Here are some really interesting statistics from a section I had to cut out of the video because this was a behemoth! Pixar has the most wins with 11, AND the most nominations with 18, meaning they win 61% of the time they’re nominated, and 47% of the time total Only SEVEN films that Pixar has submitted for the award have NOT been nominated, meaning they have a 72% nomination rate They have an 18% share of the TOTAL nominations in the history, nearly 1/5th If you loop Walt Disney Animation studios in with Pixar as they’re both owned by Disney: The have 31/99 nominations, giving them about 31% of the total nominations They’ve won 15/23 of the awards, meaning they win 65% of the time Laika has submitted 6 films and been nominated 6 times for a 100% nomination rate However, they’ve never won, giving them a 0% win rate, oof Of all 99 nominees 54 are CG animated 28 are 2D animated 17 are Stop Motion animated CG animated films have won 19/23 years for about an 82% win rate 2D animated films have won 2/23 years for about an 8.5% win rate Stop Motion animated films have won 2/23 years for about an 8.5% win rate Pete Docter has the most wins with 3 and is tied with Hayao Miyazaki for the most nominations with 4 Pete Doctor wins 75% of the time he is nominated Shrek is the franchise with the most nominations with 4, if you include the Puss in Boots spin offs Toy Story is the franchise with the most wins with 2, still the only sequels to ever win the award
Also it’s worth mentioning ever since the BAFTA introduction in 2006/2007 when they were announcing the nominations for best animated feature for the 2006 animated films, 15 of the 18 Animated films that won the BAFTA (except LEGO Movie, Kubo, and Klaus) wound up winning the Academy Award for Best Animated Feature and are 80-90% accurate compared to the Golden Globes and the Annie’s (post-2006/2007). On top of that in the last two to three years, four Animated Films that have won the Golden Globe and BAFTA wound up winning the Oscar for Best Animated Feature: _Soul, Encanto, Guillermo Del Toro’s Pinocchio,_ and _The Boy and the Heron_
Secondly outside the _Toy Story_ franchise which won Best Animated Feature through Toy Story 3-4, their hasn’t been *ANY* animated sequel that has won the Oscar. _Shrek, The Incredibles_ and _Into the Spider-Verse_ won the Oscar, yet their sequels (Shrek 2, Incredibles 2 and Across the Spider-Verse) didn’t go on to win the Oscar with the _Incredibles 2_ losing to _Into the Spider-Verse_ and now _Across the Spider-Verse_ losing to _The Boy and the Heron._
Finally while 12 adult animated films were nominated, nine of them - _The Triplets of Belleville, Persepolis, The Wind Rises, My Life as a Courgette, The Breadwinner, Loving Vincent, Isle of Dogs, Flee_ and _The Boy and the Heron_ were each rated PG-13, _Anomalisa_ is the only R-rated animated film to be nominated in this category, and _Chico and Rita_ and _I Lost My Body_ were not rated by the MPA, _The Boy and the Heron_ is currently the first and as of now the first Adult animated and first PG-13 animated film to win the Academy Award for Best Animated Feature.
I'd PAY to watch you create a series that was like "What if they had the best animated feature category for every previous year" maybe doing a decade at a time. This was one of my favorite RUclips videos I've watched in a long time
I think I remember that and the reason he did it was apart of a joke about how he take what he makes from kung-fu panda and bet it all on Pixar winning
Horses are infamously difficult to draw. James Baxter, the backbone of Spirit, is an industry legend because of his incredible ability to draw horses. Animators look for any excuse not to draw horses if they can. People have refused work because of them. The fact they got enough willing people to make a 2D horse film and it looks that good is insane.
@@Takenja Yeah. And he is still a legend, the work for that kind of highly detailed absurdly profecient 2D animation is rare in the western market these days, but you know when a production has the desire and a little budget for a scene with that stuff, that Baxter will be available. A pretty goode example would probably be the scene from the final episode of Steven Universe of Steven reunifying with his gem half. All done by James Baxter.
Watching Anomalisa lose its Oscar to Inside Out was the first moment I was like “oh, the Academy *really* doesn’t get it, huh?” So I’m glad to see it at least took home the Johnny
I wish people who prefer anomalisa over inside out didnt act like anomalisa lost to some whatever movie instead of, like, pixars most creative and heartfelt movie of said decade (like 3rd at the least)
@@undergalaxy775I get what you mean, but could you at least spell "Anomalisa" correctly? Anomalisa is also a very heartfelt and meaningful movie and ironically it feels like you're also dismissing it.
@@ChiangKai-Shrek lmao I was distracted sorry, I'll edit it. No, Im not dismissing it, its a worthy contender as well, I just believe we can all be civilized about it. I think The Breadwinner is better than coco but Im not crying death of cinema because of it
@@savvastoynoysidis360 2006 was such a shit year for animated films. paprika was probably the _only_ deserving winner from that year, and it didn't even get nominated.
@@jclkaytwo Tekkonkinkreet and The Girl Who Leapt Through Time were also super solid films that year. It's a shame that the Academy almost always ignores Japan when it comes best animated feature
@@jaredarenas7542 tekkonkinkreet was submitted for the 2007 oscars and the girl who leapt through time was never submitted at all. so... point still stands
I think Shrek doesnt realize or accept how lonely he really is until Donkey comes along and openly accepts him. He's been rejected by everyone in society his whole life so he's basically embraced that image. He becomes scary and mean because that's how people thought of him. Over time you become comfortable in your own space and you accept that you're unloveable by the rest of the world. But when someone actually decides to be nice to you it throws you for a loop because you believed for so long that you were incapable of being liked or loved, but now youre being reminded of all the hate you've endured this whole time and realizing that it didnt HAVE to be that way. I'm having a hard time coming up with similar examples in fiction at the moment but if i come up with some I'll update this comment. Just my thoughts
Thank you!! I thought that he was a bit harsh on Shrek but couldn't find a way to explain how much I loved Donkey and Shrek's relationships, or all the characters for that matter. Thank you
@@johnny2channelsthat's okay, that just means 2 great videos from 2 great RUclipsrs with some different views of some films. This year is gonna be great!
Wait two seperate animes? I know about the Manga of stitch traveling to feudal Era Japan and befriending a samurai but I did not know that he had not one but two anime about him
@@walrus6429Well not quite TWO anime, if the classification is confined to Japan, but there’s the actual Stitch anime and then a Chinese series called Stitch and Ai
The series and the Stitch Movie (and Leroy and Stitch) were my *jam*. To the point where I have made my boyfriend watch them with me because I loved it.
After watching the whole thing, I wanna say two things... 1. Thank you for giving the time and attention to the nominees that are not as talked about much, especially Boy and the World and Robot Dreams. 2. Thank you for the positivity on the films that are overhated from the majority and on the films you hate. It made me feel a little better after seeing reccent news and other sad things I saw. YAY POSITIVITY!!!!1!!!111!!! p.s. I hope Schaffrillas gives you a shoutout
I’ve only just started the video but I really appreciate your willingness to talk about the positive aspects of Shrek despite not liking it yourself. I think that’s the mark of a great writer. I love hearing about how people may not personally enjoy pieces of media but still bring positive spins on it. It’s easy to tear down something you don’t enjoy, but I find it a lot more impactful and intellectually interesting to discuss the positives of said media. I like balance!
