I wonder why HYBE keeps debuting unready idols? I mean, the foundation of being a singer is to sing! Illit had a wonderful song for a debut though, but I'm hoping they could really learn to sing, not just to dance, no hate, But Minju is the only one who is really stable and she is a former YG trainee too
The show was obviously rigged but they chose not THAT horrible at singing idols. They could definitely improve pretty quickly if they'd get vocal training. But this is hybe we're talking about so that won't happen
@@nayeonsbunny1 but they're from a survival show right? they supposedly already improved during their time in there, also their debut got postponed for months, what were they doing during those time? But I agree with you tho, it's Hybe, they'll never listen to what people say, even their own group fans lol
I agree and I realised that now they are adding auto tune during the encore as well? Especially since Le Serafim, now illit is also doing it? I don’t know if other groups outside Hybe are doing this or it’s only Hybe?
@@jiaxenha OMG!!! really? imma vote mah girl from multiple accounts lol but when is iland 2 starting? i knew it's in the second quater of this year but didn't know the date...
People who tries hard defending them would say: "Do you know how hard it is to sing while dancing?" Point taken, but isn't that why they train for a long time? ILLIT during their terrible encore: "They were crying! It's hard to sing while crying" Okay lol another exucse. What video are you watching because I don't see any tears. All I see were heavy lights reflecting on their eyes which makes it look like they're teary. AND real singers don't find it that hard to sing while crying lol. I don't hate them. I just hate some of their fans who can't admit facts.
I agree, also to ppl saying they are just a rookie group, plz watch BabyMonster’s MR removed video vs Illit’s, you can hear the major difference. Both groups went through survival show yet YG’s rookie group is stronger in singing, dancing, rapping.
@@nmixxcoasterbut they're an idol group from a survival show, supposedly they improve during their time in runext, also they postponed their debut before, and didn't seen for months, what were they doing during those times then?
@@nmixxcoasterimprove? They are debuted because they're ready to perform and sing well and also they are trained for that before debut I think they're dancers not idols.
@@jacemontefalco5703 let's take lia and shuhua, for an example. both didn't debut with good skills, but improved a lot since time has passed by. some people improve fast, while others improve slowly, but surely. if they don't improve, then they shouldn't be idols and that's it 🤷🏻♀️ that's my point though
@@DesireAeria I don't think so, YG artist has never perform on music bank, they probably attend sbs Inkigayo, mushow/mbc, and if we're lucky mnet(?) As well
No es que no puedan cantar, es que las canciones son difíciles de cantar en cuanto a control de liberación de aire y si estas bailando y cantando al mismo tiempo, no es tan sencillo como se cree. No porque a ciertos idols se les haga más fácil significa q sea una tarea sencilla, ni siquiera tiene que ver con la capacidad vocal o condición física, sino con el entrenamiento muscular y control de los órganos implicados en todo el proceso de cantar desde el diafragma, pulmones, garganta, cuerdas vocales, etc. Así que simplemente es cuestión de práctica y acostumbrar al cuerpo, si no se dedican a ser idols creo que no es adecuado establecer juicios de valor infundados. Todas tienen voces preciosas, con colores vocales unicos y buena técnica vocal :D
Why they debut them if they're not ready to sing live even if they dancing but as an idol they're gonna perform it with their voices I think they are more dancers than idol singers
Girl groups in other agencies dare to appear without lips with loud but good dances. Why is it only the Hybe girl group that can't encore well than its senior girl groups?
They can sing live, only problem is that Hype choreographies are more intense than others and require more effort. In reality, there are very few idols who actually sing live as well as in the studio. The few who sing 100% live are more accustomed to the stage because they have more experience. It doesn't make much sense that they have more training behind the scenes when the experience they need is to sing well live, on stage, nerves also play against the idol. What I'm saying is that it's too early to judge that they don't know how to sing when hasn't even been a month since their debut.
