Ad: 🔒 Remove your personal information from the web at joindeleteme.com/VILE and use code VILE for 20% off 🙌 DeleteMe international Plans: international.joindeleteme.com
Now as a human. And a lover of warhammer. I find what they did evil. And we should purge these filthy xenos from the cosmos… religious mission? If it wasn’t given by the emperor that sounds like heresy…. Okay jokes aside. What they did is obviously evil. But is it evil to them? They never killed people for fun. Or killed us off permanently period. Unlike the gravitals. Perhaps to them intelligence or sentience or life in general is a gift in general and to them maybe we abused this gift. Maybe they viewed our attempts at a galactic civilization like a cancer spreading in its host. So they in their own ways “fixed” us. And to those who resisted the hardest they were the ones truly punished. Now yes this is evil. But to them? Perhaps they viewed their actions not just as morally right but maybe they thought it HAS TO BE DONE…
That’s the part of all this that makes me disagree with Vile’s attempt to paint humanity and the Qu as being on the same level of morality. Nowhere in the story nor humanities actual history have we ever been offended by another sentient creature’s attempt to change the world around it, and because of this offense subjected the entire species to our will. Clearly the Qu knew we were sentient and could express consciousness, desires, and our inspiration to colonize the stars. This is what offended them to the point that they eradicated humanity as we knew it and for this the Qu are far more evil than humanity.
QU boyfriend: " of course I would my love but why would you turn yourself into such a lonely creature when you're so much more beautiful. With your black and dark in the eyes and your four wings and long tails. No other Qu could ever match your beauty. You are far more beautiful than the base yourself into a lonely humanoid descending warm. Come let us travel the Stars let's get married and then let us proceed to change these less intelligent into something more beautiful such as yourself. "
The crazy part of this story is the time jumps of ten of millions of years. Each species mentioned goes through a history as long and complex as ours, and it all just gets glossed over and we only know how they ended.
I personally love how obscure the depiction of Qu is. We don't get a descriptions of their structure or weaponry. One time, they just came along and humanity fell. Humans were able to detonate whole systems, but they still fell. It gives Qu that edge of unknowable horror. They don't "kill" you, don't "devastate", "disintegrate", "liquify" or any other thing, they, by using some abstract and unknowable means, just *make you lose.*
Plus fact that Qu are disturbingly similar to final depiction of Astermorphs and book gave no concrete final fate of humanity just that one day they just disapeared without trace.
@Akabans999 thats to imply the qu did infact destroy humanity, whole. Leaving only twisted genetic forms. The idea of "the qu are humans" is interesting, but i find it too shallow too simple and reduces the horror. We know that humans will do horrific shyt for horrific reasons. But the alien motives, alien means and alien forms of the qu is more horrific if they are that, alien.
If you read the book the Qu do not wipe out space borne humanity who later become the Asteromorphs. The Qu return after leaving the galaxy and in their hubris they had fallen behind humanity and get wiped out as revenge although it is implied some may have escaped. The Qu are definitely aliens though that much is clear and their motivation is explained as well, they see themselves as the chosen gods of reality and the only life allowed to exercise any agency or dominion over reality. They change the Star Children simply because they want to put them in their place.
I can't imagine how terrifying it must be to live in a world surrounded by countless ruins, eventually finding out that the cattle you use for food and transport are actually the mutated remnants of that great civilization which left the ruins. What cosmic, incomprehensible horror would be capable of such a deed.
We sort of can imagine it. The dinosaurs who dominated for millions of years are birds, chickens, gasoline, and potroleum. I were learning more about them all the time!
@@leomnidusofspartaidk why anyone would care? Like, its just another thing. I assure you, most people today would not think an extra thought about chickens if we found out that dumb dinos in space series was all true. Or this specific scenario. You’d get a huge “meh”. Bro, people be eatin regular old people. If an individual or culture can get used to that, this is *nothing* .
1:33:58 It's so interesting to think of the Gravitals with homes and families. I can just imagine one wearing a trilby hat and using antigravity to carry a briefcase.
I feel bad for the author, having had his entire book dissected without a penny. It's such a wonderful book. I'm glad you put a link to the book in the description man, it's a nice way to say thank you to the artist for his marvellous and horrifying art.
7:38 this is one of my favorite moments in the book. It makes an effort to explain how wars in space won’t be fast-paced and dramatic. They will be cold, methodical, and inhuman.
All Tomorrows is such an interesting work - I always interpret it as a story about humanitys obssession with control, controlling everything, from bodies, environment, technology and, eventually, each other, and how destructive this obssession is, when there are so many things better to do.
A story about what happens when you lose control of your destiny to the hands of something else. That obsession is not for show or boredom but survival and prosperity.
@The_Natalist Worst of alien life, maybe? But even then, the Qu have some stiff competition there. Dark Eldar kind of do the same thing and then some, and they do it specifically for the purpose of causing suffering.
One of the saddest parts of other tomorrow's is that the idea that humanity would only accept a united front towards progress after a preventable war that costs billions of lives and forced Eugenics is sadly very plausible
To be fair I wouldn't call Oedipal, test tube, post-human galactic colonialism "progress". The star people were already inhumane when they left mars. This is not progress, this is a consolation prize for humanity, and a privileged silver spoon for post-humans.
