Did anyone notice how in sync their body language was at the end? The both flipped their hair and touched their face at the exact same time. Those two have a crazy cosmic connection.
I am infatuated with how they perform their music together. When they sing it's like there's this little deep seed growing in their hearts and it grows and blossoms as they push words beautifully out of their mouths. The way they look at each other just melts my heart.
I've never seen such a connection between a man and a woman that wasn't romantic in nature. Maybe that was the problem. Maybe that connection was spilling over into personal parts of their lives. Splitting would be the noble thing to do since they're both married.
After watching all their performances together I have a weird feeling that because they never got together romantically it lead to the break up of their band. When you're meant to be with someone and they with you but you force yourself to be with someone else, it just makes it too painful to be around each other.
+job1181 "they never got together romantically"I could be wrong (I often am), but I think it's exactly because they DID at some point "get together," that (being as they're both married to other people, and have kids) they had to break up the act.Check out their song, "The One That Got Away," and consider that one of their producers is on record as having said something to the effect of, "OMG, it's all right there in the song!"Not to suggest that it's any of our business anyway, mind you...Either way, it's a tragedy that the band is no longer; a lot of great music that we're never gonna get to hear now.
They toured by themselves early on, to small venues: record stores, schools, small bars. There are people on record who were around those performances who said they sure as hell seemed to be "together". Also, and sorry if this is a little sleazy, but she was married for 8, 9 years, childless until she got pregnant during that period, and childless in the years since the breakup. Just. Sayin'.
@@megatrollificus Joy has noted in at least one interview that she and Nate had multiple miscarriages during their marriage. I'm personally childless after 14 years of marriage. Children or lack thereof says absolutely nothing about the quality or virility of a marriage.
Run, run, run away Buy yourself another day A cold wind's whispering secrets in your ear So low only you can hear Run, run, run and hide Somewhere no one else can find Tall trees bend and lean pointing where to go Where you will still be all alone Don't you fret, my dear It'll all be over soon I'll be waiting here for you Run fast as you can No one has to understand Fly high across the sky from here to kingdom come Fall back down to where you're from Don't you fret, my dear It'll all be over soon I'll be waiting here for you For you, for you Don't you fret, my dear (Don't you fret, my dear) It'll all be over soon (It'll all be over soon) I'll be waiting here Don't you fret, my dear It'll be over soon I'll be waiting here for you For you, For you Run, Run, Run Away Run, Run, Run Away
To those whose want to take the mature attitude that everyone who sees signs of intimacy in their unbelievable chemistry is being prurient, consider: a) The 'denials' of any kind of affair are very carefully phrased not-exactly-denials. b) Singing is a physical act, and duet singing can indeed be very intimate. c) They toured by themselves (no kids or spouses) during 2009-2011. A lot. d) people who claim direct, on-site observation say they sure seemed to be 'together' during that time. e) Their performances, watched from first to most recent, show a clear arc from great personal affection (intimacy, little touches, singing to each other holding eye contact, etc...) to less and less such interaction. To the point that the video of their last show, last song, shows JP will not even look at her, and she is just...broken. And the singing stays, perfect, pure... And F) The sound! The perfect, or beyond perfect, merging of voices, and the lyrical content of the songs they wrote is just...well, it's more than I can believe that they are just 'selling the song' with so much passion, with zero personal feelings involved. Just don't fly. I hate TMZ, EW, the whole celebrity-selling media and the people who consume it...and yet...and yet. This story has hooked me, partly because of the stunning music, partly because they're attractive (and adults!), partly because of the mysteries behind it all. Turned me into one of those idiot people who get way more obsessed with the lives of the "stars" than they should. But I am so obsessed, I'll even point out one totally inappropriate fact: After 10 years of childless marriage, Joy had a child after touring with JP for a year. Just sayin'...
Thanks for this comment. For a long time I was denying their 'intimacy' arguing that they are performers and artists so of course they act intimate because their music is intimate. However, the more I delved into their personal and professional affairs (no pun intended), the more I am led to believe that they in fact either had a full blown affair, or at least a highly emotional affair, which is why their split was so inappropriately handled (cancelled shows, no touring to promote the second album, a very strange vibe at the last concert). The fact that even now, after so many years, they are still on non-speaking terms (at least Joy confirmed two years ago that the last concert was the last time she spoke to John Paul) says volumes. In fact, JP has not talked about Joy in none of his interviews, ever, since 2012. That is not normal for two ex-bandmates, especially when they are obviously lovely people, so whatever conflict they had back then simply had to be highly emotional. There is no way it was about "differences in ambition". Besides, I don't know if you know this, but Joy did say that her marriage was on the rocks the year the CW was touring and took a hiatus. She said they did couples therapy and it did wonders for them. But I guess the effect was temporary. They had a second child a few years later (another attempt to create intimacy in a crumbling marriage, in my opinion) and they have separated this year. No divorce papers signed yet but they aren't living together.
