How is Russia likely to respond to the Moscow concert hall attack?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 24 мар 2024
- Following a deadly attack on a Moscow concert hall, with at least 137 killed, Russia has charged four men from Tajikistan. All appeared in court badly bruised with one falling in and out of consciousness. Daesh was quick to claim responsibility, but the Kremlin says Kiev was involved. So how is Russia likely to respond?
Guests:
Viacheslav Matuzov
Former Russian Diplomat
John E. Herbst
Senior Director at Atlantic Council’s Eurasia Center
Afzal Ashraf
Senior UK Government Adviser
Subscribe:
trt.world/subscribe
Livestream: trt.world/ytlive
Facebook: trt.world/facebook
Twitter: trt.world/twitter
Instagram: trt.world/instagram
Visit our website: trt.world
![Roddy Ricch - Survivors Remorse [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/J5IeFzr2GgE/mqdefault.jpg)
😂 war crimes against Russia what about war crimes against Bush and Blair
US..IS TOTALLY RESPONSIBLE..COMMON +$EN$E!!💯💯
If they really believe they're going to paradise, why do they look so sad in those glass cages?
Because they were tortured.
This is not about any religion.
Goes to show putin can't keep his people safe. and blaming Ukraine not good the fact the gunmen just got in and and killed so many😢 what was the so called security doing unbelievable. But it's ok putin lights a candle for the Victems but don't go to visit wow.
Because they didn't make it
It was either Ukraine or the United Snake hidden behind ISIS.
They want the Russian military to attack the Muslim population in Russia and hence civil war.
I remember after 9/11 I and my country were almost unreasonable from anger and frustration. So I understand how Russians can make connections in their minds that just aren’t there in reality. The US did that more than once. I hope reason, logic, and real evidence win out.
USA doing it now with the proxy war with Russia. Did not learn a thing. Why I also believe CIA involvement. It will take a lot to change my mind . Peace. I do agree with ya overall!
Yeah, US war in Iraq and Afghanistan flooded Europe with refugees. Your country destroyed Europe. Now we need to live in fear of terror thanks to your actions.
@loudtime265 - There will be no reason exercised. Putin will use this to shift blame away from his own failure of not taking seriously and listening to the intelligence he got from the U.S. We heard it from his own mouth. He will do everything to pin this on Ukraine and manipulate his already brainwashed and sheep like citizens with lies.
Logic should dictate that the U.S. isn't culpable for this attack. Has anyone given a reason as to what they would get out of it? The U.S. won't even allow the Ukrainians to use certain weapons that they proved to be used to strike sites inside Russia, for fear of escalating the war, but we are to believe that the U.S. is going to sponsor ISIL-K members to carry out a mass murder attack inside Russia. Only stupid people believe that.
Additionally, Ukraine has NO HISTORY of state sponsored terrorism of any kind. Besides, they would have calculated that this attack would galvanize the country in the wake of a tragedy. How does that help Ukraine? Make it make sense!!!
On top of that, ISIL-K themselves TOOK RESPONSIBILITY for the attack. Why would they put a target on their backs if they didn't do it? Obviously, Russia will retaliate. The logical answer is ISIL-K, who have many of their "brothers" in Syria and parts of African that were killed by Russian forces.
I'm sure deliberate manipulation, lies, and mass hysteria will prevail over logic and a moral response. There are so many s***y and stupid people on this planet that it's maddening.
@loudtime265 - There will be no reason exercised. Putin will use this to shift blame away from his own failure of not taking seriously and listening to the intelligence he got from the U.S. We heard it from his own mouth. He will do everything to pin this on Ukraine and manipulate his already brainwashed and sheep like citizens with lies.
Logic should dictate that the U.S. isn't culpable for this attack. Has anyone given a reason as to what they would get out of it? The U.S. won't even allow the Ukrainians to use certain weapons that they proved to be used to strike sites inside Russia, for fear of escalating the war, but we are to believe that the U.S. is going to sponsor ISIL-K members to carry out a mass murder attack inside Russia. Only stupid people believe that.
Additionally, Ukraine has NO HISTORY of state sponsored terrorism of any kind. Besides, they would have calculated that this attack would galvanize the country in the wake of a tragedy. How does that help Ukraine? Make it make sense!!!
On top of that, ISIL-K themselves TOOK RESPONSIBILITY for the attack. Why would they put a target on their backs if they didn't do it? Obviously, Russia will retaliate. The logical answer is ISIL-K, who have many of their "brothers" in Syria and parts of African that were killed by Russian forces.
