Sant Jarnail Singh: The Man, the Myth, the Truth
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 9 июн 2024
- Join host Santbir Singh as he delves into an in-depth conversation with Harinder Singh about Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale, a pivotal figure in 20th-century Sikh history.
Jarnail Singh played a significant role in the events leading up to the June 1984 Ghallughara. While celebrated by many in the Sikh community, he remains a contentious figure, often demonized by the media. This discussion aims to uncover the man behind the myth and explore the true legacy of Sant Jarnail Singh.
Don't miss this compelling exploration of history and identity.
Learn more about June 1984 at: bit.ly/june-1984
Featuring:
Harinder Singh (sikhri.org/people/harinder-singh)
Santbir Singh (sikhri.org/people/santbir-singh)
#SikhGenocide #Sikhs #History #40Years #June1984 #NeverForget #OperationBlueStar #OperationBlueStar40Years #Sikhs #SikhHistory #SikhCommunity #GhallugharaWeek
ABOUT OUR CHANNEL📜
Sikh Research Institute (SikhRI) is a global non-profit organization based in North America. SikhRI inspires individuals to connect with their roots and organizations to connect with the Sikhs based on Guru Granth Sahib’s paradigm of IkOankar’s Nam (1Force’s Identification).
SikhRI seeks to develop a principle-driven community of Sikhs by following Gurmat-based core beliefs and inspiring Sikhs through meaningful interactions, dialogue, and education.
SikhRI actively works towards promoting global harmony by building stronger relationships among the Sikh and non-Sikh communities. Our primary activities include facilitating group training, providing curriculum materials, creating global awareness of Sikhi, and delivering strategic solutions to key challenges facing the global Sikh community.
SikhRI’s Mission: Provide educational resources for Sikhs to lead a Guru-inspired life. We do this by:
1. Making Sikhi education accessible to anyone.
2. Helping people understand the principles of Sikhi.
3. Presenting Gurbani the way it is.
FIND US AT 🔍
🔗 sikhri.org
GET IN TOUCH
📧 info@sikhri.org
➡️ Facebook: 🔗 / sikhresearchinstitute
➡️ Instagram: 🔗 / sikh.research.institute
➡️ Twitter: 🔗 / sikhri
➡️ Spotify: 🔗sikhri.org/spotify
Thank you for presenting the information on 1984 ghallugara in a way that connects various aspects of the painful events of 1984. Interest-group politicians spread a lot of misinformation to blame Sikhs the world over. There is a need to clarify the Sikh character. I recommend that our community seriously listen to Harinder Singh. In addition, one should also review what was done to Sikhs in Punjab in the days that followed 1984. Torture of the Sikh men, women, and children was inflicted after 84.
No one blamed sikhs. Only individuals were blamed due to their actions- irrespective of their religious background.
There're always two sides of a coin, right ??? It has been 40 years since that gory incident took place in Punjab, and you are still fanning the same flame.... for phuck sake, please, please do not incite and spew vitriol. During those days, lot of Hindus were killed, as well. Hindus houses were marked for capture. Kids could not go to schools, they were graduated to next grade without even attending school for that year. When a life is lost, everyone mourns irrespective of his/her faith & belief. How this speaker spun the yarn to support bodyguards carrying AK-47 is nothing but duplicitious..... A man who spoke only Punjabi, who did Kirtan, and prayed, all of a sudden became so powerful that Longowal, Tohra and Badal had become next to proverbial neutered ... have you pondered how and why ?? Sikhs are my brother, Sikhs are pride of India. So please take your snarl somewhere else.
What about sikh terrori$ts massacring Hindu$ in punjab??
@@saikatbabu9842it was done by the state itself
Bhindrawale said ....I will kill 5000 Hindus in one hour if police will not release his bus....
How this man can be a sant ??😂😂😂😂.....what an andhbhakt u r 😂😂😂
Thanks for the insight ! Sant Ji was a saint warrior 🙏
Bhindrawale said ....I will kill 5000 Hindus in one hour if police will not release his bus....
How this man can be a sant ??😂😂😂😂.....what an andhbhakt u r 😂😂😂
A great podcast - informative and helped answer lots of questions I have had. Thank you 🙏🏽
It's crazy how dedicated peopl3 sant ji has even after 40 years he must be the truth❤
59:25 what shortcomings are you referring to ?
very strange, if sant ji had any in his eyse why did he not mantion any ?
