Tabletop CP: Sharp Practice Battle Report- The Church at Johnson's Landing

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 21 янв 2025

Комментарии • 63

  • @Master_Chef_Mattman
    @Master_Chef_Mattman 3 года назад +2

    Personally I preferred the old force introduction with everything laid out at once. That lets us see the entire force together in its glory!
    Congrats on the Caesar Awards Nomination!

  • @crimsonerrant
    @crimsonerrant 3 года назад +7

    Awesome video as usual. I would probably add a slower force presentation with a voice-over description. It would feel more natural and enjoyable to me.

  • @tabletopgeneralsde310
    @tabletopgeneralsde310 3 года назад +9

    Great game and the reason for Fan Choice on the Award thing, thanks for that entertaining and fun 90 minutes.

  • @oldschoolfrp2326
    @oldschoolfrp2326 3 года назад +6

    Always glad to see more Sharp Practice, especially AWI. Thumbs up for the cinematic directing when introducing the units.

  • @michaelbrockelhurst4227
    @michaelbrockelhurst4227 3 года назад +6

    I really dig that Order of Battle intro.

  • @mcflyfraser
    @mcflyfraser 3 года назад +4

    This is probably one of the most interesting sharp practice ever... so many epic saves for Travis and still close winning it even with a moral of 3...

  • @paulbenson9015
    @paulbenson9015 3 года назад

    Great Game Gents!!! Good to see the AWI
    Forces, going back to your Roots! Congratulations on your much deserved nomination for the Ceasar awards. You 've certainly got my vote👍

  • @rbale2
    @rbale2 3 года назад +4

    I liked the new format for introducing forces

  • @thattassiewargamer
    @thattassiewargamer 3 года назад +2

    I really like the new intro for the forces. It was great to see the great painted miniatures up close and in the field. 👍

  • @JamesAnderson-dp1dt
    @JamesAnderson-dp1dt 3 года назад +2

    The intro was great, we got a closer look at the units and figures than usual. I vote for continuing that method.

  • @grahamswargamevault2635
    @grahamswargamevault2635 3 года назад +2

    Really love your presentation of SP. I have posted SP games, but nothing like yours. Keep up the great work.

  • @housecaldwell
    @housecaldwell 3 года назад

    You have my permission to play Sharp Practice every week! :D Good discussion about balancing forces at 1:30:00 mark, especially comparing it with Chain of Command. I think you have a good point there. A CoC style support table would be a good article for the Lardy magazine.

  • @MrCaptbear42
    @MrCaptbear42 3 года назад +4

    I like the video.... you’ve include brief views of movement, and other things... I like new way of introducing the forces but I also like the narration... maybe include that. Also like the overhead views.
    Great video! As always. Keep up the great work.

    • @HDIAndrew1
      @HDIAndrew1 3 года назад +1

      I agree. Text plus voiceover would be my preferred way of you introducing forces

  • @Archaoen
    @Archaoen 3 года назад

    You guys have the best battle reports :) love them. I also love your 2 dice for tanks in Bolt Action.

  • @stephenphilp8222
    @stephenphilp8222 3 года назад

    Congrats on the nominations guys. I just shows how far you've come. It seems you have a professional studio setup now. Impressive. One little thing, there always is... you mentioned that defenders should get a deployment distance bonus. They already do - defenders get a bonus 6" to their deployment distance as standard. Keep rolling out that pro video.

    • @tabletopcp
      @tabletopcp  3 года назад

      One rule we always forget! And we have no studio really. Just me and my laptop 😄

    • @stephenphilp8222
      @stephenphilp8222 3 года назад

      @@tabletopcp I suspect your nerd cave qualifies as a studio.

  • @deathmagnetic300
    @deathmagnetic300 3 года назад +3

    The into list explanation was great. It was fresh.

  • @tw33dal3
    @tw33dal3 3 года назад

    Introducing the forces. Fine. Helps you to cut to the chase.
    Like the overhead camera.
    Use of cards (albeit II ones) clearer on what has been drawn than tokens.

