Great reaction. I agree with everything you said. When you say “worst performance” just consider that this only their second performance as a group (well, third if you count their audition for the show which we’ll never see) since they only got together right before the audition. While I don’t always like their artistic choices their risky arrangements are amazing for a group that’s only been together a few months.
Yeah, you can definitely hear that they were still refining their sound..., but this was their second time singing together..., second time. Peace, Love and Light Dee!!!
THANK YOU!!!!! So many Pentatonix reactors act like this performance is on par with the rest of them and it's not!!! It's not terrible, but it's not great either and I love you for admitting it!!!
Here's the thing, it took about 3 songs to really get their groove right. Song #4 and everything after that is pure Pentatonix gold!!! But the first 3 performances, while they don't suck, are warmups!!
Love your honest reaction! Keep in mind, this was only the second time they had performed as PTX in public, and they were still getting their sound and timing down. One thing - at the end of this video there was a small clip where they talked about the judges comments, and it's really interesting. Some of the people who made videos of the shows didn't include the ending clips. I have heard that "MrDuckbear11" videos always included them. The clip after their Dog Days performance (#12) is especially sweet, so I hope you react to the end clips, too.
They went from that performance to "freaking out" and taking more risks; Thereby showing how much versatility the group really has. Here is where they really began to be the leading contender to win it all. Next up for week 3 of the Sing Off is 60's era.
Sara Bareilles actually released a new album on April 6, 2019 which debuted at number six on the Billboard 200. She's always on point 😉😄 About the performance, I totally agree with you (and the judges, of course), not their best...no no.
Lightning click! I've been waiting 2 weeks for this! No shade--just so happy that you're reacting to the Sing-Off. I think it's generally agreed that this was their weakest performance in the competition. It's the only one that got any serious negative critiques from the judges (and we didn't get to see everything they said). Dee, if you would be a little bit patient and let the video play out to the end, lots of the clips (including this one) include a brief post-performance reaction from PTX. You really should get into the habit of checking it (you can always edit it out later, when there isn't anything from them at the end). Believe me, there's at least one that you're not going to want to miss!
“Get in Line!” 😆😆😆😆yup re Scott 13 episodes & then the finally (where they announce the winners), then rounding out the season there was a last episode where they perform Christmas songs. Please hold out for the entire Journey. It’s sooo worth it! (Final group Hug😅)
What can I say that hasn't been said. This performance was rough, but as the show (And their career) continues, they kept getting better and better. Only their 2nd performance and you said "average'. Not the high bar we are used to from them, but so early on to be where they were and do that live, was a sight to see. I remember watching them each week and it kept getting better and better. Wait until "let's get it on"! WOW!!!
Jordan missed 3000 shots in his career...nobody hits a swish every time. Trust your doers, they get so good (all live performances) also watch the other competitors give them standing ovations. Much love and keep on keepin on J.
On this show, five was the minimum size required, and there were three groups (out of 16) of that size. The largest group had 16 guys! Average size overall was around 8 or so. IMO, this was the weakest of their Sing-Off performances. They sound very thin, missing the fullness of their usual sound. I do like the scratch-stop, but that’s it. An online reviewer of the show during the broadcast who was very experienced in competitive acapella said he had never seen that scratch-stop done in acapella, ever.
Four groups of five--Pentatonix, Sonos, North Shore, and Cat's Pajamas. Cat's Pajamas was the first group eliminated (in week one; Pentatonix didn't debut until the second week). Sonos went home after their third performance, and North Shore was eliminated after their fourth performance.
Because of this performance they almost got eliminated. It was the only time that this happened. The final song, last episode, where they already won was not great also.The other song are all good to awesome in my opinion.
Hi! Please react to Loïc Nottet's (pronounced as Loeek nottè beacause it's french) MudBlood. He also dances in this music video! It is REALLY REALLY WORTH IT! Trust me, I promise 😉🙈 He is one of our best singers here in Belgium! Thank you, greetings from Belgium! 🇧🇪
Definitely not the best of their sing off stuff. I had kind of forgotten this existed, actually! haha. The thing with them at this point was that they'd barely sung together before the show, so that definitely does show sometimes during the run of the show!
It's not my favorite performance of theirs either. But they keep getting better, so stay the course and I look forward to seeing you react to the rest of their performances.
We...well, most of us Pentaholics actually agree with you. This and their very last Sing Off performance weren't as good. But just you wait, they hit their groove on the 4th performance! Can't wait to watch your reactions!
