Allah says the Qur'an is the best and most truthful Hadith. Allah has covered every aspect of every argument. Who will want another Hadtih after The Quran?????!!!!!
Alhamdulillah. The implication is, that all those so called scholars had not understood the ayat on "ahsanil hadees", or were not even aware of these ayat. And worse, that also Rasulullah and his close companions were not aware that The Almighty called His Quran, Ahsanal Hadees.
@@erwinsadhoe563 that’s an assumption you’re making with no evidence for the claim. You make that assumption based on the bias that the Hadith is true and is approved by Allah which it’s not, rather you are the one attributing lies to the prophet that are not authorized by Allah.
@@prodbysuli5080 seems like my comment is not understood as I intended. I am not assuming that hadith is true and is approved by Allah. At least, I cannot see why you say that from my comment.
@@erwinsadhoe563 oh man I apologize my brother I reread your comment and see the error I made. It was late at night and I finished responding to others I misread and misspoke.
True story i knew what hé meant but didn't correct IT. That's how the enormis of God and his Messenger call us but that's not how our creator described those whom fear to qscrined partners nor follow what religieus scholars have written claiming this is all from god so follow IT
@@ibrahimfazeel3951 yes i agree but we should say the truth and acknowledge that sects of islam follow books that contradict the Qur'an and we should call it out. Qur'an says dont kill apostates. Hadith says kill apostates Qur'an says dont kill adulterers. Hadith says kill adulterers. Qur'an says leave a will for family when you die. Hadith says dont leave a will. Qur'an says Christians, jews and sabians can all go to heaven. Hadith says only muslims go to heaven. Qur'an tells us not to divide into sects. Hadith says there will be 73 sects and only one goes to heaven. Qur'an says they thought the prophet was bewitched but he was not. Hadith says he actually was bewitched. Qur'an says there is medicine in honey. Hadith says there is medicine in camel urine. Qur'an says no one knows the hour but Allah. Hadith says the hour will be on a Friday. Qur'an says you cant speak to the dead. Hadith says you can speak to the dead. Qur'an says to pray 3 times. Hadith says to pray 5 times with over complicated rituals. Qur'an says you cant marry a 6 year old. Hadith says the prophet married 6 year aisha Summary of contradictions obviously not word for word from scripture. Hadith talk of adult breastfeeding and claims the prophet had his chest literally cut open and his heart removed as a child
Furthermore if you study the Shia, Ibadi and Adl Tawhid e Adha ("Mutazilites") you'll see a similar spectrum of positions that modern "Quranists" tend to take, in different ways. Shia reject or at least highly skeptical of Abu Hurairah as a narrator, so that's a majority of major Sunni hadith under skepticism, Ibadi don't reject hadith but are careful not to assume any are true saying "it is narrated" for all to make sure you're not lying, intentionally or unintentionally, Prima Quran has some good answers for hardline Quranists about accepting *some* additional guidance outside Quran from within Quran, he's a revert who found Ibadi. Mutazilites have all kinds of wild speculative takes, much like the diversity of wild tasfir you'll find amoung hardline Quran Only Quranists today, but accepted basic hadith stuff like praying tashahudd, however they didn't buy the grave punishment, the miraj hadith, and a few other keystone theological hadiths. It's very interesting to study all the sects (which really compose at least 3 other madhabs) and continue this kind of spectrum analysis.
Alhamdulillah , i hope we as a alquran follower united as 1.... the internet already expose the sunnist hambali salafi and other corruption toward alquran... pls human be a allah creature not bow to human...
A.aleykum bless you so much my brother can you tell me more avout prayers how do i pray and gow many. Please if you could explain to me i would appreciate very much. Shukran. Be bless and stay bless always.