Amazing live rendition of "Kingdom Come"! Once again (as always) perfect harmonies, lilting guitar accompaniment, and pure emotion in both the lyrics and the performance. It really hurts to think of "what could've been" for these two. This is just "Musical Perfection"!!!
"It'll all be over soon". All too soon, dammit. Together they were a gift from God. If you like singing, human voices singing together, you know there's just not many like this. Binging two days on CW and JPW and it still hurts that they can't find a way to make this magic any more. Damn.
Bcoz their choice of judging music must not be good enough to know the power of this song.. (Note: by the way, its been a long time without this music so have a moment for this and feel the power in case if u havent )😊
It's so good to listen to this again. Brings back memories. I was only thirteen when I heard this--it was a part of The Hunger Games soundtrack and I was a huge fan of that series back then. This was their first song that I listened to and I was immediately hooked by the amazing harmony and the power of their vocals. Six years later, through their breakup and all, I still am in awe every time I watch them.
So, I finally found out who don't like them and their singing and songwriting: HIPSTERS!! Saw some comments on a review of Barton Hollow at the AV Club, HATED CW. Their criticisms were mostly self-serving inventions and imaginary flaws, but yeah, there are such people. Just so ya know.
Either they were, or wanted to be together. But it would ruin their marriages. So, they left, because it would keep their lives from falling appart. But honestly, with the way they were skyrocketing in the music business, they could have pulled it off. But they decided not to. So now we'll never know what could have been.
Is this from The Hunger Games? If so this is a sad sad song. Man, I just finished watching mocking jay again - film hits you like a hit in the gut, it's very good.
Yes there second album was not as good. Much more polished, produced and overall john paul white relegated to background singer. The magic was list in that album. Apparently he fought for them to keep it minimalist, and she and her husband pushed it in the direction that got recorded. No wonder the split. But JPW ths sound he was true to was what fans loved. Look at her over produced solo effort post civil wars, pretty awful.
She was actually a Christian pop singer BEFORE The Civil Wars, and that background must have just habitually influenced her artistic decisions even when it came to a non-pop project. I personally like some of her post TCW stuff, but I do agree that stuff like this is definitely her best work.
Check out her second album. She returned to the folk sound, and it's amazing. I was listening to her new song "Trouble with Wanting" and I couldn't help but imagine it sung with JP... The trouble with wanting is I want you, I want you all the time...
It's almost mixed, under their managers' direction (her husband), as a Joy Williams promotional album, with JPW as a "backup singer". We all know he was way more than that. That, plus the finances, with Nate Yetton taking a manager's cut, may have been a cause of the breakup. (but I still sense a more intense, more personal subtext to the whole thing)
Well, it may all feel uncertain right now, but I'd like to believe that they will. It may take way longer than we'd all like, but as long as they are trying, I'll keep faith that things will work out because what they have is truly special. Believe JP when he says that they're meant to be.
Such a shame they split. I don't think I've ever seen two musicians with such chemistry. They were so in tune with each other.
+CloudsHideTheSun Just a bit too much, as it turns out... :'(
Wait wait wait hold the truck up. They broke up? I JUST FOUND THEM! FUCK
Yep. Sorry to be the bearer of bad news. Get on Spotify and have a listen to their Barton Hollow album. It may help to dull the pain.
+CloudsHideTheSun OH. MY. GODDDDDDDD. I HAVE JUST FOUND THEM TOO
CloudsHideTheSun i
the fact that they broke up as a band breaks my heart. Their harmonies are breathtaking. And the chemistry they have is amazing
Ugh! They were so perfect. I hate that they aren't singing together. Like, literally, so perfect. The way they feed off of each other.
wait, they are broke up???
Yusuf Baskoro yes they did. i also discovered them 3 yrs ago only to know they were already disbanded 😭
i cant imagine being one of their partners and watching them play/sing together. Undeniable connection/chemistry.... far deeper than the music IMO
@@tracynthayer5331 oh for sure. Their chemistry was absolutely insane.
Did anyone notice how in sync their body language was at the end? The both flipped their hair and touched their face at the exact same time. Those two have a crazy cosmic connection.