@SeanWinters Well… it makes sense. When your predecessor is pretty much a slow caveman compared to you, you won’t stick around with them long term, especially if you were made to be better and want better. It is what it is.
You’ve got an amazing command of language. Your videos impress me every time I watch. I know the point of these is not to simply agree with you, but your viewpoint on nearly everything you discuss is so convincing and comprehensive that I cannot help but believe that you are correct and entirely understanding of the subject.
Out of all the subhumans I like the colonials the most. The fact that they made it to the end game and managed to adapt into a space fairing species is the most hfy thing in this entire story.
I thought the Qu eventually came back, or were found, millions of years later when human variant life evolved/advanced again, and united to defeat the Qu? Been a while since I last looked into this story.
@@arthurdotson9579It's mentioned, but just like the book itself, it's just a footnote. At some point during the unified Galactic Empire of the Asteromorphs and Machines they found the Qu and destroyed them.
I’ve always been a fan of All Tomorrows, so thanks for featuring it as an episode! Hope you had a happy holidays! Also a just a thought, could a potential episode be made on either Gaunter O’Dimm from The Witcher 3, The Stranger from Carry-On, or The Flood from the Halo franchise?
I've been a big proponent of The Flood/Gravemind getting an analyzing evil for a while now! They're my favorite sci-fi villain race, their lore is so good
@@N_o196 I absolutely agree! I find their lore just so incredibly interesting and deep for what could appear as essentially space zombies, sure does show how strong the characterization of it is!
I had downloaded the pdf some months before I saw this video. I was determined to read it, but I was distracted by other affairs. When I saw the beginning of this video, I thought, "Don't I have this book?" I decided to pause the video at the start and read the 121 pages of "All Tomorrows." After I finished, I returned to your video. Thanks, Vile Eye, for rekindling my interest in this fascinating book!
Hope to see these covered some day: - Joe Cooper (Killer Joe) - Nino Brown (New Jack City) - Jake "The Muss" Heke (Once Were Warriors) - Harry Powell (Night of the Hunter) - Sigma (MegaMan X series) - Dr. X (from the Operation: Mindcrime albums by Queensrÿche)
I absolutely love All Tomorrows both the story and the art that goes with it. I find it fascinating but also disturbing with a touch of depressing. I'm looking forward to getting my physical copy.
The biggest difference between humanity and the Qu is we critique and critisize ourself constantly, it sounds as if monolithically the Qu have decided and agreed about and accepted this outcome, we dont see other qu's trying to send relief efforts
Im not sure if i missed it in this vid. The Qu did return to the milky way and were defeated by the asteromorphs. No genetic engineering this time. The astro's wiped them out as they were considered too dangerous to be kept alive.
I consider myself to have quite a strong stomach but this video actually has made me sick. The dude who wrote this book has the most macabre imagination ever.
It’s almost funny how the Qu are the spacers evolved into the threat they fear makes you wonder how many tomorrows have happened in the story to get to the point of unrecognizable life forms. It’s like the idea of greys not being alien but evolved versions of ourselves from a place we couldn’t comprehend.
imagine an archeologist unearths an ancient alien ruin, possibly older than most life on the planet, only to find hieroglyphs or texts depicting the genetic precurser to HORSES, that had apparantly ran a galactic empire, with culture, knowledge, language, religion, etc. And now, they're just horses, just mindless beasts. Thank you for sharing this awful story with us VE. I think "Off shoots" is a more fitting title in more ways than one.
The Qu are so smart and mighty that they are mad at us for treating the worm like we treat it so they made us into worms, not realizing some species out there, if they follow their own logic of morality, would do the same to them. So smart. This is why the categorical imperative of Kant is so important
And to add on why they are dumb af: They are not smart, because if they were, they would understand why we see and treat the worm like we do, they would have a notion of aesthetics, and practical reason, which would help them realize our way of thinking and behavior, for which they would not judge us
@@iraqinationalist7778 - He's not lmao, not even top 5. Read Reverend Insanity and tell my why he tortures people. Then read Blood Meridian and tell me why Judge Holden tortures people. The answer will be enough proof. Edit: For those others who don't know, Fang Yuan tortured people because it helped his progress of granting eternal life, he has a reason to kill, not because he wants to but because he has to for himself. Judge Holden on the other hand does it for fun and because there's nothing else worth more than doing, which is why he is known to be a devil.
@@reycesarcarino4653- Honestly he's a better comparison than some edgy child killer trying to get eternal life 😹 The Judge did evil for fun. Fang did evil for eternal life. Both are evil, but one is literally demonic, the other is more of edgy copy (philosophically).
The ridiculous scale of time and the insignificance of millennia-long terrestrial human differences are the real stars of this fascinating work of art.
1:11:09 what if these where the elder things from At the Mountain Of Madness? Like they found a way to travel through time and created a small colony in the Antarctic
This video was so intriguing! I am falling into the All Tomorrows rabbit hole now. I love all your videos, but I especially love when you delve into dark science fiction like this. All Tomorrows has got to be up there with I have no mouth but I must scream video. Would love to see you do more of these short stories. Thanks for all you do! Your videos make my work days feel like a breeze.
