The simple fact that you are concerned about this tells me you are a genuine guy. So stress less and "Keep on Bagin". You did the right thing you saved the fish, so enjoy the rewards. Great videos - keep at it, we love it down under. Your mates from OZ.
It’s a funny one Dave,hand lining is not allowed but bringing a fish in on a broken line with rod should be allowed.Well done getting it in and saving a fabulous fish.🤔
100% weigh the fish Dave,think you have done the fish a massive favor not having to swim around with the hook,line and 3oz weight round the lake. Great win .
i was once in the same situation in a match Dave and weighed it in as well saved a nice fish and thats the main reason congrats with winning the match Dave and thx for the nice video
I spent over fifteen minutes removing barbed hooks from a big old carp during a match. should i have had extra time? you did everything honestly and saved the fish. genuine bloke.
Damn right you should have weighed it. I seen it a few times while watching match fishing vlogs by some of the big names too. Congrats on the win and keep up the good work Dave.👍😁
Done exactly the same fishing pole on far bank in a club match.. caught someone's pole rig scooting past and ended up being my biggest of the day... ended up realising and giving back the rig to another member who had lost it at the start 🤣🤣🤣 absolutely it was allo wed .. topdraw DAVID 💪
I think you did right by weighing it in and you saved that fish, I have lost lots of fish during a match and still do not use barbed hooks, enjoy your fishing and keep the video's coming
We had a rule in my local club if u land it u can weigh it ,u should have seen the rule bending trout terripin,s flounders ,dead fish 🐠 tins of sweetcorn the list was endless,your only problem was u told everyone 🤫
Well done mate I'd have weighed Carp in as well you probably saved its life and you've.won the match.one good turn deserves another .don't feel guilty you were spot on.well done Dave.
Well done young man, totally agree with you that fish was potentially going to die a slow death and now will bring enjoyment for another angler ,love your contents😜👍🎣🎣.
Its only like foul hooking a fish , that's not taken bait in the mouth and they get weighed , wouldn't stress about it too much . I would definitely have weighed it .
If its not hooked by YOUR hook it don't count bud. You are a top bloke and don't stress, ITS DONE learn from it and well done for getting it in to roam free.
well done on the win Dave, same as foul hooking a fish I remember years ago on a hard canal match a section was blanking a lad hooked a plastic bottle inside the bottle was a gudgeon which he weighed in and won the section, so strange things happen, you need a bit of luck
It was just a strange and lucky catch Dave, and at least the fish is swimming around not trailing a 3oz lead and a barbless hook now! As you say, it is similar to foul hooking a fish, and it is not as if you intended to catch it that way. Well done on the win mate, even though it was tinged with some luck, but that is fishing sometimes.
Defo counts. It’s a regular occurrence on our beach matches. We lose loads of gear to snags. We are always bringing in lost gear with fish attached. They all count. No difference in this case. 👍🏻
Hi Dave nice win m8, as for the carp you landed it and got the barbed hook out and saved the fish you had the right to weigh it in that’s my opinion m8 well done 👍👍
Hi Dave you were correct to place it in your net , yes you saved the fish by removing the hook, it wasn’t your fault you casted over the line to be rewarded with the carp still on the line that you caught. Well done Dave on the match win thoroughly deserved.
Take the win Dave,you thought about the Carp's welfare first, then put it in your keepnet,if there was an objection to the capture,then it should of been voiced before the weigh in..so well done that man (you) I had a similar scenario I hooked a swivel, which had a hook length attached to a Bream,I was only pleasure fishing at the time, but if I was in a match it would of gone in my keepnet without hesitation..
Well done Dave fully deserved though you hooked that carp the way you did we all claim fish when we foul hook a fish no different and you save a fish from dragging line and weight around it so you done a good deed. Your very honest and Ive done it myself in the past when I actually hooked a carp through a swivel that the fish was trailing around couldn't believe it actually in the eye of the swivel crazy thing's happen but don't feel guilty you still played it to the net and saved it.🎣🎣🐟
dont worry about Dave mate, it was luck of the draw in the end and god only knows how long the fish was hooked for before you caught it. good to see you win again mate and keep the videos comming.
Hi Dave, luckily you have this on video. But this happens a lot more often than we think And maybe they don't talk about it as honestly as you do. And therefore this may be rewarded with your victory.
