Edmunds Inside line was making the best car videos on RUclips before Motor trend went big. Then they shut down the channel due to some stupid corporate merger or something. It's good to see them producing quality content for car enthusiasts once again, albeit on a different channel, in a different format and with a completely different team of people.
AMG for life! That guy complained about E63S being less comfortable.. well those are Recaro sport seats, they are well known for not being comfortable. The luxury, the brand imagine, handcrafted Engine, AMG.
So what? he didn't complain the car was less comfortable, he noted a fact (trepeated by most road testers) and the fact that AMG put less comfortable seats in the car is their choice. You can't excuse it. The brand and the image? Yeah when it comes to super saloons the BMW M5 defines the brand and imagemin this segment, not AMG. All that said, both cars are incredible, and I'd be happy to have either or both parked in my garage if I could afford one. 99.9999% of whingers claiming pone is better than the other won't even sit in either car, let alone own or drive one. I have sat in a new M5 and it's fantastic. I just wish I could have driven it :)
Let's not make any mistake, this M5 in particular is a tad better than the Benz save for the sound track from Benz, other than that, the BMW is the better car, Benz had the option of not making the recaro seats, but because they were hell bound to make the car less porky, they opted for these seats, so it's no excuse, they developed a harsh ride to minimise body roll, it's no excuse, they need to take lessons from Munich, let's swallow our pride and give praise where it is due, this M5 has toppled the Benz in all aspects except the sound track, PERIOD
Two of the best cars on the road today this is a great video and like the commentators it comes down to personal likes and dislikes but for me I’m a BMW M5 fan as that is my daily beater. Great job guys.
good review. but something was left out,the capacity of both cars,the E63s is a 4.0l and the M5 4.4l. that means their power delivery, despite power and torque ratings mean their delivery is slightly different in certain parts of the rev range. another thing ive noticed is that(watched a ton of reviews between the two(coming to the comp M5,not there yet!!!),it is literally 50/50 as far as drags are concerned,half of the reviews show the E63 quicker than the M5,the other half,vice verse. after all ive watched,id say it was a tie(including illegal races). the comp M5,yes it is quicker in almost every vid ive seen,bar three(more where the comp takes it). yipee for BMW fans. drive: most reviews say the same thing,M5 better for comfortable daily driving,BUT,when it comes to emotional driving,most have said that the E63s,is more fun,steering more precise and most importantly,the engine noise from the engine inside the car(and outside) is pure engine. no fake channeled engine sounds via speakers or whatever they add to make it sound real inside the car. that is when i lost respect for BMW,the " ultimate drivers car" is now an ultimate farce!!!! if you a true BMW FAN,IM SURE YOU WOULD AGREE..... i am an AMG fan,BUT(PLEASE READ THIS) BUT LOVE THE BMW TOO. BOTH ARE GREAT CARS,MAKE NO MISTAKE!!!! where BMW beats the Benz,in one area,it looses in another and vice verse,FACT. what we can be greatfull of is that these cars exist,before the full or more hybrid era takes over. hope you all can see this is a fully unbiased opinion from an AMG NUTTER!!!!! YES ID STILL GO FOR THE E63,BUT WOULD HAVE EITHER CAR,ANY DAY IN MY GARAGE WITHOUT ANY HASSLES.
Wonderful to see you guys have fun! Brings life to the video. Quite a departure from the usual staid stuff that Edmunds usually churns out. Kind of like what MT videos used to be at their peak...before their greed and poor talent management fueled kamikaze.
I just cannot make up my mind about these two. I think I just about prefer the interior of the Merc, and the sound too. They are basically the same speed, so that’s not an issue. The hifi upgrade too - is INSANE. I’ve heard that, it sounds unreal. But the ride comfort and the looks of the Beemer are factors to consider too. And the fact that Mercedes do an estate - or wagon - might tip the balance too. Probably would ultimately go for the Mercedes. Fortunately I’ll never have the money to buy either, so my problem’s sorted for me. 😂
I haven't seen a video with you guys in it before, but the quick skimming I did on this, I laughed quite a bit! You guys are great together for this stuff *Cheers
These two cars are so equally matched. It's always a toss up. However, I have seen more wins for the M5. If the AMG lost some weight it would come out on top, but any sedan hitting 2.9 zero-60 and 11 flat for 1/4 mile is wicked fast. I'd chose the mighty E63 S 4Matic+ over the M5 any day
They´re both outstanding cars and should I ever be able to afford either one they´re definitely on my list... BTW, its up up down down left right a b select start.