C.M. Kosemen cited Olaf Stapledon and Edward Gibbon's 'The History of the Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire' as his inspirations for 'All Tomorrows'
It’s been amazing watching this video’s thumbnail change like 4 times throughout today as I continually browse RUclips and wait for the right moment to begin watching
I've watched/listened to this 3x now. I love it, it gave me nightmares, I can't wait for the english translation book next year. Happy New Year, Vile! Appreciate ya!
As a suggestion for a future villain, I'd like to see a video about the four libertines from Pier Paolo Pasolini's "Salò: The 120 Days of Sodom," as well as the original book by the Marquis de Sade.
This is awesome, the Trinity of Absolute Evil is finally complete (The Qu from All Tomorrows, Judge Holden from Blood Meridian, and AM from I have No Mouth and I must Scream.) Here are ideas for villains that need to get Analysis Evil videos. 1. The Prophet of Truth from the Halo Series 2. Fire Lord Sozin from Avatar the Last Airbender 3. Spec Ops: The Line either Martin Walker or Colonel John Konrad. 5. Saw Gerrera from Star Wars (Granted I could see this video being part of the weekly star wars videos you've been doing? 6. Kratos from the God of War series 7. Colonel J. Wesley McCullough from The Planet of the Apes series. 8. Sentinel Prime from Transformers One 9. Megatron from Transformers One 10. Two Face from the Arkham Series (Especially with the recent entry Arkham: Shadow.) 11. The Joker from the DCAU 12. Frank Lucas from American Gangster (Denzel has now appeared twice on your channel.) 13. Queen Myrrah of the Locust Horde from Gears of War 14. Richard Prescott from Gears of War 15. Jianzhu or The False Avatar Yun from Avatar the Last Airbender (He is from the Avatar Kyoshi Novels.) 16. Emperor Shaddam IV Corrino from Dune 17. The Shang Merchants or Earth King Feishan from Avatar the Last Airbender (They are the villains from The Avatar Yangchen Novels.) 18. Aku from Samurai Jack 19. Makoto Itou from School Days anime 20. Jimmy Egan from Pride and Glory 21. Dracula from Castlevania (separate videos on the game version and the Netflix version.) 22. The Zeffo from Star Wars (Mainly the game Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order it would be nice to hear your take on the Zeffo and how they compared to the Kwa or the Rakata Empire.) 23. Agent 47 or Dr. Ort-Meyer or even Providence from the Hitman games 24. Wikus or MNU from District 9. 25. Doctor Niles Samson from Gears of War (In case you don't know he is the creator of The Locust Horde.)
@@SearcherRyan Totally agreed even though the gameplay from Codename 47 doesn't age well. I think the story from that first game including Dr. Ort-Meyer was great. Considering not only he was funded by Providence (at least according to the Modern Hitman Trilogy.) but also he is the creator of agent 47 and the main father of the five. The Agent 47 Birth of the Hitman comics did a great job covering this backstory. Ultimately even if the first game may not age well I still think Dr Ort-Meyer is a great villain in the Lore of Hitman considering it was his actions that lead to everything that we see in the game. If the video is mainly focus Agent 47 then it would be interested considering the whole debate of whatever or not his victims deserve to die like what ones that are justified (for an example the Meat King from Hitman Contracts and Dr Ort-Meyer from the first game.) I think the ambiguity of 47 really shines in Hitman Contracts a lot in which I considered that game to be the darkest and the best in the series. If they want to do a third hitman film If I was the producer and director of the project I would rather adapted Hitman Contracts (for the first half of the movie when he is injuried.) and Codename 47 (Ending with the death of Dr Ort-Meyer.) or Blood Money (mostly for the final mission and ending.) as the second half.
Seems like a loop. The Qu seem like super evolved humans which ruined other lifeforms and was killed by those ruined lifeforms, which they forgot were their ancestors. The machines did the same. Each acting like zealots.
Ad: 🔒 Remove your personal information from the web at joindeleteme.com/VILE and use code VILE for 20% off 🙌 DeleteMe international Plans: international.joindeleteme.com
Can you do Bondrewd, The Lord of Dawn, Please?🙏🙏🙏
Could you make a video on char from the gundam franchise
Thanks For another long video! Please consider covering Christopher moltisanti!
Hey Vile, I haven't seen the full video but I saw a comment mentioning that you said Koseman was pedo. Can you show the source, is this true?
The Vile Eye Can you please do Analyzing Evil Video on The Cybermen From doctor who
the idea of the aliens being offended on a religious level at another species attempting to terraform planets is all too believable.
Now as a human. And a lover of warhammer. I find what they did evil. And we should purge these filthy xenos from the cosmos… religious mission? If it wasn’t given by the emperor that sounds like heresy….
Okay jokes aside. What they did is obviously evil. But is it evil to them? They never killed people for fun. Or killed us off permanently period. Unlike the gravitals. Perhaps to them intelligence or sentience or life in general is a gift in general and to them maybe we abused this gift. Maybe they viewed our attempts at a galactic civilization like a cancer spreading in its host. So they in their own ways “fixed” us. And to those who resisted the hardest they were the ones truly punished. Now yes this is evil. But to them? Perhaps they viewed their actions not just as morally right but maybe they thought it HAS TO BE DONE…
Not only that. We can never theoretically apply the concept of religion or morals around as rule - most religions are young.
