Brave & well worth the time to listen. Just amazed at all the plastic unique instruments. I can’t imagine the skill needed to tune these instruments, especially the sax. I make mistakes in my performances and work them into a routine. Most people appreciate talents such as these young people. Keep on! You are great!
some of the instruments sound good the aerophone doesnt really make sound too much, its usually a midi instrument btw. it has speakers, but those are not its main features and the clarineo and jsax are meant for beginners who need to learn the basics on a cheap instrument first
Well, these are obviously very capable musicians getting all they can out of the instruments. And yes, there are intonation problems. But the true purpose of many of the plastic instruments is to affordably help children get involved in playing a musical instruments. Considering they can take a beating by children, all things considered, they are fairly decent.
i think it's more that the quality of plastic instruments varies kinda widely (and it's ofc hard to tell how much of that has to do with the skill level of the players). for example, the yamaha venova and tiger instruments sound quite nice to my ears, but the nuvo jsax is pretty bad. personally im surprised how good the intonation is in general on these, considering how cheap most of them are.
Yes, there are no short-cuts to music even with amazing plastic contrivances like the jSax and Venova. You still must practice. They both have real reed mouthpieces to control.
That's a shame about jSax because most of Amazon reviewers say that jSax feels much easier to play in tune than Venova, and some of them returned Venova to keep jSax. But in other jSax videos it sounds much better.
I wonder if they're all intonated for the same A. You can tune each instrument a few cents to get to the same A, but then intonation inevitably suffers.
TakatoEndou | The tiger brass brass instruments sound good. At least compared to most plastic brass. Edit: referring to the quality of the brand itself.
@@mr.starfish4965 Should we even bother to compare plastic brass-type instruments when any competent actual brass one sounds better than the best plastic?
1) Tiger Amazing sound quality assuming your products weren't electric or synth'd? 2) Yamaha Venova 3) Nuvo Melt that plastic down into something worth while, like pen caps. The sound on these instruments isn't just "slightly off" but way off.
@@drogoburrows8805 Yeah, from what I've briefly researched they seem to go for around the 350 dollar mark. At that price, you could very easily find an excellent Yamaha YTR student model, or you might be able to stretch and find a old Stradivarius or Xeno precursor. I mean, my Strad flugel only cost me £400 so that's not that far off. Plastic instruments in general are definitely faddy.
tiger is a really good plastic brass brand, and brass instruments sound ain't that reliant on the material they're made of compared to woodwinds also the clarineo or the j sax dont use real wood reeds, but rather plastic proprietary ones, that are way more out of tune than a normal wood reed like the one on the yamaha venova, that's why the venova sound good too but yeah plastic brass is usually not as horrible than plastic woodwinds hope that solves ur question
@@pollosasadosalcarbon The timbre of a brass instrument is very much impacted by the material of construction. There are three predominant types of brass used - independently or in combination with one another - precisely because they alter the tonality of the instrument.
What a wonderfully horrid idea. It's hard enough to play on good instruments. I commend the young lady on Trombone though..... that's a really challenging solo.... and plastic horns don;t respond in that octave nearly as well as brass. A very good effort for such a young group. I've heard pros play it worse.
I Really want to support the idea of this orchestra. But you need to tune to someone who will not slide in pitch. Or maybe you were nervous, that is Fine Keep going, and Good Luck to you, guys!
The idea is great ... Nuvo Sax, the tuning was a little unstable ... it could be the plastic reed, or the original Jsax mouthpiece is not very regular! You need to improve this issue on Jsax, if you could put a mouthpiece by Soprano Sax, maybe the sound improves ... Venova was great, but I realized that the mouthpiece is not the original of the instrument, it looks like a soprano sax mouthpiece combined with a bamboo reed ... this makes a lot of difference ... the other instruments were good !!!
You all seem like fine players, and I’ll give it a thumbs up for the experiment. There is clearly a reason that orchestras don’t use plastic instruments. I am disturbed that so many people seem impressed with the sound of the plastic. No offense if you’re someone that likes the tone, but I think you haven’t heard enough instrumental music to know what you’re missing. Thank you all for confirming my impression of plastic instruments.