He actually referred to couple of responses to media that Sant ji could do better but he mentioned that SANT JI WAS GREATEST SIKH of 19th century due to his Training of SHABAD of SGGS but the PERFECTION is Always the Guru & human is human after all. After being said, there was no need to use the word shortcoming i guess. Harinder singh need to be very careful with words . Also, whenever he uses JATHEDAAR without explaining when he started in the beginning it was just not helpful to concentrate properly in the conversation. He should first explain the usage of any new word that he comes up with & then start to explain what he is trying to explain later.
But i thank HARINDER SINGH for his GREAT WORK for last 20 years especially in bringing awareness in sikh diaspora. I myself been following his videos on You Tube since 2010.
I have seen him been out of home in the field for almost 14 years & not stopping his RESEARCH even for a month. May waheguru give him strength to keep on his work to bring education to sikhs so that we can connect with the GURU to make our inner & outer world a great place to live. I request Harinder singh to be more careful with the words that a common person can understand.
He was saint and has the spirit of his ancestors. Its very high level and not every Human can attain such level .
Listen to me everyone!! What was Sant ji or who was he? Whatever you think of him, he never cares or nobody cares. He does not need any validation from any of the so called logical minds. He is beyond every worldly mind. So please do not strain your mind judging him. God is there to judge everyone. If you think you can make an opinion just by watching a video of few of them then please forget that. You are being partial if you do that. I bet a normal and worldly mind can never reach near his substantial. Peace🙏🏻
The Golden Temple (mandir) was repaired by Maharaja Ranjit Singh but he did not wage any war or battle from it. Who gave permission for this. Did any Guru permit this or is it written in any Holy scripture? Maybe he was a great Guy but I believe this was a mistake.
@AshleyKanda-kc5mn please learn our Sikh history and do some research before replying 🙏🏼
@@AshleyKanda-kc5mn the Indian govt. waged a war not Sant ji. We are sikh and we know better about our history and great personalities. So please do not condemn anyone especially the saintly souls until you know and understand the particular religion. This is a request 🙏🏻.
Sikhism is based on philosophy of GURU NANAK and GURU GOBIND SINGH JI. GURU NANAK JI MESSAGE IS reminded of truthfulness and GURU GOBIND SINGH JI advised "ਸੁਰਾ ਸੋ ਪਹਿਚਾਨੀਏ ਜੋ ਲੜੇ ਦੀਨ ਕੇ ਹੇਤ " The real soldier is one who helped the down trodden and needy.
@@Sikh_Azadi_84 Who are you to say 'our Sikh history'? How is it your history. Prove it. I have more than 1000 year history in Punjab and all my Grandparents were Sikh. Lets get this right. I know Sikh history and you know nothing except brain washing. You select parts that suit you and are not interested in truth. Do not call yourself a Sikh.
More than that it comes under the duties of the Jathedar/leader of the Damdami taksal is to preach/teach sikhi, to give amrit to whoever is willing to take and also to address the social issues related to the panth specially if the government failed to tackle them.
He has mentioned again and again in his speeches that I am not with any political party (it was only for sangat). He was charming I agree i think another reason why he was chosen for the leadership even if Bhai amreek singh (son of previous jathedar sant kartar singh ji) was present there.
❤❤❤❤
Bhindrawale said ....I will kill 5000 Hindus in one hour if police will not release his bus....
How this man can be a sant ??😂😂😂😂.....what an andhbhakt u r 😂😂😂
Guys just read the The Struggle for Justice by Dr Randhir Singh Sandhu which contained Sant Bhindranwale ji speeches and recordings and interviews, as well as the origins and myths and truths about him.
Bhindrawale said ....I will kill 5000 Hindus in one hour if police will not release his bus....
How this man can be a sant ??😂😂😂😂.....what an andhbhakt u r 😂😂😂
U can find his video easily
Great work Waheguru ji
Bhindrawale said ....I will kill 5000 Hindus in one hour if police will not release his bus....
How this man can be a sant ??😂😂😂😂.....what an andhbhakt u r 😂😂😂
👍🙏
Why a PERSON HAS TO BE AN AKALI REPRESENTATIVE TO QUALIFY AS A SIKH REPRESENTATIVE?
Sorry please I am not able to answer your queries about being an Akali particularly when you don't have character as needed to practiced by Amritdhari.
@@AHUJASS Abe ja!
Pakhandi kahi ke. Sirf Amritdhari ka ves dharan kar ke tum Brahmgyani nahi ban jayoge!
I agree with you that Akali should follow the order of Akal Thakht in letter and spirit where as Sikh community follow Guru Granth Sahib.
