dont handle that kind of pressure and the new system wants to impose it on much younger students. 7. 6:01 entrepreneurship isnt just 'product based' services also plays a huge role in our country. hence our country cannot be just changed into product based. 8. 7:39 it doesnt necessarily have to be that science and math students are all high scorers. there are high scorers in commerce too and the courses are chosen by the student's only will/ interest at most cases. i think everyone has to stop having such stereotypes that commerce students are all 'low scorers'. * these are my opinions and criticism as a student, the ones who will be affected/ face huge changes from this proposed system. *
Bro, my biggest concern is about the teachers, The system they are bringing is absolutely fascinating but I can't trust the teachers here. Inga irukka majority of teachers ellarume mug adikkavum, salary vaangurathukum dhan irukanga, and that is the fair truth. (Not for the real dedicated teachers)
@@muthukumarankothandaraman2371 It's not antagonism......it is only going to happen in future. Like he said in the video implementation is very important to perfectly follow this system and that is never gonna happen until qualified and dedicated teachers are appointed in the field
Yov....My times le full book mattum daan...Practicals nu peruku vaipaange...i Studied Marathi, hindi, English as language and studied tamil as 4th language. Naange laam manusan elleyaa
I see. You may be well-versed in multiple languages now, good for you! How good are you at Math, Coding, Finance? How good are you at Physics and Chemistry? Was learning all those extra languages helped you succeed at global level or just national level or at least state level? Just because you went through difficult curriculum(meaning different languages), doesn't mean it is right or everybody has to go through it. So, please do not take things personally, see beyond personal gains and try to speak for people who are not even here to voice their concerns. (Ex: Government/Rural school students) PS: I studied at a Govt aided school and I understand the struggles, not everybody can afford extra tuition and at the same time not everyone can be abdul kalam(student from remote village) YET.
Dear Sir, I am glad that you have clearly mentioned the pros and cons of New education policy but it would be better if you publish the English version for this particular video so that this will reach to huge mass Thank you
Indian Nationalist don’t fall for “pudicha subject” no school and college in this world can offer “pudicha subject” for all. It’s all depending on marks. Do you think they give science and maths to ALL who wish even if they get 40, 50 percentage of marks ? Come to the reality. Don’t fall for the “pudicha subject” 😀😀. It’s a magical word. As I said, innum evvalvu new system vandhallum no system in the world can give “pudicha system” to ALL people. Again, it’s all marks + school capacity.
@@jothirajansundararaj6023 / yen pa olaarey .... First video full ah paaru .... ungalukku ulagathala nalladhu nu onnu nadakkavey nadakkadhu nu oru mindset ....always speaking negative 🤦🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️
@@jothirajansundararaj6023 activity based education,,carrier choosing training ,, if u don't like this then u must be a DMK Sombhu😂😂... Adada natla indha upi's tholla thangamudila pa ,,200 ruba vangitu DMK ku jalra thatra kootathula oruthana nee
By chance one born in Ramand/ tiny village and another one in Chennai..it has nothing to do with human talents. I am from a village, studied in Govt school in 1978, now sending ..comments to you.. updating and up keeping is left to individuals ..and need based. This is a hunger driven, greedy driven society...people use education as a route to rich is unfortunate..look at the demand for medical seats.. that is the proof for my statement..- I appreciate your review. I also expect you to review the scholarship issues related to school education. You also please tell whether education is compulsory or not for a citizen.. that should be the first order policy decision.. -Professor. S.Padmanaban
I agree with you ... very Gud policy, but need all private education sector to change the mode of 1 roof under government sector... then all students get benefits & teaching ethics to be modified , need psychological support need for students...
How many knew that India never participated in PISA (Programme for International Student Assessment)? PISA is used to evaluate educational systems worldwide based on reading, science and mathematical skills. In 2018, India participated and bagged 72nd place out of 74 countries. Singapore, Taiwan, Japan, Finland, China manages to stay in top 10. Waiting for India to get a decent rank in PISA.
I am a mechanical engineer. Till 12 th standard I studied only in govt school tamil medium. You are correct. Now 90 % of the teachers are not that much quality. Without quality teachers we can not expect good outcomes.
Keka ellame romba nalla iruku, implement panna rombave super iruku our india but ena atha implement panrathukulla na schooling finish paniduva ninachatha kastama iruku, but anyway welcome to this wonderful🎉 new education policy🎉
I got depressed after hearing about this policy Coz I didn't get a good choice to my job This policy definitely improves students skills. This makes students to get they real talent. This policy is worked correctly, I definitely support this!
@ no bro They can't be stressed by this coz they can choose they career within 6 std so that they can be stressed in that age all students include our older one try to get innovation not memorize and write only theories. I agree that in that we don't give them exams in that age but they might change that policy in lower class exams But ignore that exams policy This assessment in between 5 to 6th it's just a great idea In that age only our brain going to be focused
There are 'NO' private schools in Finland. Significantly, students will have same teacher upto 6 years of their primary education. Idea is to build the rapport between student and teacher, so the basics are strong from grassroot level.
As a teacher, If this has to be a success then teachers have to be updated... Really well updated. I can really count them. As a parent, happy and at the same time got a little fear that this plan becomes a success . I believe now it's all in the teachers hand to be more responsible.
Good conclusion on entrance.but I differ with you on field level warriors teachers.The NEP 2020 is also discussed about importance of teacher education,teacher education system and requirements in this process as you said. pls go through the frame wok sheets of NEP2020 chapter 5, page 20
Now, All the kids are studying three languages from LKG in CBSE and International syllabus. Only government school students affected. Please give some space to them also.
@@muruganandamramasamy you just try to communicate with government schools students they are far better than cbsc students if they implement this our teachers should be well knowledged...
If this was implemented before it would be very helpful to students unfortunately I can't enjoy as I am in 9th class I like experimental learning with vacational...
Policy is good, but there should be strong execution plan like pay package,selection of teachers and strong appraisal system to achieve this...if there is no operational plan, then this will be only in paper...
the thing about teachers is true i still remember my librarian teaching much more than any other teachers we should educate the teachers and train them for the new ways then it might be effective and there also should be qualifying exam for teachers regularly twice a year and paid surplus pay so that they think of their pupils than other finacial problems
Dear Friends, I am Gokulnath and I did mechanical engineer. I started a you tube channel for those who want to learn Deutsch-German language with tamil explanation. Kindly check and support my channel. I am taking online classes also at English to German to English, Tamil to German to Tamil ruclips.net/channel/UCVWBJmIwV2-mS7qsMnqo-LA Kindly contact me, if you want to learn. Thanks and Regards Gokulnath
Language indirectly imposed, board exam for 3rd, 5th standard, common exam for rural and urban students all are make more dropped outs...finally implementation...... very well analysed....it's good or not ? Future Wil answer...how india's literacy getting increased or decreased
As per right to education act, they cannot fail anyone till 8th standard. The concept of board exams are not to assess the students, but based on students' mark they are going to assess the school's ability and performance to deliver the quality outputs in terms of teaching etc. Yes I agree that it is mental pressure for kids, but it will be all like annual exams.
Language indirectly imposed poya yov upto 5 mother tounge la padam solli taralamnu iruk after 5th std tan vera 1 language padikanum nu iruk Namma yethat language padikalam hindi tan padikanumnu ila ath matri northla um koncha per tamil yedut padika vaip iruk
@@harishankar110 I said future will answer.... naanum enigeering graduate than....suthamana village.... government school...tamil medium......first graduate from family....correct ah sonna first 10th std pass...8+ years working in IT industry... successfully doing trading too ..started a ecommerce related businesses too... unable to sustain due to competition.... school first naan... college la naan lam yarune theriyathu....inga village +2 students ala city la irukira 10vayasu paiyan kooda compete panna mudiyathu...premanand too said the same......engala mathiri village la irunthu mela varavanga count nichayam kuraiyum... all are based on my experience as village person... finally I said future will answer... let's wait and see...why we need to fight here...
Very unbiased review! 👏👏👏 exactly same thoughts I had Teachers come from previous education system who are going to be part of this change implementing new education system, it will take minimum 2 decades to get all these policy vision into reality and see the impact
![Felix "Unfair" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Oswujxm2Ag0/mqdefault.jpg)
To support underprivileged students visit: lmesfoundation.com
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Find your Career interest at pickmycareer.in
Email: support@pickmycareer.in
Find Premanand Sethurajan's career Report link at pickmycareer.in/posts
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
PIckmycareer is free for Government school students. if you are a government school student check the video and register for free: ruclips.net/video/uSGYg4qbgqM/видео.html
Thank you @Let's Make Education Simple team! ✌🏻
Sir please upload the video for atm card issue and how to restrict these kinds of problems by using science please upload video for this 🙏🙏🙏
@Let's Make Education Simple Can i get my Pick My Career report?
Please reply team!!.
Thank u LMES
I think this system could be better if the school take it seriously mainly the middle and secondary stage are more important for the future of the students.
