YT192 Responding to Critics: More Questions about the Marvelous Quran Channel. Was Jesus Fallible?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 2 фев 2025

Комментарии • 96

  • @hafeezrq
    @hafeezrq День назад +24

    Salamun Alaikum, Can I say that the scholarship of last 14 centuries has just made our biases and predilections stronger enough that stops us to look into or search for truth. I mean that our Iblees has become so powerful that even we can't dare to turn towards/think about truth! Very very sad situation. May Allah SWT open our chests to The Truth. Jazaj Allah Khairun Kaseerun

  • @najibamerkhail6254
    @najibamerkhail6254 День назад +13

    May Allah gives you good health and energy to continue this benevolent and pious mission for all believers of faith.

  • @naimaamghar818
    @naimaamghar818 День назад +10

    Alhamdulillahh!
    Thank you very much Dr.Hany. May Allahh protect us from all evil.

  • @abubakarahmed5072
    @abubakarahmed5072 День назад +11

    This segment is nothing short of Historic! Thank you Dr. Hany. Hopefully, more people will listen

  • @philleaskat4445
    @philleaskat4445 День назад +11

    Salaamun alaykum.
    Alhamdulillahh,
    Those two sessions : Responding to critics, are really necessary and of great value.
    Thank you .
    May Allahh Rabb el 3alameen guide us all to serate al Mustaqeem.

  • @Swan-atl
    @Swan-atl День назад +9

    SA Dr Hany, thank you for your tireless efforts. Alhamdulillah! Allahh alone.

  • @eliaskondi1722
    @eliaskondi1722 20 часов назад +6

    Listening to your lectures is my greatest satiafaction. Do not stop, brother. The path is not easy, but it becomes so by the help of the Almighty. Love

  • @bulozar
    @bulozar 17 часов назад +3

    The Truth illuminates the perceptive, yet blinds the belying...privileged to be here & now. Thank you Dr. Hany for being scrupulous. Alhamdulillahi rabbul ālemiyn.

  • @nassiriabraham
    @nassiriabraham День назад +7

    Alhamdulillah, the presentation is watertight, we are really learning the true history along the way, and it makes sense alot.

  • @munahassen4815
    @munahassen4815 День назад +9

    Alhamdulilahh Alhamdulilahh ❤️ ❤️
    Amazing segment, and may Allahh by his mercy grant them the ability to head to and accept the truth that is based on evidence and expand their chest and understanding overcome the biases that's holding them back. ربنا اشرح صدورهم للحق وثبت قلوبنا على حكمك. الحمد لله رب العلمين ❤❤❤❤

  • @Jasia-bh7ou
    @Jasia-bh7ou День назад +7

    Love your compassion and courage as always dr .Hany as you share AL Haq with your Ahl 💗

  • @ishtiaqmiraj1853
    @ishtiaqmiraj1853 День назад +7

    Alhamdulillah! precise and to the point. Dr. Hani, you hit the nail on the head with the logical arguments and the narrations.

  • @navshams4676
    @navshams4676 14 часов назад +2

    Thank you Dr. Hany.
    May Allahh keep using you to do this great work inshaAllahh

  • @ZAKRIBAHARUDIN
    @ZAKRIBAHARUDIN День назад +7

    Salaamun aleykum
    Let’s spread this channel far and wide to wake up humanity, both alive and those in the afterlife. It’s the least we can do.

  • @mustafamohammad3081
    @mustafamohammad3081 13 часов назад +2

    Alhamdulillah
    It's really a powerful segment loaded with insights

  • @A.A-f5l
    @A.A-f5l День назад +8

    Alhamdulilah. Thank you for your courage. No more blindly following.

  • @izufami
    @izufami День назад +8

    Salamun Alaykum. Thank you for the wonderful session.

  • @abdulnasir4589
    @abdulnasir4589 11 часов назад +1

    Salaamun alaykum Dr. Hany for this Q&A sessions, very straight forward and candor, no shugar coating of words. The truth is out and those who keep renting their kursi to hawaa should have no excuse but pay attention to the seraatul mustaqeem and the MQ. AlhamdulilLahh

  • @AwwalMuslimiin
    @AwwalMuslimiin День назад +7

    alamun Alaykum. Alhamdulilah Thank you so much DH

  • @rahmahnoordin8024
    @rahmahnoordin8024 День назад +5

    Salaamun Alaykum. Thanks Dr Hany. Eye-opening.