@@AHUJASS Akal Takhat is itself under Akali control.
The whole Sikh Religious Identity has been 're invented' as ANTAGONISTIC TO Hinduism and Hindus.
My father used to go and listen to Sant jarnail singh ji and he told me that he was not a militant. I accepted for most of my life as I know my father would never say anything if he is not sure about it (if it was my mother i wouldn't believe she is too much into sikhs and being punjabi proud thing which I understand but being a non-religious person myself, I do not focus mainly on that. I prefer facts). However I did not care to know much about it.
In last 5 days day and night I have watched almost all the interviews (supportive/against), his videos, discussion with my father etc.
HE WAS 14TH JATHEDAR OF DAMDAMI TAKSAL. BORN ON 2ND OF JUNE 1947 AND DIED/MARTYRED ON 6TH OF JUNE 1984.
7:16 what did kps gill's father had done for sikhs ?
Please use respectable words for Sant Baba GERNAIL Singh JI Khalsa BHINDRAWALAY.
Thanks for your message.
Hindu-Sikh Bhai Bhai ,
Bhindranwale ne ma chu dw..*1
@@hindusangram9506 DUSHMAN da Bakwaas
Sita ne chodavai c 😂😂😂@@hindusangram9506
Terrroi$t bhindiwala 🤣🤣🤣
With respect want to correct you please ask Sant Jarnail Singh not Jathedar Jarnail Singh . In real means he was Saint Soldier according to Sikh traditions .
Thank you both for your great talk about Sant Bhindranwala and brief history about 1984 episode
Thank you S Harinder Singh great scholar of Sikhism
S Harinder Singh ji you are very close to the fact
People do change their views with time .
Before 1984 government attacked in 1920,1921,1947,1948,1955,
1966,1978 & after 1984 they stopped attacking
The day Indian Army steps in Darbaar Sahib, foundation of Khalistan would be lay. Sant ji
It's been 40 years, what have you achieved?
@@kanteya108 it took Hindu thousands of year to be free, so wait and watch. We will take our land back soon.
@@GaganSingh-ym9br what land? That little tukda you have left in India?
@@kanteya108 You ask this question to yourself that what’s Sikhs have achieved since Hindu badmaash attack on Shiri AKAAL TAKHAT sahib .
@@kanteya108 NATO issued the new map of Sikh homeland Desh Punjab Khalistan.go check
I would like to point out to viewers that most of the answers about “unsupportable topics” revolve around personal accounts of few selected individuals. We all know persons views, recollections change over time. It is very difficult to rely on individual accounts especially emotional matters like this.Personal views of military personnel cannot also be trusted, as there will be politics, biases happen in military organization happens. We all know a US air force general talked about “hallow earth” as his personal experience.
I want to point out that most of this persons explanations seems to be formed on biased opinions.
Could you make a video about a debate against Puneet Sahani and others who believe Sikhs are a part of Hinduism.
English empire created lot different identity to build theirs divisive agenda Sikh built English empire from 1857 so Sikhs along Muslim started demanding separate dream
@@bhupindersinghkanwar5681 did you even read gurbani or anything else or are you just a number one fan of that idiot
@@bhupindersinghkanwar5681okay but in gurbani Sikhi is a separate religion and has no connection with hinduism
Sikh Religion is separate Religion because firstly it eradicated caste systems and preached against various types of common do and don't of hindu Religion including "ਮੂਰਤੀ ਪੂਜਾ "
@@sahibjotathwal8198that tirangi joker is a fraud
Guru Nanak established universal democratic model at Kartarpur Sahab during muslim rules and same was emulated by the Maharaja Ranjit Singh regime during which Sikhs were in the minority community even though muslim were in the majority. Miri and piri means that law of land prevail irrespective of caste color cultural heritage and cultural diversity. No religion teaches hate and violence.
Whole trouble started with failure of Nehru to implement the promises made before partition. Worst was done by Indra Gandhi by attacking Darbar Sahib Amritsar. So congress needs to analyze history of Indian freedom and role of punjabi in getting independence for the country.
Common myth is that he was presented by the congress..only people who do not know sikhi or sikh history speak like that.
Damdami taksal has been active for 300 years since baba deep singh ji who btw also fought at the borders of amritsar to protect the holy city.
When Sant jarnail singh ji bhindrawale was given the jathedari/leadership of damdami taksal more than 1 lakh sangat was present there and many politicians were also there.
You obviously know nothing about 'Sikhism'. Stop accusing others of not knowing.
