Brexit bust-up, things get heated in the studio - BBC Newsnight
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 6 дек 2018
- Which way next for Brexit and British PM Theresa May?
Subscribe to our channel here: goo.gl/31Q53F
Opinions clash in the studio between journalist Jenni Russell, former Downing St press secretary Alastair Darling and journalist Matthew Goodwin.
Newsnight is the BBC's flagship news and current affairs TV programme - with analysis, debate, exclusives, and robust interviews.
Website: www.bbc.co.uk/newsnight
Twitter: / bbcnewsnight
Facebook: / bbcnewsnight
Wherever there is an heated argument you will find Campbell.
Remember the bust up with Adam Boulton?
I love the irony of Campbell interrupting someone to TELL her she, 'can't speak for everybody.'
This old woman called Alistair Campbell is at it again. What a bore! He always has to have the last word..
That's an insult to old women!
He’s a fucking Blairite dinosaur..
She isn't old, she's hot....
the parlous shame of this is that there is no respect for the people of the country - it is becoming more and more blatant - and dont' tell me it s a parliamentary democracy
This has gone beyond BREXIT
It is now about
DEMOCRACY
It is now the primary issue
+Robert Schofield In principle, DEMOCRACY serves the informed consent of the People. The Leavers lied massively in order to engineer dis-informed consent.
Exactly! And well said sir, democracy is the key word here! And seeing as so many have seen the light with this Brexit con and changed their mind, a second referendum is essential!
It is a pathetic shambles, we voted to leave. The politicians, the mainstream, especially the BBC and the narratives they push, their globalist agenda, are simply ignoring our vote and making an absolute mockery of Democracy, and laughing stock of Britain around the world. The progressive liberalism the BBC has relentlessly pushed, funded by us, under duress, the attack on morals, on traditions, on our indigenous people, history and culture is NOT making Britain a better place in my lifetime. 1984 was supposed to be fictional.
Charles Wood Yep, this country is a pathetic shambles alright. Thanks mainly to those who were groomed by the media and the brexiters into voting Leave. This country, since June 23rd, has been a laughing stock thanks to a bunch pushing an agenda off the back of jingoistic false nationalism. Now they’re whipping you into a frenzy with little catchphrases such a ‘stealing Brexit’, ‘killing democracy’ and ‘betrayal’. They keep telling you that all Remainers are calling you stupid, when in fact it’s they who are treating you as stupid.
The funny thing is it’s those groomed Leavers who think they’re the enlightened ones? 🤣😂 Further brainwashed by RUclips videos and little twitter echo chambers. 1984 ? BBC pushing a liberal narrative? What planet are you on! If they did their job, clowns like Farage wouldn’t have had more appearances than any MP on Question Time and they’d take him, Mogg and the rest to task on all the lies they’ve told. At least Marr tried to the other day, and little baby Nigel got rather upset didn’t he?
@@Garmez120 TUT.
I think Teresa's EU deal has united the country. Everyone is against it.
oh yes they are I wish someone could shut Campbell up as easily!
That's true; she is the great uniter!
If it didn't have the back stop it may have a chance
@@vincentmckenna281 if the backstop is such an issue just give northern Ireland back... northern ireland costs the UK 2bn more per year than EU membership does!
Yes everyone hates the deal true. But for different reasons.
I only came here to watch Campbell interrupt and tell everyone they're wrong, I wasn't disappointed.
Alistair Campbell represents everything that is wrong with this country. He never listens to anyone else and simply talks over them and insults everyone who doesn't agree with him, in fact the perfect politician!
Change will come...it must. They have led us to the brink if losing everything our nation has stood for to be treated as dogs. We must begin again on our own terms as an independent nation.
That's what the Leftest party in the USA does. If all else fails they call you a racist
This is a man who suffers depression why is on here arguing against brexit he is not of sound mind he was party to the illegal war in Iraq with his lies him and Blair should be in jail for war crimes
His mentally ill! Alistair Campbell! He has unleashed untold misery in the Middle East sexing up dossiers to justify an illegal war! Horrid horrid man!
he's not well. that's why he isnt a politician
The middle-man Matthew Goodwin nailed the debate. Sublime if it wasn't so obvious to the electorate. Pity it's taken an age for one man to work out the failures that beset this nation. “The Leave side has a very different conversation!“ Politicians with no sense of duty. Alistor.. Shuuush.
If you watch the BBC for your News your in trouble.
It means you are brainwashed!
All news channels seem to be pro Eu, pro multiculturalism. Rt don't care, they just want to get Moscow's point across. Facts are facts, it's fairly simple to come to your own conclusions.
Main stream media in the USA is wrong on everything. You can't get fair news
Says someone who doesn't know the difference between, "your" and "you're."
