they're both great singers i don't understand the need to post hateful comments every time there are 2 talented women on yt. and i also really don't understand why they're being compared.
People always say Charice is just mimicking western artists. Well maybe yes, she WAS. But if you watch Beyonce's videos when she was younger, she also sounds like Whitney and all other artists people mention. What I'm trying to say is, we start copying others so we can build our own. Uniqueness is innate, I must say, but we still have to build it as we grow older. Try watching more recent videos and you'll see what I mean.
LMFAO! It's like when he misspells the word "finesse" like "fanest" to describe how his fave's screams are better than ones with far better technique than his, LMAO
@pritykazy Agreed.I prefer Beyonce because she naturally born to be a dramatic voice type singer and she has superior vocal control.Unlike Charice,lowering her larynx to get big fat tone,sometimes her super high chest register is uncontrollable.She need voice control.
I don't understand y people say that one singer is better than the other just because she hits higher notes?! Bee doesn't just hit high notes, she sings with a lot of emotions. Happy, angry or sad, u will really feel it from her. Not to mention her excellent facial expressions. Charice hits high notes brilliantly, no doubt about that. But her style has always been the same. All songs are sung the same manner, especially at the bridge to end part. I guess u know what i mean.
@beyoncetyrafan What are you saying!!! watch Charice singing "I wanna dance with somebody" so that you can see Charice singing and dancing at the same time!!!!
@lovindacheese But erm? Charice's g#5 just ate Beyonce's and her vocal cords aren't even completely developed yet . She may not be as popular as Beyonce but sorry she won in this video, plus Charice managed too hit eb6 as well and Beyonce only did exclamations.
@Ruboanti no!..she will not rise to popularity without her OUTSTANDING SKILLS!!!..let's compare the sales of their album?..and back on Destiny's Child..Beyonce already possessed ORIGINAL STYLE!..unlike that pepe..that pepe who sounds like jojo,..mariah,..beyonce..lady gaga..and anything more..she is not identified as charice. So how can you say pepe is CLEARLY A WAY BETTER SINGER??!..when you cannot declare the uniqueness in her style??..argue??
beyonce has beautiful voice, proportion to her beautiful face, beautiful body and beautiful soul!! charice has big voice, proportion to her big face that looks like a full moon!!! ha ha ha!!!!
@xmavrawr and what you see a video of beyoncewhen she was young ..even there she is beter than charice I think the people are strange they say they love beyonce but what I dont know its my opinion but charice dont have this strong and powerful and amazing voice like beyoncce~!!
Beyoncé gana a Charice en bajos: en vivo Bb2 y estudio: F#2. En altos: Bb5 (Beautiful ones and sex on fire, minut 3:14 I believe) y estudi G#5. Falsete: Eb6, E6: (Super Bowl and Mirrors) y un F6 Exclamado! Registro de silvido "Whistle" Bb6, C#7 y D7! Wow! :D
Well beyonce obviously smashed Charice. I mean the resonance, power, and control she exibited>>>>....until them G's hit. Really, Charice took the G5, and while Bey's was extremely short, Charice's G# was thin(but still impressive) soooo ima tie that note. Overall Beyonce destroyed her.
Just look at the last note G#5. Than you'll know, who can hit and hold better the high notes. Moreover, Charice can vibrate and hold G5, which you can't see in this video. I hate those comparisons between fans, but I have to say that Charice ' HAS NEVER LOST'
@idolfun14 my God !!! did i just read "beyonce can't sing anything other than R&B??" . hahahah .. have you watch her movie cadillac records ?! Damn . she can sing jazz, blues amazingly soulful. c'mon. your writings apparently proves that you don't know Queen Bee that much! unlucky you. lol :)))
how can you say charice can't sustain notes longer than beyonce? charice holds the higher notes longer than beyonce. for a 16 year old and has that much control already at the top of her range is awesome. beyonce is awesome also, love her new song, but she's a lot like christina. vocal runs all over the place. but in terms of singing a song straight she's ok like her version of "at last". etta james still sings that song better than anyone else.
@porschetweety Unique? Original? Says who? Her style is very Whitney, Celine, J Hud.......Pleeeease, no one in the biz has been original since the 2000's. Not even Bee or Gaga.
Not only does Beyonce win, but you chose some of the worst clips of those notes to use for her. She has hit WAY better E5s, F5s and F#5 with way better vibrato and resonance than that. Also, I dontsee the big deal about Charice's last G#5? She sang with an extremely high larynx and had zero vibrato on that note.
beyonce hands down! charice won the G5 and G#5. though she is very impressive but she's very one-dimensional. she has no style of her own and she has yet to sing her own song(s).
ano b discussion d2,galing o taas ng boses?hay nku ang mga pinoy tlga,sobrang naive.mkrinig lng ng mtaas n boses mgaling n.that's not what singing is all abt. d ptaasan ang lbanan. pgandahan! vocal production.now,whther or not you can hit a hi note,it's only 2ndary.kc kng taas lng pla ang basehan e d tumili k lng pla psado ka ng singer.e d sna sumikat c regine worldwide @ na-outpace nya pa c mariah & whitney kc mas mtaas ang chest voice nya kumpara sa 2. di yan pataasan mga ating.just so u know.
