Pakistani Journalist Jamil Khan’s Heart-Wrenching Interview
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 26 дек 2023
- #jamilkhan #arvindsaharan #pakistan #1947partition
In this episode we talk with Pakistani journalist Jamil Khan on the partition of India, his family’s struggle after moving to Pakistan and the state of Indian muslims.
More Videos by Arvind Saharan
Sarhad Ke Us Paar: • Sarhad Ke Us Paar
The ViewPoint: • The Viewpoint
The Partition of India: • The Partition of India
Follow me on:
RUclips: / arvindsaharan
Facebook: / arvindsaharanofficial
Twitter: / arvindsaharan84
An absolute pure gold of a session. This conversation between Jamil Khan Saab and Arvindji proves beyond words what visionary mind and intellect Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar possessed as he advocated partition to secure a developed and progressive India. We, Indians, are truly blessed as Babasaheb Ambedkar Saab headed the drafting committee to write our Constitution. Each and every Indian must listen to this conversation to have a better understanding of the political, social, and economic situation of present India. It is indeed an eye opener.
Thank you Arvindji, for your relentless effort to bring about enriching conversation among intellectual minds. 🙏May God bless you wih great health and more power in your quest to spread awareness. 🙏Jai Hind, jai Maa Bharthi. 🙏🇮🇳
P
Religious fanatics and extremist on the both sides of Indo-Pak border were brainwashed with fascistic mentality and mean-minded selfish tendencies to wish neighbors badluck ill-wishers .Nobility of old Indian civilization is lost with Indo-Pak partition.😮😮😢😮😮.
@saswatideb8828 - 100% Agree. The fact is Islam is not compatible with humanity. We can’t ignore the fact that Muslims don’t want to live in peace with non-Muslims. Proof: wherever Muslims are in majority, the life for non-Muslims is hell. And where Muslims are in minority they do their best to make life hell for non-Muslims, also for fellow Muslims. The history of Islam and Muslims must be a compulsory subject in every school in every non-Muslim countries. We must not shy away from speaking the facts.
1:22 1:23 😊
😊
I am thankful to my 'Dadi' who alone brought at the time of partition along with my two elder brothers aged 5years, and 3 years from Rohiri Sindh to okha port and stayed in camp for about a year until our father found through radio announcements. I was critical of my parents until I heard that Hindu Sindhis are living a miserable life. I am well settled in Mumbai and my life was smooth without any downs. I solute the then leaders because of them we had a chance to grow unhindered and getting scholarships while studying in engineering. I thought I should post this in contrast.
AMU me Aaj bhi bola jata hai
" Lad ke liya pakistan has ke lenge hindustan "
Aaj bhi AMU me jinnah ki tasvir hai
@@Public_Eye3Had you been to AMU?
@@khwajaasif1146 wahan saalo gujara hai
This interview must be shown on prime time of all national and regional media
Ham Khush hai musalmaan alag ho gaya.
Thanks for the discussion
❤
JAMIL KHANJI, MY HEAD BOWS TO YOU FOR SPEAKING THE TRUTH..I DON'T THINK ANY OTHER MUSLIM HAS SPOKEN SO FREELY & SINCERELY AS YOU.. YOU HAVE NOT BROUGHT ISLAM IN TO FORE LIKE ALL MUSLIM.. YOUR ARE REALLY A GEM.. WE NEED MORE SUCH PEOPLE TO SPEAK THE TRUTH..EVEN TODAY THE PEOPLE WHOM YOU HAVE NAMED & BLAMED HAVE NOT CHANGED IN INDIA. WITH SAME MIND SET.
❤
हाथ मे लौटा मुंह में पान लेकर रहेंगे पाकिस्तान ।। ये पाकिस्तान बना ही युपी और बिहारी मुस्लमानो के कारण।
लेकिन अधिकांश ऐसे यू.पी.-बिहार के लोग जिन्होंने पाकिस्तान बनाने की वक़ालत की, पाकिस्तान गए नहीं!
@@hiteshsaxena1553😂😂 yes gajwa ye hind kaise karenge agar chale gaye to
बंगाल भी काफी हद तक दोषी था पाकिस्तान बनने मे, हुसैन सुरावर्दी का अहम रोल रहा।
@@arupratanchakravarty7638लेकिन वे लोग कम से कम (पूर्वी) पाकिस्तान चले तो गए!