I am infatuated with how they perform their music together. When they sing it's like there's this little deep seed growing in their hearts and it grows and blossoms as they push words beautifully out of their mouths. The way they look at each other just melts my heart.
Totally agree
This. Yes. Exactly.
Sadly they separated :(
That is beautifully put. You pushed these words out of your mouth very eloquently Tania 🙏
It's like a punch to the gut. I just can't let go. So. Damn. Good.
i feel your pain!!!!!!
saraliz30 same here 😰😢😥😓😣☹️☹️☹️
Same!!
Exackly.
I've never seen such a connection between a man and a woman that wasn't romantic in nature. Maybe that was the problem. Maybe that connection was spilling over into personal parts of their lives. Splitting would be the noble thing to do since they're both married.
That little smile that John Paul does after Joy fixes his hair is just about the cutest thing ever.
After watching all their performances together I have a weird feeling that because they never got together romantically it lead to the break up of their band. When you're meant to be with someone and they with you but you force yourself to be with someone else, it just makes it too painful to be around each other.
+job1181 "they never got together romantically"I could be wrong (I often am), but I think it's exactly because they DID at some point "get together," that (being as they're both married to other people, and have kids) they had to break up the act.Check out their song, "The One That Got Away," and consider that one of their producers is on record as having said something to the effect of, "OMG, it's all right there in the song!"Not to suggest that it's any of our business anyway, mind you...Either way, it's a tragedy that the band is no longer; a lot of great music that we're never gonna get to hear now.
They toured by themselves early on, to small venues: record stores, schools, small bars. There are people on record who were around those performances who said they sure as hell seemed to be "together". Also, and sorry if this is a little sleazy, but she was married for 8, 9 years, childless until she got pregnant during that period, and childless in the years since the breakup. Just. Sayin'.
No, Depp's (lol) head got too big for his hat and he didn't think he needed to have company on the stage. How wrong he was.
@@megatrollificus Joy has noted in at least one interview that she and Nate had multiple miscarriages during their marriage. I'm personally childless after 14 years of marriage. Children or lack thereof says absolutely nothing about the quality or virility of a marriage.
Run, run, run away
Buy yourself another day
A cold wind's whispering secrets in your ear
So low only you can hear
Run, run, run and hide
Somewhere no one else can find
Tall trees bend and lean pointing where to go
Where you will still be all alone
Don't you fret, my dear
It'll all be over soon
I'll be waiting here for you
Run fast as you can
No one has to understand
Fly high across the sky from here to kingdom come
Fall back down to where you're from
Don't you fret, my dear
It'll all be over soon
I'll be waiting here for you
For you, for you
Don't you fret, my dear
(Don't you fret, my dear)
It'll all be over soon
(It'll all be over soon)
I'll be waiting here
Don't you fret, my dear
It'll be over soon
I'll be waiting here for you
For you, For you
Run, Run, Run Away
Run, Run, Run Away
Joy and John Paul were pure magic together. So sad things didn't work out.
I get goose bumps every time I hear this. I downloaded and played this over and over for days on end. It's just surreal. Love it!!
To those whose want to take the mature attitude that everyone who sees signs of intimacy in their unbelievable chemistry is being prurient, consider:
a) The 'denials' of any kind of affair are very carefully phrased not-exactly-denials.
b) Singing is a physical act, and duet singing can indeed be very intimate.
c) They toured by themselves (no kids or spouses) during 2009-2011. A lot.
d) people who claim direct, on-site observation say they sure seemed to be 'together' during that time.
e) Their performances, watched from first to most recent, show a clear arc from great personal affection (intimacy, little touches, singing to each other holding eye contact, etc...) to less and less such interaction. To the point that the video of their last show, last song, shows JP will not even look at her, and she is just...broken. And the singing stays, perfect, pure...
And F) The sound! The perfect, or beyond perfect, merging of voices, and the lyrical content of the songs they wrote is just...well, it's more than I can believe that they are just 'selling the song' with so much passion, with zero personal feelings involved. Just don't fly.
I hate TMZ, EW, the whole celebrity-selling media and the people who consume it...and yet...and yet. This story has hooked me, partly because of the stunning music, partly because they're attractive (and adults!), partly because of the mysteries behind it all. Turned me into one of those idiot people who get way more obsessed with the lives of the "stars" than they should. But I am so obsessed, I'll even point out one totally inappropriate fact: After 10 years of childless marriage, Joy had a child after touring with JP for a year. Just sayin'...
Well about the kid thing...it could have been a way to reconnect the marriage/save it, too.
