The Ultimate Sectarian (Satirical Leftist Anti-Sectarian Song)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 24 мар 2016
  • Sectarianism, the biggest threat to leftism.
    Year recorded: 1930s
    Composer: Joe Glazer and Bill Friedman
    Lyricist: Joe Glazer and Bill Friedman
  • ВидеоклипыВидеоклипы

Комментарии • 827

  • @krozeder
    @krozeder Год назад +575

    As an Anarcho-Marxist-Leninist-Trotskyist-Makhnovist-Dengist-Ceaușist-Titoist-Prachanda Path with Libyan and Mongolian characteristics - 1976 Conference (Marxist), this song's great

  • @dc2008242
    @dc2008242 7 лет назад +413

    the first time I watched Monty Python's "The Life of Brian" I didn't think that joke was as funny as it is now because I didn't understand it as much until now

    • @legalizeit9558
      @legalizeit9558 3 года назад +19

      splitter!

    • @liamlove2417
      @liamlove2417 Год назад +19

      “We are the people’s front of Judea! Not the Judean people’s front!”

    • @fun_ghoul
      @fun_ghoul 11 месяцев назад +4

      I thought it was hilarious as a kid. Now, I view it as a bourgeois attack on revolutionary movements...and of course! They're all millionaires now, and John Cleese is even a shameless Tory!

    • @matthewlinus4691
      @matthewlinus4691 День назад

      ​@@fun_ghoul Is this a bit.

    • @fun_ghoul
      @fun_ghoul 8 часов назад

      @@matthewlinus4691 Shut your yap, kid.

  • @pestoriusj
    @pestoriusj 7 лет назад +857

    Anarcho-Hoxhaism-Posadism is the only revolutionary movement.

    • @Kadaspala
      @Kadaspala 7 лет назад +172

      Fully automated luxury psychic dolphin space bunker communism.

    • @dontchewglass
      @dontchewglass 7 лет назад +81

      "The philosophers have only interpreted the world, in various ways; the point is to end it" - Comrade Posadas

    • @agentsmith3142
      @agentsmith3142 7 лет назад +31

      Let us all celebrate the immortal dialectical science of Social Democratic Anarcho-Stalinist-Trotskyist Juche!

    • @dethkon
      @dethkon 7 лет назад +8

      I got 3 dolphins comrades and I'm working on my 2nd Bunker. Get on my (galactic) level!

    • @QuarrelsomeLocalOaf
      @QuarrelsomeLocalOaf 7 лет назад +12

      From each according to their h-bomb, to each according to their UFO.

  • @usami_ruku
    @usami_ruku 5 лет назад +512

    I really like how there's a "Red Heaven" with Marx as st. Peter.

    • @throwfascistsintopits3062
      @throwfascistsintopits3062 2 года назад +4

      Where?????????????

    • @big_sea
      @big_sea Год назад +4

      yes

    • @contapendrive1972
      @contapendrive1972 5 месяцев назад

      Why St. Peter?

    • @northchurch753
      @northchurch753 4 месяца назад +3

      @contapendrive1972 Peter is typically seen as "Guardian of the Gates of Heaven" so having Marx guarding the gates to Red Heaven is basically making him Red Saint Peter

  • @ccaagg
    @ccaagg 8 лет назад +225

    I loved the Life of Brian example.

    • @Sofspot1
      @Sofspot1 8 лет назад +20

      +ccaagg That clip shows how fragmented the left though... If all the leftist parties came together, we really would be a force to be reckoned with

    • @ccaagg
      @ccaagg 8 лет назад +20

      Chance Hill Indeed. There'll be plenty of time for people to argue among themselves _after_ they've defeated the common enemy.

  • @GeorgijTovarsen
    @GeorgijTovarsen 7 лет назад +756

    This song has just brought anarcho-stalinism to life

    • @rebelbeammasterx8472
      @rebelbeammasterx8472 6 лет назад +50

      Anarcho-Monarchism

    • @nathanventura548
      @nathanventura548 6 лет назад +103

      Did you just divide by zero?

    • @_chew_
      @_chew_ 6 лет назад +59

      Uphold the principles of Anarcho-theocratic Trotskyism with Australian characteristics!

    • @3uujh656
      @3uujh656 6 лет назад +15

      Add in posadism, squidwardism and pinguism and I'll be on board.

    • @shelbycrandell6354
      @shelbycrandell6354 4 года назад +6

      So maoism

  • @davidthedegenerate7841
    @davidthedegenerate7841 4 года назад +576

    I can't get the idea of red heaven out of my head.
    You pass after 80 years of doing your damnedest to change the world.
    You wake to a door which behind it is every leftest advocate you can imagine.
    Gandhi and Lenin are sitting at a table playing cards.
    Eugene Debs is having a conversation with Algernon Lee at the bar.
    Karl takes your hand and says, "You have done your part, and we thank you comrade. Now kick back and have a drink!"
    The crowd cheers you as the hymns of revolution canter in the background.
    You know you've done your part. And we salute you.

    • @fuckitweballin759
      @fuckitweballin759 3 года назад +132

      And Nestor Makhno, and Kropotkin are at the back of the bar playing darts with a dart board that has trotsky's face on it

    • @tylerford2370
      @tylerford2370 3 года назад +137

      Stalin and Trotsky are just sitting in the back arguing very loudly.