I'm sure deliberate manipulation, lies, and mass hysteria will prevail over logic and a moral response. There are so many s***y and stupid people on this planet that it's maddening.
I don't believe Islamic state would do it and clamed responsibility.
It's stupid.
same like israel owned HAMAS also has been paid by USA to do it.
Actually it's 7ews israeli USA neo natzis who did it
This is exactly what happened in Israel..... young people in a concert...then chaos... kidnapping etc
The problem is that no matter what you try to do to prevent this kind of thing, complacency sets in. Police perform security on hundreds of concerts, then this happens out of the blue. Most humans cannot comprehend a human that would kill men women and children they do not even know for money.
You should understand that, this was not an unusual open area or one time stage prepared area concert, this is a huge complex building where all around the year going different type of meetings, like concerts or exhibitions etc, and never police giving security to this building, as the complex have their own security,which was shot dead by terrorist in the entrance
This complex for different events, and they have their own security, police never giving security to such buildings as you imagined.the security was killed as like common people
In Irak US killed 500 000children add Libya , Afghanistan ,Syria ,Yemen,and Somalia .All because of 911 that was a inside job .
Putin is so evil ,shame on him.
Not easy unless big players are involved
CIA need I say more?
@@jewrue7975Or FSB ,need i say more ,where was riot police ,regular police ,police in civil clothing they all gone missing?
@@Damirijus1 still convinced CIA. thanks!
There is a master mind behind these people are professional and have money to recruit
@jewrue7975 in 2002, under Putin, the Russian security forces have used a false flag to enter Chechnya, by letting off explosives in apartment blocks in the Russian cities of Buynaksk, Moscow, and Volgodonsk, killing more than 300, injuring more than 1,000, and spreading a wave of fear across the country.
The Chechens are Sunni Muslims, and the Russians massacred from 25,000 to 200,000 civilians.
How does America know attack is imminent? if they know it is imminent, then they must also know who ? what ? why ? when ?........
Why did Russia ignore the warning
The NSA knows how many squares of toilet paper you wiped your butt with this morning.
Supercomputer, satellites, optical backbone access, keywords/phrases filtered for language and accent. For starters.
Oh, also people like money. A lot.
Only 1 answer,,cause they are the master mind at this world .
Investigate CIA and UK intel carefully
They are the mind behind this plan.
The CIA WARNED Russia that terrorist attacks were imminent. They even advised to stay away from concerts. Unfortunately, they warned 3 weeks before the attack so Russia believed it was a false warning. We cannot help that they don’t take our warnings seriously!
American forces are not fighting Russia in Ukraine - what is he talking about... the USA did not declare war on Russia!
Innocent people always are the ones hurt
Yeah😔
Canada warned Moscow also
Putin will respond hard...
Go lay down by your dish.
Izrael has the right to defend themselves.....
Russia will respond massively.
According to Russian official reports, several gunmen were intercepted at about 380 kilometers on the M-3 Highway in Bryansk Oblast, at least 200 kilometers away from the Russia-Ukraine border.
How they got away 400 km ?
Why cops came after 2 hours?
How 4 person did it in 18 minutes?
Where is videos from inside the building?
What a Hello questions stupid man..do u want to see it urslef in ur country to see and believe how it happens idiot??
They shouldn’t screw around with Mr Putin. It’s like the biggest mistake ever.
Putin is miserable
@@djvan726 mr Putin, is strong, concentrate, and more serious than ever…
What the hell was that Russian talking about?
He answered zero questions.
You telling me they can't find one person in that pit that is remotely competent.
What makes a mind so sick to the point where it will kill innocent people it knows nothing about? Throughout history, only religion can do this.
That's completely false. People just say things to say them.
these men killed for money, not for god.
I pray for all the victims ...
Good excuse for politicians to increase surveillance and detain people
Matusov should have studied his FSB talking points better. What a stooge
MOSSAD/CIA/ISIS/HAMAS/ETC/ETC
Don’t discount the NSA, “the spies that lied’!?! 👎🤬
The ones behind and supporting the killers are heartless monsters
Only legitimate speaker here is the old brown man
My condolences to those lives lost
Will Russia use a nuclear bomb in response.
Can someone translate what the Russian guy said? I don’t understand Russian.
He said:
-Pyutyyn told mi to say thyyys!
You should use captions for this video😉😅
Every body is human I wish there will be peace and all country reunite.
How can you reunite with your kids killers?????😢😢😢😢😢
@@user-mn8re8jp7vby being the bigger person for global peace? If it were gaurnteed to be global peace if everyone let the past go then it would be worth it but that’s an impossibility so hate away
If their actions are inhumane they’re not “human”.
