Hadzabe Episode 1 is here: ruclips.net/video/Ny4bHOnSg0o/видео.html See the Snake Dancing Tribe? ruclips.net/video/r6hYmGscR_Q/видео.html My Secrets on How I Discover & Film Lost Tribes: www.fearlessandfar.com/tribes Thanks for the support! 🐉❤️
If you could ask again about the stars, ask them in a way they might understand, ask what do they think the stars are, why they are there. Ask about the planets, ask them if they see the stars that move and why they thing they move, a better person to ask might be an elder. Of course I could be wrong about them and they might of understud the question but it's worth a shot to ask again
imagine being vegan and thinking these people are immoral but all our modern tech that cause mass amounts of unnecessary suffering to animals is fine (vehicles, roads, cities, factories, fossil fuels, plastics, pollution, concrete, mines, buildings, clearing mass areas of land) how do people delude themselves into thinking they are superior
@@jedex4645 people are people... try to remember we are all just squishy mostly water bags of computer processing power, The world has all kinds of Agenda's and most of them do not relate to the message they spew , so can't blame the computer , gotta blame the system that feeds false data.
It feels like everyone expected them to be some deeply spiritual people but they are just incredibly practical. Less time to make up problems when you are busy surviving.
Generally speaking, hunter gatherers actually have a ton more free time and social time than we here in modern civilization to. Pretty sure they have plenty of spirtual discussions among themselves, but a) a lot was lost in translation, and b) those are pretty personal questions to ask someone and expect them to just answer in a deep way.
@@EnriqueCuevasCwb On personal level perhaps. But religion allows you to one up the other tribe. Think about how much easier it is to rile people up with illusions than with reality. I don't know is not an inspiring answer, even if honest. Promising perks after death works much better. I am surprised with their answers though. I always thought that the leader of a tribe will always have an answer, just because everyone expects that of him. I always assumed that's how religion started, by tribe leaders inventing things up to appear more knowledgeable to the others if anything. Seems they have so little time, that they don't even think much.
Funny he was looking for something deep but really just got simple survivalistic answers. What's the most important thing? Meat. What's your biggest fear? Lions. Where do you go when you die? In a hole.
@@burgernthemomrailer they just have different needs. They go through life not having alot of time worrying about were you go when you die, what is meaning, etc. Seems simple but I doubt it's easy.
Tbh at first I hoped they would give some deep spiritual insights in their beliefe and on the world. You know like from tales that you hear from natives all over the world or old mystic tribes. After watching the video back then I was kind of disappointed and how simple their answers were like "What happens after death?" and they say "We burry the dead and go on". Now, some years later, I finally understood that they in fact gave a very deep insight on their world view and while they've put it very simple and basic, at it's core it's truely very calm and taoistic. They are the happiest when they have meat. But why? It feeds them, their family and their tribe. It makes them feel good. It gives them strength to continue and it gives them hope that in the future they will get meat again. They are the happiest when they have meat because of the value it has and the happiness it brings them and their friends. Because they share it, because they got it together. Because they achieved a goal. It is a reward for hard work. It is a reward for continuing. They don't question too much, why even should they? They are already happy when they have meat.
@@pnichols7661 not really, we were all hunter-gatherers at one point and our stories are filled with dangerous monsters and entities that hurt us because of that primal fear of being prey. Also... lions are scary.
@@pnichols7661 i dont think anyone is insane for being afraid of a lion even in our society. thats a legitimate fear. We're talking about a 400 to almost 600 pound beast.
The industrialist said to the fisherman, "Why are you napping under a tree?" "Because I've caught enough fish for the day." "Why don't you catch more?" "Why would I do that?" "So you can buy more nets, a bigger boat, go out into deeper waters, then buy a whole fleet of boats and be rich like me." "Then what?" "Well, then you can enjoy life." The fisherman: "What do you think I'm doing now?"
Maslow's Pyramid is a good explanation for this difference in worldviews. When you're busy in one tier of needs like safety, food, and community you're not really bothered by stuff like "what's the meaning of life" and self-actualization. In a way that might seem peaceful to us, but I think most of us can't even imagine the hardships of survival.
I was thinking the same thing while listening. It also made me a little sad for our city lives. We have complicated everything, making problems because we don't have to face the most basic one (generally speaking) - at least not how this tribe does.
Of course, you're asking a philosophical question to the jong hunters of the tribe. In many cultures, life and raising children come first. Reflection later. Many so-called primitive tribes use a system of initiation to spread knowledge. The fact that this group of hunters can't answer these questions doesn't mean the village elders don't have a very different answer. The same is true for western culture. There are tons of western people who don't really consider questions like this. Doesn't mean that no one does.
Agreed. I've seen enough Alone to know I wouldn't last a week outside civilization. Ive always thought it would be so interesting to meet a version of yourself that had grown up in a tribe, like a long lost twin or something. Just to see how much culture shaped you into completely different entities.
Tbh at first I hoped they would give some deep spiritual insights in their beliefe and on the world. You know like from tales that you hear from natives all over the world or old mystic tribes. After watching the video back then I was kind of disappointed and how simple their answers were like "What happens after death?" and they say "We burry the dead and go on". Now, some years later, I finally understood that they in fact gave a very deep insight on their world view and while they've put it very simple and basic, at it's core it's truely very calm and taoistic. They are the happiest when they have meat. But why? It feeds them, their family and their tribe. It makes them feel good. It gives them strength to continue and it gives them hope that in the future they will get meat again. They are the happiest when they have meat because of the value it has and the happiness it brings them and their friends. Because they share it, because they got it together. Because they achieved a goal. It is a reward for hard work. It is a reward for continuing. They don't question too much, why even should they? They are already happy when they have meat. @@rudilambert1065
Well if you think about it lions would be very scary if you live near them, it’s a big threat. Just like to urbanised people a spider might be their greatest fear as it poses a physical threat to them.
There is a tribe in the same country called the Maasai who are not afraid of the lions, infact the lions are afraid of them. To become a man in the tribe you have to kill a lion using only traditional weapons which is mind-boggling before the age of 18
It’s not just that, but he knows the sounds that will get you killed or save your life. That’s fascinating! Most of the sounds we know are not heard this way, mostly just for pleasure (music.)
Thats typical African language even when Africans speak English particularly the older generation they tend to use onomotapeias to intimate meanings when telling a story rather...
I thought it was sad they didn't know Jesus Christ as their savior. Where will you spend eternity? Will it be eternal life with our Creator, or eternal suffering apart from our Creator? Because you are going one of those places and it's very simple what determines where you will go when you die or leave this earth in some other way as God chooses. I felt I needed to share this, and do so as clearly as I can even though I don't know everything about eternity. Everything I say below is based on the Bible. You will have eternal life if you place your belief and faith in Jesus Christ who is the sacrifice for sin (for all people have sinned against God except Jesus Christ), Jesus Christ is God in human flesh (according to John 1, and other places which point to this reality). In placing our faith/trust in Jesus Christ our sin is made right before God and the righteousness of God is given to that person. An evidence this is genuine will be that you can "tell a tree by it's fruit" as the Bible says, meaning that when you observe a persons life, does what they say and do show they have their faith in Christ and are seeking to obey him - not to say they don't still sin, but what happens when someone is saved is that they turn away from sin to Christ. Paul in the Bible would be an excellent example of this if you read the story of his life as to the change that happens in someone's life when they place their faith in Christ and turn from sin. In fact Paul called himself the foremost of sinners. So God provided salvation from the punishment of sin which is eternal separation from God. And it is this salvation that the Bible says is by "grace" which is defined as an undeserved gift from God (see Ephesians 2). OR - You will spend eternity apart from God in a place described as an eternal suffering and be thrown into a lake of fire if you do not place your faith and belief in Christ to take the penalty for your sin (based on verses referenced and quoted below). These people will be punished with everlasting destruction and shut out from the presence of the Lord and from the glory of his might on the day Jesus comes to be glorified in his holy people and to be marveled at among all those who have believed (based on 2 Thessalonians 1). If you bear no "fruit" then it is observed by others that you are not in fact a believer of Christ, and if you say you are there is legitimate cause for concern. (And don't be deceived that Christ has come back before he has, it won't be hidden somewhere where you have to go to see it, it is rather compared to a lightning bolt that illuminates the whole sky based on Matthew chapter 24) Here are some other biblical sections that tie directly into this topic. Matthew 25:31-45 (Also read the whole chapter of Matthew 25, it's powerful)- “When the Son of Man comes in his glory, and all the angels with him, then he will sit on his glorious throne. Before him will be gathered all the nations, and he will separate people one from another as a shepherd separates the sheep from the goats. And he will place the sheep on his right, but the goats on the left. Then the King will say to those on his right, ‘Come, you who are blessed by my Father, inherit the kingdom prepared for you from the foundation of the world. For I was hungry and you gave me food, I was thirsty and you gave me drink, I was a stranger and you welcomed me, I was naked and you clothed me, I was sick and you visited me, I was in prison and you came to me.’ Then the righteous will answer him, saying, ‘Lord, when did we see you hungry and feed you, or thirsty and give you drink? And when did we see you a stranger and welcome you, or naked and clothe you? And when did we see you sick or in prison and visit you?’ And the King will answer them, ‘Truly, I say to you, as you did it to one of the least of these my brothers, you did it to me.’ “Then he will say to those on his left, ‘Depart from me, you who are cursed, into the eternal fire prepared for the devil and his angels. For I was hungry and you gave me nothing to eat, I was thirsty and you gave me nothing to drink, I was a stranger and you did not invite me in, I needed clothes and you did not clothe me, I was sick and in prison and you did not look after me.’ “They also will answer, ‘Lord, when did we see you hungry or thirsty or a stranger or needing clothes or sick or in prison, and did not help you?’ “He will reply, ‘Truly I tell you, whatever you did not do for one of the least of these, you did not do for me.’ “Then they will go away to eternal punishment, but the righteous to eternal life.” Luke 13:"He went on his way through towns and villages, teaching and journeying toward Jerusalem. And someone said to him, “Lord, will those who are saved be few?” And he said to them, “Strive to enter through the narrow door. For many, I tell you, will seek to enter and will not be able. When once the master of the house has risen and shut the door, and you begin to stand outside and to knock at the door, saying, ‘Lord, open to us,’ then he will answer you, ‘I do not know where you come from.’ Then you will begin to say, ‘We ate and drank in your presence, and you taught in our streets.’ But he will say, ‘I tell you, I do not know where you come from. Depart from me, all you workers of evil!’ In that place there will be weeping and gnashing of teeth, when you see Abraham and Isaac and Jacob and all the prophets in the kingdom of God but you yourselves cast out. And people will come from east and west, and from north and south, and recline at table in the kingdom of God. And behold, some are last who will be first, and some are first who will be last.”" Revelation 20 - The Thousand Years "Then I saw an angel coming down from heaven, holding in his hand the key to the bottomless pita and a great chain. And he seized the dragon, that ancient serpent, who is the devil and Satan, and bound him for a thousand years, and threw him into the pit, and shut it and sealed it over him, so that he might not deceive the nations any longer, until the thousand years were ended. After that he must be released for a little while. Then I saw thrones, and seated on them were those to whom the authority to judge was committed. Also I saw the souls of those who had been beheaded for the testimony of Jesus and for the word of God, and those who had not worshiped the beast or its image and had not received its mark on their foreheads or their hands. They came to life and reigned with Christ for a thousand years. The rest of the dead did not come to life until the thousand years were ended. This is the first resurrection. Blessed and holy is the one who shares in the first resurrection! Over such the second death has no power, but they will be priests of God and of Christ, and they will reign with him for a thousand years." The Defeat of Satan "And when the thousand years are ended, Satan will be released from his prison 8and will come out to deceive the nations that are at the four corners of the earth, Gog and Magog, to gather them for battle; their number is like the sand of the sea. And they marched up over the broad plain of the earth and surrounded the camp of the saints and the beloved city, but fire came down from heaven and consumed them, and the devil who had deceived them was thrown into the lake of fire and sulfur where the beast and the false prophet were, and they will be tormented day and night forever and ever." Judgment Before the Great White Throne "Then I saw a great white throne and him who was seated on it. From his presence earth and sky fled away, and no place was found for them. And I saw the dead, great and small, standing before the throne, and books were opened. Then another book was opened, which is the book of life. And the dead were judged by what was written in the books, according to what they had done. And the sea gave up the dead who were in it, Death and Hades gave up the dead who were in them, and they were judged, each one of them, according to what they had done. Then Death and Hades were thrown into the lake of fire. This is the second death, the lake of fire. And if anyone’s name was not found written in the book of life, he was thrown into the lake of fire." (THIS IS PART 1, PART 2 IN REPLY BELOW)
(Part 2) Matthew 25:1-13 - “Then the kingdom of heaven will be like ten virgins who took their lamps and went to meet the bridegroom. Five of them were foolish, and five were wise. For when the foolish took their lamps, they took no oil with them, but the wise took flasks of oil with their lamps. As the bridegroom was delayed, they all became drowsy and slept. But at midnight there was a cry, ‘Here is the bridegroom! Come out to meet him.’ Then all those virgins rose and trimmed their lamps. And the foolish said to the wise, ‘Give us some of your oil, for our lamps are going out.’ But the wise answered, saying, ‘Since there will not be enough for us and for you, go rather to the dealers and buy for yourselves.’ And while they were going to buy, the bridegroom came, and those who were ready went in with him to the marriage feast, and the door was shut. Afterward the other virgins came also, saying, ‘Lord, lord, open to us.’ But he answered, ‘Truly, I say to you, I do not know you.’ Watch therefore, for you know neither the day nor the hour. Luke 16:19-31 - “There was a rich man who was clothed in purple and fine linen and who feasted sumptuously every day. And at his gate was laid a poor man named Lazarus, covered with sores, who desired to be fed with what fell from the rich man’s table. Moreover, even the dogs came and licked his sores. The poor man died and was carried by the angels to Abraham’s side. The rich man also died and was buried, and in Hades, being in torment, he lifted up his eyes and saw Abraham far off and Lazarus at his side. And he called out, ‘Father Abraham, have mercy on me, and send Lazarus to dip the end of his finger in water and cool my tongue, for I am in anguish in this flame.’ But Abraham said, ‘Child, remember that you in your lifetime received your good things, and Lazarus in like manner bad things; but now he is comforted here, and you are in anguish. And besides all this, between us and you a great chasm has been fixed, in order that those who would pass from here to you may not be able, and none may cross from there to us.’ And he said, ‘Then I beg you, father, to send him to my father’s house- for I have five brothers-so that he may warn them, lest they also come into this place of torment.’ But Abraham said, ‘They have Moses and the Prophets; let them hear them.’ And he said, ‘No, father Abraham, but if someone goes to them from the dead, they will repent.’ He said to him, ‘If they do not hear Moses and the Prophets, neither will they be convinced if someone should rise from the dead.’” It makes a lot of sense that God would be present in his creation. This existence is incredible, think deeply about it and about the one true God of the Bible who made it. You and I exist.... and so does a God we are accountable to. I used to think "I'll follow God when I'm older", by God's grace that changed, our relationship with God is the most important thing.