    • @user-um1ly2kf9p
      @user-um1ly2kf9p 3 года назад +81

      Tyler Ford don’t forget Tito and Stalin are shouting over each other

    • @leontrotsky9268
      @leontrotsky9268 3 года назад +43

      Stalin and Trotsky are in an eternal death match in the corner

    • @whyamihere5732
      @whyamihere5732 3 года назад +10

      Meanwhile Beria's just looking your young commie teens. Why did I write that

  • @lilanshee9163
    @lilanshee9163 5 лет назад +153

    (Insert leftist movement) is the only true revolutionary movement

    • @stevenirizarry1304
      @stevenirizarry1304 4 года назад +1

      Hampton institute is indeed the worst

    • @MijmerMopper
      @MijmerMopper 3 года назад +13

      Nonsense, they are just splitters from too focused on petty differences and no true comrade will EVER forgive them for that!

    • @dheosilalahi7241
      @dheosilalahi7241 3 года назад

      Fifth international v:

    • @Nupetiet
      @Nupetiet Год назад

      you do realize this means war

    • @KozelPraiseGOELRO
      @KozelPraiseGOELRO 8 месяцев назад

      I mean, if they had no idea at least of how how to make it work after revolution (a scientific), they are doomed to fail anyway.

  • @agentsmith3142
    @agentsmith3142 7 лет назад +54

    Let us all celebrate the immortal dialectical science of Social Democratic Anarcho-Stalinist-Trotskyist Juche!

  • @egormoryganov
    @egormoryganov 6 лет назад +101

    It seems that the song was written yesterday: in Russia we have: CPRF, WPR, WRP, RCWP, UCP, ACPB, RCU...

    • @kpisti680
      @kpisti680 3 года назад +19

      At least you have lot in Hungary we have the:

    • @egormoryganov
      @egormoryganov 3 года назад +7

      @@kpisti680 if it's the situation - which I doubt - it gets easier in a way: you can take as much responsibility as you want.

    • @RedWanderer26
      @RedWanderer26 3 года назад +1

      Я знаю только КПРФ, кто остальные?

    • @egormoryganov
      @egormoryganov 3 года назад +6

      @@RedWanderer26 РРП, РПР, РКРП, ОКП, ВКПБ (Нины Андреевой), КПРК. Их ещё много.
      Я не знаю, какой белены я объелся, что стал переводить эти аббревиатуры.

    • @prostokotyara751
      @prostokotyara751 3 года назад

      >CPRF
      Лол

  • @eniogiannini8970
    @eniogiannini8970 Год назад +31

    For anyone Wondering:
    The Hammer and sickle flag with a gold bordered star is the flag of Kruschnev and Gorbachev's Communism
    The other one with a larger sickle is Stalinism
    The Backward Hammer and sickle with a four is Trotskyism
    The Blue, white and red flag with a red star is titoism
    The chinese flag is maoism
    And the one with the hammer and sickle symbol inside a star is Luxembourgism (German Communism)

  • @YugoslavianHeroes1943Channel
    @YugoslavianHeroes1943Channel 8 лет назад +86

    Yugoslavia flag on there yeahhh

  • @seanhardy5038
    @seanhardy5038 7 лет назад +395

    song is critical of sectarianism; comments full of justification for sectarianism...

    • @milascave2
      @milascave2 5 лет назад +14

      real: Technically, most of the anit-Stalinist in the Spanish Civil war Communists were not Trotskyites. Trotsky actually opposed the Civil war, so he said from Mexico.

    • @r.t.5767
      @r.t.5767 4 года назад +26

      sectarianism is bad, and I think all socialists should unite, but the major split between anarchists and marxists is VERY hard to overcome, comrade

    • @wendigo017
      @wendigo017 4 года назад +6

      @RealMartialNova Stalin literally did nothing wrong and he executed communism best way. Fuck all other leftists, Stalin was our God

    • @cftpafan
      @cftpafan 4 года назад +6

      @RealMartialNova And Trotsky led the Red army against the Black army I believe.

    • @mauer594
      @mauer594 3 года назад +2

      @RealMartialNova sectarianism good because stalinism bad >:((((( poor baby trotsky he only tried to plot against the bolshevik government nooooo

  • @markmikolay9019
    @markmikolay9019 Год назад +81

    Being a leftist might be a struggle and maybe you lose hope from time to time, but you have to admit that it is pretty funny at times at least.

  • @crackerdawg1
    @crackerdawg1 7 лет назад +182

    No egoist anarchism? Wow now give me that toothbrush

    • @mikemccue655
      @mikemccue655 6 лет назад +52

      Toothbrushes are spooks

    • @jaypea30
      @jaypea30 4 года назад +10

      Get outta here you mutual l o s e r

    • @oracle8192
      @oracle8192 3 года назад +11

      I'd rather have liberalism for a 1000 more years than even risk the chance egoism coming to fruition.

    • @Void-rj3sq
      @Void-rj3sq 2 года назад +13

      @@oracle8192 spooked

    • @atomaszfarbaa1650
      @atomaszfarbaa1650 Год назад +2

      ​@@oracle8192spooked

  • @jedidante7218
    @jedidante7218 7 лет назад +68

    is this the Judean peoples front ?

  • @mikkicarr5717
    @mikkicarr5717 6 лет назад +340

    I'm an ML who thinks ancoms are great comrades. We should all work together!

    • @egormoryganov
      @egormoryganov 6 лет назад +19

      Indeed. By the way, our group is working now on short and clear materialistic interpretation of Hegel. It would be rather useful to walk it through it from the perspective of another language. Do you know anyone who can give a hand or at least is interested in this kind of work?

    • @nativeitzutakua-9863
      @nativeitzutakua-9863 4 года назад +16

      I agree ,ML maoist here !!