I absolutely see no reason of explaining myself to anyone. I have said what I wanted to say. :)
When was there EVER A SIKH 'PERSONAL' LAW BEFORE THE BRTISH ANNEXATION OF THE PUNJAB AND DURING COLONIAL BRITISH RULE?
Fudu so many comments lol
Sikhs never had laws separate them from Hindus. Till the late 19th century, Sikhs followed Hindu rites for their various events like marriage, cremation, justice, etc. Even Maharaja Ranjit Singh was cremated ACC to the Vedic rites by Pundits.
@@hindusangram9506 Your rhetoric is beyond amusing, I suggest you sit down before you lose your balance. The rites you are mentioning have nothing to do with Hinduism, but cultural influences and norms, so stop promoting propaganda. You need to recognize and acknowledge Sikhs are NOT Hindus. You sound so jealous, get some mental help.
Anand marriage act was there during British rule.
@@AHUJASS What about a Personal Law?
All Guru Maharaj were married as per Hindu Rites.
SGPC has spoiled Guru Maharaj's Sikhi.
Bhindrawalwa was arrested in 1981. Anchor ! U said in 1982. Can U prove this assertion with proper evidence ?
The arrest took place in 1981.
sant jarnail singh ji Bhindrawalwe.. have some manners
Better check out this in the newspaper like The Tribune etc.
@@amanpreetkumar9294 Why? Who are you?
ਪੰਜਾਬੀ ਵਿਚ ਕਹੀਏ ਤਾਂ ਹਰਿੰਦਰ ਸਿੰਘ ਟਕਸਾਲ ਤੇ ਬਹੁ ਗਿਣਤੀ ਦੀ ਨਿਗ੍ਹਾ ਵਿੱਚ ਪਰਵਾਨ ਚੜਨਾ ਚਾਹੁੰਦੇ ਨੇ। ਸਿਖ research ਤੇ ਇਨੇ ਆਰਟੀਕਲ ਲਿਖਣ ਤੋਂ ਬਾਅਦ ਹੁਣ ਇਥੇ ਹਿੰਦੂ ਸਿੱਖ ਕਰਨ ਲੱਗਿਆਂ ਇਹਨਾਂ ਨੂੰ ਸ਼ਰਮ ਨਹੀਂ ਆਉਂਦੀ।
SANT JARNAIL SINGH JI KHALSA BHINDRANWALE ZINDABAD ⚔️
How is he Sant??
Sant sipahi soor bir bachan ke bali the woh
In High Spirits
Sant Sipahi and every Damdami Taksal leader received the title Sant.
Because he preached Sikh philosophy as Sant and sacrificed his life to maintain the sanctity of Darbar Sahib complex as warrior.
@@AHUJASS Are you for real and do you honestly believe that? What is different about Sikh philosophy? If you want to learn about Sikhism then go back to the time when it was created.
19:26 19:26 When R our Sikh panth SGPC Akali Dal Dam Di Taksal DPGC. And I on a deliberate action do not include any other Sikh Commities Panth in the further stretches of India because we cannot even have diplomacy in Punjab and Delhi. We here whispers about including all of India’s Gurudwara under one umbrella this dilusion and greed to the max.Why do we keep talking about Sant Bhindrawala because nobody has the guts of Akali Phula ji. These foreign Sikhs talk bullshit and yet hold degrees for wat working to clean McDonald’s its a damn disgraceful shame TV Sikh
Jarnail was simple milk man Jatt
His brothers 7 sister 3 become jail singh baba to divide alkali but he adopted coa isi support and fortified his temple in state congres gave him somuch benefit of doubt and he fkked all govt
Probably you need to watch video by Sukhpreet Singh
Probably you need to watch video by Sukhpreet Singh
Disagree on many things
Bhindranwala campaigned for Congress Candaidate from Amritsar Raghunandan Lal Bhatia in 1980 Parliament elections. As far Santokh Singh's funeral in Delhi is concerned, what JSB was doing in far away Delhi and which other Sikh leaders (spiritual and p[political) were present there except Congressmen?
This is fake. Sant ji was never the part of congress.
hindu doing what hindu does best.. fake and cheap propaganda .. lets hope you earned your 1 rs
Bullshit
@@harshdeepsingh8211 Cpngressi pilla. Aaj bhi Amritsar se Congress ka MP hai - kaya ukhaad liya?
Baba_E_kaum Shaheed Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindrawala. Soon khalsa Raaj
He was held in high esteem here. Could someone please clarify the following points?
