Can't come up with a better acoustic guitar riff than that...the song is (mostly) in 7/4 time which really makes it stand out among pop/rock songs - it's what gives the song its driving movement. One of my faves....glad you enjoyed it!
I would make it alternating measures of three and four. And verses begin on the second measure. And you come to the end of the second measure and hey what’s next? As you say it gives it that driving movement, always that incompleteness always that where is the next beat?
We played this at my Dad’s funeral. My Dad actually went with us to see Gabriel in the early 80s and loved it. We saw him after the 4th album and the last time was the secret world tour in about 93 I think. Please watch the live version of the Secret World, it’s magic. Keep up the good work 👍
Gabriel is a very deep rabbit hole. From Red Rain to Biko. Great lyricist, composer, flute player and showman. His live performances are phenomenal. Enjoy!
I AGREE! Saw Peter @ Madison Square Garden ages ago. It's performance art, unlike any other concert. A Gabriel Show is a HAPPENING with the audience bonding as one
I have always interpreted this song as Peter Gabriel coming home to himself. I suspect he connected with other-worldly beings quite early on - 'did not believe the information, just had to trust imagination'. He knew the knowledge would make him an outcast -- 'to keeping silence I resigned, my friends would think I was a nut'. Once you have the inner knowing, everything else pales by comparison -- 'so I went from day to day, though my life was in a rut.' Then you find courage to be something else -- 'till I thought of what I'd say, which connections I should cut.' The courage to be the real you -- 'today I don't need a replacement, I tell them what the smile on my face meant ... you can keep my things, they've come to take me home.' Home is the real Peter Gabriel who exists outside the matrix. A journey we are all trying to find the courage to take.
The lyrics of this song actually get to me emotionally. I've never fully understood why. There's just some magic in the way this entire song is composed.
The song is about his departure from Genesis, he wanted to try new and different things but because Lamb Lies Down had been so successful the record company wanted more of the same so rather than give in he left the band.
In my heart of hearts... Peter Gabriel is the pinnacle of modern composition... I am 44 year old bass player and love progressive rock, blues, jazz... He transcends the "rock" genre... Sledge Hammer is still my favorite Bass-line EVER... Tony Levin was his Bass Player for 99% of his solo music and my personal favorite bassist as well... I might also suggest "Digging In The Dirt" as is Peter at his "best"... You might even consider a watch party for his "Secret World" Concert, I'd sit in... Thanks - Joe
Must have been a great show! That "So" album was one of the first LPs somebody sent him and it wasn't me, it was "Graflex"... Sent with a bunch of other LPs and 45s if I recall....
Had the luck/privilege to see Gabriel for his first ever solo tour performing this song at The Roxy in Hollywood. His solo work actually surpasses that which he did with Genesis in volume, and matches in magnitude. You have much to listen to. Blessings.
This song is in a seven beat cycle and Gabriel’s vocal line starts on the fifth beat and ends on the eighth beat which is also the one beat of the next measure, this gives it that special movement feel. Great song with fantastic lyrics and you did a fine reaction. Thanks.
If you want to start a musicologist channel, then be my guest. It's all about whether you like the bloody song, and not how many beats to the bar or what metre it's in. Keep it musical, and stop intellectualising about the scientific minutiae!
@@Katehowe3010 We're not all philistines. Hartlor's point is a good one and explains the rhythmic movement feel of the song, and is no more 'intellectual' than the reactor's points. Interesting that you felt it necessary to use longer words than the person you're accusing of 'intellectualising'. Have you tried therapy?
@@Katehowe3010 People can comment about any aspects of the music that they want. You have quite a bit of audacity to be telling people what they should and and should not be commenting on here, when we are *all* discussing music. For you, the musical structure of songs may be unimportant, but to many people, it is interesting and important.
If this is were you start with Peter Gabriel, this is a good place. It is a long road you have begun to embark. Mr. Gabriel was limited by his place in Genesis, but the door was opened wide by this album. The subsequent recordings earned him a place in music history. I have never been disappointed by his journey.
Can't wait for Supper's Ready . I know it's on your to do list. You're going to o love it. For everyone,his live concert in Verona 2010 is beautiful. Glorious
There’s a live version of this too that you should watch, he’s always happy looking and has so much fun in his shows! Wish I could have seen one of those shows back in the day.
This is such a beautiful, timeless song! My favorite Peter Gabriel song is “Mercy Street.” It’s atmospheric and soul-stirring! Looking forward to more Peter Gabriel reactions! Well done!
It's a shame you have never had the chance to see Peter Gabriel live. He puts on a phenomenal show. Ever since the first time I saw him in 1982 I have only missed one tour (I've seen him live at least nine times in three different states). While many of the set lists are the same, each tour is a great experience. Even as he gets older, the shows are still so impressive (New Blood tour). For fun, check out the Solsbury Hill Live DNA video. It's a montage of Solsbury Hill live over several years (decades).
@@Yosef1952 it was a beast live. Though in truth I don't think that was what the song was about, it could certainly be interpreted that way. I thought it was about human suffering inspired by a dream he had. Either way great song.
I was just thinking of you. Session player Louie Shelton tells Joe Chambers that his advice to young guitar players who want to get session work is to learn several styles, but importantly, get a good base education in the blues because it will carry you through to other styles. (At 46:30. Musicians Hall of Fame channel)
This just grooves; it connects to the hips, before your brain (fails to) process the lyrics. I thought that 45 years ago and despite 3 (or 4 changes of mind subsequently, I maintain it. By which I mean I like it a great deal and was pleased you did too.
