Stealing Ukraine's Children: Inside Russia’s Camps
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 9 фев 2025
- Moscow has been accused of abducting and forcibly deporting more than 19,000 Ukrainian children. In what could amount to the most horrific war crimes committed to date, the Russian state is allegedly attempting to turn a generation of Ukrainian children into Russians.
Help keep VICE News’ fearless reporting free for millions by making a one-time or ongoing contribution here. - vice.com/contr...
Subscribe to VICE News here: bit.ly/Subscrib...
Check out VICE News for more: vicenews.com
Follow VICE News here:
TikTok: www.tiktok.com...
Facebook: / vicenews
Twitter: / vicenews
Instagram: / vicenews
More videos from the VICE network: www. vic...
Follow VICE World News here:
TikTok: www.tiktok.com...
Twitch: / vice
Facebook: / viceworldnews
Twitter: / viceworldnews
Instagram: / viceworldnews
#VICENews #News #Ukraine
WATCH NEXT: We hear from the correspondents that’ve covered generation-defining stories in every corner of the globe, from a presidential assassination in Haiti, to the fight for housing rights right here in the U.S. - ruclips.net/video/arfYqU67khc/видео.html
Hello VICE team here is another documented russian kidnapping crimes with photo proves, Eng cc available ruclips.net/video/XnP_Kw1gQpQ/видео.html
Is there any brain inside here and on the Vice News channel (a NATO-affiliated media channel) to explain why Vice News and many other Western media channels did not cover the 2014 Odessa Trade Union Building massacre? Or why there were no reports about the suppression of the Russian language and Russians from 2014 to 2022? Can Vice News analyze why Ukraine eradicated the Russian language and Soviet-era historical monuments? Oh, why did the Ukraine Maidan overthrow the Yanukovich government? Why does no media channel talk about it?
Did Hunter Biden use drugs in the White House? Vice News should do a report on this issue.
And what about the case of the black teenager shot dead by the police in France? What is the reason behind this incident? Is it racial discrimination or not?
There are many, many other issues that I and many others want to know about. As for Russia? I already know it's a bad country - let's not talk about Russia anymore. Let's talk about the excellence of the US, NATO, and the West.
The wars in Libya, Iraq, Afghanistan, and so on, there are too many stories.
Есть ли здесь хоть какой-то мозг и на канале Vice News (связанный с НАТО) чтобы объяснить, почему Vice News и многие другие западные каналы не освещали массакр в Одессе в 2014 году? Или почему не было репортажей о преследованиях русского языка и русских с 2014 по 2022 год? Может ли Vice News проанализировать причины, по которым Украина уничтожала русский язык и исторические памятники советского периода? О, почему Майдан в Украине сверг правительство Януковича? Почему никто не говорит об этом?
Использовал ли Хантер Байден наркотики в Белом доме? Vice News должен сделать репортаж по этому вопросу.
А что насчет случая с черным подростком, застреленным полицией во Франции? Какова причина этого инцидента? Это расовая дискриминация или нет?
Есть еще много-много других вопросов, о которых я и многие другие хотят знать. А что касается России? Я уже знаю, что это плохая страна - давайте больше не говорить о России. Давайте говорить об отличии США, НАТО и Запада.
Войны в Ливии, Ираке, Афганистане и т.д., историй слишком много.
19,000 no over 200,000 let's get it straight
What a bunch of BS propaganda this is.More of the same neoCON state dept,and CIA lies!!!
You need to understand that Ukrainians are not an ethnic group, they are a political movement. and it was in Ukraine that politicians brainwashed children that they were different ethnically, that they differed in blood from all the peoples of Russia. although in Russia half of the population comes from the lands that are now the Ukrainian state.
The way in which this woman is able to ask dangerously accurate questions without the blink of an eye is astonishing
She hates the woman in front of her but she has to remain to appear not bias.
Arent most of these regions ethniclaly Russian? Theyre not ukrainian so how could they be ethnically cleansing Ukrainians?
@@KoroushRPBlah, blah, blah, I don't care what language they speak, what matters is that they're Ukrainian citizens who were kidnapped and sent to brainwashing facilities far away from their parents in a hostile land. That's a crime, period.
@@KoroushRP They're of russian decent but they're Ukraine citizens, its the same as a Russian who grew up in America is an American, they're not russian.
@@KoroushRP What are you talking about? Even in the Donbas there's many ethnic Ukrainians. These were primarily Russian speaking regions but many ethnic Ukrainians. Also most Russian speaking and ethic Russians in Ukraine support Ukraine not Russia.
This is utterly horrific. The top official in charge of children's welfare, when asked if she was a war criminal, answers stupidly that she is a mother, and that's the answer. Is she wholly ignorant of the fact that there were people who had given birth in their lives AND been tyrannical murderers? Just by her defensiveness, hubris, and dismissiveness, we can all see the truth of her role in this. May she receive justice for taking these young human beings.
Are they supposed to leave the kids on the front lines and for the parents to come through the front line to get the kids of have the parents go through the front line and get them or go to Russia and get them use your fucking brain.
Yeah you can tell she's evil 😂
This is why a segment about nothing still works ... People like this moron fill in the blanks with their worst nightmares and soon everyone has such a distorted view of reality that anyone who actually has first hand knowledge, will be educated on their own experience by Americans who called it "The Ukraine" until Feb 2022.
Would be like asking Stalin if he would send people to their death and his response would be.
-“I am a father”
@@desire_002 Psychopatic level 100 evil indeed
This is the vice I fell in love with years ago. Access not given to other journalist, asking the hard questions, reporting on things others aren’t, and going into danger. I miss this side of vice and it’s nice to see it coming back little by little. Keep it up! ❤
I agree💯
Same here, less concentration on drugs and more on internationally glossed over topics please 🙏
They literally never stopped doing this. They just added in lighter content to supplement the hard journalism and everyone crapped their pampers.
@@ndnxneh Triggered by one sentence, nice 😂
@@mangostripes2335 nothing wrong with vice reporting on drugs, but I agree with your second statement.
"I am a mother" does NOT say everything. When you are committing vile actions, THAT is what says it all. I absolutely hate her. That laugh she did when asked if she was a war criminal was terrifying.
I do too. She looks so evil too and she is.
Because that's the most stupid question giving that th source of children trafficking is the west and this is the most stupid question ever made. The brother of the ICC mr Khan is a fukin pedophile. And their accusations including journalist its stupid and propagandist. There is nothing more easy for and ukranian to go to Russia
@@AndJoa The "source" of child trafficking is every country in the world. The fact is we know now, by the number Russia themselves gave, that at least 700,000 Ukrainian children have been taken from Ukrainian cities after Russia bombs them. That is not saving the children, that is trafficking.
99.9% of these kids are not being reunited with their parents, only a handful to use as propaganda for the Russian government to claim they are doing this out of goodwill when it is a blatant lie.
It is an obvious lie and somehow people still believe it.
When a country attacks another country and takes their children, that is literally taking prisoners of war, as well as human trafficking.
See it for what it truly is.