This was something I had to watch as an anthropology nerd. This tribe seems to be the last remaining echo of what life was like in the paleolithic age. Before agriculture. Before architecture. The answers given were surprisingly simple, and that in and of itself shows how practices like agriculture have impacted societies across the globe. I hope someone has this video archived somewhere. It's a profound piece of work.
Is this truly the last one? Whete did the other ones go? No other hunter gatherer ones in Africa or maybe south america or asia. Aren't Innuit or eskimo also hunter gatherers? They can't grow crops there
@@μαριοςΚαπετανοπουλος ik in africa atleast its pretty much unsustainable to be a hunter gatherer due to urbanisation and the sharp decrease of wildlife
Best lesson I learned about this: they are present. Worries=food, safety, current happiness. They don't spend much time in the past and don't really worry about the future. They stay ready for whatever comes.
Sounds nice, if anything the existential dread we so commonly are faced with is proof that our way of life has surpassed, (or rather diverged from) what we can understand as purposeful.
@Bartosz Wojciechowski Inaccurate. It is true there is a difference in cultural conceptions of fulfillment between collectivist and individualist cultures, but research has definitely demonstrated that when severe scarcity affects a society and people lack basic needs like shelter and food, they will inevitably spend most of their time focusing on acquiring these things as opposed to striving for more complex existential conceptions of fulfillment.
We live in a perfect society where there is plenty of food, no dangerous animals that could kill you and we're surrounded by our own kind (humans). However, we consider each other as dangerous as these hunters consider lions. Why? Because of capitalism which forces us to compete with each other instead of helping. "Existential crises" and other mental problems we bear are a direct result of the inhumane nature of such system where 1% hoards more resources than the rest of us have.
It makes perfect sense: these animals we think are cute, exotic or w/e are their competition for survival. Elephants vacuum up loads of what could be food for these ppl
I had a good laugh at that. It came off as a deadpan humour. I wonder what he would have thought if someone explained the worries of a “civilized” person.
“If we have meat, honey and water, then we’re happy” I respect that. The Swedes call it “lagom,” Buddhists call it zen, but a human doesn’t need much to be happy.
It's really interesting to see this guy give such blunt and simple answers. He seems very sharp minded and competent, as he would have to be to survive as a hunter-gatherer. I guess it's simply because of how focused he is on his lifestyle. He doesn't have the many distractions that we have in our daily lives. His head isn't filled with all of the complex desires and anxieties that modern life causes. His experiences are very physical and immediate. He's smart, but he doesn't need to think deeply about anything outside of his function in the tribe.
It's absolutely fascinating to witness. I would love to see some of the ugly parts of tribal life as well. Like, how do they deal with sickly babies, or how are family disputes settled. I imagine they have a dark side that people usually don't want to show.
@@andrewlove3686 it's not that they don't think about the future, they do. Their difference from us, is that we have distractions. When survival is no longer our priority and focus, we distract ourselves with other topics. He doesn't do that because he doesn't need to. He has a level of focus in his life that most people today lack. He's definitely above average for human beings if he stays that focused in a more developed society, and from his social status he's probably above average in his tribe too.
@@julius43461That's a good point. It's easy for us to romanticize the hunter-gatherer lifestyle because we're so far removed from it. He may have a much simpler life than we do, but his life definitely isn't easier. We have a lot of safety nets that we take for granted, that protect us from having to make a lot of painful decisions that he probably has to make. Of course, an easier life is not necessarily a more fulfilling life. Since survival is so easy for us, we wind up wondering what the point of our existence is. He doesn't seem to worry about that. He survives because survival is his entire existence.
@@dvf1736 i don't know man about that last half. A little to noble savage for me. Don't get me wrong theyre probably nice guys. The difference is 100k plus years of separation in completely different climates/environments then admixing with multiply other now extinct human races from all over the planet who themselves were diverged probably 700k years from each other One distraction is self imposed or optional the other is because they can't really create what you're envisioning as distractions. "Distractions" = winters/ice age/ farming and self domestication. "Distractions" = survival in hostile climate These "distractions" are evolutionary relics from the past that continue today in different forms. yes in the tropics you don't need to really think ahead or make complicated plans for the future. There's no evolutionary pressure for that. " Oh no winter is coming and they'll be 4 ft of snow on the ground for 6 months and it'll be -10 outside and I don't have enough food saved up and my advanced clothing is in need of repair" "oh no this crop we planted that took unbelievable efforts and planning failed" said no african mbuti pygmy ever. If your not farming you don't need to think ahead. No winters or ice ages don't need to think ahead. Survive year round butt naked yeah don't need to think ahead. You can't think ahead to overcome virulent tropical diseases. too big of a step and no trail of small steps to get there.. Thinking about the future/time critical advanced planning Abstract thought East Asians and jews would be on the other end of spectrum they almost entirely live mentally in the future. Yet they're probably the least happy. 2 sides to every coin.
It has more wisdom than you think. A Zen master was once asked what enlightenment was. He responded "When hungry, eat. When tired, sleep." Another Story. A monk said to the master, “Please teach me.” The master said, “Have you eaten your rice?” The monk said, “Yes, I have?” The master said, “Wash your bowl.” The monk was enlightened.
To me it was way more thought provoking than any religious sermon I ever attended, they always got the most ridiculous answers with no logic to back up their beliefs but this guy was so much more logical when he said Moon means nothing to him but can get quite annoying at times, that he truly don't know where the dead go cause u can never know unless you are dead
@@aMulliganStew it's interesting how the 'need theory' seems to be prominent here. First come basic needs (food, water, sleep etc), then psychological needs (love, safety, happiness etc) and then self-fulfillment needs (accomplishments, self-actualization etc). Most of their time goes to fulfilling basic needs.
@@hanac5586 exactly. when asked about the most important thing, the first answer was "meat" (followed by "honey"). they don't have time for an existential crisis, they just focus on fulfilling their basic needs to survive
everybody expecting some deep, spiritual answer rooted somehow in an understanding that got lost in the ages and that this tribe preserved. the hunter: "meat."
thats sorta how aids transferred to humans at first we let some groups of ppl stay in the 1400s n some of them ate or fucked monkeys or whatever iont judge but they somehow got aids from that n now theres fucking aids
when millions of people write stories and poems and what not on the moon and stars and this man just gave the most practical answer i have ever hear. "nothing". such a good video mike
I once made a political joke in an email group that triggered a Brandon supporter. That guy wanted the admin to remove me from the group. The admin then wrote several essays to me to finally arrive at the last sentence that said " I'll remove you if you request to be removed". That's how "civilized" people behave, I supposed. My response was .... nothing.
hey go to proof in the facts cannibal that's the same thing they did to my ancestors hung from trees and then cut off body parts and barbecue them and ate them I have to prove facts in the evidence right there my RUclips page thank you
@@dragonmartijn I think this man's life is so simple (not easy, just far less complex) compared to ours, that the baboons are 100% his inner demons. And maybe the time he ran out of corn porridge.
That isn't the actual meaning of life. They said only about food 🧐 Study the religion of Islam and learn the meaning of life And go ask islamic scholars 😊
The amount of western bullshit mysticism one assumes as an answer, and then he just says: "well it's annoying if the moon is too bright for hunting." :D
@@hansmuller4338 Some cultures certainly did ascribe some form of power or meaning to the moon, but of course if it keeps you from doing the most important thing you need to survive it's not gonna become your best friend. Hunter-gatherer cultures were (and still are) incredibly diverse, but of course the pop culture image can't capture all of that. And a lot of it we simply don't know. Fully understanding a living human's thoughts, ideas and motivations is hard enough, let alone those of humans who live millennia ago.
@@danielgstohl9993 It seemed to be more important to agricultural tribes or tribes closer to water. To those tribes it was useful. So was tracking the stars for navigation-based tribes or those tracking the passage of times. For these hunter-first tribes, it's just a pain in the ass 😂
@@Kryonsmommy, Once the survival basics are secured, such as in "civilized society"...the vain pursuits become necessities - humans do this harm to humans...
A life of trying to survive is inherently meaningful, it erases ambiguity and imagined boundaries, grounds you in the present. You don’t necessarily *need* to be in constant struggle to live like that, it just helps.
@@MH-nu4ip Make no mistake, your people were once in the same position as well. Shit, even most of the poor parts of Africa are more advanced than this. Crazy to think this is just a few dozen or so miles away from a town or city.
@Phumolo Maako I don't know if any people or animal could ever seen what is there after death. Hence I don't even know such a thing even possible. That's such a difficult question that I have no answer to it I just don't know man
@Phumolo Maako "But what if someone acually knows something?" that's the thing, Nobody knows. It's not that deep man. Honesty and Humility come hand in hand, I don't see being stubborn as a Humble trait,
This is a window on our ancient ancestor's way of life. We hunted and picked wild fruit when I was a kid; a priceless education for me living briefly under "primitive" conditions.
A Zen Master was once asked *‘what happens after Death?’* He replied *'How should I know?'* *‘But you are a Zen Master!’* The master replied *‘Yes, but not a dead one’*
I've always been suspicious of the spiritual overlays that some experts like to reach for to explain ancient European burials and sites. That African lad's answer to the question makes me doubly so.
Nobody knows what really happens when someone dies, there are people who believe that they are going to heaven or hell, there are people who believe that the dead person reincarnates
@@R4in46 If you press further, on Heaven, the "place" some people dedicate their entire lives to gain entry to. They are clueless on the specifics of Heaven.
@@nedson6503 It is a place like no eye have seen and it has a scent that no nose has smelled and in it all your requests are satisfied before you even think about them, that's the universal description of heaven, It can be whatever you want it to be so what do you mean by "specifics" the biome in the heaven? How it feels? no one has been there how do you expect us to answer that? Its just like saying nothing happens after death, have you died and come back to life or how exactly do you have this knowledge? It's all a mystery until its your turn to try it and at that point, whether god is real or it was all a fallacy we shall find out. I just prefer to be on the safe side. If god isn't real, I lose nothing. If god is real I go to heaven, win win situation.
@@hukihuki4135 I wonder if there actually exists the concept of "meaning" as we know it in their own language. It's such an abstract term that is so far removed from a hunter gatherer's lifestyle thing that I doubt there is.
I think they simply didn't understand the context of the questions. For example, if you asked him what's more important to him: meat or his family, he'd almost certainly say his family. He said meat is the most important thing when asked because he was thinking in terms of physical objects that you can obtain, probably. He's just never heard the question before so he was thinking inside of a box.
That is exactly right. These people don't have the physical capacity to understand the question. The truth is that people of all races and mental capacities will have a tough time knowing what is the correct answer. The Bible teaches that family is more important than a tool. However, at the end of the day, we can't prioritise every family need/want over tools.
@@cephasmee6456He isn't assuming this in the negative sense. He is just trying to be thoughtful and give them the benefit of the doubt. If anybody is smarter, then great. If not, then too bad. Just offer more info. It's simple. Questioning people, like you did, is wasteful. Quit being judgemental.
@@eugenetswong Absolute rubbish. I'm African here in the States. Stop thinking we're you. Our identity lies beyond or assets. Our wealth is not inherently tied to materialistic things. Besides even beng African, why should he give a specific answer? He is not educated and he is answering the question as he can, not as you want.
Ditto, that really got to me. It's like, we're really not that different. Personally? I don't believe in an afterlife, but I do think "When you die, the problems of the world, ones individual problems, they go away" we all hope for some type of peace after this. They know it, just as we do, though it's very different - Life contains much struggle, after death, no matter what happens, we all hope there isn't struggle. The peace of the dead, the dead? They don't have to struggle. Not to be fed, they don't have to struggle to pay the rent, they don't have to struggle to feed their children (or themselves). They don't have to struggle against the weather. It really, really made the commonality of humanity very obvious. I loved this video.
‘Am I real, is reality really real or am I being deceived by a demon, but' "I think, therefore I am" - René Descartes ‘Drink enough water, get meat and honey, we are happy’ - Hazda Tribe leader
@Gob Mccracken he’s not untouched by evolution lmao, or at least as I interpret what you mean by that. He’s no less evolved as you are. But his life is so hard that he doesn’t give two shits about philosophy. He’s just happy he’s alive while you, being raised with 3 meals a day and not having to chase your food, you have plenty of time to think about life.
yeah, because that's what the tribe is keeping alive. meat means proteine, fats and calories, thus body recreation and relative health condition. water means basic cell functions of the body are working. and wild (!) honey as well as wild herbs contain a ton of vitamins, microelements and rich calories (compared to refined white sugar that is almost empty on nutrients and dehydrates the body eventually), tasting sweet is welcome bonus effect. it makes all perfect sense from this perspection. the most valuable "thing" in their lives is food that keeps them healthy, therefore their tribe as a community with all social functions is able to thrive, or at least not crumble and suffer. this is their thought on what we would consider "a good, valuable life". the meaning comes with the position you take within a specific society, and evolves from your tasks, knowledge, experience. everybody has a function, and nobody is useless.
Yeah Descartes was a silly nerd who couldn't be happy with the life he had because he had so little to actually worry about he began to worry about if everything was real or not.
They look incredibly bright eyed energetic focused and healthy. Agree their language is fascinating. such an honor they let us glimpse into their lives a bit and took the filmmaker on their hunting expedition. the hunters and their dogs seem intertwined shows how man's best friend is a long relationship
Honestly you could learn more from them than from our modern society "specialists", we over complicated our lives and completely forgot our basic needs
"we don't really know what happens after, but we pray for their trouble to go away" is the most honest, sincere and also endearing answer I ever heard to the question of "what happens after you die?". I don't think many of us expected it clicking onto this video.
@@el_equidistante The guy said that they pray. Did you watch the video? Where did that come from? Who taught them that? My point is that it's innate. We are all incomplete without God friend
@@johnreidy2804 It wasn't divine that they knew of prayer. It's a concept far older than their tribe and passed down from generation to generation. Just because they are indigenous doesn't mean they haven't been somewhat educated a bit by those who practice a form of religion. If they had no influence from other people, then they couldn't speak enough English to answer some of these questions.
@@nerdcodestudios2840 I agree it is a concept far older than their tribe. As you say it was passed down from generation to generation. And where did it begin? Because the human brain was built by God and in it is the desire to reach out to our Lord and P R A Y! Thank you.
Their answers seem to be..."in the present". It appears that due to their hunter-gatherer lifestyle, they do not have the time to ponder deep questions about life at all. Pretty fascinating
It could have been lost in translation. Because in a way they gave the most correct and logical answer: the most important thing in life is that which allows you to have life. Perhaps better translation or a series of follow up questions could have led to something more philosophical.
They are too busy hunting. Imagine If you had to hunt or gather every meal- breakfast, lunch, and dinner! This ain't no Olive Garden lunch after church on Sunday! This is a 24/7 gig !!!
The questions were probably poorly worded. I don't know if you noticed, but they do believe in some god. This means they have some sort of spirituality and attribute life some meaning.
@@wackyruss We don't really know if they eat 3 meals a day. If they are living on meat, their body probably runs on ketosis and they might only eat once a day.
It feels so much like interviewing our ancestors from 12.000 years ago. Their struggle was obviously staying alive in all means. Every problem other than that is created by us humans, it’s just common sense but i don’t think we’re thinking about it enough, just feels normal everything to be this way.
