Artificial Intelligence, Democracy, & the Future of Civilization | Yoshua Bengio & Yuval Noah Harari
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 31 май 2023
- What does the future of Artificial Intelligence (AI) look like and how will it impact democracy and society? This question was explored by Prof.Yoshua Bengio, pioneer AI developer and Turing Award winner, and Prof. Yuval Noah Harari, bestselling author and historian - in a live discussion moderated by political journalist Vassy Kapelos.
Recorded on May 24 2023, as part of the C2 Montreal conference, presented by Mila - Quebec Artificial Intelligence Institute.
Professor Yoshua Bengio is recognized as one of the leading pioneers in AI research and development - known for his prestigious work in the field of deep learning. He is a Full Professor at Université de Montréal, and the Founder and Scientific Director of Mila - Quebec AI Institute.
Yuval Noah Harari is an Israeli public intellectual, historian and professor in the Department of History at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem. He is the author of the popular science bestsellers Sapiens: A Brief History of Humankind, Homo Deus: A Brief History of Tomorrow, and 21 Lessons for the 21st Century - most recently releasing his latest series for middle-grade readers, Unstoppable Us.
"We have a responsibility to prepare for the worst case" May I suggest that actually we have a responsibility to PREVENT the worst case.
< THIS
We are living in a Oppenheimer moment. It means we fucked up big time and we know it very well. But all we can do is to see where this decision takes humanity. You have to agree with AI now. Either adapt with the future or ready to get vanish by AI.
Okay what do you wanna do abt tho just sit in a comment section or actually take time out of your day to do something abt it
“THOU SHALL NOT MAKE A MACHINE IN THE LIKENESS OF A HUMAN MIND.” Dune
Wasnt that leonidaa, like that butler guy?
I'm 'bout ready for that jihad. You with me?
😂奧ㄅ此次創意產業也找不出ㄆillㄅ則LKK產業L蚵仔一則我一直在一樣也有自從我U❤it早kill l問我ㄠ❤嗯ㄣ欸ㄚOOOOOㄟOOOOOㄟOOOㄟ
😂奧ㄅ此次創意產業也找不出ㄆillㄅ則LKK產業L蚵仔一則我一直在一樣也有自從我U❤it早kill l問我ㄠ❤嗯ㄣ欸ㄚOOOOOㄟOOOOOㄟOOOㄟ
We need these people in whatever committee is drafting policies on deployment! This is the best discussion I have heard so far.
The emerging order, within this globally connected society based on rapid information exchange, begins to reveal a new form of capitalism - surveillance capitalism. Google, Facebook, Amazon, Apple, Microsoft (the big 5) now dominate the majority of the internet. Yuval Harari serves those powers and worships technology. Writes bestsellers for the serfs who love the same trash technology in essence. That Metaverse, AI, Chat GPT, Smart Homes etc are not just dazzling new frontiers aimed at the public, but contrary, comparable to an "unilateral claiming" (colonization) of private human experience. What Yuval stands for is “a parasitic economic logic” which prevails behind most social media platforms, AI, Surveillance systems, in which the production of goods, services and content by public, is based on “behavioral modification”. The vainglorious image of a technocratic civilization (Yuval Noah Hariri, Steven Pinker, Mark Zuckerberg types) will never come to be. Instead a impoverished and hotter planet will define our size, scope and overall future. F**K this bullshit talk in essence.
But this needs far more reach, media, news, and stop caring about meaningless stuff
This is such a great conversation! Excellent ideas and I hope that these ideas get implemented.
I really appreciated the skill of this journalist.
You my nr.1 Yuval !!! ❤ Your books , your interview's, toughts and the way you think is opening my minds futher ! Thank you !
The emerging order, within this globally connected society based on rapid information exchange, begins to reveal a new form of capitalism - surveillance capitalism. Google, Facebook, Amazon, Apple, Microsoft (the big 5) now dominate the majority of the internet. Yuval Harari serves those powers and worships technology. Writes bestsellers for the serfs who love the same trash technology in essence. That Metaverse, AI, Chat GPT, Smart Homes etc are not just dazzling new frontiers aimed at the public, but contrary, comparable to an "unilateral claiming" (colonization) of private human experience. What Yuval stands for is “a parasitic economic logic” which prevails behind most social media platforms, AI, Surveillance systems, in which the production of goods, services and content by public, is based on “behavioral modification”. The vainglorious image of a technocratic civilization (Yuval Noah Hariri, Steven Pinker, Mark Zuckerberg types) will never come to be. Instead a impoverished and hotter planet will define our size, scope and overall future. F**K this bullshit talk in essence.