So…. See what I did there? Anyway, I was in high school when i heard this song in the 80s and it was one of those songs that was on a higher level for me: and Liberty, she pirouette when I think that I am free. That line is amazing-can you see the image it evokes???!! That’s lyricism at its best. I had no idea who Peter Gabriel was I thought he was new on the scene. That’s so funny. Anyway, next step for you: in your eyes by PG and then also the movie it made famous: Say Anything.
Great choice Daniel and so much more of Peter's work is worth diving into. For a visual treat as well as a vibe, try "In Your Eyes" but do make sure it's the 'Secret World live' version, which is a very different experience to the original track - I cannot recommend it highly enough!
One of Peter's greatest songs. I've loved this one since I was a young DJ. Though Peter's made a lot of awesome music, it's this one that elicits the biggest reaction at concerts from the audience. Glad you got to hear this Daniel!!! I knew you'd appreciate it. TRUE FILM FAN
It’s a beautiful song that always leaves you with a smile on your face and gives you a feeling of freedom, exhilaration and joy, the same feelings he was having while taking the difficult, but necessary (for him) step to leave the band. The vocal noises he does at the end accentuate this feeling of joy and freedom, of finally being able to do what you want, shout, cry, laugh, wimper… whatever you feel like doing, and it makes you picture him jumping and running wild, like he’s been liberated from a huge burden. It’s a joy of a song. Sledgehammer is also a fantastic track, and very different from this one, you should definitely listen to it, you won’t regret it.
Hi Daniel, this was such a warm and welcoming reaction. Thank you for sharing with us, it was a lovely distraction from the winter blues I'm feeling! I did chuckle when you said 'what the hell?' at the way the song finishes, as I remember thinking EXACTLY the same when I first heard the ending waaay back as a kid in the 1980s. The lyrics dissection was interesting too, as I've never looked at them in depth for this song ... possibly because as a kid you maybe wouldn't? Anyway nicely one! Fingers crossed you will check out and react to Sledgehammer, as you hinted you may do. It is different from this song, very much 80s production and alas the lyrics do not compare to Solsbury Hill. However the video is well worth watching, at the time it really did make an impact ... especially remembering of course it was not possible to create such a masterpiece on a computer at that time. Wishing you well from the UK, Ian G
Gabriel is a rabbit hole you can dive into and enjoy. He is connected through Genesis with so many excellent musicians. I suggest Come Talk to Me and Red Rain once you work through his massive hits. And most of all, I recommend his live concert album/dvd Secret World. That is pure joy to watch.
Peter is so creative, it's a great rabbit hole to go down, songs like, Games Without Frontiers, Sky Blue, Here Comes The Flood, Biko, In You Eyes and my personal favourite Moribund The Burgermeister, he is great live too, his Growing Up tour was spectacular and was filmed for DVD release and there are a lot not songs from that tour on RUclips
Peter Gabriel is one of the most unique artists out there. His music is usually categorized as 'world music'. He utilizes whatever sounds and artists who help him express his visions the best, regardless of where they originate. Love the channel dude, keep on trucking. Saw him live in '93 and he absolutely mesmerized the audience. Please consider checking out 'Biko', a song he wrote bringing attention to Stephen Biko, a man who died from opposing the brutal conditions of apartheid in South Africa.
Did you do Mike Rutherford's group, Mike and the Mechanics? If not... You should. Try "Living Years" So much talent from Genesis and most of the band members solo stuff. 👍👍👍👍
@@theplanetruth Mike & The Mechanics is Mike Rutherford's group which started in the 1980's, simultaneously while the Phil Collins Genesis was rolling. Featured lead singer Paul Carrack, they had a multitude of hits, including their biggest which was "The Living Years", mentioned above,
Oh my, we ARE strolling down my Memory Lane today. I had his first 4 solo albums. Oh to be hearing this for the first time again, aged 18, 1979. I had friends from Wiltshire, where Solsbury Hill is. They were the sweetest hippy guys you ever met. Came to London to seek their fortune and a bloody good time. We certainly did; Stuart, Ken & Dave Frazier where are you now?
Gabriel has always made interesting use of percussion. All of his solo work is worth exploring. You could easily do a full album listen to each of his first five or six solo albums. This song was his first single after leaving Genesis.
Wonderful reaction! Gabriel's solo work is extremely impressive. His first four albums (before "So") hold a special place in my heart. "Moribund The Burgermeister," "Humdrum," and "Here Comes The Flood" are particularly amazing from the debut album. (Although the Robert Fripp "Exposure" album version of "Here Comes The Flood" is the BEST. It's still Peter Singing and playing piano... but the background soundtrack is BRILLIANT.) The Second solo album (known as "scratch") has some fantastic songs as well: "On The Air," "D.I.Y.," and the best track on the album "Mother Of Violence" are standouts. Also "Wonderful Day In A One Way World" and "White Shadow"... basically ALL of Side 1. The Third album (known as "Melt") is his masterpiece. Every song is worth reacting to. Kate Bush, Paul Weller (The Jam), Dave Gregory (XTC), Tony Levin (King Crimson), Robert Fripp (Kind Crimson), among others make appearances. Fourth album (also known as "Security") is great, too. HILARIOUS SIDE NOTE: On the Japanese pressing of Peter's debut album, the lyric notes for Solsbury Hill don't say "I tell them what the smile on my face meant," They say: "I tell them not to spy on my basement." It's like somebody was transcribing through lousy speakers and just gave up. lol
Solsbury Hill is a hill overlooking the very genteel city of Bath is southwest England. Gabriel used to walk round there regularly. IIRC, the song is about him giving up what he had with Genesis, and looking towards what lay ahead. I recall he said he had some sort of epiphany or other spiritual experience walking up there one day. I remember loving the song when it first came out. And being surprised (and indeed, a bit taken aback) at the wide range of different types of song on that first album!