ஒரு குழந்தை எந்த மொழியில் யோசிக்கரதோ அந்த மொழியே அவர்களுக்கு உகந்தது. சிறப்பு
Dmk iruka varikum
Tamil natu education system munerave muneradhu
@@karans8910 yes
@@karans8910 y en admk iruntha mattum munneriduma 😒😒😒😒 yen ippadi solreenga what reason 😒😒
@@nithish9863 Ena tamilnadu la most of the schools and colleges and christian support schools ella dmk keela eruku
@@harishsrinivasan-rf3gt illana naan onnu solren neengalae yosicchu parunga bjp centrela nalla rule panranga en avangala namma ethukkurathu illa sollunga. Just hindi imposition appadinu vacchi avara ethuttu irukkum. Modi article 370 eradication, foreign relationship strong aayirukku, ram mandhir issue solved, indian temples renovation, infrastructure development, railwayla vanthr baratham rail ivalo pannirukkaru DMK admk waste proyajanam illana en ivangala ethukka koodathu. Evangala ethukathathukku enna karanam🧐🧐🧐
2 Min silence to those who finished 12th Recently 😂💔
I'm gonna finish this year.😑😑😑😭😭😭😭😭
☹️
😫
I finished 12th in 2008, but enake naama padikum bodhu ipdi oru nalla system illama poche nu romba kastama dhan iruku ☹️🙁
Inimey padika poravan sethavan
எத்தனை பேர் , நாம படிக்க போது இத்தெல்லாம் கொண்டு வரலன்னு feel பண்றிங்க
Edit: Thank you for 1000 likes 🙏
*வரலைன்னு
Me 🙋
I just enjoyed what i just studied . And i wont worry any shit about it now coz done is what done
@@amnotanyoutuber8611 but school timela 10 days vocational training nalla than irukum,,, ippo teriyadhu
Me
I am a professor. With my personal experience as a teacher and as a student, I can tell u that 99% of the students understand their skills and interests only after their 22-25th age. This is y u can able to see many serious carrier switches like doctor to IPS, IT professional to farmer, musician and so on...
I even used to say that voters right age must be postponed to 25 from 18.
Students won't have enough idea about their future in their school age. Please don't compare foreign countries as their college going % is very less. Their college dropout % is also too high.
In the u.s the scientists from NASA and other engineers and doctors used to visit school students to motivate them to study doctor or engineer in the future. This will happen here as well...
Manoj's Shopping very true sir
yes, u r right... usually in a society, all the students arent naturally genius...
99.9 percent students are like normal students who understandts it lately after 22 as u said...
But think about that remaining 0.1 percent naturally curious little genius students. Those are the few who make big things!!!... The nation which makes those 0.1% to achieve their goals will shine at all...
we cant make everybody genius, and THERE IS NO NEED to make everybody genius!!!.
Make those 0.1% to shine, then their philosophy or inventions or ability will make entire world to shine...
but namma India maathiri countries la, ellarayum arivaali aakanum nu solli, oru mokkayaana, mandhamaana education policy a uruvaaki, atha ella students ayum follow panna vaikuraanga🤦🤦.
ithanaala muttaal aa irukkura pasanga and curiousity ye illama irukura pasanga ellarum oaralavuku average students aa maaridaraan, but adhe samayam "thiramayaana pasangalum avanga kooda seanthu kadaisi varaikum AVERAGE aave irunthidaraan"..😢
this is why india la ennathaan koadi koadiya padichaalum oruthanum shine aaga maatikiran, and sports la sollave thevai illa, 125 crore population, but single olympic medal vaanga mukkurom... its because our education system makes everybody as average...
sundar pichai maathiri oru student a india vaala vechi iruntha, inniki avan latcham indians a vaala vechirupaan. elon musk maathiri oru student a africa use panni iruntha, inniki satellite launch panna solli america kitta kenja veandiya nilamai south africa ku vanthu irukaathu...
Yes sir. You right . 18 years old students little unable to think Enjoyed the right to vote value. This is not Age problem its problem of society sir. So, we teach them " why we vote ? " first of all we learn that " why we vote & what is real value on vote "
And your very right . Motivation most important think to students for engaged the our own dreams. &
Thank you sir.
orton cap sundar pichai is outcome of our earlier education system and that said 0.1 percent will do even without this vayula vada sudura education policy
09:40
So true. First teachers quality should be improved
Correct
The truth is, I got understood the new education policy only by this video😁😁😁... Thanks for your explanation sir🙏🙏🙏
Well said bro👏
Me too🙋🏻♂️
Plz plz subscribe to my channel
@@dhanusht5099 plz subscribe my channel with views
@@Benja25ndn plz plz subscribe to my channel
10+2 education system is only focused on marks and percentage nothing else
100 percent unmai
Yes...
ruclips.net/video/GeFCVm6hjWk/видео.html 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😢😢😨😨😧😧😦😦😟😟🙁
💯
True!!
தனி மனித
சிந்தனையை வளர்ப்பதே
தரமான கல்வி 💯🔥💯
Poda muttaal
After I read nep draft some doubts but you cleared. I hope this system will develop more innovated our country love you lmes
Plz plz subscribe to my channel
Wat govt school infrastructure, teachers, fees, entrance exam for arts and science college
Looking forward to see new generation with great intelligence
Clear explanation..well said, Sir. "Without qualified Teachers, Mission Impossible"...
Most of the teachers not a teacher. They are workers . They just do their job for money.( Not for all. Every school has few gems)
Qualified teachers are there but no mechanism to monitor them in real time. Government should form a sperate department to monitor the performance of every teacher and should give KRA for every month. Problem with our government is simply going behind 'Vote politics' that's why playing a safe game with government employees.
sagunthala devi every year even government school teacher are also have exam in new education system
Mission impossible fallout
Correct
எங்க அம்மா அப்பா இத எங்களோட சின்ன வயசுல பண்ணாங்க... அம்மா அப்பா தெலுங்கு வீட்ல பேசுவாங்க... ஆனா எங்க கிட்ட தமிழ் தான் பேசுவாங்க...நங்க reason கேட்ட அப்ப படிக்கும் போது நீங்க confuse ஆக கூடாதுனு தான் நாங்க தமிழ் choose பண்ணோம் அப்டின்னு சொன்னாங்க... Now I'm a IT professional , still i will learn everything by using Tamil which helps me to understand well...
90's kids and early 2k kids
Am i joke to you🤣🤣🤣😂😂😂
Yes
Same feeling...
💯 Absolutely
True
If I am 2k 10 kid I'll be happy 😂🤣
Prem அண்ணா சொன்ன ஒரு point ரொம்ப சரி.
Japan ல நான் கொஞ்ச நாள் இருந்தேன்.
நாம் எப்படி UPSC எழுதி IAS try பன்றமோ . அங்க அந்த அளவு calibre அஹ் ஒரு teacher test பண்ணுவாங்க .
இங்க ஒரு IAS officer கு கிடைக்கும் respect Salary Japan ல இருக்கும் teacher கு கிடைக்கும்.
சோ திறமையான ஒரு தர் தான் டீச்சர் ஆக முடியும். அவங்க நல்ல students develop பண்ணுவாங்க.
130 கோடி மக்கள் இருந்தும் இன்னும் france ட weapon வாங்கும் இழிவு நிலை இத நாள் தான்.
Teacher UPSC வச்சு எடுத்து போடணும். நல்ல Respect salary தரணும். நாடு நிச்சயம் முன்னேறும்.
Edit 1: எனக்கு நிறைய பேர் govt teachers நிறைய salary vanguranga னு reply பண்ணி இருக்கீங்க
Yes உண்மை தான். I admit. என்னோட point என்ன நா . Government teachers are highly paid. சொன்ன மாதி அத சும்மா குடுக்காமா. அவ்ளோ salary வாங்குற ஒருத்தர் proper Upsc screening pona தான் சரி னு சொல்றன்.
Just like that ஒரு IAS ஆகிட முடியாது அதே போல் ல
டீச்சர் ஆகிட முடியாது. ஒரு பெரிய trend ல change வரணும்.
School கூட நண்பன் film CLIMAX ல வர மாதி Practical and application based அஹ் கொண்டுவரனும். Ground reality ல நிச்சயம் முடியும்.
அப்புறம் இந்தியா ல தெருக்கு தெரு வள்ளுவர், சுந்தர் பிச்சை, einstein , Newton இருப்பாங்க.
I accept that. But egga English pesuna teacher vela kedaikum
Bro, japan,Europe, USA ஓட Population எவ்வளோ. இந்தியாவை சீனாவோட கூட கம்பேர் பண்ணமுடியாது.இங்க பலதரப்பட்ட மக்கள் இருக்காங்க.......
Government school teachers are highly paid... For more than What they deliver.... Private school teachers are paid less... Most of them deliver more than what they are paid... One more is reservations in teaching profession....
@@lakshmipathyduraiswamy6973 govt school teachers are highly paid.. This thing I accept.. But what is that "than what they deliver"... Don't talk commonly abt all govt school teachers. I have seen many sincere govt school teachers who have sent their students to top colleges.. Think and talk..
Then quality teacher is also required and reservation is also required. I think both can't come together. If reservation is based on economy basis, it will be good.
Need to improve teacher skills is very more important and also teacher need to explain the concept by the way of easily reaching the students mind...
99% has hate the education that should be changed..Make the students as interested candidates on education..
Every day they should learn something from school..
These way our future kids are more intelligence than ourselves
#jaihind
Sriram L this can happen wen teachers are periodically enriched wit workshops n trainings!!!!
Dmk wont about that stuff's...
If DMK oppose any policy, then that policy is good for the nation. It should get implemented.
*Big giveaway🎁*
🤑 *Just click subscribe button Get cash 1000rs* 🤑
👇🏻👇🏻
ruclips.net/video/B3KvBQC0Jw0/видео.html
🤑 *Subscribe பன்னா பணம்* 🤑
I would rather say, there should not be 'teacher' as profession; I meant student should able to choose teacher
3 மற்றும் 5 வகுப்புகளுக்கு தேர்வு என்பது உளவியல் போராக மாறக்கூடாது....
போராக மாறி அவன்/ள் பள்ளியை விட்டு ஓடுவதைத் தானே எதிர்பார்க்கிறோம்.... அதற்கு தானே அந்த பொதுத் தேர்வுகள்...stalin packirisamy
எப்படியோ ஞாபகமறதி குழந்தைகளை பள்ளியை விட்டு விரட்டியடிப் பார்கள் அவர்களுடைய வாழ்க்கை ? தானா ?
The new policy of education is good but I doubt about the implementation....
See ideawings for NEP it's too good.