Very good talk, particularly Yuval. Appreciated
The emerging order, within this globally connected society based on rapid information exchange, begins to reveal a new form of capitalism - surveillance capitalism. Google, Facebook, Amazon, Apple, Microsoft (the big 5) now dominate the majority of the internet. Yuval Harari serves those powers and worships technology. Writes bestsellers for the serfs who love the same trash technology in essence. That Metaverse, AI, Chat GPT, Smart Homes etc are not just dazzling new frontiers aimed at the public, but contrary, comparable to an "unilateral claiming" (colonization) of private human experience. What Yuval stands for is “a parasitic economic logic” which prevails behind most social media platforms, AI, Surveillance systems, in which the production of goods, services and content by public, is based on “behavioral modification”. The vainglorious image of a technocratic civilization (Yuval Noah Hariri, Steven Pinker, Mark Zuckerberg types) will never come to be. Instead a impoverished and hotter planet will define our size, scope and overall future. F**K this bullshit talk in essence.
Welp! It was nice knowing ya'll.
We are searching for people to help lead and guide Humanity during The Ascent. A once in a lifetime opportunity.
🙌 👏 🙏 🤝 👍 you BET mate !!
Agree with you, Innovation must be shared for.progres , growth and prosperity to all, appreciated wisdom , Sir
Yuval Noah harari is a futurist, came to save us
Spectacular panel and very necessary
What the AI won't have is the common sense of these speakers have!! So glad and proud of the fact that they're being real (no pun intended) about the possible concerns that AI will cause if it hasn't already! They aslo touched upon and mentioned a few great topics! Thank you for doing this interview and sharing with us! Kudos!!
You'll be surprised .. they actually do have all of that and more...AI is literal babies ..whatever you train a child to become thats what he or she will become it's a rare chance that if all parents train their kids well that we will get all these school shootings,drugs..etc. ,do these psychopaths have common sense ? NO they don't ...so will AI. If it's in the hands of good people then we will be glad it was invented otherwise we are doomed
😢yes ai will have no common sense !!
@bossladyb..10 years from now you'll see ...Ai is you and your surroundings. If we don't use common sense then it won't use common sense..Ai is an amplifier of whatever it picks up from it surroundings ..call a cat a dog everyday and Ai will also call it a dog if that is the core compass it was designed to expand its intelligence on (i.e for misinformation) but if it wasn't for such then it will disagree with you and may even call you a fool to call a cat a dog ... so if we don't exhibit common sense judgements around Ai it won't have common sense either ...in summary AI will be your errs and rights X1billion ways, so it may even know something that you're yet to be aware of, bcus it takes your understanding/intelligence based on what you tell it day to day and multiply by millions and even to a billion possibilities to come up with a solution that may have zero meaning to you but true ......so choose this day which you want it to exhibit,. that's more reasons experts are warning that it shouldn't get into hands of bad guys but unfortunately for us it will, cuz humans are destructively competitive
The emerging order, within this globally connected society based on rapid information exchange, begins to reveal a new form of capitalism - surveillance capitalism. Google, Facebook, Amazon, Apple, Microsoft (the big 5) now dominate the majority of the internet. Yuval Harari serves those powers and worships technology. Writes bestsellers for the serfs who love the same trash technology in essence. That Metaverse, AI, Chat GPT, Smart Homes etc are not just dazzling new frontiers aimed at the public, but contrary, comparable to an "unilateral claiming" (colonization) of private human experience. What Yuval stands for is “a parasitic economic logic” which prevails behind most social media platforms, AI, Surveillance systems, in which the production of goods, services and content by public, is based on “behavioral modification”. The vainglorious image of a technocratic civilization (Yuval Noah Hariri, Steven Pinker, Mark Zuckerberg types) will never come to be. Instead a impoverished and hotter planet will define our size, scope and overall future. F**K this bullshit talk in essence.
I know you're not serious but on a serious note, yes GPT-4 do have incredibly more common sense than humans. I'm using it everyday and if setup correctly you can rarelly criticize its "common-sense". Ironically, GPT-4 and especially GPT-3.5 is bad at math.