@Steve Cj So remainers are not allowed to have an opinion because of brain washed brexiteers.
I came to the conclusion i should compromise??? You lost... No compromise on your part is needed.
Aye. My thoughts as well.
Yes we do not need to pay the EU anything as they export more into the UK than we export to the EU. That means we should be charging them if they want access to the UK market without customs.
There is no mandate for a hard Brexit.
@@garsm2290 oh yes there is, no hard or soft, just leave, its quite simple.
@@robertomancini9755 What are you talking about? There are massive differences over the kind of Brexit people want. Look at the votes in parliament over the deal agreed with the EU - and which Rees-Mogg supported.
BBC impartiality again
3 remainers vs 1 brexit
Should be ashamed
It's the BBC what do you expect?
The bbc must be made to raise its own finances not be be funded out of taxation.
Matt is impartial and just explains why Brexiters won the argument. So actually no Brexiter representation. Campbell does enough to show why Remainers have lost support though - completely ignores listening to stats and polls of people's opinions and tries bullying his agenda into the conversation.
The UK is in desperat need of workers.
We need new politician's, new political advisers
and new television interviewers....
And new Russian trolls who know plurals in English aren't formed with apostrophes.
A 2nd referendum will be a stitch up. Choices will be May's deal or remain. Neither of which deliver Brexit.
@Nanny Robinson Yes totally if Theresa May heads down that road, Brexit will never happen. This will lead to a generation of unhappiness and probably Nigel Farage becoming PM.
What does public know about TM Treaty? Shall we all have to read 584 pgs and employ a Lawyer to decipher it for us? MP's voted down 3 X , now they want to trick public to vote for that toilet paper. Sick
@@miraforeman7567 I have read some of it and it makes very poor reading. So many areas where we stay tied to the EU - not just during the transition period but forever and why would they need a section that says that politicians are free from prosecution? If this clause was necessary it shows that they KNOW that they have done wrong. As you rightly say - MPs rejected it 3 times and yet we will be offered it as our only choice. GGGGGRRRRRR
@Nanny Robinson The EU put a very bad deal our way expecting it to cause problems and potentially lead to another vote which it may well do.
Let’s hope so ! 👍👍
That interview basically concluded that we are too dumb to know what is best. That's certainly how I interpret:
"Because the country wouldn't realise how disastrous it was going to be, the country can't afford to have that referendum."
This is nothing other than a political classism being super divorced from the voters. This kind of talk is reprehensible.
Well? What do you have to say for yourself now?
@@MarkGrindell thank god we're out! I'm not a blame-everything-on-brexit guy. Take a look at the world as a whole. The pandemic, war in Ukraine has caused and is causing a wave of economic problems all through Europe and the world
Campbell makes me physically sick.
Alistair demonstrates the arrogance that was the eventual downfall of the New Labour project!
campbell, blair,brown. The 3 stoogies. Remember them?
Useless morons that listen to the sun over every economist. Thanks for destroying the country
New Liebour, New Danger was the order of the day way back when.
@@chindit6784 ha ha you got it wrong
@@watchiingunow618 no I didn't were going through economic downturns as predicted with shortages on every sector due to lack of HGV drivers, scotland is suceding, the pounds values has diminished
Remainers debating with each other. Good old auntie...
That TV licence fee is worth every penny, hey?
Far right ERG financed by None Domicile billionaires?Jacob Rees Mogg making profit from the death of six million people a year, pocketing 5 million quid a year off 21 million tobacco holdings? the sanctity of life his high on his morel hypocrisy, good old ERG ,
Twats All of them
Michael Peterson Cameron.Osborne,Heselfine.House of Lords,City,Stock exchange,IMF,Landlords all back remain.Are you a paid Soros puppet spreading misinfirmation.
Michael Paterson you and Blair with Campbells “remain dossier’ are a joke.
Where is the brexiteer on this panel? Balanced reporting?
Its the BBC what did you expect.
because its the bbc!!!!!!!
Isn't it obvious BBC has definitely a political bias?
Brexiters are correct in their thinking, hence the reason why they are not in the studio.
@CULT68 Fuck you're weird
We have not changed are minds Alister, you are out of touch. Leave leave leave!
Have you talked to 17m leavers and 16m remainers to come to this conclusion or where are you getting this information from?
Our mind, not "are minds". Dig deeper and fix the writing 😂
No deal is what we voted for in the referendum. People's vote ? Who voted in the referendum, sausage rolls ?
