This guy is making my belief in islam so strong May Allah bless him and grant him Jannah These questions used to bother and weaken my iman but now these questions r making my iman much stronger
Dr. Shabir Ally is what a man of God should be. He is one of the few Imams who genuinely respect women and regard them as true equal to men He is what Islam is
He is misinterpreting & misguiding the rulings to appease western muslims which is very very wrong being a scholar he should give correct answer as per islamic teachings & not answer as per his logic
@@zahednow but he is kinda right tho... Why is it allowed for a man to shorten his mustache to a certain form and this is not changing allahs creation but a woman is not allowed to remove some hair over the eye brows... I mean mostly you dont actually change they eyebrow form, you just remove the little hair around sou eyebrows to make face look cleaner... And he is nott misguiding anyone, he is just stating his opinion... Its up to the people if they wanna believe it or not.
@@kidiiiblilotral2394 Their is a world of difference between moustaches & eyebrows. Don't just compare apples with carrots. You should understand all body hairs for both males & females are allowed to be removed except the eyebrows (because it is clearly stated in the hadeeth). And yes the PROBLEM is that he is stating his OPINION rather than giving the CORRECT answer as per SHARIAH. Always remember the chronology for following islam (1) Quran (2) Hadeeth (3) Logic / opinion. If you start applying logic before shariah then there will be no end to it, people will question everything. Viz: what is logic behind livestock slaughter in Eid ul Azha? What is need for performing salah prayers 5 times in day when i can remember Allah in my heart 100 times, etc etc
WIth all due repect, but he speaks based on his emotions and what he 'believes' the Prophet (peace be upon him) said or did not say without even regarding the authenticity of the hadith. This is absolutely a dangerous approach to take and I dont understand who anyone sees this as acceptable.
I really appreciate Dr. Shabbir. I’ve messaged him before, and he’s super down to earth. I appreciate how his teachings are honest enough to filter traditional doctrines through the lenses of modern science and morality.
@@rahmakacem2209 Hi there! He had his email on some of his material at one time. I’m sure you can contact him from the show as well. I had a question about majoring in Islamic Studies. Best of luck!
@@AbuYusha01 Why he says were the Hadiths are coming from nothing wrong with that, he is very smart and reasonable why he doesn't believe everything that stands in an Hadith. Did you read an Hadith? Do you know what stands there actually? So many things are not allowed wich don't make sense to me at all, if you will follow the Hadiths then you should really stay at home as an Woman and not go outside at all. Its up to people if they wanna follow it, if a woman wants to follow that no problem its her Choice, same to the Man but i will not cause there is just to much that actually really didn't make sense to me, i was trying to get my Answers and finally got them truth out some Videos.
Well that is the actual problem he is giving common sense more priority than the islamic teachings. The correct order of priority should be 1st Quran, 2nd hadith &3rd comes logic.
I have fair skin and black eyebrows. Plus its a unibrow. Trust me, for the sake of people looking at me, I should pluck my eyebrows. I am so happy its not in the Quran to not pluck.
@@chemistryhacks5289 people will look more at her when she has a unibrow. Same for a woman with a beard or mustache. Trust me you would stare. And a husband doesn't want a bearded woman. So it's best to pluck it. People cling to these crazy hadith. That's why converts leave Islam. Because muslims focus on these really insignificant tiny annoying details.
Dhynasah James in Islam it’s permitted for a woman to pluck her beard/mustache. But just a quick question- when did it become ok for people to reject authentic Hadith because they don’t sit well with them?
منتصب القامة أمشي it’s not about not believing in our prophet peace upon him. It’s about dose he really says so? Who his words hasn’t change after one or to generation before they was written? People can remember wrong or partly or even change it. Even after they was written down. In those days there wasn’t so many people who can read. There is no way you can be sure that his words has came to us in the way he has spoken specially things like that with curse and being so bad but not mentioned in Quran. Surly God has not forgot about them. It’s not doubting about dear Prophet, it’s doubting about people honesty.
Thank you for your great and helpful answers. Other scholars say that one Ahadith considers eyebrow-plucking as a change of the creation, but that always confused me, because cutting the mustache, shaving the head or plucking the armpit hair isn't considered "changing the creation" but are even Sunnah or encouraged
@Not even wrong According to Dr. Shabir Ally, who dedicated his entire life to Islam and a man of knowledge, it is not a believable Ahadith. I don't find it believable as well, since cutting the mustache or shaving the hair is not considered haram, but plucking the eyebrows. Plucking your eyebrows also doesn't determine whether someone is a doer of morally good or not. Can you imagine someone that is cursed and burns in hell, just simply for plucking their eyebrows? I can't.
@Not even wrong If you were to believe every single Hadith, because it is an Hadith, you'd end up losing your mind. Even in Bukhari, which is considered the most authentic Hadith book, there are unauthentic Ahadith or Ahadith with a proven chain of narration, that contradict each other. The Ahadith about how long our Prophet (s.a.v.) stayed in Mecca in Bukhari vary as well: Bukhari 4:56:747 and 4:56:748 - He stayed in Mecca for 10 years. Bukhari 5:58:190 and 5:59:741 - He stayed in Mecca for 13 years. This is just one of many examples. Many Ahadtih that are categorized as "authentic" are only checked about their chain or narration, but not whether the context is realistic or not. This is why you can have authentic Ahadith that contradict each other. Ahadith are also bound to the time of their creation: They represent the language, politics and morals at that time. You can't approach Ahadith like the Qur'an, read them without any knowledge and take everything literally. Our Prophet (s.a.v.) used Hyperboles according to some Ahadith to emphasize something. If you're gonna take these Hyperboles, which are a representation of the style of the language at that time, literally, you'd not only find many contradictions within reality and the Qur'an, but also probably loose your Imam, because you'd only end up in contradictions. There is not a degree granting university course called "The Science of Hadith". Abu Hanifa, who is one of the greatest theologians and islamic jurists to have ever existed, spend a lot of time studying Ahadith and the way to verify and test them. You should really inform yourself more about the science of Hadith. I'd also like to add that following every Ahadith blindly and putting it next to the Qur'an is a form of Shirk. If you decide to follow this path for yourself, you're free to do whatever you want to do. But don't judge people like Dr.Shabir Ally, who has dedicated his entire life to Islam and has more knowledge than most Muslims, based on your opinion. May Allah (s.w.t.) guide us to the right path.
I wish he would elaborate more on the first hadith, for example someone should analyse the chain of narrators for the hadith which also will give context
As-Salaam-Alaikum, I agree with you, but I think that it'd be a little unrealistic to expect Dr. Shabir Ally or any human being to always have the chain of narrators memorized in their head. Secondly even a proven chain of narration doesn't necessarily mean, that an Hadith has to be true. Even in Al Bukhari there are Ahadith that are categorized as strong due to their proven chain of narration, but contradict themselves and thus are rejected by many scholars. Abu Hurayra for instance followed the Prophet (s.a.v.) for two years I think and has gathered more Ahadith than anyone else, but Aisha (r.a.) accused him of fabricating Ahadith, because she never heard the Prophet (s.a.v.) say certain things he has written down. When it comes to verifying Ahadith one should not only look at the chain of narration, but compare it's context to reliable sources such as the Qur'an or other authentic Ahadith. I would recommend you to watch lectures or read books about how to approach Ahadith, since one can't simply approach them like the Qur'an. The Qur'an is a perfected guideline from Allah (s.w.t.) for all humanity for all times, whereas Ahadith in their language and sometimes in the context are bound to that specific time in Arabia. One lecture I could recommend is called "Verifying and Understanding Hadith - Dr. Jonathan Brown". May Allah (s.w.t.) bless you and your loved ones richly in this life and in the hereafter and guide us to the right path.
@@mertmitm Waleykumsalam... if you think it's unrealistic for shabbir ally to verify the chain of hadith narrations, then the very least he can do is STOP GIVING ANSWERS WITH HIS HALF KNOWLEDGE
If you collect all the Hadith related to this topic, and the majority scholarly opinion, the conclusion is if a women is married she can pluck the eyebrows. See Darul Ifta Misreeya (Egypt’s fatwa authority) website. I was surprised Shabir didn’t mention the other Hadith related to this, he needs to be careful if he doesn’t have deeper knowledge of such topics.
Nice to see honest imam. I believe if eyebrows or Parfum was so bad definitely God would mention it in Quran. Some people says astaghfirallah when I say there is possible that people have remembered words from Prophet wrong or they have changed it in this years before so many people can read them. But people says you have to say astaghfirallah or you would be kafer. But why? God only make things Haram what is bad for us like alkohol, what bad is in Parfüm that it would be like you have done zina? If it is really so bad then God would mention it in Quran. God has given us brain for thinking. Not just except what ever you hear.
I think it's like the mention of following what the forefathers did without understanding. That's why all cultures have particular traditions etc that people cling to but don't know the meaning of it, yet they are stubborn to relinquish them. I think we often make things more complicated than they really are. Thanks God, may we use our reason
I agree with you. Also, ear piercing is allowed, which IS permanently changing the creation of God, because I still have the piercing I did decades ago although I don’t wear earrings at all. If you pluck eyebrows they grow back after a dew days how’s that permanent lol ? 😂
@@craycray507 exactly. Allah won’t leave important things for guessing or be in clear. And even they say prophet ﷺ has said when you come to masjid you should smell good and he used Parfum too he didn’t do it for women, he did it to smell good in front people and not bother them with bad sweat. I don’t see why for women it is different. I really can’t stand bad smells, I feel it so strong that I feel pain in my stomach. So why torture others with stinky smell?
I see Shabir as a rational and intellectual, though some guys, who are taqleedis or traditionalists and believe that every hadith is true are here and calling the sheikh as ignorant in some comments. Here is the channel of the rational muslim, not the cultural, dogmatic and "weak hadith" followers, in this case, those who prioritize false "narations" than following the quran and it's teachings. Listen and use your mind and be grateful to him for his time and effort!!
Very well said. So many people these days are using fear to bring people to Islaam with so many restrictions, rules and regulations mostly for women and then they say women have more rights than men.. ppffft
Aisha Khaja is doing a superb job to draw out answers from a Dr Shabir Ally. Her friendly approach is pretty good. Great team both of you. Keep it going. I am so impressed that Shabir quoted a part of Lord's Prayer. Clearly the Holy Spirit or the spirit of God/Allah is working in all of us to become good human beings whatever theology and apologetics we may wish to hold to protect our personal faiths. Best wishes from London.
1:44 Prophet Muhammad did said that because in those times bedouin women used to completely shave their eyebrows and draw new ones. It's like plastic surgery they were completely removing what Allah gave them and making something different and new they want but I don't think we're cursed just because we trim and shape it until we completely pluck them off and draw new ones. Besides, our religion tells us to look our best as much as we can. Also, I had a request can you please make a video on Mukhanith and their ruling and what differs them from Khasis and is it same to Transgender. I mean here in Bangladesh our Imam divides Third Gender people in to 4 groups= Aqua, Zenana, Khunsaye mushkila and Khutna. I'm so confused please do make a video that, HUGE REQUEST. Love the Sheikh and your videos 💓
Regarding plucking, I differ a bit with Dr. Shabir reasoning of assuming the fabrication of hadith. There is a Sahih (authentic) hadith in Bukhari 4886 (and Muslim too) in this respect. Interestingly, in that Hadith Allah curses women who tattooed, women who removed hair from face, and women who make spaces between their teeth artificially as they change Allah's creation by doing these things. I think research could be done on how the hair from face were removed in that era. I assume that it might be a thing that whole eye brows were removed for beautification and it was condemned as it changes Allah's creation. Importantly, Maulana Ishaq says that in one hadith Hazrat Ayesha was asked once can I thin my brows for my husband and Ayesha replied you can do it if your husband desires. Being a student myself, I tried to find that reference and would appreciate if someone can find the exact reference and share it with me. May Allah guide us all the best.