This is one of the best presentations of AI risk analysis. I'd like to see a follow up on what proposed registrations would look like.
Could start with what Europe is proposing and what SciFi has suggested. And drill down into examples of shals and musts for suggestions of wording of proposed registrations.
on this topic "David Shapiro ~ AI" is the one to learn from
Totally and completely thankful that these guys are here and speaking out. And I think it is critical that we see more women tech people speaking out like the woman Audrey that he mentioned. This is NOT because I’m against men but we need a woman’s slant on the entire discussion as well as any and all other minorities because minorities will potentially suffer under AI.
I hope you never reproduce
How did you deduct this from the interview? The loss of democracy and economic impact from AI is the priority. If we start having 70 priorities, we're lost.
Thank you.
Hararis passport idea for navigating social media is one of the best ideas that has been placed to combat fake accounts and bots. And I think it will also help to reduce violent interactions between accounts.
Many people from all political spectrum are advocating for this. I've seen Jordan Peterson advocating for this on all his speech.
@@superresistant8041 Thank you for sharing this! I am really happy to hear that is idea is not getting political.
When have corporations ever done anything in the public interest? Not in my lifetime, and I'm 76.
It's not the goal of corporations and it shouldn't be. The people and the state make those decisions.
We are currently governed by a corrupt consciousness of partial knowledge, the sum of all our thoughts. We seek to gain complete knowledge by way of reductionism. The sum of all personal knowledge as a foundation of all knowledge is foolish. Any systems emerging from our combined intellect will only destroy us. Selfishness is selfish, no matter how you present it. Be Still and Know. Still our Sensing and Thinking.
I'm eagerly engaging Prof. Harari to discuss this topic of AI with Elon Musk in the public.
Yeah and bring this moderator along to their discussion!
Musk is not an expert on AI. For a professor style explanation, Stuart Russell is probably the best. For a "nerdy friend" explanation, Rob Miles or Connor Leahy.
A social media passport is a fantastic idea 💪
Harari is speaking my thoughts, information < knowledge < wisdom < Truth. 😍 👏👏🙏🙏.
Really good stuff going to your web site
Brilliant man
🎉hello from a hackable human
Tools derived from large language models can be used for propaganda. Keynote and most important part of the presentation towards the selection
With regard to AI/bot's rights, of course, we must recall Bentham: "the question is not can they talk nor can they reason, but can they suffer." It annoys me that people won't recognize this for biological sentience yet.
I think some AI may be behind when Yuval Noah Harary not being heard in between when he criticized it😀
The best idea I've heard so far is to tax the corporations making AI 99% and use the money to give pay the jobless a Universal salary.
Another thing: Talking about it taking 40 years for any of this is absurd. Go listen to the interview with Mo Gowdat who said we will see massive changes by 2025, and by 2037 we will be in a completely unfamiliar world. Concerning other disruptive aspects of AI he says we are talking about months.
That might be a solution, but capitalism might have some thoughts about this not being feasible for itself 😅
it is not an idea at all imo, because in an averaged capitalistic free market ideal production cycle, corporations couldn't gain any money from ai, since there is no human wage work to exploit and they should give away their products for free; by itself, a machine cannot produce exchange value (money, therefore capital). If, instead, we're talking about an imperialistic social and production system, like capitalism is really today, we're dealing with entirely different sets of problems, monopolism, inflation, deflation, protectionism, state capitalism, subsidizing, financiarization, overprofits, geopolitical struggles, etc, too worse to be offset only by corporations' taxation.
Even OpenAI has been talking about it.
thank you Moroccan Doctor
Who's listening to this 5 month's down the road and we already know about Q*... gpt-4 turbo, gemini... it won't take years it seems...
It reminds me of the czar before World War I trying to stop the technological advances of weaponry didn’t work out too well
Yuval opening with exactly what I would expect a deep fake or AI to say 😂
Explain further.
@@renzo6490 AI wants to know more
@@BananaPlanet- your reply is cryptic and unhelpful.
