yes, they *are* singing it live but there's still mr / prerecording in some parts where some of the notes are high and are on troubled while dancing like near the beginning and the "oh my my my" part.
@@amyk3145 support track, pre recording, music recording they are all the same thing. and this mr doesn't only show up on the oh my my my part. you can hear it in the very beginning with the music itself and very clearly on jimin's part. the pre recording goes from the beginning to the end. it cant just show up on one part.
Honestly, everyone does it in K-pop. Is understandable tho, you can't sing perfectly while you're dancing but you need to be able to sing at this level of stability. The only k pop group that I know that can really sing exactly like the studio version is mamamoo and maybe gfriend (I don't know so many boy bands).
Jimin did so well here. And he really improves a lot for this cb. I've been saying this a lot these days, but still i want to say it again. I'M PROUD OF YOU, JIMIN
@@melis2141 well sorry to spoil the fun. But i appreciate his 'weak ass voice' in this era more than in fake love. He works hard to improve his vocal and WE appreciate that effort. If you don't like his 'weak ass voice' then get off here. Jimin didn't live just to please you. Go find something better and good luck with that. And btw, im done replying and going to watch his fancam. So bye 🤐
you can hear them in the background ( the most clearest at the oh my my my ) . they're really quiet and subtle though, that's how they're supposed to be anyways.
@@yoah9759 Jin still live 100%, the supporting beat have been turn on in some unmainly part and BTS didn't sing, but in some main part, when the sound been turn on, they still live If you try to hear, you will see that, BWL's vocal has a high tone so vocalist voice are thin and high, audio and live music are different so if someone removed the sound, it's very hard with live one so with thin voice, it's can make their voice unclearly like what they sing If you don't belive, you can hear Mic Drop ones with audio sound
@@doremirse9950writing all those paragraphs isn't going to change the fact that no one in BTS can sing. Good thing they are all going to the military 😂😂
Sorry but do you know LIVE BAND here is meant for??? For sure, I gotta say that in SNL it was all directly including the chorus 'oh my my my' because it was sung behind!! Can you see them or you saw them but you didn't care about it???
Are you sure you understand what I say ?? This is a LIVE BAND performance on SNL. Of course, before performing on stage, BTS and SNL discussed that how they could sing and dance without being short of breath and brings a great performance to the audience!! and the link you gave me was said the chores is not very hard ! Are you sure?? Have you practiced it? And about the packing track, why don't you ask the SNL for it?? They will give you the answer!! *THE SNL IS ALL LIVE, MY BAE!! ☺️☺️
@@turtle_rabbit5298 yes, i know this is mr removed video so i have to complain about it. This video has removed the vocals lines completely, although it was completely live, and the video makes the vocals' voices weaker than usual when they sing on the stage. From the viewers' perspective, they will judge BTS's vocals voices as weak and unattractive. It was the mistake of the removed ones that made me have to complain.
it is live, but it doesn't mean that there's no mr in the back. you can hear the mr in parts like the "your one your two" and "oh my my my" in the original video. those lines were *not* sung by the background vocals and they are there to harmonize with their voices only. ( the oh my my my is different than jungkook's note and voice, clearly a harmonization to the main vocal. ) the boys and this channel both did a good job on their work so there's no need to attack the channel.
Temur Alimurad yo wtf, it’s basic knowledge that SNL is live. We do know performances of bts where there is either backtrack or HEAVY backtrack and when it’s sung almost completely live. And bc this one had only backtrack on some parts where they didn’t even sing it but lipsynced to it this video is pretty unnecessary.
Yeah it was a live performance with back and bts was singing over the backtrack so after editing the video what we are hearing is their original raw voice
glad they're now a practically disbanded group so they can't terrorize the music industry with their vocals anymore but i need them gone forever🤞🏽 hopefully these flopping solo projects made them realize they're irrelevant individually
@@btsmochimi7924 womp womp.. they can get thousands of daesangs it still won't make them sing well. Year 2023 and all 7 twinks get shipped off to the military for good (to get their prolasped holes more loose than ever) god is good 😊😋
BTS solos were waaaaaaay more successful than Blackpink's whole career as s group. They're coming back next year to take over the music industry meanwhile jennie and Lisa looking for their next stage to strip at for some opportunities 😂
Live band doesn't mean that they are singing live 100% live. Especially with the dancing, they most likely use back vocals. This is what they get. Props to rap line and jungkook!
@@wherediditgowrongiknowwest4939 yes there was a backing track but the sound is so LLW , to the point you cant hear it and can see if they are lipsincing.
I love how y’all know that it’s bad and that’s why you are only praising the rap line like ‘wow the rap line did their best’ it’s okay people, the performance was really happy and energetic, but never ignore the value of the singing, saying stuff like ‘at least they tried’ doesn’t not help. They are professional artists so they know they should do better.
U expect Jungkook to be unstable at first...but perfectly does the ad-lib at last..what a wonderful mr removed for a live band performance.. But they were able to sing perfectly in mic drop...with a much harder choreo than this...I find it hard to believe..
I think u should watch more mr removed video in that same video.. In others video i find thier vicals quite good.. I think something is wrong in this video
@@edna7683 I don't know why ARMY's like you get so defensive to the point where you lie to yourself. Do you really think they sounded good???? Answer that honestly without being biased because you know deep down that they all sounded terrible except jungkook.