But that last bit wouldn't make sense either, because how can a husband's desire change something from being unlawful to lawful? If plucking the eyebrows really bring on a curse from god no man can break that! I don't understand how people believe this , something is either lawful or unlawful. Period. No man can change halal to haram just because he doesn't like how his wife's eyebrows looks that's just ridiculous.
@@ferielmini true. A man can not just make it halal but from what I know if things like these are causing space between a wife and a husband and the husband finds it repulsive or vice versa (if the wife finds it repulsive) they are allowed to do it so as not to cause rifts between couples. It works both ways. The woman has to look good for her husband and the husband has to look good for his wife. Rest Allah knows❤️
Hadith like Dr. Ally said is sometimes shaky, so I generally look to Quran for guidance on numerous issues. I have not found any prohibition against plucking the eyebrow or any mention of any verse that would be a logical extension for its prohibition.
@Toshin Ahnaf that’s a bit rough. So following Quran makes one devil but following hadiths when we know there are many fabrications automatically makes us pious Muslims? This is why the prophet prohibited any writings about him because he knew eventually those would overtake the Quran, you are a walking example. While I do not reject hadiths I am repulsed by people calling someone Kafir or devil for holding the Quran in higher regard than hadith. You are not only insulting the words of Allah but showing how brainwashed you are… have some shame.
@@fatimaxo4885 quranists exclusively follow quran and reject the hadith completely. that's why that guy said that. you took his comment way out of proportion. also, how do you know that the prophet prohibited any writings about him?
So proud of you dear brother to make it clear that our Prophet Muhammad did not go around cursing people! It only makes sense! You gave a good explanation of how this may have come about! May Allah award you!
It is not about "opinions", this is the Religion of Allah, not philosophy. Plucking the eyebrows in Haram without any doubts. There are many Sahih Ahadith and it is also what the Sahabah practiced and preached. Our Senior Scholars ( Ibn Baz, Uthaymeen, Fawzan, etc.) say that it is absolutely Haram. So is your opinion based on evidence or is it just an opinion as you said?
Ibn Baz gave a fatwa that plastic surgery is permisseble (for instant there was a guy he said that he found it difficult to get married because of his nose ). In my opinion is plastic surgery altering the creation of Allah SWT. Hair grows back alhamdullilah.
Don’t you know only Allah can forbid(haram) something if it’s not forbidden in Quran you can live and be a Muslim by believing in Hadiths nobody cares about dumb people like you. This the religion of Allah is Quran which is his words and he guarantee of that but not of man made written Hadiths 200 years later after the death of prophet
Well nobody wants to remove their whole eyebrow. Also prostitutes also wore perfume, makeup, jewelry, fancy clothes…Muslim Women can do all those things today depending on who can see them so why are eyebrows alone cause for curse? By that logic everything prostitutes did is supposed to be a cause for curse but it isn’t. Shaping eyebrows is no different than cutting your nails since they both grow and are not considered permanent changes to creation. I can understand keeping nails short for hygienic reasons but it is nonetheless the same concept as temporary change.
thank you for the clarification on the plucking eyebrow. it will grow back, plucking the hair of the eyebrow it's not permanent baldness (just like your hair - unless there's some deficiencies, like baldness)
Sister Ayesha, the interviewer, I think you should engage more with Dr Shabbir's replies. For example you could have asked him to explain when he said wudu includes wiping over socks rather than washing the feet as is established in the Islamic scholarship. Similarly his reasons to reject the hadith of plucking the eyebrows needed more probing. Is there any indication in text or any issues in the reporters that he used to not accept it. If it is based on his opinion then what is so important about his opinion rather than anybody else's.
You have qouted a valid point....that hadeeth of plucking eyebrows is sahih hadeeth(means authentic) yet shockingly mr. Shabir brushed it aside as week
@@Hamza000h disputes are more on the interpretation rather than authenticity of it. As this plucking eyebrows hadith is mentioned in bukhari (one of most highly regarded books of hadiths) so no scholar can doubt on it's authenticity
@@zahednow if i may say, i invyte u to look into the situation more. There have been major scholars of the past to pick up on hadith in sahih muslim and bukhari and question their authenticity. An example of this is the hadith in muslim on the prophets parents. Although vast majority are sahih, you should just be aware that some hadiths were and are questioned
@@Hamza000h agreed with your point. But now can we discuss this specific topic i.e. plucking eyebrows hadith, because the manner in which this scholar is interpreting & disregarding that hadith is very wrong
What if we have been mis interpreting this Hadith . And it means don’t shave off the whole eyebrow . Because what’s the difference between that and trimming the beard ?
It was narrated that 'Abdullah said: "I heard the Messenger of Allah ﷺ say: 'May Allah curse Al-Mutanammisat, women who have tattoos done and women who have their teeth separated, those who change the creation of Allah, Mighty and Sublime."
I really like this Hoxha, it made me change my mind cause for a while was trying so hard to avoid everything that is considered haram in the Hadiths. Realize the Hadiths arent 100% sure so if some wanna follow it no problem i don't mind these People. Do whats best for you but i totally not gonna be into Hadiths cause there is just Informations that arent true at all. As an revert was hard first to decide what truly is right but i got it now. Like this Hoxha cause he isn't ,,HARAM!''
The Hadith he mentioned is in sahih Bukhari and Muslim and was classified as sahih Hasan by Albany. So there is no reason for this sheikh not to accept it. This is frustrating.
Sahih hadiths aren't 100% reliable. In fact, they also have contradictions with each other and aren't exempt from fabrication. The only hadiths that are regarded as very reliable are the ones that come from the first three generations of Muslims known as Mutawātir hadith, but there also aren't that many of them.
Would tattoos fall into that same category to? As in a hadith prophet Muhammed PBUH also said curse be to the one who gets and the one gives a tattoo. The common understanding is that like eyebrow plucking, it is supposedly changing the creation of Allah swt.
It was narrated that ‘Abd-Allaah said: “Allaah has cursed the women who do tattoos and those who ask for tattoos to be done, those who ask for their eyebrows to be plucked, and the women ask for their teeth to be filed for the purpose of beautification, changing the creation of Allaah.” A woman from the tribe of Bani Asad whose name was Umm Ya’qoob heard of that and she came and said, “I have heard that you have cursed So and so and So and so.” He said, “Why should I not curse those whom the Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) cursed and who are mentioned in the Book of Allaah?’ She said, “I have read what is between the two covers [of the Qur’aan], and I did not find anything in it like what you have said.” He said, “If you have read it, have you not read that Allaah says, ‘And whatsoever the Messenger (Muhammad) gives you, take it; and whatsoever he forbids you, abstain (from it)’ [al-Hashr 59:7]?” She said, “Of course.” He said, “He forbade that.” She said, “I think your wife does it.” He said, “Go and look.” So she went and looked and she did not see what she was looking for. He said, “If she had been like that, she would not be with us.” Narrated by al-Bukhaari, 4604; Muslim, 2125 Subhana'Allah this hadith is in both bukhari and Muslim, in both the saheeh books, bukhari being the most authentic book after the quran, how can we disagree with a saheeh hadith???
Asalamulaikum Sisters and brothers, i wanted to ask about plucking eyebrows As i have developed unibrow (hair in between eyebrows) and little bit of uneven hair on the bottom line and above I wanted to ask that can i thread or pluck them Will i get cursed? Is it the part of the eyebrow or not Thank You
Walikumsalam, the middle section is not considered eyebrows. You can watch the video of Shaykh Yahya Ibrahim about it: ruclips.net/video/-p56lOzOwHQ/видео.html
I wanna know about water supply system during prophet's time. Cz it is related to obligatory gusul after intercourse. Was water so accessible that people (especially newly married couples) could perform farj gusul after the act each time?
Just look at human actions and you'll realize that if any of God's creations deserves hell, it's human beings. If God didn't send humans to hell, that'd be unfair to other creatures. And He can't be an "All Loving God" by only loving humans and forgetting His other creations.
I heard from a scholar once that the hadith on plucking eyebrows has been mistranslated. The scholar said that the arabic word that is often translated into 'women who pluck their eyebrows' or 'women who remove hair from their face' actually meant 'women who partially shave their heads' because in historical arabia it was fashionable for women, black women specifically, would tattoo their eyebrows and file between their teeth AND to shave from the forehead till the top of the head leaving half of the face and scalp bald which seemed very odd and unsightly. Then the Prophet P.B.U.H. expressed his disdain of these dramatic alterations to the human body in the sake of empty beauty trends. I think this hadith can also be applied today e.g. the current trend is to get gigantic fake lips and botox etc. simply for the sake of the trend and we must avoid it just like the Prophet P.B.U.H. guided women back then to avoid these materialistic meaningless gains.
I was trying to find a video that throws some light on the topic of birthday celebrations and its permissibility as per Qur'an and authentic hadeeth. Please help me with this, Jazak Allah.
Ok yes alcohol is halal iswel in my own opinion bec drinking a little will not mk me feget Allah pfft really if Allah forbids something you don't question you act upon it simple quran 6:116 and I'f you obay most of those upon the earth (including courupt scholars) they will misled you from the path of Allah they follow not except assumption and they are not but falsifying. Now am not saying he's wrong all the time but this i don't agree 100% false
This is quranic verse no denial in it,,,,,, but many things in hadeeth is already contradictory few years back it has been updated and some hadeeth has been removed too,, and I'm talking about bukhari,,,,, and bukhari was the one who decided which hadeeth to be recorded or rejected how can we affirm on him,,, in sahi bukhari compilation he rejected many hadeeth and note down many of it too,,,,, if he rejected the hadeeth which is week then what's the guarantee of the hadeeth which he compiled is right it may also be fabricated,,,,, after all it was his and his colleagues mind who differentiated that
And talking about alcohol yes in moderate proportion it doesn't harm you but the main thing that if you even start drinking little of it,,, it has the tendancy to be addicted and soon you will become more and more addictive towards it,,,, and when you have it regularly you know it's consequences what happens after it,, it destroys your own body your mind and some times it affects the people around you,,,,,,,,, that is the reason it is directly stated by the almighty to abandon it and what Allah says in quran there's no if and but,,, indeed Allah knows the best
Mohamad Tahir Ibn Ashoor said that the plucking eyebrow and other hadiths like it includes some habits that were related to prostitution at that time so in our time any habits that will have the same signals will be prohibited too
I am so happy that I found this guy! I was starting to think I was crazy for not believing in all the BS I hear from Muslims. InshAllah once the Ummah is more educated, we will move on past all this BS. People really think plucking eyebrows is haram!? LOL
H Mahdi it’s a Hadith, if you don’t believe the sayings of the prophet pbuh when you are supposed to please educate yourself before making ignorant comments
BS? Please refrain from such foul language. This is a religious post. Also, I would advise you to be kinder to those whose opinion differs from yours. Most people believe that plucking eyebrows is haram out of RESPECT for Imam Bukhari. Let's not spread arrogance and hate.
@@bangtansoneyondantiktoks3755 yes, threading the mid section is ok the only issue is plucking the brows from under or above to reduce its size or change its looks
Salaam. Jesus pbuh denies returning to earth in surah 5. I think the ahadith relating to this have defects. I'm surprised Dr Shabbir did not mention this.
Women here in comments thanking and praising him because answer goes to thier way but The hadeeth which says that the woman who plucks the eyebrows or who has that done is cursed was narrated by al-Bukhaari (4886) and Muslim (2125), from the hadeeth of ‘Abd-Allaah ibn Mas’ood (may Allaah be pleased with him)??????? What about this?
