These comments about the audience looking like their at a funeral I feel are really unfair. Maybe GG asked for an intimate performance.... maybe they were in shock, star struck, thought the sign outside was a prank or "shock-horror" they're just being respectful. Personally, i'm glad they were reserved because it gave us Lady GG's clear voice which deserves hearing for what it is, A-M-A-Z-I-N-G. Besides, you'd feel a dick wouldn't you being the only one screaming? It would be so selfish too; ruining the enjoyment of others ?? So I think everyone should lay off the audience!
Esclad.. Very respectful Audience who knew the story behind Joanne. They were honoring her with their silence so that we could understand each beautiful word that Lady Gaga sang. Thank you.
It wouldn't be strange if they did look at her like if they were at a funeral since her aunt Joanne died at a young age (according to her documentary 5ft2 at Netflix). I would think this song is very personal to her because of the family bond and also since one of her names is Joanne (according to Wikipedia). I'm not a die hard Gaga-fan, but I do enjoy her music a lot, and I think she showed one of her best sides in the documentary. Fragile yet strong, just as most people are. Because at the end of the day she is just another human being trying to survive this harsh world.
If the audience was acting any other way I'd be disturbed. This is a song about loss and grief. She is singing about her aunt who died at 19 of lupus. They should look like they are at a funeral.
Adrian 4698 - I love how this song has a Queen-like feel to it. Kind of like 'Save Me' or 'Dear Friends' & love that it's just her voice and accoustinc guitars.
I've never left a RUclips comment before so this is weird for me, please bear with me. My Grandmother passed away shortly before this song was released. I've always recognized Lady GaGa's talent but never truly liked her until this song. My Grandma's name was Joan, very similar to Joanne. When I heard this song for the first time I had flashing memories of my Grandma. I instinctively changed the lyrics to Joan. This is my comfort song and I think and ponder over the lyrics all the time. Thank you for it, Lady GaGa. You now have a fan for life from me.
I was in fatal car accident on12/16/1989 my mother Jo-ann died as a result. I named my 2nd daughter after her. Thank you LADY, FOR making me comes to terms with much buried grief
I was not a huge fan of Gaga at first, I thought she was just another regurgitated pop generational artist but I was wrong, she is incredibly talented, thoughtful and is a true artist. This album has a lot of soul and you do not see that in today's music. Love her!
I love watching her in these small venue, intimate setting gigs... Her voice is so crystal clear and, you can see she wears her real emotions right there on her sleeve... This woman is always the real deal...
Obviously not everyone here is aware that this song is about her aunt that passed several years. As you can see this song makes Lady Gaga very emotional so I wouldn’t expect them to be smiling and cheering in the background! You can tell this song is pulling on their heart strings.
Lady Gaga..i know this may no reach you,but thank you so much to be an inspiration for me to keep living. I want this song played on my funeral..that is all I ask should someday the day comes. Love you my mother monster.
I think of my late mother when I listen to this song. She absolutely loved the holidays! I share thanksgiving with my friends but I save Christmas for just me and her, and a bottle of wine :)
My best friend passed weeks before this album came out, losing her struggle to schizophrenia. This album and this song have helped me greave, spend time with her, and breathe. Lady Gaga is an angel in this earth.
She's on the edge of crying… This song gets me every time, it's the most emotional of the whole album, and it's so personal to her and her family that there's do doubt she put way more of herself in it than any other song she's written to this point…
Not sure if anyone else picked up on it, but I think the deeper and more personal reason why she dedicated the last chorus repeat was not just for those who get sad and lonely around the holidays. Her aunt Joanne, to whom the song is dedicated to, passed away the week before Christmas and is more than likely a sore time for her and her family.
Jerriell How I miss you my aunt! Life is so shocking at times. I know the essence of your spirit is around us. Thanks Gaga for always connecting with your fans in some of the most needed and important ways
love Lady Gaga and everything she brings to the world. Every song is so beautifully done. The way the song gives in on such a personal experience fans can relate with it so well because such emotion is being shown and i love every bit of it.
It looks like she swept them all up in emotion, not sure they could remember to breathe while trying to keep their eyes dry. I say, next album, just gaga and a guitar because she clearly doesn't need all the toys of a recording studio. #Awestruck
I heard this song for the first time two days after my dog died. Since then I can always feel the pain and this song makes me very emotional. I always thing about everyone I lost. My family members, my friends, my dog. It's the best song Gaga ever wrote.