@@ren3462 wkwkwk, the power of love make u blind and also deaf. maybe now, they already increase their performance and their breath. but in this video, omgggg.. and so funny to see how much people in this video comment if they are stable. wkwkwk
@@U_M287 to make this clear. i don't hate bts, but also i am not really fan of them. in here i just talk about this video, not all their performance. what i want is only, you guys accept in this video their voice are not stable. please just telling the truth, not because you guys love them so much, until they make a mistake you guys just accept that and do not do nothing
@@user-vb8rk7ge1b 무슨 소리세요? 이거 한국 일반 커뮤에서 본 사람들 해외 반응 다 좋았던 무대고 해외언론에서 칭찬한 무대에요~ 미국 snl 라이브 무덤이라고 할 정도로 음향도 안 좋고 라이브 적나라게 들려서 라이브 망친 팝가수들 있고요~ 방탄 이날 무대 밴드 라이브에 코러스까지 현장 라이브였고 당시 아무도 저 무대로 시비 건 사람 없었어요 밴드 라이브이고 공연이 생방이고 국내 해외 실시간 반응 다 좋았는데 뜬 금 몇 년 후 본 공연 mr 제거를 개인이 멋대로 하고 이제 와서 못 한 공연이었다고? 그 동안 방탄 라이브 잘해서 추천까지 됐던 무대에요~~ 그리고 애초에 mr 조차도 아닌 올 생라이브 무대 mr 제거를 한다고 올라온 게 기과 하구요. 전문가도 어디에서 인증도 받은 것도 아닌 지극히 개인이 멋대로 조작 가능한 mr 제거를 뭘로 믿나요? 교묘하게 노래 높낮이 등 얼마든지 조작이 가능한 게 mr 제거이고 진짜 웃긴게 립싱크인데 그걸 mr 제거라고 올린 것도 봤습니다~
they definitely have, compare jungkook adlibs towards the end to the rest of the vocals beforehand, even his own. they’re crisper and how we actually hear it during the performance. they’ve done something to the audio surely.
No no no, you gotta be honest with yourself. RM JK Jhope and Suga were the only ones who did well. V Jimin and Jin sounds nothing like the original song here
@@Youknowwhathido i was talking about the vocal line, not the rap line. And IN MY OPINION they did a great job. They can't sound like the original song, it is impossible. They were singing in a high pitch while dancing. But they handled the situation really well.
Lol all of them did great😍 we can't blame them for *'bad'* vocals, things like that happen. (Especially when you are stressed.) People easily say that they did not do great when they themselves cannot sing also💅 I'm not saying that everybody does this but GURL IF YOU DO... I DARE YOU TO SING BOY WITH LUV WITH THE RIGHT VOCALS AND NOTES AND DANCE TO IT AS WELL, AND ALSO MAKE SURE TO MAKE THE PERFORMANCE PERFECT OR ELSE.✂️🗡
It’s so funny when some ppl said this is band version so why we need mr.removed But you can’t deny some member run out of breath when singing and dancing at the same time.
Its such a shame how you based one performance to judge their entire career. I bet no one likes you for your personality where growth isn't accepted. This is more of a 'you' problem😊 pls get help
Genuinely wondering why armys said this performance is great, especially jimin v jin, even on the original video and with the MR they still sounds awful? I mean are you guys fr? Or just deaf?
Ik that everyone makes excuses when we want the best out of someone.... But my excuse is that they have been working none stop and that takes a toll on the body and your abilities
I dont think we need any excuse. They are humans too its okay if they werent their best. They were dancing anddd singing so it will obviously cause some variations They were anyways really good
That's not a valid excuse, they just came from a break, it's their first performance live after the comeback They aren't rookies, they have been in the industry for 6 years Most groups can do better than them. Stop excusing their mediocrity, stop being shielded, admit you overrate them.
@@idnknw3691 I see u every where.... Every one know how amazing BTS is at live...u need to check out other Mr removed...and tbey don't sound too bad though...they are breathing...is that bad.....BTS are the best at singing live among boy idols....
the guy that starts at the beginning HAS to be the worst singer i've ever heard in my life this whole group is just... maybe the song is too hard for them?
They removed all Jin's and JK's head voice, which i literally dont understand 🤔 this is 100% live, they sang with live band, so when ppl do mr removed, there some head voice is automatically removed, because the mr removed software take that as prerecord parts. U guys can go listen to mcountdown mr removed, which is much more accurate, since the boys sang with an official prerecord one.
This is not an MR Removes this is "Mic Feed" from the Show Feed audio. Which can only be extracted on the raw video itself. Basically this is where all the Mic Sound, Bass, and Drum goes.
SNL무대에서 부른걸 엠알제거 한거같은데 원래 SNL은 음향 구리기로 유명하기 때문에 거기서 라이브를 괜찮게 하면 실력 좋은 가수라는 타이틀이 붙어요 그렇기 때문에 이 엠알제거는 음향이 구린상태이고 엠알제거할때 일부러 뭉개고 못부르는것처럼 보이게 만든 악의적인 행동입니다 다른 엠알제거 들으시면 음원이랑 똑같습니다
@@nouranbtsarmy3362 That has backtrack. This is MR Removed. This is the real vocals without any editing like in the official video. It removes all backtrack and instrumentals. These are famous in Kpop because it shows the real voices behind backtracks and autotuned. You can't manipulate voices to sound different its not edited.