    • @Doughbrickstudios
      @Doughbrickstudios 4 года назад +34

      until we get shot after the revolution huh

    • @davidthedegenerate7841
      @davidthedegenerate7841 4 года назад +29

      LibSoc here and I'm open to it. Here's to the revolution, comrade. Long live the left.

    • @adamyoud6934
      @adamyoud6934 4 года назад +18

      A comrade is a comrade

  • @amityexe8326
    @amityexe8326 3 года назад +60

    And this is why the left needs to be a united front

    • @Jishy2415
      @Jishy2415 2 года назад +3

      a leftist, who has an TOH pfp. Ultra based

    • @grugg3108
      @grugg3108 Год назад +8

      I know this kinda opposes this song's values, bug I'd cooperate with other sects of left-anarchism a lot more enthusiastically than I would most forms of left authoritarianism. In fact I'd genuinely rather work with a "right-libertarain" than a stalinist or trotskyist. Still may fw MLs and Titoists

    • @Natalietrans
      @Natalietrans Год назад

      Nah these tankies are fucking bitches who call revisionist when they don’t like you

    • @Natalietrans
      @Natalietrans Год назад

      @@grugg3108definitely

    • @cumboy2596
      @cumboy2596 Год назад +10

      @@grugg3108 you, an anticapitalist, would rather work with someone who advocates for free market capitalism than anyone from the ideological faction that's done the most to combat capitalism globally. I think you've gotta rethink some of your principles

  • @stickcultist
    @stickcultist 2 месяца назад +2

    Crazy how a song recorded in the 1930s is still so relevant today

  • @szymonsokolinski9907
    @szymonsokolinski9907 3 года назад +92

    As an anarchist ancom sounds like the perfect compromise between marxism and anarchism

    • @RESTITVTOR_TOTIVS_HISPANIAE
      @RESTITVTOR_TOTIVS_HISPANIAE 2 года назад +20

      But muh vanguard party! But muh intermediary stage for the intermediary stage! Wtf is muh compromise? Wtf is muh state?????

    • @cumboy2596
      @cumboy2596 Год назад

      @@RESTITVTOR_TOTIVS_HISPANIAE centuries of developed theory have now been debunked because RESTITVTOR ORBIS said muh vanguard party

    • @anarchosnowflakist786
      @anarchosnowflakist786 Год назад +6

      I how is anarcho communism a compromise between marxism and anarchism ? I would understand with platformism which you can jokingly refer to as anarcho leninism, but anarcho communism isn't any more authoritarian or less radical, more party oriented, or more vanguardist than any other anarchist tendancy

    • @mistermensch2883
      @mistermensch2883 Год назад

      In my opinion we can't just do away with the state instantaneously becaus it has to much relevance and people are not used to living without it so there must be a transitioning periode greetings frome a ml

    • @szymonsokolinski9907
      @szymonsokolinski9907 Год назад +2

      @@anarchosnowflakist786 That's the joke. I'm an anarchist so ancom sounds like a good compromise, because I don't give up anything

  • @teslashark
    @teslashark 5 лет назад +18

    Purity is best reserved for the enemy!

  • @OctopusDropkick
    @OctopusDropkick 7 лет назад +92

    lol this comment thread has a lot of new to left politics roleplayers pretending they were involved in struggles and historical movements continents away, before they were born

    • @sigmaballsnetwork
      @sigmaballsnetwork 2 года назад

      I was obviously a part of the Afghan communist government, hell I’m Muhammad Najibullah himself!

  • @ninyaninjabrifsanovichthes45
    @ninyaninjabrifsanovichthes45 5 лет назад +22

    Anarcho-Titoism time

  • @jamesg3500
    @jamesg3500 5 лет назад +14

    Well I guess that means we should highlight the shared things we agree on, run with that first, then later on we can smooth out the rest of the finer details.

  • @uursergeelt7959
    @uursergeelt7959 5 лет назад +11

    Comrades, I know we all have our differences, but we all want to help the people, either one way or another, we may fight capitalism first and then talk about this differences

  • @niklasklasen8048
    @niklasklasen8048 7 лет назад +14

    Imma share this in every socialist community I know

  • @YugoslavianHeroes1943Channel
    @YugoslavianHeroes1943Channel 8 лет назад +7

    Good Video!

  • @Comrade3333
    @Comrade3333 2 года назад +43

    The thought of Red Heaven is awesome. Marx and Engels welcomes you. Then you have 3 choices: Farming the clouds, Protesting for Socialism or having a revolution. Lenin in revolution, Eugene Debs leading a workers protest and the serfs and peasants doing farming minus the exploitation. I'd personally would join the dream revolution with Lenin.

    • @perryplayzzz
      @perryplayzzz Год назад +2

      Revolution seems good especially with Comrade Lenin

    • @Nupetiet
      @Nupetiet Год назад +1

      not much for farming but are there any machine shops or factories or maybe a ship of some sort

  • @unknownroyalty895
    @unknownroyalty895 10 месяцев назад +4

    Bill is just Hoxha on steroids.

  • @anon-qt3mo
    @anon-qt3mo 11 месяцев назад +4

    Fireman: " Oh... I guess I'm leaving ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ "

  • @user-or7mh5we2k
    @user-or7mh5we2k 4 года назад +42

    Trotskyists when they see their own party.