1. If he was revered as a saintly figure, why did his followers commit numerous murders leading up to June 1984? This cannot be simply blamed on 3 journalists doing bad propaganda against him. This didn’t happen 1000 years ago. There was lot of news on this covered by esteemed Sikh journalists too. There was lot of evidence, not necessarily directly implicating him, but happened under his watch.
2. If he was a true religious leader who respected the sanctity of Harmandir Sahib, why were there killings within the complex under his watch? What prompted the introduction of weapons into this sacred space, transforming it into a battleground?
3. Why is the deployment of security forces to restore law and order considered wrongful, especially when the area had already become a conflict zone rife with violence and armed individuals?
4. I mean no disrespect to anyone or anything. I am seeking to understand the reasons behind the deep resentment some hold towards the government, while simultaneously venerating the individual who seemingly played a role in these events as a saint.
Propeganda
@Teugodu20
ruclips.net/video/rmU04CrXIJo/видео.htmlsi=4P3VoYBNVK6kq3L2
Hi. I can't say that I know everything, especially about the killings as I'm looking for answers myself but I can answer some of what you asked.
About the weapons, I don't think originally, weapons being in a Gurdwara harms its sanctity, that's not a sikh concept. Even if you go there today you'll find guards carrying weapons, maybe not guns but it probably depends on what the situation demands. For sikhs the ideal sikh should strive to be both a saint and a warrior, they don't have to be exclusive, something you see in practice throughout sikh history not just in theory.
If you study the background and events leading upto 84, since the independence of India, from Punjabi Suba movement to events in years before 84, you'll see that the government often did injustice so ofc there was mistrust.
Furthermore, the demands and problems initially were economic and political, more than religious. The operation wasn't planned within a few days to arrest Bhindrawale but months in advance as the guy who was originally supposed to carry it out said on record.
People who blame Bhindrawale, as I initially did, do so when they learn the narrative that he was the cause of the attack. But as you go deeper into the background and causes, you realize that he was the one who tackled an existing situation or one that was in process of building, not the cause, which is why he's revered. Personally, I'm learning about him so I havent cleared him of suspicion yet, but I do think he was not the cause even if he was a problematic individual.
Anyway, thanks for trying to learn rather than believing what you see or hear
@@ziachurail1931 Thank you immensely for dedicating time to offer insights on various matters. It is widely recognized that the decades spanning the 1960s to the 1990s in India were marked by tumultuous events. The era (even since 1947) was rife with unfulfilled promises and widespread distrust. (In fact there were broken promises even now. Laws passed by parliament were never implemented or Prime minster’s assurances in full house of parliament were never respected). In response to these challenges, numerous local leaders adopted peaceful methods to bring about change. While some resorted to violence, as a nation, we hold in the highest esteem those leaders who achieved their goals through nonviolent means. Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale, for instance, is known to have selflessly worked for a noble cause, and although his methods may not be universally accepted, his dedication is undeniable. It has been observed that even those who commend him do not endorse his violence; rather, they tend to attribute the blame elsewhere. It is my sincere hope that discussions about him remain factual, devoid of any mystification, allowing us to honor his rightful legacy in history.
@@ziachurail1931 I understand bringing/displaying weapons in Darbar Sahib may be ok for Sikh tradition. But bringing war weapons, killings, making fortifications and essentially making it battleground doesn’t amount to sacrilege? Why create grudge on government for this? I donot agree with lot of policies of government of the day or its leaders but I have to agree that they dealt with this challenge (operation blue star) with strong sense of patriotism, national integrity & selflessness as well(one has to agree that India dealt other national integrity challenges same way-without any bias). Most of the Punjab’s populace has come to terms with the fact that errors were made by all involved parties, choosing forgiveness and seeking closure. Why these foreigners continue create rift after all these years? Why dont they find peace in their adaptive lands and move on with their lives? Why spread these myths? It is concerning when even a single person is swayed by such divisive tales. My earnest hope for these foreign citizens is to shift towards more positive endeavors, better careers rather than the perpetuation of untruths.
One needs to be equal cruel , dishonest and stupid to think and make Sant and Singh's to fought against Indian army.People who blame and justify army action are equally sinners. Don't forget you will be punished severely by Guru as you r tarnishing his Sikhi. Don't forget he always did and do justice.
U making no sense?!
One needs to be equal cruel, dishonest And Stupid to think that Guru Gobind Singh with his 40 sikhs can fight 10 lakh Mughals and Hindu Rajas Army,...., and it would be ridiculous to Guru Gobind Singh expecting His Sikhs to REPEAT History for all times to Come. Oh LOL, Sikhs keep on repeating History, and they will always do the same in times to come. Wolves like you will always watch with Awe and fear 🤗
Congress NEVER TRUST THE AKALIS AND AKALI POLITICS.
