#AUSvIND

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 24 дек 2024

Комментарии • 113

  • @aadesh7
    @aadesh7 12 часов назад +52

    Its a complete joke that performing players are being dropped and non performers are being given a 100 chances.

    • @ChandraMama_Kathalu
      @ChandraMama_Kathalu 9 часов назад +3

      Why should pujara...ajinkya....ashwin not play???
      When other non performing players are given an extremely long long rope?????
      Not fare...

    • @aadesh7
      @aadesh7 8 часов назад +3

      @@ChandraMama_Kathalu yes. Ashwin averaging more that Rohit and Virat in Tests over last 3 years! Just in batting he is better nevermind the bowling.
      The team has become a joke. Selectors are spineless and clueless.

    • @nashily
      @nashily 6 часов назад

      Are you new to Indian cricket? This has been happening since forever now.

    • @ChandraMama_Kathalu
      @ChandraMama_Kathalu 6 часов назад

      @@nashily it might be...
      Would like to see a good change....don't you???
      Past is past...let's re-write present differe tly..
      They have the present in their hands...don't they???
      So, with that possibility....I am looking at it...

  • @akuser84
    @akuser84 11 часов назад +19

    Reddy has both scored important runs and picked key wickets so far in this series.He doesn't have Thakur or Pandya's pace but he can be effective.He looks a motivated cricketer and will only grow with time.He needs to stay

  • @GopalakrishnanSambamoorthy
    @GopalakrishnanSambamoorthy 10 часов назад +18

    Reddy may be treated as pure batsman and very few innings he played reveals a true class in him. Already there more dead weights in the team unnecessarily

  • @CricInd-es2pn
    @CricInd-es2pn 11 часов назад +15

    According to Manjrekar opinion, even Ben Stokes is a bits and pieces player because nobody remembers when last time he scored a century or took 5 wickets.

    • @Evolution_Tamil
      @Evolution_Tamil 9 часов назад +1

      He can do both on his day but dropping nkr is insane 😅

  • @ritikbhagat8456
    @ritikbhagat8456 11 часов назад +12

    I don’t agree with his views on NKR, experienced batters have not been able to score 120-130 still NKR gave important 40-50 runs. Also in last test he showed he has good defence skills. From bowling point of view, I agree that his bowling is not yet good enough to be considered as a full time 4th bowler.

  • @ashwinprakash3615
    @ashwinprakash3615 11 часов назад +15

    Drop Rohit Sharma and let NK reddy play …

  • @KG-gs5xj
    @KG-gs5xj 6 часов назад +8

    I disagree with Manjrekar's opinion on getting a batting all-rounder who can score 80 or 90 runs at No. 7 or 8 and also take 5 or 6 wicket hauls. Instead, non-performers like Rohit, Virat, and Gill should be dropped, and players like Reddy should be given a chance. Reddy batted exceptionally well until all the other batsmen got out, leaving him without support when he needed it most. How can you expect him to score 80 or 90 runs under such circumstances?
    Don't forget, he also took 3 crucial wickets and bowled very less overs as compare to top 4 bowlers. Manjrekar's opinion seems quite misguided 🤡

    • @sumbdi
      @sumbdi 6 часов назад

      How its realistically possible for a batting AR to score 70-80 runs and plus take wickets especially if ur a spinner toh

  • @venkateshs5366
    @venkateshs5366 9 часов назад +12

    Drop gill instead of NKR to make team balance

  • @murlimenon2291
    @murlimenon2291 11 часов назад +12

    Gill may get dropped to accommodate Washington.. Rohit bats at no. 3

  • @sundarr457
    @sundarr457 11 часов назад +11

    Absolute rubbish, Manjrekar s idea to shelve Reddy, who has been our best, confident batsman this tour, so far, given the way our top order batsman been failing.....the only way to add balance and flexibility to the playing XI, is to drop Gill, bring in Washington Sundar, as Wash can contribute with his bat, better than Gill, who has done nothing yet.... Wash s off spin can pose problems to the left handers of Aussie batting line up..... don't even think about Harshit Rana, if you are serious about winning in MCG.....he is our next generation Unmesh Yadav, leak runs from all the sides