Are you saying that Filipino singers copy the westeners? I bet you don't even know what OPM is... Gloc9 does not copy songs. He sing rap in a unique way. Not like eminem who always adds the words sh*t and f*ck in his Lyrics.
@beyrock i agree 100% charice doesn't know how to dance and sing at the same time, she on;y knows how to sing, i'm not a hater i just hate it when people make stupid videos like these. Just stop making videos related to beyonce if there;s any negative thing in it. Thankyou
Wtf are you deaf... no offense Charice is a great belter, but Beyonce was off the chart. Beyonce's belt was WAYYY more powerful and she can actually sustain a note longer than Charice. The only note i liked from Charice was the F5, G5, G#5 everything else was ok.
Beyonce!
i love beyonces e5
Both are great
Beyonce is the queen;]
Beyonce notes were perfected I even got shocked like can she really do that
btw where can I find the performances that Beyonce's E5 and F#5 are from?
what's the name of the song where beyoncé hit the G#5??
rocketto8 why don't you love me. Beyonce hit Eb5s,F#5,G5andG#5 in this song
they're both great singers i don't understand the need to post hateful comments every time there are 2 talented women on yt. and i also really don't understand why they're being compared.
Beyonce always love you
People always say Charice is just mimicking western artists. Well maybe yes, she WAS. But if you watch Beyonce's videos when she was younger, she also sounds like Whitney and all other artists people mention. What I'm trying to say is, we start copying others so we can build our own. Uniqueness is innate, I must say, but we still have to build it as we grow older. Try watching more recent videos and you'll see what I mean.
LMFAO! It's like when he misspells the word "finesse" like "fanest" to describe how his fave's screams are better than ones with far better technique than his, LMAO
@HUGOM2C
lol HA!
how long does she have before she starts deterioating?
@FiskHandlarn1
Lol post the link where MJ asked her, i highly doubt it
@xmavrawr the point of the video was that it was trying to compare the vocals, not the career.
@pritykazy Agreed.I prefer Beyonce because she naturally born to be a dramatic voice type singer and she has superior vocal control.Unlike Charice,lowering her larynx to get big fat tone,sometimes her super high chest register is uncontrollable.She need voice control.
@lightningshock12 It was sung with an open throat.
such a short video...haha...there are better notes from charice now that she's been on tour with david foster for quite some time now
@WhitneyElizabethH Yeah but the frog is also only like 16 years old at the time..
I believe (the one fantasia and diana degarmo sings in american idol)
you guys really cant compare the two best singers..
they both superb lungs to bang those freakin high notes
@Breniznit
im kiddin with ya
What's the song when Charice hit a G#5
@lightningshock12 That G#5 was extremely thin....
I don't understand y people say that one singer is better than the other just because she hits higher notes?! Bee doesn't just hit high notes, she sings with a lot of emotions. Happy, angry or sad, u will really feel it from her. Not to mention her excellent facial expressions. Charice hits high notes brilliantly, no doubt about that. But her style has always been the same. All songs are sung the same manner, especially at the bridge to end part. I guess u know what i mean.
Maybe is the eco, but I gotta a dificult time to realize what's live or not from B.
Anyway, as a belter, Charice.
Beyonce, obviously. She sings with a neutral larynx.
Charice Pempengco best
@beyoncetyrafan What are you saying!!! watch Charice singing "I wanna dance with somebody" so that you can see Charice singing and dancing at the same time!!!!
beyonce and charice are great! also tiffany evans! go to musickidjg please
@lovindacheese But erm? Charice's g#5 just ate Beyonce's and her vocal cords aren't even completely developed yet . She may not be as popular as Beyonce but sorry she won in this video, plus Charice managed too hit eb6 as well and Beyonce only did exclamations.
Beyoncé, for me.
Charice have a little age and for that shr can do the highest notes. But Beyoncé live can scream a beautiful Bb5 brlted! :)
charice G#5 is effortless proven she can way alot higher
E5:tie
F5:beyonce
F#5:beyonce
G5:charice
G#5:charice
FOR ME...CHARICE IS MUCH BETTER IN VERY HIGH NOTES (G5,G#5)....
Charice is better at belting. But if we go beyond sustaining that particular belted note, I prefer Beyonce's vocal color and agility.
@xmavrawr she already is :)
@WhitneyElizabethH If i didn't know you were kidding ..i wouldnt have called charice 'the frog' twice in a row : /
Beyonce's G#5 is actually a G5. Please label the notes correctly.
Therefore, Charice wins.
Yeaa, It's a G#5!!
@Ruboanti no!..she will not rise to popularity without her OUTSTANDING SKILLS!!!..let's compare the sales of their album?..and back on Destiny's Child..Beyonce already possessed ORIGINAL STYLE!..unlike that pepe..that pepe who sounds like jojo,..mariah,..beyonce..lady gaga..and anything more..she is not identified as charice. So how can you say pepe is CLEARLY A WAY BETTER SINGER??!..when you cannot declare the uniqueness in her style??..argue??
beyonce has beautiful voice, proportion to her beautiful face,
beautiful body and beautiful soul!!
charice has big voice, proportion to her big face that looks like a full moon!!!
ha ha ha!!!!