A truly vile person, especially for using the clip of the mother reuniting with her son as propaganda. It’s abuser mentality of saying you should thank me for giving your son that I stole from you back
She is straight up the fuckin' devil. Her words alone are enough to rile the world against her
I live in Canada. My neighbours are Ukrainian refugees from Kupiansk. They have a 5 year old son. It's absolutely terrifying to think this could have happened to them. Thanks for this excellent and well-written story.
Bahkmut is just rubble. So sad to see your home destroyed.
There are Ukrainians here in Hawaii also.
Arent most of these regions ethniclaly Russian? Theyre not ukrainian so how could they be ethnically cleansing Ukrainians?
@@KoroushRPEthnic cleaning is about the erasure of the identity irrespective of the group’s proportional representation in an area. In any case, the occupied areas are not predominantly Russian.
@@KoroushRP you are totally wrong, these regions have maybe 10-15% of russian minority.
The Ukrainian girl that was afraid to say she considers herself as such, makes me very sad... I truly hope these war criminals get punished.
Lol taking kids out of war zone is a crime orphans most of them. While usa and its kurdish allies keep isis children in prisons western kids as well where alot of them died in the prison riot. Moroever where are all the orphans from Afghanistan, Syria, libya, Iraq and etc.... do you know or care did any western government build orphanages for them. 😅 you make me laugh look in the mirror first and see how dark your culture and government is first before criticising others
war criminals !! What about the "civilized" organizers of the whole story ?
Afraid to say it on camera check civilians in mariuople its the same they don't like being recorded answering such questions, they but then say we are happy to be under Russia its what we wanted we wanted this referendum years ago but lying didn't allow it. And that's why donbass broke away.
We need not to hope we need start to do support to ask politicians to start everthing ukranian kid need active support
@@dmytrostepanyuk7808
Don't worry.
Part of these kids are going to massacre Russians when they grow up.
Karma .
It is deeply distressing to witness Russia's flagrant disregard for human rights by illegally deporting Ukrainian children and separating them from their families. Such actions are nothing short of wickedness. Furthermore, Russia's continued funding of propaganda to paint itself as a hero, while acting as the true villain, only adds to their reprehensible behavior. These acts must be condemned as war crimes.
History repeating itself.
At least we know now how Putin sleeps at night, if not how many.
You would think JSOC will be rescuring these children? Hopefully some elite NATO unite.
@@bodyboardingchronicles602 Yeah im sure their getting rambo geared up as we speak...hold your breath i promise you wont wait long...
There's a correspondent who used to work for Vice. He did a segment on Ukraine's Bandera Youth Nazi Camps like 7 years ago. He has his own show now "Popular Front". The Grey Zone already covered these camps, they have permission from the parents, some of them go to music schools, it just depends. They were originally meant to remove children from Donbas which was under heavy artillery attack since Oct 2021.
My question is why is the Vice reporter so happy while asking Oxana how afraid she is?
The Donestk and Lugansk People's Republics overwhelmingly voted in favor of incorporation into the Russian Federation. But that doesn't make sense to Americans. The whole "War crime" premise is based on the claim that it's not legal. International Law is simply dictated by the US. Its a self referencing circle...The children's counselor is a "dangerous man" because he is under international sanctions. Why is he under international sanctions? Because he's a bad Russian man. And so on.
I am so pleased that this report has shown where a lot of the Ukraine children are. I sincerely hope that all the Ukraine children are returned to their families in Ukraine. This reporter did a wonderful job and I was so pleased that no harm came to her. Thank you for sharing this as it is extremely important to find the children.
Weapons of Ukrainian children massive chasing found we need to invade Russia and steal all russian oil , they are dirty muslims communist dictators.
Poor Ukrainian children are going through battle line by the way to be stealen in russian camps, they never be in Russia cause they are Ukrainian. Poor washingtonian journalist
Probably kidnapped by traffickers,and sold to western elites in Hollywood,DC,and London!
kjj;
How do you like this camp? ruclips.net/video/CpV16BQfbrQ/видео.htmlsi=cBDhLqmXO1fieG0y
It is a pity that the same cannot be said about the children of Gaza. There is no such villain in the Israeli government who could evacuate them.
Fantastic journalism, the places you guys managed to get into to tell this story is seriously impressive. I hope the people responsible for this tragedy are held accountable.
almost like the Russia have nothing to hide thats why there were allowed in and even to pick up the kids because the kids were taken under parental permission.
@@cu6upckuu48This is pure whataboutism, gtfo.
i wonder how long untill they start saying putin eats babies...
@@cu6upckuu48 Always some daft moron out here pretending to be be knowledgeable...
@@cu6upckuu48 , РАБсссийский ботяра, ты имеешь ввиду этот случай?
Teenager adopted from Russia 'killed his mother and American Airlines pilot father in their home - stuffed his mom into a TRASH CAN' - and was finally arrested after a 12-hour SWAT standoff
Carl Edward Brewer, 17, is accused of murdering his adoptive parents
They are pilot Troy Gene Brewer, 60, and his wife Mary Brewer, 64
Police found their bodies at home Tuesday, and Brewer upstairs
Brewer barricaded himself in a room until SWAT fired in tear gas
The motive is unknown but locals say the kids had outbursts
Brewer and his two brothers were adopted from Russia at a young age
The brothers live out of state; Brewer and his parents lived together
Pure evil that society is
Pure evil is not being smart enough to not get duped into hating. Why ? Because you attract it to yourSelf and live in misery. 😀
America was putting migrant kids in cages
@@williampearson6299 whataboutism.
@@ThePoehladian pure evil is attacking a person on the internet, that is disgusted by pure evil of ruzzian mass kidnapping of Ukrainian children.
@@williampearson6299 deflection lol.... typical
You gotta love "Well we're getting the children out of the way of the airstrikes" with no reflection on who's doing those airstrikes...
both sides, region kids they left from has been Russian for years.
@@qpunk1which country invaded another country? Get out of here Russian shill. Your roubles are no good here (or anywhere)
@@qpunk1 Russian bot spotted
@@qpunk1 According to L/DPR official statistics, the people whom Russia is claiming to be there to protect, the "ukronazis of Kiev" killed in the year 2021 in Donbas a grand total of ... 23 people.
How many thousands have died because of Russia's invasion? How many tens of thousands of Donbas men have been rounded up and sent into the meatgrinder of war?
How many homes, towns, cities and settlements wiped off the map by Russia's bombs and thermobaric rockets?
And you come here, with a Z-logo in your avatar, and want to play "both sides". Have you no shame?
At least somebody save them from airstrikes. Coz surely I don't remember ever anyone made a camp during invasion in Iraq, Libya and Syria
Why’d she laugh like a super villain 💀
😭
Cause she is one
The face of evil laughing at the idea stealing kids from their homes is perfectly fine and not at all criminal.
why are we not questions the kids who are suffering due to Americans invading other countries causing wars and justifying it with lies. We remember in Afghanistan, we say American soldiers shooting at kids , and they never got punished and the person who did broadcast that video was labelled a criminal that is Julian Assange yet we are here criticizing Russia, how good did we handle such matters before? I feel Russia is doing better than NATO and Americans did before, of course war separate kids from their parents and also kill parents too, if NATO wanted peace they would have not closed the line or disobey agreements that were made during end of cold war, Russia has never disobey them but NATO keep breaking them...objectively with no bias we know NATO want war to dominate the world , and to sell weapons. Today all recent US invasion and NATO invasions since 2000s were based on lies but we still condemn a country that is defending themselves. What about Russian kids who have been killed due to this war? Are they not humans, why do they world only care about Ukraine while kids in Congo, Sudan are being killed , mothers being raped but you are still fixated on Ukraine , why or its because it has people with Pink color and because you have interests as NATO the bias in western media is sickening ...
