Every Willy Wonka Movie Ranked!
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 1 июн 2024
- Get an audiobook for FREE and a 30 day trial of Audible at www.audibletrial.com/seanchandler **AFFLIATE LINK **
We have a new Willy Wonka film. So it's time to rank every Willy Wonka film
MOVIES TO RANK
Willy Wonka & the Chocolate Factory
Charlie and the Chocolate Factory
Tom and Jerry: Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory
Wonka
Based on the Roald Dahl book
FIND ME ONLINE
INSTAGRAM @seantalksabout
TWITTER @kirkneverdied
FACEBOOK / seanchandlertalksabout
Patreon / seanchandler
FIND THE SEAN CHANDLER PODCAST:
ITUNES: podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast...
SPOTIFY: open.spotify.com/show/3xv87P7...
GOOGLE PODCASTS: play.google.com/music/m/Ivxlw...
STITCHER: www.stitcher.com/podcast/the-...
PODBEAN: seanchandler.podbean.com
My Merch Store
www.teepublic.com/stores/sean...
Check out the complete list of gear I use for creating my RUclips videos here: kit.co/SeanChandler/my-youtub...
See a list of my posters (and where to get them) here: kit.co/SeanChandler/my-movie-...
See a list of my Funko Pops here: kit.co/SeanChandler/my-funko-...
Fan Mail can be sent to:
Sean M. Chandler
PO Box 1042
Hutto, TX 78634
VIDEO SUMMARY
This video contains Sean Chandler Talks About's Every Willy Wonka Movie Ranked!
All 4 Willy Wonka Movies Ranked
AFFLIATE DISCLAIMER
I may earn a small commission for my endorsement, recommendation, testimonial, and/or link to any products or services from this video. 
Кино
When you were talking about how Chloe didn't like the Tim Burton movie and was throwing a bunch of criticisms towards it, it made me think about how she's growing up fast and starting to become just like you in terms of reviewing movies.
100% agree
1. Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory (1971)
2. Wonka (2023)
3. Charlie and the Chocolate Factory (2005)
Honestly, I do think it's disingenuous to say that no one prefers the Tim Burton movie since nowadays, there's a growing number of people who do prefer that version over the original. Me personally, I really liked the original movie, but upon rewatching it, there were some issues that I found, like some filler in the first act where there are entire scenes dedicated to characters that play no other roles in the story, most of the original songs are pointless or muddled by actors who couldn't sing (at least at the time, idk about now, and let me make it clear that I love both Candyman and Pure Imagination), and the fact that we never see the other kids leave the factory raises some questions. Meanwhile, I watched the Tim Burton adaptation, and I found that not only did it fix the issues that I had with the original (no filler, the only songs are the ones from the book, and we actually see the kids again), but it improved what I already loved about the original movie. Also, to me it never felt like they were rushing to get to Johnny Depp, but more like we got to him faster because all of the fluff from the original was removed and they only focused on the five kids (as they honestly should). I can give a more thorough explanation as a reply if anyone wants it, but this comment is already very long and there's more I wanted to go over.
I'm surprised this was never brought up, but I do think that it's important to mention that Roald Dahl actually had a pretty bad time working on the 1971 film. He was constantly shunted out of making creative decision despite the fact that it was his book, he was credited for a screenplay that was written behind his back, and he didn't even get his choice for Willy Wonka. That's why Felicity Dahl (Roald's widow) was so strict during the production of the Tim Burton movie, and the only changes from the source material were the ones that got the thumbs up from her, and I think it ultimately led to a more faithful adaptation, even down to directly quoting lines and taking the lyrics of the Oompa Loompa songs straight from the original novel.
I can see why some people might not like the Tim Burton movie, but it's one of my favorite movies.
TL:DR I respect your opinion, but I respectfully disagree.
I prefer the Tim Burton version for many of the reasons you listed, as it involved those close to Dahl to make a faithful adaptation he'd like, while also taking more risks and interesting creative choices, all while the visuals still hold up compared to the original.
I prefer this version as well and I too found a few flaws with the original one in comparison. It sux that the masses don’t see what we see. It’s a lonely feeling and kinda scary bcus they have eyeballs and ears too! They should be able to comprehend.. but I digress
Greatly said, and very accurate to how I feel as well.
He did it, he actually ranked the tom and jerry one 😂!