  • @aforrest233
    @aforrest233 21 час назад +3

    Alhamdulillah. Another segment that will change lives of those who are humble enough to listen and reflect. Thank you for your hard work Dr Hany

  • @rahmahnoordin8024
    @rahmahnoordin8024 День назад +7

    Salaamun Alaykum. Thank you v much. Very enlightening.

  • @A6A114
    @A6A114 День назад +7

    Salaamun alaikum, Alhamdulillahh.❤

  • @Caddy55
    @Caddy55 12 часов назад +3

    Feel like crying after listening to this lecture . What have been practicing all these years ?Allah forgive us .

  • @barakagerngross1353
    @barakagerngross1353 День назад +4

    جزاك الله خيرا، as always applauding the courage

  • @HlupoChish
    @HlupoChish День назад +10

    Alhamdulilahi Rabbil Alamin!

  • @Eeman.2205
    @Eeman.2205 7 часов назад +1

    MāShāAllāh
    Thanks a lot Dr Hany

  • @raf982
    @raf982 День назад +5

    Alhamdulillah. It is up to the followers of the Israelite channel, college, or university to decide where they should acquire their knowledge. They and their followers no longer have any excuse. They should either ask their teachers or conduct their own investigations

  • @ShamshadJavali
    @ShamshadJavali День назад +5

    Alhamdulillah! Thank you for your excellent effort to guide us to follow the truth.

  • @hand4529
    @hand4529 День назад +5

    Salaamun Alaykum Alhamdulillah thank you so much for everything

  • @LegendaryJoshua
    @LegendaryJoshua День назад +6

    Praise to Allahh, who has guided us to this; and we would never have been guided if Allahh had not guided us. Certainly, the messengers of our Lord had come with the truth.

  • @arrctqw1600
    @arrctqw1600 День назад +8

    Alhamdulillahi Rabbil Alamin!

  • @dajohndina9437
    @dajohndina9437 День назад +4

    Salaamun alaykum. Excellent thank you very much.

  • @mansooramlay5200
    @mansooramlay5200 День назад +4

    Salaamun alaykum beloved Tayr ❤ Looking good Maashallah and Alhamdulillah Thank you another beautiful segment we will await for prt 3of3 Inshaa Allah

  • @umaribnralphbarnett3416
    @umaribnralphbarnett3416 День назад +2

    Alhamdulillaah, very powerful lecture, also showing powerful connviction and certainity on the topics discussed. The door of truth is opening for those who follow thru with deeper on what has been said in this lecture.

  • @maaat68
    @maaat68 День назад +6

    ٱلْحَمْدُ لِلَّهِ ٱلَّذِى هَدَىٰنَا لِهَـٰذَا وَمَا كُنَّا لِنَهْتَدِىَ لَوْلَآ أَنْ هَدَىٰنَا ٱللَّهُ ۖ لَقَدْ جَآءَتْ رُسُلُ رَبِّنَا بِٱلْحَقِّ

  • @norsiahabdgapar4183
    @norsiahabdgapar4183 День назад +2

    Alhamdulillah! another great presentation. Thank you Dr Hany.

  • @saripjayadi7515
    @saripjayadi7515 7 часов назад +1

    Salaamun alaykum Dr. Hani. Alhamdulillahhi robbil 3alamiin.Thank you for sharing the 3ilm and exposing the wrong erroneous interpretation and tafseer.

  • @rahidkhondker1596
    @rahidkhondker1596 22 часа назад +2

    Thank you Dr. Hany for another amazing segment!

  • @s.s.5311
    @s.s.5311 День назад +3

    Alhamdulillah. Thank you for your excellent and clear lectures. Salaamun alaykum.

  • @omarmy3495
    @omarmy3495 День назад +2

    ALHAMDULILLAH.
    Even in summary of various previous MQ episodes, it is still refreshing to listen to. Unprecedented and still the most progressive scholarly endeavour about the inner dimensions of the text of Qur'an in modern times.

  • @umarmuhammad1608
    @umarmuhammad1608 День назад +5

    Salaamun 'alaikum
    Alhamdulillaah
    Still strugling for not becoming blind follower

  • @harunzm97
    @harunzm97 День назад +3

    salaamun3alaikum alhamdulillah ... your thoughts initiated deep insights for the new era of human awareness ... thank you dr hany

  • @semakulaatibu4564
    @semakulaatibu4564 19 часов назад +3

    Salamun alaikum and thanks for all ❤❤❤

  • @vxzvcsv5783
    @vxzvcsv5783 21 час назад +4

    Amazing thanks.