السلام عليكم رحمة الله و بركاته We are Islam from indonesia. Fyi, our ancestors had converted to Islam since before europe invasion to the world. And as we know. 90% of islam is TAQLID (تقليد ) . Including in indonesia. We actually want to know more about this community. But, we are not fluent in hearing in english. Perhaps the creator wants to provide the real subtitle. Not automated generated. عفوًا و شكرًا كثيرًا
The Time is Near Allaah ❤❤❤The Almighty Will INTERVENE. Woe to the mouchrekeen. They follow pagan ahadith books claiming it's from Allaah ❤❤❤The Almighty.
it helps when you visualize what's being said and when you give sources. speaking of sources can you actually provide any? you claim certain books were written on certain dates or are commented on starting at certain dates etc. why do you refuse to give sources? are you trying to hide something? please provide your evidences if you are truthfull. if you want people to believe your claims this is the bare minimum.
Peace - The link to all the sources is in the video notes. Here it is as well qurantalkblog.com/2023/10/12/evolution-of-hadith-reliance-in-sunni-islam/
appreciate it. the observations are solid. many sources are there but some are still missing. for example where does it say Imam Malik was against spreading his work across the land for that reason? I also have no way of knowing whether or not the statements by Nomani (deobandi?) about the books of imam abu hanifa are true or not. are there other sources stating similar? specifically about the first two books (musnad & fiqh alakbar). are you not arguing for a less certain way of understanding the quran? removing the hadith leads to that imo. I'm not saying this is better or worse. I'm just asking for your perspective how that is supposed to be better. sure you are closer to the classical scholar's method (assuming you are correct) but how does it make your understanding more correct when you don't have anything to check it with? todays sunnis at least have something to check their interpretation with. you seem to have nothing. maybe you have something else besides the hadith?
Superiority of the believers in the Oneness of Allah and the punishment of the Jews and Christians 8) Narrated Abu Musa: Allah’s Messenger said: On the Day of Resurrection, my Ummah (nation) will be gathered into three groups. One sort will enter Paradise without rendering an account (of their deeds). Another sort will be reckoned an easy account and admitted into Paradise. Yet another sort will come bearing on their backs heaps of sins like great mountains. Allah will ask the angels though He knows best about them: Who are these people? They will reply: They are humble slaves of yours. He will say: UNLOAD the sins from them AND PUT THE SAME OVER the Jews and Christians: then let the humble slaves get into Paradise by virtue of My Mercy. (This Hadith IS SOUND and mentioned in Mustadrak of Hakim). (110 Hadith Qudsi (Sacred Hadith), translated by Syed Masood-ul-Hasan, revision and commentaries by Ibrahim m. Kunna [Darussalam Publishers and Distributors], pp. 19-20;
Mustadrak of Hakim is full of false hadith written 500 years later. why are you giving reference from that? it was written by a ostensible sunni scholar in iran(shia majority)
This-Video literally proves that the Maker of This-Video literally doesn't even care how pathologically ignorant they really are. Apathy is worse than Ignorance.
@@DistortedEmpath As per the Qur’ānist (those whom claim to only adhere to The Qur’ān), referring to the Hadīth/Narration by Abī-Sa`īd al-Khudhrī (May Allah be pleased with him), concerning the Command of Muhammad (Peace be upon him) to document/record only The Qur’ān & not the Sunnah/Prophetic-Tradition (al-Bukhārī)…there’s 5-Things one must/should introspect upon. They are the following: a. How do they even know whether or not this is: Authentic, Reliable, Weak, Fabricated, etc.?!!! b. The Fact that this Narration has been authenticated (as being Sahīh/Authentic) thus proves that the Religio-Postures of Muhammad (Peace be upon him) are just as much at-Tanzīl/Revelation as The Qur’ān itself. c. The Fact that they’re literally relying upon a Hadīth/Record of the Sunnah/Prophetic-Tradition, to attempt to disprove the Validity of the Hadīth/Kitābah (Documentation) of the Sunnah, thus proves that the Sunnah is Mahlūl/Mafrūdh (Islāmically-Allowed/Mandated) to be recorded. d. Had this Hadīth not/never been recorded, realistically we would’ve never even known that Muhammad had even stated this. e. How do you know whether or not this Hadīth/Documentation of the Sunnah wasn’t made Mansūkh (Abrogated/Canceled) via Other-Nuzūl (Revelatory-Texts)?!!! garethbryant.wordpress.com/2019/11/13/quranism/