The 2005 version will always be my favorite as I grew up with it. But I will add, the 2005 film is the closest to the books\. Tim worked closely in collaboration with Dahl's wife who loved the film and noted that her husband would have as well. After the 1971 film Rahl Dahl was very angry with the film as it strayed so far from the source material so much so that he never wanted another adaptation made while he was alive.
My favorite is the Tim Burton Film, but it’s not without flaws
The OG is the one I have the most nostalgia for, watched it endlessly as a kid. MOSTLY holds up today.
Yeah, even though it’s not as faithful to the book as the 2005 version was, I have a lot of nostalgia for it watching it as a kid and my Mum and her family watched it a lot for family movie night when it came on TV in the 70’s.
I actually i love the Johnny depp one
(Mostly because of nostalgia)
Also I like to think Willy wankas father is count dooku
Same bro
Lollipops
Ought to be called cavities, on a sticccc
I like the Gene Wilder movie because of nostalgia, that one is my childhood , I was 24 in 2005 lol
I enjoy both adaptations of the book but I prefer the Tim Burton version because I enjoy Johnny Depps version of Wonka more and I thought the songs as much as I enjoy the original are more enjoyable to some extent in which theirs more variety in the genres of music
While there are elements I prefer in the 1971 film, overall I think the 2005 version works much better as a movie. It sticks closer to the book, feels more tightly paced despite a longer runtime, and presents a fantastical world closer to what is depicted in the novel, though I could do without the subplot regarding Wonka's relationship with his father. The 1971 version has better songs and probably the better writing of the two, but it's got a lot of filler that wasn't in the book and could be cut out. Haven't seen Wonka yet, but planning to go do so in the next week or so.
I haven’t seen Wonka but I do want to
3. Tom and Jerry 6/10 (I think Tom and Jerry is one of the most hilarious things ever conceived, but this isn’t really it)
2. Charlie and The Chocolate Factory 7/10
1. Willy Wonka and The Chocolate Factory 9/10
Loved the Gene Wilder one as a kid, still mostly do lol
There's no earthly way of knowing
Which direction we are going
There's no knowing where we're rowing
Or which way the river's flowing
Is it raining, is it snowing?
Is a hurricane a-blowing?
Not a speck of light is showing
So the danger must be growing
Are the fires of Hell a-glowing?
Is the grisly Reaper mowing?
Yes! The danger must be growing
For the rowers keep on rowing
And they're certainly not showing
Any signs that they are slowing!
I think El Chavo is a slightly funnier thing conceived more than Tom and Jerry 🤓 legends know what that is 😂
@@NinthShinigami😂
@@NinthShinigami😂😂
I prefer 'Charlie' over 'Willy Wonka.' By a lot, actually. It's more imaginative, closer to the book,and less of a musical (Cheer up, Charlie is insufferable). The original film upset Roald Dahl so badly he refused the studio the film rights to Charlie and the Great Glass Elevator. The new film was made to honor the book. And yet, given all that info, people still prefer the original just because of nostalgia. I can't speak for everyone, but for me, I pick 'Charlie' over the original everyday. I guess it's just too strange and unusual for some. But I guess, I myself am, strange and unusual.
You just described my exact thoughts… Word for word!
I also think Time Burton’s style also fits the writing and tone of Dahl’s books so much better.
Oh....
I've been wondering for years why there wasn't a great glass elevator film. I read the book twice and it was pretty great. That... certainly clears it up, to say the least.
I really appreciate you delivering your criticisms of the 2005 film in a respectful way. It's the version I was introduced to so I love it for all the reasons you don't: the weird eerie tone, Wonka's odd personality, the bonkers musical numbers, the wild visuals. I like the 1971 film too and I think it's sweet and warm and fuzzy, but I'll just always gravitate towards the 2005 version
Hot take: the 2005 version is better than the 1971 version. Johnny Depp is way more interesting than Gene Wilder. I think the only reason people like the 1971 version is because of nostalgia.
I’m fine if you prefer the 2005 version
But can you NOT accuse people of being nostalgically biased towards the 1971 version.
They have reasons to love the 1971 movie and your not the authority of what they think of it as much as I am not the authority of what you think of the 2005 film.
That's funny. I think people like the 2005 version because of nostalgia
@@williamholke3325 not really. Most people who like the 2005 version say they like it because it is more book-accurate.