@xmavrawr and what you see a video of beyoncewhen she was young ..even there she is beter than charice I think the people are strange they say they love beyonce but what I dont know its my opinion but charice dont have this strong and powerful and amazing voice like beyoncce~!!
charice all the way..
Beyoncé gana a Charice en bajos: en vivo Bb2 y estudio: F#2. En altos: Bb5 (Beautiful ones and sex on fire, minut 3:14 I believe) y estudi G#5. Falsete: Eb6, E6: (Super Bowl and Mirrors) y un F6 Exclamado! Registro de silvido "Whistle" Bb6, C#7 y D7! Wow! :D
@Breniznit
Brendy, the FROG SUCKS lol
sugar mama by beyonce
I can't even hear Beyonce G5 AND G#5
You used better examples of Charice hitting the notes in your other compilation against Celine Dion.
v=iHQjtlgefTk
Well beyonce obviously smashed Charice. I mean the resonance, power, and control she exibited>>>>....until them G's hit. Really, Charice took the G5, and while Bey's was extremely short, Charice's G# was thin(but still impressive) soooo ima tie that note. Overall Beyonce destroyed her.
E5-F#5: Beyonce
Charice takes the G's
Just look at the last note G#5.
Than you'll know, who can hit and hold better the high notes.
Moreover, Charice can vibrate and hold G5, which you can't see in this video.
I hate those comparisons between fans, but I have to say that Charice ' HAS NEVER LOST'
beyonce
@idolfun14 my God !!! did i just read "beyonce can't sing anything other than R&B??" . hahahah .. have you watch her movie cadillac records ?! Damn . she can sing jazz, blues amazingly soulful. c'mon. your writings apparently proves that you don't know Queen Bee that much! unlucky you. lol :)))
how can you say charice can't sustain notes longer than beyonce? charice holds the higher notes longer than beyonce. for a 16 year old and has that much control already at the top of her range is awesome. beyonce is awesome also, love her new song, but she's a lot like christina. vocal runs all over the place. but in terms of singing a song straight she's ok like her version of "at last". etta james still sings that song better than anyone else.
I' m sure those who SIDED on CHARICE are Filipinos...
don't be biased.
@porschetweety Unique? Original? Says who? Her style is very Whitney, Celine, J Hud.......Pleeeease, no one in the biz has been original since the 2000's. Not even Bee or Gaga.
Beyonce is way better but Charice is good :)
@lightningshock12 yep, charice is a better KARAOKE singer lmao
I really dunntorte believe it but charice wins....
anybody can be better than beyonce ! that's easy fo charice
Beyonce there no need to make a video to prove it
Not only does Beyonce win, but you chose some of the worst clips of those notes to use for her. She has hit WAY better E5s, F5s and F#5 with way better vibrato and resonance than that. Also, I dontsee the big deal about Charice's last G#5? She sang with an extremely high larynx and had zero vibrato on that note.
charice has a bigger voice, but i don't think she's a better singer
charice holds high notes longer
it's a blasphemy to compare the Goddess to the unknown flop from some karaoke bar
wow beyonce is good, but charice is the better belter
beyonce hands down! charice won the G5 and G#5. though she is very impressive but she's very one-dimensional. she has no style of her own and she has yet to sing her own song(s).
ano b discussion d2,galing o taas ng boses?hay nku ang mga pinoy tlga,sobrang naive.mkrinig lng ng mtaas n boses mgaling n.that's not what singing is all abt. d ptaasan ang lbanan. pgandahan! vocal production.now,whther or not you can hit a hi note,it's only 2ndary.kc kng taas lng pla ang basehan e d tumili k lng pla psado ka ng singer.e d sna sumikat c regine worldwide @ na-outpace nya pa c mariah & whitney kc mas mtaas ang chest voice nya kumpara sa 2. di yan pataasan mga ating.just so u know.
Charice isn't even in her prime yet :|
Are you saying that Filipino singers copy the westeners? I bet you don't even know what OPM is...
Gloc9 does not copy songs. He sing rap in a unique way. Not like eminem who always adds the words sh*t and f*ck in his Lyrics.
This is really unfair
@beyrock i agree 100% charice doesn't know how to dance and sing at the same time, she on;y knows how to sing, i'm not a hater i just hate it when people make stupid videos like these. Just stop making videos related to beyonce if there;s any negative thing in it. Thankyou
Beyonce won!!!! hands down...whats wrong wit yall?
Wtf are you deaf... no offense Charice is a great belter, but Beyonce was off the chart. Beyonce's belt was WAYYY more powerful and she can actually sustain a note longer than Charice. The only note i liked from Charice was the F5, G5, G#5 everything else was ok.
Beyonce has better voice control than Charice.
Charice no match for Beyonce...
my god..there wouldn't be anything more annoying than karaoke-rice's voice...bee doesn't even have to try
charice is already better than her. At least in belting notes above F5.
beyonce!!!! duh! charice is good but no where near Beys level.