Subhaan Allaah! I cannot believe he’s saying this! 1. What he’s saying is ABSOLUTELY NOT TRUE. It is proven BEYOND DOUBT that Ahaadeeth were written down DURING the lifetime of the Prophet sal Allaahu Alayhi wa sallam. Yes it’s true that the Prophet sal Allaahu Alayhi wa sallam had INITIALLY asked the Sahaabah to not record hadeeth He Sal Allaahu Alaiyhi wa Sallam said: “Do not write down anything from me except the Qur’aan.” (Muslim). The ulama gave several reasons why he said that. 1. The prohibition to write down hadeeth was at the BEGINNING when the Qur’aan was being revealed and the Prophet sal Allaahu Alayhi wa sallam did not want people to *MIX* the *Qur’aan* with *hadeeth*. 2. He didn’t want them to write hadeeth on the same paper or material as the Qur’aan was written. 3. It was preferred to memorize hadeeth by heart rather than writing it down. Imaam an-Nawawi said: “The prohibition was in effect when there was the fear that (the words of the Prophet Sal Allaahu Alaiyhi wa Sallam might be mixed with the Qur’aan. When that danger was no longer present, permission was given to write down (ahaadeeth). And it was said that the prohibition mentioned in the hadeeth referred to writing ahaadeeth on the same page as Qur’aan, lest they become mixed and thus the reader would be confused when looking at this page.” (Sharh’ saheeh Muslim) Later this order of not writing hadeeth was ABROGATED and the Prophet sal Allaahu Alayhi wa sallam actually INSTRUCTED the Sahaabah to write down hadeeth. So the prohibition was ONLY TEMPORARY and only for SOME people and the Prophet sal Allaahu Alayhi wa sallam ALLOWED the writing of hadeeth PROOF: Abdullaah ibn Amr radhi Allaahu anhu said: “I used to write whatever I heard from the Prophet Sal Allaahu Alaiyhi wa Sallam and wanted to learn it by heart. Some people of the Quraysh dissuaded me and said, "Do you write everything you hear from the Prophet, while he is a human being and sometimes he may be in anger as any other human beings may be?" Abdullaah ibn Amr conveyed this to the Prophet Sal Allaahu Alaiyhi wa Sallam. The Prophet Sal Allaahu Alaiyhi wa Sallam pointed to his lips and said: “I swear by the One in whose hands is the soul of Muhammad: nothing comes out from these two (lips) except truth. So (go ahead) *DO WRITE*.” (Abu Dawood- saheeh) That’s why many Sahaabah had their own ‘Suhuf’ (manuscripts) and personal collections of ahaadeeth by the time the Prophet sal Allaahu Alayhi wa sallam passed away. The Sahaabah had memorized the ahaadeeth well and had written them down very much IN the lifetime of the Prophet sal Allaahu Alayhi wa sallam. And thus, the ahaadeeth of the Prophet sal Allaahu Alayhi wa sallam were *well preserved*. 2. Verification of the authenticity of ahaadeeth is a very serious issue and scholars have spent their ENTIRE lifetime studying and then verifying the authenticity of ahaadeeth. In fact there’s a whole science to the study of ahaadeeth and their authentication. It’s called “Mustalah al-Hadeeth” When Allaah Subhaanahu wa Ta’aala promised to preserve this Deen, He did not just preserve the Qur’aan. Rather He ALSO preserved the Sunnah through the Sahaabah of the Prophet sal Allaahu Alayhi wa sallam. Allaah says: “Verily We: It is We Who have sent down the Dhikr (i.e. the Qur’aan and Sunnah) and surely, We will guard it (from corruption).” (Surah al-Hijr:9) Here in the above Aayah, Allaah Subhaanahu wa Ta’aala used the word “dhikr”. and promised to guard it. He did NOT use the word “Qur’aan” or “Kitaab” or any other word that could mean “just” His Book by *itself*. Rather Allaah used the word “dhikr” or “reminder” because BOTH the Qur’aan AND the authentic Sunnah are means of guidance for us. BOTH the Qur’aan and the authentic ahaadeeth are a source of legislation for us and BOTH the Qur’aan and authentic ahaadeeth are needed to truly understand and implement the orders of Allaah Subhaanahu wa Ta’aala. That’s because the authentic ahaadeeth are an EXPLANATION of what the Qur’aan contains and it’s the PRACTICAL IMPLEMENTATION of its injunctions. How else can a person know how much Zakaah to give or how many rak’aat in each prayer, or how to perform Hajj or how to slaughter an animal or how to implement all the ibaadaat and rulings? The Prophet sal Allaahu Alayhi wa sallam showed us *practically* what Allaah wants from us. And if that itself is “questionable”, Aoodhu Billaah, then how would the Deen be preserved? How would people know HOW to practice the Deen if the very explanation of how to implement the Deen was lost? So just as Allaah preserved the Qur’aan, He preserved the Deen by preserving the ahaadeeth of the Prophet sal Allaahu Alayhi wa sallam. Allaah enabled the Sahaabah to memorize, and write down the ahaadeeth of the Prophet sal Allaahu Alayhi wa sallam JUST AS they memorized and wrote down the Qur’aan. The Sahaabah then passed that knowledge on to the next generation, the Tabi’een and they memorized it and wrote it down and preserved it well. As more people came into Islaam, the need to preserve the authentic ahaadeeth was of utmost importance so Allaah enabled the scholars to develop a whole science that meticulously checked and verified the authenticity of the words, deeds and approvals of the Prophet sal Allaahu Alayhi wa sallam. Utmost care was taken to record the noble hadeeth of the Prophet Sal Allaahu Alaiyhi wa Sallam in the most accurate manner. The scholars developed a whole system of evaluating and criticizing the different narrators of hadeeth according to certain VERY STRICT CONDITIONS so as to check the reliability of their narrations, including their knowledge, and even their mental health at the time of narrating hadeeth, *when* and *where* they traveled to, and *who* they met to hear or relay ahaadeeth. The scholars even recorded the names of those that tried to corrupt the deen by fabricating ahaadeeth or narrate unreliable narrations. This way they were able to protect and distinguish the authentic ahaadeeth and weed out the weak or fabricated ones. This is a *very* brief explanation of the science of preservation of hadeeth. I could go on and on. When you study the science of hadeeth and how Allaah Subhaanahu wa Ta’aala preserved this beautiful and vital part of our Deen, it s literally MIND BOGGLING. Subhaan Allaah it is just amazing and you immediately realize that none of this could even be possible in the slightest EXCEPT that it was the Divine Work of Allaah Subhaanahu wa Ta’aala. For more information please read the book “Introduction to the science of hadeeth” in the following link sunnahonline.com/library/fiqh-and-sunnah/277-introduction-to-the-sciences-of-hadith And Allaah knows best Written by Asmaa bint Shameem the student of sheikh Mohammed AsSawi, and sheikh Waleed Basiyouni, both are students of Sheikh Mohammed Ibn Saleeh AlOtheimeen and sheikh Bin Baz.
I have a question. While I don't believe there has been a prophet since Muhammad, I am not so convinced that the one verse we quote on the issue can be considered Quranic proof. Surely if the link between man and God through messengers has been around since the start of our existence, to say that that link is now ended requires more clarification that two words.
+ElPocho DelMundo Actually I'm saying that the premise of Muhammad's finality is unsupported in the Quran to begin with, that all its stories imply to us that prophethood is continuous, and Im saying that the suggestion that the title "seal of the prophets" once used in the Quran in reference to Muhammad which is literally two Arabic words fully supports demonstrates and clarifies this finality idea, is weak at best and actually it could mean a host of other things. Such a fundamental change requires a good reason, maybe a clear sign or a change in our circumstances or perhaps some shifting in the very constants of the universe, anything really, that demonstrates why this change has to happen.
+Curtis Jea Adams Brother, it is not just the Quran but we also have saheeh hadeeths that inform us about this. I agree that the Quranic phrase can be translated differently but we cannot deny the clear meaning of saheeh hadeeths as these are authentic sayings of our prophet(pbuh). He clearly said that there will be no prophet after him. I know this idea may seem odd to comprehend at first but we must also not forget that Allah(swt) is the most wise. He knows best what to do and how to do. Sometimes we could understand it and sometimes we cannot. We humbly accept everything whether it satisfies our little mind or not. Salaam
+MOHD SAQUIB Yes brother but the important concepts of the religion have to originate in the Quran, then hadith usually provides more details, like footnotes. Allah knows best.
Well I am an Ahmadi Muslim, we believe that prophethood continues but only under the law of the Qur'an because it's the final law of Allah, our community was declared as non-muslim because of this 'heretical' belief, we do not conform to the idea that Jesus (AS) was raised physically to heaven as there is NO proof for this whatsoever and is an idea which was adopted later in Islam due to ignorance, we believe firmly just as Elijah was thought to have ascended to heaven was a false belief but the Jews were awaiting for Elijah (AS) to descend from the heaven as per prophecies in the Bible, Jesus (AS) declared John the baptist/Yahya (AS) to be the second coming of Elijah (AS), so the same way we believe that Mirza Ghulam Ahmad (AS) is the second coming of Jesus (AS), we believe that Jesus (AS) went to find the lost sheep of the house of Israel to convey the message of Allah just as his mission was, he said "I am not sent but to the lost sheep of the house of Israel", if Jesus (AS) did ascend to heaven he failed his mission, because not all of tribes of Israel were nearby at the time (hence why they were called 'lost') Let me know what you think and let me know if you need more information. Thanks
@@waymilky442dubious ? Muslim and Bukhary the 2 most authentic books of hadith you can find . I remember a time when people that wasnt sure would leave it for the sake of Allah now everybody wants to follow their passion
I am a Muslim and I believe strongly on every aspect of Islam which is based on logic and facts, but I am helpless to understand few things. God was told on the creation of Adam that they will do badly on earth, how do angles know the future? though they didn't have the intellect think other than what God instructs them to do. This intelligence implies to the behavior of making choices to do evil or God, yes or no and which can be proved by satin, he made a decision to not to bow and he ' disobeyed". God almighty never makes mistake, but for creating Adam he was proven wrong the angles, because of what Adam did. If God knew that satin will cajole him to do what he is forbidden to do that instead of satin why Adam was punished and banished to earth. Was there Eve with Adam??
fowad khan First there was prophet Adam(as). Eve/Hawa(as) came later on. However when they were punished, Eve(as) was with Adam. The angels never knew that bani-Adam/humans was going to sin. They just assumed so, because humans have a free will, the Jinn (who were on earth befor Humans) also had a free will, and they oppressed and killed each other, and caused great mischief on earth... So, since humans also got free will, the angels assumed they would be just like the Jinn... Satan will be punished because he invited Adam(as) to sin, which was through whispering. Adam(as) and Eve/Hawa(as) was punished because he sinned...
fowad khan God never made any mistakes, God knows everything and that was his plan. Verily, I am going to place (mankind) generations after generations on earth." They said: "Will You place therein those who will make mischief therein and shed blood, - while we glorify You with praises and thanks (Exalted be You above all that they associate with You as partners) and sanctify You." He (Allah) said: "I know that which you do not know." It says that God knows what the angels don’t, it doesn’t mean the angels were right, it means God knows his intentions and his plan. Please read and research properly before assuming that God made a mistake. There is not a single flaw in the Quran. You just have to understand it properly
Unapologetically, Shabbir Ali should not speak for Islaam. The companions are trustworthy and scholars of old have studied chains of narrations. Rejecting the tradition of The Prophet on the premise of not trusting narrators is such a flawed argument.
is it haram to wish merry christimas? participate in christmas celebrations and festivities? is there a verse that mentions it? or does this only applies to certain countries? thank you.