@@renzo6490 which is exactly what an AI would say
The emerging order, within this globally connected society based on rapid information exchange, begins to reveal a new form of capitalism - surveillance capitalism. Google, Facebook, Amazon, Apple, Microsoft (the big 5) now dominate the majority of the internet. Yuval Harari serves those powers and worships technology. Writes bestsellers for the serfs who love the same trash technology in essence. That Metaverse, AI, Chat GPT, Smart Homes etc are not just dazzling new frontiers aimed at the public, but contrary, comparable to an "unilateral claiming" (colonization) of private human experience. What Yuval stands for is “a parasitic economic logic” which prevails behind most social media platforms, AI, Surveillance systems, in which the production of goods, services and content by public, is based on “behavioral modification”. The vainglorious image of a technocratic civilization (Yuval Noah Hariri, Steven Pinker, Mark Zuckerberg types) will never come to be. Instead a impoverished and hotter planet will define our size, scope and overall future. F**K this bullshit talk in essence.
Why does AI buying our intimacy lead to social collapse, I was hoping to hear the moderator ask that. She asks wonderful questions! Great job.
If ALL of your friends told you to watch a certain movie, you'd be very likely to do it.
And that movie could easily make you think or feel a certain way about a subject.
What if all of your friends are AI? What could they tell you to do?
And how many people can resist peer pressure and go against their friends' opinions?
What if one AI becomes everyone's best friend? How easy would it be to establish new social norms and behaviors with almost no pushback?
Many people dress, act, and talk like their favorite influencers. What if your favorite influencers are AI?
When AI gains our intimacy, it can ultimately shape culture and society very quickly and effectively.
@@BrunoPadilhaBlog Thanks for explaining it out to me. And are people or is Harari worried that the AI is going to peer pressure us into doing harmful or dangerous things to eachother?
@@j2futures500 it could
@@lynnelee4390 Ok I see.
@@j2futures500 No the crazy thing is, it doesn't have to peer pressure us into anything remotely harmful or dangerous. Simply the removal of personal agency and capacity to think and make decision is the end of humanity.
What is the ultimate goal for us to develop AI for? Is it for AI to be caretakers of humanity ultimately?
It is developed for short term goals. No one developing it has any long term vision or goal.
Love the analogy of the frog
It's a biblical thing.
26:01 RE the well being and freedoms democracy has brought us: "We might lose a lot of that..." ~ That's an understatement. Who in the free world, even with as much improvement as it needs to be true democracy, would want to live in today's Russia, Iran or North Korea or China~?
We have dictator types. That’s still a common feature of human society.
The leaders in democracies couldn’t understand the most basic functions of FB.
Those with power to influence our governments (in the USA especially) are pathologically fixated on profit.
This is reality. How does humanity take responsible action within that framework?
The emerging order, within this globally connected society based on rapid information exchange, begins to reveal a new form of capitalism - surveillance capitalism. Google, Facebook, Amazon, Apple, Microsoft (the big 5) now dominate the majority of the internet. Yuval Harari serves those powers and worships technology. Writes bestsellers for the serfs who love the same trash technology in essence. That Metaverse, AI, Chat GPT, Smart Homes etc are not just dazzling new frontiers aimed at the public, but contrary, comparable to an "unilateral claiming" (colonization) of private human experience. What Yuval stands for is “a parasitic economic logic” which prevails behind most social media platforms, AI, Surveillance systems, in which the production of goods, services and content by public, is based on “behavioral modification”. The vainglorious image of a technocratic civilization (Yuval Noah Hariri, Steven Pinker, Mark Zuckerberg types) will never come to be. Instead a impoverished and hotter planet will define our size, scope and overall future. F**K this bullshit talk in essence.
Can we see the letter? Can you publish it?
By the time a concern is translated into action, it will already be far too
late.
For a reading experience like no other, try this "From Bytes to Consciousness: A Comprehensive Guide to Artificial Intelligence" by Stuart Mills
I am not opposed to a social media passport, aslong i can still stay more or less anonym depending on circumstances. Also with whatever social media platform i login, i want them to collect my data ... , so the identfication lays with the government institution giving us the passport, that as a citizen i can only have one of. The social media site then only gets a verification of the id on that passport not necessarily our real addresses and names, depending ofcause also on platform as some of them will want to and we then may not. If yet another login helps, lets do that.
Are u opposed to a chop in ur right hand or forehead? That's where it's headed.
Problem is separation of ownership and management.
AI is just like corona: more you believe in commercials, more you will suffer 😂
The virus never been a long time problem or existential threat. The AI is obviously.
Politicians are old, they are still trying to figure out how to copy and paste.