Dash 😂
correct bro. But you said waiting the implementation process how is going on nu. ஆன பிஜேபி ப்னிஸிங் எப்பவுமே சரி இருக்காது(got knowledge from previous schemes)...
Demonetisation big example
every point having some hidden reasons too...
Exactly bro
Exactly
The vocational training and intermidiate public exam will create low cost labours....
Valid point: Teacher's must be very talanted and have periodic appraisal for their knowledge updation.
I personally saw while my schooling. Most of the staffs (Not all few staffs are good teachers too) are not updated and spending time unnecessary in Govt. Schools.
Outdated*
ruclips.net/video/kCIQaAucz5I/видео.html இதை பாருங்க
True
@@deepanraj6585 பார்த்தேன் சகோ.
புதிய கல்வி கொள்கை வரைவு கிடைக்குமா?
அவர் அவர் அவர்களுக்கு தெரிந்த விஷயங்களை கூறுகின்றனர். நாம் முழுமையாக பார்க்க வேண்டும்.
என்ன சார் அரபியில் பெயர் வெச்சு இருக்கீங்க தமிழ்ல வீடியோ பாக்கிறீங்க
I read the 60 page NEP 2020 report and this is exactly how I felt! On paper, everything about India is good. Even the Indian healthcare system is the best on paper (not many countries give free medicines/drugs along with free healthcare) But when the implementation gets screwed up on so many levels, it is almost impossible to execute them in practice. Underprivileged/rural students have more to lose. When there is no uniform education in the country how can one think that the uniform examination/evaluation is FAIR. The playing field was never even! Thanks for your video
After decades of "Independence" as of 2012, those languishing below the poverty line is said to be 170 million people! And we are talking about uniform examination while encouraging different types of schools - for the poor, for the middle class, for the rich, for the opulent rich...
Making all schools as govt School and equal infrastructure and equipment..
Crct bro even I'm from matriculation school and want to study in government school but my parents say u will not study well in there 😭😭😭😭
Simplest way is CBSE syllabus for all schools
புதிய கல்விக் கொள்கை, பெரும் ஆபத்து அபத்தமானது. ஆ ராசாவின் நெத்தியடி பதில்கள்
News7 நிகழ்ச்சி
ruclips.net/video/1XoIiMcmPNQ/видео.html
24:40 starts
Good analysis by LMES, one of the best education channel in 🇮🇳 INDIA......
See ideawings for NEP it's too good.
International also 😁
Well said LMES. I, as a government school teacher, agree with you. I welcome the New Education Policy. Though there are a few unacceptable factors (like board exam for 3rd and 5 th std pupils, unified entrance exam) and practically improbable (at this point of time) points, the Policy, overall, gives satisfaction for many of us. I expect more emphasis to mother tongue, infrastructure development in future...
One of the heartening things for me is testing teacher's ability in regular intervals. The major disappointment on Govt School teacher is their ability. But in fact, they have already proven their ability by passing TRB, TET exams. But many of the teachers don't update themselves. The New Policy will force them updated for sure. That's a good sign. Those lazy, incapable teachers' quality will be upgraded so that the quality of Govt School education will develop.
As you said, the victory lies on implementation of the Policy....
Let's wait and see. Let's educate all... 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
Don't worry about the Board Exams for 3rd, 5th and 8th students. They may be called as Board Exams and may get External Invigilation but the students will all be the same and won't bother much about their marks. Moreover the teachers also won't care much about those small fry board exams.
And by the time they all get to the 12th Boards, which indeed is serious exam, they all will be accustomed to the Board Exam stress and atmosphere. The suicide rates of 12th students will significantly reduce as by the time they reach 12th they wouldn't bother much about scoring less marks.
@@saiyaninjafromvillagehidde8115 Yes sir. But Board Exam to 8 years old kids is too much... We used to see our rural school children daily. Most of them aren't able to hold their plates... How will they handle the mental pressure created by their parents, teachers, etc.. The society still look at marks as talent.... I agree your words that by the time they reach 12th, they will know how to manage things. But how about the early pressure...? Let's see... Time has answer for everything... 😂😂😂
@@AnandCd
Our society is really not that foolish. They will not really put too much pressure upon the 8yr olds to score marks. What I'm trying to say is that the concept of Board Exam won't be a big deal anymore for the students as they already have got exposed to it from younger ages. The society will also stop making a big fuss about BOARD EXAMS and it will be looked at just like another exam. The mature or the previlaged (that is a matter of luck) ones will ace the exams while the others will also pass. Meaningless final moment stress and student suicide rates will also drastically reduce.
@@saiyaninjafromvillagehidde8115 Rightly said sir. What all our wish is this... We should give our future masters the best education without any prejudice... Hope we'll achive it...
@Sam Ram
Govt of India, no matter what era, has always tried to provide equality as much as possible, but still our people find some loopholes in their plans and thus nothing has ever gone exactly according to the Govt's plans. But despite of that India has made some good progress and is better at something than many countries. If the Govt tries to become strict with it's actions then the greedy opposition and some foolish people start calling it as DICTATORSHIP LAW ENFORCEMENT and VIOLATION OF RIGHTS. This has been the major problem with our society. And of course this is one of the primary reasons why rural area people haven't developed enough yet that they get equal opportunities as the people in the cities.
This education system will be successful but it'll take time. Govt will also start making new reforms to give the underprevilaged better chances. But for this all to happen the politicians and unoptimistic researchers must keep their mouth shut for a while and let the others cooperate with the Govt and it's plan for a while.
This system has more positives than negatives and yes this is far better than the previous one. Slowly but surely courses like engineering (anybody's course these days) will start getting more value and only the capable will get to study engineering.
As a student, I firmly oppose your stand here. NEP promises a bright policy, but the effects could be quite the opposite. Nep has several disadvantages such as uniform entrance exam, board exam for class 3,5,8, mother tongue education, etc.
And what about the diploma offered when you don't complete your degree? According to Nep, students who do not complete the 4 year term of their degree can get a diploma for the number of Years they attended college. This is a huge drawback which will noticeably increase the dropout rate.
2:58 : In case of education in the mother tongue, it is highly impossible for a diverse country like India to implement, because if children move from one state to another, them adapting to the language of that state is a huge challenge. This will definitely undermine their learning if they switch states.
3:22 Teaching english only as a language and not as the medium would decrease the proficiency of their presenting and communication skills, much needed when they move out for jobs all over the country or to international platforms. English is an accepted international language for communication, and teaching in that medium would make kids easily adapt to society after finishing school.
3:58 as said above, India has many languages. The countries you've mentioned have largely only one language nationwide, so that system is applicable for them.
5:44 I firmly oppose your statement here, because as you know, the nep policy says there will board exams for class 3,5, 8, and so on, and if ever they fail in the 5th board exam, it would definitely lead them to choose the vocational training, while it is a very early age for deciding a child's potential and the job, and this doesn't consider a space for late blomers. This will surely lead to more dropouts, especially in rural areas and poor families, and India has 27% of people living below poverty line.
7:30 Multidisciplinary study might lead to students learning a mixture of irrelevant subjects. Each group in the existing system has access to specific jobs the child would want to persue. In the existing system we already have freedom to choose subjects in the Optional. Also according to nep, students with a non- science background in higher secondary can opt for medical courses in college. The effects of this can be dangerous.
7:48 This is absolutely UNACCEPTABLE. Please understand that many students today opt for their streams based on their interests and not based on score. As a student I see others study science while having low score and commerce students having more than 70%. Please step out of your stigma.
Overall, Nep is a highly impossible policy, let alone acceptable. The outcome might even be the exact opposite of what it promises.
i agree with your point 💯💯
Your 1st, 2nd and 3rd are contradicting on it's own when you say English is international language then why can't it be used to communicate with other states?😂😂😅
First they must bring an upgrade training & improving skills of teachers ( millions of teachers) to implement this policy. Without doing, 80% of teachers will not be able create strong fundamentals for students. This will create confusion and ineffectiveness in the education system. They have to improve the teachers standard before bringing this change
ruclips.net/video/GeFCVm6hjWk/видео.html 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😢😢😨😨😧😧😦😦😟😟🙁
7.45 I accept becoz after 10th I was denied for science group though I took above 75% overall and 55% in science then I took tc joined in other school science group got medicine seat now infected with covid 19 due to covid duty last week.
Take care bro..you will get well soon
Gws
Really accept all your points ji.. the success lies in how they going to implement it...
Thank you very much for sharing this.
There is no point g(ji) or h .🤪
Plz plz subscribe to my channel
@@thanan2425 plz plz subscribe my channel
See ideawings for NEP it's too good.
அருமையான பதிவு மற்றும் விளக்கம் ... உங்கள் கருத்துக்களை நான் வரவேற்கிறேன் தோழரே....
When you want to fly we need to change the vehicle to aircrafts. But we are dreaming to fly with cars.
Perfect example
Absolutely 👍
@@wingstamizh education policy should cater all sections of society. If some people get bullock cart only, then it is not good.
City students have lots of option for any kind of coaching to score high compated to village schools of all over India. On this Please consider all over india.this is completely against poor students those who are coming from rural villages.
First change should be our government school infrastructure with basic amenities and transportation to reach..
Waiting for this video from LMES. Finally Watched it. As always explained well.
Well said, exactly what I have felt on this system. Ofcourse there might be some challenges while implementing but if it is successfully implemented it will greatly improve the next generations vision on all kinds of jobs and rather than a stress kids will enjoy doing and parent (our generation) also can motivate them in all kinds of jobs. The implementation part like you said, is the challenging ine, it should be implemented in a way where foreign universities have professors who are scientists too, and this should be distributed all over the state/country and many visiting teachers should be encouraged which will never supress the students from asking questions. Rather than being a business education should now atleast become a necessity that government should handle. I beleive future india will be so intelligent if the vision is implemented unanimously. Hoping to see the future 🤞
Furturw india had many school dropouts Nd low cost labour
I feel that before implementing new policy for student education, govt should implement new policy for teachers ( about qualification, updating their knowledge, exams for teachers)
Can't the post graduate teachers handle classes from 6 - 12? Why do you think about qualification, exam and updation??
and navodhya schools are should be allowed to bridge the gap between rural (state board) and city (CIBC) schools.