Hey girl. I know you love PTX! Do youself a favor and react to Superfruit - Worth It! Just Mitch and Scott. Such a good song and cute video. Hope to see it. Love you!
I really wish that you would have reacted to these performances way back when you first discovered them (and I discovered your channel). You're too used to seeing them crush it in their videos, to then go back and see them still trying to find themselves as group may skew your opinion of the performances. That being said I agree with your opinion on this one. This is the worst performance of the season, they took too big of risk on this one and it fell flat. They still take some risks, but they find that 'sweet spot' where they don't lose the feeling of the original song and still make it their own. You will begin to see the real PTX take charge and blow everyone away. Love the reaction as always Dee.
You might double your subs. It's gonna sound strange but react to "petra reacts" to "Darkness keeps chasing me". I've found someone else who feels music like me, Thank You!
In my opinion, there's nothing wrong with the PERFORMANCE. The problem for the judges was the arrangement. Their execution was fine; they just changed the nature of the song too much for the judges' taste. (Mind you, they change the Janis Joplin one just as drastically, but the judges liked that one.)
it's primarily the choice of song and looking at their performance through the prism of their latest arangements , which are made with 8 years more experience and development. at the time of sing off Scott, Mitch and Kirstie were only 19. following sing off performances were much better (except final episode performances that, in my opinion, were not as good as some performances between this one and final)
Yeah there were parts of the arrangement on this song I didn't get into, so I agree this was the worst one they did. But that just means the shows get better & better as the 2 new members & 3 original members actually get more in synch & discover all the possibilities.
I think this actually is their worst performance. Which, however, still doesn't mean it's bad exactly, because they are ridiculous :D. I mean there are a few of their arrangements that I don't like, this being one of them, but that still doesn't take away the fact that even in their worst times, they don't go bellow a certain standard and aren't we all a little spoiled by that, tbh? :D I know I am. As far as their competition performances go (I don't count the ones they did outside of competing on the Sing Off - those I don't really care for either, though they're still ok :D), I think this is their weakest. I actually haven't heard it in a while, because I tend to skip it when I rewatch their Sing-Off journey.
I can't disagree with you on this one....does it help to say they all just go up from here? Love them - just not this song! But you never learn if you never fall on your bum, so this was theirs ;-)
In the whole sing off - this was the weakest performance. The others are so much better - the second weakest is "Stuck Like Glue," but it's still stronger than this performance. My favorites are Dog Days Are Over and Born to Be Wild.
"Kirstie looks so young." Are you implying she looks old now? Old and fat?? That's the meanest thing anyone has ever said about anyone in the history people saying mean things!
wjlintz oh stop. stop trying to start drama where there isn’t none to begin with. It’s true they all look soo young because this was 8 years ago! but that doesn’t mean shes shading them for any reason.
If you know Dee you would think twice to make such a comment....ofcourse she doesnt mean Kirstie looks old now..and fat??? Who said anything about fat?? ONLY YOU. She ok only meant that they all looked like babies back then and they've grown so much..vocally but also as a person..So stop creating drama where there isnt any.
Can hardly wait for you to see them do Dog Days are Over!
Great reaction. I agree with everything you said. When you say “worst performance” just consider that this only their second performance as a group (well, third if you count their audition for the show which we’ll never see) since they only got together right before the audition. While I don’t always like their artistic choices their risky arrangements are amazing for a group that’s only been together a few months.
Just wait till”Let’s Get It On”. 😁😁😁
Carburner67 mmmeee too!! Scott 🤤🤤🤤
Yeah, you can definitely hear that they were still refining their sound..., but this was their second time singing together..., second time. Peace, Love and Light Dee!!!
THANK YOU!!!!! So many Pentatonix reactors act like this performance is on par with the rest of them and it's not!!! It's not terrible, but it's not great either and I love you for admitting it!!!
Here's the thing, it took about 3 songs to really get their groove right. Song #4 and everything after that is pure Pentatonix gold!!! But the first 3 performances, while they don't suck, are warmups!!
Keep going! It gets so much better! 💖
Love your honest reaction! Keep in mind, this was only the second time they had performed as PTX in public, and they were still getting their sound and timing down. One thing - at the end of this video there was a small clip where they talked about the judges comments, and it's really interesting. Some of the people who made videos of the shows didn't include the ending clips. I have heard that "MrDuckbear11" videos always included them. The clip after their Dog Days performance (#12) is especially sweet, so I hope you react to the end clips, too.
