Gotta say....I really dig the Historic Brawl content...particularly this many videos of it in a row. My play has shifted in the last 6 months or so. I spam limited, particularly when a new set comes out, for the sake of building my collection of the new set and farming wild cards. I play a little bit of standard just for the sake of ranking up into platinum for max cosmetic rewards. Diamond and Mythic are only worth another pack each so not worth the sweat. Brawl and events is where I spend most of my time. It's where all of my wild cards go. What is so enjoyable about it is you can decide you don't want to be uber competitive one day and go with a slum/jank commander....and you will then get a chance to play against other jank commanders. You can't really do that in standard because if I go with a jank deck...I'm still going to be playing against people trying to ladder. It's nice to be able to decide how much of a try-hard I want to be at any given time so I appreciate the content.
You know, i also like the CGB's Historic Brawl content, but the lack of rank in this mode makes people scoop so easily because they have nothing to lose. So it makes not as much interesting as the Stardand rank content, where people fight till the last drop of hope. Well, it is what it is.
That last game against bridge had me at the edge of my seat. Cannot praise enough this Historic Brawl content. It’s my favorite arena format and you do such a good job with your content. Happy Brawlcation!
Hi, it’s me, the Niv Mizzet player :-) Man, seeing your commentary on that match, you read me like a book haha. I was so heartbroken when you brought Narset back, I wanted to cast Timetwister so badly. But I am honored to have made it into one of your videos, sensei. Thanks for the great game.
Awesome deck. That first win against niv was icy 🥶 If you had a ton of fun with Tasha, try a build with Narset of the Ancient Way. Places in High A-Low S, and you can easily get a turn 4 ultimate using a similar play pattern of turn 2 rock, turn 3 Narset plus, turn 4 proliferate. Replace Elderspell with Flux Channeler and boom ez emblem.
CGB! Your brawl videos are amazing!! But we are in dark times... All I ever play against is sweaty Rusko decks on the ladder... We need a HERO!! We need CGB to make a deck specifically for shredding Rusko!! He must be stopped! At. All. Cost. Thank you ;)
You could have ended the niv game 1 turn sooner by taking the elder spell and killing your own narset. It’s be risky because you didn’t know that they had only 2 creatures but hindsight is 20/20
Tezzeret’s Gambit is just one of those cards that seems subpar on the surface, but everytime I play or see someone else play it in the right deck, it’s just a powerhouse. Every game CGB drew the card it let him ulti a turn faster, which is monumental.
I played against that same Esika Planeswalkers deck yesterday. They played the bridge side and I had nothing going on, was ready for defeat. So I played the only card I could. The Immortal Sun, only thinking that the second card draw might get me something if I survived the next turn. Then the planeswalkers started popping out. I could not believe my luck on that one. Was able to wrap up the game before they could get what they needed to blow up my Sun.
I was leery about using wildcards for Brawl - seems like a bit risk to craft cards that you can't use in Standard if you end up not liking the deck. But I've been loving it. Having a great time with Uro. Also, not sure if the views warranted the work, but I really loved the deck tech videos! Helps me understand not just card choices but things like play patterns and the meta.
The thing is that for brawl you only need to craft 1 wc for each rare. And for some of the rares you can have worse uncommon substitutions. You can also be cheap on the mana base. It's much easier to get into the HB scene especially if you played arena for some time.
The thing that pisses me off the most about HB right now is for whatever reason Rusko has not been solidified into hell queue yet so I'm over playing my wide variety of HB decks and more than 50% of the time I'm queuing up against Rusko and its absolute bullshit. I don't understand why Rusko is being paired down so much after he's proven he's like the top 3 god tier HB deck alongside Teferi and Niv.
Um well...actually, may I please say that game three was exceedingly awesome...yes, I know. I'm going over the top at this point, but the games are amazing.
I am rather sure that the second Niv player fetched the Curiosity with the Wishclaw. It's also why I am somewhat cautious of giving Niv decks a Wishclaw. The Niv deck is very much a combo deck, but somewhat lacks tutors (though obviously has amazing card draw).
I love historic Brawl but haven't really played against any good decks with this commander. I love this list am having lots of fun with it :-) I won the first 5 games in a row XD
Man the number of premature scoops from your opponents is unreal. The slightest setback or unexpected development and they take their ball and go home.
Hey CGB! Could you maybe include suggestions for more Budget Versions of your Historic Brawl decks? I love all the Decks and Especially the Esper/Dimir/Azorious Colored ones but they are so freaking expensive. So if possible some suggestions to make them a little bit more affordable (especially the Mana Base) would be nice and much appreciated!