@@TheVirtualWatcher Indeed! I suspect you may well even be able to see the hill from near the studios - I think it will be around an hour's brisk walk?
The story behind this song was that he was depressed about possibly splitting from his band. He went out for a walk up Solsbury Hill. He saw a UFO.......... Had an "experience". "My friends would think I was a nut"......
One of my all time favorite PG songs! There is great stuff on all his albums, but Security is my favorite album as a whole. I believe the weird vocals at the end are Peter reciting parts of Dadaist Kurt Schwitters Ur Sonata, (or Sonata in Primal Sounds.) You can also hear Brian Eno reciting some of it on "Kurt's Rejoinder", from his Before and After Science album.
Peter Gabriel, about time! Thanks. Great comments as usual. Gabriel is so creative. Cabbages? A metaphor for the promise of future bounty? Home? As with Phil Collins, Gabriel is always intentional and thoughtful with great attention to details. He also has that rhythmic feel that his friend Phil has and all Peter's music shows that in his use of drums. I just saw a couple reviews of Genesis' "Mad Man Moon" (1976) sung about a desert and looking to find greener pastures using sand and rain as metaphors. Peter's best friend in Genesis, Tony wrote the lyrics. Several comments were that he wrote it for Gabriel. It opens and closes with a melancholy flute (synthesized). Perhaps an allusion to Peter who played flute with Genesis and Tony's sadness at his leaving the band. It would be fitting that Gabriel wrote this tune (1977) as a rebuttal; saying he was not a mad man staring at the moon, but had to leave to spread his wings. How ironic that Gabriel left to pursue his own career, just as those who 'stayed' in Genesis also pursued their own solo careers (everyone pirouettes). The brilliance is that all became very successful. Regardless, the song is inspirational for those contemplating taking a risk to spread their wings.
God, I love this song. Peter Gabriel is an absolute musical genius. He’s been my favorite solo artist for probably 40 years. His mainstream hits like Sledgehammer and Steam are NOT his best work, in my opinion. Instead, listen to “Biko”, about the South African activist murdered in police custody during apartheid. The song was credited with bringing worldwide attention to the injustice going on there in the 80’s. And “In Your Eyes”, one of the most beautiful love songs ever written. The live version from Peter’s Secret World tour is not to be missed. It’s one of his best live performances, showing what Peter is all about - bringing together diverse musicians from all over the world. In fact, any song from that concert is brilliant. The rabbit hole is deep here, and Peter’s work is very diverse. I suggest listening to “Here Comes The Flood”, “Kiss of Life”, “Father, Son”, “Mercy Street”, “Blood of Eden”, “Secret World”, “Darkness”, and “Signal to Noise”……. There are just too many great songs to list. Can’t wait to see what you listen to next.
It's a magical song, and it really takes a person out of themselves. He says mostl the song is about leaving Genesis, which made me go "huh?". Ok. I still take it as an ethereal and childlike theme.
This debut album is all over the place. Moribund Burgermeister sounds like XTC, Excuse Me is barbershop quartet, Modern Love is as straight ac/DC rock as he gets. I love this album
As you delve more into Peter's solo work, please check out Games Without Frontiers, Biko, Here Comes the Flood, I Don't Remember. And for added fun, he titled his four albums: Peter Gabriel Peter Gabriel Peter Gabriel Peter Gabriel You can only tell them apart by the covers
I believe the website that provided the lyrics is incorrect. The line near the end is "No one taught them etiquette. I was shown another me" (not "I will show another me"). At least, that's the way I've always heard it (and like a lot better). One of my all-time favorite songs.
You should listen and react to his “Secret World Tour”. Like Pink Floyd and Supertramp…..the stage show is a huge part of the overall experience with his music. It is a feast for the senses.
The unusual drum sound you mention sounds a lot like a Senegalese talking drum. But I can't find any reference to such in any of the online documentation for the song. They programmed a keyboard to make many of drum noises for the song, so maybe they programmed a synth version of a talking drum?
As with most of the folks who reply to these sort of videos, I too have a deep and personal attachment and story...but I won't bore you. Only to say that the imagery with the eagle is very much like encountering your 'spirit guide' in the natural world. "Had to listen, had no choice" and "to keep in silence, I resigned" are shamanic behaviors. Peter Gabriel is more than mere mortal in this respect. The integrity of his artistic message to the world REALLY TAKES OFF from the point of this song. His great transition piece into pure self expression. Don't do Sledgehammer Do 'Biko' LIVE! because Biko ...and because it's Black History Month (thank me later)
One of my favourite artists, and such a great song, really positive and uplifting, always makes me feel good. It would be great if you did Sledgehammer, it's a very different experience, lol. Great, fun song and musically brilliant, but you have to try and use the official video, it's a must! Love your work Daniel, and I hope you're feeling better.