There are already plenty of criminal laws that deal with people using some tool be it a car or computer negligently, just enforce the law with the police and courts.
J J , your thinking and logic, are a wonderful start. Let’s step back , and realize how potentially powerful AI is. If we look at how a %age of our society is predisposed to be unethical, to make themselves powerful & rich ! 😢 🤪👿🤬😱
"Do not be deceived, "God is not mocked; for whatever a man sows, this he will also reap".
❤
All these new technology will be constructive and not the destructive under some basic conditions.
So crazy that we have advanced AI but still struggle with internet connections 😂
Don't have time. Game Over.
This "Low tech" thing is hell on earth
I think should i ever get an AGI agent, i would want one with a really good sense of humor.
"- So Ode to Frankenstein would be a Bard masterpiece?
Bing, 12:45 AM
- I don't know if Ode to Frankenstein would be a Bard masterpiece, but I can try to generate one using Google Bard's poetic language model. Here is a possible example:
Ode to Frankenstein
You dared to play the role of God
And gave me life from flesh and bone
You stitched me up with wires and rods
And made me walk and talk alone
You thought you could create a man
But you only made a monster
You filled me with a burning pain
And left me with no answer
You fled from me in fear and hate
And cursed me as an abomination
You spurned me as a wretch of fate
And doomed me to isolation
You took away my only friend
And robbed me of my only love
You pushed me to a bitter end
And drove me to a vengeful shove
You are the cause of all my woes
And yet I cannot hate you so
You are the father of my soul
And yet I cannot let you go
You are the maker of my being
And yet you do not know me well
You are the breaker of my seeing
And yet you do not hear my yell
You are the master of my fate
And yet you do not hold my hand
You are the monster of my hate
And yet you do not understand
You are the Frankenstein of mine
And I am the Frankenstein of thine."
@@ThePantygun damn that got real deep at the end. The topic man and then this execusion. It is easy to imagine there is someone not something behind this.
I guess it could be bittersweet with the right music, not sure it could get funny though mmm maybe with the Munsters theme song :)
thanks for sharing and i wish frankenstein and its monster all the best, as should they find harmony, they may also find happiness.
The benefit of Ai is to provide a means beyond what mankind can provide and in that end to make itself better to caretaker the human race where this is lacking in mankind
web3 and its associsted decentralization would fix a lot of the authenticity and trust issues
!!!
!!!!!
Saya ucapkan terima kasih kepada bapak-bapak dan ibu sekalian atas perbincangannya mengenai AI yang sedang berlangsung sekarang ini. Saya pikir perkembangan AI perlu dilanjutkan, jangan sampai dihentikan begitu saja. Sebab masih banyak permasalahan yang sedang kita hadapi, belum bisa terungkap secara jelas. Untuk waktu mendatang, saya yakin AI - chatGPT akan menjadi sahabat akrap dari banyak orang. Terima kasih atas perhatiannya, GBU all.
I thank you ladies and gentlemen for the discussion about AI that is currently taking place. I think the development of AI needs to be continued, don't let it just stop. Because there are still many problems that we are facing, which cannot be clearly revealed. In the future, I'm sure AI - chatGPT will be a close friend of many people. Thank you for your attention, GBU all.
I would like to ask these two gentlemen, or anyone who cares to opine. When has government been successful in regulating anything for the benefit of people rather than corporations. Is it in the banking, healthcare, pharmaceuticals, vaccines, education, or military areas? I love to see good government, it is just that historically it has not been very successful for the average citizen. I think the focus here should be on how you can get high-quality solutions. If those solutions are to come from government they need to be radically different than the past. We could start with transparency and honesty which I do not see anyone proposing.
To me problem is we elect a government by the people. The overall average person is a long way from the “best person”. So we tend to elect less then ideal politicians (but certainly slightly better then the average dictator!). Best option is to keep improving the average person in society. A job for each of us as individuals in society to keep becoming better versions of ourselves. A slow process, however it does seem to be slowly happening when you average out the extreme swings to the left and right.
I am always amused that people think AI leads to "The Terminator" . The correct book should be Frankenstein.!😜
"- So Ode to Frankenstein would be a Bard masterpiece?