It's funny how this is definetely the best E63 AMG of all time, while people can't even make their mind if this is the best M5 there ever was but it still beats the E63 easily...it shows that Bavarian engineering goes even further than the other Germans
Love BMW, but props to Mercedes for the power! Truly insane, BMW is still faster but for the first time in forever the E63 actually put up a competition.
Is it a requirement for this the manufacturers to make launch control so damn confusing and complicated? Why can it just be one button you press like sport mode?
Its not as complicated as they always make it seem. Also when you actually own the car you'll barely ever use the function. Hence from a UX perspective it's behind a few layers.
sky 22 geesh! You “clearly” don’t understand what “IMO” is. I’m “clearly” not saying what you should like, but I’m “clearly” saying what appeals to me. It is “clearly” an opinion. Is that clear enough?
Michael no the build quality of all of them is equally great and the difference between them is not even noticeable because how similar great build quality they have.
I think these cars are so close its more down to the buyers taste more then anything, yes the M is better built, faster, and maybe faster on track, but the diffrence is so small so I think its taste of the buyer this time
Honestly, I’m tired of the sound of the E63. It may be louder, but it sounds so artificial/computerized, and because all AMG’s share the same engine, it gets boring.
Samuel Wu artificial??? thats a v8 masterpiece if anything sounds artificial its the bmw. They all use the same handbuilt engine for a reason. You sound like you’re better off buying a tesla sir...
Yeah, this might be one of the few videos really showing how close they are ... surprised that the M5 had 2 mph on the 1/4 though ... / 0.05s, so BMW as announced, and MB a tick faster vs mfg claim, keeps up my faith in physics :)
Stefen Cupovic S version of E63 is revealed at the same time of revealing E63 SO it's not upgraded version while Competition pack revealed 8 months after revealing M5 So comp pack is upgraded version of M5
Both cars are incredible. You pays your money (if you can afford it) and you makes your choice. No need for internet troll ("I can't afford the car, but my opinion is the law") fanboys. If I was a millionaire I'd have one of each parked in my garage.
the more I watched this the more I realized this was filmed at the Porsche Experience Center in LA.. right? I took out a 991 GTS, GT3 and Turbo on a low-friction circuit that looks identical to this as well as the "off road" background. Pretty fun experience and you guys make it look fairly easy! I did NOT have this down by the time I was done. Too bad you didn't do a lap comparison on the track there (although that circuit is defintel suited more for a cayman/boxster while the higher power 911s really would prefer some more room to stretch their legs)… regardless, fun episode! I love the E63 but I always come back to BMW.
Yea well, they are both immensely great super saloons. I am usually for BMW but it almost feels like the M5 is a bit understated exterior wise. What Mercedes has done to their exterior language the last 5 years must be acknowledged - This AMG has a sublime classic MB presence and great stance. I think it is to be expected that the next generations of BMW will be more expressive than the current. The BMW interior functionality is nearly always great but the MB has the upper hand here for exclusivity feel, a slightly greater attention to the line flow in the cabin makes it a bit more special. In the end, the choice is personal and it is a long time since I have been in between BMW and MB.
The bmw beats the merc only on track gripy roads because it's tires are more suitable for that area. but the merc is faster in normal dusty roads.hoewever the Performance are the same...
I've never seen a track like the one you guys were drifting on before. Very strange but in a good way. Looked like the cars were gliding on glass at 10 mph
This 2 cars aren’t rivals, they are just brothers from another mothers ❤️
well said
Eugen N i like this comment
Tell that to the sales departments.
Nope they have same mother (Germany) but fathers are different
Mother in the sense. Are these divided from one brand and came as different brands ?