@@tomdotcom7844 We're all hybrids of Cro Magnon, Neanderthal, Homo Erectus, Denisovan, and others. The percentages of each in our ancestry determine which group we're in. This is all in the past 40,000 years, so we'd all still be in grass huts if we had the same ancestors. There hasn't been enough time for significant evolution. Or are you saying Neanderthals were exactly the same as Homo Habilus? If they weren't the same, how can their descendants be the same?
@@customsongmakerThat's not true 😅😅 Every person with European descent in them is genetically related to Charlemagne, and he lived less than 2000 years ago. The levels of genetics from early homonind species is pretty evenly spread throughout the human genome. There's only a few anyway. Cro Magnon and Denisovian haven't been mapped in modern human genomes.
Strange how most of the world's remaining pure humans are generally invisible to the greater medias. I liked how basic and clutter-free, and lucidly clear these guys lives seem. Awesome.
Repent of sin and Trust in Jesus! John 14:6 6 Jesus saith unto him, I am the way, the truth, and the life: no man cometh unto the Father, but by me. Matthew 7:13-23 13 Enter ye in at the strait gate: for wide is the gate, and broad is the way, that leadeth to destruction, and many there be which go in thereat: 14 Because strait is the gate, and narrow is the way, which leadeth unto life, and few there be that find it. 15 Beware of false prophets, which come to you in sheep's clothing, but inwardly they are ravening wolves. 16 Ye shall know them by their fruits. Do men gather grapes of thorns, or figs of thistles? 17 Even so every good tree bringeth forth good fruit; but a corrupt tree bringeth forth evil fruit. 18 A good tree cannot bring forth evil fruit, neither can a corrupt tree bring forth good fruit. 19 Every tree that bringeth not forth good fruit is hewn down, and cast into the fire. 20 Wherefore by their fruits ye shall know them. 21 Not every one that saith unto me, Lord, Lord, shall enter into the kingdom of heaven; but he that doeth the will of my Father which is in heaven. 22 Many will say to me in that day, Lord, Lord, have we not prophesied in thy name? and in thy name have cast out devils? and in thy name done many wonderful works? 23 And then will I profess unto them, I never knew you: depart from me, ye that work iniquity. John 3:16-21 16 For God so loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Son, that whosoever believeth in him should not perish, but have everlasting life. 17 For God sent not his Son into the world to condemn the world; but that the world through him might be saved. 18 He that believeth on him is not condemned: but he that believeth not is condemned already, because he hath not believed in the name of the only begotten Son of God. 19 And this is the condemnation, that light is come into the world, and men loved darkness rather than light, because their deeds were evil. 20 For every one that doeth evil hateth the light, neither cometh to the light, lest his deeds should be reproved. 21 But he that doeth truth cometh to the light, that his deeds may be made manifest, that they are wrought in God. -
So you think everyone else is impure? The pianist and the saxophone player? The ballerina and the painter? The chef and the baker? The zoologist and the marine biologist? The architect and the landscaper? The list goes on and on. I find beauty in the diversity and complexity of modern civilization. When I was young, I was taught to hate western civilization. At this point, I will not complain whatsoever. I love all the blessings we have been given. If you don't have gratitude, if you don't enjoy what you have, you risk losing it.
Technically, he's right. We will die and our bodies will gradually become part of the dust, then will reduce into single atoms until the sun engulfs the earth during its red giant phase around 7 billion years from now. But everything on Earth will already be dead.
Really fascinating. I think this video also shows the deep way "philosophy" is born out of material conditions. These people are perfectly fine thinkers, you can get it from their answers, yet the harsh conditions they face keep them practical/grounded. When you have to constantly plan how not to starve, there is little time left for theology
@Nathan M Race is just different members of a species having different traits to benefit survival. We have different skin tones because our ancestors migrated to new locations. Black skin is not very beneficial in London and pale skin is not very useful in Nigeria.
@Nathan M I'm half Chinese half Australian (European, not Aboriginal) and live in Australia, so I'm on the pale side. Which is not ideal for Australia, hence why Sun screen exits. As for your other question, there is no best skin tone from a survival perspective. Let me ask you, what is the best coat thickness for a polar bear? Pretty thick, right? What if there was another breed of polar bears closer to he equator with short hair? What's the best hair type then? There's no answer because different breeds/races adapt differently for their environment. It depends on where your ancestors are from, their skin tone helped then survive and reproduce in their environment. There is no best skin tone, otherwise we'd all have the same skin colour.
@@iustinignatiu4433 I don't think you know what pragmatic means. Pragmatic means dealing with this practically, not worrying about what things mean but just doing things to solve problems and bring straightforward about it. These people focus on a few main things, meat, water, and survival, that's why they are pragmatic in life. They don't worry about "the meaning of life" but rather that life is meat and meat is life.
No joke I struggle with depression... switched to a high protein (mostly meat) diet and I've never felt more grounded. I'm kinda fatter too after being underweight my whole life. So I dont think they're wrong....
I heard that modern hunter-gatherers are not very representative in evaluating how our ancestors lived. Because they are pushed to more scarce regions, while our ancestors tended to live in more abundant regions.
They've distilled life's problems down to the bare essentials. Makes me realize how much garbage we spend our time worrying about. And you can tell when he talks about danger and death, he's experienced a lot of it first hand.
No one's life can be garbage, just different. You could flip it around and say how they're so simple, their day to day life has few changes and they don't understand much about other people. And that would be just as wrong as saying someone, who didn't get to choose where or with whom they were born, can live a garbage life just by being surrounded by technology and social media.
@@SwordTune well, I certainly wasn’t trying to say the modern way of life is garbage. Just that when we don’t have to worry about where our next meal or drink of water is coming from, or whether the lion will get into our sleeping shelter, it seems that people sort of “invent” problems to worry about. I know I do. It’s just a matter of perspective, and this guy’s is pretty refreshing.
they have real stuff to worry about like LIONS. your stress response adjusts to your environment, and we don't have real stressors in modern society, so saying something dumb at a party is our version of a lion. it's real messed up if you think about it.
@@gronklevlonkle1717 Um, maybe compare the mortality rates between a first world country and these guys and then come back and tell me our anxiety is reasonable. An adrenaline response to a stressful situation is made for one thing: for us to RUN REAL FAST. When was the last time you NEEDED to do that? I'm just saying our parasympathetic systems are not designed for the cushy lifestyle of a first world country, and it's really dysfunctional. Looking at a person who needs to run from a lion should give us perspective on that. I'm not saying the threat of losing your job is not scary or a bad thing, I am saying our anxiety response to it is not helpful to us in any way- because we don't need to run real fast. And quite frankly the wealthier and less troubled a person is, the more stressed they get about really dumb and inconsequential stuff- and it's simply because their body has no use for their stress response and the slightest difficulty will set it off as a result- it always finds its level, even if there's no real threat.
I love that these people have no time for superstition. This guy is over here looking for some ancient wisdom and what he is getting is pragmatic practical people just living their lives.
John Smith Yes, and we forget or don't know what our ancestors had to go through to survive. Even just as far back as grandparents and great grandparents. I know mine had it a lot harder than me. But there were times when I had to struggle due to health reasons and not being able to work. So I did realise in those times me and my own family were very lucky to have a roof over our heads and food etc.
You know… I grew up in a third world country and most of my family still lives there. Whenever I start stressing myself out with “first-world problems”, I always call my uncle and realize that my problems are usually made up. My in-laws are wealthy and they have a shit ton of these problems. Advice my uncle gave me: the richest man is not the one that has the most, it’s the one that needs the least. I keep this in the back of my mind as much as possible. This being said, it is super easy in today’s society (in love in the US) to get tangled in the material/fabricated issues.
I have someone I consider a brother who lives in Algeria. I had to explain to him what it meant by “first-world problems.” His family does ok in his city, but still not to the level of the things we worry ourselves about here in the US.
@Ali Al-Mahdi You’d get along well with my son I think. My college major was Linguistics actually. I didn’t continue with it, but language still fascinates me.
They do mention afterwards, that they hunt a big animal and kill it and celebrate the person's death, and pray that the problems of that person go away. They also mention they believe they will see their ancestors, and that people who die go into the sun.
@@larav9710 are you dumb? All humans in America are buried or something honourable happens to their body. What does "religious bs" have to do with anything? What's wrong with honouring the death of our loved ones in Church? Disrespectful kid
Agnosticism seems to be a common characteristic of hunter gatherer tribes the world over. The Pirahã of the Amazon are ostensibly atheistic about a higher power(although they do believe in tree spirits and the like). These people are essentially living the life our brains are optimized for(we are all still hunter gatherers in our genetic makeup). They are around immediate and extended family at all times and exercise in order to eat. Perhaps that makes them so deeply fulfilled they don't have a void to fill with a bunch of religious certainty
As an African who grew up in a rural community, I know that although we live among snakes, most Africans have little awareness of them since we are taught to dread them, to avoid them at all costs, to kill them on sight, so studying them is not recommended. Knowing which reptiles are venomous or not, or which plants are dangerous or not, is rare in these tribes unless you're a witch doctor or something along those lines, who specialize with such knowledge. Because there are more non-venomous snakes than venomous snakes in Africa, the snake that bit him could have been a non-venomous snake like an olive snake or an egg-eating snake, both of which seem like black mambas to those who aren't familiar with snakes.
Also venom is very demanding to produce for a snake, as a result most venomous snakes tend to reserve their venom and when they bite they will often be "dry" bites that is venomless bites. It could be the case here
I think when you ask him the most important thing in life, the question doesn't necessarily translate. It's easy to understand that as "what's the most important thing to survive". That doesn't mean food is really his highest value, like he would sacrifice his friends for it or something. He'd sacrifice food for his friends probably, making love more important, which is very normal. But it's a weird question and easy to not understand.
That's what I thought! We often forget how poetically and broadly we use words like "life", when the equivalent ideas our use of it contains might be held in 3 or more different words in their language. We also have many ideas to specifically answer questions like: "How's life?" It's both easy and humble in a sense, to take this very literally and speak about how fed you are.
@@alephmale3171 This is why etymology and the history of philosophy are both super interesting if you ever start to look into them--which I don't do that much, but I'm always happy if I am researching it hahaha. I feel like there's so much understanding to be gained looking at who first taught a culture to think a certain way, and what transformations the words have undergone overtime.
he's talking about his family n friends as a whole, whats the most important thing to all of them. Tribes like this dont have the same concept of love as we do bc all they know is love. They dont know anyone but their tribe so They don't hate anyone. While we do & we will get into arguments & stop talking to our friends and even our siblings or parents for years. They need each other for daily survival so not talking for yrs isn't even fathomable to them. Everyone in the tribe loves each other like family to the point where love isn't even thought about, its a given. Its like how we breath so much that oxygen isnt even thought about as whats most important to us.
I know it seems like their answers are simplistic and you could even see them as anti-intellectual but you have to understand that philosophy and pondering our place in the universe or life after death doesn't mean much when you're hungry, thirsty, and have to worry about apex predators killing you. They have no time to figure out life's greatest mysteries, they have to survive and ensure their families do too.
That's one thing he missed: why are they sharing their food with each other? Why have children? What happens if someone is too sick to hunt, can they have some of the food until they get better? I think these kinds of questions would point at some meaning in their life and their experiences with starvation. Belief in an afterlife isn't the only possible meaningful thing.
i feel like people get lost in the idea of human intelligence. we see that we are more intelligent than all other beings on this planet and so we think we must know it all, there is no limit. and while the limit to knowledge is non-existent, i feel like many people cant accept that. it caught me off-guard when i heard him say something like that, he was more humble than most. eitherway no matter what anyone says, there are many things we just dont know and cannot prove as of yet
@@xyouthe I don't really think they go through this thought process. It seems as if they only live to eat, it gets so clear when he talks about dead people and the meaning of the stars, which for him doesn't have any value, he's there just to live one more day.
@@sandimvictor yes right. i thought that their life was so harder because of living in nature, and also much more simple as all those questions would never being deepen
Pragmatic and down to earth answers. The moon and stars don't actually mean anytihng:: When the moon is full, there's too much light to go hunting! This was refreshing!
even the native american's had an entire myth system and answers for everything. these people don't seem very bright, imagine the vikings saying the moon means nothing
@@BielichDai They seem fairly intelligent to me. They were very quick and pragmatic with their answers. They haven't been poisoned by fear of the unknown, they just take things in their literal context or don't worry about it.
@@BielichDai I never said it doesn't have value lol. Of course it influences that stuff. It's big enough to have gravity and to see in the sky. It really is just a giant rock. I didn't say it's not valuable. But to worship it is just plain dumb.
@@TheHy6xD you're right, but it does it by creating false illusions, we can't know everything and we should get over it without making up false knowledge, enjoying what we know and helping discover new stuff
@@evm6177 Because it leads to advancement and raises up the level of living to a level not thought possible. Masses of ancient people would kill to be able to live in the comforts of modern society. You can be happy and content with your life while still striving to improve. Always seeking to improve is good.
@@Boogersandunicorns76 We are definitely not destroying ourselves. Some sort of industrial revolution is inevitable for any sapient species if it is to technologically progress. Global warming will end, and it does not threaten our survival at all. Economists estimate that within the next 50 or 60 years global warming will have a negative impact on the GDP by about 1-3%.
@@neo-filthyfrank1347 You are an idiot for thinking that. since the 50's our population has doubled and wildlife has declined by 65%. 75% of the amazon is gone, and the photonplankton that suplies 50% of oour oxigen is being eaten by fish that are mass populating the sea because we killed their natural enemies. You are dumb for saying that
greatest desire: meat. greatest happiness: meat. what happens when things die: they become meat. greatest struggle: lack of meat. greatest fear: meat thats bigger than me.
Or maybe the questions were asked in the context of the hunt, therefore they were answered in that context? I mean, if someone came to your workplace to interview you, you would also talk about that probably.
@@politereminder6284 having worked in 17 different countries and interacted with the workers on site + although I found more pleasure in working as a Millwright hands on I have quite a bit of college including sociology, psychology, history and economics (BS in Biochemistry). What I've seen is that when life is hard the focus narrows down to the important survival things and that dominates EVERYTHING, including at any task.
Even if you're not hungry, you probably still have to then worry about shelter, safety and resources, and social relationships before existential questions even cross your mind.
I loved their answers! Gives a lot of insight about what they are focused on/think about and clearly it's survival. It's their way of life and it's fascinating because it's so different from mine.
There's something profound in the apparent simplicity and tangible nature of their answers. Perhaps some of it was lost in translation, I do not know. But it seems that the meaning of life is simply to live, or to obtain the necessities things for life to sustain itself. And they admit what they do not know (i.e. what happens after death) and don't appear troubled by it as I'm guessing that it's simply not a priority. This is quite different from armchair philosophy or endless pondering, which only those with more time on their hands can afford themselves. They seem rooted in the concrete matters of living in the present moment or near future.
Then I assume you'd be willing to do great evils to remain alive on earth, if that's the goal. Further I wouldn't expect you to risk or sacrifice your life for anyone. You sure the hell never would've lied to the Nazis to hide Jews. Am I right? Because why put your life in danger? Survival is the ultimate goal right?