No. You advised. Now we need another vote give the go ahead. The referendum was advisory: "Limitation: This act required a referendum to be held on the question of the UK's continued membership of the European Union before the end of 2017. The bill did not contain any requirement for the UK Government to implement the results of the referendum, nor set a time limit by which a vote to leave the EU should be implemented. Instead, this is a type of referendum known as pre-legislative or consultative, which enables the electorate to voice an opinion which then influences the Government in its policy decisions" (uncontested in Wikipedia)
@@bencobbett2819 the vote definitely said leave or remain. Remainers then changed it to we will leave only on a good deal. Brexit means exit
@@nathanpinch8079 the MANIFESTO for the "leave" vote had more flavours than Walkers Crisps !!
@@MatraEtAlpine I wouldn't know I was a ukip voter. Their manifesto was clear as day
@@nathanpinch8079 when a Welsh assembly UKIP member admits they lied then you know y pi u voted for lies ? Was it immigrants then ? Lies. Farage lies about EU operation?
Campbell is a self opinionated Pratt that does not know when to put a sock in it.
He cannot be trusted and has proved that through his past actions.
What matters is the effect Brexit is going to have, not what you think of Campbell.
@@garsm2290 We're all going to die! we're all going to die! oh no, I mean that other thing, carry on.
You spelt *ock wrong.
@Sun Tzu Agree, Campbell is a rude, nasty bully. While someone like him is leading the Remain war of attrition it is destined to fail.
@Michael McCullagh Fully Agree
You hit the nail on the head Alistair, "you hear what people are saying" your problem is you do not LISTEN!
This is why the Brexit Party must win, then move on getting rid of this hateful EU loving big business £80,000+ over paid so call politician for the people.
I agree. Call time on the BBC
Farage is on 450K just from Aaron Banks.
@@garsm2290 so he should be hes the only one worth paying anything to unlike all the other duck houses haha.
Cambell should receive no air time.
I assume you meant, Cambell should receive no air!
Lol👍😁
MAY IS TOAST .
I strongly protest your statement, May is not Toast. Toast is delicious and capable of full filling anyone's personal expectations by the variety of ways it can be toasted and can be savory, sweet or both, depending on the choice of topping, things that can hardly be associated with May. Also, unlike May, Toast is a strong and stable foundation for any sandwich, and does not necessarily mean breakfast, it could also mean lunch, dinner or for the more fancy folks, brunch. Toast does not deserve to be equated to her, so please apologize to Toast for doing so.
@Roy Hawker Yes I think your right they certainly should be for the mess and deceit they have created, only deselection of all MP's who support Mays deal and or any other deal not giving us what we voted for and a new leader who is anti EU should make them electable. Bring back Michael Howard and Ann Widdecombe!
I dont think so
@@lovejetfuel4071 Could you explain your'e reasoning.
@@rogerbennett9641 She said she wont resign, and her own party will not vote her out because they wont chance a second election and possibly hand the keys over to Corbyn
If Campbell says one thing I promise you I would do the opposite
Didnt we have a "Peoples Vote" it was called a Referendum, WTF was that if it wasnt a peoples vote?
....because it was based on lies and bullshit? Maybe?
Yes, mainly from the remain side as i recall like the economy will collapse if we voted to leave, remember that one?
@@SidBonkers51 Spoiler alert; we're still in the transition period you clown.
@@mmcfarlane001 thats right resort to insults that'll impress everyone, not. The lie I was referring to was the one that said the economy would crash if the leave vote won, right after the election, not 4 years later. I guess you choose not to remember the real lies though.
@@SidBonkers51 Literally no-one said that. Fact.
Of course the left leaning BBC would give the author of the Dodgy Dossier a platform
So basically all that I got from this was that the two remainers want people to vote unless they vote for leave, and that if we vote again it.s either remain or may’s deal...... Remain should not even be an option anymore, it was already decided. You can not repeat elections until you get the result you want.
You can repeat the process if the situation changes or new information is revealed. It happends in every level of government and in every company that has shareholders. To not be open to the idea of a second referendum is undemocratic and a slipery slope where the excuse "but we voted" can excuse anything.
@@CrowColdblade Big Bollocks to what you think
@@CrowColdblade No new information. Your argument is utter hogwash. Leave means leave period.
@@CrowColdbladeok then after this we will have another one then anbother after all we would have had NEW information and the next time
I hope Farage sorts out BBC when he gets to be Prime minister and sacks them all! No deal is best deal except for remainers on EU gravy Train who are in main media!