@@saravanadevi6406 - may be an introduction to and training in children and student psychology may help teachers to serve students better.
Exactly...when ever wee update student with good quality at the same time the teachers also update.. 💯💯💯
வணக்கம் பிரேம் அண்ணா,
புதிய கல்விக் கொள்கை பற்றி ஒரு சிறப்பான காணொளி அளித்துள்ளீர்கள், சில சந்தேகங்கள் மற்றும் எதிர்மறை பார்வைகளுக்கு நல்ல விளக்கமும் அளித்துள்ளீர்கள் சிறப்பு.
உதாரணமாக: படிநிலை பள்ளி முறை, 6-8 வகுப்புகளில் தொழிற்கல்வி போன்றவற்றை கூறலாம்.
இது ஒரு மாற்றுக்கல்விக்கான வரைவாக இருந்தாலும் இந்த கல்வி முறை ஒன்றிய அளவில் பொதுமை படுத்தப்படும் போது அந்தந்த மாநிலத்தின் சமூக நிலை மற்றும் வரலாறு சார்ந்த கல்வியில் எத்தகைய முன்னுரிமை கொடுக்கப்படும்?
ஏனெனில் தற்போது உள்ள நிலையிலேயே வரலாறு வடக்கிருந்துதான் தொடங்குகிறது இக்கொள்கையின் முடிவு எத்தகைய விளைவை ஏற்படுத்தும்?
அடிப்படை கல்வி என்பது தாய்மொழியில் கற்பது எவ்வளவு நன்மையோ அதோபோல் தானே அந்த கல்வியின் தரத்தை நிர்ணயிக்கும் உரிமையும், அப்படியானால் மாநிலங்களுக்கு வழிகாட்டும் வரைவாகத்தானே இக்கொள்கை இருக்கவேண்டும்? மாறாக அது ஒன்றிய அதிகார குவிப்பிற்க்கான கொள்கையாக உள்ளதே அல்லது பார்க்கப்படுகின்றது ஏன்?
அப்படி இல்லை இது அனைத்துதரப்பு மாநிலங்களுக்கும் மக்களுக்கும் பொதுவானதே இதில் எந்த எதிர்மறை மற்றும் மக்களுக்கு முரணான விதிகள் இல்லை என்றால் ஏன் ஒரு பொது விவாதமின்றி சட்டமன்ற பாராளுமன்ற விவாதமின்றி கல்வியாளர்கள் மற்றும் பொதுமக்களால் அனுப்பட்ட கேள்விகள், சந்தேகங்களுக்கு பதிலேதும்மின்றி அவசர கதியில் ஏதோ அரசியல் சார் முடிவுபோல் அமல்படுத்தப்பட்டுள்ளது?
இது மேலோட்டமாக சுவைக்க தேன் போல் தெரிந்தாலும் அதன் அடியாழத்தில் மறைமுக விஷங்கள் உள்ளனவோ என்ற ஐயம் உள்ளன...
அதனாலேயே நீட் எனும் போலி சமப்பந்தி முறையில் கொள்கை வரைவோ என்று சந்தேகமும் விழைகின்றது.
உங்கள் பதிலுக்காக....
Ganesan Saravanan, இப்போது இந்த காணொளியைக் கண்டேன். சிறப்பான உங்களது response க்கு பாராட்டுக்கள்.
இப்படிப் பட்ட கேள்விகள் தாம் இவ் விஷயம் பற்றிய ஒரு அறிவு பூர்வமான, ஆக்க பூர்வமான விவாதம், பரிசீலனை க்கு வழி வகுக்கும். வெறுமனே உணர்ச்சி வசப்படாமல், நமக்கு வேண்டிய மாற்றங்கள் என்ன, அவற்றை எப்படி அடைவது என்று சிந்திக்க வைக்கும். நன்றி. தொடரட்டும் உங்களது follow-up.
தங்களது உரை சிறப்பு,நீங்கள் கடைசி யாக கூறிய பொது தேர்வு முறை ,
மிக மிக ஆழமான ஆதிக்க சிந்தனையோடு உருவாக்கியது,பொதுகல்வி முறை இல்லாத நாட்டில் பொது தேர்வுமுறை என்ன நீதி? இந்திய அளவில் அனைவருக்கும் தாய்மொழிவழியில் சமச்சீர் கல்வி திட்டத்தை நடைமுறைப்படுத்தி ,போதுமான ஆசிரியர்களை நியமனம் செய்து அனைத்து கட்டமைப்பு களையும் சரிசெய்வதே முதல் தேவையும், சீர்திருத்தமாகும். தற்போதைய சீரமைப்பு (பொது தேர்வு) என்பது அடிதட்டுமக்களை கல்வியிலிருந்து வெளியேற்ற செய்யும் குல கல்வி திட்டமேயாகும்.
.
@@dhassyestak3693 பல மொழி சமூகங்கள் வாழும் நம் நாட்டில் கல்வி என்பது அந்தந்த மொழிச்சமூகத்தி கையில் இருப்பதுதான் அச்சமூகத்தை வளர்ச்சியடைய செய்யும். நமக்கான அதிகாரம் நமது கையில்தான் இருக்க வேண்டும்.
Exactly
@UC78lOsQy2WQ4450iihkkCLA உங்கள் நம்பிக்கை நல்ல சிந்தனைதான் சகோ! ஆனால் நாம் தேர்வு என்றொரு அறியாமையில் இருட்டில் இருக்கிறோம், ஆசிரியர்களுக்கு கொடுக்க நடத்தப்பட வேண்டியது திறன் மேம்பாட்டு பயிற்சியே தவிர தேர்வு அல்ல, காரணம் பொதுவாக தேர்வு என்பது ஒரு சிலருக்கு வெற்றியை அளிக்க உதவுமே தவிர அணைவரின் திறனையும் மேம்படுத்துமா என்றால் இல்லை என்றுதான் கூற முடியும். ஆனால் ஆண்டுக்கு ஒரு அல்லது பருவ அடிப்படையில் திறன் மேம்பாட்டு பயிற்சி அளிப்பதின் மூலம் உங்களது என்னத்தின் தீர்வையும் அடையமுடியும் மாணவர்களின் கல்வியையும் மேம்படுத்த முடியும்,
ஆனால் இவை அனைத்து கல்வியின் உரிமை மாநில அரசிடம் இருந்தால் மட்டுமே அந்தந்த மொழிச்சமுகத்திற்க்கு உதவி முன்னேற்ற முடியுமே தவிர இந்த கல்வி அதிகாம் ஒன்றிய அரசின் கைகளுக்கு சென்றால் அது நிதிச்சுமை என்ற நிலையில் அரசின் கைகளை விட்டு விலகி தனியாரிடம் முழுமையாக தாரை வார்க்கப்படும் பின் நீங்கள் கோரும் எந்த தரத்தையும் முதலாளிய தனியார் நிறுவனம் நிச்சயம் தராது, இன்றும் ஓன்றிய மற்றும் மாநில அளவில் சிறந்த கல்வி மற்றும் கல்விக்கட்டமைப்பை வழங்குவதில் அரசு பல்கலைக்கழகங்கள் மற்றும் கல்லூரிகளே முன்னிலையில் உள்ளன என்பது நம் புரிதலுக்குள்ளாக வேண்டும்.
As a 90's kid I wished to have all these but it never hapnd but I'm happy that my child is going to enjoy this system!!
See ideawings for NEP it's too good.
same feeling bro
Sad thing is that still our local politicians are opposing this new policy just bcoz it was introduced by BJP
@@SanthoshKumar-in4dl so this is the time we peoples should support this new system for our future generations
emma un kolandhaiya mattum yosikriye...naladhu. un kolandha fail aiduchina??
Really appreciate all the important points discussed in the video. Especially the one highlighting the lack of talent in teaching line which is truly a cause for concern.
புதிய கல்வி கொள்கை நம் நாட்டின் எதிர்காலத்தை தீர்மானிக்கும் என்பது மறுக்க முடியாத உண்மை. ஆனால் இவற்றை சரியான முறையில் நாம் செயல்படுத்தினால் மட்டுமே சாத்தியம்..... தங்களின் இந்த அற்புதமான பதிவிற்கு மீண்டும் நன்றி வாழ்த்துக்கள் ... தோழரே..
I am equally happy and worried about my 2yr old kid's education. Happy about practical and skill based learning like in Japan, worried about board exams at early age and one additional local language
See ideawings for NEP it's too good.
Sir ... don’t worry my kid is currently in
5 th std from 3 rd std they have 3 languages ( English, Hindi & Kannada) ... They don’t find it difficult... They pick up..
I am from Bangalore...
Déjà vu LMES.
What you have been mentioning so long is suddenly implemented into a policy.
Despite the shortfalls, this does look like a giant step forward.
Congratulations to LMES for championing the education system.
Board exam, subject group, and mugging mentality must end.
Suddenly? Omg this bill is in discussion for over 6 years. Namo initiated as soon as he came to office.
O mugging mentality will gone ....how .....3 5 8 10 11 12 board exam and after entrance exam foe colleges .....how it improve ....it increase school dropouts and create low coat labourers
So many schools don't have even toilet facilities which is the most basic requirement.
No proper lab facility in many schools,
This is nice to hear but very difficult to implement
Faizal Basha manam irunthal margam undu. This will take years to correct mistakes of the past.