Half truth. Jab election hua to muslim league ko votes Kerala tak k Muslims ne diya.
Agree with him Even Hassan Nisar said that India would have been a greater power if all Muslims had been pushed out of India.
Absolutely with a cap A
😂😂
India would have been 1000 times better than what it is today
Abhi chance hai. There are refugee n India 🇮🇳
They destroy the economy of every place due to their backwardness, laziness, and violence. Yeh mehnati nahi hai. Aur humesha freebie ki talaash mein ya phir jhut moot loot. Inke leadraan bhi kabhi development ke kaam aur baath nahi karte ..Saari duniya mein yeh ek bhoj hai. Sirf maarkaat karna aur bacche banaana..
Anything founded on wrong principles, nurtured by hatred and lies can only lead to destruction.
❤
Right ye to hona he tha
First time I am listening to a Pakistani and or any Muslim to acknowledge the inherent decency of Hindu/ Sanatan dharam. Nice to hear a nice person
Dear Arvind ji, I am from Varanasi and Ordely Bazaar was established by Britishers. And that town is so developed right now that Mr. Jamil Khan will definitely take a long breath if he revisit this place. I am also Dr. Santosh Kumar of BHU, but not Santosh Bhaiya. Wonderful discussion. Very nicely explained by Mr. Jamil Sir.
It is Hinduism which has resulted in development of Bharat . Most of other religious people are engaged in increasing their population . Pakistan and Banladesh desh could not develop because they destroyed Hinduism in their countries .
True. People call it stupid argument but it is a fact. Hinduism and our principles are exactly why we are developing apart from ignoring their stupidity and problems that they create!
And due to Hinduism, Bharat became 'Gulam' .
karodo purvjo ko Youhi bhul Jayenge kya babar khilji ko Apna Parivar Hiro baap bana Dogle
@@vk-ht1vhthat is true because we did not believe in taking lives of people for a mere land .
Bilkul
जमील साहब की बातें सुनकर रोंगटे खड़े हो गए। किसी फिल्म की भांति सभी दृश्य आंखों से गुजर गए। मैं अपने गांवों से दूर रहता हूं, मुझे वहां की बहुत याद आती है ( हालांकि में गांव जाता रहता हूं) जमील साहब व उनके परिवार की तड़फ का अंदाजा लगा सकता हूं। बहुत अच्छा व दिल को छूने वाली बातें। जय हिंद
This conversation was compiled like a movie. I couldn’t realize that this 1 hour+ conversation done when it stopped. Sir Jamil Khan had also made every effort to picture the entire journey for his ancestors so well that no one deny the pain and dismay that the generations have felt and still lasting. God bless!
ऐसा कहने की हिम्मत की तारीफ है, लगताहै हिंदुस्तानी मुसलमान में अभी भी ऐसा सपना पाले है और कोई शर्म नहीं!!!
सर यह प्रोग्राम आपका सुनकर बहुत अच्छा लगा. So nice ❤
People from UP and Bengal are responsible for partition of India. They are in habit of partition . Bengalis separated from Pakistan and now these immigrants from India and called Muhajirs are struggling for further separation from Sindh. People are present Pakistan were not in favors of Partition. UPTIES are real responsible for partition.
You are absolutely right
Where a muslim is in majority....that place belongs to him alone...
Where he is in minorty it belongs to all.... Simple.
35:45
Friends we would really appreciate if you could please like, comment and share this program. 🙏🙏
Email: arvind.saharan084@gmail.com
Twitter: twitter.com/arvindsaharan84
❤❤🎉🎉
Arvind ji, Agar aap mere message ko padh rahe hai to aapse gujarish hai ki bataye "kya Pakistan me kuch Hindu Bramhan Families rahti hai ya vah sabhi Musalman ho gaye agar hai to Kahan hai aur kis halaat me hai". Ho sake to isper koi programe karen.
(2) dusra question hai "Kya Bharat ki Modi Goverment kabhi Pak Occupied Kashmir ko haasil kar payegi", Kripya ispar serious discussion Karen.