Campbell just loves the sound of his own voice and his point is the only point that matters so its stuff everybody my point is all that matters
GET JASON HUNTER ON newsnight he can really tell you the facts about brexit and won’t dodge any question just honesty
Stop putting on people who talk air, sound bites and rubbish
Loved this Woman She wants us to have 2 options on a ballot paper - remain or remain, thereby totally ignoring what we voted for
nobody had a clue what they voted for and if cameron had thought so he wouldn't have given you a vote
@Kevin Feeney what he meant was there weren't any facts behind leaving. They were skewed. One leave voter may have voted to leave for a totally different reason to the person next to them who also voted to leave. Such a vast number of reasons to vote for either but the fact of the matter is anyone who voted leave would have had no idea of the event to follow in the 2 years afterwards, leading to getting this deal.
It hasn't been easy. The deal isn't great. We might end up following EU laws for years to come without any say until we sort ourselves out. I don't think anyone voted for that.
So he's right. They didn't truly know what they were voting for. "Taking back control" maybe, don't make me laugh
@Kevin Feeney if there was another vote, what's the problem? If the country still wanted to leave having seen the deal and now has more information, they're making a more informed decision aren't they?
@Kevin Feeney so everyone that voted leave knew the true length of the negotiations and having to take on all EU laws until we sort out a future deal in the 2yr period after we leave, longer if the backstop is enacted. I think not.
There were people on the TV screaming "we left the EU though" thinking the vote was instantaneous 😂😂
No I didn't read Cameron's letter. I didn't trust his opinion, only facts. There were lots out there about the benefits of staying. Not so much for leaving...
@Salterino Kripperinono, UKIP would still be a tiny minority party,. they might get a couple of MP's in parliament but the votes the tories lost to UKIP would have given key marginal seats and the election to labour and made Ed Milliband the PM
Alistair Campbell.... DESPICABLE!!!!!
Matthew Goodwin is a very switched-on individual. He gets it.
Isn't it ironic that former colonies like Canada, Australia etc have more independence and sovereignty, yet the British govt lacks the courage to make the hard decisions.
Yep..The EU has grown too big. Unless you get out now you will sink with that leaking ship.
@@percy832 when Britain joined the EEC back in 70s, Canada, Australia ,NZ all had to negotiate trade deals from scratch with the world and now belong to,and have trade deals Britain can only dream about,but Canada etc went through hard times to get there.Britain now needs to nail its courage to the sticking place and go forward.
Allen Payne going it alone will be a new experience for Britain, with a reduced industrial base, and without the resources of the empire behind her.
@@barrysmith726 fair comment, Japan has virtually no natural resources either, but they have built up their economy since WW2 based on industrial innovation and a can do attitude, plus a reputation for quality. Britain needs to regain its independence and confidence to truly become the sovereign nation it can be.
Allen Payne and ireland has 5times the uk gdp poverty uk under england rule.
How would remainers have compromised if the vote had gone the other way?
The question is irrelevant, as just enough people were persuaded to vote for the UK to leave and withdraw from the EU.
@@ilokivi and remainers (at the time) wanted compromise. So it's a very relevant question
your personal feeling don't matter democracy must win through or were on a slippery down fall into dictatorship
"Make their constituents poorer"
*Starts an Illegal War in Iraq*
I love these Malcolm Tucker clips. He made a great Doctor too
omnishambles
Alister Campbell is a SPIN Doctor a bullshit provider for his boss Mr war criminal fuck wit Blair... Who would listen to this person who's most probably never had a proper non establishment job in his life... Piss of to Europe if you love it so much and join your un elected criminals... Your pals..you arrogant tosser.
I don't watch Doctor Who but seems like a good guy.
How much air time can the war criminal Campbell get?
16 million starving and 56 thousand dead YEMEN and maggie Mugabe may selling arms
@@jasonosborne3602 Theresa May has no support from the people. She is hated by all sides.
Bear in mind that the war parties, Labour and the Conservatives, won the overwhelming majority of both seats and votes at the 2005 general election. Therefore, if Campbell is a war criminal, then so are the British people.
@@YorickReturns so you consider British people to be war-criminals when the majority of them have no idea what we're doing in the ME?
He is a war criminal but on Brexit he is more than right...
1st Referendum was a false promise that was undelivered by 650 individuals that are overpayed. Representative parliament abdicated it's responsibility and asked the people to take over it's representative duty. The people exercised their RIGHT and voted, then the execution of the peoples choice was returned to the parliament and government and this has exposed the complete uselessness of the parliament.
If the people are required to take responsibility for the failure of the parliament a 2nd time THAT IS FINE but the entire parliament must be suspended for negligence and their benefits withdrawn backdated to the date they were elected on a LEAVE manifesto.
Alastair Darling was a great argument against Remain😆😆
Haha. Quite the humdinger there. Who copyrights this shit?!
They have no idea why we voted leave
They know exactly why but all the talk of gammon and racism shows they despise us and would rather we didn't have the vote.
Why did you vote leave?