Ist that the best you can give? So I visited your Channel, and NO you can perform EXTRAORDINARILY well on conventional instruments! So this shows what good musicians can do with plastic intstuments and what plastic intruments can't in the hands of good musicians. Although this ist kinda funny, keep going on :-)
Sinceramente la flauta sonaba bastante bien.. aunque no es comparable a la real creo que es un gran paso adelante para acercar el instrumento a más gente... Venova, basado en un saxo con digitación de flauta dulce... y usando boquilla de saxo alto (aunque creo que era el yvs-100, soprano) es un tremendo instrumento para aprender a hacer vibrar la lengüeta de instrumentos de viento madera 🤷♂️ la genialidad de este instrumento es mayor de lo que a simple vista parece... (Sigue tras clarineo) Clarineo... suena raro raro 🤷♂️ no me gustó nada 🤷♂️ Y aquí viene Venova parte 2: para sacar un sonido más "bello y cromático" al estilo del clarinete... sin que suene a rotura de tímpanos como con el clarineo. Usas "Venova en modo clarinete" ¿Qué es? Para los 3 dedos de arriba, en vez de usar el dedo índice, el dedo corazón y el dedo anular, usas corazón anular y meñique y con el dedo índice bajas una octava al Venova tapando el agujero delantero de eso que sobresale arriba como un tubo hacia el frente con el índice 🤷♂️ Así adquiere un toque cromático más similar al clarinete que al saxo al que imita (sí, imita, ya que no es un saxo, dicho por la propia empresa Yamaha). JSax si soy sincero, he oído en directo a gente que no suena tan francamente mal... aunque la calidad del sonido es paupérrima. Así que supongo que tuvo que sacrificar más en calidad para hacerlo sonar algo más fuerte y lograr ese exquisito equilibrio de volumen y resonancia que tiene la grabación 🤷♂️
これうまい人がやってるから、きれいに聞こえるんだよね。すごいよなぁ、、、
ソロまではギリ何とかなってたけど…なんかいろいろ凄まじくなってって面白かったwww
トランペット柔らかい良い音してるなぁ...
素直にすごいと思った…すげえ…
芸術は爆発である。
見た目といい音といい絶対に笑ってはいけない演奏会みたいなノリで楽しいです
音程合わせるの大変そうですね。
それにしてもここまで本格的な演奏ができるのには驚きました。
tutiiの所でこの世の終わりみたいな音程だけど、個人の技術はすごいし 素晴らしい試みですよね
みんなで吹いた瞬間なんかの儀式かと思った
なかなかクオリティの高いプラ楽器もあれば、おもちゃレベルのものまで・・・w かなり苦戦を強いられていますね。でも、個人的にはプラ楽器の未来に期待したい！
おもちゃ？？？
I remember in 1990's the plastics recorders was from good quality.
なんかもう最後の方神社の笙みたいw
金管は木管に比べたら違和感ないんだよなぁ
面白い〜っ！！！
最初のFluteとVenovaの辺りは「おっ」と思いながら聴いていたのですが、CLARINEOあたりから「ん？」と思い、j-SAXでツボに入りました…その後は、ただただ爆笑です！
でもリズム感とか音量のバランスとかは綺麗だったので「本来の楽器」だと腕の立つ方なのでしょうね。
やり過ぎて音感狂いませんように…合掌
技術は素晴らしい方ばかりなのでしょうが、サックスは楽器本体が…(；´Д`)
結果
普通の楽器が一番いい
途中まではまだ堪えれたけど最後の音の合わなさよwww
オーボエ等のダブルリードの楽器とホルンが無かったのが残念。最初のフルートの音色がプラスチックとは思えないほど美しくて、聴きほれた。トロンボーンはかなりきつかったね。トロンボーンには難しい曲だからね。それにしても皆さんプロのかた？素晴らしい演奏だった。
お節介じい
ダブルリードのプラは、オーボエしかないし、日本にはないみたいだから購入困難なため断念
ほかのダブルリード楽器は、プラスチック楽器はないが、樹脂のがっきならあるからプラスチック楽器ではない
音が何より高い...