@@FOX119900 kinda the same thing, though, tbh. IIRC, his response was something along the lines of considering it his obligation to show people the best decks, as they’re supposed to be built for the greatest success, and leaving it open to viewers to make their own cuts if they need to.
dark ritual vs black lotus. benefits and draw backs. black lotus is and artifact has to be sacrificed but it cots 0. dark ritual is an instant some cards let you play instants from your graveyard and you can copy them lol.
wait wait wait....... are you say the queue to play is based off commanders and not just finding randoms to play at the same time i am?? cuz i call complete bs on that. i get paired against 5 color horrendously too much when playing literally anything, and i switch it up every day. i rarely can beat any 5 color build unless i'm playing 3+ color.
I still don't understand why they had to make a new version for Alchemy, using the same art just to keep people guessing. I actually like the Alchemy version better. I'd love that piece to be actual cardboard. The fact I know it won't be makes me sad. It was a perfectly good idea for a piece of cardboard, and now it just can't be one.
I so hate Kinnen. There really are only two types of players who run them: player A wants nothing more than to spin the wheel for chonkers starting on turn 4 and if you put that off by even a turn they run away from the game faster than Roadrunner. Player B just wants to spin as many times as possible and will refuse to give up any game, no matter how hopeless it is, because they might, just MIGHT, hit that creature that somehow wins them the game. So they're casting a 10, 12, 14 mana Kinnen every turn, with no ability to defend, protect or spin him until you manage to finally grab the kill from them (with my Tasha deck it's often with their crappy mana creatures since I rarely ever manage to hit one of their chonkers).
Destroying Niv is so satisfying on its own, but beating Niv by making them draw from an empty deck? I don't think there's a better feeling in all of Magic.
You know, i like CGB's Historic Brawl content, but the lack of rank in this mode makes people scoop so easily because they have NOTHING to lose. So it makes not as much interesting as the Stardand rank content, where people fight till the last drop of hope. Well, it is what it is.
So why are you okay with playing alchemy cards in brawl, but not in the alchemy format. Just play alchemy, and finally admit that it’s be best format! (I know you are a closet alchemy fan, and I’m here to out you)
Man, Brainstorming turn 1 is 99,9% of the time the wrong call. You even had The Consider there. Just a small strategy heads up (I know you said criticism of plays here is bad vibes but i Hope this comes off as constructive)
![💧💀 Tasha, Unholy Archmage | Historic Brawl [MTG Arena]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/3kV-5xrl6K0/mqdefault.jpg)
Gotta say....I really dig the Historic Brawl content...particularly this many videos of it in a row. My play has shifted in the last 6 months or so. I spam limited, particularly when a new set comes out, for the sake of building my collection of the new set and farming wild cards. I play a little bit of standard just for the sake of ranking up into platinum for max cosmetic rewards. Diamond and Mythic are only worth another pack each so not worth the sweat.
Brawl and events is where I spend most of my time. It's where all of my wild cards go. What is so enjoyable about it is you can decide you don't want to be uber competitive one day and go with a slum/jank commander....and you will then get a chance to play against other jank commanders. You can't really do that in standard because if I go with a jank deck...I'm still going to be playing against people trying to ladder. It's nice to be able to decide how much of a try-hard I want to be at any given time so I appreciate the content.
You know, i also like the CGB's Historic Brawl content, but the lack of rank in this mode makes people scoop so easily because they have nothing to lose. So it makes not as much interesting as the Stardand rank content, where people fight till the last drop of hope. Well, it is what it is.
Hard to use Lofty Denial with R+G mana
Lmao came here to say this
At long last! To the glory of playing other people’s cards better than them!
That last game against bridge had me at the edge of my seat. Cannot praise enough this Historic Brawl content. It’s my favorite arena format and you do such a good job with your content. Happy Brawlcation!
Hi, it’s me, the Niv Mizzet player :-)
Man, seeing your commentary on that match, you read me like a book haha. I was so heartbroken when you brought Narset back, I wanted to cast Timetwister so badly.
But I am honored to have made it into one of your videos, sensei. Thanks for the great game.
Who's your favorite Historic Brawl commander?
Chatterfang but I can’t win with him very often
Do raffine 🤓
rosco clack maker si very fun and also dimir
I play a lot of the usual suspects....Rusko, Bolas, Golos, etc....but a guilty pleasure is Hinata.
Jin-Gitaxias, Progress Tyrant for sure, and he still plays in a fun queue.
Now that first game is magic! None of that sweaty crap
When you took Day of Judgment with Thoughtseize, you 'seized the Day.
That first match was intense! A lovely Stevens to end it as well, brilliant!
Awesome deck. That first win against niv was icy 🥶
If you had a ton of fun with Tasha, try a build with Narset of the Ancient Way. Places in High A-Low S, and you can easily get a turn 4 ultimate using a similar play pattern of turn 2 rock, turn 3 Narset plus, turn 4 proliferate. Replace Elderspell with Flux Channeler and boom ez emblem.