Jamil Khan Saheb ka dard aur khayalaat sunkar Dil andar se bhar aaya. Inhone Aaj ke Pakistan ki behad kadvi aur khaufnaak tasveer pesh ki. Inse punah rabtaa karen. Regards, 🙏🙂
हमने वीर बाल दिवस को धूमधाम से मनाया। इसपर भाजपाई नेहरू जी को डिक्टेटर बताने लगे, उनका कहना था कि खुद को 1957 में भारत रत्न देने वाला, सरकारी खर्चे पर अपना जन्मदिन मनवाने वाले का बाल दिवस से क्या संबंध? मेरा जवाब है कि माउंटबेटन का बालकों से प्रेम तो डाक्यूमेंटेड है, आप रिसर्च करो एडविन नेहरू का बालकों से प्रेम बाहर निकल आएगा।
What a torturous real story of suffering of people when india was divided. Thanks for bringing up 🙏
जमील साहब आप एकदम सभी बोल रहे हैं, यहाँ के मुस्लिम आज भी मदरसे ही खोल रहे है
Arvind you are the most big hearted person ever from the subcontinent
As of Pakistani origin I love your personality , style , compassionate heart , intelligence and demeanor
Brother you are the best !
Thank you so much.
I agree that with hindsight we can say that it is better that partition happened. My ancestors suffered but if partitioned would not have happened in 1947 generations would have suffered and still partition would have happened ultimately. With the mindset of majority muslims, partition was inevitable. The day muslims in India go beyond 25-30 be sure voices for partition will be raised again.
agree,we r better off with partition,
We are heading towards second partition
@RajaNSingh-ig5ywSahi kha brother, we Re heading towards another partition
We are already heading towards a second partition and balkanization because Hindus never learn from history and don't assert the moral power of Bhagvad Geeta to fight Adharma like what Sri Krishna taught..No wonder India has seen Adharma for last 1000 years
@@Eshaverma2957 second exodus will happen. Not partition. Exodus
भाई अगर मज़हब के नाम पर आप हिंदुस्तान छोड़कर गये तो आपको मज़हब ही तो मिलेगा, और वो भी एकदम made in pakistan, अब मयूस न हों, जन्नत मे जगह पक्की है
आर 72 हुरे शराब भी मिलेगी
बहुत खूब जले पर नमक तो है पर सच भी है कि जो चाहा वो मिला
अरे चले गए तो अच्छा हुआ यहां के मुस्लिम कौन सा भारत के प्रति सच्चे ही वो तो यहा शरिया लाना चाहते हैं।😮😢
Can see the pain of Jamil Khan jee. The decision taken by his ancestors has robbed the next generations unknowingly.
Two good points he made, one, probably the partition was better thing otherwise maybe there would have been fighting even now and secondly Indian Muslims are still poor because they are blindly following influential/politician/maulvi class who are only interested in their own good.
I wish Indian Muslims listen to this conversation.
It is always a pleasure to listen to your programmes
Jamil Khan Saheb ka dil se dard bhara interview atma ko jhakjhor gaya. Inhone aj ke Pakistan ki behad darawani tasveer pesh ki hai. Sachche insaan hai inse punah guftgoo karen.
People who supported Pakistan movement were people from UP & Bengal.
Punjab, Sindh, KP & Sind were fully Cong Constituency which never supported Pakistan Movement.
People who wanted Pakistan stayed back in India & people who did not want Pakistan got Pakistan.
Should these people send back to Pakistan because they already got.
Second partition on the cards and indian muslim will be started rising voice for another partition another time millions of people and family another loose there Every thing again
Pakistan ke halaat dekh kar koi aisa ni chahega
One of the best interview/conversation between 2 mature journalists. Enjoyed every second of it. Thanks
Ex Muslim Sahil and Adam Seeker are giving us hope for a better future. They are destroying the jehadi mindset in our Muslim fellow beings.
With due respect to the nationality-India loving Muslims who stay in India(& there is small but substantial number of such people..) I still think one of the biggest mistake was that India did not insist on complete exchange of population…now of course it’s may look like a meaningless thought..but remaining Muslims in India still have a very large percentage with same thoughts. This seems like an endless suffering for us Hindus…
Janab Jamil Sahab ki baten dil ki us gehrai se aa rahi he ki vo Rooh ko chhu rahi he. Aapki baton me hakikat or sachchai he.
Partition proved to be boon for Indian Prosperity..