@@magnuskallasCosmically I guess.
None are millions of years old.
Most a few thousand or ten thousand.
Halo music inserted here
That’s the part of all this that makes me disagree with Vile’s attempt to paint humanity and the Qu as being on the same level of morality. Nowhere in the story nor humanities actual history have we ever been offended by another sentient creature’s attempt to change the world around it, and because of this offense subjected the entire species to our will. Clearly the Qu knew we were sentient and could express consciousness, desires, and our inspiration to colonize the stars. This is what offended them to the point that they eradicated humanity as we knew it and for this the Qu are far more evil than humanity.
Qu Girlfriend: "Would you still love me if I was a hideously grotesque humanoid-descended Worm?"
Lol, your pfp makes it seem like a tool breeder wrote this comment. I guess that revolver is just one of the many tools.
QU boyfriend: " of course I would my love but why would you turn yourself into such a lonely creature when you're so much more beautiful. With your black and dark in the eyes and your four wings and long tails. No other Qu could ever match your beauty. You are far more beautiful than the base yourself into a lonely humanoid descending warm. Come let us travel the Stars let's get married and then let us proceed to change these less intelligent into something more beautiful such as yourself. "
@@wolfbane7497Qu father: I am going to turn you into a shit eating quilt-work patch of flesh, get away from my daughter immediately
Qu Boyfriend: "Good question. Let's try it out!"
We all know @VileEye CACKLED with this one 😂😂😂
The crazy part of this story is the time jumps of ten of millions of years. Each species mentioned goes through a history as long and complex as ours, and it all just gets glossed over and we only know how they ended.
They even had their own memes
@МиколаГарасимчук And their own furries.
@МиколаГарасимчук Memes, the DNA of the soul
The whole "turning people into sentient bricks for their sewer system" is so cartoonishly evil
so why does it unsettle me so much?
I think the main reason that the colonials are so disturbing is that their forms are especially suited to survival and reproduction
Being forced to eat poo is a special kind of torture.
Most other branches of humanity had to re-evolve sentience over time only for most of them to be wiped out in the end.
Yeah it's a real *SHITY* situation.
Because it's true... and you thought it wasnt.
I personally love how obscure the depiction of Qu is. We don't get a descriptions of their structure or weaponry. One time, they just came along and humanity fell. Humans were able to detonate whole systems, but they still fell. It gives Qu that edge of unknowable horror. They don't "kill" you, don't "devastate", "disintegrate", "liquify" or any other thing, they, by using some abstract and unknowable means, just *make you lose.*
Plus fact that Qu are disturbingly similar to final depiction of Astermorphs and book gave no concrete final fate of humanity just that one day they just disapeared without trace.
@Akabans999 thats to imply the qu did infact destroy humanity, whole.
Leaving only twisted genetic forms.
The idea of "the qu are humans" is interesting, but i find it too shallow too simple and reduces the horror.
We know that humans will do horrific shyt for horrific reasons.
But the alien motives, alien means and alien forms of the qu is more horrific if they are that, alien.
If you read the book the Qu do not wipe out space borne humanity who later become the Asteromorphs. The Qu return after leaving the galaxy and in their hubris they had fallen behind humanity and get wiped out as revenge although it is implied some may have escaped. The Qu are definitely aliens though that much is clear and their motivation is explained as well, they see themselves as the chosen gods of reality and the only life allowed to exercise any agency or dominion over reality. They change the Star Children simply because they want to put them in their place.
Like Cthulhu from Lovecraft's works or even the Reapers from the Mass Effect game universe. It's a concept in narrative writing I also enjoy a lot.
[star guy cowering in corner, a dead or dying species' rattmann] "we lost man"
"how the hell did you lose"
"WE FUCKING LOST"
I can't imagine how terrifying it must be to live in a world surrounded by countless ruins, eventually finding out that the cattle you use for food and transport are actually the mutated remnants of that great civilization which left the ruins. What cosmic, incomprehensible horror would be capable of such a deed.
We sort of can imagine it. The dinosaurs who dominated for millions of years are birds, chickens, gasoline, and potroleum. I were learning more about them all the time!
...like the dollar tree just before closing...
@@johnstarks7759sure but dinosaurs didn’t make skyscrapers or travel the stars. They were just animals. It truly is unimaginable for us
@@leomnidusofspartaidk why anyone would care? Like, its just another thing. I assure you, most people today would not think an extra thought about chickens if we found out that dumb dinos in space series was all true. Or this specific scenario. You’d get a huge “meh”.
Bro, people be eatin regular old people. If an individual or culture can get used to that, this is *nothing* .
@@kMegalonyxwhat are you blabbering about
1:33:58 It's so interesting to think of the Gravitals with homes and families. I can just imagine one wearing a trilby hat and using antigravity to carry a briefcase.
“Honey? I’m hooooome!”
"Balltington Jr, stop bringing all those stray Subjects into the house!"
Literally the exact same thing I imagined when he said that lol
I don't think Qu can be described as non-moral, as they clearly experiment for their own entertainment than for some greater cause.
Then again their alien beings
@miguelatkinson Implying?