@@naoslor4129 they want to be an idol but without proper training by themselves and joined the survival show and debuted and then after debuted improving huh, what they do on the survival show even if they are slow learner it's their choice if they work hard to learn faster also it's their obligation as an idol I think they do on the survival show is just dancing and just a month debuting is just an excuse thier so many new idols/groups they sing live without hesitation and they're just debuting too. (my option only)
I understand singing when dancing and jumping around the stage is difficult and you can be out of breath but what I don’t understand is why they are using auto tune during Encore? Is this some sort of new trend ever since Le Serafim started doing it? Cause now illit is using auto tune during encore as well? I haven’t seen other groups doing this except them
Jimin and all bts can't sing live either what are you on 😂😂😂 they're more terrible and worse, You're not making it any better by this cringe, bts is the worst kpop group vocally, shut up and cry about it 🤣🤣
Uhm bae exchange your see to "hear", and u can literally hear wonhee sing some of her parts, yes wonhee rarely sing live and needs to have a vocal training
@@wonslight I know but I was saying that they should sing the whole song because they are a singer but just adding a little dance to entertain, but they think performance is the most important thing and then the singing
When you debut a dancer not a singer, okay let's do autotune for them..OMG! What's happening in the new era of KPOP, Old Idols can sing and dance what a disgrace.
No because people are defending this by saying the dance moves are hard... look at aespa, newjeans(kinda), stray kids, ateez, blackpink, Le sserafim, itzy... They can sing and dance these idols are so bad hybe is stupid for releasing them when they sound like this
can y'all act stuff and educate yourself before you hate on young idols cuz you cant expect them to sound like Beyonce or some crap cuz its not that easy to have breathe control plus yk there is sm called a search bar where u can see their live singing
This is not what K-Pop should be, HYBE dropping unready groups and giving us NewJeans Style in Bad, the fact that the only one who can sing is a YG Trainee says everything… but in HYBE you dont have to sing, cause the Songs Are so pitched to fit the dreamy concept.
There's no excuse for them being rookies so they still can't sing live... Like they debuted from a survival show and it's not that it's the first time they're performing in front of an audience
번역해본 댓글들이 다 하이브가 댄스팀을 데뷔시킨다고 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 노래 제대로 부르지 못하는 아이들만 모으는 것도 능력이구나..
노래실력은 그냥 다 버리고 춤,외모로 밀고 가는 듯…
@@user-so8fx4qe5w외모도 그닥임
They can't even dance properly tho
listen to vvup’s mr removed guys, you’ll be amazed
real!
They're wayy too underrated
I wonder why HYBE keeps debuting unready idols? I mean, the foundation of being a singer is to sing! Illit had a wonderful song for a debut though, but I'm hoping they could really learn to sing, not just to dance, no hate, But Minju is the only one who is really stable and she is a former YG trainee too
It has become hybe habit these days lol, they let their idols especially gg perform like a dancer and not an idol
The show was obviously rigged but they chose not THAT horrible at singing idols. They could definitely improve pretty quickly if they'd get vocal training. But this is hybe we're talking about so that won't happen
@@nayeonsbunny1 but they're from a survival show right? they supposedly already improved during their time in there, also their debut got postponed for months, what were they doing during those time?
But I agree with you tho, it's Hybe, they'll never listen to what people say, even their own group fans lol
I agree and I realised that now they are adding auto tune during the encore as well? Especially since Le Serafim, now illit is also doing it? I don’t know if other groups outside Hybe are doing this or it’s only Hybe?
And yet there are hundreds of other idols who still aren't fit to be idols and you're coming after a ROOKIE girl group that debuted a week ago 💀
They're not crying right now hahaha
well obviously they sounded good just shallow vocals ^_^
Yes they're live vocals are really not stable but why the "hahaha"? Its not funny
춤을 출때 노래 잘해야지 아이돌입니다
How dare Hybe debuting this kind of quality.
They eliminated jiwoo and jeemin for this? and missed out Youngseo too? idk what hybe's thinking
Jeemin is now in I land 2 let's Manifest that she will debut
@@jiaxenha OMG!!! really? imma vote mah girl from multiple accounts lol but when is iland 2 starting? i knew it's in the second quater of this year but didn't know the date...
@@L_E_T_apostrophe_S_G_O18th april i think!
@@smn_tr3asur3 thank you❤
@@L_E_T_apostrophe_S_G_O yw!
Another le sserafim 😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂😂😂
Maybe better than..?
@@KimKim-tf4od In your dreams
@@jonniechimpes-hv4pg :)))well better than kazuha and sakura🤷♀️
@@KimKim-tf4od is what I would say if I was a fatty
People who tries hard defending them would say:
"Do you know how hard it is to sing while dancing?"
Point taken, but isn't that why they train for a long time?