@@bluesmaster9896 If wage repression is the answer then LEAVE is totally moronic. The only way countries can power off corporations is when the countries have an united policy to stand of corporations.
@@alexanderchisholm-loxley2426 Troika
@Blues Master Let's all follow North Korea and ignore globalisation. That means saying goodbye to trade deals - ask the head of the WTO to explain. Oh, and if we don't solve the Northern Ireland backstop, the WTO will block us anyway - again, go ask him. Isolate ourselves and cheer on the financial collapse. Only Brexit's rich Tory backers will benefit.
Prison for Campbell and Blair please!
@kevin walker It was in his job description.
Very true
It's Putin who is the aggressor don't you know. Blair and Bush didn't invade the middle east illegally and expand the conflict to 4 other countries there. Nothing to see here. Russia is your enemy.
@@forestsunset9617 WTF has that got to do with the above vid?
Prison for Moog and his mason mates for wanting to destroy the economy in order to stop EU labour regulation, enviromental regulation AND TAX AVOIDANCE... New tax regulation coming into place within the EU.... On..... 1st April 2019...you mug...
We Voted OUT not for a deal OUT MEANS OUT
Leave voters won.
They don't need to compromise
Slimy Patronising Alastair Campbell
I wonder if he would die if you poured salt on him?
@@suzesiviter6083 Horrible isn't he, when you look at his Track Record with Tony Blair, he has the arrogance to still patronise people
@@simonjandrell5897 He is, his eyes are soulless, angry and inpolite with anyone he disagrees with; look how he put that journalist down as well, I dont like her; but there was no need to be so rude.
@@suzesiviter6083 agree with you, he is a Horrid Creature, he also reminds me of Lord of the Rings and Gollam
Play the ball not the man.
Seeing how alastair campbell started a ruckus, can the BBC now bar him to be interviewed?
BBC will even travel to Spain or wherever he's on holidays and give him a script to talk back to the audience... Even if he went to the loo, BBC would still be waiting for him patiently...BBC is a propaganda machine for the establishment. That's why they don't want to privatize it.
Henry - B I havent paid bbc licence for 3 years,saved £450.I just ignore their letters,think they are overwhelmed with non payers.Plenty of legal advice on youtube,happy days.
Their is proof that leaving the Eu will be good for the country , you haven’t Honoured first vote yet leave means leave and people want their vote out of the Eu No deal
Campbell is a bell end he was Blair’s spin doctor, WMD and war in Iraq are all part of his handy work. Now he is pouring scorn on all those who want Brexit.
Mark Fraser Yep! Creates a storm, then cry’s when it rains!
@@jonsmum5552 And how precisely did he create this storm?
Michael M He talks out his arse, he’s still banging on about Brexit and at every opportunity blames Brexit for everything!
@@jonsmum5552 Because Brexit is still not resolved. Boris has now reneged on the very agreement his party came up with and we're heading for a cliff-edge exit which (and I realise the polls are far from perfect but there is consistency at least in this) that the majority of Brits do not want. Under those circumstances, I will continue to 'bang on about it', just in the same way that after a general election we still have an opposition. We don't all simple go home and agree, do we?
Michael M No we don’t go home and agree, Boris did say we will be leaving with or without a deal. All of the parties have back pedalled at some time. They promise is the this and that, to get votes, then snatch it away.
Alastair Cambellend always lose his rag, gets loud and starts waving his arms around when anyone debates him. He can't handle it if someone has a different opinion.
Yet another BBC debate with three remainers......
We urgently need to move the UK Parliament out of London.
Campbell is trying to spin and arrogance lol but he's past it no-one listening its 2019
Campbell by name, Campbell by nature. Just ask a McDonald.
Campbell, meaning in Scots.... Crooked mouth
They want May’s Deal and Remain on the ballot paper, but they won’t put No Deal on the ballot, why? Because we might vote for it.....democracy 😂
@John Doe that’s for the people to decide, it’s called democracy
@John Doe if the democratic vote of the people had been ignored by the elite and anti democrats like yourself, then you would have seen a country really torn apart, but thank you for telling me what I should really care about 😂
@John Doe that’s what people like you will never understand, the economy the economy, some things are more important. I would rather be a little poorer if I gained sovereignty, it was hard fought and shouldn’t have been easily given away. Having said that I don’t believe we would be poorer, that’s simply fear mongering by people like you who want to maintain the status quo. Funny how all the remoaners seem to be in favour of national lockdowns, suddenly the economy isn’t so important. Covid has had an effect on the economy ten times the magnitude Brexit would ever have had. I’m proud and pleased that we will be proven to be on the right side of history. Your protestations are pointless democracy has been implicated ✌🏼
What has gobsmacked continentals is not so much the Brexit decision itself: a country should of course, if it wants to, be able to leave the EU.
