This song wasn’t actually a soundtrack for this movie. RM couldn’t stop talking about this movie last year, so some ARMYs made this video combining RM’s song and movie footage. RM liked it so much that he posted it and n social media.
Closer is a sexy sad song at the same time. Blanco´s voice is amazing. Closer is my favorite from Indigo. There is a live performance that RM did with Blanco. It is great.
The audio version is better, here in the MV Version the instrument is too loud in my opinion especially the piano, anyway thank you for the reaction, hope you listen to RM full album of Indigo, better listen in order, you also can watch him sing live in NPR Tiny desk home concert or live in Seoul @rollinghall, this album is his Archive of his 20s
Indigo is one of the most wonderful complete no skip albums for me. He found the best collaborators and tried so many genres to tell the story of his 20s.
I love this song!!!! And this movie is absolutely amazing. RM recommended it, at it was splendid. He loved the movie so much and he got permission to use the clip for his song.
the people saying its not a real video clearly do not follow bts closely enough cause this is in fact a real video that namjoon posted on bangtantv he loves this movie and asked to make a trailer of sorts using his song.
Please give RM (Namjoon) a chance. He has many beautiful songs. You can watch “Wildflower” or “Still Life” from his album Indigo or you can watch his earlier works like “Joke” or “Do You.” Namjoon’s lyricism is amazing and I am sure you will love his works. He has very diverse discography.
Enjoy BTS More posted the live from Rolling Hall with subtitiles, although the song is almost entirely in English. Mahalia isn't there, but Paul Blanco is, and he's terrific.
You should watch the live version. This MV was actually in collaboration with the movie Decision to leave. RM has a beautiful singing voice, he has a few songs like this. You should check out the rest of indigo, seoul, bicycle, Tokyo.
Indigo, to me, its a masterpiece. It was my Christmas present last December. 😊 I listen a lot this song, Lonely and nr 2. He recorded Change when he was drunk, his ownTMI info😂
That video you just watched is of the film Decision to Leave. RM did perform this at Rollin Hall which is brilliant by the way. You must listen to RM's album Indigo it is a masterpiece and should be listened in order of the tracklist just as RM wanted us too. Please react to the album. 💜💜💜
Nam es un artista increíble, su musica es arte ÍNDIGO es arte, sus colaboraciones con artistas tan geniales las amo.. esta canción es una de mis favoritas, gracias por reaccionar a closer. Saludos desde Argentina 🇦🇷😘
Just so you know if it's not on BangtanTV or HYBE channel then it's a fan edit MV. A lyric video that uses Doolset or Bangtan Sub translations would have probably been more helpful on who was singing each part. The MV might mislead you as to the feelings RM was trying to convey. This is why usually we don't use fan edits because that may not be what they are saying with the song.
I am sorry but you seem not to know that the MV in this song is not a fan edit. This is an MV of a famous Korean movie titled “Decision To Leave” which Namjoon really loves and has the opportunity to put his music on. I cannot believe you do not know that.
@@teebeee5832 Because I never saw this. I never got the alert for it. And by the amount of thumbs up I'm guessing tons of us missed it. Unlike most BTS videos the views aren't matching the likes so I think people really didn't like the MV, the no subs aren't helping either I think.
@@17cutejaci Yep didn't know. Never got an alert for this MV. The YT alerts for stuff on Bangtan sometimes don't show up when stuff drops. I've even seen stuff and an alert shows up the day after. But no never saw this MV had to go look it up.
closer doesnt have a music video bc its a b-side from the album. only wildflower ft youjeen and still life ft anderson paak have music videos for this album
этот клип создан фанатами на фильм Decision to Leave (2022). RM смотрел его 6 раз, а режиссер фильма в интервью говорил о RM с уважением и благодарностью.
Hope that you can check out RM mini concert "Live at Rolling Hall, Seoul" where he performed all the songs on his latest album INDIGO. He even invited some guests including Paul Blanco whom he had collaborated with on his album.