Paprika is actually one of the best animated films ever and it was hands down the most important movie to come out that year. But sure, throw it to the wolves. Literally three movies got nominated, that's like spitting in Satoshi Kon's face.
@@reillymcwritingpaprika is the most overrated and boring film of all time it’s sad that the guy died but that doesn’t make it deserving of a nomination
Don't watch the Oscars, but damn wish they still made animations featuring characters from the movies reacting to whether they won or lost. Think the last time they did that was 2009 or 2010.
It was quite a cute detail, but I think I prefer how they do it nowadays honestly. The fact that we get to see the faces of those who created the movies just as we do with live action directors really helps raise public awareness for animation as a valid artistic medium. It's the difference between treating animated movies as quirky products created by an anonymous team (a view Disney very heavily pushed last century as a way of maintaining it's monopoly on animation, by the way) and regarding them as pieces of art created by people with unique talents and visions. Also I think those animations just wouldn't work well nowadays given that adult and other non comedic films frequently get nominated for the category. How could anyone ever make silly award ceremony skits about characters from movies like Persepolis, Anomalisa or Flee?
@@signodeinterrogacion8361 I think a middle ground could be established, of course depending on the movie maker's own desire, but to have representation in animated form for the animated productions would be great to see more again.
@@drdewott9154 I don't believe the creators themselves are the ones that can decide that, it's usually their corporate overloads that are in charge of this kind of 'marketing stunts'. And anyway having a different format for each movie that is in the running would be kind of awkward. Even if none of these adult movies ever win the entire segment would just feel off if it only applied to some movies, only half way for others and none at all for a few of them. But I get your point.
2 - 6 hour videos like this i have been DEPENDING on for the past 24 hours as my moms in the hospital with pancreatitis. Ive been watching this video throughout the entire thing and its made me feel so much better. Thank you so much for this you couldnt not uploaded this at a better time
@milkiski Hope your Mom is better. Your comment hi-lights the positive of the RUclips content world. Similar videos have been helpful to me in stressful times.
Man I remember as a teen, during the early 00s, the depressing realization that 2D animated movies where phased out so fast all of a sudden. I remember the sadness when I found out The Princess and the Frog was gonna be Disney's last 2D animated movie. I love and enjoy 3D art and have so much respect for the people who excel in that field of skill, but I wished new technology didn't make older mediums obsolete or irrelevant or less profitable (in the eyes of executives and shareholders).
I'd say Megamind absolutely deserved a nomination in 2010, it was fantastic. Definitely my most rewatched nomination in that year. Also, my favorite winner might just be Rango. As incredible as Boy and the Heron and Spirited Away are, Rango is unbelievably next level for animation, especially for CG. It's a straight up western. Thank you for introducing me to Anomalisa and Persepolis though. I think the latter after I watch it may become a new all time favorite.
megamind would've deserved a nomination in any other year, but for some reason 2010 only had three nominees despite how strong the competition was. even _tangled_ missed.
Well I think the thesis of Shrek is more "life is more complicated than Disney fairytales, but true love still exists." Like it is critical of the absurd extent of fairy tale romanization, but it still holds true to some of its core themes. Hence why Shrek dismisses the idea of true love at the beginning of the film, yet finds it at the end. He didn't believe it was possible for himself, but was later proven wrong, hence the song choice “I’m a Believer” and the lyrics “[I thought love was] meant for someone else but not for me.” Also Sid could know that a rhino's brain is small, I don’t see how that’s a stretch. I'm sure animals had their heads cracked open on occasion during the Ice Age, and it would make sense if they had simple biological knowledge like that, especially in a world where animals talk.
Honestly your analysis is like a breathe of fresh air! I can’t quite explain it but there’s just a passion for the craft rather than an expectation, fantastic video!
@@sofsof5062I truly hate how every animated movie is now marketed with a wall of celebrity names who did voices while professional VA’s toil in anonymity.
So happy this video isn't just a ranking and you actually took the time to talk about the movies and what made them deserved (or undeserved) of their nomination ! Great stuff, time to check more of the video son your channel and wait for more ^^
The Lilo and Stitch part was so unbelievably based, my favorite movie of all time Truly an underrated classic, despite Stitch being one of Disney's most iconic characters
And I feel bad cause I feel like yet again it taught Disney the wrong lesson like the reason it was perfect is cause this cute figure was so grounded in this movie that everyone adored him. But instead they though oh keep making more cute marketable mascots
As a Brazillian, i jumped straight to the "Boy and the World" review (i will come back and watch everything when i have the time). This movie is easily one of the best productions my country ever made. If you ever want to go deeper about the movie, you can search things like "Ditadura Militar" or "Exodo Rural", which are both BIG parts of its meaning. They make the emotional parts hit even deeper.
it feels so great to hear such high praise for robot dreams! i really wish the movie couldve been released in the US before the oscars, it felt like the odds were very against it because of that. but im so happy you liked it!
I finally finished "ALL 99 Animated Oscar Nominees RANKED" and I hope you update us on the new nominees every year and what you think should be nominees, this was truly an amazing video.
This was an amazing video! The RUclips algorithm blessed me with an absolute banger. I love that you went into deep dives into each film, doing thematic readings and unpacking your opinions vs. simple plot summaries. I think many people who would undergo this project would likely gloss over a lot of entries, but you clearly went above and beyond giving every single entry time in the spotlight. I also can't thank you enough for going into the submissions and snubs for each year. You've left me with a whole stack of films to check out. Thank you so much!
In defense of Spirit, I think the horses expressing themselves is like. Kind of essential to telling the story? You want animated horses to just stand around and look like normal ass horses? The great thing about animation is that you CAN pull the expressions a bit and tell a story that wouldn't be told with any other medium. That's the entire point of it being animation. Sorry, not to be harsh but I think that was a very silly criticism. Do agree the narration is stupid tho.
I am probably in minority but I didn't hate shape of water. Like dont get me wrong i love get out more but i dont think it is GDT'S worst film. Like Pinocchio and Nightmare alley were more worthy best picture but i do think is it still decent film, just the comparation was better
I understand that brother bear may not be loved by most people but I literally grew up watching this movie and it has an extremely special place in my heart
Honestly, I appreciate this video not only for it itself, but also letting me see other viewpoints on movies I love/hate - great video, you've gained a new subscriber
I thought it was pretty obvious shrek was just trying to make the best out of the life he was given knowing that would probably be his reality until the day he died, depression doesn't always show, as for shrek forever after he gets overwhelmed by the things he always wanted to have but didn't know how to handle as everyone else who had them from the begining, he unknowingly chooses the easy way out of that lifestyle only to regret it instantly
Really enjoy your writing. Super positive as well as fair. I like that you say “soften” rather than “soured”. It shows that really care about these movies even though you may not love them all. Keep up the great work👍🏽
My favorite DreamWorks movie (that was supposed to be the first) is The Prince of Egypt. The film was somewhat successful and is the darkest, most beautiful DreamWorks thing ever. The first scene is slaves working for Egypt and it doesn't hold back. It's a work of art, I don't want to spoil it.