Well done, I have never heard such an in depth analysis of a song I have loved from the start. Eagle, hillclimbing,, spirit guides, are images used in his song San Jacinto. later in his career Salsbury hill was first. I loved the image in my mind of leaving the mundane and flying into magic with Eagles soaring. Sledgehammer was Gabrials successful stab at commercial. I did not like it at all. Gabrial dancing around double entendre and doing Motown. Thought the video that went with it was inventive and funny almost made the song tolerable. . Never has Peter been so funky unless you include, Shock the Monkey. I thought to myself, he should never have left Genesis. I think he did not really hit his artistic stride at first, lots of hit and miss. while Collins was soaring with the group. . At his best as in; Wallflower or Biko. or, In Your Eyes.or Signal to Noise or Here Comes the Flood. (try to find Peter's solo piano version.}.and of course, his Genesis works. His music is stirring with unmatched beauty and power On the other hand, some of his songs go to very dark places. With the exception of Biko which is a gem, the rest of the Melting Face album frightens me, disturbing songs all. The water drop album was his most mature artistic statement, The albums masterwork, Signal to Noise, is soul wrenching and redeeming work. at the same time. his finest solo piece. in my estimation.
Thank you for this reactions of one of my favorite songs. Peter uses the same Eagle in the song San Jacinto. For me representing the Holy Spirit. I recommend to react to that song. The New Blood version, has some great renditions of his favorite songs. Of course they all have deep meaning
This song is pretty much my personal theme song. I've always thought the Turning Water into Wine line is an interesting reference to his work with Genesis. Much of his work with Genesis had religious themes - even when his bandmates did not understand it very often. And who else can find so many rhymes for Etiquette.
Listening this and comparing it to the Genesis' song "Follow You, Follow Me", I wonder the reasons Gabriel and Genesis parting ways. But of course there might have been other than pure musical reasons. Tony Banks seems to be rather strong headed if judging by his interviews on the boxed CD -set of Gabriel era Genesis.
This is good start. I was relieved to hear it after break from Genesis. First Three albums have no title, so fans named them from cover art; Car, Melt, Scratch. I think you have vinyl of PG. There is documentary of him in studio. Very creative guy. Robert Fripp and Steve Hunter provided guitars. Do more early stuff like “Games Without Frontiers” and “ Shock the Monkey” before the later Sledgehammer. Full album would be great too.
I understand why people watch the official video when listening to songs, but I really wish they wouldn't. For every song that is enhanced by its video, there are dozens that are marred. Music is an audio medium; the listening is the important part. If it needs the video, it isn't a good song. Listen to the song the way it came over the radio or played off the album when it was released. You can always go back and watch the video later.
Watch this concert! ruclips.net/video/azas-1zInJ8/видео.html Secret World Tour 1994 If not the whole concert, there are songs on RUclips from this. Solsbury Hill of course. But I’d recommend In Your Eyes.
Reminds me of once being free in America Free do go where you want when you want however you wanted to get there.
Gone are the days.
Can't come up with a better acoustic guitar riff than that...the song is (mostly) in 7/4 time which really makes it stand out among pop/rock songs - it's what gives the song its driving movement. One of my faves....glad you enjoyed it!
I've heard a cover version played in 4/4. Suffice it to say, it sucks ass.
I would make it alternating measures of three and four. And verses begin on the second measure. And you come to the end of the second measure and hey what’s next? As you say it gives it that driving movement, always that incompleteness always that where is the next beat?
2001 paul simon
We played this at my Dad’s funeral. My Dad actually went with us to see Gabriel in the early 80s and loved it. We saw him after the 4th album and the last time was the secret world tour in about 93 I think. Please watch the live version of the Secret World, it’s magic. Keep up the good work 👍
Beautiful song, one of my all time favourites
Gabriel is a very deep rabbit hole.
From Red Rain to Biko.
Great lyricist, composer, flute player and showman.
His live performances are phenomenal.
Enjoy!
I AGREE! Saw Peter @ Madison Square Garden ages ago. It's performance art, unlike any other concert. A Gabriel Show is a HAPPENING with the audience bonding as one
I never knew he was a flautist.
"Walked right out of the machinery", refers to his departure from Genesis.
I have always interpreted this song as Peter Gabriel coming home to himself. I suspect he connected with other-worldly beings quite early on - 'did not believe the information, just had to trust imagination'. He knew the knowledge would make him an outcast -- 'to keeping silence I resigned, my friends would think I was a nut'. Once you have the inner knowing, everything else pales by comparison -- 'so I went from day to day, though my life was in a rut.' Then you find courage to be something else -- 'till I thought of what I'd say, which connections I should cut.' The courage to be the real you -- 'today I don't need a replacement, I tell them what the smile on my face meant ... you can keep my things, they've come to take me home.' Home is the real Peter Gabriel who exists outside the matrix. A journey we are all trying to find the courage to take.
The lyrics of this song actually get to me emotionally. I've never fully understood why. There's just some magic in the way this entire song is composed.
The song is about his departure from Genesis, he wanted to try new and different things but because Lamb Lies Down had been so successful the record company wanted more of the same so rather than give in he left the band.
This was about Peter's exit from Genesis
In my heart of hearts... Peter Gabriel is the pinnacle of modern composition... I am 44 year old bass player and love progressive rock, blues, jazz... He transcends the "rock" genre... Sledge Hammer is still my favorite Bass-line EVER... Tony Levin was his Bass Player for 99% of his solo music and my personal favorite bassist as well... I might also suggest "Digging In The Dirt" as is Peter at his "best"... You might even consider a watch party for his "Secret World" Concert, I'd sit in... Thanks - Joe
Saw Peter Gabriel live back in the 80s. His show was phenomenal. Great voice. If you get a chance to listen to "So" (1986) you'll be in for a treat.
