Caroline Shaw - Entr'acte | WDR Sinfonieorchester

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 29 сен 2024
  • Caroline Shaw's "Entr'acte", originally written for string quartet, was played in its version for string orchestra by the WDR Symphony Orchestra conducted by Cristian Măcelaru on 04.10.2019 in the Funkhaus of the WDR in Cologne.
    WDR Symphony Orchestra
    Cristian Măcelaru, conductor
    ► More about the symphony orchestra, concerts and current live streams can be found at www.wdr-sinfon...
    ► The WDR Symphony Orchestra on Facebook / wdrsinfonieorchester

Комментарии • 25

  • @wishingonthemoon1
    @wishingonthemoon1 2 года назад +13

    Love Ms Shaw’s work. Modern music that is interesting and isn’t just noise.

  • @vclelee
    @vclelee Год назад +6

    Beautiful piece by a wonderful composer and a fine orchestra.

  • @RuteNorte
    @RuteNorte 2 года назад +3

    Beautiful!

  • @LelandJohnson-rd4sc
    @LelandJohnson-rd4sc Год назад

    I tend to agree with Steven J, but for a different set of reasons. The music , like most opuses beyond mid-20th century, is rather transparent and lacks structure, which is not related to its genesis as a piece for string quartet. This piece is like a bad dream or bad drug trip, where it's not possible to know whether any of the instruments are playing the correct notes. Avant-garde types probably fawn over crud like this... but it's still atonal trash.

    • @Gregorius24
      @Gregorius24 Год назад +3

      According to Shaw’s score, it’s in Menuet and Trio form.

    • @cynthiakatsarelis5617
      @cynthiakatsarelis5617 Год назад +7

      It definitely has an ABA structure. It's a beautiful piece that uses tonal elements in a nostalgic way. It isn't avant-garde, but it does have more emphasis on texture than a traditional piece. It really is quite beautiful and maybe that's enough for a short piece.

    • @harrisonstephens1835
      @harrisonstephens1835 Год назад +1

      as an "avant garde type" I did enjoy it a lot--I understand your criticisms of it though

    • @patrickvalentino600
      @patrickvalentino600 Год назад +1

      It's also very tonal, and functionally so at that

    • @jefflpanther
      @jefflpanther 8 месяцев назад +3

      This is certainly not atonal. Your opinion that this is trash is just your opinion.

  • @stevenj9970
    @stevenj9970 3 года назад +4

    Crap played by a wonderful orchestra…

    • @claudiawoods3854
      @claudiawoods3854 2 года назад +9

      You are incorrect.

    • @stevenj9970
      @stevenj9970 2 года назад +1

      @@claudiawoods3854SI feel sorry for the musicians of that fine orchestra.....

    • @claudiawoods3854
      @claudiawoods3854 2 года назад +3

      At least we both agree that this is an excellent orchestra!!!

    • @Gregorius24
      @Gregorius24 Год назад +3

      I don’t know - I think some of this is quite ravishing - especially the opening repeated chordal figures that lead to harmonic suspensions.

    • @aronjakob1
      @aronjakob1 Год назад +1

      Personally I don’t think this orchestra has the best interpretation of the piece. You might prefer the string quartet recording