It’s the way politicians (and large parts of the media) have handled it: their failure to come clean to voters about the fact that the Brexit they were promised does not exist; that any Brexit at all will come at a hefty price, certainly in the short and medium term; and that Britain, in the 21st century, simply does not occupy the same place in the world as it did in the 19th, or even much of the 20th.
Very well balanced 3 to 1 .
How cqn you have a referendum between mays deal and remain they are both a remain deal the whole point is to get back our independence these remainers are trying to pull a fast one hard brexit is exiting the customs union and the single market anything else would be a complete betrayal of the brexit voters
will you feel independant when ameica demands to open the nhs up to its insurance and medical buisnesses? or when india re demands free movement of people in return for trade , how about when argentina vetos us joining wto or even when we join the wto and have to alter our laws and way of doing things in order to join . ... independance is a myth , every country relies on others or it dies .
How about exiting, Euroatom, EU Data Protection, the European Arrest Warrant, and the world renowned EU Chemicals Agency? The UK government has said it wants to stay part of these parts of the EU... Is that not Brexit, despite Putin's Assassins and ISIS terrorists being very keen that we exit the European Arrest Warrant?
@@excrutiated we will offer fair systems for immigration an the indias will be happy points system based on merit not birth place as for the arrest warrant an that if they let us keep that no harm done if not then we will have to make our own an will make it great like the name Great British arrest warrant suggests it will be
Except now Moog...
@@NotFoxUK If you don't understand the advantages of the EAW... Well, you don't understand...
We voted out! Not for deal or no deal! Isn't that right Noel Edmunds............
So if the vote comes back stay... If there were 3 options of remain, accept deal and leave... does that mean we keep having votes. You can’t give it back to the people, they have already decided and if it goes wrong there will be uproar
Yep, there doesn't need to be any deal at all until after Britain pulls out. And then simply negotiate new trade deals as necessary. The political parasites are trying to make this as difficult as possible, presumably stalling time or keeping Britain locked in the EU while trying to give the illusion it has pulled out. I am not British, but most of us Europeans want the EU to collapse and each country run its own business.
A vote with 3 choices is a stitch up because leave will only but 1/3 of the choices and mathematically stands no chance of winning.
@@columkenn Rubbish. There are knuckle-draggers in every country, but the vast majority of people want the EU to succeed. Your own country, Ireland, has consistently polled well over 80% support.
@@danganbeg7225 Ireland voted No to the Lisbon treaty. It was forced to have a second vote on the same issue. Most believe the second result was fraudulent. It's the only time we had a vote on EU issues. Don't believe what the mainstream media propaganda machines tell you. They also claimed Britain would vote against Brexit. Most I speak to realise the EU is corrupt and dysfunctional only serving the globalists and the political parasites.
You've had your referendum we don't need a deal we just need to get out, how hard is that ?? what do we even pay these people for if this is the best they can do. Cant follow simple instructions>
The pack of wolves still hunting their prey (the people)
The Referendum asked to LEAVE or Remain and LEAVE WON. SO WE MUST LEAVE because that is DEMOCRACY.
Yes.. A Vote Is a VOTE and LEAVE Won the Vote
Yea Campbell you go watch Burnley but then leave as soon as possible. The people in that town voted clearly to leave the EU but you would betray them because that's what you do.
wow Burnley >? SCOTLAND voted by large majority to remain and was whole heartedly ignored by Westminster and even when proposed ways forward 2 years ago was sidelined bu arrogant Tory adn ERG puppet masters :( SO, if you are complaining about his treatmetn of Burnley, can Scotland count on your support for the same reasons ??
Campbell keeps interrupting, it seems he dare not let anyone else have a hearing. I'd love to know what he's afraid of?
Why do we have to see and hear Alastair Campbell. He is totally one sided, never been elected to any post, not even on a village council yet the BBC treat him as a Guru. Time after time his pronouncements have been shown to wrong, he is totally out of touch with reality and utterly undemocratic. Stop giving him and his warped ideas the oxygen of publicity.
Do you want my deal or leave with no deal! That is the only choice. The decision to leave has already been made!
I love the way she says that she hates when people speak down to people want or voted to leave and then at the end she does exactly that! 😊
Yeah that made me laugh
They deserve to be spoken down to. If I say that the average person is ignorant about medicine, and that sick people should go to the doctor instead, no one would find that controversial. Yet, if I say that the average person is ignorant about politics and international trade, that's allegedly gravely insulting.
@Aaron Mason so you voted leave and trusted them to get us a better deal? Or voted remain?
It's true that politicians are incompetent, but they are still much more competent than the average voter.