Salam brother , I couldnt message you through twitter so I thought Ill ask my question on your latest video: I’m struggling with 2 pro hadith arguments I came across today in a video. Basically: 2:143 talks about the first qiblah the prophet and the believers used to pray to, but nowhere in the quran is it mentioned where or what direction that qibla was, so my question is (the point of hadith followers) how did the prophet know? My second question: 3:124 tells us Remember, O Prophet,˺ when you said to the believers, “Is it not enough that your Lord will send down a reinforcement of three thousand angels for your aid?” When did Allah tell prophet Muhammad this? Im starting to think there WAS revelation outside of the quran, do you also believe this and if so, hoe is this not a problem for us ‘quran-muslims’ I can link the yt video of the debate with a time stamp too if u want Thanks in advance
Peace - this is a typical fallacious argument made by traditionalists in support of Hadith. They want to say because the prophet received revelations (wahi) outside the Quran, therefore we have to uphold Hadith which were collected hundred of years after the prophet's death. The problem with this is logic is the following: (1) there is no way of authenticating any Hadith attributed to the prophet besides the Quran, (2) the Quran tells us that our only source of law (Furqan) is the Quran (6:112-116) (3) the Quran tells us that it is complete, fully detailed, and has all the explanations we need (16:89, 17:89, 30:58). Therefore, any revelation (wahi) that the prophet received that is not in the Quran was only applicable to its time and place. Whatever is pertinent to our salvation is inside the Quran.
I’m still wondering the answers to these questions Maybe they prayed the same direction as those before them ,the Jews . And the other one I just can’t figure out
Allah says the Qur'an is the best and most truthful Hadith. Allah has covered every aspect of every argument. Who will want another Hadtih after The Quran?????!!!!!
Indeed!
Alhamdulillah. The implication is, that all those so called scholars had not understood the ayat on "ahsanil hadees", or were not even aware of these ayat. And worse, that also Rasulullah and his close companions were not aware that The Almighty called His Quran, Ahsanal Hadees.
@@erwinsadhoe563 that’s an assumption you’re making with no evidence for the claim. You make that assumption based on the bias that the Hadith is true and is approved by Allah which it’s not, rather you are the one attributing lies to the prophet that are not authorized by Allah.
@@prodbysuli5080 seems like my comment is not understood as I intended. I am not assuming that hadith is true and is approved by Allah. At least, I cannot see why you say that from my comment.
@@erwinsadhoe563 oh man I apologize my brother I reread your comment and see the error I made. It was late at night and I finished responding to others I misread and misspoke.
Thankyou so much i havent found fellow "quranists" yet. You dont know how much it means to watch your videos thankyou
We are everywhere but are as loud as the polytheists
I don’t think quranist. Just a Muslim ☝🏽
True story i knew what hé meant but didn't correct IT. That's how the enormis of God and his Messenger call us but that's not how our creator described those whom fear to qscrined partners nor follow what religieus scholars have written claiming this is all from god so follow IT
No need to make a division. Be pure god knows the intentions
@@ibrahimfazeel3951 yes i agree but we should say the truth and acknowledge that sects of islam follow books that contradict the Qur'an and we should call it out.
Qur'an says dont kill apostates. Hadith says kill apostates
Qur'an says dont kill adulterers. Hadith says kill adulterers.
Qur'an says leave a will for family when you die. Hadith says dont leave a will.
Qur'an says Christians, jews and sabians can all go to heaven. Hadith says only muslims go to heaven.
Qur'an tells us not to divide into sects. Hadith says there will be 73 sects and only one goes to heaven.
Qur'an says they thought the prophet was bewitched but he was not. Hadith says he actually was bewitched.
Qur'an says there is medicine in honey. Hadith says there is medicine in camel urine.
Qur'an says no one knows the hour but Allah. Hadith says the hour will be on a Friday.
Qur'an says you cant speak to the dead. Hadith says you can speak to the dead.
Qur'an says to pray 3 times. Hadith says to pray 5 times with over complicated rituals.
Qur'an says you cant marry a 6 year old. Hadith says the prophet married 6 year aisha
Summary of contradictions obviously not word for word from scripture. Hadith talk of adult breastfeeding and claims the prophet had his chest literally cut open and his heart removed as a child
Excellent video. Thanks for making this content. God bless!