Something rather Dickensian to it , also some Disney cartoon character from 1960s ... maybe 101 Dalmatians but I'm vague in memory. Anyhow it's material for the Brothers Grimm to muse over .
Just so you know
4000 years ago the Sumerians were known for taking children of conquered territories to their land and raise them as their own away from their parents
Babylonians and Elomites also did the same thing and so did some ancient Greek city states and the Romans and Umayyads and Vikings and Avars and Franks under Charlemagne against the Saxons in the 8th century and the British empire did that to aboriginal people in Australia and Tasmania and Canada for decades took native children from their families and put them in reserves to teach them English and erase native American languages
The ottoman empire took children from slavic and Bulgar families as young as 7 in their army never to see their parents again and were raised as Turks and called Janaissaries
In 1975 When USA withdrew from Vietnam they took 200 thousands kids to America and only few managed to find their parents again so why insulting the Russians for doing what every civilization and empire throughout history did ?
Not from "their homes", it's from "their orphanage". Which is not equal.
Children that were in danger were saved. The face of evil is yours. I would want my kids to be saved if they were in Ukraine, not bombed or left to starve, you demon.
Taking a child away from their family is one of the most despicable things humanity can do. This will stain Russia for eternity.
The US does the same thing with illegal aliens.
No
Sadly, the mark on Ukraine will be even larger, even when they win the war. I worry that so many of these kids will never see their parents again
@@RAIDENCHEEKS yes
@@bearok89 what kind of "mark" is suppose to be on Ukraine and why?
11:50 how the first kid answered was litterally the way you would answer if someone would be holding a gun to your head. nightmarish
Thanks for this report. I'm from Bucharest, Romania and some of my neighbours are Ukrainians from Svatove in Luhansk region. The horrors they went through must've been unimaginable. Praying for Ukraine every day.
im from Bucharest also,yhou can ask your Ukrainian neighbours if was in lughansk in 2014 and ho has killing the Ukrainian and children on that area? stop with this propaganda people, its not good
Varule vezi ca 400.000 de Ucrainieni nu mai au dreptul sa vorbeasca limba Romana in Ucraina fiind interzisa prin lege, in timp ce tu te rogi pentru dusmanii tai. Deasemenea vecinii tai ucrainieni au alocatii si bani gratis de la guvern de zeci de ori mai multi decat scalvii de romani care muncesc de rup p**da in ei la propriu, terminati cu propaganda asta sunteti spalati pe creier rau de tot ma jur.
@@CattaOficialrussia invaded Ukraine in 2014 and Ukraine bombed them seems logical right ? Well not for your vodka fried brain apparently stop the cap Ivan you live in a Russian swamp
@@CattaOficial 2014? You the year when fascist imperialist Russia invaded, stole and annexed Crimea and invaded and occupied parts of Luhansk and Donbass and started the war against Ukraine?
@@mortenrobinson5421It's not like people in those regions democraticly voted to get annexed to russia or anything.
15:10 "I am a mother". Yeah, Ilse Koch was a mother as well, doesnt mean she wasnt a terrible war criminal.
SHe kind of reminds me Of Ilse Koch in personality of a smiling sociopath.
It's terrible to imagine that I could have been in one of these camps if my village had not been liberated from the Russians in March 2022. Thank you for this report, it is very important to let the world know the truth about the terrorist state.
hope you stay safe, friend ❤️✌️
If your government hadn't terrorised the Donbass for 8 years this war would never have happened
@repentandbelieveinJesusChrist1Are there slaves in heaven? I have read both the bible and the Qur'an and believe that you are fighting over which end of the egg you break open! Just like in Johnathan swifts Gulliver's travels. Who was to be sacrificed by Abraham? Was it Ismail or Jacob because both very Holy books tell two different narratives. They are the word of God! Only one of those books are wrong!
BOT!
@viperculous Yes slava whatever, the west basically led them to ruin, cheer on, its fitting.
That woman who took in 12 children at $1,000 EACH is no do-gooder AT ALL.
This is the most egregious war propaganda I've ever seen! It's filled with atrocity hoaxes, out right lies, and fakes. The people who produced this should be charged with incitement to hatred using fabricated lies. This is pathetic.
Just collecting a paycheck, but she treats them like garbage behind closed doors
They said 2 dozen didn't she
Once I heard the money a month from per kid made me think the same thing. She’s in it for the money
Your reporter was so professional and humane at the same time, hats off to her. I'm so glad that mom got her son home.
😂
So sad laughing war crime brainwashed a horrible woman.
You gotta be kidding right??😄,She's a propagandist
I don't know hardly anyone with dual citizenship. What purpose would that provide besides ego for the American citizenship. As for as Ukraine vs. Russia, that would just allow them to go back and forward to each country. Which I'm sure is not happening at this time of war.
@@daixer3156 i have 2 but only because it costs money to renounce one, they are ukranian and russian, the russian one costs 500euro to get rid.... too poor and too lazy to do it.
Love this reporter. Well done to all involved in exposing the truth of child trafficking.
Isobel Yeung!! My favorite journalist as well!
ikr...I would be trembling. Where putin and his children's commissioner, maria are talking, starting at @2:33,...thrilled they are getting away with child trafficking. I can only imagine the task of getting them back... More hopeful if putin's maffia is replaced by a civil democracy... as is the intentions of the Legion Freedom of Russia
Russia is protecting the kids Ukraine are the child traffickers.
She's just repeating mainstream bs..meh..
@@FriendlyPerson-zb4gv she’s repeating evidence and allegations made by people who were affected and involved not stating her own opinions
The suffering of that mother touched me deeply. Nothing can justify these actions
It is terrible to think of your child, just to be taken away, and that there would a chance you would never see them again.
@@RZVV_1 yeah should leave em in ukraine for starvation and shelling like kids on donbass that were bombed by ukraine for 8 years before the invasion , but hey you won't show it on your pre=paid channel
🤡🤡
@@Americanhonkee type comment of someone who supports russia without knowing a minimum of history ... you are eaten by propaganda
Nothing can justify ethnic cleansing.
This is way too familiar to me. My grandparents are survivors of very similar bordering schools. They were taken against their will as children and forced into such schools for the sake of being "saved". Where they were physically and mentally abused and forced to behave, speak, and think like their kidnappers. To this day, my family is still healing from the trauma that was dealt so long ago. It is ethnic cleansing and a form of genocide. Which reminds me of the phrase that reflects their experience "Kill the Indian, save the man". Thus, I am concerned for these children.
Sad but true. It's not pleasant to think of what our ancestors did to each other. I wanted to think people had evolved past behaving that way but obviously they haven't.