@@user-8sm2iv7sm1of0vu Lmao. You're right. It's overused as hell. I could've just as easily used other examples from history, but the odds are very high that the person I'm replying to at least knows who the Nazis were, and knows about people hiding Jews...which is whats important. I want to be understood. I want to provide clear support for my point. It's perfectly useful for my argument.
@@indriddragon the lack of religiosity in a person or tribal grouping doesn't mean that they are incapable of philanthropy. people can be "good" without expecting anything in return.
They ask them *what is the meaning of life* They interpreted it as *what does it take to be alive* Of cause, apart from air, you would need food and just like air, the next one is more important that the last. I don't think these people has time to think of the meaning of life.
“When someone dies, we put them deep in a cave and we move.” The values and perspectives which define this way of life are so fascinating, and specific to material conditions. So interesting. I hope they can find success, however they would define it.
Retaining their way of life would be a great success for them. As all the remaining HGs they are threatened. I recall reading an article on the Hadza in which they were asked why they did not move to the town, get an education, etc. Their answer was in the line that, if they do that, they'd be servants, hopeless workers doomed to serve others and would not get a better but a worse life. However they seemed very aware that their lifestyle was extremely threatened, yet they did not think that was a reason to change it.
@@LuisAldamiz i mean yeah, we have better things and we are not under constant thread of being eaten by a predator but i got the sentiment right there.
I’m sure it was due to interpreting it literally. It’s like asking a child, “what are you most afraid of?” and the child replies with, “ghosts” (or “monsters”). There are less cultural nuances.
@@dadduorp for sure. I was thinking more in the lines of “feeling inadequate in my career”, or “not being a good father and husband”. But “lions” takes the cake lol.
The fact that something can't be translated proves how much the concept itself has never been thought of in their culture. I watched a mini documentary on a South Korean reporter who covered Afghanistan issues. She was interviewing an Afghanistan woman who was about to be stoned to death. The reporter kept asking what here dreams were, and she kept answering like, 'in the morning I start the fire, get the tea brewing and make breakfast'. The reporter asked the translator to get the question right and the translator said, ' these people don't know what dream is. They have never though of anything other than their present life. How do you suppose I translate better? '
An excellent demonstration of Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs in action. When your daily worries involve your most basic functions, you cannot afford to waste energy and time on abstractions. Brilliant!
I've always thought Maslow was dead on. I see his Hierarchy all through daily life. One reason I am terrified of climate change is, way too many people have never been on the lowest level we are about to be forced into . . They are not ready; I'm not ready yet . .
Well said. While we worry about which parent messed us up while growing up in suburbia, happiness to most humans ever lived was simply having the basics.
@@michaeldean5787 there was only one Aristotle, the whole Greece was not full of Aristotles. Without education and varied life experiences you may not articulate your deep understanding in anything.
"If you ever feel spiritually lost, try go hungry for a few days. If you ever feel larger than life itself, remind yourself you're living at the mercy of our nearest Sun."
@@piedramultiaristas8573 sabellius' jesus is not the real jesus, modalism does not teach the true Jesus that gave birth to the Church, the living body of Christ.
This video reminds me of something a therapist once said that even though we live modern, complicated human lives for quiet a while, that our brain still didn’t developed to process this all and rlly make proper use of this life style. It makes me wonder, maybe a simple earth life style was already good enough
This guy was probably expecting questions on how to prepare food or hunting tactics or things he's learned over the years that benefit him in life. Then the guy starts asking about the moon and stuff. You can see how confused he is that anyone would care
Not really. In the past, the moon and the stars had mythologies made of them. And they were used for navigation purposes. The hunter was probably expecting something along those lines.
@@joeo8958 That'd be true if these were uncontaminated isolated peoples. They are not. Their culture has had plenty of contact with the modern world through the ages. A more accurate view might be interviewing those cannibals on that island in the Indian Ocean as they're truly isolated. Of course this would be unwise for many reasons...
I thought that was interesting too, there's been studies that show lions have more success hunting during moonless nights, I guess the same can be said about all hunters.
Hadzabe Episode 1 is here: ruclips.net/video/Ny4bHOnSg0o/видео.html
See the Snake Dancing Tribe? ruclips.net/video/r6hYmGscR_Q/видео.html
My Secrets on How I Discover & Film Lost Tribes: www.fearlessandfar.com/tribes
Thanks for the support! 🐉❤️
You gotta keep doing videos with this tribe dude. More after the baboon one
who gets to eat the baboons brains? cause everyone knows thats the best part ......
If you could ask again about the stars, ask them in a way they might understand, ask what do they think the stars are, why they are there. Ask about the planets, ask them if they see the stars that move and why they thing they move, a better person to ask might be an elder. Of course I could be wrong about them and they might of understud the question but it's worth a shot to ask again
imagine being vegan and thinking these people are immoral
but all our modern tech that cause mass amounts of unnecessary suffering to animals is fine
(vehicles, roads, cities, factories, fossil fuels, plastics, pollution, concrete, mines, buildings, clearing mass areas of land)
how do people delude themselves into thinking they are superior
@@jedex4645 people are people... try to remember we are all just squishy mostly water bags of computer processing power, The world has all kinds of Agenda's and most of them do not relate to the message they spew , so can't blame the computer , gotta blame the system that feeds false data.
It feels like everyone expected them to be some deeply spiritual people but they are just incredibly practical. Less time to make up problems when you are busy surviving.
Or that they'd be religious ^^
But when asked about the moon they were like "fuck that, makes hunting harder"
Generally speaking, hunter gatherers actually have a ton more free time and social time than we here in modern civilization to. Pretty sure they have plenty of spirtual discussions among themselves, but a) a lot was lost in translation, and b) those are pretty personal questions to ask someone and expect them to just answer in a deep way.
@@greyngreyer5 what part the moon plays in religion? You meant spiritual perhaps?
@@thatgurunia Cults rose up around it in Europe
They are deeply spiritual. They have a system for handling their dead and they move from where they place them
“We believe the body goes to the sun but whatever, we don’t really know.”
Now that’s a good answer.
yup, pretty much sums it up xd
Much better answer than most people can give
@@EnriqueCuevasCwb On personal level perhaps. But religion allows you to one up the other tribe. Think about how much easier it is to rile people up with illusions than with reality. I don't know is not an inspiring answer, even if honest. Promising perks after death works much better.
I am surprised with their answers though. I always thought that the leader of a tribe will always have an answer, just because everyone expects that of him. I always assumed that's how religion started, by tribe leaders inventing things up to appear more knowledgeable to the others if anything. Seems they have so little time, that they don't even think much.
Much less mental gymnastics than most religions.
@@carissaexplainsitall8481 gullible*
Funny he was looking for something deep but really just got simple survivalistic answers. What's the most important thing? Meat. What's your biggest fear? Lions. Where do you go when you die? In a hole.
great point! really shows how overly complex we have become
@@jusdre313 hmm smart bad, indeed...
Lol he legit said they go to the sun and he doesn’t know if they go heaven or hell
@@burgernthemomrailer they just have different needs. They go through life not having alot of time worrying about were you go when you die, what is meaning, etc. Seems simple but I doubt it's easy.
He would have gotten something deep, it's all lost in translation. The translator doesn't really speak the language
"we don't really know." man has heroic levels of honesty right there.
The hardship and lack of resources in that tribe probably means there hasn't been a bullshit "spiritual" leader brainwashing everyone.
Loved it!!
Damn right. That's the level of honesty I wish more Americans would embrace.
Tbh at first I hoped they would give some deep spiritual insights in their beliefe and on the world. You know like from tales that you hear from natives all over the world or old mystic tribes.
After watching the video back then I was kind of disappointed and how simple their answers were like "What happens after death?" and they say "We burry the dead and go on".
Now, some years later, I finally understood that they in fact gave a very deep insight on their world view and while they've put it very simple and basic, at it's core it's truely very calm and taoistic.
They are the happiest when they have meat. But why? It feeds them, their family and their tribe. It makes them feel good. It gives them strength to continue and it gives them hope that in the future they will get meat again.
They are the happiest when they have meat because of the value it has and the happiness it brings them and their friends. Because they share it, because they got it together. Because they achieved a goal. It is a reward for hard work. It is a reward for continuing.
They don't question too much, why even should they? They are already happy when they have meat.
Not heroic levels. Just honesty. Weird how it's become something special now haha.
"What is your greatest fear?"
"Lions"
Well, can't argue with that
In western society, if your greatest fear is lions, you're insane and out of touch with reality. In their culture, it's the most accurate answer.
@@pnichols7661 not really, we were all hunter-gatherers at one point and our stories are filled with dangerous monsters and entities that hurt us because of that primal fear of being prey. Also... lions are scary.
When your two neighbors are lions and baboons, good answer.
A lion is a relatively quick death compared to a bear.
@@pnichols7661 i dont think anyone is insane for being afraid of a lion even in our society. thats a legitimate fear. We're talking about a 400 to almost 600 pound beast.
The industrialist said to the fisherman, "Why are you napping under a tree?" "Because I've caught enough fish for the day." "Why don't you catch more?" "Why would I do that?" "So you can buy more nets, a bigger boat, go out into deeper waters, then buy a whole fleet of boats and be rich like me." "Then what?" "Well, then you can enjoy life." The fisherman: "What do you think I'm doing now?"
what is this from btw? i remember reading it somewhere
@@oopalonga i read it at school but a little bit different
I got super strong Deja Vu.
@@oopalonga en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anekdote_zur_Senkung_der_Arbeitsmoral
@@oopalonga its called the story of the Mexican Fisherman
“So what is the meaning of life?”
“I don’t know, but we are going to get those baboons.”
@@Hazeleyonidas getting those damn baboons
To crush your enemies, see them driven before you, and to hear the lamentations of their women.
@@nutbastard what? the meaning of life is to progress
@@nutbastard haha I love Conan the barbarian
People distract themselves from death by creating Art but hunting baboons is a better solution
Maslow's Pyramid is a good explanation for this difference in worldviews. When you're busy in one tier of needs like safety, food, and community you're not really bothered by stuff like "what's the meaning of life" and self-actualization. In a way that might seem peaceful to us, but I think most of us can't even imagine the hardships of survival.
I was thinking the same thing while listening. It also made me a little sad for our city lives. We have complicated everything, making problems because we don't have to face the most basic one (generally speaking) - at least not how this tribe does.
Of course, you're asking a philosophical question to the jong hunters of the tribe. In many cultures, life and raising children come first. Reflection later. Many so-called primitive tribes use a system of initiation to spread knowledge. The fact that this group of hunters can't answer these questions doesn't mean the village elders don't have a very different answer. The same is true for western culture. There are tons of western people who don't really consider questions like this. Doesn't mean that no one does.
Well said my friend, I appreciate your reflection @@rudilambert1065
Agreed. I've seen enough Alone to know I wouldn't last a week outside civilization. Ive always thought it would be so interesting to meet a version of yourself that had grown up in a tribe, like a long lost twin or something. Just to see how much culture shaped you into completely different entities.
Tbh at first I hoped they would give some deep spiritual insights in their beliefe and on the world. You know like from tales that you hear from natives all over the world or old mystic tribes.
After watching the video back then I was kind of disappointed and how simple their answers were like "What happens after death?" and they say "We burry the dead and go on".
Now, some years later, I finally understood that they in fact gave a very deep insight on their world view and while they've put it very simple and basic, at it's core it's truely very calm and taoistic.
They are the happiest when they have meat. But why? It feeds them, their family and their tribe. It makes them feel good. It gives them strength to continue and it gives them hope that in the future they will get meat again.
They are the happiest when they have meat because of the value it has and the happiness it brings them and their friends. Because they share it, because they got it together. Because they achieved a goal. It is a reward for hard work. It is a reward for continuing.
They don't question too much, why even should they? They are already happy when they have meat.
@@rudilambert1065
“What’s your greatest fear?”
“Lions”
Literally the most practical answer he could have given, and I accept it.
Well if you think about it lions would be very scary if you live near them, it’s a big threat. Just like to urbanised people a spider might be their greatest fear as it poses a physical threat to them.
Next time a job interviewer asks me that question i'm gonna give that exact same answer lmao.
Seems to be mine too at least in my dreams. Often dream about lions just strolling around 😅
@@BlackholeGoblin I don’t really need to think about it. Fairly obvious
There is a tribe in the same country called the Maasai who are not afraid of the lions, infact the lions are afraid of them. To become a man in the tribe you have to kill a lion using only traditional weapons which is mind-boggling before the age of 18
I don’t care where on earth you are, you will always find a dude who imitates sounds of thing to help tell a story. I love it.
It’s not just that, but he knows the sounds that will get you killed or save your life. That’s fascinating! Most of the sounds we know are not heard this way, mostly just for pleasure (music.)
Thats typical African language even when Africans speak English particularly the older generation they tend to use onomotapeias to intimate meanings when telling a story rather...
@John Doe You are wrong on so many levels... for starters the hidden assumption of what we use language for and so many other things
@@agnidas5816 can you please explain further? is language not adapted to our needs?
lolikr, his lion and baboon sound mimicry was SO good
"But, whatever, we don't really know."
I love that response so much.
That's a more enlightened answer than many 'civilized' people would give
Nor really give a shit is implied. We're too busy hunting and surviving to care about death.
I thought it was sad they didn't know Jesus Christ as their savior. Where will you spend eternity? Will it be eternal life with our Creator, or eternal suffering apart from our Creator? Because you are going one of those places and it's very simple what determines where you will go when you die or leave this earth in some other way as God chooses. I felt I needed to share this, and do so as clearly as I can even though I don't know everything about eternity. Everything I say below is based on the Bible.
You will have eternal life if you place your belief and faith in Jesus Christ who is the sacrifice for sin (for all people have sinned against God except Jesus Christ), Jesus Christ is God in human flesh (according to John 1, and other places which point to this reality). In placing our faith/trust in Jesus Christ our sin is made right before God and the righteousness of God is given to that person. An evidence this is genuine will be that you can "tell a tree by it's fruit" as the Bible says, meaning that when you observe a persons life, does what they say and do show they have their faith in Christ and are seeking to obey him - not to say they don't still sin, but what happens when someone is saved is that they turn away from sin to Christ. Paul in the Bible would be an excellent example of this if you read the story of his life as to the change that happens in someone's life when they place their faith in Christ and turn from sin. In fact Paul called himself the foremost of sinners. So God provided salvation from the punishment of sin which is eternal separation from God. And it is this salvation that the Bible says is by "grace" which is defined as an undeserved gift from God (see Ephesians 2).
OR -
You will spend eternity apart from God in a place described as an eternal suffering and be thrown into a lake of fire if you do not place your faith and belief in Christ to take the penalty for your sin (based on verses referenced and quoted below). These people will be punished with everlasting destruction and shut out from the presence of the Lord and from the glory of his might on the day Jesus comes to be glorified in his holy people and to be marveled at among all those who have believed (based on 2 Thessalonians 1). If you bear no "fruit" then it is observed by others that you are not in fact a believer of Christ, and if you say you are there is legitimate cause for concern.