Even in TN government schools were the best schools till 1980. Only after the advent of private schools & tuition classes quality of government schools went down. I wish they ban government teachers from making money on the sides and rather pay them based on success of their students
@@kashmani8029 what is the meaning of the proverb u mentioned say it pls
@@yougetwhatudeserve3972 where there is a will there's a way
@@santhiyachokkalingam2957 kk thank you
Faisal basha, brother be positive 😊 we can do it.
When LMES give replay for you turn......
@Navin Venkatachalam dei fake paradesi, avan oru aaluthanda.
@Navin Venkatachalam dai fake check la certified youtube channel you tune only in tamilnadu
@Navin Venkatachalam then questions ketta answer pannunga atha vittutu thave illama pesatha
@Navin Venkatachalam I know LMES will answer the YOU TURN video.
Sangee sangee sangee
Government school பசங்களுக்கு எட்டாமல் இருப்பது மெடிக்கல் related course தான் அது இன்டெர்ன்ஷிப் ல இருக்கா.
அதுக்கு தானே நீட் இருக்கு
Hard work is never fails brother. 👍👌💐❤
TN govt 7% reservation for medical kodutirukanga govt school students ku
@@SivaPrasathTR
Bro ippo government school la padichavan neettuku padichu oru 250-280 eduthu pass agetannu vachukunga, avanukku private colleges tha kedaikum, so avanala college sera mudiyathu
Itheve oru well settled parentsoda paiyan only 220-240 eduthu passagi private collegela sernthuruvan.
Ithula enga equality irukunnu sollunga???
money irukaravanukku tha inga seattu.
@Bharath yeah bro....
Thank you very much! After seeing so much stupidity in internet. Finally some one has come up with the correct analysis. Of course if you are not, who will.
Yes.. . Tamilnatule naraye Peru policy padikamale pesuvanunge 😂
So many teachers are here without proper knowledge and without teaching interest..............solution of this problem is also necessary.........
True bro 😓
குறிப்பாக நீங்கள் குறிப்பிட வேண்டியது அரசு பள்ளிகளில் பணியில் உள்ள ஒரு சில ஆசிரியர்களை அனைவரையும் அல்ல....
@@mahirose1993 niraya teachers irukaanganu than sonnan........ellarum apdinu sollala.........private la yum ithu pontra teachers irukaanga......
@@mahirose1993 ரொம்ப திறமையான ஆசிரியர்கள் அரசு பள்ளிகளில் தான் இருக்காங்க
நம் நல்வாழ்விற்காக திருக்குறள் விளக்கங்களும் அதற்க்கு தொடர்புடைய சுவாரஷ்யமான தகவல்களும்
ruclips.net/video/7Zu17bApCss/видео.html
அருமை தெளிவான விளக்கம் .
மூன்றாம் மொழி கட்டாயம் என்பது ஏற்றுக்கொள்ள முடியாது விருப்பம் உள்ளவர்கள் படிக்கட்டும் அது ஹிந்தியாக இருந்தாலும் பரவாயில்லை அது அவர்கள் விருப்பம்.
I think parents also should be enlightened about the policy(in rural as well as urban) to change the perspective !
Competitive programming from 6th really unexpected, appreciated
In future India will have more redcoders
Let's hope India will win ICPC one day
what is redcoders and ICPC???
@@kruphashankar8715
ICPC ( International Collegiate Programming Contest)
=> Olympic in competitive programming
Redcoder : something like grandmaster in competitive programming
In codeforces website if you have rating higher than 2400 you will become redcoder
This rating is Calculated based on your performance in
the contests conducted by this website
It is an russian website
Worlds top competitive programmers are also participate in this contests
Haha dude. Only competitive programmers will understand what you are saying. I do. But your point is right.
இது எல்லாம் பணம் இருக்கிறவனுக்கும் தனியார் பள்ளிகளில் தான் இந்த வசதிகள் இருக்கும் இவர்களுக்கு தான் புதிய கல்வி கொள்கை நல்ல இருக்கும்
எங்களை போல ஏழைகளுக்கு நடுத்தர குடுபங்களுக்கு அரசாங்கம் பள்ளிகளில் திறமைமிக்க ஆசிரியர்கள் வசதிகள் இருக்க மாட்டார்கள் இதை எல்லாம் நடைமுறை சாத்திய படுத்துவது கடினம் நம்ம ஊரு அரசாங்க பள்ளி கூடங்களை பார்த்தாலே தெரியும்
☺️👍👌
Good take LMES:
My biggest concern against this policy and hope they consider and change is:
1. 3 language = burden
2. Common entrance after 12th. We should rather adopt de centralised approach of exams or application.
3. Board exams for 5th,8th etc shud be removed. That too National level exam adds pressure. Maybe 12th board alone is okay that too state level.
4. Say of State govt in Education ??
5. How much of government role in school education is not addressed completely.
LMES pls talk about point 3,4 & 5.
Your points are far better than those of Lmes. Very shocked lmes didn't talk abt these and more minuses of this policy.
First minus starts at the first stage that foundation starts at 3yrs of age. What a stupidity.
And I pity those who have commented that they want to learn under this policy.
Mr Premanand sethurajan bro, Yengha Oor Village la Nengha solra AI, IoT technology yellam illa, appo idhu yeppadi Sathiyam... pottery, Gardening is there... Itha patha kula kalvi thitam mari than theriyudhu..... North la innum padippu arivu illama irukan, adhukku avangha namma yeppadi mela vanthom nu follow pannallam, Namma mella irukkum so, we can go for advancement in our education.
Rip for those who have just completed 12
I'm
Adha yen thambi nyabagam paduthureenga nenjamellam punna irukku
And for studing 12 th
Online course
@@adithyanr6436 Me too Studying 12th
There is a point on starting coding from standard 6. As a software engineer I welcome this. This will definitely
Improve interest in software engineering
,
are really software engineers do coding? in india's service based IT companies,95% percentage of indian it companies are clerk service companies for core companies and those employees works as unskilled clerks in the name of software engineer
இது எல்லாம் பணம் இருக்கிறவனுக்கும் தனியார் பள்ளிகளில் தான் இந்த வசதிகள் இருக்கும் இவர்களுக்கு தான் புதிய கல்வி கொள்கை நல்ல இருக்கும்
எங்களை போல ஏழைகளுக்கு நடுத்தர குடுபங்களுக்கு அரசாங்கம் பள்ளிகளில் திறமைமிக்க ஆசிரியர்கள் வசதிகள் இருக்க மாட்டார்கள் இதை எல்லாம் நடைமுறை சாத்திய படுத்துவது கடினம் நம்ம ஊரு அரசாங்க பள்ளி கூடங்களை பார்த்தாலே தெரியும்
unknown world Indian software engineer are doing coding dood and creating products that is used all over the world and definitely we are not doing just clerk work ...what u say is old saying
@@unknownworld711 95% is a really wrong number. There are people who do clerical
Work but the number would be lower. There are also people who work for huge tech giants and there are lot of new entrepreneurs who create their own world class companies. All this is inspite of majority of our students having little or no coding knowledge until college. Teaching coding at school level would definitely improve quality of engineers from India
Your analysis is appreciable. I hav always admired ur clarity of expression. One thing that i differ is, as an educationist for 25 yrs, running a village school , our students have had three languages from age 6 and it has worked well so three lang is a good idea i feel
I'm a student of grade 11 and I don't agree with you opinion.
3rd, 5th, and 8th graders when faced with the big task called "board exams" they would DEFINITELY undergo lot of pressure in such a yound age. And also, your support for students learning in their own language cannot be followed in a country like India that has diverse range of people speaking various languages. Countries like Japan, China, Korea can do so because they have the same language all over the nation but ours does not have a single language. And what if there is a student who is transferred to another state and doesn't know the regional language, how will that student learn? Wouldn't that make it harder for the students?
👍💯
I strongly agree ur point
I strongly agree ur poimts
As a doctor I agree with everything you said ; also higher education has become a business , like you said the entrance examinations favour students who had the money to go to coaching centres and learn. As a PG aspirant it's very tough to get a seat of my choice through NEET exam without coaching although I was a topper in school.
Bro Finland education system and our new education system compare panni podunga bro...
Finland la per day ku 6hrs than wrking hours and weekly 4days than wrking day
Population do matters plus they all pay taxes.. So it makes no sense to compare
First the selection of teachers is very important to effect this NEP. For that our political system is great interference. Only qualified people must be posted w/o adopting the persent recruitment system. For the post of teachers, doctors and advocates quality is very important. For other jobs the present system of recruitment can be followed. Will it work in the present political synorio? Children can cope up with 3 languages. No problem at all. I welcome the NEP as it is.
@Sam Ram if you are generous enough to pay for farmers produce you can expect to tax their income as well. But this not happening in reality.
Finland onum avlo perusu ila bro...just keka tha nala iruku...
Being 90s kid...
I really miss this education system...
Ithu vena nu nama govt solluthu bro that is totally wrong
@@arjunsj9866 na bro ilaa..I'm girl..
@@arjunsj9866 adhylam implement paniduvagha bro.... modi ji avlo sekram vitramataruu
Yenamo ivingalu orupada matanuuinga namalaiyu orupada vidamatainga poinga sahoo
@@rupikav5576 sari akka
How can a child who is 10 year old can choose the vocational course are they matured enough to choose the course will the talent of the child be found within grade 5 till now students are struggling to find the talent inside them how can you make a child choose the course in grade 5
Nep wants board exams in grade 3 how can a child attend an board exam in grade 3 wouldn't that make more psychological pressure to the student will the student play in the park or prepare for the board exams.