This is not well removed. It's not possible to hear the backing vocals. If you see the official video there are three singers doing the backing vocals.
i’m an army but I honestly don’t know why you guys are saying everyone here is good. the rap line and jungkook were good, but v, jin and jimin needed some work. don’t get me wrong, they’re talented but they did badly this performance. I think they were more stable in the Idol era because there wasn’t as much vocals in it but whatever 💁♀️
Am I the only one who think these vocals are funny?? They really use Autotune in their live and the difference with MR and without MR is obivious. Some of the cm said they eat CD and I'm like "No Way" 🤣 They cant be sounded like this if they eat CD guys
V, Jimin and Jin have a lot of voicecracks especially when they sang fake love with Charlie Puth but when jungkook started singing, the moment changed instantly, his voice is just amazing sorry to say this but compare to the other 3 vocalist of bts, jungkook is the only vocalist who can sing stable while dancing. (bts rappers are all stable)
Woah Suga nailed it... Woah J-Hope nailed it... Woah RM nailed it... Woah Jimin nailed it... Woah V nailed it.. Woah jungkook nailed it... Woah Jin nailed it.. Edit: wait wait wait how many LIKES!?? 74? OH MY GOD THANK YOU SO MUCH GUYS
mr을 제거해야지 가수 목소리까지 지워버리는게 mr제거입니까? 똑바로 만드세요 교묘하게 멤버들 노래부르는 부분을 거의 안들리게 만들었잖아요.마이크를 입에대고 부르는데 소리가 거의 안난다는게 말이 안됩니다. 게다가 평소멤버들의 실력을 봤을때 그리고 무대봤을때 절대 이렇게 들릴수가없는데 사람들 오해하게 만들지말고 삭제하던가 다시만들던가 하세요. 진짜 화나네요
@@amyk3145 ruclips.net/video/7Udkii9bNO4/видео.html this is the real one...u can understand cause the voice in this Mr removed does not seem like BTSs but in the one which I have sent the link of...u can clearly hear our boys voice
@@justrozes and btw i did not mean that "eligibility " for u but some other random trolls that I saw. But still I should not have said it to anyone wihout knowing. But it just made me think that judging idols might be wrong. Especially coz I have seen people irl not being able to do what idols do yet hate on them. Once Again I am extremely Sorry and I feel very bad rn For what I said.
![(ENGSUB)[Full ver.2] BTS Boy With Luv Global Press Conference (방탄소년단 작은 것들을 위한 시 기자간담회) [통통TV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/lJKUKLoOQ8o/mqdefault.jpg)
![(ENGSUB)[Full ver.2] BTS Boy With Luv Global Press Conference (방탄소년단 작은 것들을 위한 시 기자간담회) [통통TV]](/img/tr.png)
![[MR Removed] BTS (방탄소년단) - ANPANMAN_180603 (O)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/iO1dYkjYkRI/mqdefault.jpg)
![[MR Removed] BTS (방탄소년단) - MIC Drop_190413 (S)](/img/1.gif)
The performance WAS LIVE why would we need an MR removed...
Albad ka thankGod someone said this
yes, they *are* singing it live but there's still mr / prerecording in some parts where some of the notes are high and are on troubled while dancing like near the beginning and the "oh my my my" part.
@@myuzmi928 it doesnt really matter tho, issa common thing so why would we need this mr remove
@@amyk3145 obviously cause there's mr / pre recordings ?? the point of the channel sweetie.
@@amyk3145 support track, pre recording, music recording they are all the same thing. and this mr doesn't only show up on the oh my my my part. you can hear it in the very beginning with the music itself and very clearly on jimin's part. the pre recording goes from the beginning to the end. it cant just show up on one part.
SNL stage is live band. Do you know what it mean? It is live not need to make a mr removed.
still need,cause they are using backsound
Klorgiest um, that was very unnecessary
@Klorgiest and why do you have to compare them?
Honestly, everyone does it in K-pop. Is understandable tho, you can't sing perfectly while you're dancing but you need to be able to sing at this level of stability. The only k pop group that I know that can really sing exactly like the studio version is mamamoo and maybe gfriend (I don't know so many boy bands).
@Klorgiest lmao why you have to drag another group to praise them 😅
jungkook amazing as always!
Why nobody talk about Yoongi Hoseok and NamJoon rap? Soooooo stable
They 3 are awesome 💃
hhahahaha... true =) raphuyn are so cool =)
bcz they sang when the dance was on break. so i know they'll be so stable✊😔
@@bidibabidiboo8473 hoseok did his rap while he dance too, proud of him
park jimin lmao u knw how energetic is hoseok when dance comes in his life nd at the same time he sounded just like in the mv 👑
Jungkook's stro~ng~er~~~ so stable!!! But why am I here? It was sung live right?
hoseok voice so stable,,, jungkook too.. so amazing..!!!
Jungkook is perfect (Y) super voice and stability
Jimin did so well here. And he really improves a lot for this cb. I've been saying this a lot these days, but still i want to say it again. I'M PROUD OF YOU, JIMIN
I'm was surprised he sing clearly. I'm so proud of him. He getting better. 😭👍❤
jimin did so well?? I have to laugh lmao
@@melis2141 is everything okay at home?? We don't need some salty ass in here. If you don't like what i said, then go.