(And don't be deceived that Christ has come back before he has, it won't be hidden somewhere where you have to go to see it, it is rather compared to a lightning bolt that illuminates the whole sky based on Matthew chapter 24)
Here are some other biblical sections that tie directly into this topic.
Matthew 25:31-45 (Also read the whole chapter of Matthew 25, it's powerful)-
“When the Son of Man comes in his glory, and all the angels with him, then he will sit on his glorious throne. Before him will be gathered all the nations, and he will separate people one from another as a shepherd separates the sheep from the goats. And he will place the sheep on his right, but the goats on the left. Then the King will say to those on his right, ‘Come, you who are blessed by my Father, inherit the kingdom prepared for you from the foundation of the world. For I was hungry and you gave me food, I was thirsty and you gave me drink, I was a stranger and you welcomed me, I was naked and you clothed me, I was sick and you visited me, I was in prison and you came to me.’ Then the righteous will answer him, saying, ‘Lord, when did we see you hungry and feed you, or thirsty and give you drink? And when did we see you a stranger and welcome you, or naked and clothe you? And when did we see you sick or in prison and visit you?’ And the King will answer them, ‘Truly, I say to you, as you did it to one of the least of these my brothers, you did it to me.’
“Then he will say to those on his left, ‘Depart from me, you who are cursed, into the eternal fire prepared for the devil and his angels. For I was hungry and you gave me nothing to eat, I was thirsty and you gave me nothing to drink, I was a stranger and you did not invite me in, I needed clothes and you did not clothe me, I was sick and in prison and you did not look after me.’
“They also will answer, ‘Lord, when did we see you hungry or thirsty or a stranger or needing clothes or sick or in prison, and did not help you?’
“He will reply, ‘Truly I tell you, whatever you did not do for one of the least of these, you did not do for me.’
“Then they will go away to eternal punishment, but the righteous to eternal life.”
Luke 13:"He went on his way through towns and villages, teaching and journeying toward Jerusalem. And someone said to him, “Lord, will those who are saved be few?” And he said to them, “Strive to enter through the narrow door. For many, I tell you, will seek to enter and will not be able. When once the master of the house has risen and shut the door, and you begin to stand outside and to knock at the door, saying, ‘Lord, open to us,’ then he will answer you, ‘I do not know where you come from.’ Then you will begin to say, ‘We ate and drank in your presence, and you taught in our streets.’ But he will say, ‘I tell you, I do not know where you come from. Depart from me, all you workers of evil!’ In that place there will be weeping and gnashing of teeth, when you see Abraham and Isaac and Jacob and all the prophets in the kingdom of God but you yourselves cast out. And people will come from east and west, and from north and south, and recline at table in the kingdom of God. And behold, some are last who will be first, and some are first who will be last.”"
Revelation 20 -
The Thousand Years
"Then I saw an angel coming down from heaven, holding in his hand the key to the bottomless pita and a great chain. And he seized the dragon, that ancient serpent, who is the devil and Satan, and bound him for a thousand years, and threw him into the pit, and shut it and sealed it over him, so that he might not deceive the nations any longer, until the thousand years were ended. After that he must be released for a little while.
Then I saw thrones, and seated on them were those to whom the authority to judge was committed. Also I saw the souls of those who had been beheaded for the testimony of Jesus and for the word of God, and those who had not worshiped the beast or its image and had not received its mark on their foreheads or their hands. They came to life and reigned with Christ for a thousand years. The rest of the dead did not come to life until the thousand years were ended. This is the first resurrection. Blessed and holy is the one who shares in the first resurrection! Over such the second death has no power, but they will be priests of God and of Christ, and they will reign with him for a thousand years."
The Defeat of Satan
"And when the thousand years are ended, Satan will be released from his prison 8and will come out to deceive the nations that are at the four corners of the earth, Gog and Magog, to gather them for battle; their number is like the sand of the sea. And they marched up over the broad plain of the earth and surrounded the camp of the saints and the beloved city, but fire came down from heaven and consumed them, and the devil who had deceived them was thrown into the lake of fire and sulfur where the beast and the false prophet were, and they will be tormented day and night forever and ever."
Judgment Before the Great White Throne
"Then I saw a great white throne and him who was seated on it. From his presence earth and sky fled away, and no place was found for them. And I saw the dead, great and small, standing before the throne, and books were opened. Then another book was opened, which is the book of life. And the dead were judged by what was written in the books, according to what they had done. And the sea gave up the dead who were in it, Death and Hades gave up the dead who were in them, and they were judged, each one of them, according to what they had done. Then Death and Hades were thrown into the lake of fire. This is the second death, the lake of fire. And if anyone’s name was not found written in the book of life, he was thrown into the lake of fire." (THIS IS PART 1, PART 2 IN REPLY BELOW)
(Part 2) Matthew 25:1-13 -
“Then the kingdom of heaven will be like ten virgins who took their lamps and went to meet the bridegroom. Five of them were foolish, and five were wise. For when the foolish took their lamps, they took no oil with them, but the wise took flasks of oil with their lamps. As the bridegroom was delayed, they all became drowsy and slept. But at midnight there was a cry, ‘Here is the bridegroom! Come out to meet him.’ Then all those virgins rose and trimmed their lamps. And the foolish said to the wise, ‘Give us some of your oil, for our lamps are going out.’ But the wise answered, saying, ‘Since there will not be enough for us and for you, go rather to the dealers and buy for yourselves.’ And while they were going to buy, the bridegroom came, and those who were ready went in with him to the marriage feast, and the door was shut. Afterward the other virgins came also, saying, ‘Lord, lord, open to us.’ But he answered, ‘Truly, I say to you, I do not know you.’ Watch therefore, for you know neither the day nor the hour.
Luke 16:19-31 -
“There was a rich man who was clothed in purple and fine linen and who feasted sumptuously every day. And at his gate was laid a poor man named Lazarus, covered with sores, who desired to be fed with what fell from the rich man’s table. Moreover, even the dogs came and licked his sores. The poor man died and was carried by the angels to Abraham’s side. The rich man also died and was buried, and in Hades, being in torment, he lifted up his eyes and saw Abraham far off and Lazarus at his side. And he called out, ‘Father Abraham, have mercy on me, and send Lazarus to dip the end of his finger in water and cool my tongue, for I am in anguish in this flame.’ But Abraham said, ‘Child, remember that you in your lifetime received your good things, and Lazarus in like manner bad things; but now he is comforted here, and you are in anguish. And besides all this, between us and you a great chasm has been fixed, in order that those who would pass from here to you may not be able, and none may cross from there to us.’ And he said, ‘Then I beg you, father, to send him to my father’s house- for I have five brothers-so that he may warn them, lest they also come into this place of torment.’ But Abraham said, ‘They have Moses and the Prophets; let them hear them.’ And he said, ‘No, father Abraham, but if someone goes to them from the dead, they will repent.’ He said to him, ‘If they do not hear Moses and the Prophets, neither will they be convinced if someone should rise from the dead.’”
It makes a lot of sense that God would be present in his creation.
This existence is incredible, think deeply about it and about the one true God of the Bible who made it. You and I exist.... and so does a God we are accountable to.
I used to think "I'll follow God when I'm older", by God's grace that changed, our relationship with God is the most important thing.
@@DrSmackAttack JESUS CHRIST MAN!!!! How long were you typing?!?!?
This was something I had to watch as an anthropology nerd. This tribe seems to be the last remaining echo of what life was like in the paleolithic age. Before agriculture. Before architecture. The answers given were surprisingly simple, and that in and of itself shows how practices like agriculture have impacted societies across the globe. I hope someone has this video archived somewhere. It's a profound piece of work.
Does it bother you most anthropological studies are faked 💀
Is this truly the last one? Whete did the other ones go? No other hunter gatherer ones in Africa or maybe south america or asia. Aren't Innuit or eskimo also hunter gatherers? They can't grow crops there
They are not the last one just one of the last remaining ones@@μαριοςΚαπετανοπουλος
HELLOOO FELLOW ANTHROPOLOGY NERD!!
@@μαριοςΚαπετανοπουλος ik in africa atleast its pretty much unsustainable to be a hunter gatherer due to urbanisation and the sharp decrease of wildlife
"If we have meat, honey, and water we are happy."
- simpler times
Lol the time can be any time
That's because ALL they do is eat, sleep and fuck. Just like animals. Some humans today might prefer that life, others not so much
@@VinyZikss lmao
@@VinyZikss if you ever get the chance to actually fuck, then you’ll know why it’s all you need lmao
Simpler, but also much much harder.
Best lesson I learned about this: they are present. Worries=food, safety, current happiness. They don't spend much time in the past and don't really worry about the future. They stay ready for whatever comes.
And that's how life was meant to be
I don't think that as positive as you made it sound. It's not good to only think about whether you will eat or not, let alone being scared by lions.
And that would be what a poor mind means.
They are close to enlightenment.
@@tapele5987 For them its different because they are out of society
I appreciate how Sokolo imitates the sounds of various animals to make his point get across
Simple communication, to the point.
Looooool
they arent very good impressions
@@vadimsokolov9206 Yeah, sokol means falcon, so you're essentially Captain Falcon
❤️ me too
"We believe they go into the sun. But whatever, we don't really know"
He's right, bless this man. 🙏
This man had it out for those Baboon's the whole interview, he kept looking at them like "I'm gonna get you mf's tonight you'll see my friend"
😎😂😂
😂🤣
facts lmaoooo
Tasty fuckin supper
Yeah, almost seemed like a personal vendetta
Suspect there's not a lot of time for existential crises when starvation, large wildlife, exposure, are all fairly immediate dangers at all times.
That's why art as a full-time occupation began when we stopped worrying about food
Maslow's hierarchy of needs
Sounds nice, if anything the existential dread we so commonly are faced with is proof that our way of life has surpassed, (or rather diverged from) what we can understand as purposeful.
@Bartosz Wojciechowski Inaccurate. It is true there is a difference in cultural conceptions of fulfillment between collectivist and individualist cultures, but research has definitely demonstrated that when severe scarcity affects a society and people lack basic needs like shelter and food, they will inevitably spend most of their time focusing on acquiring these things as opposed to striving for more complex existential conceptions of fulfillment.
We live in a perfect society where there is plenty of food, no dangerous animals that could kill you and we're surrounded by our own kind (humans). However, we consider each other as dangerous as these hunters consider lions. Why? Because of capitalism which forces us to compete with each other instead of helping. "Existential crises" and other mental problems we bear are a direct result of the inhumane nature of such system where 1% hoards more resources than the rest of us have.
"What do you fear the most?"
"Lions."
I didn't see that coming. But... yes. Lions. It puts things in perspective.
Right? At first it seems silly- like too literal. But then you realize, if you lived their life, that's exactly what you'd say.
It makes perfect sense: these animals we think are cute, exotic or w/e are their competition for survival. Elephants vacuum up loads of what could be food for these ppl
I had a good laugh at that. It came off as a deadpan humour. I wonder what he would have thought if someone explained the worries of a “civilized” person.
Yet. They still eat them. !💪🏽😆
@@justcallmerichard7596 Taking a picture of your food and worrying that not enough people will like it. 😕
“If we have meat, honey and water, then we’re happy”
I respect that. The Swedes call it “lagom,” Buddhists call it zen, but a human doesn’t need much to be happy.
Buns and cheese, vegetables, salt, water, coffee. Internet. Happy.
The more stones you add, the harder it is to balance the structure. But perhaps there is beauty there too
@@jazerasor1455 Possibly quoting God coming to some realizations during (and after) creation ;)
Lagom is just a word for not too much, not too little
@@CrazyGaming-ig6qqagreed 😊
It's really interesting to see this guy give such blunt and simple answers. He seems very sharp minded and competent, as he would have to be to survive as a hunter-gatherer. I guess it's simply because of how focused he is on his lifestyle. He doesn't have the many distractions that we have in our daily lives. His head isn't filled with all of the complex desires and anxieties that modern life causes. His experiences are very physical and immediate. He's smart, but he doesn't need to think deeply about anything outside of his function in the tribe.
Same with animals they only live in The present. Abstact thought like the future is very limited.
It's absolutely fascinating to witness. I would love to see some of the ugly parts of tribal life as well. Like, how do they deal with sickly babies, or how are family disputes settled. I imagine they have a dark side that people usually don't want to show.
@@andrewlove3686 it's not that they don't think about the future, they do. Their difference from us, is that we have distractions. When survival is no longer our priority and focus, we distract ourselves with other topics. He doesn't do that because he doesn't need to. He has a level of focus in his life that most people today lack. He's definitely above average for human beings if he stays that focused in a more developed society, and from his social status he's probably above average in his tribe too.
@@julius43461That's a good point. It's easy for us to romanticize the hunter-gatherer lifestyle because we're so far removed from it. He may have a much simpler life than we do, but his life definitely isn't easier. We have a lot of safety nets that we take for granted, that protect us from having to make a lot of painful decisions that he probably has to make.
Of course, an easier life is not necessarily a more fulfilling life. Since survival is so easy for us, we wind up wondering what the point of our existence is. He doesn't seem to worry about that. He survives because survival is his entire existence.
@@dvf1736 i don't know man about that last half. A little to noble savage for me. Don't get me wrong theyre probably nice guys. The difference is 100k plus years of separation in completely different climates/environments then admixing with multiply other now extinct human races from all over the planet who themselves were diverged probably 700k years from each other
One distraction is self imposed or optional the other is because they can't really create what you're envisioning as distractions.
"Distractions" = winters/ice age/ farming and self domestication.
"Distractions" = survival in hostile climate
These "distractions" are evolutionary relics from the past that continue today in different forms.
yes in the tropics you don't need to really think ahead or make complicated plans for the future. There's no evolutionary pressure for that.
" Oh no winter is coming and they'll be 4 ft of snow on the ground for 6 months and it'll be -10 outside and I don't have enough food saved up and my advanced clothing is in need of repair" "oh no this crop we planted that took unbelievable efforts and planning failed" said no african mbuti pygmy ever.
If your not farming you don't need to think ahead. No winters or ice ages don't need to think ahead. Survive year round butt naked yeah don't need to think ahead. You can't think ahead to overcome virulent tropical diseases.
too big of a step and no trail of small steps to get there..
Thinking about the future/time critical advanced planning
Abstract thought
East Asians and jews would be on the other end of spectrum they almost entirely live mentally in the future. Yet they're probably the least happy. 2 sides to every coin.
This was funny in a kind of wholesome way... I am sure after the interview they turned to each other: "This weird guy kept on asking crazy questions"
Exactly 😂😂😂 "What did he want? Dont know, dont care, lets get those baboons!"😂❤
@@SuiPena Yeah, they've got their priorities straight: "Eat, don't be eaten!"
@@SuiPena and honey 🐝
@@syler100 never forget the honey!
coz he's high
Everyone: Expecting a thought provoking answer
The Answer: 🍖 🍯
Even simple answers provoke thought 🍖🍯
@@esther8262 very true good man
It has more wisdom than you think.
A Zen master was once asked what enlightenment was.
He responded "When hungry, eat. When tired, sleep."
Another Story.
A monk said to the master, “Please teach me.”
The master said, “Have you eaten your rice?”
The monk said, “Yes, I have?”