They went from that performance to "freaking out" and taking more risks; Thereby showing how much versatility the group really has. Here is where they really began to be the leading contender to win it all. Next up for week 3 of the Sing Off is 60's era.
i agree, this one wasn't the best, but their rendition of the song did compliment Kevin and Avi's abilities
Sara Bareilles actually released a new album on April 6, 2019 which debuted at number six on the Billboard 200. She's always on point 😉😄 About the performance, I totally agree with you (and the judges, of course), not their best...no no.
Lightning click! I've been waiting 2 weeks for this! No shade--just so happy that you're reacting to the Sing-Off. I think it's generally agreed that this was their weakest performance in the competition. It's the only one that got any serious negative critiques from the judges (and we didn't get to see everything they said). Dee, if you would be a little bit patient and let the video play out to the end, lots of the clips (including this one) include a brief post-performance reaction from PTX. You really should get into the habit of checking it (you can always edit it out later, when there isn't anything from them at the end). Believe me, there's at least one that you're not going to want to miss!
Soooo..... where's the popcorn and beer!?! LoL It only goes up from here! :)
“Get in Line!” 😆😆😆😆yup re Scott
13 episodes & then the finally (where they announce the winners), then rounding out the season there was a last episode where they perform Christmas songs. Please hold out for the entire Journey. It’s sooo worth it! (Final group Hug😅)
accapella groups have about 10 to 15 and more that's why she said that just 5 members
What can I say that hasn't been said. This performance was rough, but as the show (And their career) continues, they kept getting better and better. Only their 2nd performance and you said "average'. Not the high bar we are used to from them, but so early on to be where they were and do that live, was a sight to see. I remember watching them each week and it kept getting better and better. Wait until "let's get it on"! WOW!!!
“Ke$ha remember KE$HA?!” Lmao same
Just wait for kirstin to kill it with Britney spears Medley. And Since you been gone
Facts .... It only gets better from here!
Pentaholic nation agrees with you, so don’t worry about that. It goes uphill in a hurry though. Keep going
Wait they get so much better. And can't wait to see what ya think.
thank you for taking us on this yourney with you, love your reactions!
Jordan missed 3000 shots in his career...nobody hits a swish every time. Trust your doers, they get so good (all live performances) also watch the other competitors give them standing ovations. Much love and keep on keepin on J.
Dee! Where've you been? I miss you! I'm sure you're out there living your best self, but... come back to us!
On this show, five was the minimum size required, and there were three groups (out of 16) of that size. The largest group had 16 guys! Average size overall was around 8 or so.
IMO, this was the weakest of their Sing-Off performances. They sound very thin, missing the fullness of their usual sound. I do like the scratch-stop, but that’s it. An online reviewer of the show during the broadcast who was very experienced in competitive acapella said he had never seen that scratch-stop done in acapella, ever.
Four groups of five--Pentatonix, Sonos, North Shore, and Cat's Pajamas. Cat's Pajamas was the first group eliminated (in week one; Pentatonix didn't debut until the second week). Sonos went home after their third performance, and North Shore was eliminated after their fourth performance.
I agree Dee
Just you wait. This isn't their worst. That is still to come. But some of their best are coming too. Thanks for being honest.
Dee , I love your reaction vids. Can you react to chris Stapleton. I think you'll love him.
Because of this performance they almost got eliminated. It was the only time that this happened. The final song, last episode, where they already won was not great also.The other song are all good to awesome in my opinion.
i GAVE IT A 7, in the beginning started out as slow but then it got better!
Kesha put out some new music a couple years ago
It's ne me quitte pas in french
When you're done with the Sing Off reactions you should react to Superfruit react to their Sing Off performances.
Hi! Please react to Loïc Nottet's (pronounced as Loeek nottè beacause it's french) MudBlood. He also dances in this music video! It is REALLY REALLY WORTH IT! Trust me, I promise 😉🙈 He is one of our best singers here in Belgium! Thank you, greetings from Belgium! 🇧🇪
Definitely not the best of their sing off stuff. I had kind of forgotten this existed, actually! haha. The thing with them at this point was that they'd barely sung together before the show, so that definitely does show sometimes during the run of the show!
All the others are better, don't worry. Please continue your review series of the sign-of performances!
It's not my favorite performance of theirs either. But they keep getting better, so stay the course and I look forward to seeing you react to the rest of their performances.