@@nurfazilah175 yall are literally praising his week ass voice- I laughed. I mean jimin's voice was good in fake love era, what happened to him?
@@melis2141 well sorry to spoil the fun. But i appreciate his 'weak ass voice' in this era more than in fake love. He works hard to improve his vocal and WE appreciate that effort. If you don't like his 'weak ass voice' then get off here. Jimin didn't live just to please you. Go find something better and good luck with that. And btw, im done replying and going to watch his fancam. So bye 🤐
Jungkook adlibs and the way he said stronger!
Even if he is give less lines he proves himself to be a main vocalist
ruclips.net/video/fU0LsBTsoQ4/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/liHJrxCSF6o/видео.html
he was not given less lines??????
@@user-yr6mr7ut5p he has second least lines dude in bwl and 8 sec screen time
@@maddiesama lmao no, he's first/second in line distribution
@@maddiesama and he's second along with hoseok in screen time
*Jungkook was really stable and so was the rap line!* ❤️
TRENCH TRASH Jungkook and the rap line always be stable
TRENCH TRASH this mr removed is not real tho
When he isn't
Whatever it is fake or not, JK is always the one can sing live perfectly. We don't need Mr Removed to prove 😊
tbh the rap line don't have to dance that much on their part.
Why can’t u hear the background vocalists? They were singing live.
you can hear them in the background ( the most clearest at the oh my my my ) . they're really quiet and subtle though, that's how they're supposed to be anyways.
아 정국아 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 오맘마아 이거너무 귀엽다
오 마이 마이 마이 인데...
남성가족부 알아요 ：） 팬들끼리 따로 부르는 언어가 있어요
진홍엄 네
그거 정국이가 부른거 아니에요 ㅜㅜ
와 한국인이네!
Golden voice's JungKook
J-hope's voice is literally not out of breath at all.. amazing
Yaassh 🙌
He always be the most stable
he is the best in this video.
that's main dancer for you 👌
@@kookieda yea, i think people always talk about JK being the most stable, but hobi is just as stable if not even more i think lol
jungkook killed it
I thought we stopped trusting mv removed videos after what happened to blackpink.
what happened?
Learn to recognize the fake ones, the pre recorder and you'll be ok
@@lokifromtheblog A channel edited their voices on purpose. I can't remember which one tho.
Their outfit is pink in that performance
@Enyå same..thats the only one i trust
let me edit my comment so people in my replies gets weird
It's not fake, there was a backing track
twitter.com/hmmmGuessWho/status/1117306183713525761?s=19
@@idnknw3691 that isn't backing track
It's a kinda support beat
It's just on in part: oh my my my, ah yeah,...
The rest are from live band behind
@@caoquyphi8978 there was a backtrack but only at 3-4 parts especially in jin 's part
@@yoah9759 Jin still live 100%, the supporting beat have been turn on in some unmainly part and BTS didn't sing, but in some main part, when the sound been turn on, they still live
If you try to hear, you will see that, BWL's vocal has a high tone so vocalist voice are thin and high, audio and live music are different so if someone removed the sound, it's very hard with live one so with thin voice, it's can make their voice unclearly like what they sing
If you don't belive, you can hear Mic Drop ones with audio sound
@@idnknw3691 can you shut the fuck up with the backing track comments
JK's voice so stable💜💜💜
Bengek😭😭 Iyain deh.
@@fasthabhiqulisqhoirota463 😭😭😭😭😭
j-hope sounds exactly like the studio version
Yet armies have the audacity to speak on other groups' vocals.
@@doremirse9950 my faves can sing live, and that too better than bts
@@doremirse9950writing all those paragraphs isn't going to change the fact that no one in BTS can sing. Good thing they are all going to the military 😂😂
@@arcnyxand if your favs are males they are going to. No one is safe
@@arcnyx they can sing pretty well, And they are in the military, still receiving awards and slaying
ruclips.net/video/-_I4XAotKnY/видео.html
Jungkook's voice is so strong, so beautiful. Omg he's so perfect😍
Lompada Lolopae if you feel bad, you can click back. Vậy nên đcmm ko nghe thì cút 😃
@Lompada Lolopae you clearly don't understand what you're saying, stop shaming yourself
Sorry but do you know LIVE BAND here is meant for???
For sure, I gotta say that in SNL it was all directly including the chorus 'oh my my my' because it was sung behind!! Can you see them or you saw them but you didn't care about it???
There was a backing track
twitter.com/hmmmGuessWho/status/1117306183713525761?s=19
Are you sure you understand what I say ??
This is a LIVE BAND performance on SNL. Of course, before performing on stage, BTS and SNL discussed that how they could sing and dance without being short of breath and brings a great performance to the audience!!
and the link you gave me was said the chores is not very hard ! Are you sure?? Have you practiced it? And about the packing track, why don't you ask the SNL for it?? They will give you the answer!!
*THE SNL IS ALL LIVE, MY BAE!! ☺️☺️
This is mr removed video. Why are you complaining?
@@turtle_rabbit5298 yes, i know this is mr removed video so i have to complain about it.
This video has removed the vocals lines completely, although it was completely live, and the video makes the vocals' voices weaker than usual when they sing on the stage.