They just be Chaotic Evil, and high Wisdom. That's a hard concept, but if you can understand that, it's a bit scary.
Then you add "omnipotent"
@@archmage_of_the_aether Indeed, hence they are morally repugnant and evil.
they think they are gods. and should control the universe
the triforce is now complete. Judge Holden, Am, and now The Qu
The qu?
@tempcam2024 Fang yuan from reverend insanity is better than all three combined
@@iraqinationalist7778 O'brein from 1984 is better than all four combined
My thoughts exactly lol
Erebus from Warhammer 40K is more evil than these three
Colonials really went from "I'm a miserable brick that watch suffering happens" into "GOGO POWER RANGER!"
This has been one of my favorite stories ever, so glad you made a video about it, and 2 hours? You're spoiling us too much
True...
Yah... this is like a Christmas present from Vile Eye
I feel bad for the author, having had his entire book dissected without a penny. It's such a wonderful book.
I'm glad you put a link to the book in the description man, it's a nice way to say thank you to the artist for his marvellous and horrifying art.
He is currently writing a full novelized version that he's probably going to sell, so he'll probably recoup a lot on that.
He has a insects named after him
@@freddyswI’d rather have a million dollars
He made no money from All tommorrow copies?! It came out decades ago 😂
@@Ex4lted_ He released it for free online. It's never cost money or been released physically.
7:38 this is one of my favorite moments in the book. It makes an effort to explain how wars in space won’t be fast-paced and dramatic. They will be cold, methodical, and inhuman.
I love this sci-fi lore, one of the greatest piece of fiction.
I wish I could write like this. Hearing an oral history of humanity spanning half a billion years in such a short video is wild.
You and be both, bud. 😅
i always loved how despite all the misery and horrors, all tomorrows in the end is always a story about hope
All Tomorrows is such an interesting work - I always interpret it as a story about humanitys obssession with control, controlling everything, from bodies, environment, technology and, eventually, each other, and how destructive this obssession is, when there are so many things better to do.
👍
Suggestions on something better to do?
A story about what happens when you lose control of your destiny to the hands of something else. That obsession is not for show or boredom but survival and prosperity.
@ObsidianFane
Video games. Control without consequences (it’s fun).
The Most Evil Trio
Judge Holden: Worst of Humanity
AM: Worst of Technology
QU: Worst of Nature
Happy Holidays Vile Eye ❤️💙💚🎁🎄❄️☃️🦌
This is the most unrated comment I've seen the first one at it too
The Qu... nature? Idk. I see the Hiteks from man after man as similar, and they are "human"
@The_Natalist
Worst of alien life, maybe?
But even then, the Qu have some stiff competition there. Dark Eldar kind of do the same thing and then some, and they do it specifically for the purpose of causing suffering.
qu would be worst of genetic modification or evolution. even of space. but nature... not so much
@pheonixgray6078 Wow, that actually worked
Thank you for all your Analyzing Evil videos in 2024 and we all look forward to what you will have for us in the New Year. 👍🏻
An "Analyzing Evil" video on Eric Cartman from South Park sounds interesting no joke
Honestly that would take forever because he would have to watch every episode of the show that has Eric in it
But I definitely would like to see it
ANALYZING EVIL 😈: GEORGE COSTANZA FROM SEINFELD
the most vile and horrific character ever conceived
3hr video minimum
Unironically.
Ted Danson from Curb Your Enthusiasm
Dude…
One of the saddest parts of other tomorrow's is that the idea that humanity would only accept a united front towards progress after a preventable war that costs billions of lives and forced Eugenics is sadly very plausible
Global Unity is dangerous and evil. Sad? It's sad they ever fell to such depravity.
To be fair I wouldn't call Oedipal, test tube, post-human galactic colonialism "progress". The star people were already inhumane when they left mars.
This is not progress, this is a consolation prize for humanity, and a privileged silver spoon for post-humans.
@@SeanWintersuhhhh huh. For sure.
@SeanWinters Well… it makes sense. When your predecessor is pretty much a slow caveman compared to you, you won’t stick around with them long term, especially if you were made to be better and want better. It is what it is.
@@SeanWinters
???????
You’ve got an amazing command of language. Your videos impress me every time I watch. I know the point of these is not to simply agree with you, but your viewpoint on nearly everything you discuss is so convincing and comprehensive that I cannot help but believe that you are correct and entirely understanding of the subject.
Out of all the subhumans I like the colonials the most. The fact that they made it to the end game and managed to adapt into a space fairing species is the most hfy thing in this entire story.
Analysing evil : Bondrewd from Made in Abyss.
I thought the Qu eventually came back, or were found, millions of years later when human variant life evolved/advanced again, and united to defeat the Qu? Been a while since I last looked into this story.
That indeed happened
@@killianzarate4682 Didn't catch that mentioned in this video though. Am I right, or did I just miss it?
@@arthurdotson9579 1:50:18 Mentioned here
@@arthurdotson9579It's mentioned, but just like the book itself, it's just a footnote. At some point during the unified Galactic Empire of the Asteromorphs and Machines they found the Qu and destroyed them.
@arthurdotson9579 he definitely mentioned it. I listened to this 3 times before I got it all.
