Can AFSPA be removed from regions where insurgency has come under control?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 9 фев 2025
- On Hum Log, we talk about the hunger strike of Irom Sharmila, the reason for her agitation and the recent incident where she was re-arrested for going on a hunger strike after being released from jail. A panel of experts and politicians explain why AFSPA is essential in certain troubled areas of north-east India and also whether it is possible to slowly phase out the act by removing it from areas where insurgency has been brought under control. (Audio in Hindi)
Watch full show: www.ndtv.com/vi...
India govt must know this "Without Manipur state India does not shine in the world" I say proudly,,,,,
u can say this for every state of india
binalakshmi negram words is great it is not a fault because our north east regions want to peace or unity with each others we do not want to conflict among the country.only Indian politicial leaders are doing wrong. ur great binalakshmi. God will with you.
Good message & clear info to public by brother Bablu Loitongbam...thanks bro
Removed AFSPA from Manipur also from Our other states
Poknapham news
Manipur deserves freedom!
nah balochistan want freedom
James Bond Returns Baluchistan is legal part of Pakistan I don't know Manipur or else but I know Jammu Kashmir international recognized disputed territory
Not being an Indian just keep your mouth shut don't poke your nose into the matters of pure concern.
The only possible solution is to make the state police more strong. The State Police should be trained like the Paramilitary Police forces because without proper training the Terrorists forces will take over Kashmir and the Maosists forces will take over Manipur . We already have an example of Grey Hounds force of Andhra Pradesh, this force was very successful against the naxals. A similar kind of force should be given to the Kashmir region , if the Indian Army feels that it is ready to move from Kashmir. We cannot forget that Pakistan is fighting a proxy war against us because it isn't possible for Pakistan Armed Forces to defeat India in straight Conventional war. The situation in which both the Kashmiris and the Manipuris are living is not good because the Army is not trained to handle any kind of civilian behaviour, these men and women are trained to fight and win wars at all costs and this is their psychology , embedded in in during their training. It is difficult for Army personnel to handle the civilian population with some rage against them because they're trained for evacuation of civilians and then fight war but the scenario in places like Kashmir and Manipur is entirely different but it doesn't makes the crime committed by any Solider or Officer of either the Army or the Para military justified and those who're guilty must be punished.
SHUBHAM KUMAR but is Jammu Kashmir till not rapist forces punished the basic reason of anger and freedom fighting of local people
So they'll kill More civilian?
ऐसे छोटी-छोटी राज्य के अल्पसंख्यक लोगों को भारत सरकार ने दबा के रख दिया
u cant feel the pain of others, if u really want to feel the pain of our, come n stay in northeast
But whats the solution?
@@AdhirajGupte ask the one who insisted us to assimilate with mainland.
@@AdhirajGupte well the most apparent is to bring reform in north east,get diplomatic solutions and try to listen to their demands.
For centuries north east has been a mess.If we can actyslly make the north east population feel more welcomed and Indian then there will be no reason to insurgencies.
All north east people want is no neglect to them as Indians,no corruption
I stay in assam
Dear Indian leaders, I want you to remember that Your greatest leader Mahatma Gandhi brought independence to India from the British rule through non violence!!How do you expect a country to be in peace with guns on doorsteps of citizens!!Don't forget to realise that The north east regions of India was forcefully taken control by the Indian government!! The insurgents are there to fight The 300000 Indian soldiers attacking their homes!! Take back your army and North east will find peace!!
no It was subash chandra bose who gave freedom not gandhi
Either surrender to Indian army or suffer
India got independent due to netaji subhash Chandra bose nt bcz of ur chutiya lodu gandhii
You came from China to take away our land.
jonah Meiphok great answer
only manipuri will know the pain....because its not mainland indian who have sufferd its us and us alone...and i feel very sorry for some sick mindset indian who are implacable...
+dranzer gigs dude, he said 'mainland indian', and 'some sick-minded indian', he means there are some indians in the fringes of the mainland, who have felt the pain he's talking about, and are not sick-minded!! Probably you are.... Peace!!
We are sorry but we youth of india with northeast brothers
Bina Lakshmi na is bonkna wala kutta ko iska awkat dekhaya...love u Bina from Kargil India
Opinions on AFSPA to be taken by central govt considering the threat scenerio and investigations on abuses by army. Civilians must realise that army is working on low intensity conflict and not in full force thats why insurgency is persisting (Atleast no more insurgent grps have fromed after afspa) Just bcoz of no political will of politicians. Army has to working on thin line there and susceptible to casualties (since they are not operating on full force) . You have to give them some protection against guerilla and insurgency type warfare, else their morale will go down and they will not be able to take action againsts these grps infact they will be more prone to damages. When fighting such wars AFSPA is required to prevent army undergoing collateral damages and to keep up the morale(they are also our brothers and are not there to die ). If any abuse of AFSPA are there that has to dealt with swiftly. If at all AFSPA is to be removed it has to be slowly and taking all stake holders in confidence.