This made me cry... i mean like, this is whats all about. Music and lyrics, they were written and performed by her but at the end, everyone has its own meaning for the song. Thank you for this gaga, there are people who are really inspired by your love and passion about telling your stories, your personal feelings and might not be a mucisian but this gives me the strengh to go on my own creativity and individuality.
I love and hate it that she made the chorus so catchy and melodic. I would always sing it as though it was nothing until I'm reminded of the lyrics... Joanne is her best album
![Lady Gaga - Million Reasons [Live on Alan Carr's Happy Hour, 9th Dec 2016 HD]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/wmCnepJSTY8/mqdefault.jpg)
These comments about the audience looking like their at a funeral I feel are really unfair. Maybe GG asked for an intimate performance.... maybe they were in shock, star struck, thought the sign outside was a prank or "shock-horror" they're just being respectful. Personally, i'm glad they were reserved because it gave us Lady GG's clear voice which deserves hearing for what it is, A-M-A-Z-I-N-G. Besides, you'd feel a dick wouldn't you being the only one screaming? It would be so selfish too; ruining the enjoyment of others ?? So I think everyone should lay off the audience!
Esclad.. Very respectful Audience who knew the story behind Joanne. They were honoring her with their silence so that we could understand each beautiful word that Lady Gaga sang. Thank you.
It wouldn't be strange if they did look at her like if they were at a funeral since her aunt Joanne died at a young age (according to her documentary 5ft2 at Netflix). I would think this song is very personal to her because of the family bond and also since one of her names is Joanne (according to Wikipedia). I'm not a die hard Gaga-fan, but I do enjoy her music a lot, and I think she showed one of her best sides in the documentary. Fragile yet strong, just as most people are. Because at the end of the day she is just another human being trying to survive this harsh world.
If the audience was acting any other way I'd be disturbed. This is a song about loss and grief. She is singing about her aunt who died at 19 of lupus. They should look like they are at a funeral.
This song had to be written for Gagas family to heal! What a touching tribute by Gaga! I love you Joanne!💞
The blond girl in the back can barely keep it together. That is me watching this every time
Joanne makes me emotional, actually this whole album did that to me
This song makes me want to cry.
Me too😭
same
John. Wayne.
sameee
I like that the guitarist is really feeling it
Christopher Scotts yes he is so near to cry. This performance shows us how emotional Gaga and her voice can be.
Yup. Not so much of a happy hour here. THE BEST HOUR!! He can probably relate to the lyrics that's why he's emotional. god bless both of them
ƙɑɼʍɑ ƙɼiȿ you can tell he most definitely relates to the song. The emotions on his face while she was singing those lyrics said it all. Beautiful 💘
Yesss he slayed Rihanna's last tour also
Haha, Dude is living it.
The level of talent this woman has is unmeasurable. She sounds better live then recorded.
yass
😭😍
One of the few artists that sounds EXACTLY alike live as they do on their album. She has amazing vocals.
She sounds better live, in my opinion ❤️
Adrian 4698 she eats CDs xD
Adrian 4698 - I love how this song has a Queen-like feel to it. Kind of like 'Save Me' or 'Dear Friends' & love that it's just her voice and accoustinc guitars.
That's because they recorder this song one time and didn't autotune it. Like yes queen!
Adrian 4698 and she sounds even better live
Gaga is truly a Legend
i think the same
No doubt
This is a rare example of a guitarisst who doesn't just come to get his job done :) And about Gaga, no words, speechless
I was just thinking about the same, this guy is inside the song.
can't get this chorus outta my head lol
Something Clever same !
Something Clever I apologize for being one year late but I just found Gaga after Star is Born and I am mesmerized
I have never imagined myself to be a fan of any human being... but with lady gaga I'm a proud fan and follower, I love her so much
Me too,,
sameeee
🙋
You all sound like Manson girls. Like you’re in a cult.
So are you a little monster?
I love how into it the guitarist gets.
I've never left a RUclips comment before so this is weird for me, please bear with me.
My Grandmother passed away shortly before this song was released. I've always recognized Lady GaGa's talent but never truly liked her until this song. My Grandma's name was Joan, very similar to Joanne. When I heard this song for the first time I had flashing memories of my Grandma. I instinctively changed the lyrics to Joan. This is my comfort song and I think and ponder over the lyrics all the time. Thank you for it, Lady GaGa. You now have a fan for life from me.
Whit B I remember the first time I heard this song about one month after my grandma has passed away and I balled my fucking eyes out.