  • @EngineerF-94
    @EngineerF-94 22 часа назад +2

    Salamun3alzkum Dr.
    Such a nice overview of past years. May Allah increase and bless you in multiples.
    Thank you.

  • @davidvargas5277
    @davidvargas5277 7 часов назад +1

    Salaamun alaykum, the evidence is right here and there is no better time to be a witness to the truth.❤

  • @moedot7
    @moedot7 День назад +2

    Salaamun Alaykum. Alhumdulillah another presentation which answered many common questions. Thank you

  • @naeyeransari4974
    @naeyeransari4974 День назад +4

    Salaamun Alaykum,
    Dr.Hany, thank you so much for explaining everything clearly and candidly. Through these clear explanations, it is super easy for anyone to understand the difference between right and wrong, what Allahh is saying in his book, what the corrupt manufactured books are saying, what our so-called scholars learned and taught us in all the Tasseer and translations of the Quran-everything you are putting on the screen and explaining. If people don’t want to understand these clear explanations with the proof before them, they decide not to understand, see, hear, and look at the truth. They want to live a dumb life and die as blind followers of Islam as their dumb and blind scholars who don’t understand anything themselves and teach to millions. I feel sorry for the blind followers if they don’t learn Islam and the Quran correctly before they die and go to Allahh as blind followers of their blind scholars.

  • @semracalik3040
    @semracalik3040 15 часов назад +1

    SA, thank you so much for ‘exposing’ that narration about the letter that the prophet was not allowed to write… shocking narration

  • @wantanamera9939
    @wantanamera9939 22 часа назад +2

    Salamun Alaykum. Alhamdulillah. May Allah protect us from evils & wrong path.

  • @al-ayattv8559
    @al-ayattv8559 19 часов назад +2

    Salaamun Alaikum,
    Alhamdulillahh, Marvelous Reminder!!!
    No way it is easy what you are doing without the Special Support from Allahh.

  • @arifabegum_7547
    @arifabegum_7547 День назад +2

    Salaamun Alaykum.
    Alhamdhulillahh.
    Jazakkum Allahhu Khair.

  • @drmdzakariahmdali6677
    @drmdzakariahmdali6677 День назад +8

    Alhamdulillah

  • @badshahali204
    @badshahali204 День назад +3

    Alhumdulillah Dr.Hany, looking forward to you addressing more of the pressing issues that we as muslims are facing on a day to day basis required by us through the traditions as part of Islam attributed to the teaching of Our messenger.Now that you mentioned that the Quran allows 4 marriages please make a vedio
    Addressing Marriage in Al Islam as per the Quran.

  • @RafiqulIslam-wr5lw
    @RafiqulIslam-wr5lw День назад +2

    Salamun alikum , excellent explanation

  • @raf982
    @raf982 6 часов назад +1

    A new breed of scholars who have made a career in interfaith dialogue or have profited by counterfeiting Quranic verses to incorporate their lack of understanding, along with the Muslim biblio scholars, need to ask themselves whether they will stop or continue misguiding others

  • @farr8043
    @farr8043 День назад +5

    Very few will follow the correct path...This has been proven true after so many Prophets before. Do you think currently the Muslims are following the correct path? Very few from later generations will be on the correct path. So true guidance comes from Allahh the creator of the universe. You are decreed with what you seek from Allahh with full conviction. The fact that the "so called scholars of Islam" have not been forthcoming to challenge, debate, discuss or to clarify this understanding of MQ is really mind blowing. Why are they holding tight to tradition??? We should request a public discussion with these so called experts of the tradition with MQ.

    • @dyharima1436
      @dyharima1436 23 часа назад

      there hadith about 73 door .. only one that correct

  • @ramla-y4r
    @ramla-y4r 8 часов назад +1

    "Salamun Alaikum, I truly appreciate your sincere hard work. Many of the explanations you deliver are similar to what I’ve heard from Saidalavi Ansari Sir. He clearly explains who or what Abu Lahab refers to and who ‘Abasa Watawalla refers to on his RUclips channels, Quran Manavam and Quranist Kerala. He also explains all the prophets mentioned in the Qur'an and what each represents within us. Although his lectures are in Malayalam, he speaks Arabic as well. It would be wonderful if Dr. Hany could reach out to him for a meaningful discussion on Qur'anic matters. His explanation of the Qur'an is one of the most practical and beautiful I’ve ever heard."