  • @grimgorkeisenpelz9392
    @grimgorkeisenpelz9392 3 года назад

    Great and very entertaining game. I had a lot of fun watching it.

  • @DeePsix501
    @DeePsix501 3 года назад

    Little Warrior here! Voting for you guys for Caesar award!

  • @Ibanhoof
    @Ibanhoof 3 года назад

    i like the Narration of introduction to the forces, maybe combining that with still pictures may be the way forward, although i did enjoy the older method to the new one

  • @marcellocolombarini1653
    @marcellocolombarini1653 3 года назад

    Nice to see you back🤗

  • @stephenpodeschi6052
    @stephenpodeschi6052 3 года назад +5

    Epic game and is why I think Sharpe practice is one of the best games, you both were a bit rusty and some weird rolls did effect the result imo but great game cheers....

  • @JamesAnderson-dp1dt
    @JamesAnderson-dp1dt 3 года назад +1

    Getting three Groups beat up in detail (Dan, Son of Magua, and those horsemen) is what got you. The Redcoats are tough enough to hold on for a long time on their own. So I'm thinking all your little Groups should have moved up as a mutually-supporting horde, while your Redcoats came in alone or with the gun, from the other side. Make it hard for your opponent to knock off a Group by itself. But then, I've not played the rules.

  • @e-4airman124
    @e-4airman124 3 года назад

    a wonderful show thank you so much

  • @thelastbattalion3509
    @thelastbattalion3509 3 года назад

    This was the boost I needed to get me to try and finish some more of my AWI collection!

  • @wargamesgeek1334
    @wargamesgeek1334 3 года назад +2

    Great game, thanks for sharing 👍

  • @tpd71261
    @tpd71261 3 года назад +1

    Great New intro... keep it up

  • @tomwinkelspecht7796
    @tomwinkelspecht7796 3 года назад

    Had a truly lousy weekend but this game was a great pick me up

  • @lanceking701
    @lanceking701 3 года назад

    Love the new intro but Lt Dans name should flash!!

  • @BerlinCardYard
    @BerlinCardYard 3 года назад

    Hello!
    Due to your channel I ordered my set of rules so I am interested to the rulebook and buttons when they arrive to play SP2. Looking foreward for next week's composition of a challange and the outcome of the beattle. And because here it is shown how fast thinks do absoloutly change by the D6s way to fall it looks realistic as warfare is. And as you are confronted playing blue with sometimes only red cards appear and pile on the grass it is quite realistic and certainly then a Tiffin nearly nailed your battle plan's coffin.
    I really do like the way you are play- and laughing having a good time. Looks like a plenty of fun and a good time without wifes drugs and biological issues*... 😉
    The interaction concept of the game's landshape and gameplay is very interesting. The shape of the obstacels and LOF-blockers wasn't made in the random way as ordered in the additional rules. That was interesting Dawns&Depature wrote something diffrend I think. So it is a very smart way to modulate the clever scenic to the intended gameplay without making one side favorite without recognizing it.
    The introduction of the troops is a bit stiff and didn't give a personal relationship to the leades what made the intro so interesting when unwritten. So please go back to the old way of introducing them to aus and I would appreciate to get a closer walk arround the leader's miniature and some words to the way they are painted and the uniform's details you did.
    In a few weeks I can start, too. The bigger part will be the paint as there are two Marlborough’s Starter boxes and some extra stuff of Cavallery and Infantry. So I'll go into the high baroque epoch of the War of the Spanish Succession 01-14 (XVIIIth century) and look if my opponent find some time to battle with me.
    Thanks for sharing this to bring the analog game to the younger generation.
    Best wishes to you all from Berlin,
    Chris
    *without surgean' and undertaker's business.

  • @marcrenouf2470
    @marcrenouf2470 3 года назад +1

    Lt. Dan, you coward! Hahahaha, another fun fight!

  • @CullodenPaintingStudio
    @CullodenPaintingStudio 3 года назад

    Great game again. Think I will take that additional 3" deployment idea for defenders.