Furthermore if you study the Shia, Ibadi and Adl Tawhid e Adha ("Mutazilites") you'll see a similar spectrum of positions that modern "Quranists" tend to take, in different ways. Shia reject or at least highly skeptical of Abu Hurairah as a narrator, so that's a majority of major Sunni hadith under skepticism, Ibadi don't reject hadith but are careful not to assume any are true saying "it is narrated" for all to make sure you're not lying, intentionally or unintentionally, Prima Quran has some good answers for hardline Quranists about accepting *some* additional guidance outside Quran from within Quran, he's a revert who found Ibadi. Mutazilites have all kinds of wild speculative takes, much like the diversity of wild tasfir you'll find amoung hardline Quran Only Quranists today, but accepted basic hadith stuff like praying tashahudd, however they didn't buy the grave punishment, the miraj hadith, and a few other keystone theological hadiths. It's very interesting to study all the sects (which really compose at least 3 other madhabs) and continue this kind of spectrum analysis.
I love Quran talk
Well covered
Thank you brother for the information. Ajrak end Allan ya akhi
praise God
Alhamdulillah , i hope we as a alquran follower united as 1.... the internet already expose the sunnist hambali salafi and other corruption toward alquran... pls human be a allah creature not bow to human...
A.aleykum bless you so much my brother can you tell me more avout prayers how do i pray and gow many. Please if you could explain to me i would appreciate very much. Shukran. Be bless and stay bless always.
السلام عليكم رحمة الله و بركاته
We are Islam from indonesia.
Fyi, our ancestors had converted to Islam since before europe invasion to the world.
And as we know. 90% of islam is TAQLID (تقليد ) . Including in indonesia.
We actually want to know more about this community. But, we are not fluent in hearing in english.
Perhaps the creator wants to provide the real subtitle. Not automated generated.
عفوًا و شكرًا كثيرًا
Brilliant anaylsis
❤
What about ibn Tammiya
Islam will great again
goat
Peganism
bro what @@unknown6715
The Time is Near
Allaah ❤❤❤The Almighty Will INTERVENE.
Woe to the mouchrekeen.
They follow pagan ahadith books claiming it's from
Allaah ❤❤❤The Almighty.
it helps when you visualize what's being said and when you give sources. speaking of sources can you actually provide any? you claim certain books were written on certain dates or are commented on starting at certain dates etc. why do you refuse to give sources? are you trying to hide something? please provide your evidences if you are truthfull. if you want people to believe your claims this is the bare minimum.
Peace - The link to all the sources is in the video notes. Here it is as well
qurantalkblog.com/2023/10/12/evolution-of-hadith-reliance-in-sunni-islam/
appreciate it. the observations are solid. many sources are there but some are still missing. for example where does it say Imam Malik was against spreading his work across the land for that reason? I also have no way of knowing whether or not the statements by Nomani (deobandi?) about the books of imam abu hanifa are true or not. are there other sources stating similar? specifically about the first two books (musnad & fiqh alakbar).
are you not arguing for a less certain way of understanding the quran? removing the hadith leads to that imo. I'm not saying this is better or worse. I'm just asking for your perspective how that is supposed to be better. sure you are closer to the classical scholar's method (assuming you are correct) but how does it make your understanding more correct when you don't have anything to check it with? todays sunnis at least have something to check their interpretation with. you seem to have nothing. maybe you have something else besides the hadith?
@@trappedinexistence
Allah has taken the responsibility to explain it (75:19)
Isnt that enough for you?
@@akab.3586 Where did I say it isn't?
❤️ P r o m o S M
Superiority of the believers in the Oneness of Allah and the punishment of the Jews and Christians
8) Narrated Abu Musa: Allah’s Messenger said: On the Day of Resurrection, my Ummah (nation) will be gathered into three groups. One sort will enter Paradise without rendering an account (of their deeds). Another sort will be reckoned an easy account and admitted into Paradise. Yet another sort will come bearing on their backs heaps of sins like great mountains. Allah will ask the angels though He knows best about them: Who are these people? They will reply: They are humble slaves of yours. He will say: UNLOAD the sins from them AND PUT THE SAME OVER the Jews and Christians: then let the humble slaves get into Paradise by virtue of My Mercy.
