"After gandhi's death fundamentalism was kept at bay by the able leadership of congress" Tell that to the chitpavan brahmins of maharashtra whose houses were burnt and who were forced to run away to other states after the assassination. The fact that he does not even mention this!
First of all india is a civilizational state not a country. Where a tamilian is just different from a Bengali as a gujurati is from Punjabi. Hindi, Regional and Cosmopolitan. Are the three identities that every Indian shares.
He studied at St Stephens College, Delhi University. Never at JNU. Also he's just being honest,not speaking ill. Sometimes you have to hear the hard truth.
This speech provides valuable insights into the minds of the currently displaced homeless Indian elites. Upon careful analysis, it becomes apparent that they viewed India as an experimental ground. They perceived it as a laboratory where they could conduct research and gather data for the benefit of a global governance in the future. This realization is truly unsettling. Modi's main focus is to foster a sovereign and self-respecting nation for the Hindu community, who have faced historical challenges and persecution over the course of centuries. However, the priorities of these elites have consistently centered around using India as a potential model for future global governance due to its remarkable diversity. When they express their strong opposition to Modi, it suggests that they feel their experimental platform has been disrupted. It is understandable that globalists like Soros took this as a personal matter.
@@rishavkumar1250 What's your point??? Do you think I should take their side because of their castes??? What exactly are you trying to say here??? Did my one Thumb (👍) upset you to this much Rishav that you will address me with my last name and try to make some imaginary connection ???
@@rishidevsharma6026 No my friend. You did not understand his point at all. He said that these intellectuals despite being brahmins never spare a moment to attack hindu culture and hindu belief system and mindlessly bootlicking their Western Masters who want entire India to bow down before them and accept the hegemony of US. I am a brahmin too. I am ashamed of it. Ramachandra Guha, Arundhati Roy, Burkha Dutt are all brahmins who have never every stood by hindus. Compare this with muslims. A muslim intellectual how much ever well read will never attack his own religion. Thats the difference
Let's be realistic. India will never be a developed country in it's lifetime. Even if India grows, it will get stuck in the middle income trap forever. India will also face major resource shortage due to overpopulation and face the wrath of climate change. India's resource base isn't large enough to support an economy too large either. Also the West and China can sabotage India in a jiffy if it grows too much. Also most Indians don't have unity and are still backward minded and tribalistic. Corruption and being unethical has become so deep rooted that it's become impossible to fix it. Also, the number of talented Indians leaving India is increasing at an alarming rate every year and many of these Indians who left India brag about India being the next big thing which is extremely comedic. The most mind boggling thing is that even if God comes down from heaven and says that India will never be a developed country, pa jeets will call him anti Indian and continue living in their fantasy of India being a developed country. Moreover, countries that actually became developed bragged less and did more. India brags more and does less. To conclude, India may improve in some areas, but it always stay a corrupt 3rd world uncivilized sh8hole. Hence, forget your dreams of being a developed country pa jeets. India is an utterly failed experiment. Adios
*1:02:09** 10 challenges India face* 1) Left wing Maoist insurgency 2) Right wing Religious fundamentalism 3) Decline in Political parties: dynasty/family firms 4) Degradation of Public Institutions 5) Growing inequalities of Rich and poor 6) Rapid pace of environmental degradation 7) Declining Independence of Media 8) Political fragmentation 9) Unsettled borders 10) Unstable neighborhood (Pakistan)
I bet India's former colonial master Britain was both surprised and disappointed that India managed to hold together. At least until this point. Not allowing Britain to further taken advantage of its former colonial slaves.
With the blessing of Shri Ram,no matter what ,India will be the superpower and antinationals,and paid speakers who like to speak against their own country for penny money will be punished 🤘🤘🤘
@@donniedarko5574okk Oxford elite Macaulay Son now read anything behind their. owner okk .Bharat become powerful also Bhartiya lifestyle like vegetarian help to curb this environment and unemployment poverty problem .
Very realistic, but portrayal or BJP in a negative tone was cynical. I think amidst these scams, Gujarat is the only state that stands out as a progressive and developed state whith a high Human development Index and GDP.
Thoughts and actions of such naive peaceniks led to the partition of India and defeat against belligerant China. West is trying to prevent the rise of India. India should follow the advice of Chanakya and not naive thinkers.