WeIl said, people just cry for their state and people, nobody thinks of Armed Forces and Country. An open minded comment by you
chanakya80 ooohoo ur forces killed fake encounter on one challenge them forces PR kanon civilian s sakt hona chahe that is it
Regards always Binalaxmi Nepram Ma'am...I support you always
Gen. Bakshi is batshit crazy!
Sambit expression at 4:17 is 🤣🤣
aspha different matter, any act or law becomes evil if practiced wrongly. why treating Irom Sharmila like that, thats so inhumane.
If you have insurgency you need to put AFSPA, is that compulsory? Many countries have insurgency did they put AFSPA? Can you name Where in the world which do not have insurgency problem
60 years of AFSPA in naga's land
I would like to drop a question to our experts that before AFSPA 1958 how many insurgency group in Manipur and after this Act how much insurgency group has formed? if its formed why? is it the responsible of AFSPA 1958?
+laikhuram momo Meitei Well,its not sorted problems,that's for sure.
Ise kehte hain anchoring! I'm a big fan of yours madam!
General sahab get angry very fast
AFSPA jaruri hey. Jabtak ek ek atankwadi khatam nei hota humara region sey tabtak ye act rehna chahiye. As a north eastern I feel safe under this act. I don't want IROM or any activist to decide the safety and security of my country. G.D Bakshi sab love you...
Let us kill your loved 1s then you will understand
irom lost in manipur!
Okay we will agree but one condition if government of India will remove the indian army we NE people remove it, if not NE people will never
Because indian government is keeping for internal security guard like wise we NE also keeping for protection of our Motherland.
Konalim.
Eche Binalaxmi na Ema leibak pu nungsibgi faoriba ethil se eikhoi pumnmkta faoba ngmba oirsnu... you can see her angerness towards truth & love of people.
gen bakshi you are old control your emotion blood pressure beware.we are all indians discussing democratically.
remove from Assam my motherland
Which is in India
@@Garuddd there is nothing "in India" lol.India is a union of states which have signed accession.India is the collective name to all the states.
When will remove this act? How long people will have to live with fear and dead? How many more people have die more by our people manipur?
"My country vs Our country "
There's huge different. "Our country" this is enough no need to argue with this old rage stup#@ man.
Well said binalakshmi👍
North east b india me hai , ye jaan Lo.... India sirf Tera baap ka nahi hai..... Assam meghalaya Arunachal Pradesh manipur Nagaland Tripura sikkim ye sab b India hai....... Study kiya nahi kya KAbhi?
armed forces special power act cannot remove from the Kashmir valley if it removed 26/11 attacks happened every day.
We are speaking about manipur - life is not kashmir all the time
8000 log gayab ho gaye AFSPA se
NE people are innocent unlike "kashmiri separatists"
Srini ohoo Kashmir people are not such extremist like Indian forces if really all Kashmiri people unite no army can pressure on them
Srini yes cz they are Hindu &Kashmir are Muslim shame on u
Let the police hanle all borders id u dont need army ..
🤣🤣😂😂
If the situation in a particular state has stabilized, then the state government is well within its rights to demand the removal of AFSPA.
However, the very fact that they want the Indian Army to remain deployed in the interiors of the State shows that the situation has not adequately normalised.
Hence, it must be made very clear that the State cannot have it both ways. If there is no AFSPA, then there shall be no deployment of the Indian Army in the interior of the State. If they want the Army, then there will have to be an act that provides them immunity from prosecution by civil authorities, while in the line of duty.
Will you agree that your loved 1s get killed by the army
Basically afsapa or Indian army is made of British (British Indian army)
Freedom to MANIPUR
Chingakham Malemnganba
Haha
Manipur is a part of India.... what freedom???
its not special provision.... its special pawors act
Voice of manipur
Cow is more important than any state for modi
Lol the law was created by congress and most damage was done by congress govt still u blame modi after comings to peace with naga and bodo accord ??
Proud of indian army 💪💪
AFSP keep on delhi also,,,,
MeiteiPari Kangleicha
There are no insurgents in delhi like Manipur
@@ashishkalkal1079 there is more insurgency in delhi then manipur - they are called rapist n racist n killers - delhi is more not safe
Sare north east wale bolaye gaye hein...studio me
aap NDTV wale general bakshi aur sambit patra ko bolne hi de rahe hai,jese hi general bakshi kuch bolte turant hi tum log unki bat kat dalte hai
Auncha Ahanthem No he doesn't. Maybe others need to grow some gains.