@@ED-es2qv why don't you worry about the closure of Russian schools in Ukraine, the deprivation of the Russian language status of the state, the deprivation of the Russian people of the status of the indigenous population, the prohibition of the use of the Russian language in advertising, the demolition of monuments to Russian cultural and scientific figures because of their national origin (Leo Tolstoy, Dostoevsky Pushkin and many others), the withdrawal of books in Russian from libraries and much more? Western humanists don't really care about that, right?
Maybe you should bother for once to listen to the other side too? Always helps in making the right conclusion...
@@59vlada This documentary did clearly have a side, which is wrong you are right. But even the most critical sceptic would surely look at this and bend slightly, this is very disturbing.
I have also yet to see any media on the "other side" to be a compelling counter to this narrative but there is only so much I can access or am willing to go looking for.
@@loucanscale1570 Well, it's enough to listen to those in the West who are not in the corporate (read: banksters') pocket. Not too hard to find, luckily, even if they have much smaller coverage than corporate media. Btw. did you hear them say a word about what happened to 85 "special needs" children from Bahmut evacuated "for their good" to Spain?
Just eternally grateful for VICE News. Thank you, all you individual contributors in the team that continue bringing us engaging news coverage.
Get a brain, VICE NEWS IS ILUMINATI DEEP STATE FUNDED PROPAGANDA MEDIA, NO WONDER THEY ARE DYING. They are only spreading ukranian and nato propaganda.
Are you are you Ukrainian
thank god vice is going under
@@Cameron-bk5gk look at my comment.
@@Xendrius Russia is essentially doing the same thing Canada did not that long ago, Residential schools.
This is one of the saddest things I’ve ever seen. There are no words.
America was putting migrant kids in cages last year
funny how evacuting children from warzones can be rebranded as stealiing children. power of propaganda
It's amazing to what absolute lows Russia steeps. It's time the people responsible and involved get solved
@@herpesdergotterbote2719 nothing is lower than trying to make Russia look bad for saving children and taking care of them. You guys are the low ones here.
@@Merku808 And who exactly is dropping those bombs and bombing civilians?
I saw the abridged version of this story on NBC's broadcast tonight. It really hits different with a 20-minute segment directly interviewing the people involved, especially the ones currently inside Russia. You can tell from that foster mother and those kids at the camp that they know exactly what is going on and don't like it, but they have to walk on eggshells with everything they say lest the authorities come for them. "I won't answer that question" says everything you need to know. It feels like we're back in the USSR.
@@Sasheeees I personally was in this camp when these journalists came. 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@Sasheeees In what way is everything turned in the opposite? Are you reunited back home in ukraine?
@@Sasheeeeswhy can't the kids answer the question if they are Ukrainian or Russian? Why can't the reporter speak with children alone, if they have nothing to hide?
@@Sasheeees so these camps are for the 1% as it were. im totally behind a meritocracy btw, but does make me fear for those who dont make the grade. the kid who said he slept on bare concrete for example. I do agree the kids (along with parents, which clearly didnt happen) shouldve been removed from the theatre of war, but as the UN convention clearly states and reported in the vid, into a 3rd country. I can 100% see why the international community is concerned about russianisation.of ukranian children. Alot of things the pro-putin people said came across as dodgy. Only adults have the ability to consent, children are too easily coerced/dominated and truth told, all too many adults are easily dominated as well, as i know to my own experiences. I am going to disappoint you, you have not persuaded me away from the angle of the reporting, if anything, you have confirmed to me that the camp the reporters were allowed to visit was for elite talented children AND propaganda. That the vast majority of ukranian children have a fate akin to 'soldier-boy' who got rescued
@@kimwarburton8490Majority of people in the conflict zone are Russians, so Russia has the right to keep those children for safety concerns, especially to avoid their misuse in war, as we know how Ukrainians are recruiting people forcefully in the army, some reports also suggests to recruit underage kids & old. Anyway, we also know, kids were sent back to their parents too.
These children are probably being lied to and told that if their families really wanted to collect them, they would, which means they abandoned/forgot them, which is why they'd be more likely to believe that russia "saved them". However, not every family likely has the resources or knowledge to know where their children are being held, and are missing them dearly. I hope these children get out; the amount of therapy they'll need to fully recover is insane, so much trauma
How could the world overlook comeback of fascism in Russia in 2023?
US over threw the Ukraine government in 2014. who would have seen the US is the new nazi germany of the era
I studied journalism for things like that. It is kinda hard to see that good materials like this one are becoming so hard to fund and produce. Kudos for Isobel and Vice once again.
I feel its wrong to ask kids about a conflict they have nothing to do or understand , did you guys ask kids about conflict regarding US and Iraq , Afghanistan , or NATO inversion of LIBYA , did you ask kids about Rwanda when Tutsi and Hutu were killing each other....I feel double standards with western media is very bad, saying Russian tvs spread propaganda while doing the same is very evil
They're not hard to produce. Get some money from a side hustle, get a camera, and then go to the place yourself. You could be interviewing Kim Jong Un on why he's starving his people to death. You'll have to grow a pair but it will be great contributions to society.
You studied journalism for spreading western propaganda? Alright then.
@@СергейМонин-д7сhow is it western propaganda when they’re on the ground and everything is for you to see plainly? If they were in a news room I’d understand potential faking or editing but they’re interviewing children and actively being monitored and questions are being surpressed…. Sounds very free no?
@@СергейМонин-д7с No, man. I just always found fascinanting how we can understand some perspectives through well told stories. Chill, dude.
Human trafficking
America was putting migrant kids in cages
@@williampearson6299Horrible I agree, but that justifies this exactly how?
@@ZivineYT parent gave permission to have there kids be taken out of the war zone. parents took the jurney to get there kids but many ended up staying with there kids in Russia to avoid going back to ukraine.
@@qpunk1 just watching this docu already confirms this not to be the case...
@@qpunk1 Man I've been looking at you in this comment section and it's bad how obvious you're paid to defend Russia online... Get a job that won't make you ashamed of telling others about it.
Give this girl a raise.
Very good report. That Lvova Belova woman sent shivers down my spine. The International Court must have solid evidence against her if they've issued an arrest warrant. The whole thing is sinister in the extreme.
She's a hero and an amazing woman that actually cares about the children. Unlike americans who torture and farm their blood for elite drugs.
They have no evidence since the ICC is just a kangaroo court.
She's one helluva Pavlova.
This woman is evil incarnate.
@@masterlightjames950 cool fanfic, bro, save it for creepypasta. No one's into your fantasies here.
That is basically one of the genocide practises, poor kids...
America was putting migrant kids in cages, release them, please
Where do you see a genocide?
Holy phock are you brainwashed.
taking children out of the war zone?
@@yzyz7779 Get help lil fella, That doesn't excuse this at all. Lets hope your in a trench soon :)
@@yzyz7779 Botski trash reported. May you soon be drafted.
There is nothing too low for the Russian state.
LOL... SHOULD THEY BE LIKE THE US AND MAKE SURE KIDS DONT LEAVE THE BATTLEFIELD. 😅
Getting you to hate is the whole reason fake news exists. You fell right into it........again.