@@runnerboys9277 Yes Millions of Indians Coping More After Leaving Indian Citizenship After Settling in Other Developed in Like USA, Canada and UK 😂🤣 Because They Know That Quality of Education and Living Standard Will Never Improve in India
Let's be realistic. India will never be a developed country in it's lifetime. Even if India grows, it will get stuck in the middle income trap forever. India will also face major resource shortage due to overpopulation and face the wrath of climate change. India's resource base isn't large enough to support an economy too large either. Also the West and China can sabotage India in a jiffy if it grows too much. Also most Indians don't have unity and are still backward minded and tribalistic. Corruption and being unethical has become so deep rooted that it's become impossible to fix it. Also, the number of talented Indians leaving India is increasing at an alarming rate every year and many of these Indians who left India brag about India being the next big thing which is extremely comedic. The most mind boggling thing is that even if God comes down from heaven and says that India will never be a developed country, pa jeets will call him anti Indian and continue living in their fantasy of India being a developed country. Moreover, countries that actually became developed bragged less and did more. India brags more and does less. To conclude, India may improve in some areas, but it always stay a corrupt 3rd world uncivilized sh8hole. Hence, forget your dreams of being a developed country pa jeets. India is an utterly failed experiment. Adios
A great lecture by Prof. Guha. Though he didn't give any substantial arguments on why India shouldn't be a superpower apart from a few abstract and insignificant indication of having cultural influence rather than military and economic and "India of the dreams of Gandhi and other leaders during independence". I think India should become a superpower to immunize itself from outer influence and intrusion as it has historically been victim of attacks of intolerant and ruthless powers. We can't make a prosperous, happy and inclusive society if someone country/institution/person is able to create misinformation, conflict or suppress Indian interest. Though our goal should be to ensure fulfilment to last person in the society. But definitely agree with statement on "Wealthy should try to support people on margins rather than just become the richest in some record book or buying the political party's support"
all indian politicianss hav to hear this 1000000000000 timesss and beee ashamed of wat they did to ancient gaint and peace loving my INDIA.....i warn uuu politicians tat dont let the dream of millions of youth like mee am 23....jai hind
R C Guha is 100% correct. We Hindu believe in rebirth / In my next birth I never ever want to be an #Indian. I never understood till 14/08/47 we were actually #slave. Just one day later suddenly #Slaves become the selectors of Ruler. From Jurassic period to 15/08/47 India was always a kingdom. King may be Hindu / Muslim/ Christian but there was a king. There was no #nehruvian democracy.
You are frustrated man. You don't know what you are saying. All my comments are backed by facts. You only read in school what made you in better position. You skipped rest of the lessons or may be you were not taught well.
There may be 10 or more than 10 reasons why India will not be a superpower but there are 2 proved reasons for which definitely India shall be a superpower. India have never attacked any neighbouring country be it small or large and helped bangladesh(east pak) and then after never took disadvantage of it. Is it not one of the traits of being a Leader who never suppresses its counter parts?. But thanks to the gentleman as all the 10 points he said are true and our govt. & we citizens needs to work on it. Good video
Good and honest speech/points from this Indian Historian... However good god, he was throwing down that water, must have been at least a few dozen times..... Also another point he missed, is India is a highly heterogeneous people, with different cultures/languages etc, as well as overpopulation.
He has repeated same speech in New York university, Boston university and other universities too. There he mentioned about heterogeneity in India. I think it slipped from his mind.
Academia has such vacuous discussions. Being a long term academic in a core scientific field, I am ashamed that the same university gives a roof to such vacuous idiots. I think some departments must simply be abolished. They simply create a nuisance in society and culture, without offering any solutions at all.
@invictussingh it happened everywhere dude, I am not going to defend the killings but being a practical guy, I am simply going to say, it was an event in history that was needed for Gujarat to reach there. Like Indo Pak divide, like WW2, like WW1, like the falling of Berlin War. It was an event in history. You can keep saying that murder of Jews was wrong but that shaped the freedom of India, end of colonialism. The fall of Berlin Wall started the idea of EUROPE and trade relations improved. etc
"What The Ancients Knew - India (Discovery Channel Documentary)": Search on RUclips. Indian math was more advanced than Chinese and Greeks. Indian math was taken to Arabs(By Hindu travellers) then it reached Greeks. What Greeks discovered was discovered by Indians centuries before. Aryans invasion theory western propaganda. 1st they claimed aryans invaded harapan civilization, when they found no proof, they switched to migration. Now both are disapproved. I tried hard enuf to educate you. Enough
@@TheSrijitMajumder maoist insurgency still active, akali dal still active, hindu muslim tension are still high, corruption is all time high, hindu fanaticism is on the rise, unemployment is very high, his pretty much accurate on all of his point.
