Economic Survey’s message to corporate sector-how it doesn’t match Modi’s record job creation claims
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 11 сен 2024
- Why is BJP doubling down on Hindutva? Modi-Shah have a different reading of 2024 result, ThePrint’s Political Editor DK Singh analyses in this episode of #politicallycorrect
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Read the column here: theprint.in/op...
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Apply here for ThePrint School of Journalism: tinyurl.com/32...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Exclusive content, special privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for Special benefits: theprint.in/su...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/su...
» Subscribe to our RUclips Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintI...
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8
BJP IT cell is unable to create a better narrative since PK quit their camp...also the party leadership has done precious little to address any strategic heft to the ground level organization...also lack of principled polity of encouraging turncoats need to be discarded right away
P.K.was never associated with BJP,
@@Dadasahab1234till 2014 he was
The vote shifted to INDIA alliance not because of anything they did but because of what BJP didn't do with 10 years in power.
Modi & Shah refuse to accept its their own doing that resulted in this.
BJP will always be seen as a upper caste Hindu party. It may have build alliances but could not build the trust among Dalits, Tribals and EBC's. who along with Minorities account for 66% vote (20% Minorities, 16% SC, 7% ST and 23% EBC).
They had a golden opportunity to uplift 100s of millions of Indians.
@@motei1853 BJP voteshare dropped only 0.8%. It was more of opposition unity getting it's act together. The real mistake of BJP was not respecting allies. But then allies like SAD and Thackeray weren't great parties anyway. BJP should now support BSP and CPM, IMO. Those 2 parties are not against pro-development policies. Mayawati had the brains to do a Brahmin-Dalit coalition, propose splitting of UP. And CPM in both Kerala and Bengal, eventually produced pro-development leaders like Pinarayi Vijayan and Buddhadeb Bhattacharjee.
I agree.
@@rajx7120 If you takeaway its gains at bottom level in south then BJP lost 5% plus where it wins seats. It went from 4% to 11 % in TN but that votes means nothing!!
Again if they are happy that only 0.8% vote is lost then they are doomed in 2029
I see around me more SC supporters of BJP, and people with Brahmins, Baniya caste names I see instead opposing BJP.
I guess problem with BJP is its inability to develop trust with in general lower income classes.
Not sure about caste but many see it as pro rich party but fact is its not pro rich its just pro billionaires hahaha.
You're missing the fact that congress fought on much less seats this time than in 2019, and BJP fought on more seats this time than on 2019. Given that they were fighting on less seats and still managed to up their vote share is a big gain. Instead of comparing BJP vs congress you should be comparing NDA vs INDIA vote share
he won't !!. If you have watched DK enough you will see he leans right.
BJP fought on 436 seats in 2019 and 441 seats in 2024 so BJP vote share didn't saw fall. But yes Congress fought only 328 seats much less than 420+ last time. But again less seat for Congress doesn't matter much as last time it fought on 80 seats in UP alone. So not fighting doesn't make much difference.
He should have compared NDA with INDI alliance. Otherwise it is not accurate comparison 😊
11:08 It's because people know, no matter how bad things are right now, Congress can always make it worse. 😂😂
Voters have already given the Congress party 60 years, now they want to try a couple of decades of the BJP. 😊😊
Tere jaise hi idiot analyst ke chalte Bhajpillon ne 400 paar kar liya😅😅😅😅
in a huge populous country like India 1% Un. employment = 1.5 Cr = 15 Million People which in itself an entire country. So government cannot chill. Western economist cannot fathom the scale of countries like india , and strict adherence to inflation has resulted in artificial unemployment crisis in india. India has to selectively bring the cost of capital down in industries that create a lot of job and do not depend on Imports. Developenment and re-developement of Real estate , Heavy industry , and other are virtually the way forward. Strategic Treaties with countries like Japan, to acknowledge Indian assets a security in Japanese banks for cheap loans in priority sector can boost the growth for both the countries. Also forcing Russians to Invest their Rupee reserve in Indian Infra without government guarantee is the path ahead. We also need to liberate our major economic hubs like Mumbai , Bangalore , and others from the burden of state politics. Something all the 4 major economics ahead of us has successfully done (US , China, Germany , Japan) according to their extent. We need Free flow of foreign talent into india.
Future investments should be funneled to Tyre2 cities which have an existing regional Airport like Coimbatore, Vijayawada, Raipur, Gwalior, Alwar, Manglore, Jarsuguda, Nagpur, Ranchi, Hubli, Pune etc and decongest existing metros.