  • @Surge1music-ve9sq
    @Surge1music-ve9sq 9 месяцев назад +9

    This song basically sums up George Orwell’s personality

  • @bottlecap3211
    @bottlecap3211 7 лет назад +6

    Gotta list all the random internet anarchist ideologies

  • @calliedunne7944
    @calliedunne7944 8 лет назад +3

    all kind of comrades, unite!!!

  • @bolenco149
    @bolenco149 3 года назад +7

    leftcom moment

  • @mixis1931
    @mixis1931 Год назад +2

    "Crowned heads, wealth and privilege may well tremble should ever again the Black and Red unite!"

  • @Kassey194
    @Kassey194 3 года назад +3

    They wrote a song about me, amazing

  • @nottherealpaulsmith
    @nottherealpaulsmith 6 лет назад +7

    Me: Time for left unity! Hey guys, want to work together?
    Anarchist: fuck off trot
    ML: fuck off trot
    Democratic Socialist: fuck off trot
    Leninist: fuck off trot
    Me: oh

    • @JaysonVaughn
      @JaysonVaughn 10 месяцев назад

      me, an ex-trot luxembourgist: fuck you stalin, i'll do it

  • @ComradeWolfman98
    @ComradeWolfman98 6 лет назад +20

    Marxism-Leninism-Sargonism is da only natural extrapolation of Marxism

  • @cocof5308
    @cocof5308 7 лет назад +1

    Does someone know what are the guitars riff to play this beautiful song ? :)

  • @darthnachname573
    @darthnachname573 8 лет назад +31

    Einheitsfront! Jetzt!

    • @barry63196
      @barry63196 4 года назад +1

      shush nazi language

    • @barry63196
      @barry63196 3 года назад +1

      @Redfong RUTTP YFGA ADUTTP lol prove it

  • @VLKYRI
    @VLKYRI 8 месяцев назад +4

    God i hope Red Heaven is a real thing. (Its not but im choosing to believe it is)

  • @SunflowerSocialist
    @SunflowerSocialist 7 лет назад +18

    I'll admit I don't want to unite with all the left, but there are times we need to get along

    • @grugg3108
      @grugg3108 Год назад +1

      As someone that would've cheered if some of the people many leftists praise met violent ends, I'd much sooner be stuck in an elevator with a Titoist than a be stuck in a cell gaurded by fascists.

    • @cumboy2596
      @cumboy2596 Год назад +6

      Absolutely. Generally leftist unity is a silly idea that has little basis in reality. But in the cases such as combating fascism, we gotta unite.

  • @cash_burner
    @cash_burner 3 года назад +1

    As a First World Market Maoist-Kolbucharist-Khviest none of you are comrades of mine

  • @ninyaninjabrifsanovichthes45
    @ninyaninjabrifsanovichthes45 6 лет назад +8

    SPLITTA'!

  • @NoaManic
    @NoaManic 5 лет назад +8

    What’s the difference in ideologies between the 2 top ones to the left that look almost exactly the same? I know about all of the others, but I have never known any difference between those 2

    • @Graknorke
      @Graknorke 5 лет назад +8

      The one with the shorter sickle and only the outline of a star is/was the Soviet one. Idk what the other one is.
      Edit: yeah the gold bordered red star was the one on the USSR flag. The one with the solid gold star is presumably something different but I've not found any indication what.
      Edit2: might just be an error? fotw.info/flags/su!err.html
      Though that doesn't explain why it would be in the graphic.

    • @derlinksfaschist8136
      @derlinksfaschist8136 4 года назад +10

      @@Graknorke The one on the top left is the USSR flag after Stalin. The one below is the one from the Stalin-Era.

    • @davidthedegenerate7841
      @davidthedegenerate7841 4 года назад +2

      No the one under the USSR is Hungary

  • @slimshady7014
    @slimshady7014 7 лет назад +4

    damn we leftists r dis united, this is why breznev was able to come to power, this is why ussr fell

  • @epicsamurai5
    @epicsamurai5 2 года назад +2

    It’s funny. Like a good chunk the people in the song ended up becoming informants.

  • @milascave2
    @milascave2 5 лет назад

    Yes, that Mony Python Bit from "Life of Brian" remains true for all Times description of the behavior of leftist groups.

  • @Команданте
    @Команданте 23 дня назад

    Прекрасная песня, товарищи🥰

  • @tristan16291
    @tristan16291 5 лет назад +2

    en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bill_Bailey_(Spanish_Civil_War_veteran) could this song be about this guy? This guy is the only bill bailey that I found who was a well known radical leftist.

  • @Evovite
    @Evovite 5 месяцев назад +1

    i have no idea what this song means but it slaps

    • @miketheant1107
      @miketheant1107 Месяц назад

      It's about sectarianism within the radical left. It cites names like Emma Goldman, a proeminant anarchist activist in north america, and the Socialist Labour Party. Both of these figures would be scoffed at by marxists, who disdain both anarchism and reformism. By the end, you get the head of the "marxist league" slamming the Gates of red heaven in Karl Marx' face for being close to Karl Kautsky and Ferdinand LaSale, proeminent figures in the 2nd international's hard turn to the right, and the transformation of the German Social Democratic Party from a communist party advocating for revolution into a bourgeois party meant only for running elections. The action of slamming the door in Marx' face is meant to ridicularize such sectarianism within the left, basically a commie version of "if Jesus came today christians would crucify him again".