@@TheBorz0I think you studies in Somalia University .WhatsApp University better then somalian University .Maoist insurgency decreased .Due to increase in education standard corruption decrease .Mr Guha Western system was one of the biggest reason Indian govt official is corrupt .Hindu Muslim tension increase if they follow your propoganda to divide Bharat .
I am quite impressed by your talk. challenges you put forward are quite enlightening. So by your logic for india to be superpower, we have to tackle these challenges. I hope my fellow indians understood it..............
A very Negative and Pessimistic Narrative but nonetheless true and bitter........ I am Indian and I am not proud of the things he said... but The Prime Minister did visit Kashmir to inaugurate the Railway system in the valley...the first of its kind there since Independence.
@ROHITVIJAYSHARMA I guess you intend to buy (may be already did) "India after Gandhi". You will enjoy the book for sure. I can't wait to buy his most recent one - Makers of Modern India - releasing in March.
Inki maa baap ko ek prashna puchna chahata hu WO inki janma keliye kab mile the, aise log isliye paida hote hai galat samay me mile toh.aise soch rakhanewale sab ko yahi prashna hai mera.apne hi desh ko barbaad karnewalonko.
This man is not "one of India's most important voices" by even a stretch, he is just Nehru/ Gandhi worshiper who was in the good books of Dynasty. The Guha dinosaur will vanish into the time oblivion soon
@invictussingh Dude, don't make antagonize me. All I wanted to say was BJP can bring about an economic turnaround and more systematic management of affairs. No one is taking away the allegations from Modi & Co. but remember they are still allegations.
Submerged city of dwarka was the work of Graham Hancock, a journalist wanna-be archaeologist. He claimed he discovered Atlantis too, LOL. Atlantis!?!?! LOL. Indus valley was the earliest in South Asia but it died. Your civilization starts with vedic aryan civilization.
@@VINNUSAURUS Arreah Thats True only India's GDP Per Capita is $2,600 With The Population of 1.4 Billion ( Among Top 5 Economics ) IMF Warned About India's Increasing Debt When Compared to India's Economic Growth And India is Prone For Many Disasters During Upcoming Years
@@ThePJExperienceNo they only want to see read Maculay brainwash colonial western Marxist education .Bharat not consume or want to become modern like west where half of population live in Sleep pill .
You find facts in your dreams just like your claim that India made the first move in 1962. Indian forces were not even in the conflict area. They went later and due to too low time to acclimatize they suffered. In 1967, China did same, but then Indian army made them retreat.
Everywhere civilization had some form of inventions, compare yours with Greco_roman and Chinese, you'll know how backwards yours is in terms of inventions,
False always sweet ,it give diabtese .You in the ways to become Mad .Second your dream to make whole BHARAT as Abrahmic Marxist Capitalist state never ever happen .Only some JNU Colombia Oxford pupil follow your propoganda .
@kingdomofloss1 In all cases of mass murder in India no big gun has ever been convicted by law, that does not mean that that they are innocent. There can be no lasting prosperity without law and order.
@invictussingh There is always such issues. Which US president has not done the same, except Obama. I think BJP had a big role to play in the Massacre, surely they did. but the development cannot be overlooked.
@@lazypops3117 I Love it when Jesusites talk about values and decency something they know enough cause they built Lies and Deceits upon it. You are of No interest or consequence to me and this nation. RCG is an excellent example of how to use relate-able world happenings wrapped in intelligent sounding self serving statements spiced with blatant lies to make the listener accept the whole deliverance as Truth. Except for Selling Lies Slipped into innocuous statements, he is nothing.
11 лет назад
Haha, can't hide truth for long. Check here: globalsecurity(dot)org/military/world/war/indo-pak_1947(dot)htm Read the 6th & 11th para. Clearly describes how u idiots sent troops & did mayham, looting & raping women. Some of the women who had been raped are STILL ALIVE in Kashmir btw. See 9th para which clearly says India refused to help - and said we cannot intervene since Kashm is not part of India.
@kingdomofloss1 just browse pictures of roasted and burnt children corpses relate to 2002 massacre. Then imagine your child in that state. The great BJP leader of your state endorsed it. What a shining example of progress.
Based. But sadly BJP is a cucked party and doesn't have a spine to do it. Whatever response to Godhra in the form of the Gujarat retaliation of 2002 was done by the common Gujarati Hindu populace.
