ToK Essay 5 May 25: Models: Wrong but Useful

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 20 янв 2025

Комментарии • 10

  • @mahmoudelfadol6597
    @mahmoudelfadol6597 3 месяца назад +8

    you are a lifesaver

    • @toktoday7978
      @toktoday7978  3 месяца назад

      I'm glad you found it useful. Thanks for the comment.

  • @Sacred_Pandora
    @Sacred_Pandora 27 дней назад +2

    Thank you so much for the video. I find it rather challenging to structure the essay because models in human science (my other AOK) also utilises mathematics. It follows that it's counterproductive to separate the two AOKs in the discussion. But it sounds messy to discuss the two AOKs altogether. How would you approach the essay structure?

    • @toktoday7978
      @toktoday7978  23 дня назад

      Thanks for the comment, and the 'useful' question. You could explore the relationship between the two AoKs, particularly the use of mathematical models in AoK Human Sciences. IMO there's a lot of scope to discuss how mathematical models are produced in a largely hypothetical framework that requires interval, or ordinal, classes. However, they may be limited when applied to the Human Sciences which can be more qualitative in nature. As such, the mathematical model may shape the labelling, categorisation and interpretation of human scientific knowledge. This would then have to be applied to the question of whether this makes the model "wrong but useful" - that's the real focus of the essay.

  • @PANTERZ
    @PANTERZ 24 дня назад +2

    Is this part correct as a counter claim saying that indeed it was incorrect or disproved in first glance then it was proven correct and be useful, so it can be used in both ways?
    These earlier models, although incomplete, laid the groundwork for the answer to the theorem. Additionally, Wiles’s proof fostered new methods and influenced mathematical research. This underlines that mathematical models and proofs can suggest reliable frameworks with a low margin of errors considering comprehending intricate relationships, even while models can have limitations.

    • @toktoday7978
      @toktoday7978  23 дня назад

      Yes - you could certainly argue that models that seem initially 'wrong' may become more accepted as more evidence is collected. However, the more pertinent issue is whether the model can actually be 'wrong' at all. Just because collected evidence in that one scenario does not align with the model doesn't necessarily mean that the model is wrong. It depends on a range of factors such as intentions of the model producers & users, context, expectations etc etc

  • @kajagrkova8546
    @kajagrkova8546 3 месяца назад +3

    How many knowledge claims do we need in our essay

    • @toktoday7978
      @toktoday7978  3 месяца назад +1

      There's no prescribed min/max amount. However, if you start by writing 1 main claim for each AoK, and then developing smaller claims from the big ones you'll be on the right track. You can find out more here: www.toktoday.com/blog-posts/2023/12/05/mastering-tok-essay-structure-a-comprehensive-guide/

  • @kajagrkova8546
    @kajagrkova8546 3 месяца назад +1

    Can you di a video on the first prescribed title

    • @toktoday7978
      @toktoday7978  3 месяца назад

      I hope to have the video on Essay #1 uploaded by Thursday 17th Oct.