Hi Dave no different than foul hooking a fish when weighing in,you save that fish good on ya,i think you feel it was controversial because you won ,well done onyour win.🐟🐟
Dave in the net for sure. You did this fish a service. By freeing from what eventually could of caused it some real harm. Basically you may have saved it from a great deal of harm. So hence to me it goes in the net. People foul hook fish and put them in the net all the time. Pull it goes to show. How much you care to show everyone this clip Dave 👍👍
Handlining is against rules but otherwise no different to foul hooking it which we'd all count.... You was honest with the scalesman & he allowed it so case shut IMO He probably just appreciated you saving such a unit
I've had exactly the same thing happen, but not in a match. I caught a method feeder with a 20ber.attached. I refused to count it towards my tally...but if I was in a match and the lad next to me caught one like that, I wouldn't have a problem. If it's not in the written rules that you have to have your hook in it's mouth, then you were fishing within the rules, and it qualifies as a foul hooked fish.
Hey dave take, it, while its there. I had the same, a week ago beach fishing. My rod flew over. Had a heavy strange fight. Caught two dogfish on someone else's rig, one hook in ones back and in another in its mouth. my line was wrapped around there rig. I got both fish and whole rigs back, result. No one else on the beach 😂😂🏖️
I would have definitely weighed that carp in and well done for probably saving its life. The only thing I would have asked at the weigh in was it landed within the rules by virtually hand lining it into your landing net.I don't know the exact ruling? Maybe someone else does? Anyway congratulations the win 👏
This happens a lot of time iv done it.i know others who hav done it. Just like foul hooking. We're do they go? In the net👌 Well do your good form continues 👍
Well David it looks like one bad fisherman lost a fish and left it to suffer by their poor methods and another good fisherman caught it and saved it. Well done mate and glad you took the rewards of weighing it in.
Perfectly fine u didn't know it was a trailer.. good skill .. it could of happened to anyone so course it counts.. fair play .. sod the haters for it .. well won david
You rescued the fish but didn’t catch it - hence it shouldn’t have been weighed would be my call, but without looking at the match rules who knows? Keep up the great videos, controversial and otherwise 🎣🎣
Mate, I was in a match on Bolingey and the guy on the next peg NETTED a half dead fish and weighed it in !!!!!! Not even caught on a rod or pole! You did right to weigh it in.
You did the right thing, Dave. You saved the fish and landed it yourself. I've had a fish with my hook in it landed and kept by the angler in the next peg. Defo a cheater in my mind!!
well done dave and that carp tha cot it AND saved it from a sad ending which some idiot was fishing wrong anyway so to me tha won fairly , other anglers would have counted it and not said nowt lol, by the way that reel made it look like youd nowt ont hook when bringing them fish in, what make was it,good vid dave.
Your decision was the right one. Fish was caught and Landed.End of story. You did the fish a favour by catching it and taking the Barbed hook out and saving it from possibly becoming tethered and dying. As you well know there is no guarantee with fishing with regards catching. You like most of us spend a lot of money and time both fishing and promoting the sport so a bit of luck is welcome. Good win. Well done mate.On to the next one.
You caught using your rod and you landed it in the other part of your kit the landing net,your hook brought the fish to the bank and your landing net transferred it to your keep net. You still caught it. It couldn't have happened to a nicer bloke!
U did right weighing that fish in as u dint do nothing wrong just cos it was not ur hook if that was some one els in match they would have done same great match
Robbie Taylor hooked a 20lb carp hooked in the eye of the swivel he won the match with this in a winter match. so absolutely nothing wrong with this mate
The simple fact that you are concerned about this tells me you are a genuine guy. So stress less and "Keep on Bagin". You did the right thing you saved the fish, so enjoy the rewards.
Great videos - keep at it, we love it down under.
Your mates from OZ.
Hey stu , thanks for the kind words buddy and thanks for becoming a member , take care 👍
Correct stu
You were right to weigh it in Dave and you have saved a cracking fish from what could have been an agonising death. Keep on Baggin.
Cheers Tony 👍
You did the right thing Dave. You saved a fish plus you did land it. Well done on the match win.
It’s a funny one Dave,hand lining is not allowed but bringing a fish in on a broken line with rod should be allowed.Well done getting it in and saving a fabulous fish.🤔
Cheers matey 👍
100% weigh the fish Dave,think you have done the fish a massive favor not having to swim around with the hook,line and 3oz weight round the lake.
