Parenting Styles | Scout O’Donnell | TEDxTheMastersSchool
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 1 июн 2017
- Scout O’Donnell’s talk will explore the current trends in parenting science from both a sociological perspective and from the point of view of children.
Named after the strong-minded, independent young girl in To Kill a Mockingbird, Scout O’Donnell grew up in Vermont and Connecticut. The alternative ways in which her parents chose to raise her contradicted the ways experienced by her peers at the competitive prep school she attended in her early years. In this TEDx talk, she relates her story of maturing into the independent girl she was named after. She shares not a doctor’s perspective or that of a parent or psychologist, but her own perspective on the best way to raise a child and progress in society as a product of alternative parenting.
This talk was given at a TEDx event using the TED conference format but independently organized by a local community. Learn more at www.ted.com/tedx
I thought this talk was excellent and I took a lot from it. But that's because I fell in love with the 'idea' of the perfect parenting. Reading the negative comments was actually a huge relief. My parents were not perfect. I am not a perfect mother but I am a good one. Cheers to all the parents doing their best in whatever circumstances you are in, whoever you are :) Variety is what makes the world great.
She was very knowledgeable! This is what I will share with my clients in our responsible parenting lesson❤️
My parents were quite similar, and I thank them a lot for doing it.
This talk is ❤
Brilliant Ted Talk!🙌
Excellent!
very good!
Thank youuuu💙👏
Parenting is NOT about controling the kids.
Hey there! When it comes to parenting styles, finding the right balance is key. Be loving and supportive, but don't forget to set boundaries too. Your parenting approach can have a lasting impact on your child's life. Show them empathy, communicate openly, and be a positive role model. It'll help shape their confidence, resilience, and overall happiness as they grow up. 👌🏻
I’m so confused at all of the negative comments, I thought this was great
I see why, it’s missing proper knowledge of secure attachment and challenges are confused with not understanding children’s needs and feelings/ she’s justifying her parents choices. Read about secure attachment- bowlby and you’ll see the huge difference
Perfectly said. Such a prequosios young lady. Your parents must be so proud.
Ok Ruby. You’re not a pretentious little brat are you?! 😂
I can't relate to any of this cos my parents barely even interacted with me. :\ I feel like she's discussing a pretty upper-class upbringing between her and her peers. Although I think she's right that micromanaging kids is detrimental.
Yeah she's trying really hard to flex on her upper class peers by giving US POORS life advice after she got jelly that she had to fill out her own college applications lmao
no, there's multiple types of parenting styles. But it is true that it's easier for people with money to parent their children in the way she described her parents raised her.
My sis parents like this and she’s on govt handouts so… I think it’s pretty universal across classes. Before we had latch key kids that were mostly neglected and they grew up to swing too far the other way
I’m doing a tedx talk late June on the “same topic” any suggestions?
don't
By focusing on your upbringing alone you're overlooking things like genetics, poverty, geographic location, lack of family support, lack of healthcare, lack of available child development resources, lack of mental health resources, etc.
Child development is multifaceted.
YES! THANK YOU, some one else said it too!
You're up bringing is by far number one
Parenting style is probably the single most influential factor in upbringing. The way you are raised will trump all of those factors
@@giovannibonesse2573 When it comes to genetics, absolutely not
I am watching this for research as I’m gonna make a RUclips video Bout a similar topic.
We all have had our challenges.
“I’m 18 and an expert on parenting bc of my singular experience being raised”
Have you watched your own content? You can’t even form an intelligent or grammatically correct sentence 😂
Complete misunderstanding of secure attachment, mixed up with @just don’t be a helicopter parent@, examples of challenges that came from not understanding children feelings as opposed to encouragement of independence- she’s just still idealising her parents not having properly looked into the impact of her childhood.
Just her bragging about how good her parents are. doesn't mention Baumrind's parenting styles (authoritative | autocratic | permissive) or Macroby and Martin's 4th style of Uninvolved parenting. interesting for hobby listening but not acedemically.
Totally agree, bet she is a republican. Let's see if anyone understands my comment.
autocratic is essentially authoritarian isn't it?
So much bragging..