@Aaron Mason I don't get how they've eroded democracy. The EU were always going to make it hard so that another country doesn't follow suit and leave. The government and the EU have been negotiating for us to leave which was what people voted for. I voted remain but as the people voted leave I thought ok let's see what they come up with.
There are benefits to leaving and staying but there are hardships we will have to endure if we leave (even with a deal) before things get better.
Take what powers back from the EU? We've always been able to reject laws being implemented, it's called a veto and it's democratic. The only thing undemocratic about the EU is the way the EU president is appointed without election but by remaining we could have had some say on changing that.
It's a sad parliament that won't accept the peoples vote.
It’s time for the YELLOW JACKETS
Omg. The lady with the green shirt has said to Campbell what millions have wanted to say!
Campbell can’t stand not being the centre of attention, eh.
I would rapid fire milkshake all over Alistair Campbell.
One question for Campbell, will you tell the truth about Dr David Kelly?
The fifty strongest-growing economies in the world are all OUTSIDE the EU.
For God's sake LEAVE!!
The sooner the better.
Never Surrender.
I could not agree more well said.LEAVE WTO
The bulk of those economies that you’re referring to are also the poorest, and the only way is up for them, the U.K. economy on the other hand is stagnant with poor productivity and a completely mismanagement economy which certain politicians quite happily blame the EU for.
When one’s economy is almost running at full capacity, growth figures look low, but when your economy is coming from a very low base, China is a good example the growth rates look astonishing.
So don’t let those growth rates outside of the EU blind you to a non existent post Brexit boom, it’s an illusion.
When Campbell is losing the argument he try’s to close it down but causing a row....
That is not fair its remain or Mays deal remain also, if we did have to have a peoples vote, it should be remain, May's deal, or leave no deal WTO rules, that's only fair as leave won!
Mathew Godwin nailed it, Leavers more concerned about personal and national security, which comes before economic benefits, remainers are all about money
The elephant in the room is IMMIGRATION. The references to security, 'borders' and 'freedom of movement' recognised the issue, but they were ignored by the other panellists. The Brexiteers I speak to are willing to accept economic disadvantage in order to avoid a deluge of refugees from Merkel's open borders. They also see sovereignty and democracy as worth a struggle, and prefer it to government by bureaucrats. Remainders may think these are worthless or irrelevant factors, but they are the basis of the Leavers position, and need to be addressed.
Fanagot, you may be right, but pretending there are no elephants plays into the hands of the Leavers. Merely calling them racists and xenophobes no longer has any effect - mere NPC language. Until the effects of globalisation and immigration are recognised and debated on their merits, without resorting to insult with no substance, the elephants will just keep growing. That is what is happening, that is why Tommy Robinson, UKIP, and the hard Brexiteers are not backing down but are getting stronger. Farage and Nuttall look like moderates this week. BBC Newsnight does nobody any favours by confining the debate to 'acceptable' topics.
fanagot: do you think 'nipping it in the bud' will require violence? The Antifa and 'punch a Nazi' movements served mostly to brand the left as totalitarian and willing to use violence as a means to an end, so that would do little good. Better a proper public debate than running battles on the streets.
@fanagot - nonsence. It is a case of realism. Leavers have a better understanding of reality.
@@Land-of-reason the better understanding of realism is that immigration into the UK on a large scale is an inevitablility. The latest figures show the same amount of people coming into the country just a switch from a majority EU to a majority non-eu. Unlike Germany we don't train our Young properly. We have a shortage of 40,000 nurses in the UK and that is entirely the fault of Westminster cutting wages and most importantly scrapping the maintenance grant. I see the impact of this everyday with my job
The elephant in the room is you becoming an unwanted immigrant to 27 other countries. The U.K. simply has to use their laws to impose more controls which is not controlled by the EU. You never know what you have until it’s gone so maybe you deserve a no deal Brexit.
"Alistair can you shut up?!". There's a true brexiter.
She is absolutely right! Alistair Campbell refuses to try and understand, as do the majority of Remainers, as to why people voted to Leave. It wasn’t so much about the economics it was more about identity, sovereignty, concern about the EU and the way it is progressing. It’s the bigger picture but Alistair refuses to try and engage in that conversation just the same as we he did over the Iraq war. It’s his arrogance that is his downfall.
Many Brexiteers are prepared to compromise and accept a deal but Remainers don’t even want that and that is causing even more conflict and resentment. His gloomy forecast is proving to be overinflated as
at the moment the economy is doing much better than predicted so how does he explain that?
""Out" is only a 3-letter, 1-syllable word. What part of it do these people not understand?
Let's raise the people's army and...