@@ThePoehladian yeah thats why vice was only able to ask certain questions 🤓
@@staygolden9264 they do that, too, more than the US does. And the US does it way too often.
@@ThePoehladian it's not hate. It's more like pity. Like, when are they going to evolve? They're being left behind, politically and morally, by almost the whole world. Don't they get tired of being backward monsters?
Nearly $300,000 a year. "Just acting in the interest of the children"
That woman is participating in a moralistic crime with few equals.
can you believe that we have so many in the US that support Russia? i heard about this months ago but had no idea it was this many children
You have contrarians in every country during wars. Some of it is driven by partisanship, and some are just straight up tankies. Still, there will always be those who do it because it bucks the mainstream. The sadder reality is that most people really don't care, and don't even know what is going on. They have no curiosity about it.
Many people in the USA loved the nazis too they still do . Nazis are now called russians and trumpers
Yes . Trump and 90% of the Republican party back Putin as well as the entire Right-wing media. People who support Trump, support fascism and love dictators like Putin like Trump does, so it's not that surprising.
It's appalling that so many in the US support Russia. It's pretty shocking too:( It sickens me to see willfully blind people. They have everything others want yet support a dictator & a murdering regime.
No surprise there are idiots in the West that do, just like those that supported the Nazis during WWII.
pretty crazy to say 'we saved the from the airstrike' when you are the ones dropping the bombs...
they don't have nearly enough self awareness to realize it though
My mother grew up in Ukraine for most of her life before moving to another country prior to this war and had me. To think if I were to grow up in Russian-occupied Ukraine with this happening gives me shudders. I feel deeply for all of those who have been taken, and I pray for their return and for this war that has fractured the lives of so many to end.
❤
your mother is an ordinary Ukrainian biomass. do you know your father?
@@Tony300186spam
Sweden has been kidnapping the kids from the Muslims families for years, and use horrific racist policies in targeting migrants and Muslims families. Even the Ukrainians refuges stopped considering to go and live in Sweden.
@@alexandervlasov4122🤡
THIS NEEDS TO BE STOPPED!!!
GIVE THEM ALL THE HELP THEY NEED
She's earning $1000 per each child. She says she acts in childrens' interest. Everage salary in ruzzia is $300
even at McDonald's (now they call it differently) the salary is $500+
@@andrewcrus but that's in moscow. Anything outside moscow is a third world country in terms of salaries
@@MrAlexbotvinko I typed in Google работа вкусно и точка Тюмень (this is the name of their McDonald's, in the city of Tyumen it is in Siberia) and the same thing is there.
About the fact that there is nothing besides Moscow, by the way, in general, a myth
@@andrewcrus Sure, because otsosijane ALWAYS pay what they advertize and ALWAYS do it on time, aha.
@@TheGamer2001 what is "otsosijane"?
I gave an example of salaries at lowlevel job for students and people without experience, I can not understand what you are trying to convey to me. Does this company not pay salaries? In Russia, as a whole, do not pay?
I was there in 2019, talked to people there and did not hear anything like that.
Painfully sad to watch. But superb journalism. Thank you for bringing this information and for putting the criminals on the spot... may they pay for these abhorrent acts.
Nope
sad to watch? DONATE TO THE UKRAINIAN ARMY NOW. FIGHT THIS FUCKING TERRORISM.
@@felixq1578 Nope to Russian disinformation.
@@Sasheeees Yeah sure. Because these "reeducation camps" are pure love and care... please. That's why government officials have to be filming the interview and why the interview was stopped. Everyone sees the disinformation. You can call the sky red all you want but if it's blue it's blue.
@@Sasheeees What is your name? Where you came from?
As an Atheist If there was something to make me believe Devil's pretending to be humans, Lvova-Belova is that person. That evil faced smiling woman is just freakishly disturbing.
EXACTLY ! ...the best when he laughs ! SATAN & MEPHISTOPHELES ! How disgusting !
God exists and So does the Adversary.
As a fellow atheist, have you seen what foster care is like in the US or other western countries? As we saw in the video, the kids are healthy, well fed, and are being provided an education on par with the children of Russia. The smile is just like what is used by anyone in high public office.
@@ColinTherac117 you clearly didn't pay attention watching the video, or watch the whole thing to hear what some of the children recovered have said.
Excusing a war crime.
@@ppser818 ok nutjob.
So the one mother was allowed to get her child back because the cameras were there BUT, also because the cameras were there, the Russian state television made it seem as though she was, in a sense, "invited" to get her child back, creating the narrative that they are "saving" Ukrainian children. If the VICE cameras weren't there, I doubt that she would have made it to get her child. How many Ukrainian parents aren't allowed to cross the border and get their children? How many are detained along the journey? How many cannot afford to make the trip? How many don't even know where their children are located? There is so much more to this that we aren't allowed to see, but even this small glimpse is disturbing.
Thank you so much for reporting on this. It was incredibly brave of your team to travel into Russia and conduct those interviews!
At least u see now it ain't dangerous at all being in russia.
@@violencelessI just watched a video of two people being arrested, one for what was essentially a silent protest, the other because she was about to voice her opinion on the war. You can believe what you want, the Russian government is awful.
Seriously only Vice does these kinds of reporting. I wish their company all the best.
@@violenceless Not dangerous at all, people just disappear forever.
@@Oorlich95have you seen what followed after that? I've seen a guy being arrested on Occupy Wall Street protests, last month he got out. 12 years for sitting in park. I'm also seen a selfies from Russian police bus. Can you imagine someone using his phone inside US police car to make selfies? This world is backwards
These people are absolute monsters these kids will be mentally scarred for life ,just wait till we start hearing what really happened to them😢😔🇺🇦🤝🇺🇸
Says who? The kids are not experiencing daily mass shootings and LGBT strippers like yours do.
Dude that Maria lady is evil. That fact that she laughs off her question about being a war criminal just says that in her sick mind everything that she is doing to those kids is right and she sees nothing wrong with it. She needs to be stopped. Director of children’s right while violating their rights at the same time.
More footage for the ICC. Ultimately, she's fucked. There is no way Putin can outlive her and with him, I hope, goes her protection
The banality of evil as it is.
taking children out of the place of hostilities and giving them a future is bad? Ukraine doesn’t need them, they despise eastern Ukrainians because they consider themselves Russian, that’s why they shelled Donetsk all these years without taking into account the losses of civilians, you watch videos on RUclips and draw conclusions and rather you don’t know the history of Russia and this conflict at all
And Russians wonder why Russophobia exist...
Very sad thing, I certainly believe because [X] did something bad we should do something awful, or completely ostrachize [Y] who is in the same set as [X] despite the fact they are two different variables
This doesn’t have to do with Russian people but rather their government. Russophobia is still very stupid in effect
people = government;
that’s their way of living, expansion and destruction
@@johnramos8703 russian people very much tolerate and support the war. Russophobia is very rational, especially if you have a border with this monster.
@@johnramos8703 Russians elect and support this government for the most part. If they didn’t then they would do more to rise up against it. Even Russians who live in the West and have access to all the information in the world still support what Russia is doing to Ukraine.