In post Independence India, Nehru's consolidation of Muslim constituency came at the cost of AKALI POLITICAL INTERESTS.
I was amazed to see that the Arab/Muslim community refer to Sant ji as قائد الحمير
As what? Please translate the last word
Every gurdwara should be fortified or able to be fortified at short notice. A gurdwara is not a Mandir or church... It is for Miri and piri. Heck even having a wall is a fortification...does your house have a wall or fence for stopping intruders?
Sikhs are Pride of India, I would say they are Pride of world; anything unfortunate happens anywhere in the world, Sikhs are the first to be there to help, feed. Their Bravery is always glorified.
Having said that, @36:11, the question posed by the host was very good. But Harinder Singh, being a weasel, very dexterously avoided the question. He started beating around the bush, juxtaposing Bhindrewale with Guru Govind Singh. Yes, Guru Govind Singh ji carried bow and arrow, but that was in the battle field, not in Gurudwara Sahib. A simple man, who spoke only Punjabi, did regular kirtan and Paath, all of a sudden became so powerful that he put his cot (Charpai) in Akaal Taqt, the most sacred place in Harimandir Sahib, and Sikh leaders Badal, Tohra and Longowal could do nothing. It was a Sikh who wore Indian Army uniform and led the Operation Blue-Star. Till today, Sikhs are trying to kill him. I do not condone Indian army going inside Harimandir, that I would never accept, but then how ak-47s were allowed inside the sacred place?.... A sikh when gets married takes his wife to Harimandir Shahib for mattha-tek (blessing). Those women were picked. After that operation, when those girls came out, they were all loaded. I asked this question to one Sardar, and I was stunned by his reply, he said and I quote "Woh saade haq layee larde paye si, es karke asi saddi'yan Kurdiy'an ditti si" .... Even today, when I go to Gurudwara, I see Bhindrawale's picture on the atrium wall with a caption "Sadda 11wa Guru" ...... no, no, no, this comparison with saintly figure like Guru Nanak is not only hideous, it is downright shameful .....
😂😂😂😂😂🎉
Don’t be a clown with your misinformation. I understand you have issues with someone who is explaining this to you with clarity and high intellect. Whether you are Punjabi Hindu or Sikh remember this for the betterment of Punjab and all communities of Punjab benefit from it.
Harinder Singh is BASING HIS ENTIRE THEORY ON THE BASIS OF TARLOCHAN SINGH.
NOBODY KNEW Bhindranwale until he was brought to the NOTICE of SANJAY GANDHI!
Two gentlemen of the Colonial British created Singh Sabha and SGPC persuasions talking about Guru Maharaj! The tragedy of Sikhi since late 19th Century.
Ur a retard haha
womp womp
@@kanwar.gi11 u meant ur a wimp wimp. Lol
Kya fook kr aayeya hai 😂😂. Saale abhi bhi Maharashtra mei takht shri hazur sahub mei puratan sikhi practice hoti hai aukaat hai teri toh challenge krke dikha de
First of all this is a story of the 80s, totally irrelevant we have far more important issues that are way more important, what that is OK. We had friends who lost their lives, few were finishing their masters, PHDs, came from very blessed families, all mislead by the movement of Khalistan. We were lucky we came to Canada and survived. Now I am reaching the end of my life, with 60 to 65 years of life experience, it won’t be as easy to intimidate or brainwash me by these so called religious self made scholars or leaders. I started to understand this little better now, this is a scheme of the cunning to divide us on the bases of religion. There is absolutely no difference between the Hindus and the Sikhs, all Sikh gurus were born in Hindu families. But I guess by dividing us, this is how they make money, majority of these will start their business from the religion side always. I started to hate many of these paid preachers and story tellers. Just as in business they will tell any story in anyway to get the bonus at the end of the year. They tell excellent stories but for money. They have turned our religion into a business. These guys are very clever, what have they done for the needy and the youth. They preach well but practice nothing. This practice failed miserably in India, especially in Punjab, you killed it there. We escaped to Canada, the country and the system put together by the Christians, we loved it here till you showed up with similar preachings and practices that distroyed us many times before. You don’t own Sikhi, it is ours too. We are fed up with people like you, stop.