ILLIT during their terrible encore:
"They were crying! It's hard to sing while crying"
Okay lol another exucse. What video are you watching because I don't see any tears. All I see were heavy lights reflecting on their eyes which makes it look like they're teary. AND real singers don't find it that hard to sing while crying lol.
I don't hate them. I just hate some of their fans who can't admit facts.
I agree, also to ppl saying they are just a rookie group, plz watch BabyMonster’s MR removed video vs Illit’s, you can hear the major difference. Both groups went through survival show yet YG’s rookie group is stronger in singing, dancing, rapping.
이거 뭐야??? 유치원 졸업무대인가???? 하이브 BTS 가 건물세웠다고 손놓고있네..... 방시혁 일좀해요!!!!!
I can see what Wonhee usually lip syncs …
Are you guys hearing what I'm hearing it sounds so bad and it seems like they're struggling to save their own song even when the low register
they can improve in the future. some people just need more time to improve.
@@nmixxcoasterbut they're an idol group from a survival show, supposedly they improve during their time in runext, also they postponed their debut before, and didn't seen for months, what were they doing during those times then?
@@n0tyourLovaa you're still right, but the show was rigged either way though
@@nmixxcoasterimprove? They are debuted because they're ready to perform and sing well and also they are trained for that before debut I think they're dancers not idols.
@@jacemontefalco5703 let's take lia and shuhua, for an example. both didn't debut with good skills, but improved a lot since time has passed by. some people improve fast, while others improve slowly, but surely. if they don't improve, then they shouldn't be idols and that's it 🤷🏻♀️
that's my point though
😂😂😂😂😂😂 the vocal,.....this is if you debut dancer group
Nge😂😂😂 UNIS❤❤
Oemgi Can't believe it
음…..이건 쉴드 불가다…
Can you pls do baby monster
but they even went to inkigayo 😭😭😭 they'll the next week
@@nauen--fxBaby monster will go to music bank too?
@@DesireAeria I don't think so, YG artist has never perform on music bank, they probably attend sbs Inkigayo, mushow/mbc, and if we're lucky mnet(?) As well
No es que no puedan cantar, es que las canciones son difíciles de cantar en cuanto a control de liberación de aire y si estas bailando y cantando al mismo tiempo, no es tan sencillo como se cree. No porque a ciertos idols se les haga más fácil significa q sea una tarea sencilla, ni siquiera tiene que ver con la capacidad vocal o condición física, sino con el entrenamiento muscular y control de los órganos implicados en todo el proceso de cantar desde el diafragma, pulmones, garganta, cuerdas vocales, etc. Así que simplemente es cuestión de práctica y acostumbrar al cuerpo, si no se dedican a ser idols creo que no es adecuado establecer juicios de valor infundados. Todas tienen voces preciosas, con colores vocales unicos y buena técnica vocal :D
Why they debut them if they're not ready to sing live even if they dancing but as an idol they're gonna perform it with their voices I think they are more dancers than idol singers
Girl groups in other agencies dare to appear without lips with loud but good dances. Why is it only the Hybe girl group that can't encore well than its senior girl groups?
They can sing live, only problem is that Hype choreographies are more intense than others and require more effort. In reality, there are very few idols who actually sing live as well as in the studio. The few who sing 100% live are more accustomed to the stage because they have more experience. It doesn't make much sense that they have more training behind the scenes when the experience they need is to sing well live, on stage, nerves also play against the idol. What I'm saying is that it's too early to judge that they don't know how to sing when hasn't even been a month since their debut.
@@naoslor4129 they want to be an idol but without proper training by themselves and joined the survival show and debuted and then after debuted improving huh, what they do on the survival show even if they are slow learner it's their choice if they work hard to learn faster also it's their obligation as an idol I think they do on the survival show is just dancing and just a month debuting is just an excuse thier so many new idols/groups they sing live without hesitation and they're just debuting too.