  • @theredjoker8857
    @theredjoker8857 3 года назад +39

    Let me explain briefly: The Trotskyists see themselves in the tradition of Lenin, whereas the Marxist-Leninists claim the same but in fact mean Stalin. The left communists claim that both is the same and see themselves in the tradition of Luxemburg and Pannekoek. Whereas the Trotskyists claim Luxemburg was a Bolshevik and consider Luxemburgism a myth. The Stalinists hate both Trotskyism and Luxemburgism, which means that they also hate Lenin. The anarchists consider everything that has to do with organisation to be authoritarian and thus hate everything and basically consider Stalin to be a Lenin 2.0, in whatever respect. If the left communists agree in this respect, which they usually do, the anarchists go straight for beating up Marx. Meanwhile, the social democrats think everyone is a left-wing fascist. The reformist socialists once again can't choose sides and go nicely back into a governing coalition. Meanwhile, the left communists, council communists, libertarian communists have no clue what their differences actually are. The anarchists "spontaneously" burn a few bins, while the Trotskyists have been practising entrism for eons. Furthermore, the Marxist-Leninists who follow Lenin's tradition do not understand that this means they basically declare themselves to be Stalinists and are arguing with the Trotskyists over trifles. The Stalinists, of course, still think everyone is a petty-bourgeois deviation and cuddle around with the Maoists and even sometimes National Bolsheviks. The anarcho-primitivists don't have a clue and start to grow crops. In between, a few stray National Socialists walk through the camera. Sydicalists and anarchists start arguing about whether they should call themselves syndicalist-anarchists or anarcho-syndicalists, while the anarcho-communists look stupid. On the side, the left communists bash in the heads of the Trotskyists and Leninists, getting help from the Stalinists. An anarcho-capitalist asks for directions on the side. The Christian socialists don't know whether to pray for good weather or peace. Neo-Marxists repeat: "All I know is that I am not a Marxist". Supposedly orthodox Marxists argue whether the "permanent revolution" or the "stage theory" is correct. The Dengists, funnily enough, agree with the social democrats and reformist socialists that we all have to wait another thousand years to introduce socialism. The autonomists have no idea what they are supposed to be doing there and prefer to beg for more democracy in the workplace. All the while Musk, Bezos etc. are watching the spectacle from their new cybertruck.
    I hope that was understandable for you, because it wasn't for me...

    • @theredjoker8857
      @theredjoker8857 3 года назад +6

      @@acezheng8148 Well, it's just a pity that in reality it's not a sensible mixture and merely reflects Stalin's own doctrine. Lenin himself said several times that Bolshevism is not universally applicable, but rather a Marxism applied to Russian conditions. Lenin would probably have ended up in jail himself at some point, according to his own wife. Instead, Stalin makes Lenin into a mannequin and gives himself credit, although Lenin strictly rejected the personality cult. And then some nutcase wants to tell me that I'm following a religion. The sentence that it was Stalin who shaped Marxism-Leninism and claims that it was a further development, namely his, makes no difference to its content. Whether Stalinism or ML, it remains Stalin's invented doctrine, just like Maoism. What if I were to go around saying, "Marxism-Leninism-Maoism-Titoism-Dengism-Hoxhaism" is the new doctrine? Making up some shit has nothing to do with the development of Marxism, neither do the constant variations of Dialectical Materialism, of which there are now also umpteen versions. Look at the crippled Chinese alone. Lenin's doctrine alone, not Stalin's, has proved how the proletariat can conquer power. Stalin at least made it clear to us that the workers and trade unions should not lose it.
      I consider myself as a (Leninist) Bolshevist and if you are still not sure, remember all the Bolshevists killed by Stalin. So beat it...

    • @theredjoker8857
      @theredjoker8857 3 года назад +7

      @@acezheng8148 ...and what I have written is what a Trotskyist would say.
      Which I may also be...shit

    • @theredjoker8857
      @theredjoker8857 3 года назад +2

      @UCDMUJOn0LmGV9Bk8Clvp-uw 🤷

    • @unco_pk_traceur7748
      @unco_pk_traceur7748 2 года назад

      when u read no theory other than about your own sect and have a really good time imagining what each tradition thinks and gets its lineage from and how each sect relates to eachother

    • @JaysonVaughn
      @JaysonVaughn 10 месяцев назад

      fuck me this is too true

  • @redberdyaev6648
    @redberdyaev6648 Месяц назад +2

    As the head of the 69th International, it is clear that all of you have betrayed the revolution with your sectarian refuse to uphold Marxism, as understood through my hyper-specific, and poor researched reading of Trotsky's 1934-1337 works.

  • @pleasureisgood5957
    @pleasureisgood5957 Год назад +1

    Now, now...We can spar, but we shouldn't fight seriously between our own.
    We have a common enemy guys!

  • @bladeofgrass216
    @bladeofgrass216 9 месяцев назад +3

    I do believe in uniting the left to some extent, but trying to unite Marxists and anarchists is idealism at play. (As a Marxist,) our theories are fundamentally opposed from one other. Yes, our end goals are the same, but our ways of getting there are different.

    • @nicholasoneal1521
      @nicholasoneal1521 9 месяцев назад +1

      Your theories are fundamentally opposed to reality

    • @TheBigWall3284
      @TheBigWall3284 7 месяцев назад +3

      ​@@nicholasoneal1521more reality based than believing that getting the ultra rich richer will make life better for everyone else

    • @nicholasoneal1521
      @nicholasoneal1521 7 месяцев назад

      @@TheBigWall3284 Marxism and getting the ultra rich richer aren't the only two options.
      Though getting the ultra rich richer is the more reality based options because that's something that can actually be done. Communism and Anarchism are impossible to achieve

  • @p.a.5254
    @p.a.5254 7 лет назад +4

    Y does one sickle and hammer have a filled in star and the other one not? what ideologies are they

    • @kameradkircheis8426
      @kameradkircheis8426 7 лет назад +5

      The one that isn't filled in is the flag of the USSR and the ones that is filled is found on the past ww2 Hungary flag, but I can't say for sure

    • @camaradatrotsky5584
      @camaradatrotsky5584 2 года назад +1

      The filled star is Stalinism, the unfilled one is Khrushchevism

    • @camaradatrotsky5584
      @camaradatrotsky5584 Год назад

      @Pravda Yes, Stalinism, nobody takes offense when they call us Trotskyists, so stop complaining when we call you what you are, Stalinists.