Maybe you should have heard the audio version/lyric video before watching the MV so you could see and hear the original version and get a feel of the song. The MV itself makes the song seem sadder because "closer" was included in this movie the "MV" is portraying but the song itself isn't particularly sad (reminiscent and poignant maybe but not quite sad)
Indigo is a piece of art, where RM is the artist.. wildflower, no.2, forgetful, still life.... They are good songs. Moonchild is another song that I love from RM, it's not from Indigo but I love it
If you have intrest there (BANGTANTV) is 'RM Indigo album magazine film' where RM and singers/producers talks. Bytheway - Mahalia is british singer/actress. Greetings from the edge of Europe
Hey guys, did you already listen to indigo? RM Album? Maybe you can react on this here or on your patrean...its a really really good, no fantastic and amazing Album. You will like it!😊
If y'all want it to watch him singing that song live you can watch "live in Seoul @ rolling hall" he performed with Paul Blanco, love it, also, being Honest, closer isn't my favorite song in this album, my favorites are forg_tful, hectic y n°2, well the hole album is just a masterpiece, from the others solo proyects, Índigo is my favorite, well all Namjon's solo songs are just awesome
This is the remix. The original is much better imo. Indigo is a masterpiece and RM is a genius musically. Listen to the album, you won’t regret it. It’s the single best grouping of songs that any of BTS has ever done.
Idk why my comment keep disappearing. Maybe it’s too long so let me put it in 2 parts. (1/2) I hope this helps but to clarify this is an official MV that RM did. It’s one of his fave movies. There was a fan made edit (I think that’s what some are referring to) that was posted on Twitter back in Dec with Closer and clips from Decision to Leave it was less than a minute long)
(2/2) RM’s friend Eaeon saw it and sent it to him and RM even posted a clip to his IG stories and said “Eaeon sent me this” Then RM did the collab with Decision to Leave and made the MV. He added lo-fi to the song (that’s why it sounds different). It was uploaded to BangtanTV and his IG posts in February of this year. Hope this helped
Hi I know this is off topic (no pun intended lol) but can yall react to txt? Their in hybe labels like bts some used to call them "bts little brothers" but no one really calls. Them that now and us moas (txt fandom) might not like it bc it can also be put as their success is just from bts and their a copy (which their not) but I hope you check them out!
People saying this is not a real MV clearly do not care or support RM. How could you not know that this video is an official video for Decision to Leave; the movie that RM really loves? He even posted this MV on his IG. Be for real. Shows your true colors.
Theres something wrong in the audio, it just doesnt seem right. Not youres but the video you watched. The live version @RollingHall is the Best version ive heard.🤚
Yes, it is real. RM liked this video so much he wanted to post it as an mv on bangtanv. I think an army made it, but what does it matter? RM loved it and wanted to use it.
RM's Indigo album should be listened to in full. Rolling Hall live concert and music videos for Wildflowers and Still Life
MASTERPIECE
Uppp!
Indigo is the masterpiece😊💜
This song wasn’t actually a soundtrack for this movie. RM couldn’t stop talking about this movie last year, so some ARMYs made this video combining RM’s song and movie footage. RM liked it so much that he posted it and n social media.
So beautiful 💜💜💜😢
RM and Paul Blanco doing this live at Rolling Hall is also great, if you want to take a look 💜
Closer is a sexy sad song at the same time. Blanco´s voice is amazing. Closer is my favorite from Indigo. There is a live performance that RM did with Blanco. It is great.
My favorite song off his Indigo album, which is absolutely a gem! So many great collabs on this album...from Erykah Badu to Anderson Paak and more. 💜
The audio version is better, here in the MV Version the instrument is too loud in my opinion especially the piano, anyway thank you for the reaction, hope you listen to RM full album of Indigo, better listen in order, you also can watch him sing live in NPR Tiny desk home concert or live in Seoul @rollinghall, this album is his Archive of his 20s
He did a live version at rolling hall with a lot of the collarbs there it was fantastic
Closer It's a gem
One of my faves but then again the whole album INDIGO is my favourite 💜
Nooooo. The original version of this is a masterpiece. 😭😭😭
Indigo is one of the most wonderful complete no skip albums for me. He found the best collaborators and tried so many genres to tell the story of his 20s.
I love this song!!!! And this movie is absolutely amazing. RM recommended it, at it was splendid. He loved the movie so much and he got permission to use the clip for his song.
RM and Paul performed this live at Rolling Hall theater in Seoul. It was 99% English.
the people saying its not a real video clearly do not follow bts closely enough cause this is in fact a real video that namjoon posted on bangtantv he loves this movie and asked to make a trailer of sorts using his song.
Ahhh man I wished it was the live performance at Rolling Hall with Paul Blanco. One of my faves from his album.
RM’s solo album Indigo, is AMAZING!! This is just a sample of how great the entire work is…although ONE of my favorite songs from it. 💜
RM had a live performance of this
Actually it is a concert you can find it at the official Bangtan channel
That is an amazing show💜
BTS RM INDIGO album film Magazine by BANGTANTV.
BTS rm INDIGO concert at Rolling hall.