@@joeyk107 they don't say they like it because of nostalgia but it's true. The only people who like it are the people who grew up with it. And they also say what you brought up, how it's more accurate to the book. This is also pretty silly, because since when has book accuracy ever been what constitutes a good movie? Sometimes, when directors create a film adaptation, what they come up with is actually better than making every little thing book accurate. Imagine if the Harry Potter movies were beat for beat adaptations of the books. We'd be sitting for 9 hours just waiting for the Order of the Phoenix to conclude
Nostaligia is a perfectly fine reason. Why does everything have to be so damn CURRENT DAY?
The original movie will always be my favorite.
Why? Nostalgia bias?
LOL
@@WritingCountingOriginal People are aloud to choose their favourite.
How would you like it if they accused you of being nostalgically biased?
Hey Sean I love how you respect everyone’s opinion. Thank you for being so respectful!
The Tim Burton movie is the most faithful adaptation to the book, which is why it’s my favorite.
Totally agree
Faithful doesn't mean better.
@@virgiliomartinezerickson8044In this case it does.
@@thegoodreylo4749 What he means is. Movies are rated by all aspects unbiased. And some things that deviate from the original story ever makes the movie better or worse. They are not an automatic flaw.
I’m fine with you preferring the 2005 movie because you like how it’s similar to the book. But if you want to judge the critical consensus of the movies. You have to do the criticisms the correct way.
@@spacecaster3802 IN THIS CASE…… following the book made it a better movie.
IN THIS CASE. Jesus Christ.
I was scratching my head when you said 4 movies, but then you said the Tom & Jerry movie and I was like, “oh that thing”
technically ther eis actually 4 willy wonka movies not 3 yes its a cartoon one but still counts and still owned by Warner bros media
I think that Pure Imagination legitimately might be one of the best songs ever written
I love that song, it’s amazing
Totally
4: tom and jerry willy wonka I dont particularly enjoy these tom and jerry versions of movies
3: charlie and the chocolate factory i have more nostalgia for this then most people i like the cast i kinda like the tone but it's too focused on willy wonkas backstory
2: wonka i thought this was a charming fun movie timothee chalemet is great in the movie Hugh grant is really funny and it's one of the feel good movies of the year
1: willy wonka and the chocolate factory i love the characters the cast and the musical numbers even though its not super faithful to the book i love this movie its one of my favorite kids movies
Let me blow your mind. The Johnny Depp version is more accurate to the book than the 1971 movie. Ronald also hated Gene Wilder as Willy Wonka. In fact, the reason why the Johnny Depp version was made in the first place was to make an adaption of the book more accurate. The Ronald Dahl family wanted to make things right and signed off on the remake.
Too right. I love Roald Dalh and love the Burton version
Ronald Dahl hated the Gene version simply because Gene was Jewish and Dahl was very Anti-Semitic
Really sad, but unfortunately true
Dahl was an absolutely nasty awful person
It was about Jewish views not the movie
And yet Gene Wilder's version will always be superior
Glad you didn't call Charlie and the Chocolate Factory a remake because its not, its another adaptation of the book
its 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
I call it a remake and inferior . Wilder is the only Wonka as far as I'm concerned
@@jonnaking3054 Ok boomer
@@dannyjorde2677Ok rotten tomato critic
@@dannyjorde2677ok person who has a biased association with the 2005 remake
Mine would be: 4) Tom and Jerry 3) 1971 2) Wonka 1) Tim Burton & Johnny Depp
the 2005 one sucks
1)Wonka (90/100)
2)Charlie and The Chocolate Factory (80/100)
3)Willy Wonka and The Chocolate Factory (80/100)
Willy Wonka & the Chocolate Factory (1971):
Main character - Charlie
Charlie & the Chocolate Factory (2005):
Main character - Willy Wonka
Fun fact Rolad Dahl didn’t like the OG bc he stated it focused too much on Wily Wonka lol
Actually that’s true lol
The Tim Burton version is just… THE BEST.
When I found out that the 1971 version existed and I watched it…. it felt like a remake and a betrayal of everything I grew up with and loved💀
I never found Johnny Depp’s Willy Wonka weird. I gravitate A LOT to Tim Burton’s protagonists.