Thanks for this comment. For a long time I was denying their 'intimacy' arguing that they are performers and artists so of course they act intimate because their music is intimate. However, the more I delved into their personal and professional affairs (no pun intended), the more I am led to believe that they in fact either had a full blown affair, or at least a highly emotional affair, which is why their split was so inappropriately handled (cancelled shows, no touring to promote the second album, a very strange vibe at the last concert). The fact that even now, after so many years, they are still on non-speaking terms (at least Joy confirmed two years ago that the last concert was the last time she spoke to John Paul) says volumes. In fact, JP has not talked about Joy in none of his interviews, ever, since 2012. That is not normal for two ex-bandmates, especially when they are obviously lovely people, so whatever conflict they had back then simply had to be highly emotional. There is no way it was about "differences in ambition".
Besides, I don't know if you know this, but Joy did say that her marriage was on the rocks the year the CW was touring and took a hiatus. She said they did couples therapy and it did wonders for them. But I guess the effect was temporary. They had a second child a few years later (another attempt to create intimacy in a crumbling marriage, in my opinion) and they have separated this year. No divorce papers signed yet but they aren't living together.
This is a thrilling theory except for one thing--their manager was Joy's husband, and he traveled with them on their tours.
Fits The Hunger Games perfectly
Amazing live rendition of "Kingdom Come"! Once again (as always) perfect harmonies, lilting guitar accompaniment, and pure emotion in both the lyrics and the performance. It really hurts to think of "what could've been" for these two. This is just "Musical Perfection"!!!
"It'll all be over soon". All too soon, dammit. Together they were a gift from God. If you like singing, human voices singing together, you know there's just not many like this. Binging two days on CW and JPW and it still hurts that they can't find a way to make this magic any more. Damn.
Why does everyone I know in person think this song is depressing...?
It's beautiful :'3
Bcoz their choice of judging music must not be good enough to know the power of this song..
(Note: by the way, its been a long time without this music so have a moment for this and feel the power in case if u havent )😊
Y'all think this is pretty you should hear safe and sound- The civil wars featuring Taylor Swift. It takes you to District 12
Joy bravely looks at John. John holds back his emotions and looks back shyly...😍😍😍😍
Am I the only one that knows this was their song for the hunger games?
olivya oreoBD no you're not
Lol...uhm....no.
Love their pairing so sad their no longer together such amazing team they make such beautiful songs together
I like never seen their faces since 2013 just listened to their songs. And I am quite suprised that they look as good as their songs. Nice.
Today is a sad day for every fan of the civil wars :(
It's so good to listen to this again. Brings back memories. I was only thirteen when I heard this--it was a part of The Hunger Games soundtrack and I was a huge fan of that series back then. This was their first song that I listened to and I was immediately hooked by the amazing harmony and the power of their vocals. Six years later, through their breakup and all, I still am in awe every time I watch them.
So, I finally found out who don't like them and their singing and songwriting: HIPSTERS!! Saw some comments on a review of Barton Hollow at the AV Club, HATED CW. Their criticisms were mostly self-serving inventions and imaginary flaws, but yeah, there are such people. Just so ya know.
I love how they look each other's eyes when they sing :)) love ❤
I like this moment 2:38-2:46 :)
And at the end...it's like they both just got caught making out. Adorable.
Both almost guilty but a little proud, too. And they should be, their singing, together, is like...orgasmic, right?
So pure. Can't let it go either. Joy is ethereal and John Paul just takes off. Awesome!
Sadly they split they were my favorite duo ever! :(
That low, droning E he plays when he's strumming hard makes all the difference. A really eery, discomforting sound. Perfect for this soundtrack.
Very much. Good call. He's pretty self-deprecatory about his guitar playing, but he's good, he's clever, he can find tunes...
Either they were, or wanted to be together. But it would ruin their marriages. So, they left, because it would keep their lives from falling appart. But honestly, with the way they were skyrocketing in the music business, they could have pulled it off. But they decided not to. So now we'll never know what could have been.
they did the correct thing and in the end they still have their solo careers AND their families.
@@fannishfanning160 Joy & her husband separated last year. :(
they adore each other.
Love this song. Its like listening to a song while you're asleep and it makes you feel more cosy. Their voices are so soothing. :)
i feel like this performance has so much subtext on both ends....
Argh it sux they split. I can never get enough of these two. They were so perfect together. 😢😢😢
Did you guys see thaaaat?!?! he wiped his hair out of his face, as did she after him and then he wiped a tear out of his eye. My heart hurts.
So good. Too bad it ran away. And hid.
The dystopian future is upon us all...