Must have been a great show!
That "So" album was one of the first LPs somebody sent him and it wasn't me, it was "Graflex"... Sent with a bunch of other LPs and 45s if I recall....
SO is my favorite PG Album
Had the luck/privilege to see Gabriel for his first ever solo tour performing this song at The Roxy in Hollywood.
His solo work actually surpasses that which he did with Genesis in volume, and matches in magnitude. You have much to listen to.
Blessings.
Me too! But in Cardiff South Wales. Stunning.
Also! "Sledgehammer" is one of Those Music Videos. (Claymation done by the studio that went on to make Wallace and Gromit.)
This song is in a seven beat cycle and Gabriel’s vocal line starts on the fifth beat and ends on the eighth beat which is also the one beat of the next measure, this gives it that special movement feel. Great song with fantastic lyrics and you did a fine reaction. Thanks.
If you want to start a musicologist channel, then be my guest. It's all about whether you like the bloody song, and not how many beats to the bar or what metre it's in. Keep it musical, and stop intellectualising about the scientific minutiae!
@@Katehowe3010 We're not all philistines. Hartlor's point is a good one and explains the rhythmic movement feel of the song, and is no more 'intellectual' than the reactor's points. Interesting that you felt it necessary to use longer words than the person you're accusing of 'intellectualising'. Have you tried therapy?
@@Katehowe3010 People can comment about any aspects of the music that they want. You have quite a bit of audacity to be telling people what they should and and should not be commenting on here, when we are *all* discussing music. For you, the musical structure of songs may be unimportant, but to many people, it is interesting and important.
@@davidjames3080 Therapy was a waste of money!
@@Katehowe3010 There are many ways to listen to music, no need to be so angry.
More of this, please. Too many forget what a phenomenal artist PG is.
Another one of his earlier solo tracks that made it onto the airwaves was Shock The Monkey. It was quite unique at the time and kind of still is.
VERY cryptic and disturbing song, and yet catchy as hell!
If this is were you start with Peter Gabriel, this is a good place. It is a long road you have begun to embark. Mr. Gabriel was limited by his place in Genesis, but the door was opened wide by this album. The subsequent recordings earned him a place in music history. I have never been disappointed by his journey.
Can't wait for Supper's Ready . I know it's on your to do list. You're going to o love it. For everyone,his live concert in Verona 2010 is beautiful. Glorious
Just love how this just carries you along. And yes Daniel it is like a journey to somewhere kinda tempo:)I love Red Rain by him!
There’s a live version of this too that you should watch, he’s always happy looking and has so much fun in his shows! Wish I could have seen one of those shows back in the day.
You might like The Charismatic Voice review of this tune. I swear she is absolutely in love with Peter Gabriel with his LIVE performance.
Love these lyrics. Peter Gabriel is a master.
Peter has always had deep thinking, emotional and a spiritual sense about his lyrics !
This is such a beautiful, timeless song! My favorite Peter Gabriel song is “Mercy Street.” It’s atmospheric and soul-stirring! Looking forward to more Peter Gabriel reactions! Well done!
I love the 7/4 time signature. It really gives movement to the song!
It's a shame you have never had the chance to see Peter Gabriel live. He puts on a phenomenal show. Ever since the first time I saw him in 1982 I have only missed one tour (I've seen him live at least nine times in three different states). While many of the set lists are the same, each tour is a great experience. Even as he gets older, the shows are still so impressive (New Blood tour).
For fun, check out the Solsbury Hill Live DNA video. It's a montage of Solsbury Hill live over several years (decades).
It’s not just music industry but also the spirit taking one home at the end of your life.
Peter Gabriel had so many hit songs in his solo career. Thanks for your reaction to this, Daniel.
Yes! Peter Gabriel, I'm excited too maybe Red Rain next time for some scope. Love it!
Red Rain is MASSIVE. A great number. A powerful statement about the horrors of a possible nuclear war, a fear that was very real when it was released.
@@Yosef1952 it was a beast live.
Though in truth I don't think that was what the song was about, it could certainly be interpreted that way. I thought it was about human suffering inspired by a dream he had. Either way great song.
I was just thinking of you. Session player Louie Shelton tells Joe Chambers that his advice to young guitar players who want to get session work is to learn several styles, but importantly, get a good base education in the blues because it will carry you through to other styles. (At 46:30. Musicians Hall of Fame channel)
This just grooves; it connects to the hips, before your brain (fails to) process the lyrics. I thought that 45 years ago and despite 3 (or 4 changes of mind subsequently, I maintain it.
By which I mean I like it a great deal and was pleased you did too.
So….
See what I did there? Anyway, I was in high school when i heard this song in the 80s and it was one of those songs that was on a higher level for me: and Liberty, she pirouette when I think that I am free. That line is amazing-can you see the image it evokes???!! That’s lyricism at its best. I had no idea who Peter Gabriel was I thought he was new on the scene. That’s so funny. Anyway, next step for you: in your eyes by PG and then also the movie it made famous: Say Anything.
Great choice Daniel and so much more of Peter's work is worth diving into. For a visual treat as well as a vibe, try "In Your Eyes" but do make sure it's the 'Secret World live' version, which is a very different experience to the original track - I cannot recommend it highly enough!