Qur'an teaches that God neither begets nor is He begotten. And I believe merry Christmas means something to do with God has begotten a child...then it is against Qur'an...
christmas is pagan tradition, its not part of Jesus the Prophet! did you know christmas was even banned in England in the 16 or 17th century because of its pagan origins? en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christmas_controversies
You are right some people invented hadith. That is why whole texts were written about validating hadith and yet you decide a hadith classed as sahih cannot be true because you cannot IMAGINE the prophet pbuh saying it. So if i were to not be able to imagine the Messenger pbuh saying something (due to my desires or any other reason)then its okay for me to reinvent deed. Also let us assume that a man had to invent a hadith and came home to his wife, who would invent a hadith saying that she must not pluck her eyebrow? No muslims do not generally hold that Jesus will return. They firmly believe as a consensus that he will definitely return. What is wrong with you man?
This is a great question but I really think Islam is so reasonable and it’s in your heart. It’s really easy to ask yourself question if you are fair minded whether things make sense. If you want to just invent because of your desire… then your hearts intent is not pure. It’s just simple
I'm shocked at what he said. If you listen to any scholar of Islam he won't have this answer. I'm wondering if this channel is secretly from some strange sect
***** Maybe I misunderstood but it seems that he is questioning the authenticity of a hadith based on what HE thinks the Prophet ASWS would say. That's a red flag to me. Also, I know it's nice to be able to understand them but someone speaking english well isn't an indication of their proficiency in the Islamic sciences.
watercongas brother Sister there r narrations and chains of it .. strong and weeks ones .. follow the one that is known to be strong through the chain of narrations.. whatever the majority of the scholars known to be well known scholars say then follow that.. this brother basically gave his answer saying I don't believe the Prophet to be saying that ??? that's not how rulings work lol quite dangerous!
السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته It is blasphemous to reject authentic hadith or say the sahabah made up hadiths !!! Please tell me your degree as an imam?! استغفر الله!!! It's not about people finding hadiths strange أعوذ بالله
Question: What is the Islamic perspective/position of the Jewish claim of Jesus (a.s) not being the messiah because he did not fulfill the messianic prophecies, such as the rebuilding of the temple and leading the Jewish people to the Land of Israel ?
from the Islamic perspective... the Torah was changed before Isa (a.s) even entered the scene. Most likely this was not an actual condition he needed to fulfill to prove his prophethood but just something that was added in to Judaic scripture after the death of Musa (a.s). Had it been an actual prophecy, Isa (a.s) wouldn't have been taken up by Allah before he could accomplish it.
What is wrong with this man? Sometimes his answers are so confusing, and is sending mixed signals. Don't be fooled Dr. And don't sell out your Deen. Islam is Organic and raw. Pure and straight. Say it at is. Don't please the creation, lest you misguide your soul and others. Pleasing the CREATOR is the duty of the believer no matter where he/ she is. And know that the ultimate destination is Akhirah (hereafter).
How can you claim that a hadith can never be false? There were so many people who started talking about what our Prophet had said or done. Why should that be all true???? In this discourse we have the WORD of GOD vs. the word of man - You should decide for yourself what you are more believing in. For me only the WORD of GOD is important.
I understand your point. I am not saying that the Hadith is ALL false. But the problem of today is that people claim a lot about Islam. As their statements cannot be supported by the Coran, they come up with the Hadith. Just look at the role of women. Show me 1 single "sure" in the Coran which describes how a woman should be dressed. Contrary to this there are "obviously" hundreds of Hadiths telling/explaining how a woman should be dressed, how she should behave, etc. This is why WE should more rely and stick to the Coran and not the Hadith which unfortunately has become more and more political.
In my opinion the core message of all religions is the same which lead to GOD. And GOD is one! BTW: the shahada and its meaning is not rocket science - it is a very logical thought which says that there is only one GOD and Mohammad is His messenger. Why should this be something mentioned in the Coran?
Brother get your facts straight before accusing others of misleading, especially one who has spent all/most of his life learning/teaching the religion.
There are many hadith collected by our classical Muhaddith; Bukhari, Muslim, Imam ahmed etc. Imam Bukharis collections of hadith was very meticulous and stringent. Mr Shabir Ali is a contemporary scholar who is Not qualified to discuss the authentication of Hadith and it's applications. This loose understanding is dangerous and puts doubts in every hadith and authentication of hadith. theres ample of ahadith with regards to this topic, I would NOT take anything from him, Muslims should be very cautious!!!! “Allaah has CURSED the woman who does tattoos and the one who has them done, the woman who plucks eyebrows and the one who has it done, and the one who files her teeth for the purpose of beauty, altering the creation of Allaah.” (Bukhaari, Muslim)
returning to break the pagan idol crosses they worshipped him with instead of his Creator, kill the Anti Kristos False Messiah and to destroy the pigs that the Christians began eating after Paul's fake indoctrination!
I once heard that Allah will eventually take everyone out from the hell including the modern day non muslims and He would only let the super arrogant like Abu Jahl and Abu Lahb types to stay in hell eternally. How true is that? Please answer me in the light of Quran. JazakAllah kheran kaseera.
Nida Aizaz Allah knws best .. it's in his knowledge.. but wicked people do go to hell :( .... but again abu thalib helped Muhammad Salalahualayhiwasalam all his life and even after prophet hood but didn't get guidance . Allah knws best
I pray so.... but God knows best. IMO we can’t rule out that possibility but not can we sit back and not take the whole thing seriously based on this possibility
Asalamualaikum Dr Shabbir, it would make things a lot clearer if you can explain why you feel this hadith is fabricated, as everywhere I've read most have classified it as authentic. I am confused as to why would a sahaba make up a hadith as I am sure they were God-fearing and wouldn't be so casual about inventing hadiths. Please share the context and elaborate a bit more as well for clarity. JazakAllah.
So Dr. "thinks" that Prophet Muhammad PBUH couldn't have said that, using his so called balanced approach and using logic. What a joke. Well then we all can't see Allah SWT nor can I see jinns or Angels, might as become atheists, using balanced approach and logic. What a joke.
U can't apply silly things like this to prophet (PBUH), plucking eye brows doesn't matter to Allah it's ur narrow thinking and perspective so keep it with you don't interpret things as per your convenience
@@syedsyed5929 who is saying that it's a silly thing? I might say growing facial hair is a silly thing, or cutting nails is a silly thing, or covering one's body for that matter. Is drinking water sitting down also silly? Is eating from right hand also silly? The question is who decides what's silly and what's not? Are we to use our logic when it comes to these things? Well our logic might say that there is no God altogether. In Islam we follow the Qur'an and the Sunnah of the Prophet Muhammad. And we can't deny something just because our little brains can't decide if it's silly or not.
Excuse me , I dint say all sunnah is silly Those which are silly or inhibits someone's right and make someone's life difficult are silly and they may be added or not maintained in its original form like doctor said Theirs a hadith quoting about wife prostrating for husband ,wife sucking pus ,etc do u think they really are from prophet they are adulterated ones Islam itself is logical ,u say don't apply logic For that matter let me answer all of ur questions logically Drinking water sitting @science says when u drink water standing their are high chances of stroke ,high chance of water directly entering stomach 2) cutting nails _bacteria and other microbes were first found by Anton von Leeuwenhoek from his teeth scraping and nails that's the reason prophet PBUH being a unlettered person gave it Rather Allah says apply logic in Quran Verily, the worst of living creatures in the sight of Allah are the deaf and dumb who will not reason. Surat Al-Anfal 8:22
Please stop trying to make a deviated sect of islam, this is not the way to be or to call others to islam. We dont change anything in Islam .either we submit to Allah and ALL of His commands, including following our beloved prophetﷺ or we dont!! We dont change Islam to fit our nafs and to please others!!
This guy is making my belief in islam so strong
May Allah bless him and grant him Jannah
These questions used to bother and weaken my iman but now these questions r making my iman much stronger
Dr. Shabir Ally is what a man of God should be. He is one of the few Imams who genuinely respect women and regard them as true equal to men
He is what Islam is
I just love him. He speaks genuinely and without bias. Alhumdullilah
Layela he is better than dr. naik
He is misinterpreting & misguiding the rulings to appease western muslims which is very very wrong being a scholar he should give correct answer as per islamic teachings & not answer as per his logic
@@zahednow but he is kinda right tho... Why is it allowed for a man to shorten his mustache to a certain form and this is not changing allahs creation but a woman is not allowed to remove some hair over the eye brows... I mean mostly you dont actually change they eyebrow form, you just remove the little hair around sou eyebrows to make face look cleaner... And he is nott misguiding anyone, he is just stating his opinion... Its up to the people if they wanna believe it or not.
@@kidiiiblilotral2394 Their is a world of difference between moustaches & eyebrows. Don't just compare apples with carrots. You should understand all body hairs for both males & females are allowed to be removed except the eyebrows (because it is clearly stated in the hadeeth).
And yes the PROBLEM is that he is stating his OPINION rather than giving the CORRECT answer as per SHARIAH.
Always remember the chronology for following islam (1) Quran (2) Hadeeth (3) Logic / opinion.
If you start applying logic before shariah then there will be no end to it, people will question everything. Viz: what is logic behind livestock slaughter in Eid ul Azha? What is need for performing salah prayers 5 times in day when i can remember Allah in my heart 100 times, etc etc
WIth all due repect, but he speaks based on his emotions and what he 'believes' the Prophet (peace be upon him) said or did not say without even regarding the authenticity of the hadith. This is absolutely a dangerous approach to take and I dont understand who anyone sees this as acceptable.
I really appreciate Dr. Shabbir. I’ve messaged him before, and he’s super down to earth. I appreciate how his teachings are honest enough to filter traditional doctrines through the lenses of modern science and morality.
How can i contact him ?
@@rahmakacem2209 Hi there! He had his email on some of his material at one time. I’m sure you can contact him from the show as well. I had a question about majoring in Islamic Studies. Best of luck!
I LOVE Dr Shabbir’s answers!!! He’s ABSOLUTELY right!!
Salaam alykum.
I really like how you judge hadith with common sense.
You really shouldn't like that.
@@AbuYusha01 Why he says were the Hadiths are coming from nothing wrong with that, he is very smart and reasonable why he doesn't believe everything that stands in an Hadith. Did you read an Hadith? Do you know what stands there actually? So many things are not allowed wich don't make sense to me at all, if you will follow the Hadiths then you should really stay at home as an Woman and not go outside at all. Its up to people if they wanna follow it, if a woman wants to follow that no problem its her Choice, same to the Man but i will not cause there is just to much that actually really didn't make sense to me, i was trying to get my Answers and finally got them truth out some Videos.
Well that is the actual problem he is giving common sense more priority than the islamic teachings. The correct order of priority should be 1st Quran, 2nd hadith &3rd comes logic.
@@zahednow
U r right there.
@Mohamed Boualem omg ikr.. So many Muslims just don't have rational thinking and it annoys me.
I have fair skin and black eyebrows. Plus its a unibrow. Trust me, for the sake of people looking at me, I should pluck my eyebrows. I am so happy its not in the Quran to not pluck.
But it actually doesn't matter...as you only show your beauty to your husband
Men aren't supposed to look at you directly
@@chemistryhacks5289 people will look more at her when she has a unibrow. Same for a woman with a beard or mustache. Trust me you would stare. And a husband doesn't want a bearded woman. So it's best to pluck it. People cling to these crazy hadith. That's why converts leave Islam. Because muslims focus on these really insignificant tiny annoying details.
Dhynasah James in Islam it’s permitted for a woman to pluck her beard/mustache.
