Seam sealing tents - Is it a con?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 22 окт 2024

Комментарии • 61

  • @peterappleton5213
    @peterappleton5213 5 месяцев назад +4

    Totally agree it should be fit for purpose straight away

  • @waitingfortheknock
    @waitingfortheknock 5 месяцев назад +3

    Nope, I wouldn't buy one. Completely agree with you. Next, it'll come in several parts, needle and thread not supplied.

  • @Stealthoperations
    @Stealthoperations 5 месяцев назад +1

    That's why I always stick with my trusty Dutch army tent. All I do every 6 months is to put a good coating of fabsil gold on it. But you have a very valid point. 😊

  • @CliffordShute
    @CliffordShute 5 месяцев назад +2

    Totally agree , i bought a khyam igloo tent back in the early 90's. Cost best part of 300 quid, leaked first weekend away, took it back to the shop and they gave me a tube of seam sealer 😂 after reading the tent instructions ,lets face it who does its a tent after all ! The manufacturer recommended sealing the seams. Ever since that weekend in my new tent/paddling pool, first thing i do now is seam seal a new tent. The Khyam is still going fantastic touring tent for motorcycles, it's opens up like a big spider. Very quick to put up and take down in the rain.

  • @JonStockman82
    @JonStockman82 5 месяцев назад +3

    I've never had to seam seal Eurohike or Vango tents and I've had a few of those. Sometimes expensive isn't always best.

  • @tamirew9247
    @tamirew9247 5 месяцев назад +2

    Agree! I bought a Napier SUV tent for $480 US. Got it out of the box and the very first recommendation was to waterproof and seam seal before use. That little tip was no where in the description. I bought it 2 years ago and still haven’t done it. Makes my blood boil every time I look at that tent still in its bag sneering back at me. It’s a damn large tent too. Can sleep 6 to 8 people with its “sun room.” I bought it that big so I could take the grandkids camping. GRRRR.

  • @benhikescamps
    @benhikescamps 5 месяцев назад +3

    One simple answer: cost.

  • @johanvanbeek7138
    @johanvanbeek7138 5 месяцев назад +2

    It would put me off buying it for sure. The Lanshan pros were all like that.

  • @RealMash
    @RealMash 5 месяцев назад +2

    I just bought a box of Pringles "chips" and set it next to the old one-it was shorter. Checked-the weight was 165 instead of 185 Grams. Same price.
    Same with the tent-they don't seal it, and you have to do it.
    They pocket the cost that they don't have to pay and leave seam sealing for the owner.
    Shrinkflation with Pringles, lowered quality with the tents.
    Record inflation, company profits soaring.
    Something tells me they are out of kilter...

  • @RootsLion
    @RootsLion 5 месяцев назад +3

    totally agree all this seam seal yourself is utter blx price your paying, these things should be ready to use and fit for purpose.... if the floor so flimsy it needs a footprint or tarp under it IT AINT A TENT an if it aint got a decent sized porch with a water proof floor it aint a proper tent... my avon s**ts all over most a these liteweight modern tents,, even if it is twice the dam weight ... a silnylon modern version of the avon 2-3 person would be nice eurohike or watever still do a version of it but very heavy not sil and they added some pretty crap plastic windows n ting mine aint got being 20yr old plus.... . a camo cloudpeak 2 with a decent porch an floor added be gd

  • @AdventureswithJeffandMeeka
    @AdventureswithJeffandMeeka 5 месяцев назад +1

    I have never had an issue with my f2, coleman, or Ozark trail tents. I do take care of them and as most of the are several years old, I do re-waterproof them at the beginning of each season. This, to me, is common sense. I recently have purchased both a OneTigris Tigamen and a Pomoly Chalet 70 pro. Both of them have not leaked. The Chalet has been through some good storms, with high winds and heavy rainfall, the past few weekends, and has held up better than expected.