India Will Never Become Developed Country 🥴 India's GDP Per capita income is Low With Just a GDP Per capita of $2,250 And Its a Fact Reason:Over Population It Will Take Another 30-40 Years For India to Reach China's Current Economic State Even If This Happened Then India Would Still be a Middle Class Country With GDP Per capita of 15,500 with The Population of 1.70 Billion China Currently Has GDP Per capita of $12,200 But Still it Regarded as Upper Middle Class Country 🥴
"After gandhi's death fundamentalism was kept at bay by the able leadership of congress"
Tell that to the chitpavan brahmins of maharashtra whose houses were burnt and who were forced to run away to other states after the assassination. The fact that he does not even mention this!
It is responsiblity of victims to tell stories,not opresers
@@mandar9000how would they ?
Sikhs, Brahmins, ALL Hindus suffered so, so much under the Left yoke.
The map behind the speaker says it all about the hypocrisy and vacuity of this discourse.
Just noticed rofl. Tells you how shameless is is Gooha type elites who just know how to serve their over lords.
The map itself omits India and describes the West😂
It is shameful that there was a time when people like him were setting the narrative for my country
First of all india is a civilizational state not a country.
Where a tamilian is just different from a Bengali as a gujurati is from Punjabi.
Hindi, Regional and Cosmopolitan. Are the three identities that every Indian shares.
It’s because he is right, and people like you have drunk the kool-aid of stupid bjp narrative. India will never be a global super power.
India is still a shithole. He is right
agreed...
Its also shameful there was a time when there were nation builders in charge not delusional religious fanatics.
Why most of the JNU products talk ill of India.
He studied at St Stephens College, Delhi University.
Never at JNU.
Also he's just being honest,not speaking ill.
Sometimes you have to hear the hard truth.
@Rahul Hari yeah we have become a fucking superpower right
@Rahul Hari india is a shithole , jitna jaldi samajh jao utna behtar (ma pakistani nhi hun , aur na muslim hu )
commitment to humanitarian values and decency does not mean talking ill.
I think because they are honestly speaking.
Mr guha is talking truth ,but many of us do not want hear the truth
Then what is with the "Must not'
@@jishnu9551exactly
This speech provides valuable insights into the minds of the currently displaced homeless Indian elites. Upon careful analysis, it becomes apparent that they viewed India as an experimental ground. They perceived it as a laboratory where they could conduct research and gather data for the benefit of a global governance in the future. This realization is truly unsettling.
Modi's main focus is to foster a sovereign and self-respecting nation for the Hindu community, who have faced historical challenges and persecution over the course of centuries. However, the priorities of these elites have consistently centered around using India as a potential model for future global governance due to its remarkable diversity. When they express their strong opposition to Modi, it suggests that they feel their experimental platform has been disrupted. It is understandable that globalists like Soros took this as a personal matter.
😂
👍
@@rishidevsharma6026 guess what sharma???
Most of these elites were sharmas and Singhs
@@rishavkumar1250 What's your point???
Do you think I should take their side because of their castes???
What exactly are you trying to say here???
Did my one Thumb (👍) upset you to this much Rishav that you will address me with my last name and try to make some imaginary connection ???
@@rishidevsharma6026
No my friend. You did not understand his point at all. He said that these intellectuals despite being brahmins never spare a moment to attack hindu culture and hindu belief system and mindlessly bootlicking their Western Masters who want entire India to bow down before them and accept the hegemony of US. I am a brahmin too. I am ashamed of it. Ramachandra Guha, Arundhati Roy, Burkha Dutt are all brahmins who have never every stood by hindus. Compare this with muslims. A muslim intellectual how much ever well read will never attack his own religion. Thats the difference
India will become superpower no matter what you like it was in Ancient times
In Dreams
With Overpopulation
It Will Never Happen
Let's be realistic. India will never be a developed country in it's lifetime. Even if India grows, it will get stuck in the middle income trap forever. India will also face major resource shortage due to overpopulation and face the wrath of climate change. India's resource base isn't large enough to support an economy too large either. Also the West and China can sabotage India in a jiffy if it grows too much. Also most Indians don't have unity and are still backward minded and tribalistic. Corruption and being unethical has become so deep rooted that it's become impossible to fix it. Also, the number of talented Indians leaving India is increasing at an alarming rate every year and many of these Indians who left India brag about India being the next big thing which is extremely comedic. The most mind boggling thing is that even if God comes down from heaven and says that India will never be a developed country, pa jeets will call him anti Indian and continue living in their fantasy of India being a developed country. Moreover, countries that actually became developed bragged less and did more. India brags more and does less. To conclude, India may improve in some areas, but it always stay a corrupt 3rd world uncivilized sh8hole. Hence, forget your dreams of being a developed country pa jeets. India is an utterly failed experiment.