All these require land reforms, labour reforms and farm reforms. And one man Rahul Gandhi wants to block this, because he wants to become PM at any cost by playing the saviour.
@@rajx7120 Mr Modi wrote the white paper against Farmer Reforms when he was a CM. Was he doing politics to become Pradhaan Meme then?
@@temp-key-999 I don't follow Modi's speeches. I follow agricultural economists on this matter. Even Congress promised these reforms in 2019 manifesto. Are they doing politics now? Don't hold reforms hostage to politics.
And if Modi was doing politics earlier, then Congress should have defended it, just like they defended the India-US nuclear deal. Then Congress would have got credit for reforms.
The Union govt believed that by bringing new farm laws amid the pandemic, they would be able to avert any opposition from farmers would be scared to come out on the roads. The govt was clearly taken by surprise over the vociferous protests of the farmers. The farmer's protest not only created unprecedented alliances across caste, class, gender, and religion, but also brought together regional small farm unions, & civil society organizations.
The Print is getting delusional and has started believing that the BJP has lost and Congress won the election 😀
Like the delusion Modi is having of being non-biological.😅😅😅
Modi & Shah are doing firefighting to appease RSS and hold their ranks together. That explains the Hindutva pitch and not the seemingly logical explanation of DK based on the CSDS survey. Whatever the pollsters may say, it is apparent that the set back suffered by BJP is due to voters apathy towards the government for taking Hindutva more seriously than the economic issues. But BJP’s immediate priorities remain in keeping the RSS in peace.
Thanks forr the update on BJP.
Thank you very much for the analysis.Your videos are simply wonderful.
My Respects Sir.🙏
Good one. Liked your few lines of clear Bangla too 😊
Problem with Ultra left- They need to go to more left to be relevant with in der support base. Stalin has reached that and hence after that Soviet union became weaker and weaker.
Problem with Right - They will go towards Right, one after another leader. They can reach till Hitler. Modi, was more in Right than Advani, who was more right than Atal. Yogi is now more in right than Modi.
So they will reach till Hitler. This is der final destination and it is bound to happen.
1. Government should remove all tax barriers for start ups. We have start up India and there have been unicorns and progress but still Government can do a lot more! Incentivize setting up companies, factories, and industries instead of trying to take tax from them.
2. Massive Massive infrastructure push. Yes, Gadkari has good very good work but our country simply needs an infrastructure facelift across the board at "scale" hitherto undreamt of. Roads, Ports, Bridges, Airports. That will generate employment.
3. Middle Class needs a tax cut badly. Purchasing power of people needs to be increased to solve the demand side of the economy.
@@RAVI89RULZ 3rd point totally agree, 2nd point, in India land laws are complex and a opposition state sabotage any developmental project by denying land. So, infrastructure development is not easy.
@@subhasishganguly5588 I agree with you. But we simply do not have the time to be patient. The world might marvel and be jealous of our 8% growth. But we do not have the luxury to be happy with that. If this government cannot do it, then no government can do it.
@@RAVI89RULZ yes, but impatience is dangerous, people will exploit this impatience and mislead. We should maintain this 08% for long term. And, the truth is we will never be a high income country like US, at max we will be a upper middle income country by 2047.
The ongoing protests in Bangladesh shoes why that country has higher per capita than India and why it is good candidate for becoming the most developing region in South Asia because Bangladeshi people seem to understand that reservations to some extent are fine if they actually helping any backward communities but nit as state policy and policy of all political parties to grab piwer.
Bangladesh GDP per capita is not higher than India. Only during pandemic, it became temporarily higher because India faced a contraction due to lockdown. But people are repeating same news after 4 years.
I think they were begging IMF for loans last month what even are you smoking brother.
So good
"And you try to generalize all farmers as uniform. Which is a fallacy. Punjab farmers are different from Bihar farmer. Big farmers are different."
DK can you please make one video on Impact of Muslim population on Aasam in near future....
As always DK conquered the show with razor sharp analysis and data points. I wish this story/column/video could have more length and some more anecdotes from different states ruled by BJP. DK sir, Kudos !! One more thing.. in your opinion which state polls can be good litmus test for this theory??
6:31 why BJP won in Karnataka, Telangana , Odisha . BJP should have got 44 seats like congress got in 2014, one thing worked for opposition is massive SC ST and Muslim consolidation these groups constitute 36% of Indian population ,. BJP workers sloppy , lazy and local BJP leaders were arrogant in many seats , BJP performs better when they are back foot eg. chattishgarh, Odisha, Uttarakhand 20222, MP 2023 ,BJP will recover and bounce back but opposition is behaving that they won the elections, once opposition loses then they will blame media and EVM .