I’ve always been a fan of All Tomorrows, so thanks for featuring it as an episode! Hope you had a happy holidays! Also a just a thought, could a potential episode be made on either Gaunter O’Dimm from The Witcher 3, The Stranger from Carry-On, or The Flood from the Halo franchise?
i second Gaunter, tho a short vid it would be. Not much known abt him
@ heck yeah! Are there any other characters in The Witcher universe that would be a good villain in need of an analysis?
I've been a big proponent of The Flood/Gravemind getting an analyzing evil for a while now! They're my favorite sci-fi villain race, their lore is so good
@@N_o196 I absolutely agree! I find their lore just so incredibly interesting and deep for what could appear as essentially space zombies, sure does show how strong the characterization of it is!
gaunter would be awesome
You NEED to cover the Emperor of Mankind and Erebus from Warhammer 40K.
Strike while the iron is hot
YES YES YES
PLEASE
It is really hard to find any faction in 40k that doesn't belong on this channel.
The horror of this story actually gets pretty close to Wh40k
The Emperor isn’t evil, though.
What up evil eye. I was just finishing the judge Holden vídeo, refresh the page and see this full feature movie. Lets go
I literally said "Oh hell yeah" when I saw the tittle. I love All Tomorrows.
I just got into All Tomorrows yesterday, and i’m a fan of this channel so this was a nice surprise
"Oh he will yeah"
Autocorrect and lack of proofreading massacred that sentence.
So what im hearing is that, even under the threat of nearly God-like beings, we will just Git Gud?
Ballin.
The Moral really is "Humanity will always find a way"
It's beautiful in a really sad way.
@@DsTslylee But we didn't...
Mr Vile, please continue the longer content, I was absolutely amazed at how well you retold the story!!
I think Gwyn from the Dark Souls series would be an amazing addition to the series
I have waited for so long for this video. Gonna make this video my saturday movie. Thank you for that man
I had downloaded the pdf some months before I saw this video. I was determined to read it, but I was distracted by other affairs. When I saw the beginning of this video, I thought, "Don't I have this book?" I decided to pause the video at the start and read the 121 pages of "All Tomorrows." After I finished, I returned to your video. Thanks, Vile Eye, for rekindling my interest in this fascinating book!
Hope to see these covered some day:
- Joe Cooper (Killer Joe)
- Nino Brown (New Jack City)
- Jake "The Muss" Heke (Once Were Warriors)
- Harry Powell (Night of the Hunter)
- Sigma (MegaMan X series)
- Dr. X (from the Operation: Mindcrime albums by Queensrÿche)
Jake "The Muss"! So cool you mention him. Haven't seen those movies in twenty years or more. Gonna have to watch them now.
Operation: Mindcrime would be a cool thing to see him cover, but I don't think he's covered any music yet on his channel.
@@noblemile it’d be cool if he did it for the first time. Operation Mindcrime or Pink Floyd’s The Wall would both be great choices for music subjects
I don’t think Dr. X from Operation Mindcrime is necessary but I do love Queensryche so I’d be excited to see it anyway.
@@noblemilehe’s been asked about it and I think he said he’s not opposed to it.
the internet's rotted my brain beyond comprehension, i audibly laughed at "published as a .pdf file"
I absolutely love All Tomorrows both the story and the art that goes with it. I find it fascinating but also disturbing with a touch of depressing. I'm looking forward to getting my physical copy.
Analyzing Evil about all tomorrows? Exactly what I didn’t know I was missing.
The biggest difference between humanity and the Qu is we critique and critisize ourself constantly, it sounds as if monolithically the Qu have decided and agreed about and accepted this outcome, we dont see other qu's trying to send relief efforts
Two hours!?
Hoo-boy. Strap in, friendos. We're going on quite the journey today.
lmao F R I E N D O S
soy
This is ai slop
Resquest: analyzing evil: the skeksis species from the Dark Crystal
I second this!
Yessss that'll be a......"interesting"episode
Beautiful. I've been following your channel for a few years now and this was the best
Indeed. This is probably the longest of his videos, I was held captive in the telling without pause
Im not sure if i missed it in this vid. The Qu did return to the milky way and were defeated by the asteromorphs. No genetic engineering this time. The astro's wiped them out as they were considered too dangerous to be kept alive.
He didn't mention it unfortunately
Speculative science fiction it’s always the best, thank your these amazing two hours of truly amazing stories
Hearing "as a pdf file" hits way different today 💀
yea because people are scared to say the actual word for fear of loss of monetization (understandable) or otherwise.
I don't get it??
@@MattiasSvanberg1987say it slow baby girl you got this
Not if you just say the damn word and don't give a pet name
@@MattiasSvanberg1987 RUclipsrs say "pdf file" instead of "pedophile" or "corn" instead of "porn" to prevent their videos from getting age restricted
My favorite book! I discovered All Tomorrows years before it got popular, and C.M. Koseman is awesome and has really good videos on yt
This is a terrifying look at something so grotesque.
Clyde Shelton “LAW ABIDING CITIZEN” pls!
Also is NICK RICE evil as well?
I consider myself to have quite a strong stomach but this video actually has made me sick. The dude who wrote this book has the most macabre imagination ever.