トロンボーン本物はアルトなんだもん…これをテナーでやれって言うのが
と自分は思う
@@とろろ-p7e アルト管があるんですね、てっきりトロンボーンはソプラノ、テナー、テナーバス、バスぐらいのものかと思ってました
@@ヒロタケトウチ うちの中学にプラ管ありましたよ笑
外見リコーダーの様なのに、クラリネットの様な音色に、感激❗️
クラリネットピッチがものすごく上がってしまうんですね
楽しい演奏です。楽器の材質云々より音楽を楽しむことですね。
これからこれらの楽器の地位と音の品質向上を目指してください。
ﾌﾟﾗｽﾁｯｸのｸﾗ、ちょっと吹かせてもらったことあるけど、普通のやつに比べて吹きにくすぎた、（笑）
プラスチックのクラリネットとかサックスはやっぱりなんか本物と違って音が変すぎる笑笑
Brave & well worth the time to listen. Just amazed at all the plastic unique instruments. I can’t imagine the skill needed to tune these instruments, especially the sax.
I make mistakes in my performances and work them into a routine. Most people appreciate talents such as these young people. Keep on! You are great!
個人のレベル高すぎてわかんないのもある
すご…
half the instruments sound like oboes
out of tune oboes
And what's wrong with that LOL. #OboesRule
oddly true
Regarding the instruments they are playing on this is quite impressive.
うちの学校みたいww
そんな悲しいこというなよ🥺
音程めっちゃ悪いね()
プラスチックだとやっぱり難しいんだろうな。
後半地獄絵面だけどベースがまともなお陰で聴けるwwww
実にすばらしい芸術家だ！
J sax: oh
Clarineo: yikes
Aerophone: omg
Full band: kill me now!
But it is probably really hard to play in tune
some of the instruments sound good
the aerophone doesnt really make sound too much, its usually a midi instrument btw. it has speakers, but those are not its main features
and the clarineo and jsax are meant for beginners who need to learn the basics on a cheap instrument first
The plastic flutes and plastic trombones are usually pretty decent
The NUVO j-Sax only has 1-1/2 octaves (C to high G in the next octave). Yamaha Venona has 2 full octaves, ,C C and 'C.
Well, these are obviously very capable musicians getting all they can out of the instruments. And yes, there are intonation problems. But the true purpose of many of the plastic instruments is to affordably help children get involved in playing a musical instruments. Considering they can take a beating by children, all things considered, they are fairly decent.
ゆうがたクインテット思い出す
めっちゃ懐いww
Ahhhhhhhhhhh the intonation just gets worse as it keeps going. Lol but this is cool and it's probably really hard to play those things in tune
i think it's more that the quality of plastic instruments varies kinda widely (and it's ofc hard to tell how much of that has to do with the skill level of the players). for example, the yamaha venova and tiger instruments sound quite nice to my ears, but the nuvo jsax is pretty bad. personally im surprised how good the intonation is in general on these, considering how cheap most of them are.
Croix I said in my comment it's probably hard to play them in tune so I understand
Yes, there are no short-cuts to music even with amazing plastic contrivances like the jSax and Venova. You still must practice. They both have real reed mouthpieces to control.
That's a shame about jSax because most of Amazon reviewers say that jSax feels much easier to play in tune than Venova, and some of them returned Venova to keep jSax. But in other jSax videos it sounds much better.
I wonder if they're all intonated for the same A. You can tune each instrument a few cents to get to the same A, but then intonation inevitably suffers.
もうサックスとかリコーダーやん
ユーフォニアム買いたいですね
クラリネオの音程やばいな笑
しょうがないと言えばしょうがないのかな
でも金管は違和感ないなぁ…
The added reverb is strong here
テューバは割といいですな。
Where is the Recorder? That would probably the star
G A L L A R D S FOR REAL
これチューニングできる？w
haha 🤣
ホルンがいない......