Why is Modi behaving like a non-biological???😅😅😅😅
They might be worried about something like Reform UK party coming in India and cutting BJP votes from right. There is a voter class who believes sabka Vikas is wrong thing & they are Modi supporters today.
Tax the rich farmers, landlords.
@@Kannadiga321-r4n All farmers should wear torn clothes and barefoot. Corporate A spent crores on foreign singers & chefs, as they have shifted their funds to Cayman islands so that 10 generations can live like kings. They are the boss of ruling party & politicians have govt agencies in their pockets. But rich farmers house should be taken by the police, who do they think they are?
Interestingly this was very well predicted by Prashant Kishor in his interviews well before June 4th.
Population is a BIGGGGGGGGGGGG Issue, something shld be done
Population is not an issue anymore. It is stabilizing. Mismatch od education and skills is the problem.
Trade barriers, economic freedom, and the Judiciary are biggest problems. Fertility rate is under replacement in much of India. Still a few states like bihar where it high.
@@amodernindian1358 This common silly excuse, by this ruling party supporters is that the fault of unemployment in India is coz of population in India. Didn't China grow quickly when it's population increased?
Hindus fertility rate in India is almost 2 percent (1.92) and Muslim fertility rate in India is 2.3 percent in 2023; so the difference between Hindu and Muslim fertility rate is below 0.4 percent.
I am tired of dirty politics that is dividing the nation in the name of hindu-muslim for political power & control. We need vikas, not slogans & temples when our holy rivers are still dirty & area around temples in UP are still dirty.
Why were you born in the first place
@tubelz judiciary is hassel n India, especially for cooperates.
Why should we adopt western way of counting numbers like 100 thousand ....
Why?
A fair analysis.
Ok did sight the reasons for 6-15% vote share fall in states where bjp sweeped in 2019
Like maharastra,up,Bihar, Karnataka,Himachal,haryana,jharkhand,rajastan, Manipur,uttrakhand,j&k , ladakh
Why such substantial fall in vote share in all these states??
Did Internal sabotage happen in all these states??
This guy seems to be a maniac. Crazy Political Editor.
Excellent
1. Govt knows what it is doing when it is publishing the employment data. Employment does not mean only Govt and private sector formal employment. It has a broader definition and the data is in line with it. 2. It is a fact that India has a huge number of unskilled, unemployable young people. They need to be taken care of somehow either by having urban MNREGA or some such scheme, for which fiscal provision has to be made. 3. DK is talking as if Modi goes today and Rahul comes tomorrow, unemployment is going to vanish. He is still not fully recovered from his disappointment of INDI Alliance losing 2024 elections!! If BJP is making mistakes about going after Hindutva rather than employment, why is DK bothered? Let Modi make mistakes and INDI Alliance come to power!!!! 4. DK, a serious political analyst, should seriously review his own performance over last 1 year !!!
According to Govt employment, unpaid workers include housewives. Govt is showing their chest that employment like this has gone up, even if that's so ridiculous.
Manufacturing shrank from 17% in 2010 to 13% in 2022 to 11.4% in 2023, as per Index of Industrial production performance data. Many crore people have gone back into farming due to joblessness after note ban & gst.
Bro are you for real ? He will be bothered if BJP doesn't generate employment because IT IS THE GOVERNMENT RIGHT NOW. You have deluded into yourself that DK is a fan of the opposition alliance.
@@rajsimhamv9045If it was a good govt, yes he would be bothered. This govt has a bad habit of burying it's head in the sand like an ostrich look at Agniveers. You will learn sooner or later.
Unhealthy food: - Sattvic diet. From 10%, now 30% are diabetic. The BJP is promoting Brahmavad, not Hindutva.
Please don't ever blame cheap carbs being sold in PDS, because stubborn farmers refuse to diversify away from rice and wheat, instead of growing pulses and oilseeds, that we are forced to import, because of which they are expensive to poor people.
There is no such thing when it comes to Indian food
The Indian food one eats is anything but Indian 😂
Potato, tomato, Cheese, Mayonnaise, Pinneapple, Cabbage , Breads, etc
Nothing is Indian here 😂
DK doing what he does best, licking the master's
Why am I not surprised by PK Singh, I am not sorry DK Singh. He doesn't disappoint. Keep peddling the narrative that there is no TINA because BJP is much smarter than their opposition.