That's because the 1971 version is nothing like the book where the Burton film is very closely adapted from the book. If it gives you any solace you and I share the same opinion as Roald Dahl who despised the 1971 film, so much so that he NEVER wanted another adaptation made while he was alive.
Closer to the book doesn't mean better imo. When they inevitably remake the Wizard of Oz, and make it closer to the book,I don't care how dark and scary they make Oz or how 500-D they make it to where you can count the nose hairs in Scarecrow's nose, the 1939 version will always be superior in my book
@@jonnaking3054they technically did do a remake of it (I could be wrong IDK if Oz the Great and Powerful is a soft remake or prequel) and it sucks
1. Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory
2. Wonka
3. Charlie and The Chocolate Factory
Wonka is the best willy wonka movie in my opinion
Great list! I haven’t seen Wonka yet but I wanna see it. I love both the 1971 version and the Tim Burton version. I think both movies are good and very fun to watch. The 1971 one is a classic and I’ve seen it a lot, it’s so good. But I also think the Tim Burton one is good too in my opinion
I agree. Personally I grew up with the Tim Burton version so I’ve always preferred it. I like the Gene Wilder version but because I saw it latter in life I can’t say it had any impact on me.
Thanks for the List and the Video 😀
"If God intended for us to walk he wouldnt have invented rollerskates"-willy wonka (gene wilder)
Bruh, the songs in the Johnny Depp version came straight from the book.
Timothèe Chalamet is adorable! He is literally the cutest little angel ever and I recently developed a crush on him. By the way, I'm currently writing a novel about Willy Wonka's daughter, Hillary. It's called Little Wonka. Fun fact: Willy Wonka's wife's name is Ava. And when I write Willy Wonka in this book about this thirteen-year-old girl who's half Lynn Loud Jr. athlete (If you know about The Loud House, you'll know what I'm talking about) and half chocolatier (takes after her daddy and mama, Ava), I see Timothèe Chalamet in this version. In the book after an introduction with Willy marrying Ava and Ava becoming pregnant with Hillary then giving birth to Hillary after nine months, the novel really starts when Hillary meets fourteen year old Sir Patrick Roswell Larkin. He's the youngest son of Pepperidge Larkin and the younger brother of Rocky Larkin. According to prophecy, Hillary is to save London from an evil threat. Turns out Pepperidge is the threat and Rocky is also a threat. They turn Yub Yub, Willy's trusted Oompa Loompa and Hillary's uncle since before she was born who speaks with a British accent and also speaks Loompanese, which is actually Ewok language, into an evil version and Pepperidge clones Patrick into evil clones and Hillary had to shoot them but ends up actually shooting Patrick (the real one). Her tears heal him, Willy is proud of his daughter, Hillary and Patrick share their first kiss, they end up together at the end, and Pepperidge and Rocky are arrested and they turn into the famous Roald Dahl characters, Aunt Sponge and Aunt Spiker.
creativity I see
I've always loved the Johnny Depp version, it's a perfect adaptation. In the book, Wonka IS a reclusive weirdo. If it was the original, and the Gene Wilder was the remake, people would prefer it.
I’ve always treated the Gene Wilder version as a remake, because I grew up with the Johnny Depp version.
I love the Johnny Depp version as well. Personally I think it’s one of Burton’s best films.
I fine with you preferring the 2005 version. but can you please not accuse people of being nostalgically biased towards the 1971 version
I have nostalgia for the book and the 2005 film and yet as an adult, I prefer the 1971 version.
@@spacecaster3802 I'm not actually talking about nostalgia, but something more subtle which is cultural impact. The original film had the impact in establishing what a wonka film "should" be, since it was the only one. So, when the newer one differed, people were naturally more cynical. If Burton's had come out first, the opposite would've happened. Although, people can always choose which they prefer, the original version had the advantage of establishing the status quo.
ppl just go for whatever is the most MODERN and CURRENT DAY
I will probably go watch Wonka in 2 weeks we are busy around the holiday season but I still can’t wait
I haven’t seen Wonka, but love the 1971 film. For a film that needs effects, most of the effects have aged like milk. But the script is quotable and sharp, even dark at times. And the performances are great, with Gene giving one for the ages.
Oh you can’t go wrong with Gene, what a wonderful performance he gave!
I love the burton movie more than the 1971 movie but i still like it.
