Folks, this is solid gold information, simple as it is. I've been scratching around the internet for the last couple of days looking for information on Stirlings. There's not a lot. There's a lot of TALK about them, but nowhere you can just "buy one" the way you would a DC or AC motor, and precious little in the way of plans and actionable information. This is material that gets your foot in the door. Add in some understanding of thermodynamics that lets you start to quantify what you're doing using real physics, and you're on the road to discovery.
Spot on. At least this guy is experimenting with designs and keeping it simple. It's also strange how stirling engines seem to have really fallen out of vogue on the internet in the last 10 years.
There are Microgen generators that you can buy and even CHP systems Ököfen for household use. I've been searching a used microgen generators or very good drawings, but it seems to be so complex to build at home that it would be better to find one.
It needs a guide rod on the piston to keep it from hitting the coil. Or making the coil wider to account for lateral movement. Great video, thanks for sharing!
May I suggest that you remove the bridge rectifier and repeat the experiment in AC mode? You are loosing power in the rectifier to the ~1.2 volt drop across 2 diodes. You also might consider lighting an LED without the rectifier. Great video! Thanks.
Not only that , he needs a guide rod at the top of the magnet so the magnet moves in a straight line. I think he can get more power with a higher resistance , so the magnet can get up to speed. Flywheel is another required item.
Perfect. This is the way to go. The efficiency is low, and others did not want to measure it anymore, but by knowing the efficiency you can easily see what changes improve the engine. I would even recommend to use an electrical heat element (for 3D printers) or a heater band (for injection molding) when doing measurements, because then you know how much energy goes in and comes out of the engine. I think stirling engines can be made much more efficient when the makers have a clear sight on the efficiency.
Would it be more efficient if you had used a speaker for the power generation ? A 2nd step could be to variably change the resistance through an arduino board because the engines output varies in frequency and this way you could steer the result.
It sure would be nice to know how much heat power is going in, though I see how that would be hard to know. Maybe you could measure how much fuel is consumed over some period of time? I understand of course that this is a proof of principle demonstration - not a serious attempt to convert power. I've tremendously enjoyed your videos on this - thanks for your time and effort!
The orientation of the magnets may not be very efficient. The magnetic field lines in this prototype may be running almost parallel to the coil. Would it be better if the coil was cutting the field lines at 90 degrees? Maybe if you could re-position the magnets it may make a difference. I'm not sure of this. Maybe someone could let me know if my thinking is wrong here. Thanks - Great video.
saudações do Brasil a todos. finalmente!!! o motor Stirling usado como gerador!!! estava esperando há muito tempo por isso. excelente demonstração. parabéns e muito sucesso.
The orientation of the magnet realtive to the coil isn't a good one. Moving a magnet into or out of a coil doesn't induce a lot of current. The magnet should move sideways relative to the axis of the coil. I know, hard to construct in this setup, and the power taken out will most likely immediately stop the engine. But just if someone is wondering.
The power that's generated by an oscillating mass is given by using the formula for simple harmonic motion : Power in watts =1/2 m .(2πr.f)^2 Note that this gives the same result as the Rotational formula : 1/2 I w^2 , where I is the moment of inertia, as I = mr^2 and w =2(pi)f, So if the mass, m, of the magnet is 50g = 0.050kg and the amplitude r of the oscillation is 1cm = 0.01m and the rate of oscillation is 20Hz. Then the power is 0.5x 0.05 x (2x 3.1416x 0.01x 20)^2 =.0394 watts =39mW Please correct my assumptions of the mass, amplitude and oscillation rate. Note the amplitude is half the peak distance moved by the centre of mass
Muito interessante êste motor e o gerador !!! Gostei e você esta de parabéns, meu amigo!!! Também faço alguns stirlings e free piston , vamos compartilhar , irmão!!! Muita saúde e harmonia em seu caminho!!!! Abraço!!!!!
Because that top is made of rubber it is not going to allow the weight to resonate in a perfect up and down motion, it smacks the sides of the coil too much. It always will too, unless we can figure out some other way to tap electricity from it.
Is there chance the magnet get demagnetised when attached to piston in a full working free piston stirling engine for electricity generation due to heat
Bonjour désolé d’écrire en français, j’ ai l’impression que la première vidéo du piston fonctionnait très bien et je me demande si vous n’ avez pas bouché un évent avec le scotche pour fixer la bobine ce qui me semble une explication au fonctionnement défaillant du piston mais je peux me tromper c’ est juste une suggestion. J’ aimerai tellement que vous refassiez l’ essaie en tenant compte de ce tout petit détail qui pourrait peut-être changer le résultat...😘 en tout cas bravo pour les belles idées...🙏
Except buck converters lower voltage. A boost converter could be considered, but that would be tough at that low voltage. However, there are joule thief circuits that run below a volt. Still won't be very efficient, so power loss.