I remember my colleague in highschool came from Pakistan. In 1971 war when our troops returned, many thousands migrated with those tanks - walking bare foot to Bharat from Sindh area.
what I am saying is - situation has not gone bad now, it has always been bad since 1947.
I was not knowing this thing, maybe others also not knowing about this .thanks for telling us this new fact .
Aravind you heard Jamil Khan due to partition only India progressed. Can you imagine, with 65cr Muslims and 85 cr Hindus in United India, we would have fighting each other. So please stop thinking of undoing of partition. As Major Arya says we should not have any relation with Pakistan. This is a common opinion. Muslims of India are hindering our progress. You should call Major Arya for discussion
We thank partition today we are going to be 3rd economy. 5 trillion soon and aiming for 8 trillion by 20 30 or 2034
Who are we to say ki kon kahan rehna chahiye… jiska jahan dana pani hoga wo wahin hoga… Muslims bhi insan hai aur unhe bhi rabb ne hi banaya jisne humein banaya
@@charurolvcharurolv9230agar aap logo ko maroge katoge to aapke sath bhi yhi hoga aage aage dekho pakistan k sath kya hota h
Jo हिन्दुओ k sath kiya h iske anjam bhugatne honge
Jo Mulk nafrat ki buniyad se Bana ho ush Mulk k log Kavi bhi Santi se rah nahi payega aaj Bangla Desh Pakistan k logo ko apna Desh me Santi se rahne nahi de raha hai har waqt Danga Atank failata rahta hai Jai hogi Sanatan Dharm aur Sanatanio ki 🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩 Bharat Mata ki Jai ❤️🇮🇳❤️🇮🇳❤️🇮🇳❤️🇮🇳❤️
Absolutely. Yehi toh shraap hai unn samajon par, ki woh kabhi bhi shaanti se reh nhi payenge. Naa jaane kitne Hinduon ki aah inko lagi hai aur inke aane waali naslon ko lagegi. Jaisa karoge, waise bhogoge. Prakriti ka yahi niyam hai.
Peaceful community spreading peace and harmony all over the world.
Khan sir is so very right looking at the hind side it was a blessing in disguise that Pakistan came into existence. We have progressed today because of the partition. Thank god.
Absolutely right Sir. Whatever we have endured has also made us move forward like a blessing in disguise.
The statement he said after 24:10
Kabaab ki dukaan badh rahi hai aur kitaab ki dukan khatm ho rhi hai.
Delhi is prime example
Feel proud of born in India 🇮🇳 how much pain has in in his interaction
So much insightful, eye opening ❤❤❤
Jamil Sahab is a gentle and very noble personality of Pakistan whose ancestors were Banarasi before independent in UP.Such personality many Pakistani have pain in heart of division of India.
I was certainly touched by this interview with Jamil sahib. Hope and pray that he can connect with his cousins and extended family in India 🙏
No thanks. His family should get out and settle in chuslimstan.
Well done Arvind bhai. I am so glad that my mom and dad who were married in Karachi left in 1947 and came to our mother India.
Very good interview.
Arvindbhai you are the DD1 of our generation, I wish someday your episodes are aired on Indian DD tv and Pakistani TV as well.
Thank you so much for this wonderful compliment Niranjan Ji.
could see sorrow and despair deep in host's heart, it was really heart-wrenching.
Jamil sahaib mai Lucknow UP se hu . Aap logo ki takleef sunkar bahut afsos hua. Hindustan nahi chorna chahiye tha. Bara hi khoobsurat mulk hai hamara Hindustan.
Is khubsurat desh ke tukde phir hone Wale he kyunki phir se shariya chahne Wale hijab burkha triple talaq halala gang active again
I can only say that Mr Jamil 's voice may be one among million Pakistanis.Whether a Muslim migrated to Pakistan or stayed back in India,their mentality generally remains same. For them Islam is everything and that is what has been pronounced by their intellectuals,leaders and scriptures. Irrespective of violent partition of our sacred motherland India is determined to march ahead and destined to regain it's lost glory. Thank U Mr Mahajan to conduct this session.
Jamil khan knows and understand what true Iman is...kudos to him for speaking absolute truth.
Jamil Saheb presented real statement of account of Pakistani mindset, ordeal of migrants and painful experiences, the backwardness of Pakistan still exist and fails to come to terms of modernity and prosperity..