    • @jim-bob-outdoors
      @jim-bob-outdoors  5 месяцев назад +1

      Agreed, I dont mind doing maintenance on a old tent. Not doing it on a new one that I have paid good money for.

  • @paganoutdoors3193
    @paganoutdoors3193 5 месяцев назад +2

    Completely agree, why I don't have any lol, tarps all the way

  • @pjboutdoors3230
    @pjboutdoors3230 5 месяцев назад +4

    Exactly my thinking Jim bob

  • @stevesmith5717
    @stevesmith5717 5 месяцев назад +1

    Totally agree with you on that.
    Especially the price of some of them

  • @ChrisWoutdoors
    @ChrisWoutdoors 5 месяцев назад +1

    Spot on Allan, watched a video the other day from Outdoor Gear Review and he had to seal it himself....Madness.

    • @jim-bob-outdoors
      @jim-bob-outdoors  5 месяцев назад +1

      I am never going to do it Chris, if I pay for a tent I want it to work out the box when new. 👍

  • @peesua
    @peesua 5 месяцев назад +4

    I've never understood it either. However, plenty of people are influenced by RUclipsrs and certain products seem to become a 'craze.'
    A point in this case is the Lanshan. Not fully waterproof straight out of the box and appears a little flimsy yet everyone seems to have one. By comparison, the OneTigris Tangram was fully waterproof out of the box, was a little more solid in construction and had a variety of features in the way you could set it up. Weighted slightly more and a bigger pack size - and this may be a reason punters were put off as many are obsessed with shedding grams. The Tangram has not sold anywhere near the amounts that Lanshan has. It's a mystery to me as the Tangram was often around £110 on Amazon at the time the Lanshan was creeping up to the £200 mark.
    My first tent when I got back into camping 5 years ago was a Robens Starlight for the very reason you highlight. It still performs brilliantly in rain and wind, and that's what you hope for when purchasing a 'shelter.'

    • @Helen-and-Katarin-Juska-law
      @Helen-and-Katarin-Juska-law 5 месяцев назад

      Totally agree...to many sheeples following the 'latest', 'best', 'recommended' 'experts' and not thinking for themselves. And 'it's 10 grams lighter so has to be best'. 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

  • @Billofthenorth1
    @Billofthenorth1 5 месяцев назад +1

    Tents, tarps and rain gear all seem to have that problem, well many of them do. But I agree, the manufacturer is in the best position to affect the best seal. Why should we have to do it? They'll probably charge us a lot more for a "professionally seam sealed" bit of kit.

  • @Helen-and-Katarin-Juska-law
    @Helen-and-Katarin-Juska-law 5 месяцев назад +2

    Agree completely - if a tent is likely to leak on the seams (or anywhere else) straight from the box then it is not fit for purpose and should be returned. Surely, in UK at least the Sale of Goods Act must come into play at some point??? Personally we think it is out-doors company's screwing the purchaser's over to make extra profit. The claims of '5000 mm hydrostatic head' should also add 'IF you seam seal' - so,questionable advertising too ?? Take care, Helen and Katarin Juska-Law and Terri with Robyn.

    • @jim-bob-outdoors
      @jim-bob-outdoors  5 месяцев назад

      Spot on. 👍

    • @southcoastoutdoorsuk6301
      @southcoastoutdoorsuk6301 5 месяцев назад

      It’s in the description when you buy a tent , many brands such as 3ful , Tarptent , OEX , Terranova , Weschel it can’t be done by machine , it also allows to use higher quality materials such as double siliconised silnylon which cannot be taped on the seams , it’s not a big deal

    • @Helen-and-Katarin-Juska-law
      @Helen-and-Katarin-Juska-law 5 месяцев назад

      @@southcoastoutdoorsuk6301 If the tent is not weatherproof out of the box then it is not fit for purpose...it is that simple. If a manufacturer uses material that does not perform as the end product should then they are either scamming their customers, don't care about customers or are making excessive profits out of customers. In any of the three options above the answer is simple....do not buy their products. Incidentally you instance OEX as a not-taped tent supplier but our Bobcat 1's are all seam taped as delivered.
      Sadly it is getting more and more prevalent that manufacturers seem to be getting away with selling inferior products - why? because people with your attitude let them - the 'no big deal' attitude simply encourages that mindset..