Please give RM (Namjoon) a chance. He has many beautiful songs. You can watch “Wildflower” or “Still Life” from his album Indigo or you can watch his earlier works like “Joke” or “Do You.” Namjoon’s lyricism is amazing and I am sure you will love his works. He has very diverse discography.
Indigo is a really special album to me!!!
Indigo is ART! thank you, Namjoon!
RM live at Rolling Hall has Paul live but not thw lady if you want to see it. 💜
Gracias por reaccionar a closer nuestro namjoon nos dio esta hermosa canción junto mahalia paul blanco, en general el álbum Indigo es increíble ❤
Maybe try the audio version, it’s better. They made some changes to it.
Aside from that tho, RM’s Indigo is honestly AMAZING
Watch the live verision its soooo good 😭😭😍😍 then you see them both singing together (paul and RM)
Yes watch RM in concert at Rolling Hall live!
Indigo is just SO GOOOOOOOOOD!
Enjoy BTS More posted the live from Rolling Hall with subtitiles, although the song is almost entirely in English. Mahalia isn't there, but Paul Blanco is, and he's terrific.
I love this song so much my favorite from the indigo album 😊💜💜💜💜
You should watch the live version. This MV was actually in collaboration with the movie Decision to leave.
RM has a beautiful singing voice, he has a few songs like this. You should check out the rest of indigo, seoul, bicycle, Tokyo.
Indigo pure art of masterpiece 💜
Please watch the original. Also there is a live version of RM and Paul Branco.
Indigo, to me, its a masterpiece. It was my Christmas present last December. 😊 I listen a lot this song, Lonely and nr 2. He recorded Change when he was drunk, his ownTMI info😂
This movie is really good title is "Decision to Leave" RM's fave
Definitely watch the perfromace by rm and Paul balance at rolling hall live seoul
So so so beautiful 😢💜💜💜✌️
This isnt the original version of the song. The music is much more muffled than the original studio version.
I hit like for my President, Kim Namjoon.
❤❤❤
That video you just watched is of the film Decision to Leave. RM did perform this at Rollin Hall which is brilliant by the way. You must listen to RM's album Indigo it is a masterpiece and should be listened in order of the tracklist just as RM wanted us too. Please react to the album. 💜💜💜
Nam es un artista increíble, su musica es arte ÍNDIGO es arte, sus colaboraciones con artistas tan geniales las amo.. esta canción es una de mis favoritas, gracias por reaccionar a closer. Saludos desde Argentina 🇦🇷😘
Just so you know if it's not on BangtanTV or HYBE channel then it's a fan edit MV. A lyric video that uses Doolset or Bangtan Sub translations would have probably been more helpful on who was singing each part. The MV might mislead you as to the feelings RM was trying to convey. This is why usually we don't use fan edits because that may not be what they are saying with the song.
I am sorry but you seem not to know that the MV in this song is not a fan edit. This is an MV of a famous Korean movie titled “Decision To Leave” which Namjoon really loves and has the opportunity to put his music on. I cannot believe you do not know that.
@@17cutejaci this
nope this is a real video not sure why you think its not its literally on bangtantv.
@@teebeee5832 Because I never saw this. I never got the alert for it. And by the amount of thumbs up I'm guessing tons of us missed it. Unlike most BTS videos the views aren't matching the likes so I think people really didn't like the MV, the no subs aren't helping either I think.
@@17cutejaci Yep didn't know. Never got an alert for this MV. The YT alerts for stuff on Bangtan sometimes don't show up when stuff drops. I've even seen stuff and an alert shows up the day after. But no never saw this MV had to go look it up.
He has a performance indigo in Seoul concert with Paul Blanco.
Lo que veis es la película favorita de Rm. La ha visto un montón de veces. Indigo es una joya
The live version of rm and Paul Blanco is much much better🥰👍
closer doesnt have a music video bc its a b-side from the album. only wildflower ft youjeen and still life ft anderson paak have music videos for this album
this is the music video that namjoon posted himself so it is a music video.
этот клип создан фанатами на фильм Decision to Leave (2022). RM смотрел его 6 раз, а режиссер фильма в интервью говорил о RM с уважением и благодарностью.
🇧🇷💜
Next rm change pt 2 pls it's lit ❤
Hope that you can check out RM mini concert "Live at Rolling Hall, Seoul" where he performed all the songs on his latest album INDIGO. He even invited some guests including Paul Blanco whom he had collaborated with on his album.