Don’t believe in this show. It’s organized by own government of Russia. How ? Simply, guys in attacked different guys with bigger body, and stronger, taller. Then there is so many cameras on their street including the hall it selfs that day they didn’t put police to stay near huge concert hall ? Normally in cheap, small out of Moscow place where I went my self standing in the mall security checking all up why ? Just in the small crowd police standing always. Before the war they always put allot of security with police .For small shows, so do u think non of cameras worked that day ? Why they put always allot security, but that day they put few? Not even one police was there why ? Why normal security number was less then normal day ? Why few days ago they Renew new insurance of that concert hall? Why the emergency police, and ambulance comes fast, but that day they came after all done ? Why their phone didn’t work inside the hall when they tried to call police ? Why they body camera of the terrorist faces is covered, but in other videos they show their faces after catching small Tajik scared emigrants ? Why they change their voice on the body camera? How that white Reno car checked on the road camera timing shows till they are on the road by that time they had to do all killing cutting necks, going up to the floors walking slowing as per video, and fire the concert hall, go change, and be on other side of city in the road close to Ukrain border ? In 15 minutes ? Don’t believe what u see as all smart Russians till now asking why they don’t show their faces ? Where are they videos of the music halls ? They stole enough Tajik guys from the street to send to Ukrain war to be killed, and people from Tajikistan landed into Russia they lock them in the room, not letting them to use toilet, and not giving them food, and water even. They got return tickets, they don’t let them fly back home why ? Coz their own people doesn’t want to go to war, most of them with dual passport running living happy life on others land, so they got use to take Tajik people into Ukrain war. They are giving them docs with supper small alphabet to sign being released, but in down other page says u are interested to go to war to fight. U guys have no idea watching this kind of videos. All this happen before choosing new president at the same time ? Before that Tajikistan president was little be rude to Russian president. Why they showing street cleaner emigrant which beat them up to say it’s them with shocking face, and his lips vibrating being scared? Why they cut one of the ears of the Guys make him to eat it to say it’s him? Why he doesn’t speak Russian, so Russian soldiers teaching what to say in the video ? Why other one in hospital half dead ? Why in the court they all drugged to not talk in shocked eyes ? Who gonna tell us the truth ? Why 3 police man wearing casual clothes siting and taking hidden videos in calm position during attack ask to close the doors instead of go to run to other doors ? Why all 3 wearing same color clothes ? Where are the real videos of the halls ? It’s shows u all coz it’s not them, but a professional soldiers of their own government. They blame Ukrain for this show, as they follow their order a day before they attack on Ukrain. No, I’m not Ukrainian. I had enough watching this crap putting those cleaner emigrants father of 4 kids, and a hair dresser 19 years old, and even they put in jail a guys who sold a car, and guy who rented the apartment. Guess what : this racist people don’t rent their apartment to emigrants, coz of that same guy from Tajikistan rented them apartment, and now his in jail also. Open ur eyes, and don’t believe directly what they tried to lie, and kill innocent people now. They didn’t care to kill more then 100 people had nothing to do with politics at all. Sorry for their lost, but don’t lie, and kill innocent emigrants who are poor came to clean ur roads to feed his 4 small kids.
Interesting what you're saying.
If true, than very sad.😢
There's so many questions from you which is what you said was right..I think it's all putin drama..
Are you mad? Breathe, please! You are full of conspiracies..😅 There's no facts on any of your statements.
There borders are more secure than ours. So what happened
NOT ISIS, smells like a Nordstream pipeline story
They admitted do it it. They confessed.
Exactly... Seems to me they're just trying to claim something that not even Al Queda were stupid enough to come Public and admit to... These guys really have no idea what they are up against..
Good newscast. But, trying to be helpful, Viatcheslav Matuzov was completely unintelligible. Him talking was no better than random word generator.
What is your second language
@@slobodankajosilo5944it is English obviously
@@slobodankajosilo5944 French. Why?
Obviously the barrier is da language, he had points to make only wish he could have stuck to speaking Russian.
Victoria nuland comments week ago explains everything 😮😮😮
Who is the beneficiary of this massacre? Just a simple question
America and NATO. They want boots on the ground. It's an excuse to escalate the war.
Not just a simple question my friend, or should I say "not a simple answer"? 😅
Islam has a religious mandate to wipe out all non believers on earth.
Ukraninas where very quick to express joy on social media but minutes later were adviced by USA to keep it down to not be pointed at.