If there is a film that deserves an honorary oscar, it's this one. All round beautiful storytelling from the visuals, animation, music, voice acting. Dare I say it's the best animated film ever put out by the west.
I really appreciate your insightful approach to each review. You have a great voice and a very interesting perspective that I think so many other essayists in the animation sphere lack. Summarizing a plot isnt a review! Great job all around.
I'm currently in a very overwork time in my life but I could not resist watching this AMAZING video. Had to watch in at least 9 different sessions but it was hella worth it!!
The plot/premise of Mirai would have made more sense if the title were better translated to english (which seems to be a common issue with Japanese animated films). In Japanese, the title is "Mirai no mirai", where Mirai (ミライ) is the character's name and mirai (未来) is a word in Japanese that means "future", so the title literally translates to "Mirai's future", which explains what happens in the movie a lot more.
Thank you so much for this Mr twice celloed! Truly an undertaking to be proud of my guy. And very much respect for inviting in other people to speak on your video. Sharing is daring. Thank you
If there's no more Wolfwalkers stans in the world, then I have passed on. So glad that it got your nod, I feel if Soul wasn't nominated that year then Saloon would have taken that Oscar home! This was a blast to power through today with some friends, and it's given me some new ideas for films to watch that I've not seen yet! So so fun as an animation junkie. Thanks for the hard work that you put into this script.
Wow just watched this over the span of three days and this solidifies my belief that videos like this with this length will forever be my favorite type of RUclips video !! Thank you so much for the entertainment 👏
If you like Loving Vincent, I recommend watching this studio's most recent movie called Peasants. It's based on polish book by Nobel Prize-winning author, and I really think it deserves more recognition.
This was a masterpiece of a video. I’ve never seen such an appreciation for animation quite like this. From Anomalisa to the Wind Rises, I now have a ton of movies to watch.
Hey Johnny! It took me a couple of days to get through this, but I did. And man, I'm so impressed with this. I realized that there's about a third of these movies that I haven't seen yet and I really want to now. Thank you, and your team, for this! Hugs from Sweden!
Hey, I finally finished the video, and I had an absolute blast watching all six hours! Thank you for the crazy amount of effort you put into this! I think it's really clear that you were more interested in introducing great films to people, rather than puting out some "objective" ranking. I really appreciate that you did your best to express what stood out about even the films you didn't care for, in case that was something someone else might resonate with. I know I definitely have some new animated movies I want to check out!
1:01-1:02 - Technically most of the Oscars wins for Best Animated Feature up until the last two Oscar’s (95th-96th) have awarded the animated films to a Pixar or Disney film with eleven of them awarded to Pixar and four to Disney. DreamWorks only won two Oscars (or one by default) via Shrek and _Wallace and Gromit: The Curse of the WereRabbit_ but not as much compared to Pixar. In fact, only eight of the animated films not from Pixar and Disney have won Oscars: 1. Shrek (DreamWorks) 2. Spirited Away (Studio Ghibli) 3. Wallace and Gromit: The Curse of the WereRabbit (DreamWorks/Aardman) 4. Happy Feet (Warner Bros.) 5. Rango (Paramount Pictures) 6. Into the Spider-Verse (Sony Picture Animation) 7. Guillermo Del Toro’s Pinocchio (Netflix/Shadow Machine) 8. The Boy and the Heron (Studio Ghibli)
Here's hoping the next year the lotr animated film or wild robot or wallace and gromit or a international choice( marcel pagnol,most precious of cargoes ,memoir of snale etc...) to ein the next since Disney was only inside out 2 and academy doesn't care about non toy story sequels
Your passion telling these stories comes through so warmly that your summaries keep bringing me to tears. I’m only one-third of the way through, but you’re gifting me rediscovery with every film you cover. Thank you
4:38:30 Spiderverse really is a celebration of many often under appreciated forms of art. Obviously comics & animation, but also graffiti/tagging & rap/hip hop.
At 5:23:48 you show a clip from Storks as an example of Sony, but it was actually produced by Warner Brothers, although it and Smallfoot are both often mistaken for Sony because they’re the only original IPs that Warner Bros animation has made
Is sad that is hated for beating puss in boots because fans didn't like the win. Guillermo had good intentions and even if PIB is more entertaining and more on focus. I still love pinocchio s win
I just want to quickly mention how great this video is. Like, I've been watching for 3 hours, not even on double speed or anything and if I had the time I would fully be open to finish it right now. It's rare that something this long is so entertaining to watch, even though it's just a guy talking about movies. I haven't finished it, but already, very good video!
This has got to be one of my favorite videos just talking about animated movies ever. Your understanding for what goes behind animation, for what goes into a story, for the directors and writers and voice actors and everything else- even when it’s something I disagree with like Shrek or Toy Story 4, I feel we comprehended everything from each movie and your arguments are simply from your own understanding. I feel like there’s a lot of movies I should go out and see now- luckily I work at the theaters, so I get free movies (saw Boy and the Heron the week it released), so I try to watch as many animated films as I can (unless it’s like Minions or Paw Patrol), I’m looking forward to seeing Robot Dreams on our screens in May (I haven’t seen any poster deliveries yet, I hope we will so I can grab one)
What a great video, I discovered your channel through this, I’d never even heard of your main channel, you managed to keep me super engaged for over 6 hours, great work
Glad I finally watched this. A great video that really shows how amazing animation is and I hope everyone here watching this takes time to check out all these films!
Did I just found the perfect video ever to listen to while I draw? this is super interesting, well covered, and I'm discovering a lot of indi films I now need to watch, thank you, this format is perfect for me rn
Wow, thank you so much for this! Watched this video in one day (tho skipped over some movies so well known that I´ve heard everything I need to know about them) and now I have a list of 22 movies I really want to see, mostly consisting of foreign movies and movies from smaller studios! As someone with a big love for animation (with Studio Ghibli, Shinkai and stop motion having my whole heart), but not a general "movie lover", it was great to see some amazing movies I`ve missed out on that I know I`m going to love when I watched them. Of course, I don`t share all of your opinions, but I respect you and this video so much and know I will look to your channel for more movie-content in the future. Thank you again!
great list! im about halfway through and i love how much detail you go to on each movie and how even with the movies you don't like, you still respect them and don't just go into snark. i wish there was more like this on movie commentary youtube
5:37:03 Absolutely agreed. As much as I liked the first two Shrek movies and especially their humor, they felt more awkwardly paced in comparison to TLW. The humor also doesn’t rely too much on pop culture references.