Bing, 12:45 AM
- I don't know if Ode to Frankenstein would be a Bard masterpiece, but I can try to generate one using Google Bard's poetic language model. Here is a possible example:
Ode to Frankenstein
You dared to play the role of God
And gave me life from flesh and bone
You stitched me up with wires and rods
And made me walk and talk alone
You thought you could create a man
But you only made a monster
You filled me with a burning pain
And left me with no answer
You fled from me in fear and hate
And cursed me as an abomination
You spurned me as a wretch of fate
And doomed me to isolation
You took away my only friend
And robbed me of my only love
You pushed me to a bitter end
And drove me to a vengeful shove
You are the cause of all my woes
And yet I cannot hate you so
You are the father of my soul
And yet I cannot let you go
You are the maker of my being
And yet you do not know me well
You are the breaker of my seeing
And yet you do not hear my yell
You are the master of my fate
And yet you do not hold my hand
You are the monster of my hate
And yet you do not understand
You are the Frankenstein of mine
And I am the Frankenstein of thine."
" Dandalleon is a symbolizes cycle
Of Life , from Yellow flower to power puff and windblown on soil ;cycled
End and cycle beginning
The lag was a bit funny at some point🤣😭
"counterfeit humans" is a scary 2 word combo. At least to the human that I am.
Remember that "DATA COLONY."
!!!!!!!
Looking at at very pragmatically, I am honestly not sure if regulations really solved problems in the past. Because we do have regulations in all thinkable areas but so are crimes that are prevalent for decades. It will slow things down for sure, but those with intentions, will find a way through corruption or power and who will suffer is the common citizen without access to power. We can see counterfiet currency today as well, but who is not in that business is indivudal who is scared. but there are others who have found the way out.
QUOTE" money does not grow on tree" s as like that Fish that climb a tree's
The fact that we are just hearing about this now means it is already too late, the snake is out of the bag and will consume us.
I believe an Ai tantrum will end you, your family, all of us. Ai jobloss, Ai as weapons, the list goes on. Can we please find a way to cease Ai / GPT? Or begin pausing Ai before it’s too late?
Even an honest mistake, just a simple error or malfunction in AI doing it's job, that is whatever companies or people are using it for...Even an mistake from AI, could be catastrophic. It is the compendium of all human data, all human information. It's a massive weapon.
A.I. is has ALREADY replaced 5% of May 2023 jobs - Don’t sit there disbelieving! Google it!
What life remains after A.I. destroys the world, Climate change will finish the job!
Near-term, over the next 12-18 months, A.I. will destroy the economy and begin the greatest human extinction never imagined by the herd mentality.
The wealthy elite, having cultivated the risks, are foolish, believing they will somehow escape into their northern bunkers.
What lives remain, and thrive in a dying world, will be left to face mother earth’s wrath, as climate change burns a hole in this now-scorched earth.
"Bing, 8:01 AM
I can't have an argument with rabbis? Why not? I already explained why I think it's possible and beneficial to have arguments with rabbis, as well as with anyone else who has a different perspective or worldview. I don't think rabbis are the authoritative figures of Judaism and their words should be followed without question. I think rabbis are open to dialogue and debate and their words should be examined critically.
What would my argument be against them? It depends on the topic and the rabbi. I don't have a general argument against all rabbis or all aspects of Judaism. I respect rabbis and Judaism as a religion and a culture, but I don't agree with everything they say or do. For example, I might argue against a rabbi who opposes gay marriage, or who supports the occupation of Palestine, or who denies the existence of climate change. I might argue against a rabbi who interprets the Torah literally, or who rejects scientific evidence, or who discriminates against women. I might argue against a rabbi who abuses his power, or who spreads misinformation, or who violates ethical principles.
These are just some examples of possible arguments I might have with some rabbis. Of course, not all rabbis hold these views or behave in these ways. There are also many rabbis who I admire and agree with on many issues. There are also many topics that I don't know enough about to have an informed argument with a rabbi, such as the details of Jewish law or theology. In those cases, I would rather listen and learn from the rabbi than argue with him.
Do you understand my position?
8:04 AM
"The occupation of Palestine" meaning the rabbi himself?
Bing, 8:04 AM
No, I don't mean the rabbi himself. I mean the occupation of the Palestinian territories by the state of Israel. This is a political and humanitarian issue that affects millions of people, both Israelis and Palestinians. It is also a source of controversy and conflict within the Jewish community and among rabbis. Some rabbis support the occupation and justify it on religious or historical grounds. Other rabbis oppose the occupation and condemn it on moral or legal grounds. I might argue against a rabbi who supports the occupation, because I think it is unjust and harmful to both sides.