An absorbing session conducted by Arvind Ji, my all sympathies for Jamil Saheb's ancestors who went to Pakistan and forcibly forbade them to return India..
Will extremists of both Nations learn the lessons from past mistakes and try to mend their ways ?
Answer is Big NO..
India is surviving and prospering due to its Hindu majority and it's kindness towards preserving humanity..
I saw first time a true honest Pakistani. Pranam Jamil Khan Saab.
As always very informative and sane discussion. Keep up the good work Arvind.
Thank you Arvindji for such an emotional conversation. Mr Khan was speaking with lots of sadness and emotions.
काश भारत से सारे मुस्लिम को पाकिस्तान ही भेज दिया जाता तो दोनों देश शुख शांति से रहते। या फिर बंटवारा ही ना होता
Fir india bhi bhikh mang rha hota fir ye bnaye hindu rastra fir brahman ko devta bnate vo mandir bnate or desh ko lut te
Ha bhai he log viras he 😂
मुहाजिर पाकिस्तान में सात की जगह तीस प्रतिशत होते तो पाकिस्तान टूट जाता 1965का युद्ध नही होता
Sare chle jate to besk india abtk superpower hota
But na jate to sara continent ab tk is kensr k chpet me aa chuka hota
Kensr likhney waley Bhai jinhey kensr kaha..... woh Cancer likhna jaanta hai dhanyavad 😂😂😂... Muzaffar Ali Khan
Thank you, Arvindbhai Saharan for this illuminating video showing history, politics, separation issues resulting from the partition. Continue pursuing this theme, history and pain.
Congratulations 👏👏 Jamil Saheb ❤
Very correct appraisal given about Indian Muslims by Jamil Saheb..
Thoughtful conversation ❤
Moved by Jamal sb heart felt story of migration and family experience.
A conversation that each Pakistani and Indian more so the Muslims must see and learn from it.
I hope India that is BHARAT becomes soooo rich and sooooo powerful then I want to hear Pakistanis stories 🤗🙏🇮🇳🌹
जो दुरसे तुफान का करते हैं नजारा
उनके लिये तुफान यहाँ भी हैं वहां भी
धारेमें जो मिल जाओगे तो बन जाओगे धारा
ये वक्तका ऐलान वहां भी यहाँ भी!..... Thanks for quoting this....I have been struggling to remember the last two lines since I saw गर्म हवा many decades ago.
Exmuslim jindabad. Exmuslim sahil and exmuslim Adam seeker are new nobi
Thank you very much Arvind ji ,for giving an opportunity to watch such an intellectual Pakistani. After listening how their grand parents,parents suffered because of partion very painful. Kitab ki nahin Kabab ki kimat thi . It is intrested to watch again.Saying is ,Aai Agg Len ban bethiGharwaali.
अरविंद जी ने कमाल की बात की है। हिंदुस्तान के इतिहास को साहित्य बना डाला है। शुक्रिया सर।
अपना तहेदिल से धन्यवाद शंभु प्रसाद जी। 🙏🙏
Brilliant video.
Thank you dear Arvindji.
You have done an extremely wonderful job by inviting Janab Jamil Khan saheb. It's really surprising to see the simplicity and innocent, unbiased opinion about Indian Muslims. How could his family survive in such a despicable situation in Pakistan.
Eagerly waiting for your next episode dear sir.
Thank you once again Arvindji.❤❤❤❤
Arvind bhai - long time supporter here. Have to say this is one of the most insightful episodes you have ever done! What a well sorted individual. We must have a few follow up conversations by popular demand. All the best to you and if I make it to NZ, would love to meet up with you.
Lovely. Such a simple but intense discussions
Arvind Bhai saab Ram Ram mujko aapka program esliye pasand hai ki aap details mai karte ho ❤❤❤
bharat me rahkar pakistan jindabad karne wale ye video jaroor dekhen
It is unbelievable to listen to this gentleman.
Rarely honest and informative video. Fully concur with Jamil Sahib, partition was good for India... would have been better if there could be a complete exchange of population is a planned and peaceful manner. It is difficult for a muslim to live peacefully even with muslim of other maslak.
Very lovely guest.Honest reporting. Garm Hawa, a classic film.
