Here's an idea: What if TDA came first? Basically TDI didn't exist and TDA aired first with the canon cast of 14. You can have the full cast, but I think it'd be more interesting to be just the original cast and their dynamics, without knowing each other. You can still have Courtney debuting as a new character, same for the additions of WT (Noah, Tyler, Cody), beside Sierra and Alejandro.
It’s nice to see Katie and Sadie have a storyline going here. Out of the everyone in the og cast those two and Eva didn’t really get much screen time so it’s nice to see
It's great to see Katie and Sadie getting farther in the game together! when I was watching I thought that since there are no teams they would get father then they would before with teams. Excited to see what happens to them in the future! ^_^
This is really great ! I love that Owen is cut second and Katie and Sadie seem to have a main arc in the season. You came up with really great ideas, I sure want to see the second part
I’m sorry but Bridgette getting booted out 4th is wild 💀 Heather did not like Leshawna or Gwen at all on the actual show wouldn’t she try to get the numbers on her side to get rid of them fast
Oh I was right lol (: Looks like I'm good at predicting (: Me when I see who is the fourth eleminated: )::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::
Even if Cody wouldnt be eliminated by chris in canon, you still can do whatever you want in this What If lol, its your video anyways, do whatever makes sense
I wonder if heather will be able to get katie back on her side? if Sadie gets voted out, she could get lindsey convince Katie that the guys voted sadie out making katie join their side again and having katie blow up at them providing heather's alliance with a shield in katie. or having lindsey and tyler defect and join sadie and katie to make a 4 way alliance for the late game.
It would be interesting to see what if another contestant in TDI was the main antagonist instead of heather….then again some things about him or her would have to change up.
My ideas: What if Sierra and Topher swapped seasons? What if Katie and Sadie AND Amy and Sammie swapped seasons? What if Trent didn't obsess over Gwen in Action? What if Duncan didn't come back World Tour? What if Scarlett wasn't cartoonishly evil? What if Sky and Zoey swapped seasons? What if Blaineley was the host of Total Drama? What if Scott and Rodney swapped seasons? What if Bridgette was the ratings freak instead of Geoff? What if Sierra didn't blow up the plane in World Tour? What if Dakota wasn't mutated? What if Ezekiel didn't become feral? What if Alejandro and Justin switched seasons?
I dislike the characterization of Justin in the Dodgebrawl challenge. He canonically participates, and seems to do average. Basing it on his Action character shift makes it more of a "My Way" than a "What If", if you ask me. With that said, I mostly agree with the rest. Pretty neat idea, and good execution.
Hey just a quick note, Ik lindsay diddnt win immunity first challange anyway, but she said "if heathers not doing it im not doing it" so lindsay wouldnt do it
Just one correction. I think Lindsay wouldn't have jumped either, because she wouldnt jump unless Heather did, and since Heather didn't, she wouldn't jump. Just a correction. Overall, amazing video.
I feel Lindsay should have lost immunity earlier in the first challenge because when Heather said she would jump she said "If she's not doing it I'm not doing it"
What if gwen won the tie breaker in tdwt? What if trent wasn't obsessed in tda? What if brick got eliminated in ep 4 of tdroti? What if geoff never agreed to voting bridgette?
Even though Noah got eliminated pretty early I still think this is such a good vid. The thought put into this makes sense and although I think heather still has some plot armour I cant be mad because she makes the series so enjoyable. Keep up the work man
But I think once her Alliance had a majority she would use a tactic to get rid of Tyler later on down the line so they both wouldn't vote for her in the final three
It was great love the fact that Eva wasn’t just in two episodes. Great that she made it to three love the idea. Super interesting I hope for part two as soon as possible.
This was amazing, I love how you thought of plots, please do more the elimination order for now assuming there will be two people who will return like in canon: 24th Ezekiel 23rd Owen 22nd Eva 21st Bridgette 20th Justin 19th Noah 18th Izzy 17th Cody 16th Harold 15th Beth
Hey nice video you just earned a subscriber may you please tell me who’s left? It’s kinda confusing too tell and if you can’t that’s okay? Can’t wait for part 2 and you too do other seasons
Here's an idea:
What if TDA came first?