I saw Robot Dreams in the cinema (it has been a while since it has been released in Spain) and let me tell you it was a rollercoaster to watch, so much joy, sadness.... and the music chef's kiss!!! It's a must watch !!!
after watching the whole thing, I can say that I really, really, need to watch anomalisa and the tale of the princess kaguya. Of course tons of others as well. Great work on this!
Trying to watch all of these - and all future nominees - now feels like a budding family tradition I'd love to invest time in. The way that you gave every movie the same chance and open mind made me realise I often haven't - both in being too part of the Disney/Pixar circuit, AND in rejecting it and avoiding it once it wore thin. The level of love and effort in this video was incredible, and I'm so glad to be able to sit here and watch it, and to learn about so many movies that passed me by, and so many movies I'd lost sight of and should give another chance. Thank you for your dedication bringing this to the world!!
I'mma be honest, people who felt betrayed by Toy Story 4 and those who loved it are the only stances I've seen on the internet thus far. It's a testament to how impactful the film was in the public zeitgeist.
I loved this video so so so much!! Can truly feel the love for animation and art in general here and it’s lovely. There’s truly so many amazing movies and i love how you covered them, especially the extra non nominated movies each year. Love the even coverage of everything too! I love how even movies you weren’t a huge fan of weren’t just you dunking on them for a whole segment. Such a positive watch! Really felt like these 6 and a quarter hours just flew by. Also holy hell lmao this video really really puts into perspective how good studio ghibli is. What the fuck man lmao
So grateful for RUclips creators like you inviting such awesome conversations about theatrical animation, man. Lotta movies added to my Letterboxd watchlist!
Loved to hear the Finding Nemo appreciation, particularly for elaborating on how amazing the scene of Nemo hearing about his father's journey is. I've never heard anyone else give as much elaboration on all the reasons that make it one of my underspoken favourites, so that was really cool to see here!
![Felix "Unfair" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Oswujxm2Ag0/mqdefault.jpg)
![Noob To Max With DRAGON REWORK In Blox Fruits [FULL MOVIE]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/LnBMOinoOvA/mqdefault.jpg)
Here are some really interesting statistics from a section I had to cut out of the video because this was a behemoth!
Pixar has the most wins with 11, AND the most nominations with 18, meaning they win 61% of the time they’re nominated, and 47% of the time total
Only SEVEN films that Pixar has submitted for the award have NOT been nominated, meaning they have a 72% nomination rate
They have an 18% share of the TOTAL nominations in the history, nearly 1/5th
If you loop Walt Disney Animation studios in with Pixar as they’re both owned by Disney:
The have 31/99 nominations, giving them about 31% of the total nominations
They’ve won 15/23 of the awards, meaning they win 65% of the time
Laika has submitted 6 films and been nominated 6 times for a 100% nomination rate
However, they’ve never won, giving them a 0% win rate, oof
Of all 99 nominees
54 are CG animated
28 are 2D animated
17 are Stop Motion animated
CG animated films have won 19/23 years for about an 82% win rate
2D animated films have won 2/23 years for about an 8.5% win rate
Stop Motion animated films have won 2/23 years for about an 8.5% win rate
Pete Docter has the most wins with 3 and is tied with Hayao Miyazaki for the most nominations with 4
Pete Doctor wins 75% of the time he is nominated
Shrek is the franchise with the most nominations with 4, if you include the Puss in Boots spin offs
Toy Story is the franchise with the most wins with 2, still the only sequels to ever win the award
This is a great undertaking
Also it’s worth mentioning ever since the BAFTA introduction in 2006/2007 when they were announcing the nominations for best animated feature for the 2006 animated films, 15 of the 18 Animated films that won the BAFTA (except LEGO Movie, Kubo, and Klaus) wound up winning the Academy Award for Best Animated Feature and are 80-90% accurate compared to the Golden Globes and the Annie’s (post-2006/2007).
On top of that in the last two to three years, four Animated Films that have won the Golden Globe and BAFTA wound up winning the Oscar for Best Animated Feature: _Soul, Encanto, Guillermo Del Toro’s Pinocchio,_ and _The Boy and the Heron_
Secondly outside the _Toy Story_ franchise which won Best Animated Feature through Toy Story 3-4, their hasn’t been *ANY* animated sequel that has won the Oscar. _Shrek, The Incredibles_ and _Into the Spider-Verse_ won the Oscar, yet their sequels (Shrek 2, Incredibles 2 and Across the Spider-Verse) didn’t go on to win the Oscar with the _Incredibles 2_ losing to _Into the Spider-Verse_ and now _Across the Spider-Verse_ losing to _The Boy and the Heron._
Finally while 12 adult animated films were nominated, nine of them - _The Triplets of Belleville, Persepolis, The Wind Rises, My Life as a Courgette, The Breadwinner, Loving Vincent, Isle of Dogs, Flee_ and _The Boy and the Heron_ were each rated PG-13, _Anomalisa_ is the only R-rated animated film to be nominated in this category, and _Chico and Rita_ and _I Lost My Body_ were not rated by the MPA, _The Boy and the Heron_ is currently the first and as of now the first Adult animated and first PG-13 animated film to win the Academy Award for Best Animated Feature.
I'd PAY to watch you create a series that was like "What if they had the best animated feature category for every previous year" maybe doing a decade at a time. This was one of my favorite RUclips videos I've watched in a long time
Jack Black being genuinely enthusiastic about WALL-E winning the 2009 Oscar over Kung Fu Panda is sweet :')
I think I remember that and the reason he did it was apart of a joke about how he take what he makes from kung-fu panda and bet it all on Pixar winning
Imagine if Kung Fu panda won. Dude might have done a backflip
The Fundamental Facts of Life:
1. Wall-E is an AMAZING piece of cinema.
2. Jack Black is a nice bloke.
Calling John Lasseter disgraced every single time he is mentioned is so fucking funny
Makes me want to merge without looking
Yeah, it's almost "character actress Margo Martindale" level
Horses are infamously difficult to draw. James Baxter, the backbone of Spirit, is an industry legend because of his incredible ability to draw horses. Animators look for any excuse not to draw horses if they can. People have refused work because of them. The fact they got enough willing people to make a 2D horse film and it looks that good is insane.
This is why we don't have Steel Ball Run 😭😭😭😭
Jaaaaames Baaaaxter!
@@MisterSynysterYeah, man, I wanna be like James Baxter, always rollin' in on a beach ball, saying his name in a horse voice, making people smile.
Holy shit that's why James Baxter is the name of the horse in Adventure Time, I never knew this!
@@Takenja Yeah. And he is still a legend, the work for that kind of highly detailed absurdly profecient 2D animation is rare in the western market these days, but you know when a production has the desire and a little budget for a scene with that stuff, that Baxter will be available. A pretty goode example would probably be the scene from the final episode of Steven Universe of Steven reunifying with his gem half. All done by James Baxter.