    • @pranavreddy4450
      @pranavreddy4450 10 часов назад +3

      Even Umesh Yadav is tons better as he was a genuine wicket taker, with due respect to Rana. At least drop Gill and bring Sundar or Prasidh Krishna, depending on the conditions

    • @vimalramachandran
      @vimalramachandran 6 часов назад

      @@pranavreddy4450 Prasidh has been tried several times and he has failed constantly. I'm not sure why he continues to be picked for every series.

  • @Parthiban-bk1do
    @Parthiban-bk1do 10 часов назад +8

    Stop this nonsense for removing nithish Reddy from playing 11. Nithish should get a chance.

  • @saiprakash523
    @saiprakash523 4 часа назад +2

    Manjrekar doesn’t have the guts to say drop Rohit / Kohli or Gill. Instead he says drop Reddy. Reddy has actually been India’s most consistent batsmen. He has looked most confident among the bigger names. Experts like him will destroy a talented player’ s career. Agreed Jadeja played well but why target Reddy ? Also, Harshit is definitely not reliable. Might as well try Krishna. He’s tall and bowls 140 kmph.

  • @anishramakrishna5046
    @anishramakrishna5046 9 часов назад +4

    At this stage put nitish in top 5 and he will definitely score more than other batters

  • @sagarsaxena6318
    @sagarsaxena6318 5 часов назад +2

    It's not Reddy's fault that he's being asked to bat at No. 8. He has had little support in most innings and thus had to score keeping in mind that the batter at the other end won't last much. Idk if he can score 120 or no but he has played 2 extremely crucial knocks for India given the context. It makes no sense to drop him.

  • @vox-populi-vox-dei-
    @vox-populi-vox-dei- 3 часа назад +1

    I'd have dropped influential Gill for Nitesh. Nitesh is the second highest run scorer in this tour so far. Nitish brings more all-round abilities whereas Gill neighther can bowl nor can field well. Nitish, Washington, and Ravindra would have been a deadly-trio combo for India. I don't know why BCCI onboard young people and dumb them without a long rope as in the case of Sanju Samson, Washington Sundar (last four years), and Nitesh (today), Mayank Markande, etc.,

  • @sanketkulkarni2390
    @sanketkulkarni2390 13 часов назад +11

    Harshith Rana played only 12 1st class matches with economy 4 in tests at first class level… why not give chance to Mukesh kumar??? Who has played 49 first class with economy 2.89 and avg 21.2??

    • @RohliSKYVirma-cr9uy
      @RohliSKYVirma-cr9uy 12 часов назад +1

      I agree with you 💯. GGs fetish for allrounders made him pick Harshit as bowling allrounder 😅. But Mukesh is better than all of them even better than Siraj😅

    • @pranavreddy4450
      @pranavreddy4450 10 часов назад

      Should look at Prasidh krishna

    • @shubhamtandon9129
      @shubhamtandon9129 10 часов назад

      Mukesh is too slow for Australian pitches / international cricket in general

    • @sanketkulkarni2390
      @sanketkulkarni2390 10 часов назад

      @@shubhamtandon9129 nope he and Boland has same pace but perfect line and length around mid 135

    • @vimalramachandran
      @vimalramachandran 6 часов назад

      @@sanketkulkarni2390 Mukesh played both India A unofficial Tests against Aus A and failed to deliver. Boland is tall and can extract bounce, which Mukesh can't. Also, Boland is much more accurate with his lengths compared to Mukesh.