Great win .
i was once in the same situation in a match Dave and weighed it in as well saved a nice fish and thats the main reason congrats with winning the match Dave and thx for the nice video
Cheers Steven 👍
Great win, mate! Your fish fair and square 👊👊
I spent over fifteen minutes removing barbed hooks from a big old carp during a match. should i have had extra time? you did everything honestly and saved the fish. genuine bloke.
It is just the same as a Coul hook pal, so no problems here.
Foul hook
Well done dave
100% right and you saved a cracking fish... Well done 👏👏
Cheers matey
i like the rod rest system . yes defo count it , thank god you caught it
Damn right you should have weighed it. I seen it a few times while watching match fishing vlogs by some of the big names too. Congrats on the win and keep up the good work Dave.👍😁
Done exactly the same fishing pole on far bank in a club match.. caught someone's pole rig scooting past and ended up being my biggest of the day... ended up realising and giving back the rig to another member who had lost it at the start 🤣🤣🤣 absolutely it was allo wed .. topdraw DAVID 💪
Cheers matey 👍
Well done mate good fishing
You caught it m8.well dun
And you saved it.
I agree with what you say.
Wot a mighty fisherman you are.
I think you did right by weighing it in and you saved that fish, I have lost lots of fish during a match and still do not use barbed hooks, enjoy your fishing and keep the video's coming
Cheers David
Well done Dave, good win and nice save mate.
We had a rule in my local club if u land it u can weigh it ,u should have seen the rule bending trout terripin,s flounders ,dead fish 🐠 tins of sweetcorn the list was endless,your only problem was u told everyone 🤫
Dave you won the match fair and square and probably saved that fishes life 😉😄😄😄
Well done mate I'd have weighed Carp in as well you probably saved its life and you've.won the match.one good turn deserves another .don't feel guilty you were spot on.well done Dave.
Cheers matey 👍
A fail hooked fish still counts, its not taken your bait!!
I think you did the right thing David, and yes another nice video😊👍
I was fishing the pellet wag once and hooked a pole rig through the eye of the float, some how iv managed to land the fish and i weighed it in
Well done young man, totally agree with you that fish was potentially going to die a slow death and now will bring enjoyment for another angler ,love your contents😜👍🎣🎣.
Cheers Michael 👍
You landed fish fella so great win keep videos coming bud
Cheers matey 👍
Don't feel bad l think you did the right thing at the end of the day you rescued the fish
To me it's just the same as weighing a foul hooked fish, and everybody does that. Well won Dave 👍👏
For me dave you pulled it in on your line regardless who's bait it was nice bit of angling mate well done on the win.
Top job Mr Wood it's your catch you still reeled it in and saved the meaty boy well done indeed keep on bagging and keep the the nets wet 🎣🎣🐟👍
Cheers matey 👍
Its only like foul hooking a fish , that's not taken bait in the mouth and they get weighed , wouldn't stress about it too much . I would definitely have weighed it .
You had the bite mate played it in and landed it anyone else catching that would have weighed it in well done on the win
Cheers Neal 👍
If its not hooked by YOUR hook it don't count bud. You are a top bloke and don't stress, ITS DONE learn from it and well done for getting it in to roam free.
well done on the win Dave, same as foul hooking a fish I remember years ago on a hard canal match a section was blanking a lad hooked a plastic bottle inside the bottle was a gudgeon which he weighed in and won the section, so strange things happen, you need a bit of luck
It was just a strange and lucky catch Dave, and at least the fish is swimming around not trailing a 3oz lead and a barbless hook now! As you say, it is similar to foul hooking a fish, and it is not as if you intended to catch it that way. Well done on the win mate, even though it was tinged with some luck, but that is fishing sometimes.
Cheers Ken 👍
You brought it in on your rod and reel so it’s yours to claim in my eyes pal. Good angling and tight lines
Well done dave you caught it you net it
Good Karma Dave. The carp obviously wanted get on a BagUp video, innit!!! 😬🎣👍🏽
Cheers matey 👍
They all count Dave 👍, I wouldn't feel guilty, you have done you & the fish a favour Dave its a win win win.
You saved the fish and deserved the win well done Dave.
Defo counts. It’s a regular occurrence on our beach matches. We lose loads of gear to snags. We are always bringing in lost gear with fish attached. They all count. No difference in this case. 👍🏻
Hi Dave nice win m8, as for the carp you landed it and got the barbed hook out and saved the fish you had the right to weigh it in that’s my opinion m8 well done 👍👍
Just class as foul hooked.