It’s almost funny how the Qu are the spacers evolved into the threat they fear makes you wonder how many tomorrows have happened in the story to get to the point of unrecognizable life forms. It’s like the idea of greys not being alien but evolved versions of ourselves from a place we couldn’t comprehend.
1:57:21 ngl i actually got teared eyed at thei final quote
Its very poetic
imagine an archeologist unearths an ancient alien ruin, possibly older than most life on the planet, only to find hieroglyphs or texts depicting the genetic precurser to HORSES, that had apparantly ran a galactic empire, with culture, knowledge, language, religion, etc.
And now, they're just horses, just mindless beasts. Thank you for sharing this awful story with us VE. I think "Off shoots" is a more fitting title in more ways than one.
The Qu are so smart and mighty that they are mad at us for treating the worm like we treat it so they made us into worms, not realizing some species out there, if they follow their own logic of morality, would do the same to them. So smart. This is why the categorical imperative of Kant is so important
And to add on why they are dumb af: They are not smart, because if they were, they would understand why we see and treat the worm like we do, they would have a notion of aesthetics, and practical reason, which would help them realize our way of thinking and behavior, for which they would not judge us
The qu are arrogant
Where arogant*
and here I thought that “I have no mouth and I must scream” broke me but this gave me a whole new existential dread 😂 good job Mr. Vile Eye
You should do some analog horrors like the Mandela Catalogue, the Monument Mythos and the Painter next.
Ohhhhh that'll be good I personally want the Mandela catalog all of the biblical references and stuff will be cool to hear from him
Thank you for covering this piece of media, its amazing to see how far you have come from 10k subs, Just know you content is appreciated.
Look Tomar, it's you!
What? No way.
"What? No it's not."
What da hell is a Roach Dogg doing all up in my Tomorrows?!?
Spa get tie
"Hey Tomar, what would you do if the Qu offered to change you and Jaxxy into any of the creatures they've made."
Just wanted to say this channel is great. Thank you for putting time and effort into high quality videos
It's a dark day when Warhammer 40k has a more hopeful future for humanity
We need "Analyzing Evil: Kevin McAllister"
Vile Eye has finally completed The Unholy Trinity of Pure Evil
1)Judge Holden
2)AM
3)The Qu
Happy Holidays Vile Eye 🎄
Fang yuan from reverend insanity is better than all three combined
@@iraqinationalist7778 - He's not lmao, not even top 5. Read Reverend Insanity and tell my why he tortures people. Then read Blood Meridian and tell me why Judge Holden tortures people. The answer will be enough proof.
Edit: For those others who don't know, Fang Yuan tortured people because it helped his progress of granting eternal life, he has a reason to kill, not because he wants to but because he has to for himself. Judge Holden on the other hand does it for fun and because there's nothing else worth more than doing, which is why he is known to be a devil.
What about Bill Cipher
@@iraqinationalist7778 - Glazed. He has a reason to do evil, Holden and QU did not.
@@reycesarcarino4653- Honestly he's a better comparison than some edgy child killer trying to get eternal life 😹
The Judge did evil for fun. Fang did evil for eternal life. Both are evil, but one is literally demonic, the other is more of edgy copy (philosophically).
This may be your best video yet, nice job!
I agree. Nothing on RUclips is quite like this. I hope you have continued success despite RUclipss obstacles.
The Asymmetric People also regreted having exterminated their parent species, which shows how human they really were.
How The Vile Eye starts a video in December 2024
*F O R E P L A Y*
I watched too many videos on All Tomorrows and dreamt the Qu turned me into a living toaster, forced to make toast for the Qu canteen.
Wow absolutely amazing, the platform dosnt deserve someone like you giving us quality content like this, keep it up vile!!
It's a good channel, it's too bad about all the AI though
@archmage_of_the_aether this channel use ai?
The ridiculous scale of time and the insignificance of millennia-long terrestrial human differences are the real stars of this fascinating work of art.
1:11:09 what if these where the elder things from At the Mountain Of Madness? Like they found a way to travel through time and created a small colony in the Antarctic
27:47 The only time ot makes sense for your girl to ask you "would you love me if I was a worm?"
Omg no way I’ve been binging these all tomorrow videos and my fav RUclipsr makes a video ?????!!?!!!
This video was so intriguing! I am falling into the All Tomorrows rabbit hole now. I love all your videos, but I especially love when you delve into dark science fiction like this. All Tomorrows has got to be up there with I have no mouth but I must scream video. Would love to see you do more of these short stories. Thanks for all you do! Your videos make my work days feel like a breeze.
'All Tomorrows' seems quite a lot like 'Last and First Men' by Olaf Stapledon!
C.M. Kosemen cited Olaf Stapledon and Edward Gibbon's 'The History of the Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire' as his inspirations for 'All Tomorrows'
It’s been amazing watching this video’s thumbnail change like 4 times throughout today as I continually browse RUclips and wait for the right moment to begin watching
"The Indomitable Human Spirit" basically, All Tomorrows
I've watched/listened to this 3x now. I love it, it gave me nightmares, I can't wait for the english translation book next year. Happy New Year, Vile! Appreciate ya!
You actually covered the most evil trio!
As a suggestion for a future villain, I'd like to see a video about the four libertines from Pier Paolo Pasolini's "Salò: The 120 Days of Sodom," as well as the original book by the Marquis de Sade.