Can you build a small wind turbine that generates electric traditionally (alternator method) with also a Wimshurst mechanism added to it to harvest additional static discharge? They both use rotary motion, so it would seem that you could combine mechanisms to produce something interesting (I have a few ideas on top of this, but just getting a little test in place would be intriguing).
Most experimentors have early disappointing results and together with the sayers requires resilience and determination. Examine Faradays work. Without his determination we would still be reading by candlelight.
Folks, this is solid gold information, simple as it is. I've been scratching around the internet for the last couple of days looking for information on Stirlings. There's not a lot. There's a lot of TALK about them, but nowhere you can just "buy one" the way you would a DC or AC motor, and precious little in the way of plans and actionable information. This is material that gets your foot in the door. Add in some understanding of thermodynamics that lets you start to quantify what you're doing using real physics, and you're on the road to discovery.
Spot on. At least this guy is experimenting with designs and keeping it simple. It's also strange how stirling engines seem to have really fallen out of vogue on the internet in the last 10 years.
There are Microgen generators that you can buy and even CHP systems Ököfen for household use. I've been searching a used microgen generators or very good drawings, but it seems to be so complex to build at home that it would be better to find one.
It needs a guide rod on the piston to keep it from hitting the coil. Or making the coil wider to account for lateral movement. Great video, thanks for sharing!
Your right it needs a guide because making the coil diameter larger would reduce efficiency, in my opinion not a solution to the problem at play
@@BJL2142Absolutely.
May I suggest that you remove the bridge rectifier and repeat the experiment in AC mode?
You are loosing power in the rectifier to the ~1.2 volt drop across 2 diodes.
You also might consider lighting an LED without the rectifier.
Great video! Thanks.
Not only that , he needs a guide rod at the top of the magnet so the magnet moves in a straight line. I think he can get more power with a higher resistance , so the magnet can get up to speed. Flywheel is another required item.
With a processor with an a/d converter, you could make a synchronous rectifier made of VMOS FETS and get a zero voltage drop rectifier.
@@benthere8051
You can actually buy ideal diode ICs now, no micro required for synchronous rectifiers.
@@GlennHamblin I've been retired for a while now and out-of-touch with the latest developments. Thanks.
@@benthere8051
No worries Ben, I'm getting there myself, just wanted to let you know. :) Have a great weekend!
Perfect. This is the way to go. The efficiency is low, and others did not want to measure it anymore, but by knowing the efficiency you can easily see what changes improve the engine. I would even recommend to use an electrical heat element (for 3D printers) or a heater band (for injection molding) when doing measurements, because then you know how much energy goes in and comes out of the engine. I think stirling engines can be made much more efficient when the makers have a clear sight on the efficiency.
I agree, there has been a lack of focus on efficiency
Wonderful demonstration of the concepts behind heat engines and electric power generation.
Të lumtë mëndja e ndritur që keni,suksese pa fund.
Ky është realizimi më me rendiment i motorit stirling.
SUKSESE PA FUND.
1.) the Aluminum-Can (Closed Ring) produces a partial shortcut.
2.) using schottky-rectifier will reduce the loss for the rectifier dramatically.
Sounds like it needs a guide to have it through the coils.
Interesting you can see the flame through the can? Or is it a glass gar?
Would it be more efficient if you had used a speaker for the power generation ? A 2nd step could be to variably change the resistance through an arduino board because the engines output varies in frequency and this way you could steer the result.
It sure would be nice to know how much heat power is going in, though I see how that would be hard to know. Maybe you could measure how much fuel is consumed over some period of time? I understand of course that this is a proof of principle demonstration - not a serious attempt to convert power. I've tremendously enjoyed your videos on this - thanks for your time and effort!
Sugar ants have driven me crazy. After living in Indonesia for a few months...they are the bane of my existence. lol
Lol yes
The orientation of the magnets may not be very efficient. The magnetic field lines in this prototype may be running almost parallel to the coil. Would it be better if the coil was cutting the field lines at 90 degrees? Maybe if you could re-position the magnets it may make a difference. I'm not sure of this. Maybe someone could let me know if my thinking is wrong here. Thanks - Great video.
saudações do Brasil a todos. finalmente!!! o motor Stirling usado como gerador!!! estava esperando há muito tempo por isso. excelente demonstração. parabéns e muito sucesso.
You can make it automatically starting by applying single electric pulse to the coil initially.