  • @johncrouch8988
    @johncrouch8988 5 месяцев назад +1

    I’ve never seam sealed a tent in 40 years and I’ve still not had a problem with leaks through the seams. All inexpensive tents too with seam seal included!🤷‍♂️

  • @paulmackenzie1572
    @paulmackenzie1572 5 месяцев назад +1

    I do agree that it should be sealed in the factory. It does rather feel your getting something that's not finished. Next they'll be giving you a needle and thread and getting you to sow the tent your self 😄

  • @michaelme491
    @michaelme491 5 месяцев назад +1

    I agree, if the tent is not sealed against the elements then do not purchase it.

  • @shez81
    @shez81 5 месяцев назад +1

    I think they should come seam sealing myself like specially at the prices for tents nowadays

  • @NaturesSolitude
    @NaturesSolitude 5 месяцев назад +1

    I’m with you on that Allan, I wanted to buy the Lanshan last year until I saw I had to seam seal it myself, when I found that out and saw the price I said they can keep it.

    • @southcoastoutdoorsuk6301
      @southcoastoutdoorsuk6301 5 месяцев назад +1

      Grab the standard model they are taped as it’s sil/pu coatings 👍

    • @NaturesSolitude
      @NaturesSolitude 5 месяцев назад +1

      @@southcoastoutdoorsuk6301 I’ll go and check them out, cheers mate 👍🏻

    • @southcoastoutdoorsuk6301
      @southcoastoutdoorsuk6301 5 месяцев назад +1

      Try Outdoor Gear Essentials Uk based next day delivery 👍

    • @NaturesSolitude
      @NaturesSolitude 5 месяцев назад +1

      @@southcoastoutdoorsuk6301 I will do, thank you ☺️

  • @stoatmcgroaty1586
    @stoatmcgroaty1586 5 месяцев назад +1

    It depends on the tent really ... some of the more exotic tents can't be taped ... and seam sealer takes a fair while to cure ... so the tent has to be put up somewhere and left up for over 24 hours ... the cost of that space required and the people to do the work would seriously impact the cost of an already expensive tent .... so to a degree it also comes down to what kind of tent owner you are ... if you're an enthusiast and consider some tents to be heirloom pieces then you'll be prepared to undertake the maintenance involved from the start .... it's a bit like don't buy a Harley if you're not prepared to polish the chrome and grease it's balls 😉

  • @DazBurbyUntamedWild
    @DazBurbyUntamedWild 5 месяцев назад +5

    To seam seal a tent, it needs to be put up and left up while the sealant dries. If the manufacturer is making thousands of tents, imagine the space needed to erect and seal thousands of tents. This is why

  • @michaellaing2067
    @michaellaing2067 5 месяцев назад +1

    Agree totally with you mate

  • @owenmorse3136
    @owenmorse3136 5 месяцев назад +1

    If the material is 100% silicon fabric the only way to seal the seams is build the tent and then seal them according to Google. The manufacturer can seal them but at a extra cost .

    • @jim-bob-outdoors
      @jim-bob-outdoors  5 месяцев назад

      Then they should do it an add a few quid to the price.

  • @lardyguts2
    @lardyguts2 5 месяцев назад +1

    apparently you cant seam tape sill nylon . it need seam sealing. that costs too much

  • @MartynStone-jv1yf
    @MartynStone-jv1yf 3 месяца назад +1

    I could not agree more

  • @ChowchillaCharlie
    @ChowchillaCharlie Месяц назад +2

    Isn't it something about you having to put it up to do it properly and its too much work for the factory? Personally I agree that it shouldnt be a problem we have to deal with, but not every tent is made nortent/hilleberg style with cooled needles so the holes are minimal and they got expanding thread when it gets wet and whatever else magic they use. I'm sure they are 99.9999% waterproof with this technique but I think alot of people, including me, think that for a little bit of work on my end I can feel even safer inside of my shelter and thats worth alot.