From the viewers' perspective, they will judge BTS's vocals voices as weak and unattractive.
It was the mistake of the removed ones that made me have to complain.
it is live, but it doesn't mean that there's no mr in the back. you can hear the mr in parts like the "your one your two" and "oh my my my" in the original video.
those lines were *not* sung by the background vocals and they are there to harmonize with their voices only. ( the oh my my my is different than jungkook's note and voice, clearly a harmonization to the main vocal. )
the boys and this channel both did a good job on their work so there's no need to attack the channel.
THIS IS ACTUALLY A LIVE PERFORMANCE SO NO NEED FOR MR REMOVED
typical delusional bts fangirl
some voice got distorted
Temur Alimurad yo wtf, it’s basic knowledge that SNL is live. We do know performances of bts where there is either backtrack or HEAVY backtrack and when it’s sung almost completely live. And bc this one had only backtrack on some parts where they didn’t even sing it but lipsynced to it this video is pretty unnecessary.
@@temuralimurad9561 typical hater
@@temuralimurad9561 typical dumbass hater
JUNGKOOK’S VOICE ❤️
sounds awful. people who think this performance was lit are clearly gaslighting themselves
They sing better than trashpink💀
@@eu4ky4 oh nice name for them!
I think it was a live performance..so we don’t need mr removed
Mr removed was made for LIVE PERFORMANCE
Yeah it was a live performance with back and bts was singing over the backtrack so after editing the video what we are hearing is their original raw voice
Jungkook's adlibs❤
*JUNGKOOK VOICE IS SO BooTiFUl* !!!
Edit 1 : omg I have never got 90 likes in my life.Tysm guys
glad they're now a practically disbanded group so they can't terrorize the music industry with their vocals anymore but i need them gone forever🤞🏽 hopefully these flopping solo projects made them realize they're irrelevant individually
I love it when this aged so bad...they still won a daesang in the year 2023. flop? You are an irrelevant person. Remember that.
You are a kid who dont have a happy home. Watch your tongue
@@btsmochimi7924 womp womp.. they can get thousands of daesangs it still won't make them sing well. Year 2023 and all 7 twinks get shipped off to the military for good (to get their prolasped holes more loose than ever) god is good 😊😋
BTS solos were waaaaaaay more successful than Blackpink's whole career as s group. They're coming back next year to take over the music industry meanwhile jennie and Lisa looking for their next stage to strip at for some opportunities 😂
@@OO27.88 blud you go watch their performances, way better than Bp`s whole career of str*pping and sh*tting 💀
Live band doesn't mean that they are singing live 100% live. Especially with the dancing, they most likely use back vocals. This is what they get. Props to rap line and jungkook!
THIS HAS ME ON THE FLOOR LAUGHING
BTS AND THEIR ARMYPIGS ARE GIVING A BAD REPUTATION TO KPOP BLACKPINK AND GGs ARE LITERALLY SAVING KPOP
Bp cant sing live lol
True, but that was earlier. They have improved a lot now. You can check out their encores or recent Mr removed videos.
Did you know this is LIVE? If you know,why did MR removed?
There was a backing track
twitter.com/hmmmGuessWho/status/1117306183713525761?s=19
It is not backing track
@@idnknw3691 Yes In the live I can still hear the recorded audio that's why I looked for the mr removed.
@@wherediditgowrongiknowwest4939 yes there was a backing track but the sound is so LLW , to the point you cant hear it and can see if they are lipsincing.
Because it was not clean live.
For example , for Jin and V.
I heard Jungkook's, J-Hope's and Suga's "live" singing very well
kook and hope, stable af damn
I love how y’all know that it’s bad and that’s why you are only praising the rap line like ‘wow the rap line did their best’ it’s okay people, the performance was really happy and energetic, but never ignore the value of the singing, saying stuff like ‘at least they tried’ doesn’t not help.
They are professional artists so they know they should do better.
LMFAO RIGHT
idk what to say anymoro. this is so bad.
@@loefiy and funny 😂
JUNGKOOKIE OH MY MY MY
You're sooo coool ❤️
Jungkook is always saving the live performances as usual. Stable king.
He is literally carrying whole vocal line
You’re basically saying Jungkook is the only one good singing live?? wtf
Are you army??
@@ItsMillaMilla that's what the fact is
They all did a good job.
아니...mr제거를 하려면 깔끔하게 해야죠..소리 없어지게 하면 어떡합니까..다른 분들 mr 제거 들으면 엄청 깔끔하던데.. 반주가 밴드라 제거가 잘 안되셨나요...
맞아여...
잘만 된거 같은디
ruclips.net/video/liHJrxCSF6o/видео.html
그러게요 다른 영상들은 깔끔하던데요..
아마 라이브 밴드 무대여서 음원과 달라서 그런것 같아요. 음원을 빼는건데
잘만 된거같은데
엄청 잘된건데요?;;
The rap line and Jungkookie are more stable than other :v
I'm sorry but I thought it gonna be true :)
Is your profile pic a painting? If it is, where is it from?
they are not singing so ofc. jk’s vocals were kinda flat during the first part.
U expect Jungkook to be unstable at first...but perfectly does the ad-lib at last..what a wonderful mr removed for a live band performance..
But they were able to sing perfectly in mic drop...with a much harder choreo than this...I find it hard to believe..