You have been decoded as RAW agent 0000000000💯
@@HARMEETSINGH-us8xh you are right, absolutely
We all get life from one source then why hindus, muslims and Christian's are different.You think Hinduism is greater than Prime Eternal source , so that people diverting to a different religion from hinduism can never be different from hindus, but originating from same primary source can get different labels.
@@ninderkaurdhindsa8656 read Sri Guru Garinth Sahib.
@@ninderkaurdhindsa8656 we are Sikhs, we believe in Sabad Guru, our living God is Sri Guru Garanth Sahib. Our guru tells us, there is no difference between Waheguru ji, Sri Ram, Sri Krishna, Christ and Allah. All religions are equal no one is superior. Our guru ji writes “ Allah Pakan Pak ah Allah, Sak Kare je Doosar Hoi. Allah is God, he is true and Supreme. He also writes about lord Krishna; “ Aape Gopi, Aape Kaana, Aape Gau Charavee”. Meaning, he himself is Kaana, he himself is Gopi meaning God himself. We all are the same. When you connected with him, you won’t see Hindu, you won’t see Sikh, you won’t Muslim. The ones who divide us are nor Sikh, they nor Hindu, they nor Christian, they are nor Muslim, they are trying to cash religion out, no one owns Sikh religion, no one owns Hinduism religion, no one owns Muslim religion.
This guy is a crook, buyer beware
If Bhindranwale is a SANT then every Jansanghi or Arya Samaji abusing Sikhs in Punjab is a Mahashay ✌🏻💪🏻
He himself asked not be called a Sant. But you are right about the Hindus whose hatred for Sikhs started when Guru Nanak Dev ji was 9 yrs old. So the hatred of five centuries continues. "ਪੰਜ ਸਦੀਆਂ ਦਾ ਵੈਰ"
@@jdsingh6148 Every Reformer has haters and opponents.
Arya Samajis and Brahmo Samajis DIDN'T HAVE OPPONENTS AMONGST ORTHODOXY?
Why DOESNT SGPC narrative TALK ABOUT HINDUS WHO UPHELD, ACCEPTED AND PROMOTED GURU MAHARAJ?
The Singh Sabhaites, before Singh Sabha, FAILING TO GAIN ANY TRACTION IN THE LEADERSHIP ROLE WITHIN ARYA SAMAJ, TOOK UPON THEMSELVES FOR SOCIO POLITICAL RELEVANCY, TO PRESENT SIKHI IN OPPOSITION TO WHAT GURU MAHARAJ HAD PROMOTED.
@@hotfun07So you think being socio politically relevant is the prerogative of Hindus only
@hotful07 Sant Bhinderanwale didn't abuse anyone.Don't compare him with Aryasamajies and jansaghies who are full of hatred for Sikhs and because of that hatred always worked against the interests of Punjab
@@ninderkaurdhindsa8656 Agree that SGPC is NO DIFFERENTFROM SANGH PARIVAAR.
BOTH USE RELIGIOIS NARRATIVE FOR POLITICAL PURPOSES.
Besides, SANGH PARIVAAR DOESNT HAVE THE AUTHORITY TO 'DEFINE' WHAT IS IT BEING A HINDU.
IMPORTANTLY, MAJORITY HINDUS DO NOT AGREE WITH SANGH PARIVAAR. BUT NO ORGANIZATION USER SANGH PARIVAAR UMBRELLA HAS THE AUTHORITY TO CALL THEM APOSTATE!
This 'privilege' is RESERVED FOR SGPC 🤣
Corrupt
The lies by Harinder Singh make me 🤮
Ek bhi jhooth batade kya bola hai
@@harshdeepsingh8211 Sara he jhoot bolya harinder Singh is just rubbing the balls of taksalies
Please be factual, don’t spread misinformation.
Learn to make a difference between Sikh and Khalsa!
There is no difference, they are codependents, complementing each other. Learn the facts before you make absurd statements.
Agree, this troll we know what there agenda is. Always trying to put Sikhs down and create confusion.
@@pavanSingh-ts5ym Khalsa is nowhere to be found in Granth sahib. also almost all 10 Sikh Gurus were NOT Khalsas. G Gobind Singh ji became Khalsa for just 6-7 years before his death. Sikh Gurus practiced Hinduism for all the practical reasons. They were Married according to Hindu Vedic rites and they were cremated by Hindu priests
@@hindusangram9506haha stfu retard.. educate ur urinated 🧠
Ur a fudu stop commenting here to drink some urine. Lepussy
Sikhs were NEVER 30% of the British Indian Army!