Adios
HAHAHA
India is a shithole.
My friend if india was a such a big superpower then why it can't stop so many invasions you are so delusional
*1:02:09** 10 challenges India face*
1) Left wing Maoist insurgency
2) Right wing Religious fundamentalism
3) Decline in Political parties: dynasty/family firms
4) Degradation of Public Institutions
5) Growing inequalities of Rich and poor
6) Rapid pace of environmental degradation
7) Declining Independence of Media
8) Political fragmentation
9) Unsettled borders
10) Unstable neighborhood (Pakistan)
And BJP has made these problems worse
we lost this battle and this project of india is doomed to fail now
@@siliconcore Yes. Now f*ck off from India and keep your filthy opinion out of this country.
@@Arjun.Trivedi how? By making india 5th largest economy? And one of the fastest growing ones after covid? U guys just can't stop hating...
@@abhr74 he is taking lessons from WhatsApp University bro
I bet India's former colonial master Britain was both surprised and disappointed that India managed to hold together. At least until this point. Not allowing Britain to further taken advantage of its former colonial slaves.
You are still slave whether you like it or not but you are
But it’s not so….India view Britain in rear view mirror and hate them viscerally
With the blessing of Shri Ram,no matter what ,India will be the superpower and antinationals,and paid speakers who like to speak against their own country for penny money will be punished 🤘🤘🤘
India is already a supapawar saaaar i read in WhatsApp saaar
@@donniedarko5574 😂🤣
@@donniedarko5574okk Oxford elite Macaulay Son now read anything behind their. owner okk .Bharat become powerful also Bhartiya lifestyle like vegetarian help to curb this environment and unemployment poverty problem .
Very realistic, but portrayal or BJP in a negative tone was cynical. I think amidst these scams, Gujarat is the only state that stands out as a progressive and developed state whith a high Human development Index and GDP.
What do you have to say now?
@@karumotoart5040 doin great. better than ever. thanks to bjp we might have a chance of becoming a super power in next 20 years.
@@karumotoart5040 which world do you stay ??
@@amrithMilW I'm not even alive
This didn't age well
Thoughts and actions of such naive peaceniks led to the partition of India and defeat against belligerant China. West is trying to prevent the rise of India. India should follow the advice of Chanakya and not naive thinkers.
India Will Never Become Developed Country Due to Over population
india is on the path to become supr power . 🗿
In Your Dreams 🤣
Stop Living in Parallel World
India Will Never Become Developed Country
@@KAN443 Cope more 😂😂
@@runnerboys9277 Yes Millions of Indians Coping More After Leaving Indian Citizenship After Settling in Other Developed in Like USA, Canada and UK 😂🤣
Because They Know That Quality of Education and Living Standard Will Never Improve in India
Let's be realistic. India will never be a developed country in it's lifetime. Even if India grows, it will get stuck in the middle income trap forever. India will also face major resource shortage due to overpopulation and face the wrath of climate change. India's resource base isn't large enough to support an economy too large either. Also the West and China can sabotage India in a jiffy if it grows too much. Also most Indians don't have unity and are still backward minded and tribalistic. Corruption and being unethical has become so deep rooted that it's become impossible to fix it. Also, the number of talented Indians leaving India is increasing at an alarming rate every year and many of these Indians who left India brag about India being the next big thing which is extremely comedic. The most mind boggling thing is that even if God comes down from heaven and says that India will never be a developed country, pa jeets will call him anti Indian and continue living in their fantasy of India being a developed country. Moreover, countries that actually became developed bragged less and did more. India brags more and does less. To conclude, India may improve in some areas, but it always stay a corrupt 3rd world uncivilized sh8hole. Hence, forget your dreams of being a developed country pa jeets. India is an utterly failed experiment.
Adios
India is a shithole.
A great lecture by Prof. Guha. Though he didn't give any substantial arguments on why India shouldn't be a superpower apart from a few abstract and insignificant indication of having cultural influence rather than military and economic and "India of the dreams of Gandhi and other leaders during independence".