  • @malamsingh1944
    @malamsingh1944 13 часов назад +5

    Poor choice to choose Harshit over Prasidh. When things don't go your way, you need to be calm and consistent which we didn't see from Harshit.
    Meanwhile, Prasidh is in Aus since India A matches and he took 5-6 wkts in those matches with long spells. He also got extra bounce due to his height. Also, he is looking good in nets as per the info coming from various insiders.
    So, if India wants an extra pacer it's a pretty simple choice to go with Prasidh Krishna.
    But dropping NKR can also be a double edged sword, he is pivotal as batter down the order

    • @vimalramachandran
      @vimalramachandran 6 часов назад

      Prasidh bowls short and leaks runs; so him taking a few wickets wouldn't even matter. That has happened in every opportunity he has got. Travis Head might hit another easy century with Prasidh bowling.

  • @RohliSKYVirma-cr9uy
    @RohliSKYVirma-cr9uy 12 часов назад +5

    6:25 Need specialist in team 😅. Bits & pieces kirkut expert Manjrekar - 🃏 🤡

    • @yuvrajgupta9414
      @yuvrajgupta9414 12 часов назад

      Whats wrong in that test is a game of specialist...leave bits and pieces player only few proper all rounder across the globe has done well

  • @tdbandara365
    @tdbandara365 11 часов назад +2

    Australia and Sanjay Manjerakar are the best combination...always masters

  • @rajaguruperiasamy8845
    @rajaguruperiasamy8845 8 часов назад +2

    What's the point of having players who are on paper a top5 batter but are producing nothing in the field. Rubbish idea to drop a performing player to accommodate a non-performing player.

  • @bharathwajan4452
    @bharathwajan4452 10 часов назад +3

    Can Gill , Rohit can get a 42? Did they give that confidence, Forget 120 which you have required from Reddy , drop one of them Reddy on current form can replace if Ash/Jadeja can be dropped these 2 are not even closer to their 20% of achievements to keep playing after every failures in test cricket

    • @ChandraMama_Kathalu
      @ChandraMama_Kathalu 9 часов назад

      Absolutely...
      Team is losing but they drop good players...and stick with the popular ones even though they don't perform for a very long time in different aspects..

    • @athreyiraj9356
      @athreyiraj9356 3 часа назад

      Leave aside score 42 runs can they play 40 balls without giving away their wicket 🤷‍♀️NKR can bat, bowl and gun fielder as well. But this is not cricket but movie so they need megastars only for showbiz

  • @vimalramachandran
    @vimalramachandran 6 часов назад

    More than making runs, Reddy has shown the correct attitude by not allowing himself to be bogged down by the Aussie quicks. That's what needs to be acknowledged. His grit and determination are what might come in handy once again for us.

  • @naimalum
    @naimalum 7 часов назад +1

    I'm waiting for a video on "Leaving Manjrekar helps quality of commentary".

  • @wesleyjohnmathews3098
    @wesleyjohnmathews3098 9 часов назад +2

    If Rohit wants to win this match play with reddy. If they dropped him sure india will lose this match.. Drop Gill or Rohit why reddy?.. Reddy should play in Gill's spot

  • @ganeshk6120
    @ganeshk6120 11 часов назад +2

    Its fair point frm Manajerakar. Nitish if he can 3 wiks and can get 80 90 runs consistently then he can play.. So we need to get sundar or any other seamer based on conditions.. Bse jadeja is playing mainly batsman . Reddy can get 1 wik if batsman make mistake.. So bowling look weak. We need one more bowler who can strike which will be good support for 3 quicks

    • @AshokReddy-sw6lh
      @AshokReddy-sw6lh 10 часов назад

      Can you tell me how many wickets taken by Australian 4th seamer

    • @AshokReddy-sw6lh
      @AshokReddy-sw6lh 10 часов назад +1

      For adding that Nitish is top3 run scorer for this series at the moment

    • @pvkchakraverthy1565
      @pvkchakraverthy1565 10 часов назад +3

      Exactly true..No need to drop nitish reddy...he consistent batting performer..otherwise better drop gill..take other seamer/spinner