Bts Army mic drop doesn’t have amazing vocals, bwl is hardest in that part
I think u should watch more mr removed video in that same video.. In others video i find thier vicals quite good.. I think something is wrong in this video
Kookieeeee❤️
jungkook is so stable.
Jungkook is the only stable singer.
Thats no true xdxd
All are super stable
@@edna7683 I don't know why ARMY's like you get so defensive to the point where you lie to yourself. Do you really think they sounded good???? Answer that honestly without being biased because you know deep down that they all sounded terrible except jungkook.
@Real One 925 This is a fake mr removed, SNL is a live band = no playback. Watch the original video instead.
*jimin's voice cracks*
Fans: Oh my God he is so stable
Me:???
Jungkook is the only stable vocal and the rap line of course😍
@@Jenny-ml3st Where's the original? Drop the link please! Don't tell me the one in the SNL video?
you guys really said their voices are stable in live?
wow one performance isn’t
@@ren3462 wkwkwk, the power of love make u blind and also deaf. maybe now, they already increase their performance and their breath. but in this video, omgggg.. and so funny to see how much people in this video comment if they are stable. wkwkwk
@@damitrapaolo2195 wait did u listen to their lgo.film.out and all that performances.
@@damitrapaolo2195 u are literally busy with a vid of 2019.
@@U_M287 to make this clear. i don't hate bts, but also i am not really fan of them. in here i just talk about this video, not all their performance. what i want is only, you guys accept in this video their voice are not stable. please just telling the truth, not because you guys love them so much, until they make a mistake you guys just accept that and do not do nothing
원본 밴드라이브 미국 실시간 생방으로 방탄 해외에서 극찬 받은 무대에요 이 mr 영상 자체가 원본이랑 다릅니다 진짜 mr 제거를 이런 식으로 날조 하는 거 첨 보네요
@@user-vb8rk7ge1b 무슨 소리세요? 이거 한국 일반 커뮤에서 본 사람들 해외 반응 다 좋았던 무대고 해외언론에서 칭찬한 무대에요~ 미국 snl 라이브 무덤이라고 할 정도로 음향도 안 좋고 라이브 적나라게 들려서 라이브 망친 팝가수들 있고요~ 방탄 이날 무대 밴드 라이브에 코러스까지 현장 라이브였고 당시 아무도 저 무대로 시비 건 사람 없었어요
밴드 라이브이고 공연이 생방이고 국내 해외 실시간 반응 다 좋았는데 뜬 금 몇 년 후 본 공연 mr 제거를 개인이 멋대로 하고 이제 와서 못 한 공연이었다고?
그 동안 방탄 라이브 잘해서 추천까지 됐던 무대에요~~
그리고 애초에 mr 조차도 아닌 올 생라이브 무대 mr 제거를 한다고 올라온 게 기과 하구요. 전문가도 어디에서 인증도 받은 것도 아닌 지극히 개인이 멋대로 조작 가능한 mr 제거를 뭘로 믿나요?
교묘하게 노래 높낮이 등 얼마든지 조작이 가능한 게 mr 제거이고 진짜 웃긴게 립싱크인데 그걸 mr 제거라고 올린 것도 봤습니다~
Skpb MR Removed is jhope biased 😂🌚
jhope is stable in all songs and live.
Um stfu he is just talented bitch
I just feel like the vocal line voices have been distorted :)
Yes. Jin kept cutting in and out even though he was singing and just walking at one point. His mic?
Idk why i cant hear the jin's voice, i can tell if the backing track is so low
they definitely have, compare jungkook adlibs towards the end to the rest of the vocals beforehand, even his own. they’re crisper and how we actually hear it during the performance. they’ve done something to the audio surely.
Poor Jin...
Maybe they’re just tired
Jungkook and rapline ✨✨
Omg Jimin and Jungkook sings really well and Jin and V also sings so good
No no no, you gotta be honest with yourself. RM JK Jhope and Suga were the only ones who did well. V Jimin and Jin sounds nothing like the original song here
@@Youknowwhathido i was talking about the vocal line, not the rap line. And IN MY OPINION they did a great job. They can't sound like the original song, it is impossible. They were singing in a high pitch while dancing. But they handled the situation really well.
@@Youknowwhathido V was amazing what are you talking about?
MayMadness ohh?? i’m not sure maybe your ears betrayed you but they did amazing.
Lol all of them did great😍
we can't blame them for *'bad'* vocals, things like that happen. (Especially when you are stressed.)
People easily say that they did not do great when they themselves cannot sing also💅 I'm not saying that everybody does this but GURL IF YOU DO...
I DARE YOU TO SING BOY WITH LUV WITH THE RIGHT VOCALS AND NOTES AND DANCE TO IT AS WELL, AND ALSO MAKE SURE TO MAKE THE PERFORMANCE PERFECT OR ELSE.✂️🗡
It’s so funny when some ppl said this is band version so why we need mr.removed
But you can’t deny some member run out of breath when singing and dancing at the same time.
Jeon jungkook is not human!1!1
Suga, Jhope, RM, JK their stable voice is so woaaah
The rap line is so stable💞
yesss
There is no melody in rap so it should be stable.