@@FinepixF30and let me guess they listened to the us and kept it down? As if any social media people give a dam what anyone has to say and especially the us. Ukraine has every right to feel good about it. They live it every single day of their life right now for reasons that are made up of lies I myself feel bad for the Russians but I feel much much worse for Ukrainians
I am so sorry for what happened in Russia. May God help these people through their sorrow. Barbara US
.....how did the security guard had enter them without proper check...
I wouldn't be surprised if Putin went Stalin batshit crazy...
Yes, I agree. This is just another false flag of Putin.
Wo is responsible for north stream pipeline?
Who pulled my bandaid off too fast?
Napoleon..who else..
I do agree mostly with the U.S. fr ambassador but the professor in London has got a point about the NORDC pipeline… A theory is it was done by Ukraine special forces with the help of Poland intelligence.
There is nothing to be gained by either Ukraine or Poland to perform such a heinous act. Try thinking for a change.
Conspiracy theory's abound.
The oil pipeline bypass the eastern block counties. It’s always been Poland best interest to keep Russia and Germany apart…look at their history from WW2 to before the Napoleonic wars.
And it’s just a theory
Izrael has the right to defend themselves ..... Russia has the same rights ?
What proof does Putin have in saying that Ukraine has something to do with it?
Why don't you go ask him!
He doesn't. He's just putting that spin on it to get his citizens to support his failed war
What proof US had just one hour after terrorist that Ukraine was not involved.
ISUS-UK
Pootie has about as much "proof" Ukraine was involved as Trump has about the 2020 election being rigged. None.
Mr. ohn E. Herbst, How about extending condolences instead of trying to pin it on Isis so badly ? Or, offering help to find the responsible ? Best you have is to deny that the guys were paid and protect the those who are really behind and paid them.
Izrael has the right to defend themselves. US and puppets are helping Izrael to kill 30.000 innocent people. But in this case, they are even blaming Russia. How come Izrael didn't know about terrorist attack to.
Prepare to Accept Angry putin.
Put the name of host in the description BOX! Andrea Sanke is awesome! She shouldcome on daily
See Inside Russia w/ intel/video by Russian expat who had been to this theatre/ mall complex many x! ... a Russian K9 cop seen patroling calmly while concert goers are fleeing for their lives ??!
I believe that Russian Security and Intelligence did not evaluate the intelligence provided by the United States. It was stunning that Sri Lankan security had not expressed serious worry about the intelligence provided by India several weeks before the Easter Sunday attack on April 21, 2019. Finally, a few hours before the attack on 21 April 2019, Indian intelligence agencies informed SL government authorities about the obvious attack on churches and hotels, which SL responsible security forces and police did not take into account, resulting in the deaths of 271 people and injuries to over 500.
Despite the fact that security council meetings were held prior to the incident, the leaders of the three agencies and the police did not take simple precautions to prevent the attack. Despite the fact that security council meetings which President was chaired were held prior to the incident, the leaders of the three agencies and the police did not take simple precautions to prevent the attack. That was due to SL security being extremely lazy and possessing characters solely for the sake of pleasing politicians.
It was also terrible to hear about the Russian terrorist attack, even though, those who did not take security precautions must be held accountable and law enforcement should be implemented.
Even flooding you still blembing urianians
You make excellent points.
Lo sentimos mucho DESDE suecia ❤❤❤
Why is it always Us Brits to send a Non-British National?
Well, at least America tried to tell Russia, not my fault they didn’t listen
To be clear the road in the Bryansk region heads to BELARUS AND UKRAINE its a main road to Belarus. They came from the Belarus border with the car with belarus plates, Tajikistan have visa free travel with Belarus and russia. Makes sense to go back the way you came. NOT GO THROUGH A WARZONE.
Explain how it took 90 minutes for security services to arrive. The security base was five minutes away. False flag. Putler did it
Which source said that is was 90 minutes? Thanks.
Source is Ukrainian and Western propaganda. No 90 minutes to arrive. LIE. They was followed and chased all the way to near Ukrainian border by police,Speznaz, high way patrol and caught. Russians needed to know where these monsters running too, obviously to those who hired them and promised safe pass tru the border.
Police station in areal Crocus expo...... check map... weird.
Police can't handle terrorists.
How many times interviewer can say “OK”. Learn some other word to stop or interapt your giests.
Not one Russian carry a side arm to stop those guys . and if this happened in United States the u.s citizen will stop those guys
It’s a gigantic lyes
This reporter or whatever she is looks like an SNL parody of a reporter.