The crossover I’ve been waiting for bro
This is genuinely one of the most interesting sci-fi stories I have ever heard. Definitely going to check out an audio book of this at some point.
Day 1 of asking analyzing evil jadis the white witch from narnia
Thank you for sharing this incredible story. I had no idea it existed until now. Much love.
46:32 "Monstrous as they looked, these ex men thrived-"
X-MEN MENTIONED RAHHH GUITAR RIFF
TO ME, MY SEX MEN
No way bro covered one of my fav books
This is awesome, the Trinity of Absolute Evil is finally complete (The Qu from All Tomorrows, Judge Holden from Blood Meridian, and AM from I have No Mouth and I must Scream.)
Here are ideas for villains that need to get Analysis Evil videos.
1. The Prophet of Truth from the Halo Series
2. Fire Lord Sozin from Avatar the Last Airbender
3. Spec Ops: The Line either Martin Walker or Colonel John Konrad.
5. Saw Gerrera from Star Wars (Granted I could see this video being part of the weekly star wars videos you've been doing?
6. Kratos from the God of War series
7. Colonel J. Wesley McCullough from The Planet of the Apes series.
8. Sentinel Prime from Transformers One
9. Megatron from Transformers One
10. Two Face from the Arkham Series (Especially with the recent entry Arkham: Shadow.)
11. The Joker from the DCAU
12. Frank Lucas from American Gangster (Denzel has now appeared twice on your channel.)
13. Queen Myrrah of the Locust Horde from Gears of War
14. Richard Prescott from Gears of War
15. Jianzhu or The False Avatar Yun from Avatar the Last Airbender (He is from the Avatar Kyoshi Novels.)
16. Emperor Shaddam IV Corrino from Dune
17. The Shang Merchants or Earth King Feishan from Avatar the Last Airbender (They are the villains from The Avatar Yangchen Novels.)
18. Aku from Samurai Jack
19. Makoto Itou from School Days anime
20. Jimmy Egan from Pride and Glory
21. Dracula from Castlevania (separate videos on the game version and the Netflix version.)
22. The Zeffo from Star Wars (Mainly the game Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order it would be nice to hear your take on the Zeffo and how they compared to the Kwa or the Rakata Empire.)
23. Agent 47 or Dr. Ort-Meyer or even Providence from the Hitman games
24. Wikus or MNU from District 9.
25. Doctor Niles Samson from Gears of War (In case you don't know he is the creator of The Locust Horde.)
Friedhelm Winter from Generation War
I really want to see 23
@@SearcherRyan Totally agreed even though the gameplay from Codename 47 doesn't age well. I think the story from that first game including Dr. Ort-Meyer was great. Considering not only he was funded by Providence (at least according to the Modern Hitman Trilogy.) but also he is the creator of agent 47 and the main father of the five. The Agent 47 Birth of the Hitman comics did a great job covering this backstory. Ultimately even if the first game may not age well I still think Dr Ort-Meyer is a great villain in the Lore of Hitman considering it was his actions that lead to everything that we see in the game.
If the video is mainly focus Agent 47 then it would be interested considering the whole debate of whatever or not his victims deserve to die like what ones that are justified (for an example the Meat King from Hitman Contracts and Dr Ort-Meyer from the first game.) I think the ambiguity of 47 really shines in Hitman Contracts a lot in which I considered that game to be the darkest and the best in the series.
If they want to do a third hitman film If I was the producer and director of the project I would rather adapted Hitman Contracts (for the first half of the movie when he is injuried.) and Codename 47 (Ending with the death of Dr Ort-Meyer.) or Blood Money (mostly for the final mission and ending.) as the second half.
HiTeks from _Man after Man_
why does everyone keep posting the same three?
Glad this fandom still gets attention it deserves
Analyzing Evil: Beetlejuice
you deserve 1 million+ subs. idk how you havent reached that point yet, your drive and dedication enough is deserving
Day 58 of asking you to please make a video analyzing leo kasper/daniel lamb/the project from the game manhunt 2.
U have to be a paying patreon member to have ur suggestions taken into account
It doesn’t hurt to keep posting your request here. Patreon members may see it and agree with you.
@@drp1bb856 i dont make the rules, itz just what he does
Great game, but they made it obvious way too early that Leo Casper wasn't real
@@TheRealBatCave I never said you did.
Need a video on John Smith from Man in the High Castle.
Huh, i never even thought about the Qu in an analyzing evil context. Super cool video man happy holidays
Great Video, All Tomorrow's is a Classic
You’re literally the coolest dude on the planet, thank you for taking your time with this!
analysing evil: the characters and themes from chernobyl, or the umbrella corporation from resident evil, or vergil from devil may cry
Amazing stuff! Your channel has grown so much it's actually inspiring. Keep it up!
Day 3 of asking for analyzing evil: Teddy McDonald: snowfall
its so cool that the asteromorphs not only mirror the qu in their actions but also in their look
Seems like a loop. The Qu seem like super evolved humans which ruined other lifeforms and was killed by those ruined lifeforms, which they forgot were their ancestors. The machines did the same. Each acting like zealots.
Bonus points if time travel
Awesome! Love this world. Thanks to you and Alt Shift X for deep diving into it for us