EDGAR MELENDEZ what would that have to do with being republican? Politics aren’t involved in everything and it’s not ok to stereotype people without any justifiable reason
Shlug life who said anything about right or left? It was about parenting. She’s correct on how many parents are out here and only care that their kids get straight A’s and think that that will make them successful rather than also teaching them emotionally
this literally reads like a high school narrative essay lmao
I'm glad I wasn't the only who thought that this was a bad speech covering a major topic.
ok, Be proud of you so much pride of herself
What everyone seems to be afraid to mention is that children don’t have to stay with their parents from the time that they can get up and crawl. Anyone will take a child into their arms and care for them because their irresistible and no one can give up the opportunity to care for a child. They should go to only the ones that love the most. Even if a child was one years old and crawled right out their parents front door there would be someone to take care of them. There would be no caveats or restrictions other than the ones that capitalists place upon a child rearing and the current fascitisation we are seeing.
Can you please explain what you meant by your comment. More specifically the "There would be no caveats or restrictions other than the ones that capitalists place upon a child rearing and the current fascitisation we are seeing" part.
100% false. The bond that begins between mother and child starting from in the womb is irreplaceable. What are you even arguing? Do you know how many kids are treated like dirt, abused, neglected etc? If your argument were true none of those said issues would exist and all children would be well cared for lol😂
Makes literally no sense
So, because I'm bad at smalltalk I'll never find a job? lol
Great to hear from someone who knows everything about a subject they know nothing about. She went to “running through the fields” university.
If she didn’t know anything about the subject then why would TedX have done this? Angry little troll. Small D energy 🤷🏻♂️💋
But employers do reward people for doing a task that was expected of them. This reward is you get paid or even sometimes get a raise. Lol
I came here for facts but instead I got this young ladies life experiences and opinions.
How many kids does this chick have? Garrantee, zero. Thought this was meant to be on [parenting styles.. not just a general assumption that everyone but her own parents has the same parenting style....... I accept some of her points but also wonder if she could have benefitted a little more emotional support as a young child....
Sound like you have limited exposure to various demographics. Some kids need more guidance than others. For some, sports are the best way to develop and stay out of trouble. I encourage you to learn about groups other than boarding school kids and parents.
Think the point is to let your child explore what they like and support those endeavors; sports, art, etc... not try and mold them into what their parent(s) believe the child should like or do stemming from personal reasons.
Sounds like you need to open your mind up and stop thinking at surface level. She never said sports are bad, she was trying to say that you should let your kids be who they want to be and find themselves in their own interest.
Sound like you’re a know it all 🤷🏻♂️
I played have danced since I could walk, played soccer, field hockey, basketball, played the flute, and cheer..... but I still love to read books 😭 so this ted talk is my least fav
This is probably the worst ted talk ever.
I find this video extremely condescending. Sociologists don’t know why students are not performing very well. not every parent does their children’s applications some kids are calm because they’ve given up and they have depression not because he had helicopter parents. There’s a lot of holes in her argument. I like what she’s putting down or trying to, but at the same time no one knows anyone else in there is a not a very well understood reason as to why kids in college are feeling so much depression, anxiety so on and so forth.
Is she a parent?
Is that necessary to speak on this?
She talked like an 8 year olds presentation
I can provide you with a link to a female therapist who is on her 3rd marriage due to having your style. I feel sorry for you.
Link please?
We need that link.
Link
Also whay does marriage have to do with anything anyway.
Wow. Feel sorry for yourself that you feel the need to publicly attack a young girl over what she feels helped enhance her success.
I don't feel like I heard a Ted talk. I feel like I heard an uninformed person parroting sound bites the Boomer generation has been whining about for decades, participation trophies and all. She speaks in absolutes, primarily from her own experience. This talk could use a dose of humility, empathy, and sound academic research. I think 10 hypothetical parents could independently follow all of her "tips" without making a single mistake and have 10 completely different results. Either her parents were extremely lucky and she happened to be very responsive to their style, or they were very smart and saw her areas of need and areas of lack of need and now she is taking her success as the "only" way. A form of survivors bias with a hint of confirmation bias. There's no accounting for socioeconomic variance. She almost seems to be desperately trying to rationalize her success and reconcile that with the way her parents treated her. In any case, this felt more like it belonged on PragerU than Tedx. It is basically an opinion piece.
Sounds like you’re the expert. So why hasn’t TedX reached out for you for your Ted talk then?
@@giovannibonesse2573 Not an expert, and I'm busy with other things -- not seeking out the opportunity for a TED talk. But I also don't parade as an expert. I have some sense of what I don't know. But hey, I bet that was rhetorical and you simply disagree with what I said. In which case, why don't you comment on something material that I said wrong so I can address it?
"Scout"? Seriously?
What an a-hole. Making fun of a young girl over her name? Ever read To Kill a Mockingbird?