This happened in the US with the native Americans and then with the children of Vietnam - history repeats itself folks
It's the same as when Red Cross was invited to Terezín camp in the Czech Republic (nazi occupation). They showed a happy "family camp". Look at those nice beds and showers... only building they were allowed. Others were nearly as horrifying as other concentration camps. Russians have experience with the concept of Potemkin's villages.
I think this is something that will be talked about for a long time regardless of how the war ends, these kids will grow up in this absurd reality, i wish this issue will be a part of a peace deal but i honestly don't know if that'll happen
It can, but it will be really difficult with a counterpart that only values strength and unfair deals. I hope Ukraine got some prisoners to exchange for them to come back. :(
@@MrCodePanda the kids are not being held hostage, you fool. They're being kept safe, fed and away from the fighting.
Ukrainian Kids: rumors of Russification are totally bogus.
Reporter: so do you consider yourself Ukrainian or Russian?
Ukrainian Kids: I refuse to answer that question.
💀
Do you consider yourself Texan or American? Do you love your mom or orange juice? A classic alternative question manipulation. Calling for a choice. Performed on already stressed and confused kids. Cheap.
they consider themselves human most of all, their nationality matter little. the reporter is obviously asking, what side are you on and the kid is bright enough not to fall into that trap so he refuses to answer to someone who will only use their answer to portray whatever that reporter wishes to portray thru his media channel.
@@martinseptimryden7272 actually that was a brilliant question that instantly shattered the illusionary situation they tried to create in that room and made apparent to everyone in that room and the viewers what was actually going on.
So do you consider yourself Ukrainian or Russian?
Nikolai Gogol in 1830: I refuse to answer that question.
Westerners: awFull russIaAN PropogaNda! Kill Pu! 🤣
@@martinseptimryden7272 +15 rubles
When Vice is good, Vice is incredible. Thank you for reporting on this. Our Children will return home!
VICE, CIA propanda founded by Proud Boy Gavin McInnes ahhahaa... dummy
No wonder Vice news is bankrupt …all F^κε Ν3ω5 and lies…and more lies..
stealing russian kids from ukrainian pedophilies who sell russian kids to western europe and usa pedophilies.... nice job! Putin GOD BLESS YOU! keep going!
and when its crap it sure is crap. this is impressive journalism though
Not just peace but justice for Ukraine.
@adriandx6185 None of those countries are ruled by outsiders. So what are you talking about?
The US left Afghanistan, remember? That's one of the reasons the USSR figured that USA wouldn't interfere when they invaded Ukraine. And, speaking of which, did you forget that Russia invaded and tried to control Afghanistan too?
But it's Ukraine now that Russia is attempting to conquer.
You want justice for all? Fine. That's good. But you don't get to distract from what Russia is doing to Ukraine right now.
@adriandx6185 "antifacista antianarquista pero sobre todo anti-Estados Unidos"
The US didn't invade Ukraine, destroy its cities, murder is people, and certainly isn't stealing its children. *Russia did.* The US doesn't even have any troops in Ukraine. So what are you talking about?
Or do you just hate the US so much that you love their enemies even when those enemies are worse? "antifacista" my ass.
Those children are highly manipulated and obviously even the hand picked ones cannot hold back their emotions just imagine being those kids and trying to sleep at night😔🌻🇺🇦🤝🇺🇸
Have you imagined what happens to those kids at the Southern US border, you sick hypocrite? These kids are safe and taken care of, far from the war front. That's humanity. Russia is not like you demons who killed half a million Iraqi children with sanctions. Demons.
This is very sad may God help the Ukrain children
I imagine what would happen to that girl is she saying she considers herself Ukrainian
in Russia, at the time of the last census in 2021, about 900,000 people called themselves Ukrainians. There are about 190 different nationalities in Russia. So she could call herself even a reptilian, no one would care.
Or stop bombing my country !
nothing, there are a lot of ukranians in Russia
@@majusmajus4304 Are they treated like humans, otsosijski bot? The fact that you capitalized ruzzia and not Ukrainians tells me everything I need to know about you. Wish you to experience the same thing that these children experience, you deserve it. 😁
Meanwhile, the Prime minister of Hungary Orbán Viktor gave an interview to a German newspaper saying that Putin is not a war criminal.
That's his boss.
He doesn't want to lose his job (and fall out of a window)
Joseph Biden is a war criminal, George W. Bush is a war criminal, Barack Obama is a war criminal, Madeleine Albright is a war criminal, Colin Powell is a war criminal, Tony Blair is a war criminal, Boris Johnson is a war criminal, Emmanuel Macron is a war criminal. Benjamin Netanyahu is a war criminal. Vladimir Zelensky is a war criminal.
You have someone to accuse of war crimes, in addition to Putin.
I don't consider removing children from war zone is a war crime. And it is not thousand only 300+ proven.
Europe take children from Ukrainian refugees too. 240 is taken.
One facist defending another. Hungary should be suspended from the EU as soon as possible until they restore democracy in that country.
🤦♂️
My heart breaks for any mother separated from her child by force... Crazy circumstances out there...
Vice is doing the real work!
I feel its wrong to ask kids about a conflict they have nothing to do or understand , did you guys ask kids about conflict regarding US and Iraq , Afghanistan , or NATO inversion of LIBYA , did you ask kids about Rwanda when Tutsi and Hutu were killing each other....I feel double standards with western media is very bad, saying Russian tvs spread propaganda while doing the same is very evil
I couldn’t even imagine being raped, murdered and have your child taken away to then die for the enemy’s army in 10 years. This war is fucking horrific
Maria lavova Bulova knows NOTHING about being an actual authentic mother, she has no maternal instinct whatsoever. l'm left with the impressions she really wouldn't care if her kids got stolen. Such vile and despicable acts, karma will catch up with her
slavery, residential schools, the uyghurs and now this, how are we not learning from the world's past mistakes
My heart is aching seeing this. What Belova started is absolutely vile. I'm the most scared for the young impressionable children. They will be so confused thrown into the middle of all of this. You can watch documentaries about Polish and other Slavic kids taken to Germany and how all these years later it has consequences. Some can't accept that they were taken and insist they are fully German and say that to the face of the siblings they were separated from. It destroys families. Others find out and are absolutely devastated that their lives were a lie. And this is happening again to Ukrainian children. I just hope they all will be able to reunite with their real families and grow up free and safe. All the responsible individuals who took the children must be punished.
These are Russian speaking kids.
@@mitchyoung93They might as well speak North Korean. It's the same type of government these days!
Ваш комментарий пропитан западной и украинской пропагандой. Никто детей не похищал. Это дети по каким то причинам оказавшиеся без родительского контроля или вообще без родителей. Если родители нашлись, проблем для воссоединения нет. Что касается промывки мозгов, то Украина активно занималась этим более 30 лет и не только этнически украинским детям и взрослым, но и русским.
@@mitchyoung93so you can take them from their families? are you sick or what?
@@mitchyoung93they were Ukrainian but the Russians seem to be brainwashing them
It breaks my heart to see children become victims of wars. Every child, regardless of nationality or background, deserves safety and protection. Instead of destroying their childhood, let's give them a chance to dream, learn and enjoy. The future of our world depends on how we care for our children today.