I'm wondering how they debuted with these poor skills in the first place..!! Even the rookies with no training can sing better than them, that shame 🥴
Its such a shame how you based one performance to judge their entire career. I bet no one likes you for your personality where growth isn't accepted. This is more of a 'you' problem😊 pls get help
ruclips.net/video/-_I4XAotKnY/видео.html
Genuinely wondering why armys said this performance is great, especially jimin v jin, even on the original video and with the MR they still sounds awful? I mean are you guys fr? Or just deaf?
I forgot I'm watching a MR removed
7명 목소리가 다 고르게 들리는게 아닌데 이게 제대로 된건가요?
ruclips.net/video/_FIWDLtkS4s/видео.html
이게 더 깔끔하게 된 것 같아요
The comments saying that they did so well ⚰️⚰️⚰️ are your ears okay?
😭
ruclips.net/video/-_I4XAotKnY/видео.html
😂😂😂😂😂😂
What you doing with jungkook voices???😤
Earthquake: *happens
JK voice: do u hear sumn?
Ik that everyone makes excuses when we want the best out of someone.... But my excuse is that they have been working none stop and that takes a toll on the body and your abilities
I dont think we need any excuse.
They are humans too its okay if they werent their best.
They were dancing anddd singing so it will obviously cause some variations
They were anyways really good
@@tanyagoel7141 Good Point!!!
That's not a valid excuse, they just came from a break, it's their first performance live after the comeback
They aren't rookies, they have been in the industry for 6 years
Most groups can do better than them.
Stop excusing their mediocrity, stop being shielded, admit you overrate them.
@@tanyagoel7141
Seventeen & NCT sing while dancing & they sound ALOT BETTER.
@@idnknw3691 I see u every where.... Every one know how amazing BTS is at live...u need to check out other Mr removed...and tbey don't sound too bad though...they are breathing...is that bad.....BTS are the best at singing live among boy idols....
안티 논리: MR제거해서 못한거는 믿고 잘한거는 못믿겠다ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
ㅁ근데 이건 못했는데
...? 이거 못한거 아님?
이게 작은시 앨범 내고 첫 무대 snl에서 했던거 맞죠?
개못한거잖아요...
그러니까요 안티들은 이런영상만 믿고 라이브잘한영상을 절대 안믿음
Jungkook voice man always 🔥🔥🔥
이 영상보는 아미들 그냥 '신고' 눌러요. MR 제거 영상은 얼마든지 더 잘해보이게 혹은 더 못해 보이게 조작할 수 있는거 아시죠? 의도를 모르겠는데 짜증나네요.
잘만 하는 것 같은데
ruclips.net/video/RGzQddbpBI4/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/_FIWDLtkS4s/видео.html
뭐 잘못 한 것도 없는데 신고는 왜 하는 거예요... 그리구 잘만하는데
That actually so bad
my ears hurt me after I listen to this 💀
ruclips.net/video/-_I4XAotKnY/видео.html
WTF whit their vocals
ruclips.net/video/-_I4XAotKnY/видео.html
@@Modijiindiabtspavedthefkingway wawwww
Their vocal line here is a total mess except for maybe Jk.
Yes jungkook is the only real vocalist in bts
then u need ears
@@peyneust Right back at you. Not my fault you're in denial.
This is a fake MR remove
@@jah1504 Prove it.
the guy that starts at the beginning HAS to be the worst singer i've ever heard in my life
this whole group is just... maybe the song is too hard for them?
the contrast between jungkook sounding decent and j!min singing off tune in 3 different keys😭
Sorry but this is awful af...i don't understand why people in the cmnts section find it good...like my ears are bleeding
i'm sorry but only jungkook sounds good like what the actual fuck is going on with jimin and jin 😭
exo is still the best
이분 방탄 안티에요 목소리 다 뭉개놨어요..;;
This is his bulletproof anti. He's got his voice crushed.
ruclips.net/video/RGzQddbpBI4/видео.html
Jungkook unbelievable!
They removed all Jin's and JK's head voice, which i literally dont understand 🤔 this is 100% live, they sang with live band, so when ppl do mr removed, there some head voice is automatically removed, because the mr removed software take that as prerecord parts. U guys can go listen to mcountdown mr removed, which is much more accurate, since the boys sang with an official prerecord one.
This is not an MR Removes this is "Mic Feed" from the Show Feed audio. Which can only be extracted on the raw video itself. Basically this is where all the Mic Sound, Bass, and Drum goes.
SNL무대에서 부른걸 엠알제거 한거같은데 원래 SNL은 음향 구리기로 유명하기 때문에 거기서 라이브를 괜찮게 하면 실력 좋은 가수라는 타이틀이 붙어요 그렇기 때문에 이 엠알제거는 음향이 구린상태이고 엠알제거할때
일부러 뭉개고 못부르는것처럼 보이게 만든 악의적인 행동입니다 다른 엠알제거 들으시면 음원이랑 똑같습니다
My bias hobi out here sounding EXACTLY like the CD every damn time but being underappreciated.
This is totally fake...there might have been a back up track but we could clearly hear the live vocals....
0:46 MY STOMACH😭
Bro wtf 😂😂😂😂😂 armys still saying BTS voices are beautiful
Bro are u okay? 😂😂😂😂😂
not all of them are the best , i would say hoseok and jungkook sing the best tbh
It’s clear that the edit effected the real voice go watch the real one instead…
@@nouranbtsarmy3362 That has backtrack. This is MR Removed. This is the real vocals without any editing like in the official video. It removes all backtrack and instrumentals. These are famous in Kpop because it shows the real voices behind backtracks and autotuned. You can't manipulate voices to sound different its not edited.