A queeeeen
😭
That connection between the guitarist,lyrics and lady gaga. What a tearjerker performance.
i like how the guitarist is feeling it
Ikr❤️😊
I was in fatal car accident on12/16/1989 my mother Jo-ann died as a result. I named my 2nd daughter after her. Thank you LADY, FOR making me comes to terms with much buried grief
Krisy Lackey im so sorry for that darling Stay strong
Krisy Lackey sorry for your lost
❤️👼
She is more than a Singer. She can be so deep. It's was too emotional.
for anyone whose sad these holidays... .bursts into tears.
This comment saved lives
True artist!!! What a talent
I miss you Mom
pff, same... I lost mine last year... It is still not easy :(
Ernesto Aviles Arteaga Hope you are doing well
she is still here, she lives in your heart... i hope you stay strong and live on. God bless you
its no easy, but I'm here
I lost mine in July. It's really hard.💔 Sending love to all of you
For me this is her best song. The vocals, the lyrics , the instrumental …. It’s all working beautifully and cohesively.
Probably watched this about 30 times just today. Hands down, an untouchable performance.
my god these vocals get better with every performance!
Her BEST song to DATE!
most powerful one for sure! it gets me every time
Christian Steinborn me toooo! Every. Single. Time.
Jermaine Tindell "Joanne" and "Speechless" are tied for me. Both powerful songs that make me overly emotional.
Lady Gaga is not only a great ARTIST she's above all very human
The entire album made me emotional but this song takes the cake!!! Such a heart breaking song
'for anyone who is sad these holidays,this is for you" thanks gaga
I was not a huge fan of Gaga at first, I thought she was just another regurgitated pop generational artist but I was wrong, she is incredibly talented, thoughtful and is a true artist. This album has a lot of soul and you do not see that in today's music. Love her!
I'm surprised this gem hasn't reached 1million views yet. This video is absolutely belonged to Gaga's perfect and powerful live performances 🥺
Acording to me Joanne is the best song in this album, and album "Joanne" is her best album
This is incredible.
Parker DW It’s majestic. And that it’s just 1.1 guitars and one voice.
Omfg if I was there I would be freaking out seeing my queen
Lady GagaVEVO I would faint
i love my mom forever.
even now she′s gone
thx gaga,i also love u forever
duck 大可 ❤
I love watching her in these small venue, intimate setting gigs... Her voice is so crystal clear and, you can see she wears her real emotions right there on her sleeve... This woman is always the real deal...
Her best song…and the best live performance of this song too!
I love you My lady #Brazil
Brazil 😻🎉
PLEASE COME TO BRAZIL
Thanasis Pumpkin já vai vir no Rock in rio minha criança
Grammy winning song. ❤️❤️❤️
Obviously not everyone here is aware that this song is about her aunt that passed several years. As you can see this song makes Lady Gaga very emotional so I wouldn’t expect them to be smiling and cheering in the background! You can tell this song is pulling on their heart strings.
Lady Gaga..i know this may no reach you,but thank you so much to be an inspiration for me to keep living. I want this song played on my funeral..that is all I ask should someday the day comes. Love you my mother monster.
hey, you alright?
I love the new lady gaga. This song is beautiful and I appreciate how real she has become. Her voice! She's amazing!
THAT is one talented woman. Wow. A song about an aunt she never knew.
I think of my late mother when I listen to this song. She absolutely loved the holidays! I share thanksgiving with my friends but I save Christmas for just me and her, and a bottle of wine :)
A lot can make hits and top the charts. But only a selected few can touch hearts.
amen
How do any of these people not have tears streaming down … my god
This is for my Ava 💖🐞🥀 I love you forever my little princess. I'll see you again one day.
One of the most captivating and unique artists of all time
Gaga is so emotional you can just feel it
I miss you grandpa, can't wait to see you soar. Life isn't the same without you.
THIS IS MOST BEAUTIFUL ALBUM EVER!!! 😍💓💓💓💓💓💓
Always one of my favorites, but I can’t bear to listen right now. I lost my Mom three months ago. It rips my heart out.
sorry for your loss
My best friend passed weeks before this album came out, losing her struggle to schizophrenia. This album and this song have helped me greave, spend time with her, and breathe. Lady Gaga is an angel in this earth.
"XOXO Joanne" omg 😭😭😭 💓💓
My goodness this performance literally brings me to tears every single time I watch it. Its absolutely mind blowing how emotionally powerful this is.