Hi Dave you were correct to place it in your net , yes you saved the fish by removing the hook, it wasn’t your fault you casted over the line to be rewarded with the carp still on the line that you caught. Well done Dave on the match win thoroughly deserved.
Thanks Mate 👍
Good days fishing like you seid contreversil win but a fish in the net is yours if hooked on your line well done thight lines keep Bagging
Cheers matey 👍
Fully deserved win. You caught the fish. If anything, it was harder to land that way. And you saved the fish. Onwards and upwards
Cheers Paul 👍
Take the win Dave,you thought about the Carp's welfare first, then put it in your keepnet,if there was an objection to the capture,then it should of been voiced before the weigh in..so well done that man (you) I had a similar scenario I hooked a swivel, which had a hook length attached to a Bream,I was only pleasure fishing at the time, but if I was in a match it would of gone in my keepnet without hesitation..
Cheers Ste 👍
Well done Dave fully deserved though you hooked that carp the way you did we all claim fish when we foul hook a fish no different and you save a fish from dragging line and weight around it so you done a good deed.
Your very honest and Ive done it myself in the past when I actually hooked a carp through a swivel that the fish was trailing around couldn't believe it actually in the eye of the swivel crazy thing's happen but don't feel guilty you still played it to the net and saved it.🎣🎣🐟
Cheers Paul much appreciated 👍
dont worry about Dave mate, it was luck of the draw in the end and god only knows how long the fish was hooked for before you caught it. good to see you win again mate and keep the videos comming.
Cheers matey , much appreciated, yeah few people said I’ve saved it’s life 👍
Wins a win mate, nice one 👍👍👍👍
Cheers mate
You netted it. It’s your fish. Well done lad 👍🏼
you won Dave and landed the biggest weight. `no problem!
All’s well in love and war!!! You did the right thing Dave, as you said it was just like foul hooking a fish!!
Good result well done 🎣🎣🎣
Cheers matey 👍
Did the right thing dave and saved a cracking carp ,don't feel guilty ,your mate nosh wouldn't 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🎣🎣🎣🎣🎣
😂😂🤣
100% counts. Good win!
Hi Dave, luckily you have this on video. But this happens a lot more often than we think And maybe they don't talk about it as honestly as you do. And therefore this may be rewarded with your victory.
Cheers Jan 👍
Hi Dave no different than foul hooking a fish when weighing in,you save that fish good on ya,i think you feel it was controversial because you won ,well done onyour win.🐟🐟
Yes Dave you do weigh it in its happend to me you caught it buddy well done 👏.
Hey up mate . Just a foul hooked fish that anyone of us would have weighed in..well done pal. Fish suffering averted.😊
Winner 🏆
What gets me is the state of your car...always looks brand new/ super clean...a far cry from my fishing wagon I must say!
Hahah I don’t think so Tony it’s a right mess lol
I’ve done this myself and told I can’t weigh in but I believe you can so
Dave in the net for sure. You did this fish a service. By freeing from what eventually could of caused it some real harm. Basically you may have saved it from a great deal of harm. So hence to me it goes in the net. People foul hook fish and put them in the net all the time. Pull it goes to show. How much you care to show everyone this clip Dave 👍👍
Cheers Kevin 👍
Handlining is against rules but otherwise no different to foul hooking it which we'd all count.... You was honest with the scalesman & he allowed it so case shut IMO
He probably just appreciated you saving such a unit
That was a death rig . Some people have no idea .
Keep on bagin.
You definitely did catch that carp, no doubt about it. We weigh in foul hooked fish and you sort of foul hooked it!
Fairs fair dave well done mate 👏👏
Oh plz let me know what the opening n closing music is called. Cant get it outta my ed 🤪🤪
Cheers mate it’s in the description 👍
Well in mate. These things happen well done pal 👏🏻👍🏻👍🏻
Cheers Dave 👍
I've had exactly the same thing happen, but not in a match. I caught a method feeder with a 20ber.attached. I refused to count it towards my tally...but if I was in a match and the lad next to me caught one like that, I wouldn't have a problem.
If it's not in the written rules that you have to have your hook in it's mouth, then you were fishing within the rules, and it qualifies as a foul hooked fish.
you caught it regardless imo , played it in and untangled it, take the win mate
Hey dave take, it, while its there. I had the same, a week ago beach fishing. My rod flew over. Had a heavy strange fight. Caught two dogfish on someone else's rig, one hook in ones back and in another in its mouth. my line was wrapped around there rig. I got both fish and whole rigs back, result. No one else on the beach 😂😂🏖️
Earlier this year a lad in one of our matches did the same as you and landed a double and came 2nd in the match and nobody complained
Cheers matey 👍
Well done dave you saved the fish from stress tight lines
Thanks Martin 👍
Not controversial !! You saved its life, it owed you a favour in return.