The orientation of the magnet realtive to the coil isn't a good one. Moving a magnet into or out of a coil doesn't induce a lot of current. The magnet should move sideways relative to the axis of the coil. I know, hard to construct in this setup, and the power taken out will most likely immediately stop the engine. But just if someone is wondering.
Very interesting suggestion! I'd like to see him repeat the experiment with the coils oriented by 90°.
The power that's generated by an oscillating mass is given by using the formula for simple harmonic motion :
Power in watts =1/2 m .(2πr.f)^2
Note that this gives the same result as the Rotational formula : 1/2 I w^2 ,
where I is the moment of inertia, as I = mr^2 and w =2(pi)f,
So if the mass, m, of the magnet is 50g = 0.050kg and the amplitude r of the oscillation is 1cm = 0.01m and the rate of oscillation is 20Hz. Then the power is 0.5x 0.05 x (2x 3.1416x 0.01x 20)^2 =.0394 watts =39mW
Please correct my assumptions of the mass, amplitude and oscillation rate.
Note the amplitude is half the peak distance moved by the centre of mass
Po,shumë saktë,mendimi juaj rrit akoma cilësinë e këtij motor gjeneratori.Respekte.
This engine produces more power than free energy generators
LOL fo sure!
Seems to be that with this field coil arrangement that the power diaphragm was unable to get up to full speed (power band).
Wow wonderful design and very powerful thank you very much for the information
Muito interessante êste motor e o gerador !!! Gostei e você esta de parabéns, meu amigo!!! Também faço alguns stirlings e free piston , vamos compartilhar , irmão!!! Muita saúde e harmonia em seu caminho!!!! Abraço!!!!!
Because that top is made of rubber it is not going to allow the weight to resonate in a perfect up and down motion, it smacks the sides of the coil too much. It always will too, unless we can figure out some other way to tap electricity from it.
Amazing video amazing video
Is there chance the magnet get demagnetised when attached to piston in a full working free piston stirling engine for electricity generation due to heat
now calculate the thermal effiiency.i recommend to use a calculator with a wide display so that you dont lose your results in the decimal places
Excellent proof of concept it may improve the power if scaled up!
compress co2 from kombucha brew, to turn turbine, A GenBucha was born.
Looks promising
Bonjour désolé d’écrire en français, j’ ai l’impression que la première vidéo du piston fonctionnait très bien et je me demande si vous n’ avez pas bouché un évent avec le scotche pour fixer la bobine ce qui me semble une explication au fonctionnement défaillant du piston mais je peux me tromper c’ est juste une suggestion. J’ aimerai tellement que vous refassiez l’ essaie en tenant compte de ce tout petit détail qui pourrait peut-être changer le résultat...😘 en tout cas bravo pour les belles idées...🙏
Oui. Continuer les experiments come Coulomb, Ampere et Faraday.
Good Job Sir !!! Thank You. ****cheers**** !!! =)
Tal vez falte equilibrar mejor la posición pero muy buena la idea.
Add dc to dc buck converter to increase voltage
Except buck converters lower voltage. A boost converter could be considered, but that would be tough at that low voltage. However, there are joule thief circuits that run below a volt. Still won't be very efficient, so power loss.
@@GlennHamblin maybe increase in turns of wdg leads to voltage rise
Exactly how would a buck converter increase the voltage.
1:28 like if you see an ant 🐜
I saw
Can you build a small wind turbine that generates electric traditionally (alternator method) with also a Wimshurst mechanism added to it to harvest additional static discharge? They both use rotary motion, so it would seem that you could combine mechanisms to produce something interesting (I have a few ideas on top of this, but just getting a little test in place would be intriguing).
There is too much tape on the top side so there is no cooling
Yes the top should be a cool as possible. Heatsink perhaps and minimal tape insulation.
Looks like it works just fine to me.
This Guy is Epic...
Put a polyethylene or Teflon sleeve inside the coil hole.
or put a schottky rectifier.
Cool!
If we scale this up then could this be used as an alternative to a nuclear plant? ;)
LOL!
Mrówki atakują....
Where is Stirling himself? I do not see the heater, cooler, heat source.
Shouldn't the top of the engine cool? Maybe use aluminium tape instead of duct tape.
Yes or even better copper tape
1V with only Multimeter which has 1MOhm resistor
its super super low power unusable
Most experimentors have early disappointing results and together with the sayers requires resilience and determination. Examine Faradays work. Without his determination we would still be reading by candlelight.
The coil is saturated
the thing shouldnt need starting at all. Definitely not lengthty starting attempts.
No mechanical engine truly starts by it's self.
Unsubbed too many bloody commercials
Jaja alto inglish bro aunque te queda mejor el español
Fab