Do it!! ruclips.net/video/evN6DIGPIJM/видео.html
One of Peter's greatest songs. I've loved this one since I was a young DJ. Though Peter's made a lot of awesome music, it's this one that elicits the biggest reaction at concerts from the audience. Glad you got to hear this Daniel!!! I knew you'd appreciate it. TRUE FILM FAN
Two tasty sweets in one day. Thanks.
You have such a deep spirit. I'm glad to see you going strong.
Gabriel’s work in the 70s and 80s was awesome .
It’s a beautiful song that always leaves you with a smile on your face and gives you a feeling of freedom, exhilaration and joy, the same feelings he was having while taking the difficult, but necessary (for him) step to leave the band. The vocal noises he does at the end accentuate this feeling of joy and freedom, of finally being able to do what you want, shout, cry, laugh, wimper… whatever you feel like doing, and it makes you picture him jumping and running wild, like he’s been liberated from a huge burden. It’s a joy of a song. Sledgehammer is also a fantastic track, and very different from this one, you should definitely listen to it, you won’t regret it.
Oh! A favorite. Perfect first solo song to react to for PG!
I loved seeing Peter Gabriel in concert!!
Shock the Monkey tour, he's so talented musically and visually ♥️🎶
Please, sir, may we have some more?
Hi Daniel, this was such a warm and welcoming reaction. Thank you for sharing with us, it was a lovely distraction from the winter blues I'm feeling!
I did chuckle when you said 'what the hell?' at the way the song finishes, as I remember thinking EXACTLY the same when I first heard the ending waaay back as a kid in the 1980s. The lyrics dissection was interesting too, as I've never looked at them in depth for this song ... possibly because as a kid you maybe wouldn't? Anyway nicely one!
Fingers crossed you will check out and react to Sledgehammer, as you hinted you may do. It is different from this song, very much 80s production and alas the lyrics do not compare to Solsbury Hill. However the video is well worth watching, at the time it really did make an impact ... especially remembering of course it was not possible to create such a masterpiece on a computer at that time.
Wishing you well from the UK, Ian G
Gabriel is a rabbit hole you can dive into and enjoy. He is connected through Genesis with so many excellent musicians. I suggest Come Talk to Me and Red Rain once you work through his massive hits. And most of all, I recommend his live concert album/dvd Secret World. That is pure joy to watch.
Earlier it was America and now Gabriel. What a day
You should totally check out 'Red Rain'. Great song by Peter.
Peter is so creative, it's a great rabbit hole to go down, songs like, Games Without Frontiers, Sky Blue, Here Comes The Flood, Biko, In You Eyes and my personal favourite Moribund The Burgermeister, he is great live too, his Growing Up tour was spectacular and was filmed for DVD release and there are a lot not songs from that tour on RUclips
Peter Gabriel is one of the most unique artists out there. His music is usually categorized as 'world music'. He utilizes whatever sounds and artists who help him express his visions the best, regardless of where they originate. Love the channel dude, keep on trucking. Saw him live in '93 and he absolutely mesmerized the audience. Please consider checking out 'Biko', a song he wrote bringing attention to Stephen Biko, a man who died from opposing the brutal conditions of apartheid in South Africa.
One of Gabriel's other masterpieces: "Supper's Ready"... it awaits.
Did you do Mike Rutherford's group, Mike and the Mechanics? If not... You should.
Try "Living Years"
So much talent from Genesis and most of the band members solo stuff. 👍👍👍👍
In my comment I mentioned I had no idea who PG was re Genesis. Same with M&TM. No clue who Rutherford was as a kid.
@@theplanetruth Mike & The Mechanics is Mike Rutherford's group which started in the 1980's, simultaneously while the Phil Collins Genesis was rolling. Featured lead singer Paul Carrack, they had a multitude of hits, including their biggest which was "The Living Years", mentioned above,
Daniel did that one with the old man as they say...
ruclips.net/video/Z4awN97KNhQ/видео.html
@@georgewodicka4839 in case you missed it
Daniel did that one with the old man as they say...
ruclips.net/video/Z4awN97KNhQ/видео.html
@@daveking9393 Yes, I remember it now, of course I didn't 30 minutes ago :)
Oh my, we ARE strolling down my Memory Lane today. I had his first 4 solo albums. Oh to be hearing this for the first time again, aged 18, 1979.
I had friends from Wiltshire, where Solsbury Hill is. They were the sweetest hippy guys you ever met. Came to London to seek their fortune and a bloody good time. We certainly did; Stuart, Ken & Dave Frazier where are you now?
Gabriel has always made interesting use of percussion. All of his solo work is worth exploring. You could easily do a full album listen to each of his first five or six solo albums. This song was his first single after leaving Genesis.
His live shows are beautiful. The “One World” concert is a work of art
Wonderful reaction! Gabriel's solo work is extremely impressive. His first four albums (before "So") hold a special place in my heart. "Moribund The Burgermeister," "Humdrum," and "Here Comes The Flood" are particularly amazing from the debut album. (Although the Robert Fripp "Exposure" album version of "Here Comes The Flood" is the BEST. It's still Peter Singing and playing piano... but the background soundtrack is BRILLIANT.)
The Second solo album (known as "scratch") has some fantastic songs as well: "On The Air," "D.I.Y.," and the best track on the album "Mother Of Violence" are standouts. Also "Wonderful Day In A One Way World" and "White Shadow"... basically ALL of Side 1.