This is exactly the reason they were taken out of the war zone. The places mentioned - Mariupol, Kupyansk, etc. are all very much close to the front lines and either being contested or intermittently struck by missiles from both sides.
@@iliatregoubenko4224 Mariupol was encircled by Russians, so it was struck only by one side with rockets, artillery shells, and heavy air bombing.
@@iliatregoubenko4224 The war zone Russia created. Botski trash reported, may you soon be drafted.
@@suprotyv7534 not what the residents said about the Ukrainian army's occupation for 8 years, doofus.
@@masterlightjames950 what residents, you half-wit? What occupation? Mariupul was and is Ukraine. It lived a perfect life till the ruskie Nazis didn't come there. They once tried to take it, in 2014, but the mighty Azov threw those losers away. The terrorists were jealous of Mariupol evading the fate that followed other parts of Donbass, so the terrorists then shelled it in 2015 for revenge. And then it came full circle in 2022 when they completely destroyed it.
Who’s doing this has no moral.
Leave the kids alone!
Free Ukraine 🇺🇦
This made me physically sick, truly nauseous.
But I really appreciate this reporting.
Very North Korean stuff happening in Russia
Isobel Yeung is a real life Lois Lane for her fearless reporting and professional handling of each of her stories that she reports on. Such a gem in the journalistic field! Stay safe, Ms. Yeung!
Are you kidding? Only an idiot would ask a question like "Are you a war criminal?" The naivety and sensationalist approach prevented her from asking the questions that could have shown more and made these people tell the truth by mistake. What a wasted opportunity to learn more.
I think you nailed it.
She’ll need to find a new job since Vice is going bye bye
That must have taken huge balls. I would be terrified
Very professional and unbias literally can't listen to her since she sounds like she's gonna burst out crying. Why can't they find another reporter
My heart weeps for these children.
And also their parents
Weep for yourself. The children are fine.
@@masterlightjames950Russia thanks you for you service.
@@masterlightjames950 Be quiet
@@masterlightjames950You are going to experience karma in its truest form… That will be sooner than you think… Have a good day
This has been going on forever. Nothing like taking your enemies kids and raise them to hate you. Classic
В самом материале видно что детей возвращают обратно к их родственникам после розысков. Детей хорошо содержат в российских лагерях о чем к примеру палестинские дети и мечтать даже не могут. Все правильно Россия делает что не оставляет людей в зоне боевых действий.
I can't see how any of these poor kids will ever forget this. This has to be a child's worst nightmare, to be taken by orcs.
*by force
not by orcs
Those dang orcs back at it again
@@jarekgonzalez12 They orc-hestrated it on this relatively small scale simply to prove that they're all non-human creations of Mordor - instead of merely disorcanized sheeple trying to get along and not upset the higher-ups!
Never heard any mother complain about her child getting stolen. But you sick dogs in the West and your supporters are always hallucinating and spreading lies about others
@@zetristan4525 russian thugs have been called orcs for years now...
Thanks for this story. I saw one of your series about my home city Mykolaiv. That spring 2022 was hard for us. But what they are doing to our kids and families is more terrifying for me than to stay in the city under constant bombarding. Russians doing the same what nazis did during WW2. God save Ukraine.
I understand that you have some troubles with WW2 history due to some very "interesting" ukrainian school history books' content, so I must inform you. Nazies like your country's beloved Bandera didnt take children into fosterhouses, they burned them with their families in granaries.
God punish those racist Ukrainians, we haven't forgotten what you did to Africans trying to flee.
Arent most of these regions ethniclaly Russian? Theyre not ukrainian so how could they be ethnically cleansing Ukrainians?
@@Berjozka and millions upon millions of Ukrainians died fighting for the red army in ww2 what's your point when a small percentage fought for bandera
@@starwarsROXmyThe point is obscuring Russia’s ostensibly more explicit anti-Semitism and the undeniable fact that Putin has long collaborated with and supported Nazi mercenaries, obvi.
How they take children away from the mothers that gave them life is the worst part.
Is it?
That usually happens during Child Birth when the umbilical cord is cut.
And where's the proof of that? Which mother has come out to accuse Russia of taking her children?
how is leaving kids with a homeless mother in a country that no longer has working electricity for large sections in any way ok? The Russians are doing the right thing by evacuating those kids.
@@ColinTherac117 Since when did Electricity became the basis of good parenting ? Its only been about 90 to 100 years that Electricity has been widely available in all homes.
Ну вот вопрос всё-таки. Если у ребёнка нет опекуна, его родители мертвы, что с ним делать? Репортаж показывает, что родитель может приехать и забрать своего ребёнка. На месте не всегда есть возможность и время выяснять. По мне так это лучше, чем оставлять детей в небезопасном месте.
Well, here's the question after all. If a child does not have a guardian, his parents are dead, what to do with him? The report shows that a parent can come and pick up their child. There is not always an opportunity and time to find out on the spot. For me, it's better than leaving children in an unsafe place.
по женевской конвенции, вывозить их нужно на территорию страны гражданства
Hope the kids make it back home. I feel for them!
The parents can go to Russia and get them any time it says it on the website I don’t see how hard that is to understand that they putting the kids to Russia is better than leaving them on the front lines
Yeah me too. Ukraine needs them for their next doomed offensive.
@@joshuaalexander7006 "KyIV wIll FaLl in 3 DaYs!!!!!," "oTsoSiJa iZ WinnIng!!!!!," da, otsosijski bot? 😁
@@JohnJohn-bz1lq ah yes letd jusy fucking waltz in across a warzone to get ones kidnapped children whode whereabouts are fully unknown.
@@JohnJohn-bz1lq What about the brainwashing going on? By the end of this war, those kids might even hate their real parents because of what the Ruzzians are teaching them. Besides, like it came up in this video, the kids should be in a 3rd party country.
Russia must be stopped at any cost.
😝
Unfortunately, Ukraine's only option is to kick the Russian invaders out of all of their country. If Ukraine went to take the war all the way to Moscow, the Russian population might feel attacked and begin mobilizing adding recruitment powers to grind down Ukrainian troops in an attraction warfare. And unless Russia does a catastrophic attack on NATO nations, there's nothing NATO can do.
Nuclear war?
@@zagudivine1850 Putin would be the first to go
At any cost 🤣 Yeah at the cost of the half of Ukrainian population 🤣 Take a pre-war population and divide by two, just about right cost to stop Russia 😁
This is horrible... how this even possible
This is a much better report than the previous one. I can see that you actually admit the mistakes and produced a report without "Ukraine and russia accuse each other", sorry I called you an idiot on Twitter. Thank you for doing this.
This journalist does not matter. She still got granted entry to russsia. This says everything you need to know.
So, why vice don't go with nikita mom to take nikita back?, This is bulshit, nikita mom totally actres
@@adiputrav Puttins wumao much? Russia is completely see through, it's pathetic.
@@adiputrav tool.
That child snatcher deserves death penalty for sure .
But only a long-lasting painful one
This is extremely disturbing and stomach churning.
Why?
To say that this is sick is a complete understatement! If there's any reason to fight and win against Russia it's this,to get these children back.
Go see a doctor
So you want to leave the kids in a war zone? US is sending more cluster 💣
Resurrecting the Soviet Union requires manpower.