Sales pitch! I like that!
Funnel future investments to Tyre 2 cities which have an exciting operational airport like Coimbatore, Vijayawada, Raipur, Jarsuguda, Nagpur, Ranchi, Gwalior, Alwar, Manglore, Hubli Jabalpur, Mysore etc and decongest existing metros and create employment opportunities in every state.
True true
The Print's focus is always on if somebody's 'Push Hindutva' agenda but for others secularism comes into play.
Job creation is going to be a huge challenge for India. It should not have let the population get to this level of 1.5 billion. With automation and AI even huge factories and industry need few workers. With a gdp of 20 trillion USA has jobless issues with a population of only 350 million or so. People should try migration to get employed
When dumb govt. Want to provide reservations in Private Sector then how would the Private Sector stand against their Maai Baap Sarkar?
Absolutely inumerate analysis of data.
Jai bjp, jai hinduvta
How much you are getting money from BJP
Did u even watch the video. U shd be asking how much money form congress 😅.
This was a very biased video. DK being like Modi, Shah, BJP know everything and even their mistakes will give them better results in the longer run. Either DK is biased/rooting for BJP or ThePrint is sold out.
Soft propaganda है 😂😂
@@avsbiyani didnt he just mean that BJP is reading the post poll data in certain way, while the opposition is basically over interpretating the mandate, given that, bjp had a very localised loss driven by some ad hoc local factors.
Spot on DK is dalal
Singing the praise of modi
Modi shah boot licker
Did you ever find The Print not being biased for bjp?
@@sujithkumar2041 i've been watching for 3-4 years. half the comment sections say print is sold out to congress, other half bjp.
I read the section on climate change. Honestly it’s just a complain rant. Even last year half the new power plant are coal when solar is cheaper? Makes no sense. It deeply wrong mindset which opposes everything west. Look forward not backward. Policymakers have to only get out of their bungalows to see the pollution. Stop complaining and be the change you want to see
This logic is erroneous...
There is a decline of 7-8 percent of BJP vote share in the entire Northern -Western belt...and major problem is coming from rural India which is most affected by unemployment and inflation....
Secondly there have improved significantly in regions where they were not major players, which makes up for vote share on Pan-India basis....
Moreover, in almost all places like Bihar, AP, even Maharashtra and UP allies have outperformed BJP, which saved them to a large extent
Good for you that the BJP got lesser seats ... At least your channel will keep going.
Ur analysis is also same like bjp politics law of diminishing returns now I don’t even watch the channels earlier I used to watch get angry but this is what is happening
Modi is the Joss Biden of India, burao satiya gya h. 8crore jobs..... abb apprenticeship ko bhi job ka tittle dene lage h bhiayyo.😂😂
the data is wrong ......please ask the EC. Dont waste your time
How much is the sample size of the survey you are quoting , I think your opinion is wrong on this particular issue
to be on the right path we need a complete redesign and rebuild of our Economy, which I don't see Happening, We never fully industrialized because of our socialist fantasies in the 70's and 80's, while Agriculture is important but for some reason we Romanticize it and demonize industrialization, Industrilization means manufacturing, and manufacturing provides the bulk jobs even though you are not highly educated, our Land and labour laws are a nightmare for a ny companies so that's why many choose to stay as MSME and get whatever benefits they can instead of scaling up, add the Vote bank caste issue and all hte political drama associated with this, even a reformist cannot correct this. As far as Hindutva is concerned, I think on a fundamental level there needs to be a reformation of Hindu faith, caste and superstitions (like godmen) need to be overcome....that's a dream, but I know it won't happen.
If you want to reform hindu faith, then free temples from government control.
Promote literature
Bhagvad Geeta
Books on Ayurveda
Upanishads
Tirukkural
Sri Aurobindos books.
@@saureld2229 India's manufacturing sector has fallen from over 51 million in 2016, to less than 36 million in 2023. The slow transition away from agricultural employment has witnessed a reversal after 2019 since people can't find any employment.
@@saureld2229 Manufacturing shrank from 17% in 2010 to 13% in 2022 to 11.4% in 2023, as per Index of Industrial production performance data. Many crore people have gone back into farming due to joblessness after note ban & gst.
@@xxyz2023 True..but system is not correct at a fundamental level.
@@xxyz2023 we all saw what happened when labor/land reforms and farm laws were brought.
Yes. The developing story is simply that NO opposition really existed and even now is NOT fully playing, apart from some "issues".
You have TO choose. SO it is BJP ....this is exactly PKs view. Watch when there IS a fully mature, strategic, focused opposition...