I totally agree with your rank sequence and loved both Gene Wilder’s “Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory” and the prequel “Wonka”. Watch both musicals, take the whole family to “Wonka” (all ages), and enjoy!!!
In the prequel, Timothée Chalamet picks up on all of the Gene Wilder mannerisms and energy to give a excellent performance. I especially loved the Oompa Loompa with Hugh Grant's voice and face. This prequel Wonka gets to the heart of why he started the factory and brought in the Oompa Loompas in the first place. The prequel theme is about the importance of holding onto our dreams, delightful creative wonder of candy, and the extreme importance of mothers. My favorite quote of the movie…
"It’s not the chocolate that matters; it’s the people you share it with."
~ Momma Wonka
I wished you would have included Snowpiercer in this list as a joke(there is a fun popular theory on RUclips regarding it being a sequel movie)
The 1971 version is fine, but I have a lot more fun with Tim Burton's version. "Lollipops; ought to be called 'cavity on a stick'".
In Ireland the public tv channel rte plays this movie every Christmas every year and we started this tradition where we watch it every year those are the best times
Edit it’s the original Willy wonka
Nice to hear your ranking on the film series. As a big Willy Wonka fan, my ranking of the films currently goes:
1. Charlie and the Chocolate Factory (yeah, fight me)
2. Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory
3. Wonka
4. And in the last place, by a massive margin, Tom and Jerry Willy Wonka.
The top 3 I love, while we don't talk about the 4th. Anyways, its always nice to hear your insight. And I appreciate that you didn't call Tim Burton's version a "remake" either. Though, it did kinda annoy me when you labeled it as "the version that no one prefers over the original." Like do you respect opinions or not? Have you seen the growing fanbase there is for that movie? 😂
Charlie and the chocolate factory is one of the most overrated remakes there is. And that’s a fact, not an opinion.
@@Witchcraft_gt Wow. You seem like a real fun person to talk to.
@@margogoralski6294 yes I am, and I’m proud of it.
@@Witchcraft_gt "Well, you do seem confident, and confidence is key."
@@margogoralski6294 ;)
0:23, I would rank the Burton version with Johnny Depp on the bottom because in the books Willy Wonka invites both Charlie and his family to join him at the factory and personally pulls Charlie’s grandparents bed with them in it into the Great Glass Elevator so that Charlie can be with his family (and does all that without any hesitation so Willy Wonka hating family to the point of giving Charlie an ultimatum to choose between them and the factory was completely out of character for him. And the movie gave Willy Wonka an elaborate origin story designed entirely to explain why he hates family even though it was a trait he never had in the book. And it made it so that his real motivation for everything was spite and juvenile rebellion. That isn’t Willy Wonka. It’s just not. Despite some deviations from the source material at least the 1971 movie got Willy Wonka right
Great ranking👍
The best one is the Tim Burton movie. That’s my childhood.
spoiler alert for wonka: i love the chocaholik monks they were too funny
Really well explained about Tim Burton’s philosophy of subverting characters. That’s exactly what I’ve been thinking all the time and never heard anyone mention before
I like the Tim Burton movie. Better effects. More straightforward adaptation of Dahl. A unique original portrayal of Wonka by Depp. Freddie Highmore outdoes Peter Ostrum, but David Kelly fades a bit next to Jack Albertson. But, David Kelly is overall more appealing than Jack Albertson in the Grandpa Joe role. Gentler and even seems kinder than Albertson. I can’t get behind the subplot in Charlie And The Chocolate Factory involving Wilbur Wonka, Willy’s Dad the dentist. It seems like they were going for conflict and irony, but it comes off forced and cheesy.
Was really hoping Sean Chandler would give an honorable mention to the movie Snowpiercer.
Controversial opinion: Tim burton Willy wonka> the 1971 version
I agree
I disagree
Disagree but respect 🤝
@@ziitrixYTYeah same! I haven’t seen the new one, but I prefer the original 1971 film to the 2005 version.
I enjoy both.
I'm surprised Sean didn't cosplay as Wonka
Every Sean Chandler movies are lovable and delightful like chocolates! ❤❤
I didn't know about the Tom and Jerry film
Tim burton's adaptation is easily my favourite and more faithful... I've always thought the 1971 version is seriously overrated
I agree there. Most people just love Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory because of their nostalgia for it. But the movie itself is really bad overall. It was just made as a commercial for the Quaker company. Plus, the side characters, aside from Wonka, all are pretty bad and one-note. The new kids were much better.