    • @AshokReddy-sw6lh
      @AshokReddy-sw6lh 10 часов назад

      @ yes 🙌

  • @vox-populi-vox-dei-
    @vox-populi-vox-dei- 2 часа назад +1

    Yash
    Rahul
    Virat (can retire)
    Shubman (drop)
    Rohit(can retire)
    Pant(drop)
    Nitesh
    Ravindra (he will retire himself soon)
    Washy
    Siraj(drop)
    Bumrah

  • @rajaramanv7150
    @rajaramanv7150 11 часов назад +2

    No stopping of bringing out Thakur's name who is long back out of India reckoning..😂..Iam a fan of Shradul Thakur but don't need frequent references to his past history unnecessarily.. Mumbai connection???😂

  • @navshannakhwa8499
    @navshannakhwa8499 6 минут назад

    6:25 Manjrekar trying so hard not to call Nitish Kumar Reddy a 'bits and pieces cricketer' 🤣🤣

  • @AkashBharti1
    @AkashBharti1 9 часов назад +2

    Isse better gill ko drop karke dhruv ya kisi pacer ko khila lo

  • @nashily
    @nashily 6 часов назад +1

    I would much rather drop Rohit Sharma than drop Nitish Reddy

  • @sandbpr
    @sandbpr 5 часов назад

    Remember Nitish Kumar Reddy is in good touch, he knows when to hit and last test he played more balls comfortably than other batsmen’s, more over picked key wickets in this series so far, bad luck Rohit dropped sitter of Travis Head when he was in 70’s in the bowling of Nitish kumar Reddy.

  • @sandbpr
    @sandbpr 4 часа назад

    How many runs manjrekar score in Australia series in 1992, and what was his confidence level in that test series.

  • @GANESHVISWANATHAN-pf8pn
    @GANESHVISWANATHAN-pf8pn 7 часов назад

    Prasidh krishna is better option than Siraj,Rohit has to learn his batting technique from his own game he played in Australia few years ago and he has to play straight drives rather than hook shot or cover drives until he gets well settled.

  • @omm22
    @omm22 3 часа назад +1

    no batting coach for the men's team right now.

  • @saiyadmohammadharis288
    @saiyadmohammadharis288 Час назад

    Xl- 1.Jashwal
    2.Rahul
    3.Gill
    4.virat
    5.Rohit
    6.Pant
    7.sarfraz
    8.jadeza
    9.Bumrah
    10.H.rana
    11.Siraj

  • @asgokhale32
    @asgokhale32 3 часа назад

    Jadeja should bat at no 6 based on current form. Sundar should play. Rest Gill and go with an extra bowler . Gill hasn’t done much. Sundar will trouble Head. Manjrekar should be appointed batting coach. He was technically better than all current Indian batters. Rohit and Rahul should open. Jaiswal no. 3, kohli 4, Pant, 5, Jadeja 6, Washington 7, Reddy 8, Akashdeep , 9, Bumrah 10, Siraj 11

  • @goutam0007
    @goutam0007 3 часа назад +1

    If you want to drop someone, please drop Rohit and Kohli. Definitely not Nitish Reddy.

  • @WhatifwithSRB
    @WhatifwithSRB 5 часов назад

    I think he has gone out of mind. It was nitish reddy who looked apart from any of other batters and you drop your best batsman just to make balance. Its not a hard call... It will be foolish call. Why not drop gill and push rohit up. Play nitish and washington or any other bowler you want to play.

  • @ArjunJangidHere
    @ArjunJangidHere 9 часов назад

    India should play Dhruv jurel in place of gill...
    Then put Prasidh krishna in place of NKR.... Unfair on NKR but we need 4 pacers.... Can also give siraj rest and get harshit in.... Bumrah needs to play all 5 matches.

  • @clickslick1
    @clickslick1 4 часа назад

    How the heck would you drop Reddy?? He is the back bone of our batting. The problem is not our bowling it's our batting. Only a fool would even think about replacing him for this match.