Who's here because of being refreshed by her artistry in A Star Is Born
meee
I love you lady gaga and I'm your fan since 8 years ago
Fabiola Solano me 7years
"for anyone who's sad these holidays this one's for you"
Omg i LOVE her so much!!!!!
Beyond amazing. One of the greatest artists of our time. So glad she is showing us this side of her. Truly talented.
She's on the edge of crying… This song gets me every time, it's the most emotional of the whole album, and it's so personal to her and her family that there's do doubt she put way more of herself in it than any other song she's written to this point…
Beautiful homage * JOANNE* .
I'm a fan Lady Gaga. Applause.
The guitar part really touched my heart so deeply ;(
Love this track. I love Joanne the album fully. It is a musical masterpiece.
I wasn't a fan until this album. Fascinated now.
My eyes are just sweating, scroll down.
That bridge part was absolutely gorgeous.
This must be a single. Such an amazing song!
João Victor Mendes No ... this song will flopped ... music chart is weird now
Its a Single in Italy.
I got all the feelings watching this because we can see he's feeling the song as well its so beautiful.
this girl is unbelievable. loved her new album. so emotional
She’s a throwback to something I thought was long gone
Such an amazing voice !
Einfach unbeschreiblich wie gesegnet mit Talent sie ist!
Stimme dir absolut zu
Not sure if anyone else picked up on it, but I think the deeper and more personal reason why she dedicated the last chorus repeat was not just for those who get sad and lonely around the holidays. Her aunt Joanne, to whom the song is dedicated to, passed away the week before Christmas and is more than likely a sore time for her and her family.
Jerriell How I miss you my aunt! Life is so shocking at times. I know the essence of your spirit is around us.
Thanks Gaga for always connecting with your fans in some of the most needed and important ways
LADY GAGA IS A QUEEN OF POP! I'M A LITTLE MONSTER I LOVE YOU GAGA!
She just keeps pumping them out ! ... great song , best voice in the business right now .
My FAVORITE Performance by GAGA....PERIOD.
love Lady Gaga and everything she brings to the world. Every song is so beautifully done. The way the song gives in on such a personal experience fans can relate with it so well because such emotion is being shown and i love every bit of it.
I think this is my favorite performance of this era so far
Lady Gaga just made me cry
That guitarist got really emotional
Thank you so much Joanne
It looks like she swept them all up in emotion, not sure they could remember to breathe while trying to keep their eyes dry. I say, next album, just gaga and a guitar because she clearly doesn't need all the toys of a recording studio. #Awestruck
its our first Thanksgiving without our mother. This song makes me think of her and reminds me of how much we love and miss her.
Truly Amazing!
who else fell in love with this song ?
I am really sad this week Joanne. Thank you for your beautiful music and beautiful voice
she looks perfect Goooodddeessss, I Love u
Beautiful and amazing vocals from Lady Gaga. Thank you for a great acoustical performance!
in tears , beautiful tribute song. I know your aunt is watching over you proud as can be. Keep rocking Gaga
Chill bumps is an understatement that song is a work of pure art and heart. She truly is an Icon. Xoxo
John Legend and Lady Gaga in the same video, 2016 couldn't have ended better
No words...she blows my mind.
What a legendary vocalist ❤❤
I heard this song for the first time two days after my dog died. Since then I can always feel the pain and this song makes me very emotional. I always thing about everyone I lost. My family members, my friends, my dog. It's the best song Gaga ever wrote.
this woman is just amazing wow best song after best song wow
as soon as she said "For anybody who's sad on these holidays... this is for you." I fucking LOST it and started bawling
This made me cry... i mean like, this is whats all about. Music and lyrics, they were written and performed by her but at the end, everyone has its own meaning for the song. Thank you for this gaga, there are people who are really inspired by your love and passion about telling your stories, your personal feelings and might not be a mucisian but this gives me the strengh to go on my own creativity and individuality.
Makes me cry every time. She’s so amazing. Her voice and how real she is when she performs 💜💜💜 my idol xo
I love Joanne I think of my mother evertime I hear this song. Amazing voice Lady Gaga's talent goes beyond words!
I love and hate it that she made the chorus so catchy and melodic. I would always sing it as though it was nothing until I'm reminded of the lyrics... Joanne is her best album
omg i love you gaga , your voice is amazing ! this song make me cry , I lost my mom soon 6 years and this song remember her, she miss me !
OMG she gives me the chills everytime. Flawless! That made me cry
It's phenomenal how good her voice has got this tour, it was always good, it's jut bumped up another level 😲
Such a powerful and emotional performance..