But just a quick question- when did it become ok for people to reject authentic Hadith because they don’t sit well with them?
Dhynasah James please don’t call it ‘crazy’ Hadith, you are talking about our prophet pbuhs sayings, be careful what you say
منتصب القامة أمشي it’s not about not believing in our prophet peace upon him. It’s about dose he really says so? Who his words hasn’t change after one or to generation before they was written? People can remember wrong or partly or even change it. Even after they was written down. In those days there wasn’t so many people who can read. There is no way you can be sure that his words has came to us in the way he has spoken specially things like that with curse and being so bad but not mentioned in Quran. Surly God has not forgot about them. It’s not doubting about dear Prophet, it’s doubting about people honesty.
Thank you for your great and helpful answers. Other scholars say that one Ahadith considers eyebrow-plucking as a change of the creation, but that always confused me, because cutting the mustache, shaving the head or plucking the armpit hair isn't considered "changing the creation" but are even Sunnah or encouraged
@Not even wrong According to Dr. Shabir Ally, who dedicated his entire life to Islam and a man of knowledge, it is not a believable Ahadith. I don't find it believable as well, since cutting the mustache or shaving the hair is not considered haram, but plucking the eyebrows. Plucking your eyebrows also doesn't determine whether someone is a doer of morally good or not. Can you imagine someone that is cursed and burns in hell, just simply for plucking their eyebrows? I can't.
@Not even wrong If you were to believe every single Hadith, because it is an Hadith, you'd end up losing your mind. Even in Bukhari, which is considered the most authentic Hadith book, there are unauthentic Ahadith or Ahadith with a proven chain of narration, that contradict each other. The Ahadith about how long our Prophet (s.a.v.) stayed in Mecca in Bukhari vary as well:
Bukhari 4:56:747 and 4:56:748 - He stayed in Mecca for 10 years.
Bukhari 5:58:190 and 5:59:741 - He stayed in Mecca for 13 years.
This is just one of many examples. Many Ahadtih that are categorized as "authentic" are only checked about their chain or narration, but not whether the context is realistic or not. This is why you can have authentic Ahadith that contradict each other. Ahadith are also bound to the time of their creation: They represent the language, politics and morals at that time. You can't approach Ahadith like the Qur'an, read them without any knowledge and take everything literally. Our Prophet (s.a.v.) used Hyperboles according to some Ahadith to emphasize something. If you're gonna take these Hyperboles, which are a representation of the style of the language at that time, literally, you'd not only find many contradictions within reality and the Qur'an, but also probably loose your Imam, because you'd only end up in contradictions. There is not a degree granting university course called "The Science of Hadith". Abu Hanifa, who is one of the greatest theologians and islamic jurists to have ever existed, spend a lot of time studying Ahadith and the way to verify and test them. You should really inform yourself more about the science of Hadith. I'd also like to add that following every Ahadith blindly and putting it next to the Qur'an is a form of Shirk. If you decide to follow this path for yourself, you're free to do whatever you want to do. But don't judge people like Dr.Shabir Ally, who has dedicated his entire life to Islam and has more knowledge than most Muslims, based on your opinion. May Allah (s.w.t.) guide us to the right path.
True!
I wish he would elaborate more on the first hadith, for example someone should analyse the chain of narrators for the hadith which also will give context
As-Salaam-Alaikum,
I agree with you, but I think that it'd be a little unrealistic to expect Dr. Shabir Ally or any human being to always have the chain of narrators memorized in their head. Secondly even a proven chain of narration doesn't necessarily mean, that an Hadith has to be true. Even in Al Bukhari there are Ahadith that are categorized as strong due to their proven chain of narration, but contradict themselves and thus are rejected by many scholars. Abu Hurayra for instance followed the Prophet (s.a.v.) for two years I think and has gathered more Ahadith than anyone else, but Aisha (r.a.) accused him of fabricating Ahadith, because she never heard the Prophet (s.a.v.) say certain things he has written down. When it comes to verifying Ahadith one should not only look at the chain of narration, but compare it's context to reliable sources such as the Qur'an or other authentic Ahadith. I would recommend you to watch lectures or read books about how to approach Ahadith, since one can't simply approach them like the Qur'an. The Qur'an is a perfected guideline from Allah (s.w.t.) for all humanity for all times, whereas Ahadith in their language and sometimes in the context are bound to that specific time in Arabia. One lecture I could recommend is called "Verifying and Understanding Hadith - Dr. Jonathan Brown". May Allah (s.w.t.) bless you and your loved ones richly in this life and in the hereafter and guide us to the right path.
@@mertmitm Waleykumsalam... if you think it's unrealistic for shabbir ally to verify the chain of hadith narrations, then the very least he can do is STOP GIVING ANSWERS WITH HIS HALF KNOWLEDGE
@@zahednow watch mufti abu layths bukharigate
But im sure even that won't convince you! Lol
@@ahmedmohammad7300 firstly, you can post the link of whatever you are saying.... secondly, what is there for me to get convinced here
If you collect all the Hadith related to this topic, and the majority scholarly opinion, the conclusion is if a women is married she can pluck the eyebrows. See Darul Ifta Misreeya (Egypt’s fatwa authority) website. I was surprised Shabir didn’t mention the other Hadith related to this, he needs to be careful if he doesn’t have deeper knowledge of such topics.
Nice to see honest imam. I believe if eyebrows or Parfum was so bad definitely God would mention it in Quran. Some people says astaghfirallah when I say there is possible that people have remembered words from Prophet wrong or they have changed it in this years before so many people can read them. But people says you have to say astaghfirallah or you would be kafer. But why? God only make things Haram what is bad for us like alkohol, what bad is in Parfüm that it would be like you have done zina? If it is really so bad then God would mention it in Quran. God has given us brain for thinking. Not just except what ever you hear.
I think it's like the mention of following what the forefathers did without understanding. That's why all cultures have particular traditions etc that people cling to but don't know the meaning of it, yet they are stubborn to relinquish them. I think we often make things more complicated than they really are. Thanks God, may we use our reason
I agree with you. Also, ear piercing is allowed, which IS permanently changing the creation of God, because I still have the piercing I did decades ago although I don’t wear earrings at all. If you pluck eyebrows they grow back after a dew days how’s that permanent lol ? 😂
@@craycray507 exactly. Allah won’t leave important things for guessing or be in clear. And even they say prophet ﷺ has said when you come to masjid you should smell good and he used Parfum too he didn’t do it for women, he did it to smell good in front people and not bother them with bad sweat. I don’t see why for women it is different. I really can’t stand bad smells, I feel it so strong that I feel pain in my stomach. So why torture others with stinky smell?
Perfume is allowed at home but not to attract non-mahram!
I see Shabir as a rational and intellectual, though some guys, who are taqleedis or traditionalists and believe that every hadith is true are here and calling the sheikh as ignorant in some comments. Here is the channel of the rational muslim, not the cultural, dogmatic and "weak hadith" followers, in this case, those who prioritize false "narations" than following the quran and it's teachings. Listen and use your mind and be grateful to him for his time and effort!!
Atomizer right on brother
Atomizer I like shabir than dr.naik and deedat
How is it rational to say what ALLAH in the Quran says about eternal hell fire that He(ALLAH) even swore about is not a real thing ?
The hadith he quoted wasn't actually weak though about plucking eyebrows. But Allah knows best.
Very well said.
So many people these days are using fear to bring people to Islaam with so many restrictions, rules and regulations mostly for women and then they say women have more rights than men.. ppffft
He is not a constipated scholar and that's why I like him, he is full of knowledge.
What an intellectual and well spoken individual
Aisha Khaja is doing a superb job to draw out answers from a Dr Shabir Ally. Her friendly approach is pretty good. Great team both of you. Keep it going. I am so impressed that Shabir quoted a part of Lord's Prayer. Clearly the Holy Spirit or the spirit of God/Allah is working in all of us to become good human beings whatever theology and apologetics we may wish to hold to protect our personal faiths. Best wishes from London.
1:44 Prophet Muhammad did said that because in those times bedouin women used to completely shave their eyebrows and draw new ones. It's like plastic surgery they were completely removing what Allah gave them and making something different and new they want but I don't think we're cursed just because we trim and shape it until we completely pluck them off and draw new ones. Besides, our religion tells us to look our best as much as we can.
Also, I had a request can you please make a video on Mukhanith and their ruling and what differs them from Khasis and is it same to Transgender. I mean here in Bangladesh our Imam divides Third Gender people in to 4 groups= Aqua, Zenana, Khunsaye mushkila and Khutna. I'm so confused please do make a video that, HUGE REQUEST. Love the Sheikh and your videos 💓
Regarding plucking, I differ a bit with Dr. Shabir reasoning of assuming the fabrication of hadith. There is a Sahih (authentic) hadith in Bukhari 4886 (and Muslim too) in this respect. Interestingly, in that Hadith Allah curses women who tattooed, women who removed hair from face, and women who make spaces between their teeth artificially as they change Allah's creation by doing these things. I think research could be done on how the hair from face were removed in that era. I assume that it might be a thing that whole eye brows were removed for beautification and it was condemned as it changes Allah's creation. Importantly, Maulana Ishaq says that in one hadith Hazrat Ayesha was asked once can I thin my brows for my husband and Ayesha replied you can do it if your husband desires. Being a student myself, I tried to find that reference and would appreciate if someone can find the exact reference and share it with me.
May Allah guide us all the best.
But that last bit wouldn't make sense either, because how can a husband's desire change something from being unlawful to lawful? If plucking the eyebrows really bring on a curse from god no man can break that! I don't understand how people believe this , something is either lawful or unlawful. Period. No man can change halal to haram just because he doesn't like how his wife's eyebrows looks that's just ridiculous.
@@ferielmini true. A man can not just make it halal but from what I know if things like these are causing space between a wife and a husband and the husband finds it repulsive or vice versa (if the wife finds it repulsive) they are allowed to do it so as not to cause rifts between couples. It works both ways. The woman has to look good for her husband and the husband has to look good for his wife. Rest Allah knows❤️
Hadith like Dr. Ally said is sometimes shaky, so I generally look to Quran for guidance on numerous issues. I have not found any prohibition against plucking the eyebrow or any mention of any verse that would be a logical extension for its prohibition.
@Toshin Ahnaf that’s a bit rough. So following Quran makes one devil but following hadiths when we know there are many fabrications automatically makes us pious Muslims? This is why the prophet prohibited any writings about him because he knew eventually those would overtake the Quran, you are a walking example. While I do not reject hadiths I am repulsed by people calling someone Kafir or devil for holding the Quran in higher regard than hadith. You are not only insulting the words of Allah but showing how brainwashed you are… have some shame.
@@fatimaxo4885 quranists exclusively follow quran and reject the hadith completely. that's why that guy said that. you took his comment way out of proportion. also, how do you know that the prophet prohibited any writings about him?
So proud of you dear brother to make it clear that our Prophet Muhammad did not go around cursing people! It only makes sense! You gave a good explanation of how this may have come about! May Allah award you!
The answer by this scholar is very vague & misguiding, I request you to look up to other scholars eg: farhat hashmi for better guidance
It is not about "opinions", this is the Religion of Allah, not philosophy. Plucking the eyebrows in Haram without any doubts. There are many Sahih Ahadith and it is also what the Sahabah practiced and preached. Our Senior Scholars ( Ibn Baz, Uthaymeen, Fawzan, etc.) say that it is absolutely Haram. So is your opinion based on evidence or is it just an opinion as you said?
lol...haram??? You made a mockery of Islam.... as well as your salafis references. Nuts!
Ibn Baz gave a fatwa that plastic surgery is permisseble (for instant there was a guy he said that he found it difficult to get married because of his nose ). In my opinion is plastic surgery altering the creation of Allah SWT.