ダブルリードにおもちゃ楽器が参入するのはいつになることやら
Your plastic is out of tune
ボレロかー名曲ありがたい
Pitch?!
People, people give them a break! They are doing what most of us wish we could do.
Lol you know something is not okay when the Venova is the most decent sounding instrument in your whole orchestra.
well they actually put time and effort into the venova, unlike the other plastic junk
TakatoEndou | The tiger brass brass instruments sound good. At least compared to most plastic brass.
Edit: referring to the quality of the brand itself.
The player was incredible. Excellent breath control. But venovas are a crime against humanity.
@@mr.starfish4965 Should we even bother to compare plastic brass-type instruments when any competent actual brass one sounds better than the best plastic?
ヴァイブラートサックスも入れて欲しかったなw
wwwこwwwれwwwはwwwひwwwどwwwいwww
けどめちゃくちゃ面白い。最高
プラスチック楽器！？
これはこれでアリ笑
1) Tiger Amazing sound quality assuming your products weren't electric or synth'd? 2) Yamaha Venova 3) Nuvo Melt that plastic down into something worth while, like pen caps. The sound on these instruments isn't just "slightly off" but way off.
how does that trumpet sound so good
Tiger seems to be the only company to make plastic brass sound bearable. Too bad that it's more expensive than most normal trumpets
@@drogoburrows8805 Yeah, from what I've briefly researched they seem to go for around the 350 dollar mark. At that price, you could very easily find an excellent Yamaha YTR student model, or you might be able to stretch and find a old Stradivarius or Xeno precursor. I mean, my Strad flugel only cost me £400 so that's not that far off.
Plastic instruments in general are definitely faddy.
@@kaizokuAUTO absolutely
tiger is a really good plastic brass brand, and brass instruments sound ain't that reliant on the material they're made of compared to woodwinds
also the clarineo or the j sax dont use real wood reeds, but rather plastic proprietary ones, that are way more out of tune than a normal wood reed like the one on the yamaha venova, that's why the venova sound good too
but yeah plastic brass is usually not as horrible than plastic woodwinds
hope that solves ur question
@@pollosasadosalcarbon The timbre of a brass instrument is very much impacted by the material of construction. There are three predominant types of brass used - independently or in combination with one another - precisely because they alter the tonality of the instrument.
Great for practice or traveling, but nothing like the real thing...
Definitely need a recorder
What a wonderfully horrid idea. It's hard enough to play on good instruments.
I commend the young lady on Trombone though..... that's a really challenging solo.... and plastic horns don;t respond in that octave nearly as well as brass.
A very good effort for such a young group. I've heard pros play it worse.
I Really want to support the idea of this orchestra.
But you need to tune to someone who will not slide in pitch.
Or maybe you were nervous, that is Fine
Keep going, and Good Luck to you, guys!
Omg, I am not a pro but i know for sure the J-Sax is out of tune
guineapig the trumpets actually sound very nice
Greetings from Canada. It is very good music. All-plastic!
Is it me, or does a jSax often sound flat??
Sharp
ヴぇノーヴァってこんな奇麗な音出せるんだ
Hahaha, I LOVED this. :D This was an absolute riot. :D
Bravissimi!!! 😀
Awesome
The trumpet actually didn’t sound too bad for plastic
The idea is great ... Nuvo Sax, the tuning was a little unstable ... it could be the plastic reed, or the original Jsax mouthpiece is not very regular! You need to improve this issue on Jsax, if you could put a mouthpiece by Soprano Sax, maybe the sound improves ... Venova was great, but I realized that the mouthpiece is not the original of the instrument, it looks like a soprano sax mouthpiece combined with a bamboo reed ... this makes a lot of difference ... the other instruments were good !!!
音程がバラバラでそれぞれがそれぞれの楽譜を演奏してるだけにしか聞こえない笑
でも面白い！演奏会で使用したいとは思わないけど、プラ楽器も進化していくといいな
うまいけど、
ピッチだけが中学生地区大会くらいに聞こえてしまう
普段ほんとに上手なのに
Intonation! Are the Clarineo and J-Sax not tunable?