(my option only)
Please can you upload some songs of XG
I understand singing when dancing and jumping around the stage is difficult and you can be out of breath but what I don’t understand is why they are using auto tune during Encore? Is this some sort of new trend ever since Le Serafim started doing it? Cause now illit is using auto tune during encore as well? I haven’t seen other groups doing this except them
they won The Show but they can't sing live. What a shame to BTS. lol
How is it connected to BTS ?, and if you're comparing to a group that existed for YEARS and a rookie group who debuted for WEEKS is just crazy
@@wonslight Again, listen to BabyMonster’s MR removed video vs Illit, you can hear the major difference. Btw both groups are rookies
Jimin and all bts can't sing live either what are you on 😂😂😂 they're more terrible and worse, You're not making it any better by this cringe, bts is the worst kpop group vocally, shut up and cry about it 🤣🤣
Even when they're mics are on they are still not singing. Its not the company its them! Especially Wonhee i never see her sing live.
Uhm bae exchange your see to "hear", and u can literally hear wonhee sing some of her parts, yes wonhee rarely sing live and needs to have a vocal training
@@wonslight but it should be all or most not some parts
@@뱃살공주-s9c i meant that wonhee sings some parts, i didn't say that wonhee should sing just some parts
@@wonslight I know but I was saying that they should sing the whole song because they are a singer but just adding a little dance to entertain, but they think performance is the most important thing and then the singing
I mean the parts that she is supposed to sing not the whole song
andai bisa tag hybe langsung .....
omg 😂
Make one for ONEUS please
I hope this group not forever? I mean from survival show only a couple years?
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
Can u pls do txt comeback showcase
The Morse code means tomorrow
why do hybe keep producing mediocre idols?!
i love how yall keep them so relevant 💕😂
anyways stan illit
When you debut a dancer not a singer, okay let's do autotune for them..OMG! What's happening in the new era of KPOP,
Old Idols can sing and dance what a disgrace.
🤧
HEY ADMIN I want their the music show encore please
💀
There’s no point listening to the encore, for some reason they have started doing auto tune for that as well😭
@@rianpark8332autotune ≠ backtrack
No because people are defending this by saying the dance moves are hard... look at aespa, newjeans(kinda), stray kids, ateez, blackpink, Le sserafim, itzy... They can sing and dance these idols are so bad hybe is stupid for releasing them when they sound like this
I don't hearing they singing only like they talking
Huh ?, u can deff hear the members sing but not really 🤨
They are good but I think VVUP is much better even though they're from a small agency
😂😂
이건 솔직히 mr 제거작업 고의적 장난질 많이 한거잖아 적당히좀 해라..
애들이 불쌍하네
Kaya mayat
Well at least they didn’t lip sync here?
can y'all act stuff and educate yourself before you hate on young idols cuz you cant expect them to sound like Beyonce or some crap cuz its not that easy to have breathe control plus yk there is sm called a search bar where u can see their live singing
Rigged-it
Go cry about it!
real
@@Kurafilm. Rigged-it Rigged-itRigged-itRigged-itRigged-itRigged-itRigged-itRigged-itRigged-itRigged-itRigged-itRigged-itRigged-itRigged-itRigged-itRigged-itRigged-itRigged-itRigged-itRigged-itRigged-itRigged-itRigged-itRigged-itRigged-it
@ddavvs you thought you did something lol 💀
@ddavvs also i never said anything related to their singing kindly try to read properly 💀
Why they don't sing? Its their debut isnt it
이젠 하이브 여돌 믿거
srsly?? 😂
This is not what K-Pop should be, HYBE dropping unready groups and giving us NewJeans Style in Bad, the fact that the only one who can sing is a YG Trainee says everything… but in HYBE you dont have to sing, cause the Songs Are so pitched to fit the dreamy concept.
🐑
뭐라는 거냐...?
Why do HYBE debuted this group that still needs years of training? 🤦🏻♀️🤦🏻♀️🤦🏻♀️
뭐야 이게
There's no excuse for them being rookies so they still can't sing live... Like they debuted from a survival show and it's not that it's the first time they're performing in front of an audience
This is so embarrassing 😂
Their encore was so bad too 😂 they were just standing but could not sing their OWN song. Wtf is this? Singers who can't sing.
They can definitely do better
Stop adding Japanese Trainee if they can't sing omg let them practice more and harder cos the way they sang is different, so they need more practice!!
Alana es igual a agustin en lloros, que paja ver noticias todo el tiempo de la llorona
Singer but not singing?
terrible
🤮
:/
원희는 최악이야 춤도 노래도. 심지어 얼굴합도 안맞음
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 are they back up dancers? they can't sing ngl.
i think my little sister can sing much better than this 😅
그래도 서바이벌 출신 아이돌인데… ㅋㅋ 왜 그러지