Filling the void of Motortrend; very nice.
couldn't agree more
Edmunds Inside line was making the best car videos on RUclips before Motor trend went big. Then they shut down the channel due to some stupid corporate merger or something. It's good to see them producing quality content for car enthusiasts once again, albeit on a different channel, in a different format and with a completely different team of people.
AoshichanX # Motor Trend ? What's that??? RIP
Motor Trend were dead against BMW.
AMG E63S FOR EVER.
its dead the M5 COMP DESTROYED it.. what is e63s?
@@drdj69 destroyed it in launch speed and handling that's it, the m5 will never provide the sensation like the sound as good as the e63
@@drdj69 stick with your fake engine noise bud that's all you'll ever get with a BMW
@@Jeettravelz mmmmm says the guy that likes the brand that plays fake engine sounds through the speakers. (bmw that is)
BMW
BMW is back baby!
m5 comp is killing it
I’ll take the BMW anyday.
Cool vid, glad to see the two of you working together, both excellent at what you do.
Carlos Lago literally brought this Channel to life. This is the old Motortrend. The new Motortrend is horrible. Jason should join this show too.
Here for Carlos, this guy does the most informed un biased reviews on cars 🙌🏾
E63 AMG S the best!!
The new M5 is nice
nice and boring
Taurus Viking M5 is Nice and Smooth your boring
dont be jealous. whatever your name is lollll
Taurus Viking: You're the one that's jealous I like the M5
you like these nuts
Finally!!! Thanks Edmunds for actually dragging these two competitors when others wouldn't.
I love them both
BMW 💪
ruclips.net/video/di8glML5J8g/видео.html
I clearly choose M5👍
nice havent seen much of carlos
You two did awesomemin this video. Got me to smile with the "fun" button
AMG for life! That guy complained about E63S being less comfortable.. well those are Recaro sport seats, they are well known for not being comfortable. The luxury, the brand imagine, handcrafted Engine, AMG.
Real720 yea, in 1 video said bimmer mor comfy than merc, and in other videos and this planet merc is 5x more comfy
So what? he didn't complain the car was less comfortable, he noted a fact (trepeated by most road testers) and the fact that AMG put less comfortable seats in the car is their choice. You can't excuse it. The brand and the image? Yeah when it comes to super saloons the BMW M5 defines the brand and imagemin this segment, not AMG. All that said, both cars are incredible, and I'd be happy to have either or both parked in my garage if I could afford one. 99.9999% of whingers claiming pone is better than the other won't even sit in either car, let alone own or drive one. I have sat in a new M5 and it's fantastic. I just wish I could have driven it :)
Virakyuth Tha So M5 is more comfortable and trashes the E63S on every track and occasion. So what’s the benefit of the AMG then?
Let's not make any mistake, this M5 in particular is a tad better than the Benz save for the sound track from Benz, other than that, the BMW is the better car, Benz had the option of not making the recaro seats, but because they were hell bound to make the car less porky, they opted for these seats, so it's no excuse, they developed a harsh ride to minimise body roll, it's no excuse, they need to take lessons from Munich, let's swallow our pride and give praise where it is due, this M5 has toppled the Benz in all aspects except the sound track, PERIOD
Virakyuth Tha
SHUT UP BENZ FANBOY
Great video, both lovely cars!
ruclips.net/video/di8glML5J8g/видео.html
@@patricia-isaac What the fuck dude.
Why u r everywhere?
@@mdalamgirhussain7917 I know he is everywhere its a nightmare.
The Best Or Nothing ! 💪
Stronger than Time ! 💪
MERCEDES 👑
Now that's a review that no one's done before. Thumbs up!
Two of the best cars on the road today this is a great video and like the commentators it comes down to personal likes and dislikes but for me I’m a BMW M5 fan as that is my daily beater.