    • @jim-bob-outdoors
      @jim-bob-outdoors  Месяц назад +2

      How come a lot of the cheaper tents are done in the factory? I think its just some of the bigger brands adding a little to the margins

    • @ChowchillaCharlie
      @ChowchillaCharlie Месяц назад

      @@jim-bob-outdoors You mean the ones seamsealed with tape? I dont know what it entails if you have to do it "properly" applying the liquid to the seam.. my guess is that it takes alot of time for it to dry compared to the tape thats instant and you basically have to leave it out and have space for it. Even if you are a brand like Hilleberg that puts up every tent before shipping it to make sure it meets quality standards it would take alot of time to go through every seam by hand and then having space at the factory to let it sit there and dry before packaging it, and therefor its easier to just leave this process to the customer since its not really needed anyway for the function of the tent. I dont know what kind of chemicals are available but on SeamGrip its alot of hours for it to dry on the SilNylon material and lots of hours on the polyester aswell.

  • @marksadventures3889
    @marksadventures3889 5 месяцев назад +1

    Agreed 100%

  • @bc81
    @bc81 5 месяцев назад +2

    It's simple. It comes down to cost.
    Materials like silpoly can't be seam taped so adds time and money to making them if they were to seam seal them too. Take the lanshan pros . Personally I was happy to spend £10 to seam seal my 1 and 2 pro instead of paying an extra £35 each.
    Not to mention I'll happily trust my seam seal job and not worry for there first outing in the rain if I'd of paid for it to be done.

  • @H.ArminGilsdorf
    @H.ArminGilsdorf 5 месяцев назад +1

    If I am going to buy a tent I want it complete. I also do not buy a rain jacket and I have to add water resitantance by my self......

  • @kennethwilson8633
    @kennethwilson8633 5 месяцев назад +1

    Yep just shoddy work if you ask me.

  • @southcoastoutdoorsuk6301
    @southcoastoutdoorsuk6301 5 месяцев назад

    It’s time consuming and has to be done by hand , but why buy a tent you need to put a tarp over to make waterproof 🤷‍♂️

  • @lewisgardner1660
    @lewisgardner1660 5 месяцев назад +1

    I have seen airfix is getting into the tent game be interesting

    • @jim-bob-outdoors
      @jim-bob-outdoors  5 месяцев назад

      Sounds interesting.

    • @lewisgardner1660
      @lewisgardner1660 5 месяцев назад +1

      @@jim-bob-outdoors yes you get a load of canvas couple of zips needle and cotton and some cord, how hard can it be?

  • @ChiefScout_Outdoors
    @ChiefScout_Outdoors 5 месяцев назад +5

    100% don’t buy if you have to seal it, not acceptable 🤬

  • @MetallicrealitE
    @MetallicrealitE 5 месяцев назад +1

    I wouldn't buy a tent that isnt finisheed, what a rip off.

  • @leemichel8199
    @leemichel8199 5 месяцев назад +2

    I've seen some high-end tent companies that are starting to send you a tube of seem seal with the tents, and are expecting you to do it yourself ,considering the prices, it's the least they can do, just lazyness in most cases, in my opinion.God bless you and your family and happy camping 🏕 😀 😊 🙏 😄 😉 🏕. Lee

    • @jim-bob-outdoors
      @jim-bob-outdoors  5 месяцев назад +1

      Its just increasing the profit margin on a already expensive product. 😒

    • @leemichel8199
      @leemichel8199 5 месяцев назад +1

      @frogmaster83 exactly mate, not fair on the ones buying