The master said, “Wash your bowl.”
The monk was enlightened.
How complex is our life today it seems unnatural to me that we are separating ourselves from nature and natural way of living..
To me it was way more thought provoking than any religious sermon I ever attended, they always got the most ridiculous answers with no logic to back up their beliefs but this guy was so much more logical when he said Moon means nothing to him but can get quite annoying at times, that he truly don't know where the dead go cause u can never know unless you are dead
notice how they answer honestly, it's a sincere conversation, no weird situations. These people seem so pure
What they need is a good religion to give them meaningless answers to meaningless questions.
These guys have their priorities straight. And I mean that with zero disrespect or sarcasm.
Any other priorities and they’d be dead from starvation.
@@aMulliganStew yes, thank you
@@aMulliganStew it's interesting how the 'need theory' seems to be prominent here. First come basic needs (food, water, sleep etc), then psychological needs (love, safety, happiness etc) and then self-fulfillment needs (accomplishments, self-actualization etc). Most of their time goes to fulfilling basic needs.
@@hanac5586 exactly. when asked about the most important thing, the first answer was "meat" (followed by "honey"). they don't have time for an existential crisis, they just focus on fulfilling their basic needs to survive
@@hanac5586 need theory isn't prominent here, it's the here that's prominent in need theory.
everybody expecting some deep, spiritual answer rooted somehow in an understanding that got lost in the ages and that this tribe preserved.
the hunter: "meat."
The deep meaning of life is simple. It's to live it.
@@dao8611 Boom.
@@dao8611 Some people are more complex than others
@@cyberblock7619 yea, a superiority complex
@@cyberblock7619 No such thing as Race IQ because there are no living human races except Homo Sapiens, therefore, it's impossible to prove.
Wife: I bet he's thinking about baboons
Husband: Thinking about baboons
Hahahaha underrated comment
Wife: I bet he's thinking about baboons
Husband: Shoots the wife
thats sorta how aids transferred to humans at first
we let some groups of ppl stay in the 1400s n some of them ate or fucked monkeys or whatever iont judge but they somehow got aids from that
n now theres fucking aids
I R baboon
Totally laughing out loud at this.
when millions of people write stories and poems and what not on the moon and stars and this man just gave the most practical answer i have ever hear. "nothing". such a good video mike
It's zen
I once made a political joke in an email group that triggered a Brandon supporter. That guy wanted the admin to remove me from the group. The admin then wrote several essays to me to finally arrive at the last sentence that said " I'll remove you if you request to be removed". That's how "civilized" people behave, I supposed. My response was .... nothing.
@@tomsd8656 THEY HAVE EMAIL GROUPS?
"This stranger asks some weird quesions."
"Right? Everything is so obvious."
"You'd think this stranger has never experienced real hunger."
You can see the two's faces feeling uncomfortable with the guy for using them as a tourist attraction
@@mushmush4980
tourist attraction? Seems very, very speculative
Yeah it's obvious, like when you're buying number of presents to a woman and she is like questioning herself why
@@emeralddragongaming2930 did you mean: blackened snake
"What do the moon and stars mean to you?"
"Nothing" (I can't eat them)
Ok it really made me laugh
And full moon is bad for them as it's too bright to Hunt
"Fk the moon, it makes hunting harder" lol
hey go to proof in the facts cannibal that's the same thing they did to my ancestors hung from trees and then cut off body parts and barbecue them and ate them I have to prove facts in the evidence right there my RUclips page thank you
Jeje
I love how he listens and answers the questions but his mind is too busy with baboons. ''Those damn baboons are up to something.''
You mean… the baboons are his inner demons making havoc.
excellent
@@dragonmartijn I think this man's life is so simple (not easy, just far less complex) compared to ours, that the baboons are 100% his inner demons. And maybe the time he ran out of corn porridge.
Exactly
His grunts and animal sounds sold the whole thing for me. 🤣
'the moon means nothing and only meat and honey make a good day, look the baboons are out we'll eat them later', awesome
Beauty in simplicity
That isn't the actual meaning of life. They said only about food 🧐
Study the religion of Islam and learn the meaning of life
And go ask islamic scholars 😊
@@abdihakim391
Now, you're being sentimental.
I honestly love the simplicity of it
Islam thinks everyone who is not islam is a baboon. So baboon barbeque is the meaning of life.
"What does the moon mean"
Ancient tribes: It is the God i Worship
This tribe: shiiii ionno kinda annoying sometimes tho
The amount of western bullshit mysticism one assumes as an answer, and then he just says: "well it's annoying if the moon is too bright for hunting." :D
@@hansmuller4338 right
Apparently some American astronauts went there in the 1960s and they too agreed that it’s useless. They haven’t bothered going back since.
@@hansmuller4338 Some cultures certainly did ascribe some form of power or meaning to the moon, but of course if it keeps you from doing the most important thing you need to survive it's not gonna become your best friend.
Hunter-gatherer cultures were (and still are) incredibly diverse, but of course the pop culture image can't capture all of that.
And a lot of it we simply don't know. Fully understanding a living human's thoughts, ideas and motivations is hard enough, let alone those of humans who live millennia ago.
@@danielgstohl9993 It seemed to be more important to agricultural tribes or tribes closer to water. To those tribes it was useful. So was tracking the stars for navigation-based tribes or those tracking the passage of times. For these hunter-first tribes, it's just a pain in the ass 😂
Evrthing else is a secondary when food itself is a luxury.
Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs. A life of trying to survive leaves no room for vain pursuits.
@@Kryonsmommy, Once the survival basics are secured, such as in "civilized society"...the vain pursuits become necessities - humans do this harm to humans...
A life of trying to survive is inherently meaningful, it erases ambiguity and imagined boundaries, grounds you in the present. You don’t necessarily *need* to be in constant struggle to live like that, it just helps.
Democracy is just a word when the people are starving.
@@MH-nu4ip Make no mistake, your people were once in the same position as well. Shit, even most of the poor parts of Africa are more advanced than this. Crazy to think this is just a few dozen or so miles away from a town or city.
The most humble answer ever "I don't know"
We should all be that humble because no-one knows, no-one has any certainty, just ideas and faiths
@Phumolo Maako I don't know if any people or animal could ever seen what is there after death. Hence I don't even know such a thing even possible. That's such a difficult question that I have no answer to it I just don't know man
@Phumolo Maako "But what if someone acually knows something?" that's the thing, Nobody knows. It's not that deep man. Honesty and Humility come hand in hand, I don't see being stubborn as a Humble trait,
uum actually its "sorry but i dont know"
I always answer that i dont know but a lot seem to be irritated by this. By i truly dont know, how can u understand everything?
This is a window on our ancient ancestor's way of life. We hunted and picked wild fruit when I was a kid; a priceless education for me living briefly under "primitive" conditions.
What did you learn?
"when somebody dies - we put them in a cave and move" This guy is a true leader
A doctor was asked by his patient, doctor what happens after I die ,the doctor replied we clean the bed and admit the next patient
@@rahulshyam4752 In some country he could have said: “We detain your body until someone sells his house to pay the enormous bill.”
nah...they aint bad people but they got problems we can't think of
A Zen Master was once asked *‘what happens after Death?’*
He replied *'How should I know?'*
*‘But you are a Zen Master!’*
The master replied *‘Yes, but not a dead one’*
I've always been suspicious of the spiritual overlays that some experts like to reach for to explain ancient European burials and sites. That African lad's answer to the question makes me doubly so.
"We believe it goes to the sun, but whatever... We don't know"
*THE HONESTY* 🤯
Nobody knows what really happens when someone dies, there are people who believe that they are going to heaven or hell, there are people who believe that the dead person reincarnates
@@R4in46 If you press further, on Heaven, the "place" some people dedicate their entire lives to gain entry to.
They are clueless on the specifics of Heaven.
I think he meant it evaporates, cause it if that's the case we literally do go to the sun
@@nedson6503 It is a place like no eye have seen and it has a scent that no nose has smelled and in it all your requests are satisfied before you even think about them, that's the universal description of heaven, It can be whatever you want it to be so what do you mean by "specifics" the biome in the heaven? How it feels? no one has been there how do you expect us to answer that? Its just like saying nothing happens after death, have you died and come back to life or how exactly do you have this knowledge? It's all a mystery until its your turn to try it and at that point, whether god is real or it was all a fallacy we shall find out. I just prefer to be on the safe side. If god isn't real, I lose nothing. If god is real I go to heaven, win win situation.
@@ThouguohT I highly doubt that tribe would even have the scientific knowledge required to understand evaporation.
He asked "What is the meaning of life?" and got the answer to the question "How to not die?". I think it is very good answer.
Now that I think about it, I wonder whether the question was lost in translation
@@hukihuki4135 I wonder if there actually exists the concept of "meaning" as we know it in their own language. It's such an abstract term that is so far removed from a hunter gatherer's lifestyle thing that I doubt there is.
@@sword_of_damocle5 yep, exactly what I was thinking
@@hukihuki4135 how so? it seems to me, that "how to not die" is a perfectly adequate answer, no?
I think for them "meaning" is the same as "purpose"; see the moon question.
I think they simply didn't understand the context of the questions. For example, if you asked him what's more important to him: meat or his family, he'd almost certainly say his family. He said meat is the most important thing when asked because he was thinking in terms of physical objects that you can obtain, probably. He's just never heard the question before so he was thinking inside of a box.
That is exactly right. These people don't have the physical capacity to understand the question. The truth is that people of all races and mental capacities will have a tough time knowing what is the correct answer.
The Bible teaches that family is more important than a tool. However, at the end of the day, we can't prioritise every family need/want over tools.
Agreed
Why do you assume this?
everyone always think they're smarter.
@@cephasmee6456He isn't assuming this in the negative sense. He is just trying to be thoughtful and give them the benefit of the doubt. If anybody is smarter, then great. If not, then too bad. Just offer more info. It's simple.
Questioning people, like you did, is wasteful. Quit being judgemental.
@@eugenetswong Absolute rubbish. I'm African here in the States. Stop thinking we're you. Our identity lies beyond or assets. Our wealth is not inherently tied to materialistic things. Besides even beng African, why should he give a specific answer? He is not educated and he is answering the question as he can, not as you want.
"What's the most important thing in life?"
*Starts naming foods*
Tbh, same
Avrei detto la stessa cosa 😂
Hahaha
Steak, BBQ ribs, etc.
Meat is just another word for money or material needs. An extremely important aspect in modern humans' lives as well.
@@kanisch5825 i think they meant it literally
I really like their answer for how they handle death. "If they struggled in this life, we wish them no more struggle."
Ditto, that really got to me. It's like, we're really not that different. Personally? I don't believe in an afterlife, but I do think "When you die, the problems of the world, ones individual problems, they go away" we all hope for some type of peace after this. They know it, just as we do, though it's very different - Life contains much struggle, after death, no matter what happens, we all hope there isn't struggle. The peace of the dead, the dead? They don't have to struggle. Not to be fed, they don't have to struggle to pay the rent, they don't have to struggle to feed their children (or themselves). They don't have to struggle against the weather. It really, really made the commonality of humanity very obvious. I loved this video.
Basically he's saying, "Rest in peace."
Rest, know nothing😊
and they put the dead in a hole and move on 🤷♂️
I really liked their answer for what the moon means: nothing. Except when it's full, the full moon makes hunting more difficult
‘Am I real, is reality really real or am I being deceived by a demon, but' "I think, therefore I am" - René Descartes
‘Drink enough water, get meat and honey, we are happy’ - Hazda Tribe leader
Yes child!
@Gob Mccracken he’s not untouched by evolution lmao, or at least as I interpret what you mean by that. He’s no less evolved as you are. But his life is so hard that he doesn’t give two shits about philosophy. He’s just happy he’s alive while you, being raised with 3 meals a day and not having to chase your food, you have plenty of time to think about life.
@@crimsonholocene949 i guess untouched by the recent cultural evolution
yeah, because that's what the tribe is keeping alive. meat means proteine, fats and calories, thus body recreation and relative health condition. water means basic cell functions of the body are working. and wild (!) honey as well as wild herbs contain a ton of vitamins, microelements and rich calories (compared to refined white sugar that is almost empty on nutrients and dehydrates the body eventually), tasting sweet is welcome bonus effect. it makes all perfect sense from this perspection. the most valuable "thing" in their lives is food that keeps them healthy, therefore their tribe as a community with all social functions is able to thrive, or at least not crumble and suffer. this is their thought on what we would consider "a good, valuable life". the meaning comes with the position you take within a specific society, and evolves from your tasks, knowledge, experience. everybody has a function, and nobody is useless.
Yeah Descartes was a silly nerd who couldn't be happy with the life he had because he had so little to actually worry about he began to worry about if everything was real or not.
They look incredibly bright eyed energetic focused and healthy. Agree their language is fascinating. such an honor they let us glimpse into their lives a bit and took the filmmaker on their hunting expedition. the hunters and their dogs seem intertwined shows how man's best friend is a long relationship
I love how practical their answers and advice is. "Stay hydrated" by a boy who looks no older than 15.
Honestly you could learn more from them than from our modern society "specialists", we over complicated our lives and completely forgot our basic needs
modest pelican would be very happy to hear that his message has reached isolated african tribes
For them it takes more work to stay hydrated than to crank up the water tap. It is more like a daily survival challenge.
Blood moon Yes, he answered so simple and true. We worry too much over a lot of BS.
@@youneskasdi Well, I think the specialists have knowledge they don't have, just as they have knowledge those specialists don't have
The meaning of life: meat
Your occupation: hunting for meat
Your hobby: eating meat
What is the purpose of your visit to the US: a steakhouse
the industrial (and agricultural) revolution and its consequences have been a disaster for the human race.
Yeah we are slave to wheat, rice, corn and money
@@anonymousstout4759 do you know whom i am quoting from
if they visited the us they would die lol
@@Ceskyify I believe it was from Yuval Harari's book; Sapiens
lol kid said the moon fucks his hunting up, he don't need any damn light.
what do you mean? a full moon is dangerous for every animal, including humans. so what is it that you don´t understand?
@@maxthiren5690 i think its you who dont understand what he said
@@maxthiren5690 he is joking because it’s impressive that the boy doesn’t need light to hunt.
man only fucks with night vision goggles yana
@@maxthiren5690 You've made a mistake, which is fine. The last part makes it sound very condescending which makes the comment sound very off-putting.
- What feelings, emotions and poetry does the beautiful, mythical moon evokes on you?
- Nothing. Oh, the full moon is bad for hunting, friend.
"we don't really know what happens after, but we pray for their trouble to go away" is the most honest, sincere and also endearing answer I ever heard to the question of "what happens after you die?". I don't think many of us expected it clicking onto this video.
They mentioned "pray" now how did they know that? Atheists take notice!!!
@@johnreidy2804 what?
@@el_equidistante The guy said that they pray. Did you watch the video? Where did that come from? Who taught them that? My point is that it's innate. We are all incomplete without God friend
@@johnreidy2804 It wasn't divine that they knew of prayer. It's a concept far older than their tribe and passed down from generation to generation. Just because they are indigenous doesn't mean they haven't been somewhat educated a bit by those who practice a form of religion. If they had no influence from other people, then they couldn't speak enough English to answer some of these questions.