  • @patraprateek
    @patraprateek 7 часов назад

    I understand GG won't risk dropping Rohit and Virat right now, but dropping NKR? Come on, drop Gill and get Krishna. Everyone else moves up 1 spot

  • @satishkumarov
    @satishkumarov 6 часов назад

    Mumbai lobby working hard, if anything he will add balance because he is multi discipline player.

  • @padmanabhshenoy3924
    @padmanabhshenoy3924 5 часов назад

    Correct. If you need an all rounder he has to be a Botham or Kapil Dev type all rounder. We can't win with bits and pieces all rounder. Best to go for a specialist batsman or specialist bowler.

  • @ramav87
    @ramav87 5 часов назад

    Reddy is more likely to score runs than Kohli and Rohit in my opinion. India can continue to back the greats, hoping they will come good, maybe they will. But the problem has been going on for too long.
    Regarding the batting coach, I dunno what Manjrekar is thinking. If joe schmos on RUclips can determine what the problem is, then I am certain Rohit and Virat can figure out that they shouldn't be playing balls outside off stump. It's a mental issue they have, an inability to switch to the test mindset where they need to leave the ball more often than not.

  • @Jay16485
    @Jay16485 Час назад

    Gill, Rohit, Virat and Pant - one should be dropped and India should bring in one fast bowler. All are not in form and not scoring runs. Dropping Nitish Kumar reddy who is in form is stupidity.

  • @praveenaprasad6757
    @praveenaprasad6757 9 часов назад

    Perform or perish..gill should be dropped..Rahul should play at 1 down..dhurv jurel should replace gill..jurel is technically strong..washinton sunder should replace reddy..sunder can be handy as a bowler..siraj should be replaced with harshith Rana..

  • @sandbpr
    @sandbpr 5 часов назад

    Dropping confident batsmen like Nitish Kumar Reddy is foolish, if you want to balance the side better drop Rohit Sharma. Rohit can only bat as opener which seems difficult as jaiswal & Rahul combination is in good.

  • @athreyiraj9356
    @athreyiraj9356 4 часа назад

    lol the all rounders should score 120 and also be good enough to get 5 wickets. Whereas the core batsmen are not even good enough to play 30 balls - Ro,Ko,Gill baggage

  • @ratnakumar4384
    @ratnakumar4384 6 часов назад

    Now I will be happy even India lost to Australia with this mindset in selection

    • @athreyiraj9356
      @athreyiraj9356 3 часа назад +1

      Yes and then atleast Ro-Ko will retire hopefully.

  • @throneg1159
    @throneg1159 3 часа назад

    Drop pant or gill, kl can keep wickets.
    KL
    Yasaswi
    Gill
    Kohli
    Jadeja
    Rohith
    Pant
    Nithish/ harshith rana
    Sundar
    Akashdeep
    Bumrah
    Use yasaswi as part timer

  • @throneg1159
    @throneg1159 3 часа назад

    KL
    Yasaswi
    Gill
    Kohli
    Jadeja
    Rohith
    Pant
    Nithish/ harshith rana
    Sundar
    Akashdeep
    Bumrah
    Use yasaswi as part timer

  • @pranavtendulkar7142
    @pranavtendulkar7142 7 часов назад

    if reddy is deopped.It will be so disappointing for the youngster.Despite peeforing best if he is not given chance .it ll be cruel.

  • @Hyperticketbatch
    @Hyperticketbatch 2 часа назад

    Why don’t we drop Rohit and promote nitish to that place? We have balls to talk but fails to address. What if Rohit hits 25 and out in any innings of this match would that suffice your comments Mr. Manjrekar

  • @yashsahay5858
    @yashsahay5858 8 часов назад

    Then why Nitish was selected

  • @rogerIndianKing
    @rogerIndianKing 7 часов назад

    This guy is a joke. Performing players do not fit in his plans and justifies inclusion of non-performing players. How can we not see Bias?

  • @yashsahay5858
    @yashsahay5858 8 часов назад

    Can we get 100 from Gill ?

  • @saranketharam9002
    @saranketharam9002 2 часа назад

    Is this guy for real?