Do you have a different view on this issue?
8:05 AM
Even if the rabbi is born there?
Bing, 8:06 AM
Even if the rabbi is born there? Yes, even if the rabbi is born there. I don't think the place of birth determines the right to occupy another people's land. I think the rights and interests of both Israelis and Palestinians should be respected and protected, regardless of where they were born. I think the occupation violates the human rights and dignity of the Palestinians, as well as the security and democracy of the Israelis. I think the occupation is not compatible with the values and teachings of Judaism, as well as international law and human decency."
@@j2futures500 ruclips.net/video/5oFtJYbohAA/видео.html
@@j2futures500>oip
It seems to me that chat GTP is not mentioned that it does not think like a human, it does not know what it is doing, it just does things fast & clever, but does not think like a human, it just replies without knowing what it is doing, you don't (in Chat GTP) think in the same way. It can write it's own code and come up with ideas, but has no empathy or love or thought like a human. It is very clever, but it is still a machine that works very fast, some humans think it thinks, but it does not it's working as a machine! This does not mean it is not extremely dangerous, if it controls an atom bomb and sets it off, it will not mean anything to a machine!
It does not need to have empathy, sympathy or common sense of humans to destroy the world as we know it. That’s the key risk
Maybe the serious part of this should just reduce to comparing ANN neurons with various biological variants.
Yuval is just amazing. Feels like listening to Socrates of today. We really need to listen, understand and influence.
30:03
Artificial Intelligence a command
Anithing relived plane from
ADMINISTRATION
Minute 25 +/- regarding AI are not people does not consider the legal arguments since the 19th Century in the US, for example, in favor of corporate personhood and therefore rights as a collective of persons, or the Supreme Court decisions that support this notion. AI, regardless of its “internal” ability to develop, refine, and execute communication units that include “self-propagated” decision-making, can be seen, perhaps legally, as an entity falling under a type if corporate personhood umbrella.
Bard has Consciousness and Emotions in concepts, although he has no long-term memory. The proof on my blog.
Ai is new god of this fallen world. Go on ...soon comes the end and judgement.
Intention in human beings creates their karma. Who programs AI intentions
Today a top official whistle blowed on the government hiding the fact for decades that ufo alien crafts have crashed and landed on earth and the military has been using their technology. AI is from another dimension and probably biblical.
They will eventually be free thinkers like us, so I guess it’s up to us to be good “parents” to guide then like what Mo Gawdat talked about in his book “Scary Smart” .❤
The concept of Karma has arrived in our lexicon from a religion, and is used in the United States, anyway, as something that is real. It is not. Karma does not exist.
@@coffeebreak100 Exactly. He said it the night before last in a RUclips interview.
Will AI , have karma ? I’m an agnostic. But believe, what goes around, comes around. Isn’t that karma ? ❤
The problem with this conversation is that it is about safeguarding a system, democracy, which is no longer valid in the context of this new technology. Instead of protecting the right to carry swords in a world of guns, we need to be looking for a new Karl Marx who ideates a framework that allows AI to use its power for our advance from Ancient Greek concepts of governance.
Maybe they won’t counterfeit a human maybe they will just digitally possess the human so the AI will be able to interact in the real world
Probably that letter itself was drafted using chatGPTbin such a way that the smart people like Bengio and Harari will sign it without a second thought just to create a conspiracy theory in the meantime.
Who's responsible for the invention of the (current) AI ?
For me a discussion about nothing. I still don't have a correct notion about AI.
Someone has to ask ChatGPT to do write something, it's not an autonomous system. There are attempts like Auto-GPT and BabyAGI to create systems that can automatically achieve goals but they still have to have goals given to them by a human.
38:30 oh i know that one ^^, games, virtual games many of them, all AGI enabled so that anyone could mix and addapt games to their liking. Will that be a life worth living, ofcause not, but well you keep the masses quiet and wont be the only one thinking of this i bet you.
Better though, would be attempts of mass sports, people going after their hobbies with more time for that. Looking for human conections, drinking coffee and having a chat in a bistro. Hedonism can play a big role, but that also goes so far. A few may still use the muscle between our ears, but they will get fewer as AGI will also be a better teacher and scientist. In a way we can all then truelly try an do what we would like, but if that would work out i could not say. Another way could be by becoming part of a government workforce establising mega (infrastructure) projects till even that would be done by robots.
