Umineko Episode 8 Manga Boat Scene- When the Seagulls Cry (w/Japanese Voice Acting)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 30 окт 2021
- I have synced up the visual novel’s voice acting and the osts with the manga panels. Of course, it’s not perfect, this is my first attempt ever at video editing but out of my love for the series and in commemoration of Halloween, here is my offering to the catbox. Rest In Peace, my Beloved Beatrice.
None of the osts, voice acting, or images are owned by me.
Peak fiction
Hate each other ---> love each other
Actually, this scene takes place before ep 1 in the world, so technically its love each other -> hate each other -> love each other again lmao
Is complicated. Really.
@@Blueberry173.Actually, this is probably one of the forgeries made by those with love, since Tohya can't remember this part of his escape.
So technically it's hate each other(first forgeries) to love each other(love/truth forgeries)
@@Psyralov well i am talking about battler as a character in the story, though not love, they liked each other quite a lot as battler and sayo, then metaverse happens where he hates beato, and then in the end they are in love.
This scene is fantastical in nature because tohya can't remember it clearly, not that he completely doesnt remember, its probably a forgery by tohya himself, remember, in reality, this is just sayo's delusion, battler couldnt save her and she thinks about a version of battler she desired.
08:52 wait does this mean the final scene where battler is hugging beato as they sink into the ocean was all magic? battler didnt have his jacket on and lost beato, then suddenly battler is holding beato with his jacket, did poor beatrice hallucinate battler on his side until the end? thats so fucking tragic
(spoilers ahead)
Yes, you are right. Also is a way to show that Battler also died on that day so the two of them could remain forever together inside the catbox, that's why at the end it's mentioned the golden rose at the bottom of the abyss. The golden rose is to symbolize the golden land
You could consider it a hallucination, or you could view it as symbolizing how Battler "died" alongside Beato. His body survived, but Tohya is psychologically a different person from him
Very late response but good observation about the jacket.
Author leaves it open ended to believe whether or not it was real or magic. I didn’t upload the full chapter in the video, but the pages before the video show that this the singular truth of what happened to Battler and Yasuda that day (indicating the boat scene is the beginning of the story) and the pages after they drown show Yasuda, as Beatrice the Golden Witch, waking up in the Catbox World with an amnesiac Battler. From there, she then starts the meta games, starting with Legend of the Golden Witch, hoping for Battler to remember himself through the games and his promise, which strongly hints at the meta world and magic being all real this whole time (which is a brilliant subversion) and that this is the start of the meta games (and birth of Meta Battler).
The ending of the ep 8 manga also shows the part of Battler within Tohya merging with Meta Battler, suggesting that Meta Battler was half of Battler’s soul (who accompanied the drowning Yasuda) while the other half was within Tohya and that both halves become amnesiac from splitting. Battler had triggered a miracle by splitting his soul in order to save Beato, not wanting her to be alone again.
Of course, you can also interpret things in a nonmagic light, where it’s just Yasuda hallucinating Battler accompanying her, as a final comfort to herself and symbolic of Battler dying with her mentally (as Tohya is a different person psychologically). Or that Tohya retroactively revised the scene to show he understood her or is with her spiritually. And the scene afterwards with amnesiac Meta Battler and Beato in the catbox world could be metaphorical to Tohya facing the truth and reading Yasuda’s message bottles.
@Lorenzo Vonmatterhorn this uncertainty of interpretation is the magic vs trick which is the main theme of the story.
My interpretation... beato died alone in the real world, normally we can interpret the scene as battler's soul coming out of his body since his body can't take it anymore.
But in my view, from how magic has been seen to work, it is different, they are not hallucinations but fictions created after the event. fictions normally created by writings/stories.
Basically, Hachijo Tohya finally finished episode 8 and felt complete, that's when he decided to revisit Beatrice's death but writing a "fiction" or "magic" where he finally caught up with her and left with her.
It is Tohya's attempt to make the time after Beatrice's death more peaceful, and at the same time create a magical story of the reason why he lost his memory.
The same song says it "now that I have created this tale, you can rest in peace"
The beginning and the end overlap, this is the beginning of the story but it is the end point for the story that create battler.
Yes, just yes.
Beautiful
Imo the Best scene in fiction
Exactly. No other fictional scene can portray a tragedy this beautifully. It's a strange sensation, even with tears in my eyes I felt calm and a sublime grief in this scene
It's really touching
Peak fiction fr 👌🗿
@@anuradhamallick138 best part is, even after more than an year, it's damn melancholic and the feeling truly sticks forevermore.
Ongggg I just finished on Monday life will never be the same
SUBARASHI *BEATOVOICE*
Really symbolic
Kino
more please.
Ur wish is my command.
😢