  • @Natraja_369
    @Natraja_369 12 часов назад

    Can Tanush kotian become the next Ravi Ashwin ??

  • @sidtheslotth5940
    @sidtheslotth5940 7 часов назад

    Skipped video after 6:49, don't want to listen to rubbish anymore

  • @shibashishdas7982
    @shibashishdas7982 5 часов назад

    Prediction for Past Prime Players. Will Rohit Kohli score more than 10 Runs individually in each innings? Yes/No

  • @AS-ct7eq
    @AS-ct7eq 8 часов назад

    Hey What's your take on this playing XI if India goes with this sort of combination😉🧐🤔:
    KL Rahul(WK)
    Y Jaiswal
    Shubman Gill
    Virat Kohli
    Rohit Sharma(C)
    Nitish Kumar Reddy
    Ravindra Jadeja
    Washington Sundar
    Prasidh Krishna
    Aakashdeep
    J Bumrah

  • @jeetsingh710
    @jeetsingh710 6 часов назад

    लिख के ले लो रेड्डी को हटाया तो हारोगे,, 100%

  • @Minmalist
    @Minmalist 3 часа назад

    Simple force rohit sharma and virat kohli to retire and reddy plays higher

  • @pemmarajuramasaran7211
    @pemmarajuramasaran7211 9 часов назад

    Can we get a Century at least one in each of the remaining Tests either from Kohi, Gill and Rohit. If yes NKR may be dropped. Sanjay instead analyzing the poor batting skills of these is pointing at NKR. Without analyzing their batting Otherwise his entire analysis is just a joke. 😊

  • @kiranvarma9163
    @kiranvarma9163 5 часов назад

    Drop Rohit and Gill

  • @sajjalsarkar5067
    @sajjalsarkar5067 8 часов назад

    India will lose again.
    its just a formality to play at MCG. On the other side .. Let's see what Harchel Gibbs statement

    • @sumbdi
      @sumbdi 6 часов назад

      Why will india lose

  • @mohandasrms4905
    @mohandasrms4905 6 часов назад

    Nonsence.. Rahul is the best batter

  • @jayandranm1317
    @jayandranm1317 4 часа назад

    Hey they are doing homework and plan for established batsman
    New surprise their bowlers

  • @kushanshah8040
    @kushanshah8040 7 часов назад

    I don't know why people are so crazy about a guy who has basically scored three 40s. Reddy is loose as a fifth bowler which is his main job.

    • @Kumar.R974
      @Kumar.R974 5 часов назад

      Because he scored 40’s when even main batsman struggled. what did Rohit, Gill achieve by putting Washington and Jurel out even after getting so many chances. Three 40’s are better than low 20’s or even less runs and above all he took wickets when main pacers were struggling. It always good to have a part time bowler or a not so part time bowler than having a batsman who cannot bowl and not score runs too. India is lucky to have Nitish and need to groom him. Why do you think Bumrah took him in the first place as a Captain? Players like nitish should stay. remember he scored those 40’s in quick succession and he remeained not out too. Go back and look at how Australian team energy when he started scoring runs.

  • @ssrujan6917
    @ssrujan6917 7 часов назад +1

    How can a player performing for the team can be removed !! He dint got the chance to score big batting with tailenders and he won't get new ball to bowl

  • @mayurlive
    @mayurlive 8 часов назад

    This manja random yap

  • @SHRAVNITHA1
    @SHRAVNITHA1 5 часов назад

    This team under Rohit is pure politics. They always drop players from minor states (AP and Bengal) and not from Delhi, Mumbai or Karnataka. Dropping both Kohli and Rohit and replacing them with Jurel and Padikkal will give India batting depth. These two senior players do not remotely look like scoring any runs but they would still play.

  • @raghurao1980
    @raghurao1980 11 часов назад

    No

  • @umajain2854
    @umajain2854 13 часов назад

    ❤😊

  • @Doz997
    @Doz997 4 часа назад

    Rohit needs to step down