Ok even though Nep is implemented education comes with under state list wouldn't it create an big confusion between the states. How can this policy be implemented
Everybody here focusing only about negative points mentioned by him. Understand he has supported many other aspects as well. Life is not 0 or 1. Everything is not good or bad. There is good AND bad. Pls learn to accept and give credit where it's due
உண்மை தான் ஆனால் அதில் உள்ள எதிர் கருத்துக்களை அறிந்து நேர்மறையாக மாற்றுவது தான் சிறந்தது...ஒருவன் நேர்மறையாக இருப்பவனை விட எதிர்மறையான சிந்தனைகளை நேர்மறையான மாற்றுபவர்களே திறமைசாலிகள்...
@Vel Kumaran Moolaye kidayadha? Edhaanu detail irukka un badhil la? Maatru karuthe illai nu neeye suvatrai paarthu perumaiya sollikuviya? brainwashed !!!
@@gcstech4922 yes lets hope they implement well. naatula thirudar kootamaan, aana nalladhu seiya varavan 90% nalladhu senja podhadhu, 120% seiyanum adhaane? naama road cross panravangalukku vazhi viduroma? naama namma veetu velai seiyum nabar kuppai thottiyil dhaan kuppaiyai poduraara nu paakuroma? namma implementation en kaathula pogudhu eppovum?
@Vel Kumaran nalla vizhicha po. edhuvume detail kudukadha, hindi hindi hindi, pinnani, paarpana sadhi, adimai, naalai kaalam sudukaadu mayam nu sema peela
இது எல்லாம் பணம் இருக்கிறவனுக்கும் தனியார் பள்ளிகளில் தான் இந்த வசதிகள் இருக்கும் இவர்களுக்கு தான் புதிய கல்வி கொள்கை நல்ல இருக்கும்
எங்களை போல ஏழைகளுக்கு நடுத்தர குடுபங்களுக்கு அரசாங்கம் பள்ளிகளில் திறமைமிக்க ஆசிரியர்கள் வசதிகள் இருக்க மாட்டார்கள் இதை எல்லாம் நடைமுறை சாத்திய படுத்துவது கடினம் நம்ம ஊரு அரசாங்க பள்ளி கூடங்களை பார்த்தாலே தெரியும்
12th complete pannathuku aparam ipadi oru policy 🤦🏻♂️....
Adhu nama vidi bro
See ideawings for NEP it's too good.
Neenga soldrathaa patha
Intha policy nalla than irukku
But itha schls and teachers ozhunga pannanum....so that we can get more intelligence students....🔥🔥🔥
This education policy It's does not wrk in Village,
Yes. Even in private schl teacher also wont work....
@@powerprofile69 yeah I agree that's y we are opposing this system
இது எல்லாம் பணம் இருக்கிறவனுக்கும் தனியார் பள்ளிகளில் தான் இந்த வசதிகள் இருக்கும் இவர்களுக்கு தான் புதிய கல்வி கொள்கை நல்ல இருக்கும்
எங்களை போல ஏழைகளுக்கு நடுத்தர குடுபங்களுக்கு அரசாங்கம் பள்ளிகளில் திறமைமிக்க ஆசிரியர்கள் வசதிகள் இருக்க மாட்டார்கள் இதை எல்லாம் நடைமுறை சாத்திய படுத்துவது கடினம் நம்ம ஊரு அரசாங்க பள்ளி கூடங்களை பார்த்தாலே தெரியும்
Athu ellam k. Yenna unga name ye quarantine nu change pannitinga. Corano kuda vazha palakitinga polave.
கருத்துக்களை படிக்கலாமுன்னு வந்தேன் ஒரே ஆங்கிலம் !
தமிழில் பதிவு செய்திருந்தால் எனக்கு பயனுள்ளதாக இருந்திருக்கும்.
Saaman thombi pola nee?
Good to see positive comments on New Education Policy despite some concerns. Just because it is brought by BJP, some people r opposing it. Shashi Taroor from Congress too welcomed the move. Hope Kalam's dream will come true 💓
I don't belong to any party. I would say all party should stop advertising their party in each policy. Regarding this education policy it is good move indeed, are we addressing teachers and government schools enhancements. I strongly feel education and health care should be run by government if not fully at least 60-70 percent with all facility equal to private at subsidised cost. Else people will suffer whatever the policy be, private will turn it to their profit. I expect school fees rise once this policy Is implemented
@@baburaj-zv4cb Of course, Private Schools will b on looting spree as usual. Most of the private schools are run by politicians or their binamies. So they will not bring norms to control the fee structure..
Anna you are the light for the many students here.....
உங்கள் சேவை மூலம் கிடைக்கும் வெற்றி மகத்தானது
இந்த புதிய கல்விக் கொள்கையை நான் வரவேற்கிறேன்.. இம்முயற்சி வெற்றி பெற்று நம் மாணவர்கள் பயன் பெற வேண்டும்..
Yes all MIDDLE CLASS PEOPLE.
நான் ஐந்தாம் வகுப்பு வரை மட்டுமே படித்தவன் எனவே இந்த காணோளி
தமிழ்லில் இருந்து இருந்தால் இன்னும்
சிறப்பாக இருக்கும்
I got jealous when i hearing this policy because still now i didn't get what is my passion and stuck in career growth.
But, this policy definitely makes the students more intelligent.
I support
True brother
Correct brother
Bro ipavum entha prob um illa unga passion ahh ipavum follow pannala age is not a limit ofcourse sila risks iruku economical ahh but edu thu paarunga backup oda jus give it a try:)
Yes
Nice Video Anna..i am also thinking the same..having some disadvantages (many exams & 3rd language ) and many positives..but implications, we have to wait and see🤝👍
Plz plz subscribe my channel
ruclips.net/video/hfegz1yfMsQ/видео.html
Please support
Plz plz subscribe my channel with views
Yes, 3rd language is waste
In my opinion 3rd language is not wrong at all. I'm a person who actually knows 4 languages. Learning languages from young ages has a lot of positive impact in the IQ and Emotional Quotient of a person. Moreover it also makes our communication skills more effective.
We should not consider learning new languages as a stress to the children at all.
And I personally feel that Hindi is a language we Tamilians must also learn as I have seen people struggling to communicate in the North due to their non Hindi background.
We must also keep in mind that the English that we all learn is itself a foreign language but we oppose when we are told to learn Hindi, which is an Indian language. When Indian Govt says that Hindi is must learn language our politicians say that they are IMPOSING Hindi upon us but they seldom remember that English, which is a non Indian language, was itself FORCIBLY IMPOSED upon us Indians BY THE BRITISHERS.
Thank you for the brief explanation.. The policy is good but I don’t think we have qualified teachers to understand the new policy and shape the students.. As a standard,a tool like pick my career and feedback of teachers should be compared, based on this students should be able to understand or visualise their passion..
Parents choose panni sollrathu than bro mukka vasi passanga higher study la yedukranga 😔
Bro India la naraya courses ku perusa scope illa bro. Government should need to change this. In USA u can earn 2500$(Rs. 2L) per month if you studied Bsc.Physics. because USA focuses research based things more. But in India aracha maavaye araikaranga. New policy super ah irukku. Naan kastapatta maari en kozhandhainga kastapada maatanga😀.
@@karthikeyan53 mm bro... USA, UK la engineering kum,bsc phy, chem, mat la nalla scope irukka vaippu irukku bro...salary better a irukkum india va compare panna nu nenaikren bro......
Na padikumpodu 3 languages padichen malayam ,Hindi , engilsh and Sanskrit venum na aduvum iruku I'm from Kerala and enaku Tamil um theriyum
Hats off to this channel , for making educational videos and inspiring slot of people
Athu hats off pa
எல்லாத்துக்கும் entrance entrance நா கண்டிப்பா மிடில், low peoples பாதிக்கபாடுவாங்க... ஒன்னு தெரிஞ்சுக்கோங்க entrance ல பெரிய பெரிய coching செனட்டர் ல படிச்சு pass பண்ணவங்க அறிவாளி இல்ல....
Kastapattu padi karaven than pass pannuvan, periya couching center pona mattum pothathu.
It create parrelel market for tuition centres and coaching centres
@@logesmech9837 bro critizing is part of democracy .... without critizing we will become an autocratic society
Cracking exams and being genuinely knowledgable is the respective subject are two very different things.
@Parameshwaran R I hope u read it completely please say how u justifying three language policy ..it's purely hindi imposition
உங்கள் கருத்தும் கணிப்பும் மிக சரியே . மாற்றங்கள் வேண்டும் அதை செய்ய தகுதியும் வாய்ப்பும் இருக்கின்றதா என்பது சந்தேகம் . இங்கு கல்வி மிகப்பெரிய பணம் கொழிக்கும் தொழிலாக மாறிவிட்டது . உங்கள் சிந்தனை படி மும்மொழி கொள்கை தேவை அற்றது என்பது உண்மைதான் . நீங்கள் சொல்லும் திருத்தந்தை செய்தால் சிறப்பாக இருக்கும் . மகிழ்ச்சியே
This sounds too good to be true. Its good on paper . implementation ?
I feel the same too!
It has many flaw .....we can feel sad that we missed it but feel 3 5 8 10 11 12 this much board exam ..the amount pressure and entrance exam preparation after school ....
Coding from 6th!!! Best idea! Engineering students ae coding theriyama struggle panranga... Middle school la padichirndha kavalaye illa...90skids 2k kids paavam.
yes..True..We missed this.!
Coding ??? You make English optional in the primary class and coding from sixth ?you think everyone has the facilities for that???? Moreover this policy also talks about vocational courses ?? Which UC rich person will send their kid for these courses??? The people from the Dalit and backward communities only they will end up in these courses ,and what's the logic behind bringing in foreign universities ??the rich kids will go abroad and study ,but why you bringing it here 🤷♀️then again the policy talks about more "autonomy " for universities which is again a dangerous proposition for social justice ,again making English optional is a foolish idea ,then what's the relevance of sanskrit now? This policy will only benefit the upper castes elites and the private institutes and coaching institutes
Sharad Mahendar www.ijhssi.org/papers/vol8(6)/Series-3/A0806030109.pdf
@@Sharadmahendar12 enga kudaa caste nee kondu varaa dingaa chaii caste pityakaraa kutamm galaa...