Great job guys.
good review. but something was left out,the capacity of both cars,the E63s is a 4.0l and the M5 4.4l. that means their power delivery, despite power and torque ratings mean their delivery is slightly different in certain parts of the rev range.
another thing ive noticed is that(watched a ton of reviews between the two(coming to the comp M5,not there yet!!!),it is literally 50/50 as far as drags are concerned,half of the reviews show the E63 quicker than the M5,the other half,vice verse. after all ive watched,id say it was a tie(including illegal races).
the comp M5,yes it is quicker in almost every vid ive seen,bar three(more where the comp takes it). yipee for BMW fans.
drive: most reviews say the same thing,M5 better for comfortable daily driving,BUT,when it comes to emotional driving,most have said that the E63s,is more fun,steering more precise and most importantly,the engine noise from the engine inside the car(and outside) is pure engine. no fake channeled engine sounds via speakers or whatever they add to make it sound real inside the car. that is when i lost respect for BMW,the " ultimate drivers car" is now an ultimate farce!!!! if you a true BMW FAN,IM SURE YOU WOULD AGREE.....
i am an AMG fan,BUT(PLEASE READ THIS) BUT LOVE THE BMW TOO. BOTH ARE GREAT CARS,MAKE NO MISTAKE!!!! where BMW beats the Benz,in one area,it looses in another and vice verse,FACT. what we can be greatfull of is that these cars exist,before the full or more hybrid era takes over. hope you all can see this is a fully unbiased opinion from an AMG NUTTER!!!!! YES ID STILL GO FOR THE E63,BUT WOULD HAVE EITHER CAR,ANY DAY IN MY GARAGE WITHOUT ANY HASSLES.
Carlos, glad to see you're back making great vids!
I would love to see bootleg Adam Sandler and Carlos team up
This channel deserves a lot more subs. Thanks for the free awesome content!!
Wonderful job! Nice review. You did pick up what MT toss away-people.
Finally equal comparison!
Jay Scott haha only ever an equal comparison when the m car wins. Hilarious!
3.17 sec to 60? What's next? Competition Pack 3 sec flat? Those are crazy numbers !
Keep it up Carlos !
Two awesome cars and two awesome hosts, Solid review !!
True car guys will know both cars are beautiful creations and will appreciate the technology and ingenuity that goes into these machines.
Wonderful to see you guys have fun! Brings life to the video. Quite a departure from the usual staid stuff that Edmunds usually churns out. Kind of like what MT videos used to be at their peak...before their greed and poor talent management fueled kamikaze.
I’d still take the E63 🤷🏻♂️
xxthehuskycaboosexx same but both are great cars
I would take the one from Munich
I'm going for the more sporty M5, lovely design and quality interior that's more gratifying
Bmw loser
BMW M///POWER FTW we all know that, so stop and quit your winin'
Both are excellent cars....excellent brands....final choice is pure personal preference.
I just cannot make up my mind about these two.
I think I just about prefer the interior of the Merc, and the sound too.
They are basically the same speed, so that’s not an issue.
The hifi upgrade too - is INSANE. I’ve heard that, it sounds unreal.
But the ride comfort and the looks of the Beemer are factors to consider too.
And the fact that Mercedes do an estate - or wagon - might tip the balance too.
Probably would ultimately go for the Mercedes.
Fortunately I’ll never have the money to buy either, so my problem’s sorted for me. 😂
So this is where Carlos went. Love this guy
I haven't seen a video with you guys in it before, but the quick skimming I did on this, I laughed quite a bit! You guys are great together for this stuff *Cheers
Imagine when the M5 Competition comes out! The Car game is over!! Merc going to have to bring out a E63s squared to beat it haha
Whoever makes it last makes the fastest car
Motortrend became too much personality and exaggeration, stay true boys. Keep it up.
I totally agree. I couldn’t stand Jonny and Fake Sandler. These guys are great.
I totally agree. I couldn’t stand Jonny and Fake Sandler. These guys are great.
These two cars are so equally matched. It's always a toss up. However, I have seen more wins for the M5. If the AMG lost some weight it would come out on top, but any sedan hitting 2.9 zero-60 and 11 flat for 1/4 mile is wicked fast. I'd chose the mighty E63 S 4Matic+ over the M5 any day
Happy to see Carlos here!