@@darkridergames1707 I’m fine if you prefer the 2005 version
But can you NOT accuse people of being nostalgically biased towards the 1971 version.
How do we know your not the one being nostalgically biased.
People have reasons to love the 1971 movie and your not the authority what they think of it as much as I am not the authority of what you think of the 2005 film.
I’m talking to you darkridergames
@@spacecaster3802 I grew up with the 1971 version and I didn't like it back then... nothing to do with nostalgia for for me, I just prefer Tim Burton's version
Same. Just because something is a classic doesn't mean it's the best.
Look I pick the original movie because it is has terror in it.
Can you rank Tim Burton movies?
Wonka is my favorite one
Charlie and the Chocolate Factory-As a kid this was a big deal. I bought all the tie in chocolate and snacks and read the tie in book with a ton of pictures from the movie. It's still a favorite in my family.
Willy Wonka & the Chocolate Factory
Wonka
Oh yeah, I remember at the time it was huge. I remember going with my Mum and brother to see it when it came out at the cinema in the Melbourne CBD, which is now closed and I can’t remember which street it was on, maybe Collins Street?
But I watched the original one a lot as a kid and my Mum did during the 70’s as a child with her family when it came on TV so I’m probably more nostalgic for that one.
@@andrewburgemeister6684 That's amazing. It's awesome when movies like that can be shared with family. I love it.
@@jordansweet8054 yes, Mum’s family always gathered around the TV when they had Willy Wonka, The Sound of Music, My Fair Lady etc showing as the Saturday night family movie, it’s how she grew up with all those classics.
I think at that same cinema on Collins Street the year before me and my brother took Mum and Dad to see The SpongeBob SquarePants Movie for Dad’s Birthday lol, Dad enjoyed the experience even though looking back now we don’t really remember a lot except for The Hoff’s cameo but it was a great time haha
Honestly for me the Tim Burton 2005 version is by far my favourite. Now I admit I'm probably very biased cos I grew up with it. It doesn't have the magic spark the original does but I think that's the point. It's meant to be a more modern interpretation. Johnny Depp is just amazing in the role. Almost everything he says is frickin hilarious every time. It's one of my favourite comedy movies. The cast is so good. I kinda like how the chocolate factory has a very eerie vibe to it. I think the story of Wonka's past is interesting and I like how they deepen the character
yes totally, everything has to be so totally TODAY and MODERN! Current day all the way baby! They just should have made it 500-D, it's no good if we can't count the nose hairs in Wonka's nose
I know Johnny Depps’s version isnt that good but I will always love it because it was the one I grew up with
I just saw this movie yesterday. I loved it. I put the other Wonka movies out of my mind. Timothy was a wonderful movie, A+, from me.
I've only watched the Tim Burton and Wonka version and I don't think the Tim Barton version is that bad, but I don't think this movie will be wanted for adults to watch. It's true that it's creepy and downright weird at times, but most of all it's simple for older audiences. Every kid has some bad character trait for which he or she is punished, and Charlie is sweet and perfect to a fault, which really annoyed me. And Depp himself as Wonka is okay, but in my opinion it's a much less successful version of the Hatter from Alice in Wonderland. Wonka, however, is also a simple film, but made in such a way that children, teenagers and adults will have great fun. I've always had mixed feelings about Chalamet, but here he captured Wonka's charm and energy perfectly. And these colorful supporting characters, Hugh Grant and great songs!
willy wonka and the chocolate factory - about Charile and Charlie and the Chocolate Factory - about Willy Wonka
Im so glad to hear people saying they like Charlie and the chocolate factory. Ive like I was defending that movie against several people. I understand if people don't like it because its weird or gave them nightmares, but it is not a bad movie. Its very well made if you put it in context. The sets are amazing, the children are done very well, the only flaw is Willy Wonka doesn't have a goatee. Although that would look weird.
Yeah I did not know there was a Tom and Jerry Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory until I started working on my review on Wonka that's crazy they made one of those but the original is always going be my favorite. Wonka me and my family really enjoy that movie. I 100% agree on this ranking
Suggestion for movie ranked , adaptation of Shakespeare work like Macbeth or Hamlet, it can be a long term project and will introduce how his work has been adapted by different countries and directors.