The Third album (known as "Melt") is his masterpiece. Every song is worth reacting to. Kate Bush, Paul Weller (The Jam), Dave Gregory (XTC), Tony Levin (King Crimson), Robert Fripp (Kind Crimson), among others make appearances.
Fourth album (also known as "Security") is great, too.
HILARIOUS SIDE NOTE: On the Japanese pressing of Peter's debut album, the lyric notes for Solsbury Hill don't say "I tell them what the smile on my face meant," They say: "I tell them not to spy on my basement." It's like somebody was transcribing through lousy speakers and just gave up. lol
I learned more about Gabriel's solo career in this comment than in the entirety of his actual solo career. Well said!
@@georgewodicka4839 ha ha... Cheers!
Gabriel is a genius, and Tony Levin is one of my favorite bassists. He plays Chapman Stick on this for the bass.
Sledgehammer is a very fun sung and the video is wild and inventive. It created quite a sensation when it came out.
In Your Eyes!
Solsbury Hill is a hill overlooking the very genteel city of Bath is southwest England. Gabriel used to walk round there regularly. IIRC, the song is about him giving up what he had with Genesis, and looking towards what lay ahead. I recall he said he had some sort of epiphany or other spiritual experience walking up there one day. I remember loving the song when it first came out. And being surprised (and indeed, a bit taken aback) at the wide range of different types of song on that first album!
Not very far from his 'Real World Studios' in the village of Box.
@@TheVirtualWatcher Indeed! I suspect you may well even be able to see the hill from near the studios - I think it will be around an hour's brisk walk?
The story behind this song was that he was depressed about possibly splitting from his band. He went out for a walk up Solsbury Hill. He saw a UFO.......... Had an "experience". "My friends would think I was a nut"......
So glad you did this one. One of my all time favorites ❤ love these lyrics so much.
I always loved this track!
One of my all time favorite PG songs! There is great stuff on all his albums, but Security is my favorite album as a whole.
I believe the weird vocals at the end are Peter reciting parts of Dadaist Kurt Schwitters Ur Sonata, (or Sonata in Primal Sounds.) You can also hear Brian Eno reciting some of it on "Kurt's Rejoinder", from his Before and After Science album.
Peter Gabriel, about time! Thanks. Great comments as usual.
Gabriel is so creative. Cabbages? A metaphor for the promise of future bounty? Home? As with Phil Collins, Gabriel is always intentional and thoughtful with great attention to details. He also has that rhythmic feel that his friend Phil has and all Peter's music shows that in his use of drums.
I just saw a couple reviews of Genesis' "Mad Man Moon" (1976) sung about a desert and looking to find greener pastures using sand and rain as metaphors. Peter's best friend in Genesis, Tony wrote the lyrics. Several comments were that he wrote it for Gabriel. It opens and closes with a melancholy flute (synthesized). Perhaps an allusion to Peter who played flute with Genesis and Tony's sadness at his leaving the band. It would be fitting that Gabriel wrote this tune (1977) as a rebuttal; saying he was not a mad man staring at the moon, but had to leave to spread his wings.
How ironic that Gabriel left to pursue his own career, just as those who 'stayed' in Genesis also pursued their own solo careers (everyone pirouettes). The brilliance is that all became very successful. Regardless, the song is inspirational for those contemplating taking a risk to spread their wings.
The cabbage images in the video were done 10 years later, not the original video.
One of the greatest student covers ever - check out Solsbury Hill by the School of Rock
God, I love this song. Peter Gabriel is an absolute musical genius. He’s been my favorite solo artist for probably 40 years. His mainstream hits like Sledgehammer and Steam are NOT his best work, in my opinion. Instead, listen to “Biko”, about the South African activist murdered in police custody during apartheid. The song was credited with bringing worldwide attention to the injustice going on there in the 80’s. And “In Your Eyes”, one of the most beautiful love songs ever written. The live version from Peter’s Secret World tour is not to be missed. It’s one of his best live performances, showing what Peter is all about - bringing together diverse musicians from all over the world. In fact, any song from that concert is brilliant.
The rabbit hole is deep here, and Peter’s work is very diverse. I suggest listening to “Here Comes The Flood”, “Kiss of Life”, “Father, Son”, “Mercy Street”, “Blood of Eden”, “Secret World”, “Darkness”, and “Signal to Noise”……. There are just too many great songs to list.
Can’t wait to see what you listen to next.
Great analysis
It's a magical song, and it really takes a person out of themselves. He says mostl the song is about leaving Genesis, which made me go "huh?". Ok. I still take it as an ethereal and childlike theme.
This debut album is all over the place. Moribund Burgermeister sounds like XTC, Excuse Me is barbershop quartet, Modern Love is as straight ac/DC rock as he gets. I love this album
As you delve more into Peter's solo work, please check out Games Without Frontiers, Biko, Here Comes the Flood, I Don't Remember. And for added fun, he titled his four albums:
Peter Gabriel
Peter Gabriel
Peter Gabriel
Peter Gabriel
You can only tell them apart by the covers
The One World tour version of "In Your Eyes" please. Beautiful and you will smile
I believe the website that provided the lyrics is incorrect. The line near the end is "No one taught them etiquette. I was shown another me" (not "I will show another me"). At least, that's the way I've always heard it (and like a lot better). One of my all-time favorite songs.