    • @camaradatrotsky5584
      @camaradatrotsky5584 Год назад

      @Pravda Stalinism is not a theory, it is a characterization given to Stalin's supporters; Trotsky also did not synthesize any theory of his own, Trotskyism is the name given to his followers.

    • @camaradatrotsky5584
      @camaradatrotsky5584 Год назад +1

      @Pravda The Permanent Revolution is not an independent theory, it has become inseparable from Leninist practice. In short, it is the realization that it is no longer possible to form popular fronts with the bourgeoisie and that the proletariat must act independently even in backward countries. This was developed by Trotsky yes, but it is not because an author develops a concept that is already from a different branch of Marxism, otherwise we would have an ideology for every existing Marxist thinker. The Permanent Revolution is, in essence, a way of applying revolution in the context of modern capitalism, it is a method of practical action, Stalin also had methods, but they fluctuated a lot, he used one between 1928 and 1934 (sectarianism), another between 1934 and 1939 (step revolution, popular fronts with the bourgeoisie), and so on, the difference is that Trotsky's method is more enduring. It does not inaugurate a different revolutionary formation, as Mao Tse-Tung or Ho Chin Minh did, for example.

  • @emmathestonedspider8676
    @emmathestonedspider8676 5 лет назад +12

    Some days Bill Bailey seems highly rational.

  • @MaRaX93
    @MaRaX93 7 лет назад +3

    love monty python

  • @Vpentrov
    @Vpentrov 2 года назад +1

    Anybody know who sings this?

  • @zorbaknecromancer
    @zorbaknecromancer 8 лет назад +1

    Where is this song from

  • @KozelPraiseGOELRO
    @KozelPraiseGOELRO 8 месяцев назад

    The problem we will face we like it or not:
    What decitions do we make and how to identify the best and worst for our intentiom.
    That is the real issue among the rad-left.

  • @nayezdnik9077
    @nayezdnik9077 4 года назад +1

    Oh you may be a friend of Max Schachtman, Jim Cannon and you may agree, You may get a long with Norman Thomas and with Algernon Lee. You may be an old time Wobbly and think Jay Lovestone's fine, yes, you may be a comrade to all those folks, but you ain't no comrade of mine. 0:26

  • @robertaylor9218
    @robertaylor9218 5 месяцев назад +1

    This sounds like a couple of hard leftists I’ve interacted with.

  • @Unholyhybridgaming2022
    @Unholyhybridgaming2022 Год назад +1

    As a Marxist-Leninist-Trotskyist (something I like to call UnholyHybridism) I truly think sectarianism is a big threat to Leftism.

  • @singularityghost6290
    @singularityghost6290 8 лет назад

    gonna link this in my SIG, screw basically all of rev left

  • @jimhughon621
    @jimhughon621 6 лет назад +2

    Glory to the P.R.L

  • @emmytweetie2177
    @emmytweetie2177 4 года назад +1

    The only real comrade is yourself

  • @jonathanwright8025
    @jonathanwright8025 7 месяцев назад

    As an Ex-Post-Fact-Oehlerite, this really tracks.

  • @pendragon665
    @pendragon665 5 лет назад +1

    Haha, reminds me of the Rovics song

  • @lothairthecommiemonarch8488
    @lothairthecommiemonarch8488 4 года назад +1

    I recognise Titoism,Trotskyism,Maoism,ancom,anarcho mutualist,anarcho primitivism and Luxembourgism (?);what are those others?

    • @zhiracs
      @zhiracs 4 года назад +3

      Communist side, top to bottom:
      Marxism-Leninism, classical Leninism, Trotskyism, Titoism, Maoism, Luxemburgism
      Anarchist side:
      Mutualism, anarcho-transhumanism, green anarchism, anarcha-feminism, pacifist anarchsim, agorism.
      Center: anarcho-communism.

  • @StormAce96
    @StormAce96 7 лет назад +2

  • @derlinksfaschist8136
    @derlinksfaschist8136 3 года назад +4

    ''Gekrönte Häupter, Reichtum und Privilegien werden zerbrechen, sollten sich die Roten und Schwarzen je wieder verbünden.'' - Otto v. Bismark

  • @sredacted1647
    @sredacted1647 Год назад

    What is the difference between the two hammer and sickle plus star symbols? Stalinism vs Brezhnevism?

    • @JaysonVaughn
      @JaysonVaughn 10 месяцев назад

      stalinism vs kruschevism

  • @TheCanterlonian
    @TheCanterlonian 7 лет назад

    Schnitz today.

  • @thepatrioticcommunistcommi8497
    @thepatrioticcommunistcommi8497 5 лет назад +3

    I think all types of Communist and Socialist ideologies from Marxism-Leninism, Jucheism, Libertarian Communism, Marxist Socialism, Rightist Socialism, Stalinism, Maoism, Titoism, to Trotskyism and Posadism could all unite together because their all Marxist/Communist ideologies that all came from the same Political Philosopher with just an adjustment of different Political and Economical Aesthetics from different powerful leaders. Although we don't know what to do with all kinds of Anarchists because Anarchism is too different of an Philosophy and ideology which it is away from the Communists perspective.