Jameel Sahab ko sunkar bht achchha laga . Sunata hi rah gaya . Oob nhi hui zara bhi . Aise vicharon k log bhi hain Pakistan me , jaankar beshumar khushi hui . Is tarah k vidvan aur log Pakistan me bhi hain , jaankar bht sukoon mila . Aise logon ko aar paar aate jate rahana chahiye. Bharat k musalmanon ko dhoort Congress ne baragalaaya aur bigaada hai .
Kabhi aakar dekhiye waqai hamara Hindustan bahut hi khoobsurat hai.
Excellent discussion. Very bright
Jamil KhanJi, you are a true gem of undivided India! Your story made me misty. I hope you can visit India and meet your relatives. Arvindji, thank you for this program, you are a great humanitarian.
Arvind, this session was an eye opener. Quite nice. The interviewee too was honest and i liked him a lot. Good work. 🎉
THANX ARVIND BHAI. I. AGREE WITH MR.KHAN. 100 % CORRECT.
Wonderful session, master of words, articulate and great poise, what style..... I am amazed,...without using harsh words, the sharp agony expressed... जमील sahab amazing...
wow what a session this was .....learnt a lot more about the problems in the society...
I fail to understand this superiority complex that people in Pakistan suffer from, very few people like this gentleman who are grounded and rooted in reality….probably because of education
That superiority complex is necessary to justify partition and ignore the flawed Islamic doctrine.
Arvind we should never give air to this thought that the partition of India was bad for Muslims as it divided them. This thought that undivided Muslims would have been a political power has at its root the same thought and idea that Muslims are different and must have a separate Nation. The correct and unprejudiced way would be to say that the partition caused great hardships to all on both sides.
Actually the correct thought on partition is Jamil Khan sahab who quotes Dr. Ambedkar. Islam is incompatible to live with any other.
Great respect for Jamil sahab.
Very rare pearls of histrical wisdom frm Jamil Khan. Perhaps the founder of his country shouldve had him as his aide and learnt from him. many of his blunders would have been avoided. Salute to this erudite gentleman.
Jamil Khan is an intrepid journalist and an enlightened person ❤
YOUR SESSIONS ARE ALWAYS A ROLLERCOASTER FOR ME ... THANK YOU ARVIND
Rulaa diya bhai sahab ney. Aur khush bhi kiya ki hum bach gaye... or else Lanka would've 'dhao-fiited'. Appreciado y muchas gracias senor Arvind.
Thank you arvind ji
Thanks Arvind, to bring such a nice human and true intellectual person from Pakistan
It’s one of your best interview,hatts off to Mr Jamil for such free and honest admission of narrative of Pakistan elite. 🙏
Dear Arivind ji I have been watching your videos since long. Such a pleasure to watch them a lot of research you do and the guests you bring enriching experience for me. Best wishes.
Very enlightened person.
True approval of Baba Saheb,s version by Zamil Khan and u , regards
India should award BHARAT RATNA for Jinnah for taking half kachra.
वाकई जमील साहब निहायत जहीन व बेहद रोशनखयाल शख्शियत है निहायत ही समझदार दयावान व साफ बोलने वाले इंसान हैं। जमील साहब ने निहायत ही साफगोई से सारी बातें बताई व स्वीकार भी की। ऐसे इंसान कम ही है दुनिया में जो इतनी साफदिली से सारी बातें कहे।।
❤❤Arvind ji 🙏. I am ur regular viewer of ur videos, it's always nice to see ❤❤.
Yah saheb to bahut Himmat wale aur Islam ki Sachi bolne ki Himmat rakhte hain. All the best enko
Rula diya ajto apne arvind bhai
This is a great guest. Would love to hear him on your show again.
अरविंद भाई जमील साहब से एक दो बार और चर्चा का कार्यक्रम रखिए। वाकई आज की चर्चा बहुत ही सार्थक और खूबसूरत रही।
ਬਹੁਤ ਵਧੀਆਂ ਗੱਲ-ਬਾਤ
Very touching talk .
Never came to such story.
It is such a candid unbiased narration by Jamil Kahan about life in Pakistan with Arvindji. I feel this discussion should be told to all people in India. State of Pakistan and its
General public who is suffering the most. What has Pakistan gained making an Islamic country? What are their achievements since the birth Pakistan for past 75 years.