Punjabis WERE 30% - 42% OF THE BRITISH INDIAN ARMY. AND PUNJABI MUSALAMANS ALWAYS OVER REPRESENTED SIKHS AND HINDUS BESIDES THE PUNJABI MUSLIM COMPOSITION ALWAYS INCREAED AT THE COST OF SIKHS AND HINDUS 1910s ONWARDS.
Ur mommy tell u that? U seem pretty stupid I'd educate ur 🧠 just saying lol
Their were more sacrifices then these two groups and they we were the first to lift ourselves up and fight the English
Such crap.
Did you say it before you opened the video or did you just put earmuffs instead air pods.
BHARAT KE FAUJ ZINDABAD.CONGRATULATION FOR SUCCESS OF OPERATION BLUE STAR
Indian army was misinformed . Better watch the interview of sant Jr with Subermaniam swamy then an Bjp MP,
@@AHUJASS WHAT WAS INDIAN ARMY MISINFORMED ABOUT. THE WHOLE WORLD KNEW THAT KHALISTANI EXTREMISTS WERE INSIDE IT
संत भिंडरावाले 20 वीं सदी के शिरोमणि अथवा अद्वितये वीर योद्धा थे, जिन्होंने मुठी भर सूरमा मर्जीवड़ों से 1 1/2 लाख फ़ौज को लोहे के चने चबवाये, जब संत जी की 5 दिन बाद शहादत हुई, तो उनके चारों तरफ हज़ारों कायरो की लाशें पड़ी थी 💯
@@HARMEETSINGH-us8xh JO ALPSHANKIYAK SAMUDAYE K LOG APNA ALAG DESH MANGE GEH UNKO BAHADUR BHARAT KE FAUZ KABAR MAIN 100 FOOT NEECHE GATAR K ANDAR PAUCHADEGEE DEGEE. AMAR RAHE BHARAT KE SENA , AMAR RAHE SHRI SANJAY GANDHI JI AMAR RAHE SHREE JAGDISH TYTLER JI. JINHONE POORA SAHYOG KIYA ALPSHANKIYAK SAMUDAYE K DAISHATGARDOO KO JHANUM PAHUCHANE MAIN
@@user-dg2zn6mc8iहम अलप संख्यक नहीं हूँ, हम बहुसंख्यक को अपनी जेब में रखता हूँ 😂
CCTV hote toh ASHARAM hee tha😂😂😂😂
Nangi aurton ki bodies mili thi golden temple se
Lindu clown showing his cheap mentality
Teri maa di honi you recognize her body
Teri maa v mili honi you recognize her body
Sorry, Your INDIAN GOVERNMENT PROPAGANDA couldn’t survive for long. Even JAAT brother HARYANA recognized the same propaganda against them during their own protest in Haryana.
That is a fake propaganda by indian army. Bahut jagah isko debunk kiya geya tha
This apologist says warrants were never issued against Jarnail Singh Bhindranwala. It is a lie. Warrants were issued at least twice against him. Warrants were issued in Sept 1981 after the murder of L Jagat Narain (Chief Editor Punjab Kesari). Bhindranwala mentioned this warrant in his speech quoted by Ranbir Singh Sandhu in his book on the sanitised speeches (page 459 and many others). JSB said: Lala Jagat Narain died on the 9 (September 1981) and, on the 12th, warrants for my arrest were issued. On the 14th the incident occurs in Chando-Kalan and on the 16th September at four in the evening I am served with the warrants. Under what law did the Government cause all the destruction before serving the warrants? Let it answer.
Let me clear the doubts, there is no FIR against the saint, in any police station of Punjab, or elsewhere 🙏
Khalistan jindavaad
2 warrants against him however no convictions. Sounds like an innocent man
@@SooBlue931 No convictions because his case did not go to the trial stage. G Zail singh who was the Home Minister of India at that time ordered Bhindranwala's release. Also, despite being a murder accused, was detained in a government guest house. He was also allowed to chose his date, time and venue of his arrest. Not only that, Bhindranwala also asked for an Amritdhari or saabat soorat police officer to arrest him. The drama queen's tantrums led to 18 of his followers dying in police firing as they rioted after his arrest.
@@HARMEETSINGH-us8xh what do you mean there was no FIR against Bhindranwala? He was arrested twice (once for the murder of Jagat Narain and then for the murder of the Nirankari Chief Gurbachan Singh) and as far as my knowledge goes, the arrest cannot be made without a FIR.
Thnx to Indira Gandhi ji, KPS Gill Ji for getting rid of khali$tani bhindiwala. Jai Hind 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Please look into the whole background of this episode before coming to any conclusion.