  • @yaseenbanda4515
    @yaseenbanda4515 День назад +2

    الحمد لله الذي هدانا لهذا وما كنا لنهتدي لولا ان هدانا الله لقد جاءت رسل ربما بالحق

  • @cybon1
    @cybon1 День назад +3

    💯. Couldn't agree more.

  • @sinamehrparvar
    @sinamehrparvar День назад +9

    Salaamun Alaykum, when the evidences speaks for themselves, when the truth reigns, when everything is becoming clearer and clearer with every presentation by Dr Hany, then what is preventing people to accept THE TRUTH? Be critical thinkers and do not be afraid to empty your cups (your previous understandings and knowledge) to be able to unlearn and relearn new and correct things with the divine rain from Allahh, Just use your rational ability to weigh the evidences presented in all of these 192 segments , and Insha'Allahh all of you will reach the inevitable conclusion that yeah the 1400 years of scholarship means nothing if it proven by the Quran that they are wrong, end of the story . Be courageous and take side with the Truth.

  • @mangolian
    @mangolian 12 часов назад +1

    Keep chipping away at the remnants of demagoguery of Dr Hany. Much appreciated. Alhamdullilah

  • @mahmudbejani9648
    @mahmudbejani9648 4 часа назад

    Dr. Hany you are on the right path. Despite I disagree in some cases with you, but your work is great. I always make Dua for you and all Muslims that work for Truth and Quran and Allah and Humankind.

  • @ammadkhan7228
    @ammadkhan7228 13 часов назад +1

    There's this Australian cartoon Islamic show with a polar bear. They're talking about Surah Al- Fil. They claim to have the name of the guy attacking the Kaaba and the name of the elephant 😂

  • @Zack-qq1de
    @Zack-qq1de 10 часов назад +2

    Alhamdulillah.

  • @hamdiali8872
    @hamdiali8872 23 часа назад +1

    Its an eye opening rereshing, taking as back to the Prophet's time via the quran Alhamdullilah.

  • @semracalik3040
    @semracalik3040 День назад +2

    Salaamun alaykum,
    Thank you

  • @Truthandjusticeforever
    @Truthandjusticeforever 21 час назад +2

    Spot on!

  • @seekingknowledgesister5318
    @seekingknowledgesister5318 День назад +2

    Thank you

  • @manila656
    @manila656 День назад +1

    I’m so agree with you about the stores in the Quran

  • @motivateuganda7794
    @motivateuganda7794 День назад +2

    Alhamdulillah, truly 💖Alhamdulillah ❤

  • @sekai7378
    @sekai7378 День назад +5

    Alhamdullilah

  • @amjadshoki4600
    @amjadshoki4600 17 часов назад +2

    Alhamdulillahh..

  • @Wereview_by_salman
    @Wereview_by_salman 44 минуты назад

    Amazing! Waiting for part 3. If possible kindly include one of my small researches ( if found worthy) to your next stream. And it is about your video on Did Prophet Coveted Zainab r.a.
    Dr Hany I was shocked when 1. I went on researching about the Zayd and Zainab r.a marriage dispute issue which they( scholars) claim was due to sharp tongue of Zainab and her being boastful of her class against Zayd ( ex slave), but I couldn't find a single acceptable report which suggest such bad words for her character.
    2. They scholars have used almost all data in this issue from history, and same history suggest that Zayd has already married 4 times before marrying to Zainab r.a
    Zayd married to cousin of Khadija r.a, daughter of Abu lahab(ended up in divorce), niece of Uthman Caliph, and ex slave of Hz Abu Talib aka care take of Prophet when he was in teen i.e umm Ayman whom Prophet used to call her mother and respected like her mother. Moreover Zayd have the only child from Ummeed Ayman, uthama bin zayd.
    They( scholars) claim that without evidence Prophet made marriage between zayd and zainab to send a message of equality in society as she was from noble lineage.
    I mean how it can be true of considering history, zayd's earlier marriage with upper class women already ended in divorce.
    Also, why would prophet keep on marrying zayd with every women when umm Ayman, his dear one already happily married with a children?
    This all exposes their false defenses.
    3. They( scholars) says that Prophet took care of zayd from his childhood, but the fact is Zayd died in battle of muta when he was 55 years, and he was actually only 5-7 years younger than Prophet himself, I mean how he could have been brought up as a child.
    Hence we found no single acceptable hadis ( according to their rule) which supports that Prophet himself make him his son.
    4. Shocking is that In a strongest chain In muwatta Malik, the husband of Zainab r.a was abdurrahman bin awf and muhaddis altogether dismissed it as a mistake of muwatta writers because they are sure from tafsir that zainab was married to zayd, though according to their criteria we have not a single clear chain which says they are both married.! Shocking! It's all in tafsir and history!
    After your video, I did this research which increase my faith against their fake scholarship. They are not even standing to their own criteria