For that the teacher must know about coding and importantly there must be computer for every student in schools?????
வணக்கம்!
கல்விக் கொள்கை குறித்த எனது எண்ணங்களையும், விருப்பங்களையும் தொகுத்து கீழ்கண்டவாறு கொடுத்துள்ளேன். இதனை செயல்முறை படுத்த ஆவன செய்து நம் கல்வியையும், அதன் வாயிலாக நாட்டையும் செம்மை படுத்த வேண்டுகிறேன்.
அனைவருக்கும் அரசு கல்வி வழங்குதல் வேண்டும்
எந்தவித ஏற்றத்தாழ்வுகளும், பிரிவினைகளும் அற்ற கல்வி 10ஆம் வகுப்பு வரை வேண்டும். இது அனைத்து அடிப்படை அறிவு அனைவர்க்கும் தர வழி செய்யும்.
கட்டாயம் கல்வியை அரசு மட்டுமே தர வேண்டும். புதிய தனியார் கல்வி நிலையங்களுக்கு அனுமதி மறுத்து, தற்போது உள்ள தனியார் கல்வி நிலையங்களை குறைந்த கால எல்லைக்குள் அரசுடைமை ஆக்குதல் வேண்டும்.
கல்வியில் ஏற்றத்தாழ்வு தவிர்க்கப்படவும் அனைவர்க்கும் கல்வி வழங்கப்படவும், அனைவருக்கும் சமமான வாய்ப்பு வழங்கவும், கல்வியை இலவசமாக வழங்குதல் வேண்டும்.
கல்விக் கொள்கைகளுக்கு மாநிலங்களின் பங்களிப்புடன் உடன்பட்டு அனைத்து வகையான கருத்துக்களையும் நன்கு பரிசீலித்து முடிவெடுக்க படவேண்டும். மண் சார்ந்த அறிவு தர மாநிலங்களின் பங்களிப்பே முதன்மையாகும்.
அனைவர்க்கும் தாய்மொழி வழி கல்வி பயில தளங்களை உருவாக்கி தரவேண்டும். தாய் மொழி வழி கல்வியால் செழுமையான சிந்தனை கொண்ட அடுத்த தலைமுறை மாணவர்களை உருவாக்க முடியம். எளிமையான முறையில் விளங்கிக்கொள்ளவும், புரிந்தவற்றை கொண்டு மேலும் சிந்தனை தூண்டப்பட்டு அடுத்த நிலைக்கு செல்லவும் இதுவே முதன்மை வழி.
ஒரு மொழி கொண்டே பல்துறை திறன் வளர்த்தல் எளிமையாக நிகழுவதால் மும்மொழி கொள்கை தேவையற்றது.
கல்விதான் ஒரு நாட்டின் மக்களின் எதிர்காலமாக உள்ளதால், கல்வியை அரசியல் படுத்தவேண்டாம். தமிழர்க்கு எக்காலத்திலும் இந்தி வேண்டாம். அதை ஒன்றிய அரசு ஒரு போதும் கட்டாய படுத்தவோ, திணிக்கவோ, பரிந்துரை செய்யவோ வேண்டாம். விருப்பம் உள்ளவர்களும் தேவை உள்ளவர்களும் தாமாக முன்வந்து கற்பர்.
நுனிப்புல் மேய்வது ஒருகாலும் சிறந்த கல்வி ஆகாது, கல்வியின் அகல ஆழம் காண தாய்மொழி வழி கல்வியே தேவையானது. தாய்மொழி செளுமையுற்றால் சிந்தையும், திறமும், செயலும் சிறப்புறும்.
உலகம் மாறிவரும் தொழில்நுட்ப திறத்தால் ஓர் மொழியே மாந்தர்க்கு போதும், மற்றவற்றை தொழில்நுட்பம் நிரப்பும். மொழிமாற்றம், மொழிபெயர்ப்பு யாவற்றையும் தொழில்நுட்பம் கைக்கொள்ளும். தொடர்புக்காக என தனிமொழி கற்று நேரத்தை விரயம் செய்ய தேவையில்லை
அனைத்து துறை சார்ந்த சொற்களையும், தகவல்களையும் தாய் மொழி வழியாக பயிலும் வண்ணமும், பயிற்றுவிக்கும் வண்ணமும் சொல்லியில் மற்றும் துறையில் ஆய்வுகள் நடத்தி எளிமையாக கையாளுதல் வேண்டும்.
கல்வி கற்பிக்கும் முறை, ஆசிரியர் மாணவர் உறவு, பாடநூலுக்கு வெளிய உள்ள கல்வி, ஆசிரியர்களுக்கு தொடர் கல்வியியல் சார்ந்த உள்ளீடு என கற்பிக்கும் முறையில் அன்றாடம் புதுமை புகுத்துதல் என மாணாக்கரின் ஆர்வத்தினையும் உந்துசத்தியினையும் உற்சாகத்தினையும் தன்னம்பிக்கையையும் அளிப்பதன் மூலம் வளமான சமூகத்தை வளர்த்தெடுக்க போராடவேண்டும்.
மதிப்பெண் மையமாக உள்ள கல்வியில் இருந்து மாறுபட்டு சிந்தனை மற்றும் செயல் திறன் மையமாக கல்வி அமைத்தல் வேண்டும்.
இடைநிற்றல் என்ற முறை ஒழிக்கப்பட்டு, எவ்வண்ணம் மாணாக்கரை முன்னழைத்து செல்வது என்ற சிந்தனை தேவை.
குழந்தைகளுக்கு பொது தேர்வு போன்ற அச்சுறுத்தல்களை ஒளித்து. அவர்களின் இயல்புகளை உணர்ந்து கல்வி பயணம் மேற்கொள்ள வழிவகை செய்யவேண்டும்.
கல்லூரி செல்ல ஊக்குவிப்பும், உறுதுணையுமே செய்யவேண்டும், அதை தவிர்த்து நுழைவு தேர்வு போன்றவற்றை இனி தொடராது என்ற உறுதிப்பாடு வேண்டும்.
சமூக நீதி, இட ஒதுக்கீடு, நிதி உதவி, போன்றவற்றை மேலும் வலுப்படுத்தி மக்கள் வாழ்வும், வளமும் பெறுக வழி செய்யதல் வேண்டும்.
உலகின் சிறந்த கல்விக் கொள்கைகளை ஆராய்ந்து அதை முறைப்படுத்த ஒரு சிறந்த குழு அமைத்தல் வேண்டும்.
கல்விக் குழுவிற்கு சிறந்த கல்வி ஆலோசகர்கள், சிறந்த கல்வியாளர்கள் என அனைவரையும் ஒன்று திரட்டி ஆலோசனை நடத்தி முடிவெடுத்தல் வேண்டும்.
அறம், நீதிநெறி, இயற்கை சார்ந்த விழிப்புணர்வு, சுற்றுசூழல்பராமரிப்பு, சுய சிந்தனை, சுய முன்னேற்றம், கலை, அறிவியல், இலக்கியம், பண்பாடு, விளையாட்டு, சமகால நிகழ்வுகள், உலகை நோக்கின பார்வை/புரிதல், அரசியல், பொருளாதாரம், மனிதநேயம் என அனைத்து முதன்மையான விடையங்களையும் கருத்தில் கொண்டு கல்வி அமைத்தல் வேண்டும்
Bro tamil la comment panruthu romba kashtam neenga epdi panninga
Ungalin karuthu varaverka thakkathu.
@@DrKSekar Google keyboard installed.
@@mahalakshmi3249 மிக்க நன்றி 😊
☺️👍
I am a student of grade 11 and i would like to say that i disagree with your stance and i would like to state my opinions and reasons why i do not stand with the proposed education system by nep:
1. 2:00 i think 5th graders are far away from not knowing how to read or write or do simple calculations. And also i think interactive classes DO take place for students below grade 5, so i do not take this point as for something 'newly' implemented by nep.
2. 3:22 students in english medium schools can speak well in their own mother tongue and understand better as it is a language used often in their surroundings, i dont think it is necessary for it to be completely changed to it to understand better.
3. 3:40 "english to be taught as a language" - students have already adapted to their subjects being taught in school in english and if it is switched to regional language wont it be harder for them to adapt to this huge change??
4. 3:56 comparing india to other countries like japan, south korea, china, etc, they only have english+ their one regional language. In india each state has many language speakers, so this point makes your statement irrelevant.
5. 5:26 i do not think drop percentage will be affected only by a few percentage (like u stated 1-2%) and plus isnt the 'internship' just changing the mindset of students themselves to be discouraged in certain ways?
6. 5:26 drop percentage also plays a huge role in thid point as board exams for grades 3,5 and 8 just puts a LOT of pressure on students at that young age? even 10th graders dont handle that kind of pressure and the new system wants to impose it on much younger students.
7. 6:01 entrepreneurship isnt just 'product based' services also plays a huge role in our country. hence our country cannot be just changed into product based.
8. 7:39 it doesnt necessarily have to be that science and math students are all high scorers. there are high scorers in commerce too and the courses are chosen by the student's only will/ interest at most cases. i think everyone has to stop having such stereotypes that commerce students are all 'low scorers'.
* these are my opinions and criticism as a student, the ones who will be affected/ face huge changes from this proposed system. *
Yes!! I agree with you!!
I too agree this
Yeahhh I too agree with this 👍🏻
Bro, my biggest concern is about the teachers,
The system they are bringing is absolutely fascinating but I can't trust the teachers here.
Inga irukka majority of teachers ellarume mug adikkavum, salary vaangurathukum dhan irukanga, and that is the fair truth.