Hair grows back alhamdullilah.
ghozmit1
U are irrelevant in the wider scheme of things
M E Lol wut?
Don’t you know only Allah can forbid(haram) something if it’s not forbidden in Quran you can live and be a Muslim by believing in Hadiths nobody cares about dumb people like you. This the religion of Allah is Quran which is his words and he guarantee of that but not of man made written Hadiths 200 years later after the death of prophet
Alhamdulillah. We have such sheikhs in our lyf
It was said to me once, that prostitutes back then, removed the whole eye brow as a sign to be recognized.
That is the reason for the cursing.
thanks for giving me information.
And that means....??
Well nobody wants to remove their whole eyebrow. Also prostitutes also wore perfume, makeup, jewelry, fancy clothes…Muslim Women can do all those things today depending on who can see them so why are eyebrows alone cause for curse? By that logic everything prostitutes did is supposed to be a cause for curse but it isn’t. Shaping eyebrows is no different than cutting your nails since they both grow and are not considered permanent changes to creation. I can understand keeping nails short for hygienic reasons but it is nonetheless the same concept as temporary change.
Women can not wear fancy make up outside!
thank you for the clarification on the plucking eyebrow. it will grow back, plucking the hair of the eyebrow it's not permanent baldness (just like your hair - unless there's some deficiencies, like baldness)
Thank you.... 😍😍.. I'm so happy I've got u..... U r the reason I started to have faith again
Sister Ayesha, the interviewer, I think you should engage more with Dr Shabbir's replies. For example you could have asked him to explain when he said wudu includes wiping over socks rather than washing the feet as is established in the Islamic scholarship. Similarly his reasons to reject the hadith of plucking the eyebrows needed more probing. Is there any indication in text or any issues in the reporters that he used to not accept it. If it is based on his opinion then what is so important about his opinion rather than anybody else's.
You have qouted a valid point....that hadeeth of plucking eyebrows is sahih hadeeth(means authentic) yet shockingly mr. Shabir brushed it aside as week
@@zahednow scholars often dispute whether a hadith is sahih or not. One scholar says yes, the other may say no
@@Hamza000h disputes are more on the interpretation rather than authenticity of it. As this plucking eyebrows hadith is mentioned in bukhari (one of most highly regarded books of hadiths) so no scholar can doubt on it's authenticity
@@zahednow if i may say, i invyte u to look into the situation more. There have been major scholars of the past to pick up on hadith in sahih muslim and bukhari and question their authenticity. An example of this is the hadith in muslim on the prophets parents.
Although vast majority are sahih, you should just be aware that some hadiths were and are questioned
@@Hamza000h agreed with your point. But now can we discuss this specific topic i.e. plucking eyebrows hadith, because the manner in which this scholar is interpreting & disregarding that hadith is very wrong
I agree with you Brother Shabbir. Quran Speaks team is doing wonderful work... may Allah bless you all
Thank you Dr. Shabbir Ali. May Allah bless you with a good hayat.
What if we have been mis interpreting this Hadith . And it means don’t shave off the whole eyebrow . Because what’s the difference between that and trimming the beard ?
I appreciate his stance on eyebrow plucking. And Allah knows best.
It was narrated that 'Abdullah said:
"I heard the Messenger of Allah ﷺ say: 'May Allah curse Al-Mutanammisat, women who have tattoos done and women who have their teeth separated, those who change the creation of Allah, Mighty and Sublime."
Not 100% true!
I really like this Hoxha, it made me change my mind cause for a while was trying so hard to avoid everything that is considered haram in the Hadiths. Realize the Hadiths arent 100% sure so if some wanna follow it no problem i don't mind these People. Do whats best for you but i totally not gonna be into Hadiths cause there is just Informations that arent true at all. As an revert was hard first to decide what truly is right but i got it now. Like this Hoxha cause he isn't ,,HARAM!''
The Hadith he mentioned is in sahih Bukhari and Muslim and was classified as sahih Hasan by Albany. So there is no reason for this sheikh not to accept it. This is frustrating.
Sahih hadiths aren't 100% reliable. In fact, they also have contradictions with each other and aren't exempt from fabrication. The only hadiths that are regarded as very reliable are the ones that come from the first three generations of Muslims known as Mutawātir hadith, but there also aren't that many of them.
Would tattoos fall into that same category to? As in a hadith prophet Muhammed PBUH also said curse be to the one who gets and the one gives a tattoo. The common understanding is that like eyebrow plucking, it is supposedly changing the creation of Allah swt.
May Allah bless you and preserve Dr shabir Ally, i have been watching you since a child. JAZAK Allah Khair
Masha-Allah beautiful. I love your channel.
It was narrated that ‘Abd-Allaah said: “Allaah has cursed the women who do tattoos and those who ask for tattoos to be done, those who ask for their eyebrows to be plucked, and the women ask for their teeth to be filed for the purpose of beautification, changing the creation of Allaah.” A woman from the tribe of Bani Asad whose name was Umm Ya’qoob heard of that and she came and said, “I have heard that you have cursed So and so and So and so.” He said, “Why should I not curse those whom the Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) cursed and who are mentioned in the Book of Allaah?’ She said, “I have read what is between the two covers [of the Qur’aan], and I did not find anything in it like what you have said.” He said, “If you have read it, have you not read that Allaah says,
‘And whatsoever the Messenger (Muhammad) gives you, take it; and whatsoever he forbids you, abstain (from it)’
[al-Hashr 59:7]?”
She said, “Of course.” He said, “He forbade that.” She said, “I think your wife does it.” He said, “Go and look.” So she went and looked and she did not see what she was looking for. He said, “If she had been like that, she would not be with us.”
Narrated by al-Bukhaari, 4604; Muslim, 2125
Subhana'Allah this hadith is in both bukhari and Muslim, in both the saheeh books, bukhari being the most authentic book after the quran, how can we disagree with a saheeh hadith???
Baaraka LLAAHU feekum, brother.
Thank you for this. These people have done more harm than good.
May Allah save the Ummah from them.
Asalamulaikum Sisters and brothers,
i wanted to ask about plucking eyebrows
As i have developed unibrow (hair in between eyebrows) and little bit of uneven hair on the bottom line and above
I wanted to ask that can i thread or pluck them
Will i get cursed?
Is it the part of the eyebrow or not
Thank You
Walikumsalam, the middle section is not considered eyebrows.
You can watch the video of Shaykh Yahya Ibrahim about it: ruclips.net/video/-p56lOzOwHQ/видео.html
@@syedshababahmed5209 thank you 🙂
Unibrows and hairs around are ok.
I wanna know about water supply system during prophet's time. Cz it is related to obligatory gusul after intercourse. Was water so accessible that people (especially newly married couples) could perform farj gusul after the act each time?
Just look at human actions and you'll realize that if any of God's creations deserves hell, it's human beings.
If God didn't send humans to hell, that'd be unfair to other creatures. And He can't be an "All Loving God" by only loving humans and forgetting His other creations.
I love this guy
I heard from a scholar once that the hadith on plucking eyebrows has been mistranslated. The scholar said that the arabic word that is often translated into 'women who pluck their eyebrows' or 'women who remove hair from their face' actually meant 'women who partially shave their heads' because in historical arabia it was fashionable for women, black women specifically, would tattoo their eyebrows and file between their teeth AND to shave from the forehead till the top of the head leaving half of the face and scalp bald which seemed very odd and unsightly. Then the Prophet P.B.U.H. expressed his disdain of these dramatic alterations to the human body in the sake of empty beauty trends.
I think this hadith can also be applied today e.g. the current trend is to get gigantic fake lips and botox etc. simply for the sake of the trend and we must avoid it just like the Prophet P.B.U.H. guided women back then to avoid these materialistic meaningless gains.
Yes u are correct….. we are allowed to clean our eyebrows but not to alter the shape of them……
@@faithjames8900 That makes sense *sarcasm*
I was trying to find a video that throws some light on the topic of birthday celebrations and its permissibility as per Qur'an and authentic hadeeth. Please help me with this, Jazak Allah.
You can celebrate it...but no music or dancing or wishing...
Not true. We are forbidden from imitating the kuffar . Dont speak without knowledge.
Ok yes alcohol is halal iswel in my own opinion bec drinking a little will not mk me feget Allah pfft really if Allah forbids something you don't question you act upon it simple quran 6:116 and I'f you obay most of those upon the earth (including courupt scholars) they will misled you from the path of Allah they follow not except assumption and they are not but falsifying. Now am not saying he's wrong all the time but this i don't agree 100% false
This is quranic verse no denial in it,,,,,, but many things in hadeeth is already contradictory few years back it has been updated and some hadeeth has been removed too,, and I'm talking about bukhari,,,,, and bukhari was the one who decided which hadeeth to be recorded or rejected how can we affirm on him,,, in sahi bukhari compilation he rejected many hadeeth and note down many of it too,,,,, if he rejected the hadeeth which is week then what's the guarantee of the hadeeth which he compiled is right it may also be fabricated,,,,, after all it was his and his colleagues mind who differentiated that
And talking about alcohol yes in moderate proportion it doesn't harm you but the main thing that if you even start drinking little of it,,, it has the tendancy to be addicted and soon you will become more and more addictive towards it,,,, and when you have it regularly you know it's consequences what happens after it,, it destroys your own body your mind and some times it affects the people around you,,,,,,,,, that is the reason it is directly stated by the almighty to abandon it and what Allah says in quran there's no if and but,,, indeed Allah knows the best
can someone clarify are you allowed to remove the hair In between your eyebrows
Yes.
If course every scholar says so.
Mohamad Tahir Ibn Ashoor said that the plucking eyebrow and other hadiths like it includes some habits that were related to prostitution at that time so in our time any habits that will have the same signals will be prohibited too
Finally I have doubt eyelashes put or not plz say anyone wat he said
Lovely answer!
Good teacher he can guide us well.
Need more enlighten on this topic
I am so happy that I found this guy! I was starting to think I was crazy for not believing in all the BS I hear from Muslims. InshAllah once the Ummah is more educated, we will move on past all this BS. People really think plucking eyebrows is haram!? LOL
H Mahdi it’s a Hadith, if you don’t believe the sayings of the prophet pbuh when you are supposed to please educate yourself before making ignorant comments
H Mahdi I agree however the problem is this “ bs” is a big business. It makes people a lot of money
BS? Please refrain from such foul language. This is a religious post.
Also, I would advise you to be kinder to those whose opinion differs from yours.
Most people believe that plucking eyebrows is haram out of RESPECT for Imam Bukhari.
Let's not spread arrogance and hate.
Ok I have a unibrow so can I thread the mid section so that it can be a distinct 2 brows? I also get made fun of for this and my unibrow has to go😂
You could thread the mid section and it doesn't have to be plucking the eyebrows 👌👌
@@thefalcon7021 is it?? 😭
@@bangtansoneyondantiktoks3755 yes, threading the mid section is ok the only issue is plucking the brows from under or above to reduce its size or change its looks
@@thefalcon7021 thank you❤ ..its remove my confusion
@@thefalcon7021 for women only or both??
Thank you so much
So if you pluck can you do hair extensions?
So does the eybrows refer to men too??
He is so good !!!! 💕💕
making it up as they go along
Just because you’re not convinced this does not necessarily mean Rasool Allah SAW didn’t say it.
Razz c i thought the same thing.
But you don't know that he said it! Just because you are convinced doesn't mean he said it!
Do more videos like this !!
You can argue about every hadeez if that is the case. 🤷♂️
@??? i suggest u watch him and understand what he means
Yes true ....that is the reason his interpretation is giving more question than answer
Well yes of course duh.