Watching Anomalisa lose its Oscar to Inside Out was the first moment I was like “oh, the Academy *really* doesn’t get it, huh?” So I’m glad to see it at least took home the Johnny
Yoo it's mother's basment yooo
If the fans do a full-on oscar ceremony, it should be called the Johnny's
I wish people who prefer anomalisa over inside out didnt act like anomalisa lost to some whatever movie instead of, like, pixars most creative and heartfelt movie of said decade (like 3rd at the least)
@@undergalaxy775I get what you mean, but could you at least spell "Anomalisa" correctly?
Anomalisa is also a very heartfelt and meaningful movie and ironically it feels like you're also dismissing it.
@@ChiangKai-Shrek lmao I was distracted sorry, I'll edit it. No, Im not dismissing it, its a worthy contender as well, I just believe we can all be civilized about it. I think The Breadwinner is better than coco but Im not crying death of cinema because of it
Man it was a bold take to put Shark Tale at number 1 but I respect it
😂
His analysis of Will Smith's GROUNDBREAKING vocal performance as OSCAR, the main protagonist of SHARK TALE made me cry
SHARK TALE. IS. CINEMA. I mean, it has Martin Scorsese in it, of course it is!
This is becoming Fantano's comment section
@@vamoacalmarno3868 I didn't know you hated memes The Rock
it's so frustrating to learn that Satoshi Kon never got nominated while his work constantly influence a lot of Hollywood films to come.
Millennium actress and tokyo godfathers should had been nominated over brother bear and paprika should nominated and win over happy feet
@@savvastoynoysidis360 2006 was such a shit year for animated films. paprika was probably the _only_ deserving winner from that year, and it didn't even get nominated.
fr we would’ve never gotten black swan, inception, requiem for a dream etc if it weren’t for his genius
@@jclkaytwo Tekkonkinkreet and The Girl Who Leapt Through Time were also super solid films that year. It's a shame that the Academy almost always ignores Japan when it comes best animated feature
@@jaredarenas7542 tekkonkinkreet was submitted for the 2007 oscars and the girl who leapt through time was never submitted at all. so... point still stands
I think Shrek doesnt realize or accept how lonely he really is until Donkey comes along and openly accepts him. He's been rejected by everyone in society his whole life so he's basically embraced that image. He becomes scary and mean because that's how people thought of him. Over time you become comfortable in your own space and you accept that you're unloveable by the rest of the world. But when someone actually decides to be nice to you it throws you for a loop because you believed for so long that you were incapable of being liked or loved, but now youre being reminded of all the hate you've endured this whole time and realizing that it didnt HAVE to be that way.
I'm having a hard time coming up with similar examples in fiction at the moment but if i come up with some I'll update this comment. Just my thoughts
Well said.
Thank you!! I thought that he was a bit harsh on Shrek but couldn't find a way to explain how much I loved Donkey and Shrek's relationships, or all the characters for that matter. Thank you
You can think of real life examples. Pretty much all the trolls on the Internet.
Fun fact: Eddie Murphy in Shrek is the only voice acting performance ever to get an acting nomination at the BAFTAs
It also received 6 nominations, including best Film, winning Adapted screenplay. The Brits went nuts for Shrek
@@notchuckproductions5029 Was probably Shrek's Scottish accent
Bro congratulations, you got this out before Schaffrillas Productions did!
He's not actually doing this is he
@@johnny2channelsyeah he is he said so on twitter
@@johnny2channelshe is
He announced it on Twitter yesterday
you're fucking kidding me lol
@@johnny2channelsthat's okay, that just means 2 great videos from 2 great RUclipsrs with some different views of some films. This year is gonna be great!
"Constant accidental 9/11's" is not a phrase I expected to hear in an animation review but I can't say I'm mad about it.
I saw this comment when I hadn’t seen most of the video, I was expecting it to be in response to Turning Red.
Johnny: *wishes Lilo and Stitch got more attention*
Lilo and Stitch: *received three sequel movies, a series and two separate animes*
NOT THAT KIND OF ATTENTION
Wait two seperate animes?
I know about the Manga of stitch traveling to feudal Era Japan and befriending a samurai but I did not know that he had not one but two anime about him
@@walrus6429Well not quite TWO anime, if the classification is confined to Japan, but there’s the actual Stitch anime and then a Chinese series called Stitch and Ai
LMAO literally just commented this before reading other replies.
The series and the Stitch Movie (and Leroy and Stitch) were my *jam*. To the point where I have made my boyfriend watch them with me because I loved it.
After watching the whole thing, I wanna say two things...
1. Thank you for giving the time and attention to the nominees that are not as talked about much, especially Boy and the World and Robot Dreams.
2. Thank you for the positivity on the films that are overhated from the majority and on the films you hate. It made me feel a little better after seeing reccent news and other sad things I saw. YAY POSITIVITY!!!!1!!!111!!!
p.s. I hope Schaffrillas gives you a shoutout
I’ve only just started the video but I really appreciate your willingness to talk about the positive aspects of Shrek despite not liking it yourself. I think that’s the mark of a great writer. I love hearing about how people may not personally enjoy pieces of media but still bring positive spins on it. It’s easy to tear down something you don’t enjoy, but I find it a lot more impactful and intellectually interesting to discuss the positives of said media. I like balance!
THANK YOU that means a lot to me and I apologize in advance for having nothing good to say about Shark Tale lol
@@johnny2channels I think it's humanly impossible to find enough good things to say about Shark Tale
"Lilo and Stitch never got the attention it deserved"
To be fair it got two sequels, a tv show, an anime, and a TON of merchadise.
But unfortunately, Stitch has kinda turned into Disney’s Minions when it come to its role in popular culture.
And an upcoming live action remake...
The injustice of Happy Feet winning and Paprika not getting a nom at all, unbelievable.
Paprika is actually one of the best animated films ever and it was hands down the most important movie to come out that year. But sure, throw it to the wolves. Literally three movies got nominated, that's like spitting in Satoshi Kon's face.
I think paprika didn't ( underseving) nom because it was rather obscure with cars and happy feet domain the award season
@@reillymcwritingnah paprika was movie made by someone who had drugs
Okay but it also means we get to say "Academy Award Winner George Miller" so... auteur for an auteur?
@@reillymcwritingpaprika is the most overrated and boring film of all time it’s sad that the guy died but that doesn’t make it deserving of a nomination
Don't watch the Oscars, but damn wish they still made animations featuring characters from the movies reacting to whether they won or lost.
Think the last time they did that was 2009 or 2010.
It was quite a cute detail, but I think I prefer how they do it nowadays honestly. The fact that we get to see the faces of those who created the movies just as we do with live action directors really helps raise public awareness for animation as a valid artistic medium. It's the difference between treating animated movies as quirky products created by an anonymous team (a view Disney very heavily pushed last century as a way of maintaining it's monopoly on animation, by the way) and regarding them as pieces of art created by people with unique talents and visions.