Wow that was really good and intense
You all seem like fine players, and I’ll give it a thumbs up for the experiment. There is clearly a reason that orchestras don’t use plastic instruments. I am disturbed that so many people seem impressed with the sound of the plastic. No offense if you’re someone that likes the tone, but I think you haven’t heard enough instrumental music to know what you’re missing. Thank you all for confirming my impression of plastic instruments.
トロンボーン1つキラキラしてたからプラスチック？ (。=｀ω´=)ぇ?って思いながら見てたらちゃんとプラスチックだったw
Remember when Hollywood movies had crazy plastic instruments that looked really fake? Think again.
meanwhile, in the Japanese 4th grade recorder choir....
難しそう...
That was incredible
Aerophoneの前カオスだけど、スペイン的な感じがするから作曲者の解釈通りでおｋ()
The J-Sax player be like "Naw, I don't need to practice for this gig...(2 minutes in...)...Awww shiiii--"
At least the JSax was better than the trombone, who kept hitting the wrong notes.
j-sax……
vibratoにすればよかったのに
Increíble
all i hear are oboes
弘法筆を選ばず、ですね！
6:01
ソロは良いけど、、、
ピッチの調節が口でやりにくそーーーーな感じの音がもう至る所に…笑
金管がんばれーーーってなった笑笑
もうtuttiは、雅楽ほどピッチがあってない(雅楽が下手とは言ってない)
Beautiful. I've subscribed; God Bless : )
Nice
They forgot about recorders :-:
材質はどうでもよい、音色は元の楽器のものを開発していただきたい
Ist that the best you can give? So I visited your Channel, and NO you can perform EXTRAORDINARILY well on conventional instruments! So this shows what good musicians can do with plastic intstuments and what plastic intruments can't in the hands of good musicians. Although this ist kinda funny, keep going on :-)
Definitely an interesting experiment, but would I want to see a philharmonic's instruments replaced with plastic replicas?
Hell to the no!
Toychestra
jsaxの音が悪い
ホルンてプラスチックのないんですか？
1212 nachi あります
プレイテックのがあったはずです。(ただあんまり評価は…)
二つ目の楽器コールアングレかと思ったw
プラスチックだとsoloはいいけど、ハーモニーがあんまり得意じゃなさそう、って印象です。
メイン楽器以外にちょっとお試しでやってみたい楽器はプラスチック買ってみてもいいかも
Sinceramente la flauta sonaba bastante bien.. aunque no es comparable a la real creo que es un gran paso adelante para acercar el instrumento a más gente...
Venova, basado en un saxo con digitación de flauta dulce... y usando boquilla de saxo alto (aunque creo que era el yvs-100, soprano) es un tremendo instrumento para aprender a hacer vibrar la lengüeta de instrumentos de viento madera 🤷♂️ la genialidad de este instrumento es mayor de lo que a simple vista parece... (Sigue tras clarineo)
Clarineo... suena raro raro 🤷♂️ no me gustó nada 🤷♂️
Y aquí viene Venova parte 2: para sacar un sonido más "bello y cromático" al estilo del clarinete... sin que suene a rotura de tímpanos como con el clarineo. Usas "Venova en modo clarinete" ¿Qué es? Para los 3 dedos de arriba, en vez de usar el dedo índice, el dedo corazón y el dedo anular, usas corazón anular y meñique y con el dedo índice bajas una octava al Venova tapando el agujero delantero de eso que sobresale arriba como un tubo hacia el frente con el índice 🤷♂️
Así adquiere un toque cromático más similar al clarinete que al saxo al que imita (sí, imita, ya que no es un saxo, dicho por la propia empresa Yamaha).
JSax si soy sincero, he oído en directo a gente que no suena tan francamente mal... aunque la calidad del sonido es paupérrima. Así que supongo que tuvo que sacrificar más en calidad para hacerlo sonar algo más fuerte y lograr ese exquisito equilibrio de volumen y resonancia que tiene la grabación 🤷♂️
キッツイはこれｗｗｗ