Sencillamente bello !!
2019 and still missing them!!! 😭😭😭😭
Olivya oreoBD if you haven't noticed that safe and sound is by Taylor swift FEAT. The civil wars.
Taylor swift is singing basically the whole song.
You could tell me this was the studio version and I literally would never have known. Absolutely stunning vocals and guitar skills.
Is this from The Hunger Games? If so this is a sad sad song. Man, I just finished watching mocking jay again - film hits you like a hit in the gut, it's very good.
I love this so incredibly much.
always
so many Hunger Games feels
So take a nap from life have some good music again to get some freshness 😊
+Olivya oreoBD, it was on their album, Barton Hollow, as well.
Haunting. Beautiful. A truly tragic breakup.
Either way, I don't wanna wake up from you
what kind of dream is this?
I will never get over the beauty these two created.
Yes there second album was not as good. Much more polished, produced and overall john paul white relegated to background singer. The magic was list in that album. Apparently he fought for them to keep it minimalist, and she and her husband pushed it in the direction that got recorded. No wonder the split. But JPW ths sound he was true to was what fans loved. Look at her over produced solo effort post civil wars, pretty awful.
She was actually a Christian pop singer BEFORE The Civil Wars, and that background must have just habitually influenced her artistic decisions even when it came to a non-pop project. I personally like some of her post TCW stuff, but I do agree that stuff like this is definitely her best work.
Check out her second album. She returned to the folk sound, and it's amazing. I was listening to her new song "Trouble with Wanting" and I couldn't help but imagine it sung with JP...
The trouble with wanting is I want you, I want you all the time...
they ahould have stick to this formula but the 2nd album just sounded different , much far from barton hallow
It's almost mixed, under their managers' direction (her husband), as a Joy Williams promotional album, with JPW as a "backup singer". We all know he was way more than that. That, plus the finances, with Nate Yetton taking a manager's cut, may have been a cause of the breakup. (but I still sense a more intense, more personal subtext to the whole thing)
March 2022 always makes me feel better ❤️
one of my fave songs by them!!! they are so cool and love their music
2:27-2:34 The way the look and sing to each other ☺
Wait-who that guy in the background ??
I still think this is better than safe and sound though that one is really great too
greatest song for hunger games
They become one through the music. Mesmerizing and pure joy. They burned white hot, then were consumed by the flame.
JOHNNY DEPP DOPPELGANGER
+ruthiejable Its usage has been seriously upped since the advent of The Vampire Diaries. :D
I actually first discovered the word from watching the show How I Met Your Mother
Or a DEPPELGANGER
Nice.
I still miss them so much
I still think this is better than safe and sound though that one is really great too
i miss this
Love this song off the hunger games
Buen Vídeo Amigós👍😊🎶💕💕💕:-) son los mejores Gracias👍
This is from the hunger games
Rewatched the hunger games recently and heard this song and god it makes me so sad they broke up and thg is over :(
Ethereal. Not what I'd expect to play at the end of the hunger games....
Finally , I found this song after a long time
They are so talented ! Its beautiful
Chills.
coming back here because of the new hunger games prequel movie
i can't stop listening this
Absolute perfection! And live! So very impressive!!!!
I love it!
This is so special. Well done, guys;
Voices blend ...yeah !
So nice!
Beautiful voices.
AGH! SO....BEAUTIF...UL.....
Totally spellbound !
Это... это... ВЕЩЬ. В финальных титрах 'Голодных игр" её полюбил, но с видеорядом - другой уровень. Спасибо за эмоции.
Beautiful absolutely beautiful
I love the girls voice it's so pretty 🐱
It's the very first song I've ever heard from them. in the credits for the movie The Hunger Games. song, my love)). I love it!!
Three wishes camel
Still the greatest ❤
sp perfect it hurts.
: still missed.
Well, it may all feel uncertain right now, but I'd like to believe that they will. It may take way longer than we'd all like, but as long as they are trying, I'll keep faith that things will work out because what they have is truly special. Believe JP when he says that they're meant to be.
The woman signer is hot. I could fall in love quick. ❤️
Hermosa cancion....
chills
do you think they're gonna work it out? are there any news or reasons or just... something, anything?
adoro essa musica
Amazing
Bom d mais
❤
Dios Mio, la voz de Joy Williams es realmente hermosa *-*
Why did they stop singing together?
Love
They were both married
I had no idea TJ Miller was such a talented musician.
j'adore vos voix et cette chanson est magnifique merci
Ustedes alegran mis idas con sus hermosas canciones :3
This song helped me through talot of hard times