We should analyze every hadith!
is it prohibited only for women or both men n women
Salaam. Jesus pbuh denies returning to earth in surah 5. I think the ahadith relating to this have defects. I'm surprised Dr Shabbir did not mention this.
Is there any sahih hadith about eyebrows?
This is sahih but not 109% true.
Women here in comments thanking and praising him because answer goes to thier way but The hadeeth which says that the woman who plucks the eyebrows or who has that done is cursed was narrated by al-Bukhaari (4886) and Muslim (2125), from the hadeeth of ‘Abd-Allaah ibn Mas’ood (may Allaah be pleased with him)??????? What about this?
Look is Mohammed allah? No so can he just ban thing randomly or not?
And?
Doesn't make it true.
Subhaan Allaah!
I cannot believe he’s saying this!
1. What he’s saying is ABSOLUTELY NOT TRUE.
It is proven BEYOND DOUBT that Ahaadeeth were written down DURING the lifetime of the Prophet sal Allaahu Alayhi wa sallam.
Yes it’s true that the Prophet sal Allaahu Alayhi wa sallam had INITIALLY asked the Sahaabah to not record hadeeth
He Sal Allaahu Alaiyhi wa Sallam said:
“Do not write down anything from me except the Qur’aan.” (Muslim).
The ulama gave several reasons why he said that.
1. The prohibition to write down hadeeth was at the BEGINNING when the Qur’aan was being revealed and the Prophet sal Allaahu Alayhi wa sallam did not want people to *MIX* the *Qur’aan* with *hadeeth*.
2. He didn’t want them to write hadeeth on the same paper or material as the Qur’aan was written.
3. It was preferred to memorize hadeeth by heart rather than writing it down.
Imaam an-Nawawi said:
“The prohibition was in effect when there was the fear that (the words of the Prophet
Sal Allaahu Alaiyhi wa Sallam
might be mixed with the Qur’aan.
When that danger was no longer present, permission was given to write down (ahaadeeth).
And it was said that the prohibition mentioned in the hadeeth referred to writing ahaadeeth on the same page as Qur’aan, lest they become mixed and thus the reader would be confused when looking at this page.”
(Sharh’ saheeh Muslim)
Later this order of not writing hadeeth was ABROGATED and the Prophet sal Allaahu Alayhi wa sallam actually INSTRUCTED the Sahaabah to write down hadeeth.
So the prohibition was ONLY TEMPORARY and only for SOME people and the Prophet sal Allaahu Alayhi wa sallam ALLOWED the writing of hadeeth
PROOF:
Abdullaah ibn Amr radhi Allaahu anhu said:
“I used to write whatever I heard from the Prophet Sal Allaahu Alaiyhi wa Sallam and wanted to learn it by heart. Some people of the Quraysh dissuaded me and said,
"Do you write everything you hear from the Prophet, while he is a human being and sometimes he may be in anger as any other human beings may be?"
Abdullaah ibn Amr conveyed this to the Prophet Sal Allaahu Alaiyhi wa Sallam.
The Prophet Sal Allaahu Alaiyhi wa Sallam pointed to his lips and said:
“I swear by the One in whose hands is the soul of Muhammad: nothing comes out from these two (lips) except truth.
So (go ahead) *DO WRITE*.”
(Abu Dawood- saheeh)
That’s why many Sahaabah had their own ‘Suhuf’
(manuscripts) and personal collections of ahaadeeth by the time the Prophet sal Allaahu Alayhi wa sallam passed away.
The Sahaabah had memorized the ahaadeeth well and had written them down very much IN the lifetime of the Prophet sal Allaahu Alayhi wa sallam.
And thus, the ahaadeeth of the Prophet sal Allaahu Alayhi wa sallam were *well preserved*.
2. Verification of the authenticity of ahaadeeth is a very serious issue and scholars have spent their ENTIRE lifetime studying and then verifying the authenticity of ahaadeeth.
In fact there’s a whole science to the study of ahaadeeth and their authentication.
It’s called “Mustalah al-Hadeeth”
When Allaah Subhaanahu wa Ta’aala promised to preserve this Deen, He did not just preserve the Qur’aan.
Rather He ALSO preserved the Sunnah through the Sahaabah of the Prophet sal Allaahu Alayhi wa sallam.
Allaah says:
“Verily We: It is We Who have sent down the Dhikr (i.e. the Qur’aan and Sunnah) and surely, We will guard it (from corruption).” (Surah al-Hijr:9)
Here in the above Aayah, Allaah Subhaanahu wa Ta’aala used the word “dhikr”.
and promised to guard it.
He did NOT use the word “Qur’aan” or “Kitaab” or any other word that could mean “just” His Book by *itself*.
Rather Allaah used the word “dhikr” or “reminder” because BOTH the Qur’aan AND the authentic Sunnah are means of guidance for us.
BOTH the Qur’aan and the authentic ahaadeeth are a source of legislation for us and BOTH the Qur’aan and authentic ahaadeeth are needed to truly understand and implement the orders of Allaah Subhaanahu wa Ta’aala.
That’s because the authentic ahaadeeth are an EXPLANATION of what the Qur’aan contains and it’s the PRACTICAL IMPLEMENTATION of its injunctions.
How else can a person know how much Zakaah to give or how many rak’aat in each prayer, or how to perform Hajj or how to slaughter an animal or how to implement all the ibaadaat and rulings?
The Prophet sal Allaahu Alayhi wa sallam showed us *practically* what Allaah wants from us.
And if that itself is “questionable”, Aoodhu Billaah, then how would the Deen be preserved?
How would people know HOW to practice the Deen if the very explanation of how to implement the Deen was lost?
So just as Allaah preserved the Qur’aan, He preserved the Deen by preserving the ahaadeeth of the Prophet sal Allaahu Alayhi wa sallam.
Allaah enabled the Sahaabah to memorize, and write down the ahaadeeth of the Prophet sal Allaahu Alayhi wa sallam JUST AS they memorized and wrote down the Qur’aan.
The Sahaabah then passed that knowledge on to the next generation, the Tabi’een and they memorized it and wrote it down and preserved it well.
As more people came into Islaam, the need to preserve the authentic ahaadeeth was of utmost importance so
Allaah enabled the scholars to develop a whole science that meticulously checked and verified the authenticity of the words, deeds and approvals of the Prophet sal Allaahu Alayhi wa sallam.
Utmost care was taken to record the noble hadeeth of the Prophet Sal Allaahu Alaiyhi wa Sallam in the most accurate manner.
The scholars developed a whole system of evaluating and criticizing the different narrators of hadeeth according to certain VERY STRICT CONDITIONS so as to check the reliability of their narrations, including their knowledge, and even their mental health at the time of narrating hadeeth, *when* and *where* they traveled to, and *who* they met to hear or relay ahaadeeth.
The scholars even recorded the names of those that tried to corrupt the deen by fabricating ahaadeeth or narrate unreliable narrations.
This way they were able to protect and distinguish the authentic ahaadeeth and weed out the weak or fabricated ones.
This is a *very* brief explanation of the science of preservation of hadeeth.
I could go on and on.
When you study the science of hadeeth and how Allaah Subhaanahu wa Ta’aala preserved this beautiful and vital part of our Deen, it s literally MIND BOGGLING.
Subhaan Allaah it is just amazing and you immediately realize that none of this could even be possible in the slightest EXCEPT that it was the Divine Work of Allaah Subhaanahu wa Ta’aala.
For more information please read the book “Introduction to the science of hadeeth” in the following link
sunnahonline.com/library/fiqh-and-sunnah/277-introduction-to-the-sciences-of-hadith
And Allaah knows best
Written by Asmaa bint Shameem the student of sheikh Mohammed AsSawi, and sheikh Waleed Basiyouni, both are students of Sheikh Mohammed Ibn Saleeh AlOtheimeen and sheikh Bin Baz.
Thank u so much
I have a question. While I don't believe there has been a prophet since Muhammad, I am not so convinced that the one verse we quote on the issue can be considered Quranic proof. Surely if the link between man and God through messengers has been around since the start of our existence, to say that that link is now ended requires more clarification that two words.
The link has not ended coz we have the Quran- the best way to connect to god. You cannot get a better link than that. :)
+ElPocho DelMundo Actually I'm saying that the premise of Muhammad's finality is unsupported in the Quran to begin with, that all its stories imply to us that prophethood is continuous, and Im saying that the suggestion that the title "seal of the prophets" once used in the Quran in reference to Muhammad which is literally two Arabic words fully supports demonstrates and clarifies this finality idea, is weak at best and actually it could mean a host of other things. Such a fundamental change requires a good reason, maybe a clear sign or a change in our circumstances or perhaps some shifting in the very constants of the universe, anything really, that demonstrates why this change has to happen.
+Curtis Jea Adams Brother, it is not just the Quran but we also have saheeh hadeeths that inform us about this. I agree that the Quranic phrase can be translated differently but we cannot deny the clear meaning of saheeh hadeeths as these are authentic sayings of our prophet(pbuh). He clearly said that there will be no prophet after him. I know this idea may seem odd to comprehend at first but we must also not forget that Allah(swt) is the most wise. He knows best what to do and how to do. Sometimes we could understand it and sometimes we cannot. We humbly accept everything whether it satisfies our little mind or not. Salaam
+MOHD SAQUIB Yes brother but the important concepts of the religion have to originate in the Quran, then hadith usually provides more details, like footnotes. Allah knows best.
Well I am an Ahmadi Muslim, we believe that prophethood continues but only under the law of the Qur'an because it's the final law of Allah, our community was declared as non-muslim because of this 'heretical' belief, we do not conform to the idea that Jesus (AS) was raised physically to heaven as there is NO proof for this whatsoever and is an idea which was adopted later in Islam due to ignorance, we believe firmly just as Elijah was thought to have ascended to heaven was a false belief but the Jews were awaiting for Elijah (AS) to descend from the heaven as per prophecies in the Bible, Jesus (AS) declared John the baptist/Yahya (AS) to be the second coming of Elijah (AS), so the same way we believe that Mirza Ghulam Ahmad (AS) is the second coming of Jesus (AS), we believe that Jesus (AS) went to find the lost sheep of the house of Israel to convey the message of Allah just as his mission was, he said "I am not sent but to the lost sheep of the house of Israel", if Jesus (AS) did ascend to heaven he failed his mission, because not all of tribes of Israel were nearby at the time (hence why they were called 'lost') Let me know what you think and let me know if you need more information. Thanks
So it’s okay to do plucking ?
You decide if you want to follow that dubious hadith or not.
@@waymilky442dubious ? Muslim and Bukhary the 2 most authentic books of hadith you can find .
I remember a time when people that wasnt sure would leave it for the sake of Allah now everybody wants to follow their passion
Sister, if I make questions in the comments can I get the answers, please tell me
You need to go to their website, click on participate and then click on ask a question.
@@hals634 Can you give me the link please
Redwan Green www.quranspeaks.com/participate
@@hals634 The answer by this scholar is very vague & misguiding, I request you to look up to other scholars eg: farhat hashmi for better guidance
I think I saw a vid you did before about abraham in islam, is it still around?
I am a Muslim and I believe strongly on every aspect of Islam which is based on logic and facts, but I am helpless to understand few things.
God was told on the creation of Adam that they will do badly on earth, how do angles know the future? though they didn't have the intellect think other than what God instructs them to do.
This intelligence implies to the behavior of making choices to do evil or God, yes or no and which can be proved by satin, he made a decision to not to bow and he ' disobeyed".
God almighty never makes mistake, but for creating Adam he was proven wrong the angles, because of what Adam did.
If God knew that satin will cajole him to do what he is forbidden to do that instead of satin why Adam was punished and banished to earth.