We...well, most of us Pentaholics actually agree with you. This and their very last Sing Off performance weren't as good. But just you wait, they hit their groove on the 4th performance! Can't wait to watch your reactions!
Where is Dee ?
Hey girl. I know you love PTX! Do youself a favor and react to Superfruit - Worth It! Just Mitch and Scott. Such a good song and cute video. Hope to see it. Love you!
Pls react to avi kaplan doing an overtone
YYYAAASSSS This is very much their worst Sing off performance. KEEP THESE COMING!
Please react to Pentatonix-Payphone, great job with the channel.
You should react to Sara Bareilles. Her new songs are amazing. Well, everything she does is amazing, but I'm obsessed with Fire and Saint Honesty.
Not the worst. Their last performance had some issues. No hate if you being honest.
I really wish that you would have reacted to these performances way back when you first discovered them (and I discovered your channel). You're too used to seeing them crush it in their videos, to then go back and see them still trying to find themselves as group may skew your opinion of the performances. That being said I agree with your opinion on this one. This is the worst performance of the season, they took too big of risk on this one and it fell flat. They still take some risks, but they find that 'sweet spot' where they don't lose the feeling of the original song and still make it their own. You will begin to see the real PTX take charge and blow everyone away. Love the reaction as always Dee.
You might double your subs. It's gonna sound strange but react to "petra reacts" to "Darkness keeps chasing me". I've found someone else who feels music like me, Thank You!
In my opinion, there's nothing wrong with the PERFORMANCE. The problem for the judges was the arrangement. Their execution was fine; they just changed the nature of the song too much for the judges' taste. (Mind you, they change the Janis Joplin one just as drastically, but the judges liked that one.)
it's primarily the choice of song and looking at their performance through the prism of their latest arangements , which are made with 8 years more experience and development. at the time of sing off Scott, Mitch and Kirstie were only 19. following sing off performances were much better (except final episode performances that, in my opinion, were not as good as some performances between this one and final)
Yeah there were parts of the arrangement on this song I didn't get into, so I agree this was the worst one they did. But that just means the shows get better & better as the 2 new members & 3 original members actually get more in synch & discover all the possibilities.
Please Please Please to Jaques Brel if you go away, it will break your heart
React to “someone “ by nick nittoli please
Mitch won that show for them.
No that would be Scott, Mitch is overrated and I am over the hype
@@cradleofmidian666 Mitch won that whole show with his Dog Days solo. Don't argue. I'm correct.
Mitch is only one person in the group, and not even the most talented, so I disagree
I think this actually is their worst performance. Which, however, still doesn't mean it's bad exactly, because they are ridiculous :D. I mean there are a few of their arrangements that I don't like, this being one of them, but that still doesn't take away the fact that even in their worst times, they don't go bellow a certain standard and aren't we all a little spoiled by that, tbh? :D I know I am.
As far as their competition performances go (I don't count the ones they did outside of competing on the Sing Off - those I don't really care for either, though they're still ok :D), I think this is their weakest. I actually haven't heard it in a while, because I tend to skip it when I rewatch their Sing-Off journey.
Although he is Belgian
I can't disagree with you on this one....does it help to say they all just go up from here? Love them - just not this song! But you never learn if you never fall on your bum, so this was theirs ;-)
In the whole sing off - this was the weakest performance. The others are so much better - the second weakest is "Stuck Like Glue," but it's still stronger than this performance. My favorites are Dog Days Are Over and Born to Be Wild.
Stuck Like Glue is in my top 3 :D. I love how what they did with it. But I get why people aren't wild about it.
this was the only one I disliked out of everything they've ever done. lol
Ok that was your second chance and you blew it. You are NOT a true Pentaholic and I am done. #Unsubscribe
"Kirstie looks so young." Are you implying she looks old now? Old and fat?? That's the meanest thing anyone has ever said about anyone in the history people saying mean things!
wjlintz oh stop. stop trying to start drama where there isn’t none to begin with. It’s true they all look soo young because this was 8 years ago! but that doesn’t mean shes shading them for any reason.
If you know Dee you would think twice to make such a comment....ofcourse she doesnt mean Kirstie looks old now..and fat??? Who said anything about fat?? ONLY YOU. She ok only meant that they all looked like babies back then and they've grown so much..vocally but also as a person..So stop creating drama where there isnt any.
Good golly! Was my sarcasm not obvious enough? ruclips.net/video/q-AZbZsyZf0/видео.html