RG...PK...and NEW XYZ...why not?
In coming decades.....
Two parties are needed...
Provide link to source document.
Gossip needs no documents.
@@Dadasahab1234 🤣🤣👌👌
Incisive to say the least.
माननीय प्रधानमंत्री जी के नेतृत्व में हमारा देश बहुत तेजिसे तरक्की कर रहा है. नए रोजगार और रोजगार अवसर सबके लिए available है. अब हमें विश्व कि सबसे बड़ी और ताकतवर शक्ति बनने से कोइ नही रोक सकता 💪💪💪
Jobs are driven by middle-class private sector, particularly through small & medium-sized businesses. Middle-class entrepreneurs play a crucial role in not only jobs but also in wages growth, which boosts per capita income of a nation; these directly depend on Union govt's economic policies & increased funding to states for education. Ironically, in Feb, Union govt had reduced funding for education.
In most successful nations, there is a balanced approach combining capitalism & socialism that drives economic growth & increase per capita income of a nation. Both crony capitalism & communism have failed in the World. Large corporations often engage in tax evasion by moving funds to offshore tax heavens like the Cayman Islands, allowing them to hide wealth, for 10 generations to live like kings, & without contributing back to the nation. India's per capita is lower than Nigeria. Ultra rich are the owners of ruling govt, & agencies are in party pockets, so smart Indian youth, are illegally going to America & Europe, Israel & Arab nation, looking for paying jobs.
When the middle class has more disposable income, the economy grows faster & healthier. India's poorest & middle class pay 50% & 33% gst taxes, while the wealthy industrialists pay only 3% gst, oxfam. Union govt claim of 8 crore employment from RBI data, includes the rise in "unpaid" workers like housewives. Meanwhile, UP has the highest no. of cust0dial d inside police stations & also has the highest cases where victims are wrongly charged with crimes. But, DK still keeps on trusting in 400 paar survey numbers
Please save Arjun
Please devote an episode or two to Arvind Kejriwal
I would like to remind print owner SG an antimodi lutyens media ecosystem analysts and also paid agent of Sonia Gandhi family that EPS data shows 9.8 cr members have enrolled. GOI under Modi may have failed but opps have no agenda except minorities appeasement.
@@sridharmahalingam8190 I grew up never seeing such requirements of name for religion identification, until now. This is making us look narrow minded.
Our educated Hindu elders have always told us that there is no deep-hidden muslim threat behind jain or halal labels. How does it matter to any true Hindu if we eat something that jain or muslims must eat due to their religion?
In hospitals, do we ask for hindu or muslim only blood? As Viswamitra we have to start building unity instead of these divisions.
We still have many real issues, like our holy rivers and area around our temples are still not clean. We won't get to the high table wasting our human resources & talents.
P.s. Hindus fertility rate in India is almost 2 percent (1.92) and Muslim fertility rate in India is 2.3 percent in 2023; so the difference between Hindu and Muslim fertility rate is below 0.4 percent.
Another Godiwallah
Change in dopt memorandum to allow govt employ to be part of rss functions, is start of rekindling of relations between both, party giving more importance to rss is welcome change
This is the last budget of Modi Govt.....Modi will not be as PM from next year....in 2-3 months there is an elections in Maharashtra and Haryana....BJP will loose very badly....NDA will collapse thereafter and 1st party which will leave NDA will be JDU....Modi curse is going to over very soon....
U know nothing about politics, being with bjp ensures Nitish being CM. And BJP is expected to lose anyway, nothing surprising going to happen.
Do you have a Time Machine?😅
did you even pass maths in school? so the party with 240 will loose power because they wont win state election? as party with 16 MPs will leave it...
keep day dreaming 😂
Well the actual curse will begin after that if it happens, curse of bunch of salivating feral dogs running the government, curse of socialism, curse of islamic jihad, curse of macroeconomic disaster, curse of becoming bankrupt like karnataka, kerala, punjab, west bengal
Bakwas
With reservations ,lack of discipline ,tax looting rich farmers , baby producing populations INDIA is not going developed country.
All farmers should wear torn clothes and barefoot. Corporate A spent crores on foreign singers & chefs, as they have shifted their funds to Cayman islands so that 10 generations can live like kings. They are the boss of ruling party & politicians have govt agencies in their pockets. But rich farmers house should be taken by the police, who do they think they are?
Singh DK = What happens when a Congress beat reporter becomes political editor...chatukaar analysis and insights 😂😂😂😂