That M5 is fast people question test for the M5 doing 2.8 but this vid recorded 2.9 the M5 could be possible for 2.7 imagine the competition pack
M5 is always king. Just wait for Competition
It’s funny that probably 98% of all the hate comments, either side, are from people who don’t own and have never driven either car
Carlos review for the M5 F10 on motor trend was legendary
Thumbs up if you think he should make one for the new M5
"... M5 and all of its competition"
Killed it!
M5
Hi there! Love me some "Head to Head", keep it coming Carlos.
Finally good channel about cars..
Carlos!!! Is that you!!?? Finally!!
at the end personal taste decides wich is for you, i go for the M but im a BMW Fanboy and i understand everyone who choose the AMG
BMW has made it clear that the M5 is unbeatable
great honest review. good to see carlos. subscribed :)
It is so good to see ya, Carlos. Keep up the good work. Luv the M5, btw... 🚙
They´re both outstanding cars and should I ever be able to afford either one they´re definitely on my list... BTW, its up up down down left right a b select start.
This is the new Motortrend! Thanks Edmunds 😄
It's funny how this is definetely the best E63 AMG of all time, while people can't even make their mind if this is the best M5 there ever was but it still beats the E63 easily...it shows that Bavarian engineering goes even further than the other Germans
BMW BMW BMW BMW is the world bossssss ... merc boys wanna swap sides since 1990's but to proud to admit
Love BMW, but props to Mercedes for the power! Truly insane, BMW is still faster but for the first time in forever the E63 actually put up a competition.
Is it a requirement for this the manufacturers to make launch control so damn confusing and complicated? Why can it just be one button you press like sport mode?
Blake Swan you mean why can't they just 'Porsche' it.
I guess the idea is that you don't accidentally engage the launch control.
Blake Swan That would be to easy, the Germans don't like easy!
In my Audi, simply put it in Dynamic mode, turn off traction control, and you can launch it.
Its not as complicated as they always make it seem. Also when you actually own the car you'll barely ever use the function. Hence from a UX perspective it's behind a few layers.
What road surface is that
I like the M5 a little better, but still like the MB. The interior is the biggest difference maker...BMW interior looks better IMO.
golfbuddy1969 seriously....
you clearly haven't sat in them then. the dash alone makes the MB interior superior
sky 22 geesh! You “clearly” don’t understand what “IMO” is. I’m “clearly” not saying what you should like, but I’m “clearly” saying what appeals to me. It is “clearly” an opinion.
Is that clear enough?
sky 22 the MB have a better interior designe but the quality is poor in comparison with Audi and BMW, in quality the M5 is better...
Michael no the build quality of all of them is equally great and the difference between them is not even noticeable because how similar great build quality they have.
I think these cars are so close its more down to the buyers taste more then anything, yes the M is better built, faster, and maybe faster on track, but the diffrence is so small so I think its taste of the buyer this time
Excellent review guys!
Great video guys ! Keep it up and you will get more subscribers
Where is that low friction circuit located? Can I drive there and how much do they charge?
GREAT VIDEO 👍
NO BULLSHIT.. GOOD WORK GUYS !!
The launch control in the BMW de-activates after 10 seconds. But, as professionals, you already know this.
The m5 came out a year after...the top speed is irrelevant. The benz interior and engine sound are light years ahead of bmw.
You must be deaf....cant argue with somebody who likes boring cars.
Honestly, I’m tired of the sound of the E63. It may be louder, but it sounds so artificial/computerized, and because all AMG’s share the same engine, it gets boring.
nicholas yegani you have heard driven both then eh?
Samuel Wu artificial??? thats a v8 masterpiece if anything sounds artificial its the bmw. They all use the same handbuilt engine for a reason. You sound like you’re better off buying a tesla sir...
Sam Jones why buy this then? Stick to a 528i or e300... duhhh
BMW really makes you work for that launch control, I doubt the average owner will use it a lot.
Wow, the M5 is even more of a beast...by a small margin. I'm still loyal to MB so I'll take the E63 S 4matic+.
Celeste Hearn u won't because you haven't the money
Cucumber ....charming. I take my leave of you. You deserve no such attention.