@@triplej8666 they are singing with a live band y’all so dumb I swear
@@triplej8666 No this is edited
This is not well removed. It's not possible to hear the backing vocals. If you see the official video there are three singers doing the backing vocals.
its a nice live.... its just that it was only the rap and jungkooks voice who was stable... Its nice 😍 BUT CAN BE IMPROVED
Anthony Cabuenas this is fake sis
i’m an army but I honestly don’t know why you guys are saying everyone here is good. the rap line and jungkook were good, but v, jin and jimin needed some work. don’t get me wrong, they’re talented but they did badly this performance. I think they were more stable in the Idol era because there wasn’t as much vocals in it but whatever 💁♀️
Am I the only one who think these vocals are funny??
They really use Autotune in their live and the difference with MR and without MR is obivious.
Some of the cm said they eat CD and I'm like "No Way" 🤣
They cant be sounded like this if they eat CD guys
진짜 정말..객관적으로 딴건 모르겠는데 이건 ㄴㅓ무... 못하지 않았나? 왜 칭찬하지...?
빠순이 + 막귀로 무작정 빨아주는 외국팬들땜에
진심 개못하는데
@@케인아영양제먹어라 그럼 다른 퍼미션투댄스mr제거 영상은 뭐죠? 그때는 개잘했는데..근데 솔직히 외국인들 이번엔 이상하긴했음
@@정구가사랑한다고사랑 엠알이 제거 안됐나보네요 ^^
@@정구가사랑한다고사랑 외퀴들 특징이 댓글 무지막지 써내려서 댓글조작하는게 일상임
In every mr removed, jhope sounds the same.
I know right! His voice is always on point 🤗
Jhope is the most stable
V, Jimin and Jin have a lot of voicecracks especially when they sang fake love with Charlie Puth but when jungkook started singing, the moment changed instantly, his voice is just amazing sorry to say this but compare to the other 3 vocalist of bts, jungkook is the only vocalist who can sing stable while dancing. (bts rappers are all stable)
Jungkook and Jimin have the same sound source
Jin and Taehyung are so difficult to sing that they cannot make a sound.
This is the worst mr removed i have ever heard in my entire life.
so?
when i used to stan, jimin wasn't this bad back in 2015-18 bruh what happened 😭😭
probably because he wasn’t using the proper technique when singing so it damaged his vocal cords over time :o he sounds quite strained tbh in here
Excuse me Jimin is lead vocalist for a reason he vocals is really good now this is just artificial website which is probably demage their live vocals
Woah Suga nailed it...
Woah J-Hope nailed it...
Woah RM nailed it...
Woah Jimin nailed it...
Woah V nailed it..
Woah jungkook nailed it...
Woah Jin nailed it..
Edit: wait wait wait how many LIKES!?? 74? OH MY GOD THANK YOU SO MUCH GUYS
idk what to say anymore...
no one asked you loser
mr을 제거해야지 가수 목소리까지 지워버리는게 mr제거입니까? 똑바로 만드세요 교묘하게 멤버들 노래부르는 부분을 거의 안들리게 만들었잖아요.마이크를 입에대고 부르는데 소리가 거의 안난다는게 말이 안됩니다. 게다가 평소멤버들의 실력을 봤을때 그리고 무대봤을때 절대 이렇게 들릴수가없는데 사람들 오해하게 만들지말고 삭제하던가 다시만들던가 하세요. 진짜 화나네요
이게 쟤들 평소실력 입니다 ㅋㅋㅋ
정국이 진짜 너무 잘한다ㅜ 특히 뒤에 애드립부분 ㅜㅜ
랩라 편안하네
J hope and suga so stable
I can tell you take away some of their voices too but i know is unavoidable because you need to cut off the music
@@idnknw3691 the backing track was quite low though
@@poonamkothari2284 if the backing tracks was low we still can hear the actual voice, but idk in this video i cant hear jin's voice
@@amyk3145 this vedio is fake....i found the real one...
@@amyk3145 ruclips.net/video/7Udkii9bNO4/видео.html this is the real one...u can understand cause the voice in this Mr removed does not seem like BTSs but in the one which I have sent the link of...u can clearly hear our boys voice
@@poonamkothari2284 the video isnt available :(
You call them ARTISTS?????
Yes, it’s just one performance..?
@@U_M287 I said what I said. It's none of your business. At least you don't even know me.
@@justrozes ok i am sorry I just came off as a bit rude ig :)
@@justrozes and btw i did not mean that "eligibility " for u but some other random trolls that I saw. But still I should not have said it to anyone wihout knowing. But it just made me think that judging idols might be wrong. Especially coz I have seen people irl not being able to do what idols do yet hate on them.
Once Again I am extremely Sorry and I feel very bad rn For what I said.
LMAOOOO WHY I’M LAUGHING AT THE “oH mYmyMy” 😭
LMFAOAOSGEGEFWFW😭😭
@@werewolftaemin 🌽🌽🌽🌽🌽
it's so bad😭😭😭😭😭
진 심각하네 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
진은 괜찮을 것 같았는데 아니였음...