Was there Eve with Adam??
fowad khan
First there was prophet Adam(as). Eve/Hawa(as) came later on. However when they were punished, Eve(as) was with Adam.
The angels never knew that bani-Adam/humans was going to sin. They just assumed so, because humans have a free will, the Jinn (who were on earth befor Humans) also had a free will, and they oppressed and killed each other, and caused great mischief on earth... So, since humans also got free will, the angels assumed they would be just like the Jinn...
Satan will be punished because he invited Adam(as) to sin, which was through whispering. Adam(as) and Eve/Hawa(as) was punished because he sinned...
fowad khan God never made any mistakes, God knows everything and that was his plan. Verily, I am going to place (mankind) generations after generations on earth." They said: "Will You place therein those who will make mischief therein and shed blood, - while we glorify You with praises and thanks (Exalted be You above all that they associate with You as partners) and sanctify You." He (Allah) said: "I know that which you do not know." It says that God knows what the angels don’t, it doesn’t mean the angels were right, it means God knows his intentions and his plan. Please read and research properly before assuming that God made a mistake. There is not a single flaw in the Quran. You just have to understand it properly
So true, otherwise men trimming or dedigning their beards would have been haram too
Unapologetically, Shabbir Ali should not speak for Islaam.
The companions are trustworthy and scholars of old have studied chains of narrations. Rejecting the tradition of The Prophet on the premise of not trusting narrators is such a flawed argument.
is it haram to wish merry christimas? participate in christmas celebrations and festivities?
is there a verse that mentions it?
or does this only applies to certain countries?
thank you.
Qur'an teaches that God neither begets nor is He begotten.
And I believe merry Christmas means something to do with God has begotten a child...then it is against Qur'an...
christmas is pagan tradition, its not part of Jesus the Prophet! did you know christmas was even banned in England in the 16 or 17th century because of its pagan origins?
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christmas_controversies
You have answers to your loaded questions.
Thank You.
Yes...it's haram and inappropriate
Jesus in the son of God. Whoever quoted specific verses to lie to you, indeed lie to you. You need to research it for yourself. You need to be save.
You are right some people invented hadith. That is why whole texts were written about validating hadith and yet you decide a hadith classed as sahih cannot be true because you cannot IMAGINE the prophet pbuh saying it. So if i were to not be able to imagine the Messenger pbuh saying something (due to my desires or any other reason)then its okay for me to reinvent deed. Also let us assume that a man had to invent a hadith and came home to his wife, who would invent a hadith saying that she must not pluck her eyebrow?
No muslims do not generally hold that Jesus will return. They firmly believe as a consensus that he will definitely return. What is wrong with you man?
💯
This is a great question but I really think Islam is so reasonable and it’s in your heart. It’s really easy to ask yourself question if you are fair minded whether things make sense. If you want to just invent because of your desire… then your hearts intent is not pure. It’s just simple
Sahih doesn't mean 100% true!
So the following question relationg to the first question in the video would be, how do we know which hadith is trustworthy and which ones aren't?
I'm shocked at what he said. If you listen to any scholar of Islam he won't have this answer. I'm wondering if this channel is secretly from some strange sect
why do you think that? this channel seems to be much more reliable than those with the scholars who barely speak english with a thick accent..
***** Maybe I misunderstood but it seems that he is questioning the authenticity of a hadith based on what HE thinks the Prophet ASWS would say. That's a red flag to me.
Also, I know it's nice to be able to understand them but someone speaking english well isn't an indication of their proficiency in the Islamic sciences.
watercongas brother Sister there r narrations and chains of it .. strong and weeks ones .. follow the one that is known to be strong through the chain of narrations.. whatever the majority of the scholars known to be well known scholars say then follow that.. this brother basically gave his answer saying I don't believe the Prophet to be saying that ??? that's not how rulings work lol quite dangerous!
Seera Masters in love u for Allah's sake ! what u said is what I thought!
Great
We dont use our own logic when it comes to rulings in shariah!!! لاحول ولاقوة الابالله العلي العظيم
Mu'tazilites would've kept the muslim world on top.
At the cost of their Imam and success in the Akhirah? No, they would not have.
Allah knows best. People who spread wrong information are sinners.
more volume would be great
Selam
They still play those games, using ahadith to bend others to their will 😂😂😂
what is it about lizards and that we have to kill them to earn rewards???
السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته
It is blasphemous to reject authentic hadith or say the sahabah made up hadiths !!! Please tell me your degree as an imam?! استغفر الله!!! It's not about people finding hadiths strange أعوذ بالله
!&m not Muslim..... my friends are that..
Masa Allah
Question: What is the Islamic perspective/position of the Jewish claim of Jesus (a.s) not being the messiah because he did not fulfill the messianic prophecies, such as the rebuilding of the temple and leading the Jewish people to the Land of Israel ?
maybe he was rejected too soon before it could be accomplished?
from the Islamic perspective... the Torah was changed before Isa (a.s) even entered the scene. Most likely this was not an actual condition he needed to fulfill to prove his prophethood but just something that was added in to Judaic scripture after the death of Musa (a.s). Had it been an actual prophecy, Isa (a.s) wouldn't have been taken up by Allah before he could accomplish it.
batil
Who is Elijah?
+Abdul Salam
a prophet from the prophets of the jews in the OT
+بنت اليوتيوب :P Thank you
Elijah
What is wrong with this man? Sometimes his answers are so confusing, and is sending mixed signals. Don't be fooled Dr. And don't sell out your Deen. Islam is Organic and raw. Pure and straight. Say it at is. Don't please the creation, lest you misguide your soul and others. Pleasing the CREATOR is the duty of the believer no matter where he/ she is. And know that the ultimate destination is Akhirah (hereafter).
Yeah then follow Quran which is God’s words and he said not to follow any other book after Quran you’re the one confusing yourself
What is wrong withbyou?
does that mean if one hadith could be false what are the chance they all are false...???
Exactly, this is my problem as well. The Coran should be the important book and the WORD of GOD and NOT the Hadith.
How can you claim that a hadith can never be false? There were so many people who started talking about what our Prophet had said or done. Why should that be all true????
In this discourse we have the WORD of GOD vs. the word of man - You should decide for yourself what you are more believing in.
For me only the WORD of GOD is important.
I understand your point. I am not saying that the Hadith is ALL false. But the problem of today is that people claim a lot about Islam. As their statements cannot be supported by the Coran, they come up with the Hadith.
Just look at the role of women. Show me 1 single "sure" in the Coran which describes how a woman should be dressed. Contrary to this there are "obviously" hundreds of Hadiths telling/explaining how a woman should be dressed, how she should behave, etc.
This is why WE should more rely and stick to the Coran and not the Hadith which unfortunately has become more and more political.
In my opinion the core message of all religions is the same which lead to GOD. And GOD is one!
BTW: the shahada and its meaning is not rocket science - it is a very logical thought which says that there is only one GOD and Mohammad is His messenger. Why should this be something mentioned in the Coran?
Brother get your facts straight before accusing others of misleading, especially one who has spent all/most of his life learning/teaching the religion.
There are many hadith collected by our classical Muhaddith; Bukhari, Muslim, Imam ahmed etc.
Imam Bukharis collections of hadith was very meticulous and stringent.
Mr Shabir Ali is a contemporary scholar who is Not qualified to discuss the authentication of Hadith and it's applications.
This loose understanding is dangerous and puts doubts in every hadith and authentication of hadith.
theres ample of ahadith with regards to this topic, I would NOT take anything from him, Muslims should be very cautious!!!!
“Allaah has CURSED the woman who does tattoos and the one who has them done, the woman who plucks eyebrows and the one who has it done, and the one who files her teeth for the purpose of beauty, altering the creation of Allaah.” (Bukhaari, Muslim)
Do not add things to The Word of Allaah❤❤❤, The Almighty. To follow Bughari, Muslim and co.... this SHIRK. Woooo you.
His analysis is merly based on his thoughs ..no verse no hadess are being cited to support his views.
I just like your personality Dr but I'm not a Muslim and I will never be. You're a good person Dr may Allah bless you for your teachings
Why not?
Not what?
Be ready Jesus Christ is he’s returning back soon
According to Marks gospel, Jesus will tell you guys, the priests and pasters " get lost you evil and adelterous people, I don't know you "
returning to break the pagan idol crosses they worshipped him with instead of his Creator, kill the Anti Kristos False Messiah and to destroy the pigs that the Christians began eating after Paul's fake indoctrination!
fidel catsro Haha wonderfully said.
I once heard that Allah will eventually take everyone out from the hell including the modern day non muslims and He would only let the super arrogant like Abu Jahl and Abu Lahb types to stay in hell eternally. How true is that? Please answer me in the light of Quran. JazakAllah kheran kaseera.
Nida Aizaz Allah knws best .. it's in his knowledge.. but wicked people do go to hell :( .... but again abu thalib helped Muhammad Salalahualayhiwasalam all his life and even after prophet hood but didn't get guidance . Allah knws best
I pray so.... but God knows best. IMO we can’t rule out that possibility but not can we sit back and not take the whole thing seriously based on this possibility
Why hell ? Sorry please stop using emotion ! Justice is justice
Asalamualaikum Dr Shabbir, it would make things a lot clearer if you can explain why you feel this hadith is fabricated, as everywhere I've read most have classified it as authentic. I am confused as to why would a sahaba make up a hadith as I am sure they were God-fearing and wouldn't be so casual about inventing hadiths. Please share the context and elaborate a bit more as well for clarity. JazakAllah.
Here's Dr. Shabir's series on hadith: ruclips.net/p/PLFgZuRzI2wM7lUU7yIyD7p6uPHt_KUYzz
So Dr. "thinks" that Prophet Muhammad PBUH couldn't have said that, using his so called balanced approach and using logic. What a joke.
Well then we all can't see Allah SWT nor can I see jinns or Angels, might as become atheists, using balanced approach and logic.
What a joke.
I am confused
@@zaidmalik4376 confused about what?
U can't apply silly things like this to prophet (PBUH), plucking eye brows doesn't matter to Allah it's ur narrow thinking and perspective so keep it with you don't interpret things as per your convenience
@@syedsyed5929 who is saying that it's a silly thing?
I might say growing facial hair is a silly thing, or cutting nails is a silly thing, or covering one's body for that matter. Is drinking water sitting down also silly? Is eating from right hand also silly?
The question is who decides what's silly and what's not?
Are we to use our logic when it comes to these things?
Well our logic might say that there is no God altogether.
In Islam we follow the Qur'an and the Sunnah of the Prophet Muhammad. And we can't deny something just because our little brains can't decide if it's silly or not.
Excuse me ,
I dint say all sunnah is silly
Those which are silly or inhibits someone's right and make someone's life difficult are silly and they may be added or not maintained in its original form like doctor said
Theirs a hadith quoting about wife prostrating for husband ,wife sucking pus ,etc do u think they really are from prophet they are adulterated ones
Islam itself is logical ,u say don't apply logic
For that matter let me answer all of ur questions logically
Drinking water sitting @science says when u drink water standing their are high chances of stroke ,high chance of water directly entering stomach
2) cutting nails _bacteria and other microbes were first found by Anton von Leeuwenhoek from his teeth scraping and nails that's the reason prophet PBUH being a unlettered person gave it
Rather Allah says apply logic in Quran
Verily, the worst of living creatures in the sight of Allah are the deaf and dumb who will not reason.
Surat Al-Anfal 8:22
Please stop trying to make a deviated sect of islam, this is not the way to be or to call others to islam. We dont change anything in Islam .either we submit to Allah and ALL of His commands, including following our beloved prophetﷺ or we dont!! We dont change Islam to fit our nafs and to please others!!