    • @tabletopcp
      @tabletopcp  3 года назад

      I was just reminded that defenders already get an extra 6” deployment distance

    • @CullodenPaintingStudio
      @CullodenPaintingStudio 3 года назад

      @@tabletopcp such a good idea the Lardies already thought of it!

  • @DE-rd1zl
    @DE-rd1zl 3 года назад

    Good stuff as usual.

  • @lanceking701
    @lanceking701 3 года назад

    Just voted!

  • @StackingLimit
    @StackingLimit 3 года назад

    Where did you get your roads? this table is exquisite. Really beautiful and fun to watch game. Good luck in the Caesar awards. Definitely well deserved.

    • @tabletopcp
      @tabletopcp  3 года назад

      Thanks Andrew! We made the roads ourselves.

  • @jekylthorn8969
    @jekylthorn8969 3 года назад +1

    Fantastic video again, guys. Been addicted to this throughout lockdown! What size is your gaming table, by the way?

    • @andreleineke7219
      @andreleineke7219 3 года назад +1

      The table is made from a 4 x 8 foot sheet of plywood. The ends are reduced by one foot on each end for the removable trays. Quick answer, the play area is 4 x 6 feet.

    • @jekylthorn8969
      @jekylthorn8969 3 года назад

      @@andreleineke7219 Excellent, thank you!

  • @btsquad27
    @btsquad27 3 года назад +2

    If you could slow down the forces intro that would be nice

    • @andreleineke7219
      @andreleineke7219 3 года назад

      I agree, currently it is speed reading. Travis, give us a moment to let the info sink in.

  • @BootsontheTable
    @BootsontheTable 3 года назад

    Nice game guys. I like the new approach to forces, but can you leave the caption on for slightly longer? Us oldens find it hard to read it before you had moved on. Cheers Travis

    • @tabletopcp
      @tabletopcp  3 года назад

      Roger that Dom. That’s been the consensus so far. Next time I do it I will make it longer

  • @moedean3342
    @moedean3342 3 года назад

    You guys have played quite a few games of Sharpe Practice now. What is your overall assesment of the rules, like, dislike, fun, not fun? Thanks.

    • @tabletopcp
      @tabletopcp  3 года назад +2

      It’s amazing. Definitely my favorite of all the games we play. It’s a lot of fun.

  • @peterweston189
    @peterweston189 3 года назад +1

    I liked the intro, but I had to stop and start the video for every unit, in order to take in what level of leader, how many groups, how many leaders. Could you cut the music and describe the units? My 2p worth

    • @tabletopcp
      @tabletopcp  3 года назад +1

      Thanks. I could do that. Too fast has been the consensus thus far.

    • @housecaldwell
      @housecaldwell 3 года назад

      @@tabletopcp Yep, a little fast, but I do like seeing all the information instead of just hearing it. That said, narration would be helpful to hear the pronunciation of leader's names. More work for you. :-)

  • @jekylthorn8969
    @jekylthorn8969 3 года назад

    Watching all of these again for the second time! Do you use plastic or metal figures?

    • @tabletopcp
      @tabletopcp  3 года назад

      It s a combo of metal and plastic. The bill f the force are plastic from Warlord Games

    • @jekylthorn8969
      @jekylthorn8969 3 года назад

      @@tabletopcp Fantastic! Thank you for the rapid response!

  • @StevanEC
    @StevanEC Год назад

    Where did you get the cavalry? Warlord Games has not cavalry for this period.

    • @tabletopcp
      @tabletopcp  Год назад

      It’s metal cav from Perry

    • @StevanEC
      @StevanEC Год назад

      @@tabletopcp thanks!

  • @robertdalrymple216
    @robertdalrymple216 3 года назад

    Always like you're reports but thumbs down for intro cause I'm usually painting miniatures and have to look up to read screen

  • @johnvint3122
    @johnvint3122 3 года назад

    Text plus voice over, would be better

  • @stonewalljackson5994
    @stonewalljackson5994 3 года назад

    pls omaha beach dog green sector. or iwo jima