I think India should become a superpower to immunize itself from outer influence and intrusion as it has historically been victim of attacks of intolerant and ruthless powers. We can't make a prosperous, happy and inclusive society if someone country/institution/person is able to create misinformation, conflict or suppress Indian interest. Though our goal should be to ensure fulfilment to last person in the society.
But definitely agree with statement on "Wealthy should try to support people on margins rather than just become the richest in some record book or buying the political party's support"
He is just not feel good seeing praise for India as he is western Ass kisser
Great lecture gandu he says India should not become a superpower and u are saying it is great 😂😂😂😂 pee paa ke baitha hai kya
India will become a superpower.
After 7 years, someone has liked your comment and he is inspired to make it happen!
@@chessmania8152 it will take more 7 years lol
🤜🇮🇳
All it can be is poopdia 😅😅😅😹😹😹
@@nitaseely6830 you indian?
all indian politicianss hav to hear this 1000000000000 timesss and beee ashamed of wat they did to ancient gaint and peace loving my INDIA.....i warn uuu politicians tat dont let the dream of millions of youth like mee am 23....jai hind
Can we talk? - +918668240047
Change these politician .No change this British system and your weakness .okk
R C Guha is 100% correct.
We Hindu believe in rebirth / In my next birth I never ever want to be an #Indian.
I never understood till 14/08/47 we were actually #slave. Just one day later suddenly #Slaves become the selectors of Ruler.
From Jurassic period to 15/08/47 India was always a kingdom. King may be Hindu / Muslim/ Christian but there was a king.
There was no #nehruvian democracy.
'India's most imp voices '😆 🤣
You are frustrated man. You don't know what you are saying. All my comments are backed by facts. You only read in school what made you in better position. You skipped rest of the lessons or may be you were not taught well.
Deliberation has few gaps but definitely worth the time.
ramchandra is overahadowed by young thinkers like sai deepakak..minakshi jains..sanyal..bikram sampat and so on...
There may be 10 or more than 10 reasons why India will not be a superpower but there are 2 proved reasons for which definitely India shall be a superpower. India have never attacked any neighbouring country be it small or large and helped bangladesh(east pak) and then after never took disadvantage of it. Is it not one of the traits of being a Leader who never suppresses its counter parts?. But thanks to the gentleman as all the 10 points he said are true and our govt. & we citizens needs to work on it. Good video
Attackers countries always become super powerful go read the history brother...
Thata because you never been taught history right, India has captured many territories ever since 1947. How do you think it got bigger
@@TheBorz0 take some protein your brain is malfunctioning
Guha fulfilling his name while shitting going around everywhere showing his deep rooted hatred of the place he belongs to.
Good and honest speech/points from this Indian Historian... However good god, he was throwing down that water, must have been at least a few dozen times.....
Also another point he missed, is India is a highly heterogeneous people, with different cultures/languages etc, as well as overpopulation.
HE smokes marijuana and needs coffee to keep his thirst under control.
He has repeated same speech in New York university, Boston university and other universities too. There he mentioned about heterogeneity in India. I think it slipped from his mind.
I dia Don have different cultural
Perfectly put He Anti Indian Self Obsessed Critic
Academia has such vacuous discussions. Being a long term academic in a core scientific field, I am ashamed that the same university gives a roof to such vacuous idiots. I think some departments must simply be abolished. They simply create a nuisance in society and culture, without offering any solutions at all.
Yes they create nuisance only nuisance .
@invictussingh it happened everywhere dude, I am not going to defend the killings but being a practical guy, I am simply going to say, it was an event in history that was needed for Gujarat to reach there. Like Indo Pak divide, like WW2, like WW1, like the falling of Berlin War. It was an event in history. You can keep saying that murder of Jews was wrong but that shaped the freedom of India, end of colonialism. The fall of Berlin Wall started the idea of EUROPE and trade relations improved. etc
India's feeble babus and netas ensure India never rises at all - so what is all that debate(s) for?
Wow you understood that 9 years ago, I find that many Indians today won’t even know this simple fact.
He chose his quotes so it's his words .
After 14 years, india is going to become the next somalia.
In your house and your dream .Bharat rises and become Bharat where your owner Arabic Irani Brit want to come .Discovery new way to reach Bharat .
This lecture is invalid. We have people who will stop all kinds of growth here.