If this material is enough for you to draw such conclusions, then I'm sorry for you, you are very poor in understanding the essence. A little more, and President Zelensky will start sending 16-year-old children to the front, then ask this liar Nikita what he thinks, and ask his mother too.
@@chectorr7895Youre a Real Clown. Drafting age is currently 27. And honestly? How can u say it's right to steal children, give them propaganda and keep them 🤡🤡
Nothing will stop a mothers love for her babies. These poor kids can’t even imagine how scared they are. PTSD at such a young age.
Children in that part of the world are not snowflakes. They have had a tough life and can endure almost anything, especially when compared to children in the US, Canada, UK etc. who throw fits over not being able to use their phone or play games all day. Meaning, they are little super heroes and are far safer there than living in a warzone awaiting a artillery shell to fall on their heads. No, I do not agree with the conflict so spare me the bs. I am simply saying they are safer there.
@@russellwilliams3209 why are you so upset. I didn’t say anything bad at all. Are you a mom? Or a father? If not you have no clue what I’m saying about a mothers love for a child. I feel for these kids they have endured and continue to endure a lot. There kids having to grow up very fast being in adult situations. So calm yourself down go get laid or something grab a coffee or soda because obviously you a lot of pent up issues. Where did I ever say I agreed with the conflict. Apparently you can’t read properly or understand the 3 sentences I stated. If your not a parent you can’t even understand when I say nothing will stop a mothers love for her babies. Even a fathers love. A parent will go to hell and back for their kids, that is my point. There I made is very simple for you. 🫡
@@russellwilliams3209They are not safe there . Russian propagandists have stated many times Ukraine should not exist . They nay be raped daily or sent to the front line as Russian " conscripts "
They are not " tough " no child is
They will be traumatised
“These are provocative questions” are you kidding me how tf have they even convinced themselves that they are the “good guys”💀
SLAVA UKRAINI!!!!!!! we are watching from Colombia south America!!!
I fear the haunting images these children will face for the rest of their lives... Trauma does not heal quickly, especially in young children
This is beyon my imagination how someone can be this cruel and heartless 😢 i hope all paid the price on jail
Are you a war criminal?
*laughs like a goddam villain*
What an awful awful human being she is.
In a Oct 24, 2017 article at the PBS web site titled "What’s the difference between genocide and ethnic cleansing?"
"The United Nations first defined genocide in 1948 in the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide. The treaty outlines five acts that can constitute genocide if they are done “with the intent to destroy an ethnic, national, racial or religious group”:
1. Killing members of the group
2. Causing serious bodily or mental harm
3. Deliberately inflicting conditions of life calculated to bring about the group’s physical destruction in whole or in part
4. Imposing measures intended to prevent births
💢5. Forcibly transferring children"
"acting in their best interests" dawg their best interests would be to be returned to their actual parents 💀
And stop waging war against their country .
It is good to see that the children are in safe hands.
After they where forced out by this war. And now are subject to brainwashing
@@sH-ed5yfthe brainwashing is going on in Ukraine for many years.. ever heard of Stepan Bandera and the OUN ?
So many Russian bots around
... Beware!
so many brainwashed liberal they/thems
u mean ukrainian. or ur mind doesnt even allow such a thought?
Hit the flag button and report.
You get used to the botskis and their silly little scripts...but it takes a special kind of evil to defend Russia stealing children from a war they started.
@@breakingbadheisenberg9703 is this the real way of democracy, to hit the buton and block this video or some other human? the problem is that americans with a similar level of journalism, where the reporter clearly says what is a lie and what is not, they see everything in two colors - black or white)) @MrKh4Ot1k as most commenters here is one of them. fools and liars
This is my own translation of her statement or lack thereof:
Russian Woman: I'm taking care of these children the best I can, and Russia is helping me do that. I don't agree that they are here (which is why I didn't say they "belonged here"), but while they are, I will love them like my own!
I agree. Shindler probably wouln't speak his mind if you asked him about the conflict during German occupation. Time will tell.
Seeing the Russian foster mom speak is chilling. You can not tell if she truly just wants to care for the children, if she believes the Russian Propaganda, or if she know the truth, but also understand that if she says anything about it she would be punished and the children put into another russian, possible worse, family.
I want to believe she know the truth and simply wants to care for the children, knowing that she might be the best chance for the children to one day return home. I want this to be the case, but how can we tell if she is afraid to speak out, believes the russian propaganda, or is simply out for the cash?
Doesn't matter, she's still an accessory to genocide. Punish accordingly and set an example.
She's in it for the money. Video mentioned £1000 per month per child and she has 25 children in her charge. Russian government is subsiding the build of a new house for her and kids .
Most likely it started for the money, little doubt there. But in Russia Putin lovers are not shy of answering total BS with a straight face (you can see the interviews that YT channel 1420 does), the mere act of not answering is a rebellion. That would place here in some unknown middle ground.
@@philip5940 assuming she actually gets that much money. The Russian Medien monthly income is around 630$ (in 2023). Does the Russian Government actually give Foster mother nearly twice the Median Income PER CHILD they take care of? That's hard to believe
But yes money, probably is another reason for taking so many children. But is it the only reason?
Her refusal to answer that one question makes me think she feels she is the best of the options now the kids are in russia. If she was genuinely pro-putin, she wouldve answered it
The lady taking kids away from their parents and said she's just an innocent mother. How would she feel if a country took her kids away from her.
These children will grow and mature over time.They start to think about their life with their own minds and start asking questions, start looking for the truth... Arrogant and proud Russia is raising a generation of its own enemies.
We'll see, I think it's too early to say. Let's just hope they return home to Ukraine ASAP. :(
Sick. Barbaric.
Of course they're only gonna let you speak to the kids who are the best behaved. How sad, you can see in their body language that they all wanna leave!
This is extremely upsetting
This is heartless. This is Putin.
I am a person who is blind, and I am unable to read the subtitles. I would love if this media were more accessible, but it is great reporting from what I heard. Not sure if anyone will read this. Thanks if you do.
I Hope someone who’s able to help you with this reads this! It is sad to me because until I read your comment I wasn’t aware that this could be an issue and thus it’s good to spread awareness on this. I used to think until now that it’s good that they just subtitle it because it gives hearing and seeing viewers more transparency since a lot can get lost or deterred in translation. Therefore, I though until now that it is good for Ukrainian and Russian speakers to verify the accuracy of the translation. I was not aware it was excluding a huge demographic or hampering accessibility.
@@dominik6375 wondering how she will read your comment
Thank you for doing the episode. What the Russians did to the Ukrainian children is unimaginable and sickening. I do hope the kids will reunite with their families.
lol Russian bad
Like WW1 and WW2 (mainly)
Better to give them to european pedophils or organ mafia?
It will take years... And i fear that by the time the work is done, many parents won't recognize their children.
But we have to. If we don't, we are no better than the animals that did this in the first place.
@@DJ_POOP_IT_OUT_FEAT_LIL_WiiWii yes kidnapping children is a criminal offence sir.
The world would not enjoy the day w/o Vice News… nothing but love & respect for their work 🍾🍾
Apparently you don’t know that soros bought vice!