Basically TDI didn't exist and TDA aired first with the canon cast of 14. You can have the full cast, but I think it'd be more interesting to be just the original cast and their dynamics, without knowing each other. You can still have Courtney debuting as a new character, same for the additions of WT (Noah, Tyler, Cody), beside Sierra and Alejandro.
It would be interesting to see what it would be like if Eva, Katie and Sadie never existed because they didn’t qualify for any of the later seasons.
I love that Idea
🤪
Would Heather be bald or no?
i love that katie & sadie have an arc 😭🩷
Bro never runs out of ideas but can u do if ava was in action
Real
Yess
It’s nice to see Katie and Sadie have a storyline going here. Out of the everyone in the og cast those two and Eva didn’t really get much screen time so it’s nice to see
It's great to see Katie and Sadie getting farther in the game together! when I was watching I thought that since there are no teams they would get father then they would before with teams. Excited to see what happens to them in the future! ^_^
This is really great ! I love that Owen is cut second and Katie and Sadie seem to have a main arc in the season. You came up with really great ideas, I sure want to see the second part
Yesss Sadie is a queen without her own empire
PLEASE DO THE OTHER SEASONS!!!
I’m sorry but Bridgette getting booted out 4th is wild 💀 Heather did not like Leshawna or Gwen at all on the actual show wouldn’t she try to get the numbers on her side to get rid of them fast
I've always thought a merge-only season would be interesting, so this is really cool to see!
The Ridonculous Race comes as a close canon counterpart, but it still has teams (as opposed to individuals) and elimination is automatic.
What if Action had everyone in it
Been a while since I last commented. I would like to request what if Katie and Sadie never got lost in the sixth episode of total drama
3:35 bye, im no longer watching
I had this idea for so long. I couldn't have asked for anyone better to do it.
My Way:
Ezekiel
Owen
Eva
Bridgette
Sadie
Geoff
Izzy
Cody
DJ
Beth
Justin
Noah
Courtney
Harold
Trent
Katie
Tyler
Gwen
Duncan
Lindsay
Heather
Leshawna
Oh I was right lol (:
Looks like I'm good at predicting (:
Me when I see who is the fourth eleminated: )::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::
Great idea honestly, looking forward to the second part
If There Wasn't Any Teams
It Would Just A Complete Disaster And Chaos
Love this, id be happy if you'd continue it.
I always wanted to see this. Great someone finally made it
Current placement according to this video:
22. Ezekiel
21. Owen
20. Eva
19. Bridgette
18. Justin
17. Noah
16. Izzy
15. Cody
14. Harold
13. Beth
Even if Cody wouldnt be eliminated by chris in canon, you still can do whatever you want in this What If lol, its your video anyways, do whatever makes sense
I'm early for once 🎉
I wonder if heather will be able to get katie back on her side? if Sadie gets voted out, she could get lindsey convince Katie that the guys voted sadie out making katie join their side again and having katie blow up at them providing heather's alliance with a shield in katie. or having lindsey and tyler defect and join sadie and katie to make a 4 way alliance for the late game.
❤❤
I’m curious as to how TDI would play out, if the teams were split by who are the first 11 to arrive and the second 11 to arrive.
It would be interesting to see what if another contestant in TDI was the main antagonist instead of heather….then again some things about him or her would have to change up.
My ideas:
What if Sierra and Topher swapped seasons?
What if Katie and Sadie AND Amy and Sammie swapped seasons?
What if Trent didn't obsess over Gwen in Action?
What if Duncan didn't come back World Tour?
What if Scarlett wasn't cartoonishly evil?
What if Sky and Zoey swapped seasons?
What if Blaineley was the host of Total Drama?
What if Scott and Rodney swapped seasons?
What if Bridgette was the ratings freak instead of Geoff?
What if Sierra didn't blow up the plane in World Tour?
What if Dakota wasn't mutated?
What if Ezekiel didn't become feral?
What if Alejandro and Justin switched seasons?
you are now obligated to do the other seasons.