@@nerdcodestudios2840 I agree it is a concept far older than their tribe. As you say it was passed down from generation to generation. And where did it begin? Because the human brain was built by God and in it is the desire to reach out to our Lord and P R A Y!
Thank you.
"What happens when you see a woman you like?"
"we shoot it" 😂
Yo I was like wtf may b shoot her in the leg so she don’t get away I guess 😂
@@johnnygutierrez9855 I guess what they meant is the money shoot
Translator got it wrong concerning that question
I knew it. He's American pupil.
@@movementmathebula828 No the guy was still talking about snakes
Their answers seem to be..."in the present". It appears that due to their hunter-gatherer lifestyle, they do not have the time to ponder deep questions about life at all. Pretty fascinating
It could have been lost in translation. Because in a way they gave the most correct and logical answer: the most important thing in life is that which allows you to have life. Perhaps better translation or a series of follow up questions could have led to something more philosophical.
They are too busy hunting. Imagine If you had to hunt or gather every meal- breakfast, lunch, and dinner! This ain't no Olive Garden lunch after church on Sunday! This is a 24/7 gig !!!
The questions were probably poorly worded. I don't know if you noticed, but they do believe in some god. This means they have some sort of spirituality and attribute life some meaning.
Is possible that their language limits them to think about and make plans for a long term future
@@wackyruss We don't really know if they eat 3 meals a day. If they are living on meat, their body probably runs on ketosis and they might only eat once a day.
It feels so much like interviewing our ancestors from 12.000 years ago. Their struggle was obviously staying alive in all means. Every problem other than that is created by us humans, it’s just common sense but i don’t think we’re thinking about it enough, just feels normal everything to be this way.
It's more like interviewing THEIR ancestors from 12,000 years ago. Ours made progress.
@@customsongmakerwe all have the same ancestors bud. There are no human races. We're all the same
@@tomdotcom7844
False .
@@tomdotcom7844 We're all hybrids of Cro Magnon, Neanderthal, Homo Erectus, Denisovan, and others. The percentages of each in our ancestry determine which group we're in. This is all in the past 40,000 years, so we'd all still be in grass huts if we had the same ancestors. There hasn't been enough time for significant evolution.
Or are you saying Neanderthals were exactly the same as Homo Habilus? If they weren't the same, how can their descendants be the same?
@@customsongmakerThat's not true 😅😅
Every person with European descent in them is genetically related to Charlemagne, and he lived less than 2000 years ago.
The levels of genetics from early homonind species is pretty evenly spread throughout the human genome. There's only a few anyway. Cro Magnon and Denisovian haven't been mapped in modern human genomes.
I feel like the entire conversation was lost in translation, however, I stilll learn about their way of life.
Their way of life is simply live to live not work for someone else to gain
They just surviving
They have no time for thinking about a way of life
It’s just basic survival
That’s exactly what I felt too.
@@AntonioAugusto1010 actually they have only around a 5 hour work day
The entire conversation??
sounds like the meaning of life is life itself.
Underrated comment 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
!!!
😑
This is just an euphemism for simplicity.
Wrong!
Meaning of life was meat!
These guys keep the agenda simple, and stay focused on their goals. Meat, honey, water: it's all good. I like them and wish them well.
First you get the meat, then you get the honey, then you get the water.
@@edbingey ahahahahahahahahhah you bastard killed me 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
I didnt get the joke
I wonder what the wives would have answered. If men didn’t like women, they would be living like this even today. Women love stuff
@@tick_tack watch the film scarface with tony montana and you will get it :Dd
Strange how most of the world's remaining pure humans are generally invisible to the greater medias.
I liked how basic and clutter-free, and lucidly clear these guys lives seem.
Awesome.
what do you mean by "pure humans"?
Repent of sin and Trust in Jesus!
John 14:6
6 Jesus saith unto him, I am the way, the truth, and the life: no man cometh unto the Father, but by me.
Matthew 7:13-23
13 Enter ye in at the strait gate: for wide is the gate, and broad is the way, that leadeth to destruction, and many there be which go in thereat:
14 Because strait is the gate, and narrow is the way, which leadeth unto life, and few there be that find it.
15 Beware of false prophets, which come to you in sheep's clothing, but inwardly they are ravening wolves.
16 Ye shall know them by their fruits. Do men gather grapes of thorns, or figs of thistles?
17 Even so every good tree bringeth forth good fruit; but a corrupt tree bringeth forth evil fruit.
18 A good tree cannot bring forth evil fruit, neither can a corrupt tree bring forth good fruit.
19 Every tree that bringeth not forth good fruit is hewn down, and cast into the fire.
20 Wherefore by their fruits ye shall know them.
21 Not every one that saith unto me, Lord, Lord, shall enter into the kingdom of heaven; but he that doeth the will of my Father which is in heaven.
22 Many will say to me in that day, Lord, Lord, have we not prophesied in thy name? and in thy name have cast out devils? and in thy name done many wonderful works?
23 And then will I profess unto them, I never knew you: depart from me, ye that work iniquity.
John 3:16-21
16 For God so loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Son, that whosoever believeth in him should not perish, but have everlasting life.
17 For God sent not his Son into the world to condemn the world; but that the world through him might be saved.
18 He that believeth on him is not condemned: but he that believeth not is condemned already, because he hath not believed in the name of the only begotten Son of God.
19 And this is the condemnation, that light is come into the world, and men loved darkness rather than light, because their deeds were evil.
20 For every one that doeth evil hateth the light, neither cometh to the light, lest his deeds should be reproved.
21 But he that doeth truth cometh to the light, that his deeds may be made manifest, that they are wrought in God.
-
yeah it's so "clutter-free" that they're every day at risk of being eaten by a lion lmao so calming and simple
So you think everyone else is impure? The pianist and the saxophone player? The ballerina and the painter? The chef and the baker? The zoologist and the marine biologist? The architect and the landscaper? The list goes on and on. I find beauty in the diversity and complexity of modern civilization.
When I was young, I was taught to hate western civilization. At this point, I will not complain whatsoever. I love all the blessings we have been given. If you don't have gratitude, if you don't enjoy what you have, you risk losing it.
@@coniglianafr I feel bad more than anything
"Their body goes to the sun or something, we don't really know." brilliant
What exactly is so brilliant about that?
Honesty rather than arrogance. We don’t really know - fact
Gotta ask the shaman to get the real shit
@@papercut7141 hahahaha
Technically, he's right. We will die and our bodies will gradually become part of the dust, then will reduce into single atoms until the sun engulfs the earth during its red giant phase around 7 billion years from now. But everything on Earth will already be dead.
Really fascinating. I think this video also shows the deep way "philosophy" is born out of material conditions. These people are perfectly fine thinkers, you can get it from their answers, yet the harsh conditions they face keep them practical/grounded. When you have to constantly plan how not to starve, there is little time left for theology
@Nathan M Race is just different members of a species having different traits to benefit survival. We have different skin tones because our ancestors migrated to new locations. Black skin is not very beneficial in London and pale skin is not very useful in Nigeria.
Are you kidding? These people are so unquestioning, they had never thought to ask what the moon is? That's not "fine thinking".
I was thinking exactly the same thing
@Nathan M I'm half Chinese half Australian (European, not Aboriginal) and live in Australia, so I'm on the pale side. Which is not ideal for Australia, hence why Sun screen exits.
As for your other question, there is no best skin tone from a survival perspective. Let me ask you, what is the best coat thickness for a polar bear? Pretty thick, right? What if there was another breed of polar bears closer to he equator with short hair? What's the best hair type then? There's no answer because different breeds/races adapt differently for their environment. It depends on where your ancestors are from, their skin tone helped then survive and reproduce in their environment. There is no best skin tone, otherwise we'd all have the same skin colour.
@Nathan M They're two separate species. They can't interbreed and produce fertile offspring.
This guy is so goal-oriented that he would pass any job interview for managerial position just fine.
He would probably use no jargon and achieve his team goals in half the time too.. :)
That's right! He goes out hunting for dollars and comes back with a truckload - and the occassional raccoon.
People with PhD 's aren't qualified to work at McDonald's my dude
He lives in survival mode
he is goal oriented because if he fails, the whole tribe dies of hunger
- What does the Moon mean?
- Nothing.
Understandable, have a good day sir.
I love how pragmatic they are, no messing around, straight to the point
I'm guessing any of their ancestors who weren't like that didn't last too long.
Yeah no bullshitting 24/7 like in our culture
Pragmatic? If they were pragmatic, they would reply to comments here on youtube.
@@iustinignatiu4433 I don't think you know what pragmatic means. Pragmatic means dealing with this practically, not worrying about what things mean but just doing things to solve problems and bring straightforward about it. These people focus on a few main things, meat, water, and survival, that's why they are pragmatic in life. They don't worry about "the meaning of life" but rather that life is meat and meat is life.
@@cmmmmmmmw I think you mean "Our Ancestors"
Its so wholesome that they refer him as "friend"
That's a common african phrase, it's like Americans saying "my guy" or "bro"
😑 When your life is so uncertain, you need friends. Enemies means death and disaster.
It's so wholesome when people call me bro it must mean I'm like a brother to them
Hunger gatherer societies are entirely based off of their cooperation and togetherness so it makes sense he would say that
No, they're just really thick.
"Why do people kill themselves?"
"Cause they can't get meat"
The idea of suicide is probably incomprehensible to them.
get ya meat up
🤣🤣🤣🤣 thats deep man that deep
@@edvard0 amen lmaooo
No joke I struggle with depression... switched to a high protein (mostly meat) diet and I've never felt more grounded. I'm kinda fatter too after being underweight my whole life. So I dont think they're wrong....
I heard that modern hunter-gatherers are not very representative in evaluating how our ancestors lived. Because they are pushed to more scarce regions, while our ancestors tended to live in more abundant regions.
They've distilled life's problems down to the bare essentials. Makes me realize how much garbage we spend our time worrying about. And you can tell when he talks about danger and death, he's experienced a lot of it first hand.
No one's life can be garbage, just different. You could flip it around and say how they're so simple, their day to day life has few changes and they don't understand much about other people. And that would be just as wrong as saying someone, who didn't get to choose where or with whom they were born, can live a garbage life just by being surrounded by technology and social media.
@@SwordTune well, I certainly wasn’t trying to say the modern way of life is garbage. Just that when we don’t have to worry about where our next meal or drink of water is coming from, or whether the lion will get into our sleeping shelter, it seems that people sort of “invent” problems to worry about. I know I do. It’s just a matter of perspective, and this guy’s is pretty refreshing.
they have real stuff to worry about like LIONS. your stress response adjusts to your environment, and we don't have real stressors in modern society, so saying something dumb at a party is our version of a lion. it's real messed up if you think about it.
@@kristajohnson9173 We have different needs. It doesn't make the challenges any less real though.
@@gronklevlonkle1717 Um, maybe compare the mortality rates between a first world country and these guys and then come back and tell me our anxiety is reasonable. An adrenaline response to a stressful situation is made for one thing: for us to RUN REAL FAST. When was the last time you NEEDED to do that? I'm just saying our parasympathetic systems are not designed for the cushy lifestyle of a first world country, and it's really dysfunctional. Looking at a person who needs to run from a lion should give us perspective on that. I'm not saying the threat of losing your job is not scary or a bad thing, I am saying our anxiety response to it is not helpful to us in any way- because we don't need to run real fast.
And quite frankly the wealthier and less troubled a person is, the more stressed they get about really dumb and inconsequential stuff- and it's simply because their body has no use for their stress response and the slightest difficulty will set it off as a result- it always finds its level, even if there's no real threat.
I love that these people have no time for superstition. This guy is over here looking for some ancient wisdom and what he is getting is pragmatic practical people just living their lives.
Yes. I was expecting deep wise answers and what he said kind of floored me. So true and simple. We worry too much over a lot of BS.
@@ingc3852 We are constantly looking for meaning in our lives, they already have it.
Mayhe if he had asked someone older, they'd have better answers. Some of the people there have memorised books worth of old stories and superstitions
When we have all our needs taken care of, in a 1st world country, it’s easier to ask what’s it all for?
John Smith Yes, and we forget or don't know what our ancestors had to go through to survive. Even just as far back as grandparents and great grandparents. I know mine had it a lot harder than me. But there were times when I had to struggle due to health reasons and not being able to work. So I did realise in those times me and my own family were very lucky to have a roof over our heads and food etc.
You know… I grew up in a third world country and most of my family still lives there. Whenever I start stressing myself out with “first-world problems”, I always call my uncle and realize that my problems are usually made up. My in-laws are wealthy and they have a shit ton of these problems. Advice my uncle gave me: the richest man is not the one that has the most, it’s the one that needs the least. I keep this in the back of my mind as much as possible.
This being said, it is super easy in today’s society (in love in the US) to get tangled in the material/fabricated issues.
I have someone I consider a brother who lives in Algeria. I had to explain to him what it meant by “first-world problems.” His family does ok in his city, but still not to the level of the things we worry ourselves about here in the US.
@Ali Al-Mahdi You’d get along well with my son I think. My college major was Linguistics actually. I didn’t continue with it, but language still fascinates me.
That is wise advice from your uncle. I will take it and use it.
Not really.
You should read the book civilization and it's discontents
your uncle sounds wise, great advice
These are the closest descendants to my original ancestors and I'm so glad that I have the chance to hear them tell their stories here.
"When somone dies, we put them deep in a cave and move."
Very practical. No drama. Lol.😅
😂😂😂😂coz religious b.s people haven't brainwashed them so
They do mention afterwards, that they hunt a big animal and kill it and celebrate the person's death, and pray that the problems of that person go away. They also mention they believe they will see their ancestors, and that people who die go into the sun.
@@larav9710 are you dumb? All humans in America are buried or something honourable happens to their body. What does "religious bs" have to do with anything? What's wrong with honouring the death of our loved ones in Church? Disrespectful kid
@@larav9710 *tips fedora*
M'lady
nah fr they skipped the grieving process wefowejo
"but whatever we don't really know"
there, he answered it
Agnosticism seems to be a common characteristic of hunter gatherer tribes the world over. The Pirahã of the Amazon are ostensibly atheistic about a higher power(although they do believe in tree spirits and the like). These people are essentially living the life our brains are optimized for(we are all still hunter gatherers in our genetic makeup). They are around immediate and extended family at all times and exercise in order to eat. Perhaps that makes them so deeply fulfilled they don't have a void to fill with a bunch of religious certainty
@@presidentresident Great answer!
@@nanofan100 thx buddy
yes.
@@presidentresident
Most insightful comment I've seen since I don't know when - many thanks and well done!!👍
As an African who grew up in a rural community, I know that although we live among snakes, most Africans have little awareness of them since we are taught to dread them, to avoid them at all costs, to kill them on sight, so studying them is not recommended. Knowing which reptiles are venomous or not, or which plants are dangerous or not, is rare in these tribes unless you're a witch doctor or something along those lines, who specialize with such knowledge.
Because there are more non-venomous snakes than venomous snakes in Africa, the snake that bit him could have been a non-venomous snake like an olive snake or an egg-eating snake, both of which seem like black mambas to those who aren't familiar with snakes.