Gabriel's Book of Love is a staple at SO many weddings .... : > P
You should listen and react to his “Secret World Tour”. Like Pink Floyd and Supertramp…..the stage show is a huge part of the overall experience with his music. It is a feast for the senses.
That video was made years later.
There is a great live version at a concert in Europe France or Greece not sure but very enjoyable!
The unusual drum sound you mention sounds a lot like a Senegalese talking drum. But I can't find any reference to such in any of the online documentation for the song. They programmed a keyboard to make many of drum noises for the song, so maybe they programmed a synth version of a talking drum?
What a great smile at 4:59.
Neil Young wrote a song about leaving Crosby Stills Nash. It was on Rust Never Sleeps.
Try Genesis "Selling England by the pound " 💜
More Peter Gabriel: Shock the Monkey, Games without Frontiers, Red Rain, in your eyes, don’t give up, mercy street. Steam, etc…
As with most of the folks who reply to these sort of videos, I too have a deep and personal attachment and story...but I won't bore you. Only to say that the imagery with the eagle is very much like encountering your 'spirit guide' in the natural world. "Had to listen, had no choice" and "to keep in silence, I resigned" are shamanic behaviors. Peter Gabriel is more than mere mortal in this respect. The integrity of his artistic message to the world REALLY TAKES OFF from the point of this song. His great transition piece into pure self expression.
Don't do Sledgehammer
Do 'Biko' LIVE! because Biko ...and because it's Black History Month (thank me later)
Biko! Biko!
surely the greatest single song ever made about why someone quit a band
One of my favourite artists, and such a great song, really positive and uplifting, always makes me feel good. It would be great if you did Sledgehammer, it's a very different experience, lol. Great, fun song and musically brilliant, but you have to try and use the official video, it's a must! Love your work Daniel, and I hope you're feeling better.
Well done, I have never heard such an in depth analysis of a song I have loved from the start. Eagle, hillclimbing,, spirit guides, are images used in his song San Jacinto. later in his career Salsbury hill was first. I loved the image in my mind of leaving the mundane and flying into magic with Eagles soaring. Sledgehammer was Gabrials successful stab at commercial. I did not like it at all. Gabrial dancing around double entendre and doing Motown. Thought the video that went with it was inventive and funny almost made the song tolerable. . Never has Peter been so funky unless you include, Shock the Monkey. I thought to myself, he should never have left Genesis. I think he did not really hit his artistic stride at first, lots of hit and miss. while Collins was soaring with the group. .
At his best as in; Wallflower or Biko. or, In Your Eyes.or Signal to Noise or Here Comes the Flood. (try to find Peter's solo piano version.}.and of course, his Genesis works. His music is stirring with unmatched beauty and power On the other hand, some of his songs go to very dark places. With the exception of Biko which is a gem, the rest of the Melting Face album frightens me, disturbing songs all. The water drop album was his most mature artistic statement, The albums masterwork, Signal to Noise, is soul wrenching and redeeming work. at the same time. his finest solo piece. in my estimation.
One of the most underappreciated/played songs from PG. Love the cabbage...
This song gave future albums from Peter, a fork in the road made awesome songs later on 😎
My parents' take on this song was that it was either about aliens or a religious experience.
Thank you for this reactions of one of my favorite songs. Peter uses the same Eagle in the song San Jacinto. For me representing the Holy Spirit. I recommend to react to that song. The New Blood version, has some great renditions of his favorite songs. Of course they all have deep meaning
This song has been known to make me break down and weep like a 4 year old child....oof, it’s a very powerful tune
This song is pretty much my personal theme song. I've always thought the Turning Water into Wine line is an interesting reference to his work with Genesis. Much of his work with Genesis had religious themes - even when his bandmates did not understand it very often.
And who else can find so many rhymes for Etiquette.
First!!! New Zealand 🇳🇿 ❤ here!
You should check out the live videos of this on here
Listening this and comparing it to the Genesis' song "Follow You, Follow Me", I wonder the reasons Gabriel and Genesis parting ways. But of course there might have been other than pure musical reasons. Tony Banks seems to be rather strong headed if judging by his interviews on the boxed CD -set of Gabriel era Genesis.
This is good start. I was relieved to hear it after break from Genesis. First Three albums have no title, so fans named them from cover art; Car, Melt, Scratch. I think you have vinyl of PG. There is documentary of him in studio. Very creative guy. Robert Fripp and Steve Hunter provided guitars. Do more early stuff like “Games Without Frontiers” and “ Shock the Monkey” before the later Sledgehammer. Full album would be great too.
Love this song. I Have the Touch and Shock the Monkey are a couple other good singles by PG.
I understand why people watch the official video when listening to songs, but I really wish they wouldn't. For every song that is enhanced by its video, there are dozens that are marred. Music is an audio medium; the listening is the important part. If it needs the video, it isn't a good song. Listen to the song the way it came over the radio or played off the album when it was released. You can always go back and watch the video later.
Sledgehammer is also a lot of fun! "Big Time" is pretty good, too.
As far as I know, PG dreamed of growing cabbages on a farm after he left Genesis - starting a new life on the land.
Watch this concert! ruclips.net/video/azas-1zInJ8/видео.html
Secret World Tour 1994
If not the whole concert, there are songs on RUclips from this. Solsbury Hill of course. But I’d recommend In Your Eyes.
In his live concerts ,he would jump on a kids bike and drive around the stage ................ :)