I love ndtv
I love aishas pussy
Just being Me Allahh just fucked Mohammad
हमे अपनी सेना पर गर्व हैं ।अगर एक दो गलती हुई भी है सेना से तो उन्हें सजा दी गई है ।
yeh sab army officers ko medal chahiye isiliye fake encounter manipur chalta hai abhi social media advantages hora ha hey isiliye ye forces chup betha hey nahi to abhi bhi hum manipuris khas karke meitei people ko bahut marna tha
feel bad at G D bakshi attitude towards the lady . if he is a politician i can understand but bein a retd gen i didnt expect that from him.
oye sickular
my brother has not recive his home yet in srinagar
oye huskulund .... plizz b specific . what do u mean by ur bro n srinagar ?
but here discussion is about north eastern states not j&k
She seem so furios..
#shutdownNDTV
NDTV=Nehru Dynasty Television
Ye sach bolta hai isliye???
Haanji Kyu ki sacch bolna paap hai
Bhai tu zee news dekh
When GD bakshi is talking. no one should dare to stop him
why? is he God?
Harshit Tabyal No because he doesn't like to be interupted
meet Singh at
meet Singh why does India treat its minorities like shit
Well a manipuri lady dared to stop him ....what now???
Hi...
One year later...
But may bola...
Ea government kuch kiya?
Afspa hata kiya?
Serf vason... Sarkar bongaya... Responsibleti out...
आप जैसे लोगों को माइनॉरिटी का प्रॉब्लम मालूम नहीं है ना इसलिए आप लोग ऐसी बातें करते रहता अगर आप लोगों को भी अपनी ही राज्य में अल्पसंख्यक बनाया जाता तो आप लोग क्या करते हैं
Fouz apni manabadhikar ki bat karta hai, esmei koi burayi nehi hai. Lekin apni manabadhikar ke lie dusre ki jine ki aadhikar chhina kaha tak jayes hai??? Is bat ka zabab zouz de de.
I never salute india army, assam riffle, crpf......
NDTV reporting means don't let them talk who talks truth only traitors will bark
madam I have a touch with a soldier who has posting in Kashmir they also considers these but u can drop gun from the hands of terrorist if yes do it
iron Lady ko salam
Bharat Mata ki jai
Vande mataram
Indian army zindabad
Really bakwas debate.yha sirf ek hi side ko sunaya jaa rha hai.
general baksi ko kuch balna nahi da raho ..totaly one sided anchoring
repeal afspa when u find the other way to maintain peaxe
G D bakshi is right .
GA Kashmir
GA URDU DESH in Bihar & UP
GA Khalistan
GA Naga Land
GA Gurkha Land
GA Assam
Fauji General ke ILawa Saab Log sach bol rahe hai Bas fauji ka hi dimaag kharaab hai
Sambit Patra I salute to you .
you are very very Gentle and GD Bakshi 👎
this lady in yellow sari ......kasam kha k ayi h not listen others
U can't understand her pain
She is an insurgent in disguise......
@@vishnukumarkr3499 You are absolutely wrong. pliz do research before spitting ignorance. I am disappointed in your prejudice and lack of knowledge
For your kind information we don,t wear your fucking saree
NDTV sucks
the women in yellow is pretending to be intellectual but she is totally intellectually blind.........only G.D bakshi is talking with sense here
paalu84 can u please tell what G D bakshi said. he couldnt finish his sentence n bought jammu only so what conclusion did he gave ?
paalu84 she is activist n she knows more then u ,me n gen bakshi. pliz try to understand there had been cases where girl was accused n raped n kill by these paramilitary force , we know it happen in world but the thing is that after postmortem bullets were found inside her vagina . now how do u feel ?
haorungbam sikander Gen Bakshi want to say that these days the definition of war has changed and proxy war is new trend.....It means foreign agencies or organisations are using these militants against India by providing them finance, weapons, intelligence and training.......otherwise this is impossible for these organisation to afford all the finance or arrange military level weapons.......and to highlight this fact Gen Bakshi is also telling about arms and ammunitions seized by security agencies from terrorists in kashmir.
haorungbam sikander some of these activists( but not all) along with some journalists are also proxy soldiers of these foreign organisation.......she may be a genuine activist but her intellectual calibre is not so high that's why she is putting all weight behind removal of AFSPA...on the other hand gen bakshi is talking with practical experience.....I think the biggest factor along with proxy war is rampant corruption and lack of opportunities in north eastern states.
haorungbam sikander soldiers are not god and like other humans they can be good or bad.......but because of few bad soldiers you cant blame the entire army......AFSPA is seriously needed to deal with militancy and there can not be any compromise on it..........I think activist should focus on removing corruption in these areas
God Bakshi is good but crazy
Chakras.... Vagera vagera chakras...... Does that chashmish chutia intellectual know these chakras r won by sacrificing life..... Does he know how much bravery is put by each soldier in army...... Bat karta hai sala.....