Also venom is very demanding to produce for a snake, as a result most venomous snakes tend to reserve their venom and when they bite they will often be "dry" bites that is venomless bites. It could be the case here
That’s so interesting 😲. It’s fascinating that only a few would have that knowledge
And this gem right here is why I still even bother read the yt comments 🙌👏
@@federicocappellini3241
It depends, not all snakes are capable of "dry" bite.
@@federicocappellini3241 Thats interesting , thank you for sharing this knowledge
I think when you ask him the most important thing in life, the question doesn't necessarily translate. It's easy to understand that as "what's the most important thing to survive". That doesn't mean food is really his highest value, like he would sacrifice his friends for it or something. He'd sacrifice food for his friends probably, making love more important, which is very normal. But it's a weird question and easy to not understand.
That's what I thought! We often forget how poetically and broadly we use words like "life", when the equivalent ideas our use of it contains might be held in 3 or more different words in their language. We also have many ideas to specifically answer questions like: "How's life?" It's both easy and humble in a sense, to take this very literally and speak about how fed you are.
@@reneekatz Yeah I would think it would be, not being Latin-based and having a totally disparate cultural context.
@@alephmale3171 This is why etymology and the history of philosophy are both super interesting if you ever start to look into them--which I don't do that much, but I'm always happy if I am researching it hahaha.
I feel like there's so much understanding to be gained looking at who first taught a culture to think a certain way, and what transformations the words have undergone overtime.
he's talking about his family n friends as a whole, whats the most important thing to all of them. Tribes like this dont have the same concept of love as we do bc all they know is love. They dont know anyone but their tribe so They don't hate anyone. While we do & we will get into arguments & stop talking to our friends and even our siblings or parents for years. They need each other for daily survival so not talking for yrs isn't even fathomable to them. Everyone in the tribe loves each other like family to the point where love isn't even thought about, its a given. Its like how we breath so much that oxygen isnt even thought about as whats most important to us.
@@RobinXlone how did you come to know this?
I know it seems like their answers are simplistic and you could even see them as anti-intellectual but you have to understand that philosophy and pondering our place in the universe or life after death doesn't mean much when you're hungry, thirsty, and have to worry about apex predators killing you. They have no time to figure out life's greatest mysteries, they have to survive and ensure their families do too.
They don't care about anything.
They just want to kill the goddamn baboons
Besides, they've got the bare necessities of life and they all seem quite happy, and that is seriously the dream
I was thinking the same thing
Stop with the fake deep shit it’s cringe
That's one thing he missed: why are they sharing their food with each other? Why have children? What happens if someone is too sick to hunt, can they have some of the food until they get better? I think these kinds of questions would point at some meaning in their life and their experiences with starvation. Belief in an afterlife isn't the only possible meaningful thing.
"but whatever we don't really know"
They have humility
i feel like people get lost in the idea of human intelligence. we see that we are more intelligent than all other beings on this planet and so we think we must know it all, there is no limit. and while the limit to knowledge is non-existent, i feel like many people cant accept that. it caught me off-guard when i heard him say something like that, he was more humble than most. eitherway no matter what anyone says, there are many things we just dont know and cannot prove as of yet
@@xyouthe I don't really think they go through this thought process. It seems as if they only live to eat, it gets so clear when he talks about dead people and the meaning of the stars, which for him doesn't have any value, he's there just to live one more day.
@@sandimvictor yes right.
i thought that their life was so harder because of living in nature, and also much more simple as all those questions would never being deepen
Maybe they just don’t want to share too much about their sacred beliefs with outsiders? I wonder
@@sandimvictor Something must drive them to want to survive at all, I bet they have a lot of love for each other.
Pragmatic and down to earth answers. The moon and stars don't actually mean anytihng:: When the moon is full, there's too much light to go hunting!
This was refreshing!
Exactly what I love !
even the native american's had an entire myth system and answers for everything. these people don't seem very bright, imagine the vikings saying the moon means nothing
@@BielichDai well, that's because the moon doesn't mean anything. It's a rock.
@@BielichDai They seem fairly intelligent to me. They were very quick and pragmatic with their answers. They haven't been poisoned by fear of the unknown, they just take things in their literal context or don't worry about it.
@@BielichDai I never said it doesn't have value lol. Of course it influences that stuff. It's big enough to have gravity and to see in the sky. It really is just a giant rock. I didn't say it's not valuable. But to worship it is just plain dumb.
Some of the most fascinating people/interviews Ive ever seen. Thank you for doing this.
Alternative title: Giving existential crisis to hunter gatherers.
The way the man's eyes started going left and right when he was asked "what does the moon mean to you?"
@@subhashishdey4010 well religion helps to prevent existential crisis, isn’t it?
@@TheHy6xD you're right, but it does it by creating false illusions, we can't know everything and we should get over it without making up false knowledge, enjoying what we know and helping discover new stuff
@I'm Okay, lmfao.... so true!!! Good laugh and spot on!
Best comment so far.
When you have what you need, you start looking for things you don’t need.
That is normal and good
@@neo-filthyfrank1347 How? 🤷♀️🍷
@@evm6177 Because it leads to advancement and raises up the level of living to a level not thought possible. Masses of ancient people would kill to be able to live in the comforts of modern society. You can be happy and content with your life while still striving to improve. Always seeking to improve is good.
@@Boogersandunicorns76 We are definitely not destroying ourselves. Some sort of industrial revolution is inevitable for any sapient species if it is to technologically progress. Global warming will end, and it does not threaten our survival at all. Economists estimate that within the next 50 or 60 years global warming will have a negative impact on the GDP by about 1-3%.
@@neo-filthyfrank1347 You are an idiot for thinking that. since the 50's our population has doubled and wildlife has declined by 65%. 75% of the amazon is gone, and the photonplankton that suplies 50% of oour oxigen is being eaten by fish that are mass populating the sea because we killed their natural enemies. You are dumb for saying that
Why is nobody talking about how this dude straight-up tanked a Black Mamba bite? That's impressive as all hell, what an actual legend.
seemingly he has huge venom immunity if that's even a thing.
@@muhammadsaroshali2274 it is from a high amount of being poisoned
Maybe he sucked it out the bite wound immediately.
@@neddersass8439 you can’t suck it out that does nothing
Apparently he had the one on his arm and one on his head that went away
“We believe the body goes to the sun, but whatever. We don’t really know…” LOL this is the best part of the interview.
greatest desire: meat.
greatest happiness: meat.
what happens when things die: they become meat.
greatest struggle: lack of meat.
greatest fear: meat thats bigger than me.
Jesus loves you. . ,
Basically luffy from the anime one piece
@@combsbrushes777 no he doesnt
Okay this is straight up sokka from avatar the last Airbender lol
@@avatarluluedits5273 true
- what is the most important thing in life?
- meat
- what makes you happy?
- meat
- what is your biggest struggle?
- meat
Welcome to africa
now insert "money" instead of meat
He's Luffy's cousin!
Imagine if someone told him about vegans
That would've been an interesting conversation!
The lesson is: only if you're not hungry can you think about philosophical questions.
Or maybe the questions were asked in the context of the hunt, therefore they were answered in that context?
I mean, if someone came to your workplace to interview you, you would also talk about that probably.
@@politereminder6284 having worked in 17 different countries and interacted with the workers on site + although I found more pleasure in working as a Millwright hands on I have quite a bit of college including sociology, psychology, history and economics (BS in Biochemistry).
What I've seen is that when life is hard the focus narrows down to the important survival things and that dominates EVERYTHING, including at any task.
Maslow agrees with you
Even if you're not hungry, you probably still have to then worry about shelter, safety and resources, and social relationships before existential questions even cross your mind.
It's been said that idle hands are the devil's play things. We think too much because we're bored
I loved their answers! Gives a lot of insight about what they are focused on/think about and clearly it's survival. It's their way of life and it's fascinating because it's so different from mine.
There's something profound in the apparent simplicity and tangible nature of their answers. Perhaps some of it was lost in translation, I do not know. But it seems that the meaning of life is simply to live, or to obtain the necessities things for life to sustain itself. And they admit what they do not know (i.e. what happens after death) and don't appear troubled by it as I'm guessing that it's simply not a priority. This is quite different from armchair philosophy or endless pondering, which only those with more time on their hands can afford themselves. They seem rooted in the concrete matters of living in the present moment or near future.
Then I assume you'd be willing to do great evils to remain alive on earth, if that's the goal. Further I wouldn't expect you to risk or sacrifice your life for anyone. You sure the hell never would've lied to the Nazis to hide Jews. Am I right? Because why put your life in danger? Survival is the ultimate goal right?
@@user-8sm2iv7sm1of0vu Lmao. You're right. It's overused as hell. I could've just as easily used other examples from history, but the odds are very high that the person I'm replying to at least knows who the Nazis were, and knows about people hiding Jews...which is whats important. I want to be understood. I want to provide clear support for my point. It's perfectly useful for my argument.
They see ghosts and think the dead go to the Sun, but that was only mentioned briefly. I think the translator is only making basic translations.
@@indriddragon the lack of religiosity in a person or tribal grouping doesn't mean that they are incapable of philanthropy. people can be "good" without expecting anything in return.
They ask them *what is the meaning of life*
They interpreted it as *what does it take to be alive*
Of cause, apart from air, you would need food and just like air, the next one is more important that the last. I don't think these people has time to think of the meaning of life.
“When someone dies, we put them deep in a cave and we move.” The values and perspectives which define this way of life are so fascinating, and specific to material conditions. So interesting. I hope they can find success, however they would define it.
Retaining their way of life would be a great success for them. As all the remaining HGs they are threatened.
I recall reading an article on the Hadza in which they were asked why they did not move to the town, get an education, etc. Their answer was in the line that, if they do that, they'd be servants, hopeless workers doomed to serve others and would not get a better but a worse life. However they seemed very aware that their lifestyle was extremely threatened, yet they did not think that was a reason to change it.
"meat and honey".
It’s not that interesting or complex. They just living simply.
@@Amygondor Get meat and honey, success, happy
@@LuisAldamiz i mean yeah, we have better things and we are not under constant thread of being eaten by a predator but i got the sentiment right there.
Interviewer was trying to be all philosophical asking “What’s your greatest fear?” Dude deadpanned answered “Lions”. 😂😂😂
lol
Thats a life without tv for you
I’m sure it was due to interpreting it literally. It’s like asking a child, “what are you most afraid of?” and the child replies with, “ghosts” (or “monsters”). There are less cultural nuances.
@@dadduorp for sure. I was thinking more in the lines of “feeling inadequate in my career”, or “not being a good father and husband”. But “lions” takes the cake lol.
The only reason this isn't your answer is because you don't have to face off with lions.
just how lucky you are man. a true honor to hunt with such a beautiful tribe and just to get to talk with them.
The fact that something can't be translated proves how much the concept itself has never been thought of in their culture. I watched a mini documentary on a South Korean reporter who covered Afghanistan issues. She was interviewing an Afghanistan woman who was about to be stoned to death. The reporter kept asking what here dreams were, and she kept answering like, 'in the morning I start the fire, get the tea brewing and make breakfast'. The reporter asked the translator to get the question right and the translator said, ' these people don't know what dream is. They have never though of anything other than their present life. How do you suppose I translate better? '
So do they just not have dreams then?
@@zubairhoosen8441 but dreams can mean two things here. When we go to bed and see visions then there’s how we want our best life, our goals!
whats the name of the documentary?
I seriously doubt that the concept of hopes and aspirations "has never been thought of" in Afghan culture
😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆
An excellent demonstration of Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs in action. When your daily worries involve your most basic functions, you cannot afford to waste energy and time on abstractions. Brilliant!
I've always thought Maslow was dead on. I see his Hierarchy all through daily life. One reason I am terrified of climate change is, way too many people have never been on the lowest level we are about to be forced into . . They are not ready; I'm not ready yet . .
Well said. While we worry about which parent messed us up while growing up in suburbia, happiness to most humans ever lived was simply having the basics.
There's plenty of tribes with deep spiritual philosophies that live hand to mouth
Maybe
@@michaeldean5787 there was only one Aristotle, the whole Greece was not full of Aristotles. Without education and varied life experiences you may not articulate your deep understanding in anything.
"We believe it goes to the sun... But whatever, we don't really know."
If that's not the wisest words I heard...
Pretty wise, actually. Even though he mentioned the sun, he still acknowledges that they dont truly know. Not like other religions we know
Thank you for this glimpse into the lives our ancestors once lived.
These men have fresher haircuts than me
😀 I also thought the same
and clean teeth too
@Yosaron true
Stop lying white shamed boi
@@amineidir5021 what?
"If you ever feel spiritually lost, try go hungry for a few days. If you ever feel larger than life itself, remind yourself you're living at the mercy of our nearest Sun."
The One who keeps the sun burning in the heavens is infinitely more worthy to be feared
@@darcie7773 nah
@@darcie7773 On the other hand. 💊I'm sharing Acts 2:38 also look for oneness about Jesus with anyone who wants it bless
don't feel larger than life, just feel the agony of the animals you pay farmers to torture and murder
@@piedramultiaristas8573 sabellius' jesus is not the real jesus, modalism does not teach the true Jesus that gave birth to the Church, the living body of Christ.
That one dude really has it out for those baboons.
His father was drowned by baboons
Poor baboons. :(
This video reminds me of something a therapist once said that even though we live modern, complicated human lives for quiet a while, that our brain still didn’t developed to process this all and rlly make proper use of this life style. It makes me wonder, maybe a simple earth life style was already good enough
This guy was probably expecting questions on how to prepare food or hunting tactics or things he's learned over the years that benefit him in life. Then the guy starts asking about the moon and stuff. You can see how confused he is that anyone would care
Exactly
Not really. In the past, the moon and the stars had mythologies made of them. And they were used for navigation purposes. The hunter was probably expecting something along those lines.
@@EBSJones4 probably not. They are living a paleolithic life. More primitive than society. Feel their lifestyle hasn't changed much from 10,000 B.C.
@@joeo8958 That'd be true if these were uncontaminated isolated peoples. They are not. Their culture has had plenty of contact with the modern world through the ages. A more accurate view might be interviewing those cannibals on that island in the Indian Ocean as they're truly isolated. Of course this would be unwise for many reasons...
@@tritonlandscaping1505 the sentinel(spelling) people... they are wicked. Kill anyone who are within arrow distance
Never thought of the moon as a problem before, damn that’s interesting.
I thought that was interesting too, there's been studies that show lions have more success hunting during moonless nights, I guess the same can be said about all hunters.
Moonless nights are pitch dark so it probably is easier to hunt. If you know where you're looking.
Tides? King tides?
They still used a flashlight at night, though.
@@VietnameseAmericanFamily i think that was the camera crew's light, they had to be able to capture it on camera.
Basically
"What's the meaning of life?"
"Not dying, duh."
I think it is the best answer! It is sad but yeah...
To Survive
death is a part of life. You don't live if your only focus is to avoid death.
@@muntaha681 If the meaning of life is not to die, even thou we gonna die, so, why are we born anyway then?
@@juancmf9634 because the universe decided to evolve into living things :/. Pointless, but, at least we can have some fun.