CGB! Your brawl videos are amazing!!
But we are in dark times...
All I ever play against is sweaty Rusko decks on the ladder...
We need a HERO!!
We need CGB to make a deck specifically for shredding Rusko!! He must be stopped! At. All. Cost.
Thank you ;)
You could have ended the niv game 1 turn sooner by taking the elder spell and killing your own narset. It’s be risky because you didn’t know that they had only 2 creatures but hindsight is 20/20
Tezzeret’s Gambit is just one of those cards that seems subpar on the surface, but everytime I play or see someone else play it in the right deck, it’s just a powerhouse. Every game CGB drew the card it let him ulti a turn faster, which is monumental.
It's a great proliferate card the draws are secondary honestly
brawl is so fun... the one card rule make the game fantastic.. several options with no option lol... it is really fun. TY for that CGB
I played against that same Esika Planeswalkers deck yesterday. They played the bridge side and I had nothing going on, was ready for defeat. So I played the only card I could. The Immortal Sun, only thinking that the second card draw might get me something if I survived the next turn. Then the planeswalkers started popping out. I could not believe my luck on that one. Was able to wrap up the game before they could get what they needed to blow up my Sun.
i had a guess in the summer that a black blue deck with witch queen could be super interesting
Experimental Augury is a nice little addition, too. Dig for three, choose, proliferate.
I could watch this deck play all day long
That 1st game was such a pleasure to watch.
i really like blood on the snow lol. Olivia pairs nicely with it...
“I wanna play commander!”
“We have commander at home”
Commander at home: HELL QUEUE
I’ve been struggling to decide where to invest my few wildcards, but it might be this format. Seems really fun
I was leery about using wildcards for Brawl - seems like a bit risk to craft cards that you can't use in Standard if you end up not liking the deck. But I've been loving it. Having a great time with Uro.
Also, not sure if the views warranted the work, but I really loved the deck tech videos! Helps me understand not just card choices but things like play patterns and the meta.
The thing is that for brawl you only need to craft 1 wc for each rare. And for some of the rares you can have worse uncommon substitutions. You can also be cheap on the mana base. It's much easier to get into the HB scene especially if you played arena for some time.
So satisfying winning a game on 1hp, especially if it's a confident play, no timing out and the player doesn't DC.
Loving January for the brawl!
Sick first game CGB.
Why doesn't CGB use the Johnny avatar when it looks like him?
Are there actual matchmaking tiers, or do you just have to intuit it?
Very entertaining, thanks!
My only problem with brawl is I have to go back and remember to rank up since I’ve forgotten about standard lol.
I love her as a commander or even in the 99 she’s definitely A tier
How do you decide whether to put in cards like Mox Jet or Mox Pearl?
The thing that pisses me off the most about HB right now is for whatever reason Rusko has not been solidified into hell queue yet so I'm over playing my wide variety of HB decks and more than 50% of the time I'm queuing up against Rusko and its absolute bullshit. I don't understand why Rusko is being paired down so much after he's proven he's like the top 3 god tier HB deck alongside Teferi and Niv.
The first game was by far the most legendary thing I’ve seen
Dude, this HB vacay is gonna get you to that magic number soooooon!
169,420
Let's GO!
How do you know that she has been moved to high A-queue? Just based on the opponents you're facing?
May I pease just take a moment to point out that came one was absolutely perfect.
Actually, may I please take another moment to point out that game two was equally amazing....please.. haha
Um well...actually, may I please say that game three was exceedingly awesome...yes, I know. I'm going over the top at this point, but the games are amazing.
Ya know, if you had to play against yourself, you'd lose your flipping mind with how slowly you play.
I think that’s why the second opponent scooped.
I am rather sure that the second Niv player fetched the Curiosity with the Wishclaw. It's also why I am somewhat cautious of giving Niv decks a Wishclaw. The Niv deck is very much a combo deck, but somewhat lacks tutors (though obviously has amazing card draw).
Im a simple man, I see Dimir I watch the Vid, I see Mill I smash the like. Sick Vid.
That first game was beautiful.
My greatest wish for MTGA was that we had gotten the paper Tasha.
I haven't touched paper In years what did They change before putting her on arena?
…we did
Lucky they didnt cast lofty denial /s
Have you ever played Niv-Mizzet, Parun in cHB? Would love to see your take on it.
I love historic Brawl but haven't really played against any good decks with this commander. I love this list am having lots of fun with it :-) I won the first 5 games in a row XD
Man the number of premature scoops from your opponents is unreal. The slightest setback or unexpected development and they take their ball and go home.