I read the book and Johnny Depp's Willy Wonka is nothing like the original character. Let Dahl's family say what they want, but I highly doubt he would have liked Depp's creation between Michael Jackson and Marilyn Manson. Burton has his own original style that I quite like in small doses, but I was quite bored with his version, it was so clunky. Even the original film isn't perfect, but Wilder captured the best glimpses of Wonka's mischievous character in it. On the other hand, I wouldn't even compare the new Wonka. That movie goes its own way, it doesn't even have the same story, it's more naive, but at the same time very magical. It's the perfect Christmas family movie.
Tim Burton's version was my introduction to Willy Wonka growing up so therefore its the version I love the most
My fave wonka movie is wonka
Love ❤ Your list
3. Wonka
2. Charlie and the Chocolate Factory
1. Willy Wonka and The Chocolate Factory
R.I.P. Gene Wilder
Not gonna lie I haven’t seen wonka yet but I don’t particularly care for either Willy Wonka and The Chocolate Factory or the Tim Burton film
1: Gene Wilder
2: Johnny Depp
3: Timothee Chalamet
1. Charlie & the Chocolate Factory (2005)
2. Willy Wonka & the Chocolate Factory (1971)
3? Wonka (2023)
4. Tom & Jerry: Willy Wonka & the Chocolate Factory (2017)
(I haven’t seen Wonka yet, but I’m assuming it’ll be better than the Tom & Jerry version.)
Honestly this is my ranking exactly
Actually the songs from 2005 are from the 📖
I never seen the 1st one but if i had to choose between wonka and Charlie and the chocolate factory, Ima say wonka bc i just rlly enjoyed everything about it, The acting, The songs, And other stuff!
I think sticking close to the books is irrelevant when telling a story from a theatrical medium so even though 2005 is more faithful to the source material the 1971 willy wonka works better as a theatrical adaptation.
In the first act of 1971 you develope a connection and emotional bond to the character of charlie, you feel his heart break when he doesnt find the ticket for example. The 1971 charlie has a much more. impactful character arc where as the 2005 charlie is forgetable and might as well not be there.
Depps portrayal of wonka comes across as too creepy because he lacks the childlike whimsicle charm that both Wilder and Timothee portray
1. Willy wonka and the chocolate factory (1971)
2. Wonka (2023)
3. Charlie and the chocolate factory (2005)
2:05 the Nostalgia Critic review on this is truly something else!
My listing (from worst to best):
*4: Tom & Jerry and Willy Wonka & the Chocolate Factory
I agree with you entirely about the Tom & Jerry Wonka movie!
*3: Charlie and the Chocolate Factory (2005)
I agree with you for the most part. I deeply dislike Depp’s choices for playing Willy Wonka (and I love Johnny Depp as an actor)! I do like that the look of Wonka’s factory and the Oompa Loompa’s songs are all pulled right from Roald Dahl’s book, which I love! I also love Grandpa Joe in this version more than 1971 Grandpa Joe.
*2: Wonka (2023)
I really enjoyed this version of Wonka! The aesthetics were lovely to see and Timothée Chalamet was delightful as a younger Willy Wonka! I do think the plot and pacing could have been better and it would have been much better as a stand-alone Wonka movie instead of trying to do its own thing while also being a prequel to the 1971 movie.
*1: Willy Wonka & the Chocolate Factory (1971)
I really love this movie so much! Everything about it is utterly delightful and memorable! Gene Wilder was perfect as Willy Wonka (I found him much closer to book!Wonka than Depp’s version of Willy Wonka ever was)! The only thing I dislike about this movie is Grandpa Joe.
If there’s one thing that 2005 did better over 1971 is that Grandpa Joe is actually a decent guy and not a leeching bum who let his family wallow in poverty and almost cost Charlie the factory with the fizzy drink incident!!
Charlie and the chocolate factory is my fav
Sean you give a shout out to Johnny Depp and Timothée Chalamet but not one mention of Gene Wilder- the true reason people still love the 1971 movie today. I know you ranked it no1 but that’s a slight omission dude.
All the best!
I haven't seen Wonka yet, but maybe I would agree after I watch it.
Where did you get that Marvel Hoodie at!! I love that and wanna buy it!