WHY SOMEONE KNEW SOMETHING ??? DOUBLE HEADS SNEAK 🤔
She call that turture..these are kisses on the face...you havenot seen the real coming kisses yet.
The dirty tricks of CIA
The Russian expert must speak in Russian because he is struggling to express himself. As for the American expert he is very devious in his statement and trying to accuse the Rissian security forces of staging it. This is disgusting, but not surprising.
Russia and the United States are not at war. Please correct yourself.
I can't understand him, Biden makes more sense
Это сделали ЦРУ США и Ми 6 Англия совместно с Украиной.
Agree
Possible
USA warned Russia. Why don't they put extra security on large gatherings after being warned? Russia ignored warnings
Prove it..... Of course Putin is going to blame US and Ukraine... Prove your self before saying stupid stuff...
Putin hates the west
This Russian please next time bring an interpreter 😂
Does Russia have the right to defend itself just like how Israel?
Everyone knows who's to blame but People now a days don't want the truth
How can a terrorist state blame anyone in anything. Putler is a criminal what r u even talking abt
In that sense, US,UK and many other states are terrorist too. Bush is a criminal as well, biden too
Using demeaning words to describe a popular president of Russia shows the extent of Western intellectual degeneration. and that's what comes when you ban Tolstoy, Pushkin, even Gorky!
Putin does not want another defeat in afghanistan ; eying one side of the coin only .
18:50 a hypothesis not an
US and Ukraine are responsible. Blaming ISIS is a diversion
Let the future begin................DUST!
At last flower sellers as rich
One of terrorists said while captured that he just arrived in Russia from Turkey March 4. They pretend not speak Russian at first but they did understand questions very well and speak Russian. They was caught 100 kilometers near Ukrainian border in Bryansk woods AFTER police, highway patrol literally follow and watch them from Crocus city all the way tru Bryansk region for single purpose -- to know where they are trying escape to.
America needs President Trump and President Putin to bring peace .
They’re both going to jail,sorry.
@djvan726 take another perc and go to sleep
🤮
Terrorists attack where they want to. Wasn't the U.S. a greater victim?
This civilization do not deserve peace
If you don’t believe Ukraine is not corrupt
Just do a little research it’s no innocent victim
Putin will do what ever it takes to fit his Narrative
The world is full of hypocrate. 😢 nobody stand for higher principal.
How does it feel russians
Большинство людей считают что теракт организовал сумасшедший президент
Stupid
Wait for ur turn idiot
I don't remember the warning. I remember the threat made by Victoria Nuland ☹️☹️☹️🇿🇦❤️🇷🇺
That Atlantic Council cimmentator was just another Nuland clone.
It doesn’t add up to ISIS just like how the other guy mentioned. ISIS don’t just killed and run away and made no kind of demand, they would have fought to the end.
Blame Ukraine for every attack.
I wonder who the five innocent people are that were arrested for the attack. Well I’m only guessing they are innocent but if they caught the four shooters and they are trying to blame it on Ukraine I would imagine the five others have links to Ukraine and are innocent
Zelenski he is freaked out and singing wasn’t me.
God bless you all ❤❤❤
So bias the last person to speak, is the arch enemy of Russia, the Indian guy is rational one, the Russian have the hard time to express himself
Next time bring guests on that can speak English. Thanks 👍🏾
🇷🇺👑🇷🇺💪🏻☝🏻
Putin blaming ukraine. Stupid.
The gunmen, after the attack were headed for Ukraine to get the rest of their blood money.
😂😂😂😂really
He's not stupid He's right He's always right
Blame who then?
@@JonTheChron The one arm man!
Did you ever talk about israeli terrorism?
If Pootin lips are moving he’s lying.
Putin can’t blame crank they had the information his intelligence was supposed to tell him
Easy bbc watcher, do your work b4 you have your fingers liberty to write filth 😅
How about Izrael.
Don't mess with Texas, and Dont muck with Russia.
Ukraine sends its best.
I think this is an orange from Ukraine because Ukraine is strongly supporting Pakistan.
Kyiv is involved?! LOL!
PUTIN'S STRATEGY
😘🌹❤️❣️🇭🇹 love from Haiti paradise to mother Russia condolences for the Russian people God bless you all
GANG OF FOUR IS MASTER MIND
Elon. Musk is involved in this.
Nothing for Ukraine to benefit from this. Nice word salad from the russian. He needs to take his meds. And go for a nap.
If Daesh is involved, Israeli Intelligence service is definitely involved.