  • @solsolsolomon
    @solsolsolomon Год назад +1

    What are the different anarchist spheres ?

    • @stevenorrington473
      @stevenorrington473 3 месяца назад

      It's all anarchism(opposition to hierarchy) with varying amounts of socialism.

  • @DarkFinks330284
    @DarkFinks330284 6 лет назад

    What's with the Symbols on the left hand

  • @bobmcbob1050
    @bobmcbob1050 8 лет назад +2

    i know only emma. tell me who are the offers.

    • @OWfan
      @OWfan 8 лет назад +13

      +Bob McBob James Cannon: former national secretary of the Socialist Workers Party; Max Shachtman: also associated with the SWP; Norman Thomas: former prez candidate for the Socialist Party of America and pacifist; Algernon Lee: SPoA member and New York councilman and mayoral candidate; Wobbly - IWW members; Jay Lovestone: CPUSA leader, later union head and snitch to the CIA; Ben Gitlow: CPUSA founding member and later anti-communist conservative; Rev. Muste: pacifist and anti-war activist; SLP: Socialist Labor Party; Karl Kautsky: SPD co-founder and critic of their stance on WWI along w/ critiquing Lenin and Bernstein; Ferd LaSalle: early international socialist and involved in supporting the (ultimately unsuccessful) revolution of 1848, also corresponded w/ Marx and Engels; William Liebknecht: co-founder of the SPD and father of Karl Liebknecht who was murdered w/ Luxemburg during the '18-19 German Revolution attempt.

  • @themillermaster1
    @themillermaster1 7 лет назад +7

    This but unironically

  • @UkaSozi
    @UkaSozi 13 дней назад

    1 leftist enters the room, 3 leftists get out

  • @christiannewaye7306
    @christiannewaye7306 7 лет назад +1

    Whats the movie at the end.

  • @theshitposterscp
    @theshitposterscp 2 года назад +1

    This would be great music for a left wing slander video

  • @sazxcdewq123
    @sazxcdewq123 6 лет назад +4

    What the symbols on the right mean? I see:
    Marxism-Leninism
    ???
    Trotskyism
    Titoism?
    Maoism
    ???

    • @comradejellobiafra4638
      @comradejellobiafra4638 5 лет назад +2

      The last one is Luxemburgism(Spartacists)

    • @Azoth86730
      @Azoth86730 5 лет назад +3

      Mutualism (orange), anarcho-transhumanism (blue), green-anarchism/anarcho-primitivism (green), anarcha-feminism (purple), anarcho-pacifism (white), agorism (grey), anarcho - syndicalism/ancom (red, middle one), Luxemburgist/spartacists (left bottom)

    • @r.t.5767
      @r.t.5767 4 года назад +2

      @@Azoth86730 the grey one may be anarcho-nihilist as well
      oh, and red and black can mean anarcho-collectivism too or even more broadly: anarchism or libertarian socialism in general ;)

    • @camaradatrotsky5584
      @camaradatrotsky5584 2 года назад

      Stalinism and Luxemburguism

  • @funkhc
    @funkhc 7 лет назад +144

    left unity is great look at how awesome it went for all of the anarchists in the past working with tankies.

    • @vladimirlenintv295
      @vladimirlenintv295 7 лет назад +62

      unity, now stfu

    • @adityaakbar2575
      @adityaakbar2575 7 лет назад +45

      Vladimir Lenin Tv continuing the old tradition of silencing anarchist voice eh?

    • @principetnomusic
      @principetnomusic 7 лет назад +24

      Tankies are not even real leftists, I would call them socialistic nationalists. National Socialists...

    • @Madness13371
      @Madness13371 7 лет назад +3

      What are you talking about guys, gulag is good

    • @DuckSociety
      @DuckSociety 6 лет назад +18

      Woah, guys! Guys! Please, we leftists are acting like the Capitalists we should be fighting! Cast off the actions of the past! Only then can we the people unite in world revolution! I’m a Marxist, FYI.

  • @jeanlebreton2049
    @jeanlebreton2049 3 месяца назад

    What do the blue, orange, grey and white anarchist flags stand for? Same question for the red star flag.

    • @mutualaideconomy
      @mutualaideconomy 3 месяца назад

      Blue: Anarcho-Transhumanism
      Orange: Anarcho-Mutualism
      Grey: Anarcho-Agorism
      White: Anarcho-Pacifism

    • @jeanlebreton2049
      @jeanlebreton2049 3 месяца назад

      @@mutualaideconomy Thanks. You're opening to whole ranges of anarchist branches I ignored.

  • @jonaswomack4493
    @jonaswomack4493 5 лет назад

    What does the Yugoslav flag mean?

  • @stevenirizarry1304
    @stevenirizarry1304 4 года назад +2

    World socialist website theme song

  • @user-or7mh5we2k
    @user-or7mh5we2k 6 лет назад +1

    What kind of anarchys are the black-blue and black-grey.

    • @justinmcauley531
      @justinmcauley531 5 лет назад +12

      Orange is Mutualism
      Blue is Transhumanism
      Green is Anarcho-Naturism
      Purple is Anarcha-Feminism
      White is Anarcho-Pacifism
      Grey is Agorism
      And of course, red is Anarcho-Communism (although it can represent Anarcho-Syndicalism and Collectivist Anarchism)

    • @user-or7mh5we2k
      @user-or7mh5we2k 5 лет назад

      @@justinmcauley531 thanks but isn't green anarcho primitimism and blue egoism?