As you said Dave after match that carp was released none the worse for what happened you netted it fair and square.
I would have definitely weighed that carp in and well done for probably saving its life. The only thing I would have asked at the weigh in was it landed within the rules by virtually hand lining it into your landing net.I don't know the exact ruling? Maybe someone else does? Anyway congratulations the win 👏
Cheers Nigel 👍
So much for dropping the lead myth :)
It does drop on a running rig. This carp was caught on a fixed rig which I think should be illegal.
I also think barbed hooks should be banned. You don’t need them if your skill levels are okay.
The only thing to question is your not allowed to hand line fish in strange one well done for saving the fish dave
Cheers matey 👍
This happens a lot of time iv done it.i know others who hav done it.
Just like foul hooking.
We're do they go?
In the net👌
Well do your good form continues 👍
Well David it looks like one bad fisherman lost a fish and left it to suffer by their poor methods and another good fisherman caught it and saved it. Well done mate and glad you took the rewards of weighing it in.
Cheers James 👍
In my eyes mate you caught the line that the fish was attached to so thats your fish and you saved a cracking fish from dying so everyones a winner🏆
Perfectly fine u didn't know it was a trailer.. good skill .. it could of happened to anyone so course it counts.. fair play .. sod the haters for it .. well won david
Cheers matey 👍
You rescued the fish but didn’t catch it - hence it shouldn’t have been weighed would be my call, but without looking at the match rules who knows? Keep up the great videos, controversial and otherwise 🎣🎣
Mate, I was in a match on Bolingey and the guy on the next peg NETTED a half dead fish and weighed it in !!!!!! Not even caught on a rod or pole! You did right to weigh it in.
Wow 😮 cheers mate
You did the right thing, Dave. You saved the fish and landed it yourself. I've had a fish with my hook in it landed and kept by the angler in the next peg. Defo a cheater in my mind!!
Cheers Paul 👍
well done dave and that carp tha cot it AND saved it from a sad ending which some idiot was fishing wrong anyway so to me tha won fairly , other anglers would have counted it and not said nowt lol, by the way that reel made it look like youd nowt ont hook when bringing them fish in, what make was it,good vid dave.
Cheers matey the reel is a castizam 250 I think it’s called 👍
Dont worry if there is no rule either way you weigh in Good luck
Saving a tethered fish is all good rules state rod and line your rod caught the line that the fish was tethered to
All good, you can fool hook a fish and weigh it in 👍👍👍👍
Your decision was the right one. Fish was caught and Landed.End of story. You did the fish a favour by catching it and taking the Barbed hook out and saving it from possibly becoming tethered and dying. As you well know there is no guarantee with fishing with regards catching. You like most of us spend a lot of money and time both fishing and promoting the sport so a bit of luck is welcome. Good win. Well done mate.On to the next one.
Cheers Peter 👍
Wen you save a fisch like dat , you deserve it . 🎣👌👍
Not sure of the rules, but you landed it and most likely saved it life! Well done
Cheers Peter 👍
Off course
Should not weigh that fish in. Under the rule of only one hook to be used, obviously two hooks were used.
Really?
Nowt rong with it mate you saved a nice fish someone else can catch it in the future keep on bagging
Cheers matey 👍
100% weigh it in wasn't a pike ! Get ready for a ribbing off Nosher lol 😆
Cheating should have put it back .why risk your reputation 🧐
You caught using your rod and you landed it in the other part of your kit the landing net,your hook brought the fish to the bank and your landing net transferred it to your keep net. You still caught it. It couldn't have happened to a nicer bloke!
You saved the fish !!!!
How come they are using BARBED HOOKS !!!!!
JONATHAN
Yes barbed hooks are barred
100% weigh it in
U did right weighing that fish in as u dint do nothing wrong just cos it was not ur hook if that was some one els in match they would have done same great match
Cheers Brett, yeah looking back it was the right decision 👍 much appreciated mate
@@BagUpTV ye it's like u said it dnt matter how u catch a fish if it gose in net then its in the net mate its there to be weighed
Robbie Taylor hooked a 20lb carp hooked in the eye of the swivel he won the match with this in a winter match. so absolutely nothing wrong with this mate