Maybe you should have heard the audio version/lyric video before watching the MV so you could see and hear the original version and get a feel of the song. The MV itself makes the song seem sadder because "closer" was included in this movie the "MV" is portraying but the song itself isn't particularly sad (reminiscent and poignant maybe but not quite sad)
Please do the lyrics video! The song is slightly different ❤
I love both version. The original and lofi version of this song. Thanks for watching namjoon work.
Indigo is a piece of art, where RM is the artist.. wildflower, no.2, forgetful, still life.... They are good songs.
Moonchild is another song that I love from RM, it's not from Indigo but I love it
Oh i love this. Well actually i love the whole indigo album
Es la película Decision to leave ,la canción forma parte de la banda sonora
If you have intrest there (BANGTANTV) is 'RM Indigo album magazine film' where RM and singers/producers talks. Bytheway - Mahalia is british singer/actress. Greetings from the edge of Europe
The album version is soooooo much better. Amazing base and beat drops in the original. React again!💜
You have to see the movie… speechless. Decision to leave!
Another W vid
Closer obra de arte 💜💜💜💜💜
I think the audio version is better
RM's Live performance of Indigo at Rolling Hall is a must watch.
Here is Closer from that show
ruclips.net/video/0eznlND9ZE0/видео.html
Hey guys, did you already listen to indigo? RM Album? Maybe you can react on this here or on your patrean...its a really really good, no fantastic and amazing Album. You will like it!😊
Something to check out for sure!
I can never get tired of this songg. Pls do react to the original version of the song though
You should have watched the colour coded version it changes from person to person
If y'all want it to watch him singing that song live you can watch "live in Seoul @ rolling hall" he performed with Paul Blanco, love it, also, being
Honest, closer isn't my favorite song in this album, my favorites are forg_tful, hectic y n°2, well the hole album is just a masterpiece, from the others solo proyects, Índigo is my favorite, well all Namjon's solo songs are just awesome
Reaction RM feat Younha winter flower,thank you
The images wete from a KDrama.
The audio version is better!😢
You guys should do a listen party for indigo
This is the remix. The original is much better imo. Indigo is a masterpiece and RM is a genius musically. Listen to the album, you won’t regret it. It’s the single best grouping of songs that any of BTS has ever done.
Idk why my comment keep disappearing. Maybe it’s too long so let me put it in 2 parts.
(1/2) I hope this helps but to clarify this is an official MV that RM did. It’s one of his fave movies.
There was a fan made edit (I think that’s what some are referring to) that was posted on Twitter back in Dec with Closer and clips from Decision to Leave it was less than a minute long)
(2/2) RM’s friend Eaeon saw it and sent it to him and RM even posted a clip to his IG stories and said “Eaeon sent me this”
Then RM did the collab with Decision to Leave and made the MV. He added lo-fi to the song (that’s why it sounds different). It was uploaded to BangtanTV and his IG posts in February of this year.
Hope this helped
i like the original audio version better, this song originally doesnt have an mv. indigo is a masterpiece you should listen to the album
Hi I know this is off topic (no pun intended lol) but can yall react to txt? Their in hybe labels like bts some used to call them "bts little brothers" but no one really calls. Them that now and us moas (txt fandom) might not like it bc it can also be put as their success is just from bts and their a copy (which their not) but I hope you check them out!
People saying this is not a real MV clearly do not care or support RM. How could you not know that this video is an official video for Decision to Leave; the movie that RM really loves? He even posted this MV on his IG. Be for real. Shows your true colors.
Thank you for liking BTS. Think you will enjoy Jungkook’s cover of “Let there be Love”.
You should watch the lyrics ❤ then you will know
To think this MV came about because of ARMY edits is 😂😂😂
The rolling loud performance would have been better 🤧
Watch him at the rolling hill bc this one on the vid is not how the entire instruments and beat sounds
The song nothing to do with the movie... But I recommend the movie too, "Decision to leave", 2022, directed by Park Chan-wook
Theres something wrong in the audio, it just doesnt seem right. Not youres but the video you watched. The live version @RollingHall is the Best version ive heard.🤚
Not a real video. This is fan made
This is a real MV. It was a collab MV with the movie "Decision to Leave".
it IS real though its on bangtantv not fan made namjoon posted it himself.
Yes, it is real. RM liked this video so much he wanted to post it as an mv on bangtanv. I think an army made it, but what does it matter? RM loved it and wanted to use it.
This mv is very distracting to the song. Please watch the live version.
Audio is so bad..im dissapointed colored lyrics version is better. Who recommended this video?
For me the song is ruined really. 🥲 It has a completely different color in lyrics ver ....you guys who recommended them the official mv 🤧