Some people just dont enjoy being slaves maybe teresa may can be a slave but we want out now
What The peoples vote will look like
Remain
Or
Remain
Nice choice!
will remainers be happy when thier kids are being called up for the EU Army ?
Will never happen.
It was once said couldn't imagine people being willing to die for the eec.
Eu army is just too ridiculous.
Leave and then make a deal. Stop muddying the water.We are not stupid, you don't fool us.
Appeasement Appeasement Appeasement
Is what this country stands for now
No Backbone No Bottle No Fight Cowards all the way
If we were in World War 2 with this lot we would all be speaking German
No Deal is the best deal. Out of the EU with no strings attached. You can't allow yourself to be a slave living on the EU plantation afraid of running away because of the uncertainty of freedom.
Oh the hypocrisy of u! The sun never set on The British Empire 24hrs a day because God wudnt trust yous in the Dark!😂
Membership of the EU is voluntary... We could always leave and now are .. So what are you talking about? We place our troops in Nato under the command of foreign Nato generals.... That dies not make as a colony or slave of Nato... Membership is voluntary...
Except May wants us in Euratom, the European Arrest Warrant, EU Data protection, and in the EU (world renowned) chemicals agency...And very sensible of her to... Who you think benefits if we are not part? Putin's assassins and ISIS terrorists will certainly like us out of the European Arrest Warrant... But, of course, for you to accept that there are good parts of the EU and that working together with Europe to our mutual interest is beneficial... is against your Brexit Cult...Arguing with you Brexit fanatics is like arguing with a religious fundamentalist about evolution...
@Martin Cheung It would only be "in effect voting for prices to go up" if you (the UK) choose to impose tariffs on your imports. It would entirely be up to you, the other member countries would have no say. Right now you are choosing to pay higher prices for many many items by being a member of the EU. The EU is a protectionist racket that can't compete with global prices on many many goods and services. As Mr. Jacob Reese-Mogg likes to point out your prices right now on food, clothing and footwear are artificially high because you're protecting EU businesses from competing against the global market. The EU does not have a monopoly on food, clothing and footwear and once you're out of the EU you're free to buy them from whomever you choose and have them compete for your business.
You really think you'll have no trade deals ever again? How long will you be trading on WTO rules alone? a couple months? a week? a day? America has a deal ready to go the moment you're free to sign it.
@@AustinDpOwers89 wrong, the prices has already gone up due to the pound becoming weaker. And even if you dont have tarrifs you need to start processing everything that comes into the country from the EU. Someone will have to pay for it, and as always the consumer will carry the extra cost.
Matthew Goodwin is impressive here. Maittlis dismisses leavers’ concerns as a faith. The 2019 election proved him right. He is also polite and measured unlike Campbell.
Look up Goodwin's interview post 2019 GE on Triggernometry. It's very insightful. He talks how he presented his findings on the shift in working class voting patterns to Milliband's team in 2015 and nobody was interested. When he presented to the Tories they were all over it.
Why the deal and remain. Why not the deal or leave on WTO
So many reasons- but one is, tons of countries in WTO object to our plans and it would take years to work out.
The people have already had their say!!!
@05rosebud They never had their say on the mess we're now being offered!
The people were lied to, in an outrageous campaign, which broke many rules and laws, and thus the outcome of the advisory referendum should be declared null and void, and article 50 revoked. If then it is felt that we should have a second referendum later (which I think would be a mistake), then it must be very carefully run, with any information properly referenced and checked.
Send this Alistair home. He is the example of what is wrong.
as an American, this Brexit is about freedom democracy and politicians keeping their word instead of quibbling away the people's vote.
There are 3 options - One to stay, one to sign the deal (i.e stay) or leave. If that is put to a vote leave stands no chance mathematically of winning as in is only 1/3 of the choice.
REMAIN. Become France, see the EU is working so well in France.
Are you being sarcastic? Have you seen what is happening there?
Their economy has overtaken us since brexit... Peaceful protests by drivers plus a few Anarchists rioting in Central Paris is not 1789...You are a victim of the media...
@@pyellard3013 I am not a victim of the press. I have just returned home from the Continent, travelling through France and Paris. I experienced the yellow jackets first-hand. You are seeing a new revolution in France.
@@melodyschleicher81 Well, I saw less than 2OO anti Putin protestors in Moscow... On British TV it was portrayed as a major demonstration...
@@pyellard3013 I know nothing about Russia, so refrain from comment.
The leavers only won 1-0, nearly a draw. Lets play again. How stupid are these MPs Not one of them has any back bone, all worried about their carreers & not the people or the country.
Don’t you get it? It’s a crap deal
Old Jenny would want to learn to keep her composure, didn't hive a great account of herself