"What The Ancients Knew - India (Discovery Channel Documentary)": Search on RUclips. Indian math was more advanced than Chinese and Greeks. Indian math was taken to Arabs(By Hindu travellers) then it reached Greeks. What Greeks discovered was discovered by Indians centuries before. Aryans invasion theory western propaganda. 1st they claimed aryans invaded harapan civilization, when they found no proof, they switched to migration. Now both are disapproved. I tried hard enuf to educate you. Enough
Good joke 😂😂😂
@@subzero4119Reality always look like joke for Alcoholic like you .
To Guha- India will become a superpower.
In dreams or after mass extinction
Come on u got to agree on atleast one thing that these ppl make u patriotic.
11 year but still so much relevant..
True 🤣😂
But Many Indians Refusing to Accept it
Wonderful Clown show 🤡🤡🤡🤡
She got offended 😂 don't tell them truth they just want to live life in their fantasy land superpower lund saaar😂😂
Do you have more credentials to say these guys are wrong?
'विश्र्वगुरू भारत' translate this.
Cut the crap. Talk starts at 0:12:30
Buddy are you still around? It's been 12 years
Well well his prediction didn't last long
Bol toh aise rahe jaise india superpower बन चुका hai 😂😂😂
@@rishavkumar1250 bhai super shayad hua nahi but power to hai hum.
Why not exude more confidence and approach?
@@TheSrijitMajumder maoist insurgency still active, akali dal still active, hindu muslim tension are still high, corruption is all time high, hindu fanaticism is on the rise, unemployment is very high, his pretty much accurate on all of his point.
@@TheBorz0I think you studies in Somalia University .WhatsApp University better then somalian University .Maoist insurgency decreased .Due to increase in education standard corruption decrease .Mr Guha Western system was one of the biggest reason Indian govt official is corrupt .Hindu Muslim tension increase if they follow your propoganda to divide Bharat .
@@abhinavsharma1104 whatever, india is still a gr4pe and cancer capital of the world.
I am quite impressed by your talk. challenges you put forward are quite enlightening. So by your logic for india to be superpower, we have to tackle these challenges. I hope my fellow indians understood it..............
Can we talk? - +918668240047
A very Negative and Pessimistic Narrative but nonetheless true and bitter........
I am Indian and I am not proud of the things he said...
but The Prime Minister did visit Kashmir to inaugurate the Railway system in the valley...the first of its kind there since Independence.
@ROHITVIJAYSHARMA
I guess you intend to buy (may be already did) "India after Gandhi". You will enjoy the book for sure.
I can't wait to buy his most recent one - Makers of Modern India - releasing in March.
Inki maa baap ko ek prashna puchna chahata hu WO inki janma keliye kab mile the, aise log isliye paida hote hai galat samay me mile toh.aise soch rakhanewale sab ko yahi prashna hai mera.apne hi desh ko barbaad karnewalonko.
the second guy sounds like john malkovich
This man is not "one of India's most important voices" by even a stretch, he is just Nehru/ Gandhi worshiper who was in the good books of Dynasty. The Guha dinosaur will vanish into the time oblivion soon
India will become superpower and would shut desh drohis like guha, shame on him.
Deshbhakti ka Nasha afeem se bhi bhayankar hai
India Will Never Become Developed Country 🥴
Due to over Population
Jail him, taking indian currency out of India is illegal 😂
@invictussingh Dude, don't make antagonize me. All I wanted to say was BJP can bring about an economic turnaround and more systematic management of affairs. No one is taking away the allegations from Modi & Co. but remember they are still allegations.
Astute predictions
Submerged city of dwarka was the work of Graham Hancock, a journalist wanna-be archaeologist. He claimed he discovered Atlantis too, LOL. Atlantis!?!?! LOL.
Indus valley was the earliest in South Asia but it died. Your civilization starts with vedic aryan civilization.
And now we have economic crises in UK stabilised by an British Indian Rishi Sunan.😂😂😂😂
Maybe we will hav a Scotland 😂😂😂
UK is Already a Developed Country Unlike India
@@KAN443are you a britan ?
@@VINNUSAURUS Arreah
Thats True only
India's GDP Per Capita is $2,600 With The Population of 1.4 Billion
( Among Top 5 Economics )
IMF Warned About India's Increasing Debt When Compared to India's Economic Growth
And India is Prone For Many Disasters During Upcoming Years
"Flavour of the month"? David Malone clearly isn't a very erudite or scholarly man. He sounds peevish and judgmental.