    • @justinmcauley531
      @justinmcauley531 5 лет назад +2

      anti- libertarian
      Egoism is a more cyan color and anarcho-primitivism is a darker shade of green.

    • @justinmcauley531
      @justinmcauley531 5 лет назад +1

      anti- libertarian There's also a very light blue color, which is Individualist Anarchism.

    • @user-or7mh5we2k
      @user-or7mh5we2k 5 лет назад

      @@justinmcauley531 I didn't know that Thank you.

  • @3a146
    @3a146 6 лет назад +2

    Trot

  • @tgcid2018
    @tgcid2018 3 года назад

    Is this song about Teddy Russkin?

  • @Alatriste_uzl
    @Alatriste_uzl 6 лет назад

    И всё это на руку буржуям.

  • @RDRF_SB13
    @RDRF_SB13 3 года назад +13

    Truly I'm an An, but when I get angry I can quickly turn Auth. How much of the division is emotional?

    • @raptordraws7088
      @raptordraws7088 2 года назад +17

      I'm an anarchist, but damn Lemme see someone criticise socialism or communism and I'll put pol pot's authoritarianism to shame

    • @RDRF_SB13
      @RDRF_SB13 2 года назад +8

      @@raptordraws7088 I feel you. I like debating people if they can remain on topic and not use insults. If they resort to pettiness then I go troll mode.
      If someone actually does something I believe is intentionally and consciously exploitative of others I loose my temper.

    • @haltair4015
      @haltair4015 Год назад

      Most of it I'm afraid

    • @fun_ghoul
      @fun_ghoul Год назад

      @@RDRF_SB13 You're using "Auth" as a synonym for a-hole. Ugh.

  • @olehsztul6177
    @olehsztul6177 4 года назад +1

    I'm offended that there's no reference to left nationalism... Shakhrai gang unite.

    • @UlsterRedGuard
      @UlsterRedGuard 4 года назад

      Oleh SZTUL fucking nationalist

    • @olehsztul6177
      @olehsztul6177 4 года назад

      ​@@UlsterRedGuard The irony is that I'm the most internationalist leftnat.

    • @r.t.5767
      @r.t.5767 4 года назад

      if you are a multi-culturalist against assimilation and an anarchist then you are a comrade for me ;)

    • @olehsztul6177
      @olehsztul6177 4 года назад +1

      @@r.t.5767 You need to be able to work with the people of the country you live in regardless of ethnic or religious background and not be a chauvinist. I have no problems with anarchism, many anarchists have national consciousness.

    • @olehsztul6177
      @olehsztul6177 4 года назад +1

      @StalinLovesYou Many people seem to think they are.

  • @entiretotal7207
    @entiretotal7207 5 лет назад +1

    Who's the performer?

    • @zhiracs
      @zhiracs 5 лет назад

      Joe Glazer and Bill Friedland

  • @DissidentMitch
    @DissidentMitch 2 года назад +14

    Right Wing Version: Ol Pragey belonged to every right wing party that ever came to be, 
Till he finally decided to start his own party so he wouldn't disagree. 
He got himself an office with a sign outside the door, with "Prager League" in letters red, 
And to everyone who came around these were the words he said:
    "Oh, you may be a friend of Ol Donald (2), Dolf Hitler (3) and you may agree, 
You may get along with Pinochet(4) and with Ol Robert E Lee(5) 
You may be an old-time Christain(6), and think Wilhem is (7) fine, 
Yes, you may be a comrade to all of these folks, but you ain't no Comrade of mine." 
For 17 years Dennis Prager kept his office with the sign outside the door, 
But he never, ever got a new member. Everybody made him sore. 
And then one night, there came a big fire and through the flame and smoke, 
As the firemen rushed in to save Pragers life, these were the words he spoke:
    "Oh, you may be a friend of Benito (8); Louis the 16th(9) and you may agree, 
You may get along with Ol Spencer(10) and also with the NSP11). 
You may have belonged to every right wing party that ever had a line, 
Yes, you may be a comrade to all of those folks, but you ain't no comrade of mine." 
And so on this day, Dennis Prager passed away, and his soul to White Heaven flew. 
He was met at the gate by old Nixon (12) and George Wahington(13), too. 
They said, "Welcome, comrade," as they opened the gate to let Dennis come inside, 
As he slammed the door back in old Nixons face, these were the words he cried:
    "Oh, you may be a friend of Ol Davis (14), and a pal of Jefferson(15), 
You may get along with Wallace himself (16) and the American National(17), 
Yes, you may have inspired every Democratic party from the Hudson to the Rhine, 
Oh, you may be a comrade of all of those folks, but you ain't no comrade of mine."

  • @mikesomeguy7452
    @mikesomeguy7452 6 лет назад +2

    It said the sectarianism the biggest threat to communism isn't capitalism???

    • @FinleyUwU
      @FinleyUwU 4 года назад +1

      one of the biggest threat*

  • @ntropi9186
    @ntropi9186 5 лет назад +2

    LeFt WiNg uNiTe
    All talk and no action

  • @theshakhrayist7649
    @theshakhrayist7649 Год назад

    The NatCom anthem

  • @user-si1wp4wq8n
    @user-si1wp4wq8n 3 года назад +1

    Agorism isn’t left leaning it’s right