(Not for the real dedicated teachers)
Indha govt kitta propoganda dhan iruku... Implementation seri illayae ba
8000 salary la?
Gov la vela kidacha settled aagalaam nu dhan niraya per seruranga
bro avar solra madhiri moota poochiku bayandhu veeta koluthiraamaari..ippo edhi change varamaari theridhu...idha namma appa generation edhirthaaa paravaal..naama kandippan welcome pannanum.indha education policy la naan irundharikka koodadhani irukku..let welcome the change and be the change...
@@arisudhan3629 government ellarukum vela kodukuradhillaiye
I am sad that I can't study in this system
Same
Don't be too sad coz this will not be perfectly followed in our state.This policy is just a gimmick. Nothing will change
Same
@@muthukumarankothandaraman2371 It's not antagonism......it is only going to happen in future. Like he said in the video implementation is very important to perfectly follow this system and that is never gonna happen until qualified and dedicated teachers are appointed in the field
apolam mugap aduchu ennoda life ah keduthu ta
Excellent explanation👌👌👌 Thank you LMES!
Yov....My times le full book mattum daan...Practicals nu peruku vaipaange...i Studied Marathi, hindi, English as language and studied tamil as 4th language. Naange laam manusan elleyaa
I see. You may be well-versed in multiple languages now, good for you! How good are you at Math, Coding, Finance? How good are you at Physics and Chemistry? Was learning all those extra languages helped you succeed at global level or just national level or at least state level? Just because you went through difficult curriculum(meaning different languages), doesn't mean it is right or everybody has to go through it. So, please do not take things personally, see beyond personal gains and try to speak for people who are not even here to voice their concerns. (Ex: Government/Rural school students) PS: I studied at a Govt aided school and I understand the struggles, not everybody can afford extra tuition and at the same time not everyone can be abdul kalam(student from remote village) YET.
Dear Sir,
I am glad that you have clearly mentioned the pros and cons of New education policy but it would be better if you publish the English version for this particular video so that this will reach to huge mass
Thank you
@Dumeel Dude he deserved it bro
Naanga padikirapoo ipdi oru system varama pooche😏😏 .. Most welcoming system😊
Can you tell me which one attracted you?
@@jothirajansundararaj6023 / pudicha subject padikkalaaam nu options irukku la ....adhukku Mela ennanga attraction venum
Indian Nationalist don’t fall for “pudicha subject” no school and college in this world can offer “pudicha subject” for all. It’s all depending on marks. Do you think they give science and maths to ALL who wish even if they get 40, 50 percentage of marks ? Come to the reality. Don’t fall for the “pudicha subject” 😀😀. It’s a magical word. As I said, innum evvalvu new system vandhallum no system in the world can give “pudicha system” to ALL people. Again, it’s all marks + school capacity.
@@jothirajansundararaj6023 / yen pa olaarey .... First video full ah paaru .... ungalukku ulagathala nalladhu nu onnu nadakkavey nadakkadhu nu oru mindset ....always speaking negative 🤦🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️
@@jothirajansundararaj6023 activity based education,,carrier choosing training ,, if u don't like this then u must be a DMK Sombhu😂😂... Adada natla indha upi's tholla thangamudila pa ,,200 ruba vangitu DMK ku jalra thatra kootathula oruthana nee
By chance one born in Ramand/ tiny village and another one in Chennai..it has nothing to do with human talents. I am from a village, studied in Govt school in 1978, now sending ..comments to you.. updating and up keeping is left to individuals ..and need based. This is a hunger driven, greedy driven society...people use education as a route to rich is unfortunate..look at the demand for medical seats.. that is the proof for my statement..- I appreciate your review. I also expect you to review the scholarship issues related to school education. You also please tell whether education is compulsory or not for a citizen.. that should be the first order policy decision.. -Professor. S.Padmanaban
I agree with you ... very Gud policy, but need all private education sector to change the mode of 1 roof under government sector... then all students get benefits & teaching ethics to be modified , need psychological support need for students...
How many knew that India never participated in PISA (Programme for International Student Assessment)? PISA is used to evaluate educational systems worldwide based on reading, science and mathematical skills. In 2018, India participated and bagged 72nd place out of 74 countries. Singapore, Taiwan, Japan, Finland, China manages to stay in top 10. Waiting for India to get a decent rank in PISA.
I am a mechanical engineer. Till 12 th standard I studied only in govt school tamil medium. You are correct. Now 90 % of the teachers are not that much quality. Without quality teachers we can not expect good outcomes.
When all cbse, international school, matric school, govt school standards r equal then education system s good..
Keka ellame romba nalla iruku, implement panna rombave super iruku our india but ena atha implement panrathukulla na schooling finish paniduva ninachatha kastama iruku, but anyway welcome to this wonderful🎉 new education policy🎉
I got depressed after hearing about this policy
Coz I didn't get a good choice to my job
This policy definitely improves students skills. This makes students to get they real talent.
This policy is worked correctly,
I definitely support this!
ruclips.net/video/wmMw_EF32RY/видео.html
@ It can be better if they fix the small problems in this system
@ no bro
They can't be stressed by this coz they can choose they career within 6 std so that they can be stressed in that age all students include our older one try to get innovation not memorize and write only theories.
I agree that in that we don't give them exams in that age but they might change that policy in lower class exams
But ignore that exams policy
This assessment in between 5 to 6th it's just a great idea
In that age only our brain going to be focused
@@jesushhere a kid is not mature enough to choose his career in 6th std
Udu...we have time... Unnaku puduchatha pannu
Toughest job in Finland is teacher career, there we can easily become an doctor though.
But Doctors also play role as a teacher you know
Appo neenga doctora?
There are 'NO' private schools in Finland. Significantly, students will have same teacher upto 6 years of their primary education. Idea is to build the rapport between student and teacher, so the basics are strong from grassroot level.
But no homeworks ,hometest, projects in finland
Inga irukkira niraya Peru Finland la irukkeenga pola irukke
As a teacher, If this has to be a success then teachers have to be updated... Really well updated. I can really count them.
As a parent, happy and at the same time got a little fear that this plan becomes a success .
I believe now it's all in the teachers hand to be more responsible.
Good conclusion on entrance.but I differ with you on field level warriors teachers.The NEP 2020 is also discussed about importance of teacher education,teacher education system and requirements in this process as you said. pls go through the frame wok sheets of NEP2020 chapter 5, page 20
I got confused about this NEP 2020 ...Thanks For This video..It's Really Very Clear..Only thing I Opposed is Three Language Scheme 😢😢😢
Yes, antha vayasula avanga pesurathe athigam ithula 3 languages kashtam dha😥
Now, All the kids are studying three languages from LKG in CBSE and International syllabus. Only government school students affected. Please give some space to them also.
Implement panum pothu theriyum avlo irkunu ..bjp sonatha panathu ila
@@muruganandamramasamy you just try to communicate with government schools students they are far better than cbsc students if they implement this our teachers should be well knowledged...
@@tnpscgroup22a46 i agree this too...
How entrance exam coaching will be held to everyone?
If this was implemented before it would be very helpful to students unfortunately I can't enjoy as I am in 9th class I like experimental learning with vacational...
Policy is good, but there should be strong execution plan like pay package,selection of teachers and strong appraisal system to achieve this...if there is no operational plan, then this will be only in paper...
the thing about teachers is true
i still remember my librarian teaching much more than any other teachers
we should educate the teachers and train them for the new ways then it might be effective
and there also should be qualifying exam for teachers regularly twice a year
and paid surplus pay so that they think of their pupils than other finacial problems
True...we learned many from them..
Dear Friends,
I am Gokulnath and I did mechanical engineer. I started a you tube channel for those who want to learn Deutsch-German language with tamil explanation.
Kindly check and support my channel.
I am taking online classes also at English to German to English,
Tamil to German to Tamil
ruclips.net/channel/UCVWBJmIwV2-mS7qsMnqo-LA
Kindly contact me, if you want to learn.
Thanks and Regards
Gokulnath
Language indirectly imposed, board exam for 3rd, 5th standard, common exam for rural and urban students all are make more dropped outs...finally implementation...... very well analysed....it's good or not ? Future Wil answer...how india's literacy getting increased or decreased
As per right to education act, they cannot fail anyone till 8th standard. The concept of board exams are not to assess the students, but based on students' mark they are going to assess the school's ability and performance to deliver the quality outputs in terms of teaching etc. Yes I agree that it is mental pressure for kids, but it will be all like annual exams.
Language indirectly imposed poya yov upto 5 mother tounge la padam solli taralamnu iruk after 5th std tan vera 1 language padikanum nu iruk Namma yethat language padikalam hindi tan padikanumnu ila ath matri northla um koncha per tamil yedut padika vaip iruk
Finally literacy rate pati sollerukenga nanum 1 engineering graduate tan yenna matri basic knowledge kooda ilama latchakanakula engineering graduates irukanga Indiala so onnum illama verum degree matum potum literacy rate increase aavumna apdi 1 literacy rateae teva illa
@@harishankar110 I said future will answer.... naanum enigeering graduate than....suthamana village.... government school...tamil medium......first graduate from family....correct ah sonna first 10th std pass...8+ years working in IT industry... successfully doing trading too ..started a ecommerce related businesses too... unable to sustain due to competition.... school first naan... college la naan lam yarune theriyathu....inga village +2 students ala city la irukira 10vayasu paiyan kooda compete panna mudiyathu...premanand too said the same......engala mathiri village la irunthu mela varavanga count nichayam kuraiyum... all are based on my experience as village person... finally I said future will answer... let's wait and see...why we need to fight here...
Very unbiased review! 👏👏👏 exactly same thoughts I had
Teachers come from previous education system who are going to be part of this change implementing new education system, it will take minimum 2 decades to get all these policy vision into reality and see the impact