Yeah, this might be one of the few videos really showing how close they are ... surprised that the M5 had 2 mph on the 1/4 though ... / 0.05s, so BMW as announced, and MB a tick faster vs mfg claim, keeps up my faith in physics :)
Great video, great cars, great presenters!
Carlos!!!!
Great to see You!
AMG E 63s 🇰🇿🇰🇿
I hate those ugly Mercedes tail lights, the old ones were so much better.
Both amazing cars and I'd take either one, but if I had to pick I'd go with the Benz.
And the M5 is regular not competition package the AMG is S model! What a beast M5
Check and mate E63s AMG...
Dont need the M5 COMPETITION💪🏻
GAME OVER AMG
TRY AGAIN🏁
Facemouk Redone hahaha finally the m actually wins a comparison and all of a sudden its a cake walk....you fanboys are embarrassing
m5 competition will completely destroy that taxi
ŠK its e63s dummy lolol like a comp pack m car the s varient of amg is the slightly upgraded version of same car.
Oh my god you are mean hahahahaha taxi hahahaha
ŠK you dum e63 s real competitor is m5 comp pack.
Stefen Cupovic S version of E63 is revealed at the same time of revealing E63
SO it's not upgraded version
while Competition pack revealed 8 months after revealing M5
So comp pack is upgraded version of M5
Hard time for BMW ..chasing taxi!
I'd love to see both of these in my Driveway... damn I'll fell like a King or Evil Dictator
The Merc has the much nicer sound, the BMW has a anoying sound inside which gives you headache on longer trips.
It's funny the 2005 M5 had a higher top speed than both these cars, 200mph+
They are limited, take limiter off and they can go 200+.
Without a top speed limiter they will do 200 plus all day
Yes sir both cars would do 200 plus
Go Edmunds!! - the video I wanted to see!!! And way better on this channel. More please?
What is that color called on the Merc?
What's with the volume difference between talking/music?
Anybody know where this was filmed?
This isn't even the competition pack M5 and it still beat the E63 *S*
Both cars are incredible. You pays your money (if you can afford it) and you makes your choice. No need for internet troll ("I can't afford the car, but my opinion is the law") fanboys. If I was a millionaire I'd have one of each parked in my garage.
LOVED THIS. MOAR
the more I watched this the more I realized this was filmed at the Porsche Experience Center in LA.. right? I took out a 991 GTS, GT3 and Turbo on a low-friction circuit that looks identical to this as well as the "off road" background. Pretty fun experience and you guys make it look fairly easy! I did NOT have this down by the time I was done. Too bad you didn't do a lap comparison on the track there (although that circuit is defintel suited more for a cayman/boxster while the higher power 911s really would prefer some more room to stretch their legs)… regardless, fun episode! I love the E63 but I always come back to BMW.
Two both great cars I would be happy with any of them
loan me one of your cars bro lol
Great job. Keep Carlos forever.
what is roll out at 348?
bmw of course. Its not called the ultimate driving machine for mothing
great marketing moniker
Yea well, they are both immensely great super saloons. I am usually for BMW but it almost feels like the M5 is a bit understated exterior wise. What Mercedes has done to their exterior language the last 5 years must be acknowledged - This AMG has a sublime classic MB presence and great stance. I think it is to be expected that the next generations of BMW will be more expressive than the current. The BMW interior functionality is nearly always great but the MB has the upper hand here for exclusivity feel, a slightly greater attention to the line flow in the cabin makes it a bit more special. In the end, the choice is personal and it is a long time since I have been in between BMW and MB.
Did Carlos leave motortrend?
cant wait for the competition pack..
the best test of these machines
i would like to know what kind of tyres they used. as far as i'm aware when these 2 were dragged on the same tyres the merc always won.....
The bmw beats the merc only on track gripy roads because it's tires are more suitable for that area.
but the merc is faster in normal dusty roads.hoewever the Performance are the same...
Great video! But can you lower the music's volume pls? It's way too high compared to the other parts in the video
I've never seen a track like the one you guys were drifting on before. Very strange but in a good way. Looked like the cars were gliding on glass at 10 mph