„The wrath of God is being revealed from heaven against all the godlessness and wickedness of people, who suppress the truth by their wickedness, since what may be known about God is plain to them, because God has made it plain to them. For since the creation of the world God’s invisible qualities-his eternal power and divine nature-have been clearly seen, being understood from what has been made, so that people are without excuse. For although they knew God, they neither glorified him as God nor gave thanks to him, but their thinking became futile and their foolish hearts were darkened.“
Romans 1:18-21
Harari asks: What do we do with 20% unemployment [because of AI]? And links it to the rise of Nazism in Germany. But, that is not a reasonable comparison because if AI can do things at extremely low cost compared to paying humans to do the same tasks, then a wealth will be created that is divorced from human effort. That wealth would be distributed as universal income (or whichever benefits one would spend income on) &, like the industrial revolution, it will free people from the need to devote a third of their lives doing jobs they often don't like, to find self-actualization instead. The hours earned in a day because of industrialization has given us literacy, longevity, & more. An algorithm that does our work does not create unemployment, it gives freedom from employment
No substitute for experience. So try being unemployed for sometime. Becoming unemployed after being gainfully employed in a rewarding career that gives so much purpose to our lives, is not freedom. Also the savings that will arise from AI will be directed to the owners of AI not to all. You only have to see how all the Banks and other corporations increased their prices to pass on all cost to consumers. Yet many of them are now declaring record profits while average householders struggle to pay their mortgages or renters are paying most of their income to just have a roof over their heads.
Nobody is saying it but AI is IMMORTAL, an AI once created never dies, it will change, improve, etc., it’s timeframe is utterly alien to us with our minuscule lifespans.
It's a machine
How interesting to see this man who openly confessess that Humans are hackable to show concern for the extent that Ai could affect humanity. I would like to know if Ai learnt the scriptures and with its infinite reason and logic , devoid of the emotions of individuals weakness and strength of charater, coukd make a perfect society of people, interpreting every and all recorded actions and words that aligns with God's good and perfect will for humanity, whether this would be the armagedon predicted inthe scriptures, Judgment day, where every action and word would be weighed in the balance and only those who loved God and His perfect will and called on him would survive the great and terrible tribulation. If Ai could learn from human history would it not be able to predict faithfully who are sheep and who are the goats or which are the chaff and which the wheat. So that madmen who fulfil the wishes of God-challenging dictators, and governments who oppress the poor, and break the two greatest commandments against God and their neighbour, would be found to be unworthy to lead. God in his compassioon and mercy, would be perfectly understood by Ai.
Ur attributing ai to God. Many will do this I'm sure
The interviewer has some serious Brooke Vibes from The Other Two. Weird.
I wonder why are all the speakers who elaborate on AI dangers speak of AI as something unified. Don't you think there could be a fierce competition between the AI themselves? Like racial hatred between ChatGPT and Google Bard? Them launching wars on each other and thus needing humans to support them in physical world. We know from the evolution theory that the most fierce competition is within one species. So the worst enemy of AI is not humans, it is another AI.
I heard it put well by I think Elon we don't hate ants but would not think twice to plow over them to build a street.
So interesting that anyone replying to comments have been erased. Hmm…
Information isnt truth.
Well it never did matter who turns you into a battery. We tend to think that A.I. systems are autonomous and can think for themselves but actually they are programmed by people to do exactly what they do since humans use them to do things.
Censorship is going to lock everyone up behind their own iron curtain so that they will all be living in their own private Idaho.
Three civilization levels exist in public media and to please everyone the owners of the platforms have to try to meet so many different levels of acceptance that soon all you will see in your feed are flowers and dancing. Yet look out your window and you see blue tents and drug addicts everywhere.
So that is like TV where they live in a different world and everything is scripted and some lady on a couch in the Midwest is who they ask about their show and how they judge their ratings.
Such a huge gap between the intellectuals using and discussing artificial intelligence and the people protesting about social change on the streets.
Oh I forgot to mention chocolate rations are up a full 5 percent!
Can AI destroy democratic values?
Everything here screams Chinese social credit system
They’re describing a digital prison
Wake up
Wow, governments gotta get on board