  • @muhammedahmed1642
    @muhammedahmed1642 17 часов назад +1

    Masha Allah tabarakallah

  • @salmanmansoor6673
    @salmanmansoor6673 22 часа назад +1

    JAZAKALLAH 🤲❤

  • @zeeshanahmed6161
    @zeeshanahmed6161 День назад +3

    Slamming Alaykum Brother Hani the Hadi you mentioned you could take one more point from it that Muhammad wants to rite something for them and maybe 99% Muslim believe he does not know how to read and rite.

  • @tiaratiarasam1886
    @tiaratiarasam1886 День назад +2

    Surah al baiyinat sums them up...
    ..the kafaru of cohorts of the book and the musyriks will not attain to faith until? Eventhough? There comes to them baiyinat.
    If Allah says it, it is a fulfilled promise.
    If others say it, it could be mawj

  • @khajavaseem5093
    @khajavaseem5093 День назад +1

    Dr Hani can you clarify which of hadees you accept .

  • @Caddy55
    @Caddy55 14 часов назад +1

    🙏

  • @ChadStenberg-c7e
    @ChadStenberg-c7e 9 часов назад

    Thanks for the breakdown! A bit off-topic, but I wanted to ask: My OKX wallet holds some USDT, and I have the seed phrase. (alarm fetch churn bridge exercise tape speak race clerk couch crater letter). How should I go about transferring them to Binance?

  • @AgeOfReconciliation
    @AgeOfReconciliation 19 часов назад +1

    How is tilawa oral recitation if the moon does it?

    • @MarvelousQuran
      @MarvelousQuran  19 часов назад +3

      Aya 91:2: And by the moon (i.e., the prophet) when he recites it (the scripture),

    • @al-ayattv8559
      @al-ayattv8559 18 часов назад

      Pls refer YT127.
      ruclips.net/video/rJmtvvhPeOk/видео.htmlsi=PsEIlwtpBpj0sU4l

    • @AgeOfReconciliation
      @AgeOfReconciliation 17 часов назад +3

      If the prophet is the moon, then Abraham mistakened him for being his lord like he did the sun (6:77)?

  • @MohamedMbarak-e5c
    @MohamedMbarak-e5c 22 часа назад

    I am sorry to disturb u but what about the jinns.

    • @AM-xi4sy
      @AM-xi4sy 19 часов назад +1

      Do u know who are JINNS?

  • @hajaranaduvalath5243
    @hajaranaduvalath5243 12 часов назад

    Salamun Alaikum, "I have listened to several of your lectures on the Marvelous Quran RUclips channel. While I agree with much of your explanation, there are a few points, particularly about Nabi Isa (AS), where I strongly disagree.
    There is a scholar from Kerala, India, named Saidalavi Ansari, who is brilliant when it comes to explaining the Quran. Unfortunately, his lectures are mostly in Malayalam, a language spoken primarily by people in Kerala, which is why I believe he isn't as well-known. However, I am confident that he can communicate in Arabic as well. He has a RUclips channel called 'Quran Manavam.'
    I suggest that you reach out to him. If you work together, you could discuss your ideas on the Quran, and insha'Allah, the light of the Quran will shine even brighter for the world to see."

  • @moniruzzamanmohammad5409
    @moniruzzamanmohammad5409 День назад +6

    Alhamdulillah

  • @asbul321
    @asbul321 Час назад

    Alhamdulillah.

  • @udilahyaw
    @udilahyaw 21 час назад +2

    Alhamdulillah