Also I think those animations just wouldn't work well nowadays given that adult and other non comedic films frequently get nominated for the category. How could anyone ever make silly award ceremony skits about characters from movies like Persepolis, Anomalisa or Flee?
@@signodeinterrogacion8361 I think a middle ground could be established, of course depending on the movie maker's own desire, but to have representation in animated form for the animated productions would be great to see more again.
@@drdewott9154 I don't believe the creators themselves are the ones that can decide that, it's usually their corporate overloads that are in charge of this kind of 'marketing stunts'.
And anyway having a different format for each movie that is in the running would be kind of awkward. Even if none of these adult movies ever win the entire segment would just feel off if it only applied to some movies, only half way for others and none at all for a few of them.
But I get your point.
4:06:42 “how are there not constant accidental 9/11’s” is probably my favorite out of context line in this video
Don’t you mean 4:06:30?
@@incrediblesnn I spent those 12 seconds giggling and thought that was close enough. Sorry for not being perfect 😔
@@incrediblesnnsurely you mean 09:11:01?
2 - 6 hour videos like this i have been DEPENDING on for the past 24 hours as my moms in the hospital with pancreatitis. Ive been watching this video throughout the entire thing and its made me feel so much better. Thank you so much for this you couldnt not uploaded this at a better time
I hope your mom makes a recovery!
@milkiski Hope your Mom is better. Your comment hi-lights the positive of the RUclips content world. Similar videos have been helpful to me in stressful times.
@@michelehamilton961 shes doing so much better! I just have to remind her to take it easy on herself because shes takes her work seriously
Someone must have let you into the kitchen at Casa Bonita because who let you cook like this???
Man I remember as a teen, during the early 00s, the depressing realization that 2D animated movies where phased out so fast all of a sudden. I remember the sadness when I found out The Princess and the Frog was gonna be Disney's last 2D animated movie. I love and enjoy 3D art and have so much respect for the people who excel in that field of skill, but I wished new technology didn't make older mediums obsolete or irrelevant or less profitable (in the eyes of executives and shareholders).
I'd say Megamind absolutely deserved a nomination in 2010, it was fantastic. Definitely my most rewatched nomination in that year.
Also, my favorite winner might just be Rango. As incredible as Boy and the Heron and Spirited Away are, Rango is unbelievably next level for animation, especially for CG. It's a straight up western. Thank you for introducing me to Anomalisa and Persepolis though. I think the latter after I watch it may become a new all time favorite.
If I didn't have such a nostalgic appreciation for Wall-E I would agree with you. Actually I'm not sure Into the Spiderverse might be there too
megamind would've deserved a nomination in any other year, but for some reason 2010 only had three nominees despite how strong the competition was. even _tangled_ missed.
As a kid that was taken from his family by child services, man Lilo and Stitch hit HARD as a child.
Well I think the thesis of Shrek is more "life is more complicated than Disney fairytales, but true love still exists." Like it is critical of the absurd extent of fairy tale romanization, but it still holds true to some of its core themes. Hence why Shrek dismisses the idea of true love at the beginning of the film, yet finds it at the end. He didn't believe it was possible for himself, but was later proven wrong, hence the song choice “I’m a Believer” and the lyrics “[I thought love was] meant for someone else but not for me.” Also Sid could know that a rhino's brain is small, I don’t see how that’s a stretch. I'm sure animals had their heads cracked open on occasion during the Ice Age, and it would make sense if they had simple biological knowledge like that, especially in a world where animals talk.
Honestly your analysis is like a breathe of fresh air! I can’t quite explain it but there’s just a passion for the craft rather than an expectation, fantastic video!
They should really have a voice acting category for best actor and actress
But then the idiots would give it to chris pratt
@@sofsof5062
That's a fine trade for the west to treat voice acting more like traditional acting and not a lesser form.
@@sofsof5062I truly hate how every animated movie is now marketed with a wall of celebrity names who did voices while professional VA’s toil in anonymity.
So happy this video isn't just a ranking and you actually took the time to talk about the movies and what made them deserved (or undeserved) of their nomination !
Great stuff, time to check more of the video son your channel and wait for more ^^
The Lilo and Stitch part was so unbelievably based, my favorite movie of all time
Truly an underrated classic, despite Stitch being one of Disney's most iconic characters
And I feel bad cause I feel like yet again it taught Disney the wrong lesson like the reason it was perfect is cause this cute figure was so grounded in this movie that everyone adored him. But instead they though oh keep making more cute marketable mascots
Your coverage of "Spirited Away" actively drove me to watch through the whole movie again.
And having just done so, I am extremely grateful for that.
Why did I have to be called out as a bisexual enjoyer of Howl’s Moving Castle!?
I heard that and it made so much sense because everyone I know that loves that movie is bi
I’m not bi, I’m pan and I love Howl’s Moving Castle so I guess that’s still close enough 😂
@@a_ninja2376why though, because both Howl and Sophie are really attractive? 😄
OH MY GOD
Same, but I also have an asexual heteroromantic friend who adores this movie, so there's that.
As a Brazillian, i jumped straight to the "Boy and the World" review (i will come back and watch everything when i have the time). This movie is easily one of the best productions my country ever made. If you ever want to go deeper about the movie, you can search things like "Ditadura Militar" or "Exodo Rural", which are both BIG parts of its meaning. They make the emotional parts hit even deeper.
Is weirdly one of my favourites films of all time. Im not Brazilian but the colors,the symbolism and the message make this such a great watch
He ranked it really high too
Pfvr pfvr pfvr marca em que minuto tá! Cliquei no vídeo por esse filme, mas não quero assitir todas as 6:16:42 horas pra encontrar :(
@@savvastoynoysidis360we really appreciate that!
@@srob6168 3:40:36 amg!!!!!!!
it feels so great to hear such high praise for robot dreams! i really wish the movie couldve been released in the US before the oscars, it felt like the odds were very against it because of that. but im so happy you liked it!
I finally finished "ALL 99 Animated Oscar Nominees RANKED" and I hope you update us on the new nominees every year and what you think should be nominees, this was truly an amazing video.
Found this video late, but this is an absolute banger Johnny
Omg chippy
This was an amazing video! The RUclips algorithm blessed me with an absolute banger. I love that you went into deep dives into each film, doing thematic readings and unpacking your opinions vs. simple plot summaries. I think many people who would undergo this project would likely gloss over a lot of entries, but you clearly went above and beyond giving every single entry time in the spotlight. I also can't thank you enough for going into the submissions and snubs for each year. You've left me with a whole stack of films to check out. Thank you so much!
Mike Wazowski in the thumbnail is genius! Using the time code as an Easter Egg 🤯
The way you talk about these movies with so much passion and joy literally made me cry a few times. Great job man!
In defense of Spirit, I think the horses expressing themselves is like. Kind of essential to telling the story? You want animated horses to just stand around and look like normal ass horses? The great thing about animation is that you CAN pull the expressions a bit and tell a story that wouldn't be told with any other medium. That's the entire point of it being animation.