You know Wonka is a prequel to the 1971 Film because this has no connection of the remake
I would give Willy wonka and the chocolate factory. A 100 / 100
Whenever i see chocolate factory stuff i get in the mood for chocolate bars
Tom & Jerry 😂😂😂😂😂
The Tim Burton, Johnny Depp one my 🐐 though. Can watch the scene where the kids first enter the factory over the 71 entire movie 😂😂😂🤷🏽♂️🤷🏽♂️🤷🏽♂️
My ranking
3. Charlie and the Chocolate Factory
2. Wonka
1. Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory
Never seen the Tom and Jerry one.
4:charlie and the chocolate factory
3:tom and jerry willy wonka and the chocolate factory
2:wonka
1:willy wonka and the chocolate factory
1971 is number 1 obviously
2023 Number 2
2005 Number 3
Here’s my take on the new one.
My wife and I really enjoyed the movie !! It was amazing. The music scenes were good and I loved the origin story. The second Wonka was just like the first one and that’s why this one is really good. I loved the first one the best, obviously the second one was good too but it didn’t stand out. . Deflating moment was when the store burned down, it was sad but I knew a redemption story was coming. Loved the last scene noodle and her mom. with 10/10 because of the story.
Nostalgia biased 50 year old ^
@@WritingCountingOriginalJust enjoy what you prefer.
Your not the authority of how people watch a movie. Stop harassing people who prefer the 1971 movie.
@@WritingCountingOriginal And God forbid if anything is older than 5 minutes old it's sooo OUTDATED 🙄
@@WritingCountingOriginal Dumb gen Zer who can't read a clock or sign your name 😆😂
@@jonnaking3054 Well tbf the 2005 movie just does most scenes objectively better than the 1971 version, and the 2005 movie is longer.
I can't stand the Burton one but it's been famously known that Roald Dahl hated the 1971 one. But for most of us, Wilder was more charming as Wonka than Depp. Add all the classic songs. Depp said he portrayed Wonka like a game show host. His big smile creeps me out. Was also not a fan of the Oompa Loompas using the same actor (Deep Roy) in the 2005 one.
The Roald Dahl book was my favorite book as a child when I read it during the 5th grade recommended by one of my classmates and it remains one of my favorite books as the story feels so timeless. I haven't seen the Wonka prequel but I'm sure the 1971 one will never be topped. It's actually one of my all-time favorite musicals. Wonka 2023 is said to work as a great companion piece for it like The Godfather Part II is to Part I and Priscilla (2023) can be to Elvis (2022).
The reason why the oompa loompas look the way they do in the Burton version is because that is how they were described in the book. The Burton version, unlike the Gene Wilder version, was actually trying to be accurate to the source material.
@@joeyk107 I'll defend the 2005 version until the day I die but the Oompa-Loompas weren't really described that way in the book
@@spacecaster3802 I think you may have responded to the wrong person. At no point in my comment was I being judgmental about another’s opinion. So what about my comment was it that set you off on this tirade?
@@ethanhart129 Apologies
It’s just when you said “I’ll defend the 2005 version with my life”. It sounded like your one of those people who constantly harasses people who prefer the 1971 version.
I’m fine with whatever people prefer. I just wish some fans of the 2005 version, had a better attitude.
Tom and Kerry in Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory... if you felt like a title could make you lose brain cells you were right.
On a side note, it doesn't make any sense that the original adaption is a rename of a book but the remake has the name of the original book, why wouldn't you name the original adaption after the name and rename it for the remake.
Can't wait to see your thoughts on Tom and Jerry Wizard of Oz and Muppets Wizard of Oz when Wicked Part 1 comes out later next year!
I was wondering if you would be including the Tom and Jerry version.
Lol that Tom and Jerry one 😆. Don't care for the Tim Burton version at all, the original will always top the bill. That frantic GOOD DAY SIR frightened the heck out of me when I was little
3rd Willy Wonka and the Chocolate factory
2nd Charlie and the Chocolate factory
1st Wonka
How about ranking all ronal dhal film adaptation
It’s Mr bean! 9:24 😂
I'm not sure if i really agree with your "ridiculous" assesment of the New Wonka. There were many very serious moments and storylines that genuinely made you feel. Noodles Dream, Noodles reuniting with her mother, Slugworth was a pretty monstrous villian, etc.
Conspiculously left out one of the live-action Wonkas on the thumbnail. I wonder who will be last...