Its really good!!!....give it a shot
It's a shame that not even a million Indians have seen this
INdeed , all they want to see is false glorification and pat themselves on the back for mob lynching
@@ThePJExperienceNo they only want to see read Maculay brainwash colonial western Marxist education .Bharat not consume or want to become modern like west where half of population live in Sleep pill .
Gandhi was western pet
Whole indians were western pet
@gokulmb who are you what are you famous for.
I think Mr. Guha deserved a standing ovation at the end of this insightful talk.
SIck man Mr. Guha is.
You find facts in your dreams just like your claim that India made the first move in 1962. Indian forces were not even in the conflict area. They went later and due to too low time to acclimatize they suffered. In 1967, China did same, but then Indian army made them retreat.
Hahahahah gaand mara WhatsApp university
wont seems bilateral thinking.
Everywhere civilization had some form of inventions, compare yours with Greco_roman and Chinese, you'll know how backwards yours is in terms of inventions,
Rambling on and on and on and on and on..?
Truth always bitter, it hurts. But truth is truth. India is on its way to become somalia
False always sweet ,it give diabtese .You in the ways to become Mad .Second your dream to make whole BHARAT as Abrahmic Marxist Capitalist state never ever happen .Only some JNU Colombia Oxford pupil follow your propoganda .
@kingdomofloss1 In all cases of mass murder in India no big gun has ever been convicted by law, that does not mean that that they are innocent.
There can be no lasting prosperity without law and order.
good great , lot to learn
@invictussingh There is always such issues. Which US president has not done the same, except Obama. I think BJP had a big role to play in the Massacre, surely they did. but the development cannot be overlooked.
All Jargons and nothing of substance
He is not to good to discuss with.
he has a throat problem known as laryngitis..
u better be happy to have a privilege of listening to him
Full of rhetoric..!!
MY MY This Guy is "EMINENT" - He is just a Story Teller with nothing to add from his own grey material
humanitarian values and decency are not hindu for you? you want a competitive nationalistic machocistic pride. how will the lord forgive you?
@@lazypops3117 I Love it when Jesusites talk about values and decency something they know enough cause they built Lies and Deceits upon it. You are of No interest or consequence to me and this nation.
RCG is an excellent example of how to use relate-able world happenings wrapped in intelligent sounding self serving statements spiced with blatant lies to make the listener accept the whole deliverance as Truth.
Except for Selling Lies Slipped into innocuous statements, he is nothing.
Haha, can't hide truth for long. Check here:
globalsecurity(dot)org/military/world/war/indo-pak_1947(dot)htm
Read the 6th & 11th para. Clearly describes how u idiots sent troops & did mayham, looting & raping women. Some of the women who had been raped are STILL ALIVE in Kashmir btw.
See 9th para which clearly says India refused to help - and said we cannot intervene since Kashm is not part of India.
Who this joker is , dysentery through mouth
he has at least 100 time has a sip of water
🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄
35:03 absolutely correct definition of RSS
He is defining lsIam.
Guha is a white man's poodle.
greed,
Wish he could take a breath while speaking and slow the hell down. Otherwise, a great speech.
Bullshit
Yeh jhuta historian hai jnu ka lodu
It is a anty national commet for india.
This joker is a blot on the country.
his style and frequency of water drinking is irritating
@kingdomofloss1 just browse pictures of roasted and burnt children corpses relate to 2002 massacre. Then imagine your child in that state. The great BJP leader of your state endorsed it. What a shining example of progress.
Who endorsed it ?? Did you see burnt corpses from the train ??
@@amrithMilW Bhai see nupur Sharma issue , how they beheaded people
Based. But sadly BJP is a cucked party and doesn't have a spine to do it. Whatever response to Godhra in the form of the Gujarat retaliation of 2002 was done by the common Gujarati Hindu populace.
hahahaha... You are frustrated man.. Can't help you..
Dalla guha 😂😂
He is a historian 🙄
This means I have read his history in my school days 🙄
Yaaaaaak 🤒😵💫
@@ww7308 he is Congressi historian i have also read history but never believed in them
India Will Never Become Developed Country 🥴
India's GDP Per capita income is Low With Just a GDP Per capita of $2,250
And Its a Fact
Reason:Over Population
It Will Take Another 30-40 Years For India to Reach China's Current Economic State
Even If This Happened Then India Would Still be a Middle Class Country With GDP Per capita of 15,500 with The Population of 1.70 Billion
China Currently Has GDP Per capita of $12,200 But Still it Regarded as Upper Middle Class Country 🥴