Guess you could say solve the equation. SOLVED THE PROBLEM in that first match. Hehe
jesus christ that first game was beautiful
whats with the mono counter spell decks?
TASHA AND CGB, WHAT A VIDEO
Hey CGB! Could you maybe include suggestions for more Budget Versions of your Historic Brawl decks? I love all the Decks and Especially the Esper/Dimir/Azorious Colored ones but they are so freaking expensive. So if possible some suggestions to make them a little bit more affordable (especially the Mana Base) would be nice and much appreciated!
He’s said before that he’s not interested in doing budget decks.
@@johnrobertson1Not budget Decks, but suggestions how to keep them more budget friendly.
@@FOX119900 kinda the same thing, though, tbh. IIRC, his response was something along the lines of considering it his obligation to show people the best decks, as they’re supposed to be built for the greatest success, and leaving it open to viewers to make their own cuts if they need to.
dark ritual vs black lotus. benefits and draw backs. black lotus is and artifact has to be sacrificed but it cots 0. dark ritual is an instant some cards let you play instants from your graveyard and you can copy them lol.
To everyone who plays Tasha without Displacer Kitten : you absolutely should. Most broken card in this deck without hesitation
wait wait wait....... are you say the queue to play is based off commanders and not just finding randoms to play at the same time i am?? cuz i call complete bs on that. i get paired against 5 color horrendously too much when playing literally anything, and i switch it up every day. i rarely can beat any 5 color build unless i'm playing 3+ color.
Hey cgb why dont you try Vannifar? I played her a bunch and she seemed very strong and consistent
I still don't understand why they had to make a new version for Alchemy, using the same art just to keep people guessing.
I actually like the Alchemy version better. I'd love that piece to be actual cardboard. The fact I know it won't be makes me sad. It was a perfectly good idea for a piece of cardboard, and now it just can't be one.
I've been playing Tasha for weeks and never found the mirror. I'm so glad because f the mirror match up. Worst idea ever!
Try a Xanathar deck with roughly the same kind of dimir control shell to really maximize the salt
Pact weapon and connections is fire
i noticed, u wouldnt get the tasha back with blood on the snow cause u would only have 3 snow lands not 4
I so hate Kinnen. There really are only two types of players who run them: player A wants nothing more than to spin the wheel for chonkers starting on turn 4 and if you put that off by even a turn they run away from the game faster than Roadrunner. Player B just wants to spin as many times as possible and will refuse to give up any game, no matter how hopeless it is, because they might, just MIGHT, hit that creature that somehow wins them the game. So they're casting a 10, 12, 14 mana Kinnen every turn, with no ability to defend, protect or spin him until you manage to finally grab the kill from them (with my Tasha deck it's often with their crappy mana creatures since I rarely ever manage to hit one of their chonkers).
Requesting a Xanathar deck
So many opponents with early scoops. Is that a common thing in brawl, or are so many opponents just impatient?
Destroying Niv is so satisfying on its own, but beating Niv by making them draw from an empty deck? I don't think there's a better feeling in all of Magic.
43:14 does anybody know why the opponent didn't play the Bridge here?
I'm not sure, but possibly brain damage.
My favourite Commander
best decks mill.
You should really add a spark double to this deck
Im really enjoying your brawl content! Anyway I can entice you to play my pet commander kykar? Haha.
Tasha hb needs an update, this is sweet
Life is just a resource!
Whats wrong with the Alchemy Cards?!
2 mana for an extra turn 😳
Historic Brawl is the best
we are getting close to 169 subs jinions are about to be appeased
Liebe Grüße aus Deutschland. Danke
Gonna be honest, the payoff for hitting that sub goal is very underwhelming.
You dont use wishclaw untill you can win the game
I see Tasha I turn off the ligh.... I upvote.
You know, i like CGB's Historic Brawl content, but the lack of rank in this mode makes people scoop so easily because they have NOTHING to lose. So it makes not as much interesting as the Stardand rank content, where people fight till the last drop of hope. Well, it is what it is.
Oooooo this is a mean list, the one I made is more fair. Just Rouges and control cards... this is the epic rude of rude.
Round 2 opp scooped because you took forever.
When is MTG going to make Brawl Ranked? Come on wizards
Second scooped because you didn't answer the GG
Mommy Tasha
FIRST!!! FOR CGB
Yo
Early gang.
Posting mill decks… shame on you CGB
First?
So why are you okay with playing alchemy cards in brawl, but not in the alchemy format.
Just play alchemy, and finally admit that it’s be best format! (I know you are a closet alchemy fan, and I’m here to out you)
Man, Brainstorming turn 1 is 99,9% of the time the wrong call. You even had The Consider there. Just a small strategy heads up (I know you said criticism of plays here is bad vibes but i Hope this comes off as constructive)
First