Sorry, not to be harsh but I think that was a very silly criticism.
Do agree the narration is stupid tho.
It’s only criticism in conjunction with the narration lol it all feels desperate
@johnny2channels I always forget it even has narration since it's so little and spread out its such an odd part of it lmao
How Shrek 2 not 69 is outrageous. Arguable the horniest Oscar nominated movie till Shape of Water
I am probably in minority but I didn't hate shape of water. Like dont get me wrong i love get out more but i dont think it is GDT'S worst film. Like Pinocchio and Nightmare alley were more worthy best picture but i do think is it still decent film, just the comparation was better
nah happy feet is right there
@@dablloydtruther it fits more cause it may be the horniest kids movie
@@ΓΕΏΡΓΙΟΣ-ι8νyou think the majority of people hate Shape of Water? Based on what?
@@dablloydtruthervery few children’s movies open with a Prince song.
I understand that brother bear may not be loved by most people but I literally grew up watching this movie and it has an extremely special place in my heart
same especially as a native american
Honestly, I appreciate this video not only for it itself, but also letting me see other viewpoints on movies I love/hate - great video, you've gained a new subscriber
I thought it was pretty obvious shrek was just trying to make the best out of the life he was given knowing that would probably be his reality until the day he died, depression doesn't always show, as for shrek forever after he gets overwhelmed by the things he always wanted to have but didn't know how to handle as everyone else who had them from the begining, he unknowingly chooses the easy way out of that lifestyle only to regret it instantly
Exactly. I would think we all know that moment when the sadness jus drapes over us. Trying to make the best of things but the happiness doesn't last.
Really enjoy your writing. Super positive as well as fair. I like that you say “soften” rather than “soured”. It shows that really care about these movies even though you may not love them all. Keep up the great work👍🏽
My favorite DreamWorks movie (that was supposed to be the first) is The Prince of Egypt. The film was somewhat successful and is the darkest, most beautiful DreamWorks thing ever. The first scene is slaves working for Egypt and it doesn't hold back. It's a work of art, I don't want to spoil it.
If there is a film that deserves an honorary oscar, it's this one. All round beautiful storytelling from the visuals, animation, music, voice acting. Dare I say it's the best animated film ever put out by the west.
I really appreciate your insightful approach to each review. You have a great voice and a very interesting perspective that I think so many other essayists in the animation sphere lack. Summarizing a plot isnt a review! Great job all around.
I'm currently in a very overwork time in my life but I could not resist watching this AMAZING video. Had to watch in at least 9 different sessions but it was hella worth it!!
The way you analyze each film it's so entertaining that it makes the video shorter than it actually is,splendid job johnny ♡
The plot/premise of Mirai would have made more sense if the title were better translated to english (which seems to be a common issue with Japanese animated films). In Japanese, the title is "Mirai no mirai", where Mirai (ミライ) is the character's name and mirai (未来) is a word in Japanese that means "future", so the title literally translates to "Mirai's future", which explains what happens in the movie a lot more.
Thank you so much for this Mr twice celloed! Truly an undertaking to be proud of my guy. And very much respect for inviting in other people to speak on your video. Sharing is daring. Thank you
If there's no more Wolfwalkers stans in the world, then I have passed on. So glad that it got your nod, I feel if Soul wasn't nominated that year then Saloon would have taken that Oscar home!
This was a blast to power through today with some friends, and it's given me some new ideas for films to watch that I've not seen yet! So so fun as an animation junkie. Thanks for the hard work that you put into this script.
Wow just watched this over the span of three days and this solidifies my belief that videos like this with this length will forever be my favorite type of RUclips video !! Thank you so much for the entertainment 👏
If you like Loving Vincent, I recommend watching this studio's most recent movie called Peasants.
It's based on polish book by Nobel Prize-winning author, and I really think it deserves more recognition.
I shout it out towards the end of the video but haven't seen it yet!
This was a masterpiece of a video. I’ve never seen such an appreciation for animation quite like this. From Anomalisa to the Wind Rises, I now have a ton of movies to watch.
4:09
*THIS JUST IN!! WE FOUND JUSTIN BIEBER LONG LOST TWIN, JOHNNY BIEBER*
Nah, thats Jessie Bye Burr
6 hours of well written animation analysis? This is incredible.
man this is one of the best videos i’ve ever seen on youtube. great work.
Hey Johnny!
It took me a couple of days to get through this, but I did. And man, I'm so impressed with this. I realized that there's about a third of these movies that I haven't seen yet and I really want to now.
Thank you, and your team, for this!
Hugs from Sweden!
I was wondering when this was coming out. Everytime I went on Letterboxd, I’d see you log and remember you were doing this project
I watched all 6 hours this week, and was really sorry when I was finished. Phenomenal video!
Beating Schaffrillas to the punch, good on you.
This is the kind of content I didnt know I needed. So many films are being added to my watch list. Youve done it once again Johnny
Holy crap this is a video I didn't know I always wanted. And there are time codes! This is amazing.
Hey, I finally finished the video, and I had an absolute blast watching all six hours! Thank you for the crazy amount of effort you put into this! I think it's really clear that you were more interested in introducing great films to people, rather than puting out some "objective" ranking. I really appreciate that you did your best to express what stood out about even the films you didn't care for, in case that was something someone else might resonate with. I know I definitely have some new animated movies I want to check out!
1:01-1:02 - Technically most of the Oscars wins for Best Animated Feature up until the last two Oscar’s (95th-96th) have awarded the animated films to a Pixar or Disney film with eleven of them awarded to Pixar and four to Disney.
DreamWorks only won two Oscars (or one by default) via Shrek and _Wallace and Gromit: The Curse of the WereRabbit_ but not as much compared to Pixar.
In fact, only eight of the animated films not from Pixar and Disney have won Oscars:
1. Shrek (DreamWorks)
2. Spirited Away (Studio Ghibli)
3. Wallace and Gromit: The Curse of the WereRabbit (DreamWorks/Aardman)
4. Happy Feet (Warner Bros.)
5. Rango (Paramount Pictures)
6. Into the Spider-Verse (Sony Picture Animation)
7. Guillermo Del Toro’s Pinocchio (Netflix/Shadow Machine)
8. The Boy and the Heron (Studio Ghibli)
I hope Laika wins one of these days
@@RileyShaw-ry7xzthe might win for wildwood if the academy aren't interested at Elio or Zootopia 2.
Here's hoping the next year the lotr animated film or wild robot or wallace and gromit or a international choice( marcel pagnol,most precious of cargoes ,memoir of snale etc...) to ein the next since Disney was only inside out 2 and academy doesn't care about non toy story sequels
This must’ve taken a lot of work. You earned yourself a new subscriber!
Your passion telling these stories comes through so warmly that your summaries keep bringing me to tears. I’m only one-third of the way through, but you’re gifting me rediscovery with every film you cover. Thank you
Dude, the soundtrack you put behind some of these entries is insane! Pumpkin Hill??? In Coraline???