(This Hadith IS SOUND and mentioned in Mustadrak of Hakim). (110 Hadith Qudsi (Sacred Hadith), translated by Syed Masood-ul-Hasan, revision and commentaries by Ibrahim m. Kunna [Darussalam Publishers and Distributors], pp. 19-20;
That’s not true! Allah actually loves all human beings. You cannot judge he will decide who goes to heaven and hell!
Mustadrak of Hakim is full of false hadith written 500 years later. why are you giving reference from that? it was written by a ostensible sunni scholar in iran(shia majority)
This-Video literally proves that the Maker of This-Video literally doesn't even care how pathologically ignorant they really are. Apathy is worse than Ignorance.
He's just giving opinion of scholars of old and his own
@@DistortedEmpath
Apathy is worse than Ignorance.
@GarethBryant15 you calling scholars apathetic he's quoting people not once he have his own opnion
@@DistortedEmpath
As per the Qur’ānist (those whom claim to only adhere to The Qur’ān), referring to the Hadīth/Narration by Abī-Sa`īd al-Khudhrī (May Allah be pleased with him), concerning the Command of Muhammad (Peace be upon him) to document/record only The Qur’ān & not the Sunnah/Prophetic-Tradition (al-Bukhārī)…there’s 5-Things one must/should introspect upon.
They are the following:
a. How do they even know whether or not this is: Authentic, Reliable, Weak, Fabricated, etc.?!!!
b. The Fact that this Narration has been authenticated (as being Sahīh/Authentic) thus proves that the Religio-Postures of Muhammad (Peace be upon him) are just as much at-Tanzīl/Revelation as The Qur’ān itself.
c. The Fact that they’re literally relying upon a Hadīth/Record of the Sunnah/Prophetic-Tradition, to attempt to disprove the Validity of the Hadīth/Kitābah (Documentation) of the Sunnah, thus proves that the Sunnah is Mahlūl/Mafrūdh (Islāmically-Allowed/Mandated) to be recorded.
d. Had this Hadīth not/never been recorded, realistically we would’ve never even known that Muhammad had even stated this.
e. How do you know whether or not this Hadīth/Documentation of the Sunnah wasn’t made Mansūkh (Abrogated/Canceled) via Other-Nuzūl (Revelatory-Texts)?!!!
garethbryant.wordpress.com/2019/11/13/quranism/
Salam brother , I couldnt message you through twitter so I thought Ill ask my question on your latest video:
I’m struggling with 2 pro hadith arguments I came across today in a video. Basically: 2:143 talks about the first qiblah the prophet and the believers used to pray to, but nowhere in the quran is it mentioned where or what direction that qibla was, so my question is (the point of hadith followers) how did the prophet know?
My second question: 3:124 tells us Remember, O Prophet,˺ when you said to the believers, “Is it not enough that your Lord will send down a reinforcement of three thousand angels for your aid?” When did Allah tell prophet Muhammad this?
Im starting to think there WAS revelation outside of the quran, do you also believe this and if so, hoe is this not a problem for us ‘quran-muslims’
I can link the yt video of the debate with a time stamp too if u want
Thanks in advance
Peace - this is a typical fallacious argument made by traditionalists in support of Hadith. They want to say because the prophet received revelations (wahi) outside the Quran, therefore we have to uphold Hadith which were collected hundred of years after the prophet's death. The problem with this is logic is the following:
(1) there is no way of authenticating any Hadith attributed to the prophet besides the Quran,
(2) the Quran tells us that our only source of law (Furqan) is the Quran (6:112-116)
(3) the Quran tells us that it is complete, fully detailed, and has all the explanations we need (16:89, 17:89, 30:58).
Therefore, any revelation (wahi) that the prophet received that is not in the Quran was only applicable to its time and place. Whatever is pertinent to our salvation is inside the Quran.
@@QuranTalk thanks brother, good answer.
@@QuranTalk
👍🏻
I’m still wondering the answers to these questions
Maybe they prayed the same direction as those before them ,the Jews .
And the other one I just can’t figure out
❤