What if Blaineley was a debut alongside Alejandro and Sierra OR What if Beth joined TDWT instead of Blaineley?
Ezekiel should not have lost
what if eva was in TDA
I dislike the characterization of Justin in the Dodgebrawl challenge. He canonically participates, and seems to do average. Basing it on his Action character shift makes it more of a "My Way" than a "What If", if you ask me.
With that said, I mostly agree with the rest. Pretty neat idea, and good execution.
Hey just a quick note, Ik lindsay diddnt win immunity first challange anyway, but she said "if heathers not doing it im not doing it" so lindsay wouldnt do it
Only after being prompted by the team, yes. But that wouldn't happen, so she wouldn't be gaining any points with Heather by saying that here
Just one correction. I think Lindsay wouldn't have jumped either, because she wouldnt jump unless Heather did, and since Heather didn't, she wouldn't jump. Just a correction. Overall, amazing video.
I feel Lindsay should have lost immunity earlier in the first challenge because when Heather said she would jump she said "If she's not doing it I'm not doing it"
What if gwen won the tie breaker in tdwt?
What if trent wasn't obsessed in tda?
What if brick got eliminated in ep 4 of tdroti?
What if geoff never agreed to voting bridgette?
3:22 Wait. Those were ten immunity winners-
3:27 But- But only 4 girls won immunity-
I don't think that would be enough girls for ezekiel to say anything
4 out of 11 is kinda big. Ezekiel would likely be salty even if it was 1 or 2
Don’t forget that Devin and Carrie also got eliminated in canon because Devin got injured, even though they didn’t place in the bottom.
what if Noah was a teamplayer, in dodgebrawal?
Hi! Nice video!
U gave heather more plot armor! 17:24
More of this more
Katie and Sadie would go early because they're annoying, unless people think it's a jury vote and are counting on them being annoying
ur more annoying than both of them combined
@@Ieshawna have you watched their episodes lately?
Even though Noah got eliminated pretty early I still think this is such a good vid. The thought put into this makes sense and although I think heather still has some plot armour I cant be mad because she makes the series so enjoyable. Keep up the work man
Of course she does. Plot armor to Heather (Except in Action) is like Gwen to Trent. If the former isn’t there, the latter will cease to exist.
hi do you tke requests?
I think Heather would take advantage of the fact that Tyler and Lindsay are together and manipulate both of them
But I think once her Alliance had a majority she would use a tactic to get rid of Tyler later on down the line so they both wouldn't vote for her in the final three
It was great love the fact that Eva wasn’t just in two episodes. Great that she made it to three love the idea. Super interesting I hope for part two as soon as possible.
PART 2
16:30 is there gonna be a branching path for if Katie shot Sadie with a real gun
I love the katie side switcharoo
You forgot in the first episode Lindsay said if Heather doesn’t jump she wouldn’t ❤
Only after being prompted by the team, yes. But that wouldn't happen, so she wouldn't be gaining any points with Heather by saying that here
17:10 You don't know how fast my heartbeat went here because Sadie's my favorite character
I feel bad if you main Stacy in total Roblox drama
@@eggnog_egg i don't she just my profile pic
@@Charles-xe4ow oh I love the pfp still
@@eggnog_egg This is outdated now, HAROLD is my fav character now
@@Charles-xe4ow oh
This was amazing, I love how you thought of plots, please do more
the elimination order for now assuming there will be two people who will return like in canon:
24th Ezekiel
23rd Owen
22nd Eva
21st Bridgette
20th Justin
19th Noah
18th Izzy
17th Cody
16th Harold
15th Beth
Hey nice video you just earned a subscriber may you please tell me who’s left? It’s kinda confusing too tell and if you can’t that’s okay? Can’t wait for part 2 and you too do other seasons
This Means If there's No Teams In total drama Island Then That Means It's Merge but with 22 contestants
Thanks sherlock
RIP Akira Toriyama
Sierra be like 'CODDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY'
nice vid btw
Nice
hey can you do a viedo where u disscus if "what if sierra wasnt obbssed with cody?"