Almost done with the video. I really enjoy the way you are always able to find the positives in most movies. It is refreshing.
4:38:30
Spiderverse really is a celebration of many often under appreciated forms of art. Obviously comics & animation, but also graffiti/tagging & rap/hip hop.
Lilo & Stitch is a masterpiece. Absolutely one of Disney's greatest works.
At 5:23:48 you show a clip from Storks as an example of Sony, but it was actually produced by Warner Brothers, although it and Smallfoot are both often mistaken for Sony because they’re the only original IPs that Warner Bros animation has made
This video is such an achievement, I'm enjoying watching it piecemeal over the week. Love it!
GDT’s Pinocchio would definitely be in my top 10 I absolutely adored it. It’s one of my favouriter films ever made
Is sad that is hated for beating puss in boots because fans didn't like the win. Guillermo had good intentions and even if PIB is more entertaining and more on focus. I still love pinocchio s win
I love that movie with my whole soul, omg more fans!!🥺🥺🥺 it deserved that win❤
I just want to quickly mention how great this video is. Like, I've been watching for 3 hours, not even on double speed or anything and if I had the time I would fully be open to finish it right now. It's rare that something this long is so entertaining to watch, even though it's just a guy talking about movies. I haven't finished it, but already, very good video!
Brother I have to drive across the country and you just saved my life with this video
This has got to be one of my favorite videos just talking about animated movies ever. Your understanding for what goes behind animation, for what goes into a story, for the directors and writers and voice actors and everything else- even when it’s something I disagree with like Shrek or Toy Story 4, I feel we comprehended everything from each movie and your arguments are simply from your own understanding. I feel like there’s a lot of movies I should go out and see now- luckily I work at the theaters, so I get free movies (saw Boy and the Heron the week it released), so I try to watch as many animated films as I can (unless it’s like Minions or Paw Patrol), I’m looking forward to seeing Robot Dreams on our screens in May (I haven’t seen any poster deliveries yet, I hope we will so I can grab one)
What a great video, I discovered your channel through this, I’d never even heard of your main channel, you managed to keep me super engaged for over 6 hours, great work
Glad I finally watched this. A great video that really shows how amazing animation is and I hope everyone here watching this takes time to check out all these films!
This was such a great huge video... and I was still sad when it ended.
Did I just found the perfect video ever to listen to while I draw? this is super interesting, well covered, and I'm discovering a lot of indi films I now need to watch, thank you, this format is perfect for me rn
Wow, thank you so much for this! Watched this video in one day (tho skipped over some movies so well known that I´ve heard everything I need to know about them) and now I have a list of 22 movies I really want to see, mostly consisting of foreign movies and movies from smaller studios! As someone with a big love for animation (with Studio Ghibli, Shinkai and stop motion having my whole heart), but not a general "movie lover", it was great to see some amazing movies I`ve missed out on that I know I`m going to love when I watched them. Of course, I don`t share all of your opinions, but I respect you and this video so much and know I will look to your channel for more movie-content in the future. Thank you again!
Thanks for watching! Hope you didn’t skip Ratatouille I’m really proud of that section
great list! im about halfway through and i love how much detail you go to on each movie and how even with the movies you don't like, you still respect them and don't just go into snark. i wish there was more like this on movie commentary youtube
Thank you so much!
This an incredible feat well done Johnny!
Acho que esse vídeo pode ser considerado um vídeo HISTÓRICO do RUclips ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Obrigado por fazer esse vídeo ❤️
5:37:03 Absolutely agreed. As much as I liked the first two Shrek movies and especially their humor, they felt more awkwardly paced in comparison to TLW. The humor also doesn’t rely too much on pop culture references.
I saw Robot Dreams in the cinema (it has been a while since it has been released in Spain) and let me tell you it was a rollercoaster to watch, so much joy, sadness.... and the music chef's kiss!!! It's a must watch !!!
I'm only halfway through but this is an incredibly thorough and excellent video, great job!
Thank you Jenny!! I don’t know what to do with my life now that it’s finished lol
after watching the whole thing, I can say that I really, really, need to watch anomalisa and the tale of the princess kaguya. Of course tons of others as well.
Great work on this!
"Little inbred firefly getting sent to Valhalla" was the line that made me subscribe.
This was such a well-written and presented video. Crazy good. Looking forward to that Aardman retrospective in the future! 🥂
Liked, commented, subbed, and favorited. Tremendous effort poured into a fantastic and important video. Thank you for this!
Trying to watch all of these - and all future nominees - now feels like a budding family tradition I'd love to invest time in. The way that you gave every movie the same chance and open mind made me realise I often haven't - both in being too part of the Disney/Pixar circuit, AND in rejecting it and avoiding it once it wore thin.
The level of love and effort in this video was incredible, and I'm so glad to be able to sit here and watch it, and to learn about so many movies that passed me by, and so many movies I'd lost sight of and should give another chance. Thank you for your dedication bringing this to the world!!
Just watched Wolfwalkers because of this video. Wow. What a beautiful film.
Annoyingly, it's not widely available on Blu-ray. Just part of an expensive (and limited) set.
Such a great video 🎉🎉🎉
It took me 3 days to complete it, but it was a treat; now I have a full list of films to watch!
We need a list of the snubs 🙏🏻
Gotta respect you going all out for this
I'mma be honest, people who felt betrayed by Toy Story 4 and those who loved it are the only stances I've seen on the internet thus far. It's a testament to how impactful the film was in the public zeitgeist.
Toy story 4 is by far the worst toy story imo and was defo just a cashgrab to me soiled a great trilogy to me
I enjoyed Toy story 4 but i still stand by that klaus and i lost my body deserves the award more
Toy Story 4 is the biggest Abomination I've ever seen in animation cinematic history! I HATE it with every beat of my heart!
Toy story 4 was just okay. I thought Klaus or even the not nominated weathering with you snubbed
I loved this video so so so much!! Can truly feel the love for animation and art in general here and it’s lovely. There’s truly so many amazing movies and i love how you covered them, especially the extra non nominated movies each year.
Love the even coverage of everything too! I love how even movies you weren’t a huge fan of weren’t just you dunking on them for a whole segment. Such a positive watch! Really felt like these 6 and a quarter hours just flew by.
Also holy hell lmao this video really really puts into perspective how good studio ghibli is. What the fuck man lmao
So grateful for RUclips creators like you inviting such awesome conversations about theatrical animation, man. Lotta movies added to my Letterboxd watchlist!
Loved to hear the Finding Nemo appreciation, particularly for elaborating on how amazing the scene of Nemo hearing about his father's journey is. I've never heard anyone else give as much elaboration on all the reasons that make it one of my underspoken favourites, so that was really cool to see here!
Woah, this definitely is *ONE HECK OF A VIDEO!* I love ''one of those unreasonably long videos'' a lot so I will enjoy watching this for sure.