아스트로..정말 열심히 활동했네요.. 너무 늦게 알아 미안하고..충분히 더 많은 사랑을 받았어야할 아스트로 였는데ㅠㅠ 빈아..잘 지내지? 여긴 걱정하지 말구 행복하게 지내길 바랄께..이것역시 우리가 감당해야 할 몫이니까..빈이만 행복하다면 그걸로 된거야..사랑해..보고싶다..빈..❤❤❤
Honestly I love Astro but they are definitely not singing live. They might have a track playing plus their vocals but it’s not just them. You can definitely practice but it’s whether you have a great stamina. It really all depends and most of the time a lot of idols can’t sing and dance. Just because they’re fit doesn’t mean that they can sing live and dance. They can still get out of breath. A lot of idols are fit and most of them can’t sing and dance at the same.
I'm here again and I would like to say how crazy their performance is that most comments said they were lip syncing but they're not. 1:29 You can clearly see Eunwoo's veins popping out in his neck, that's how you'll know they're singing live. 2:44 Moonbin catches some breath and veins popping. Gosh, i will never regret stanning Astro, everyone can live sing but astro is so stable.. Skills 100%
이 모습을 이제 볼 수 없어서 그래서 너무 슬픈가봐..아스트로 영상을 볼때면 늘 눈물이 고여 안 울려고 웃을려고 애 쓰는데 너무 그리워서 아직까지도 믿기지 않아서 힘들다..시간이 지나면 괜찮아 지겠지...?빈아 부디 그곳에서는 행복해야 돼..그리고 명준아 부대에서 빈이 생각나서 걱정 돼서 많이 힘들지? 군복무 건강하게 잘 마치고 바로 돌아오지 않아도 되니까 마음 잘 추스르면 좋겠다 그리고 진우야 너무 슬퍼하지마 웃어줘 빈이한테는 진우가 든든했으니까 빈이 잘 지내라고 웃어주자 사랑해 그리고 가장 친했던 하나뿐인 친구 은우야 괜찮아..너 탓이 아니야 빈이가 그냥 여행하고 싶어서 여행 하러 간거니까 마음이 많이 힘들지 않았으면 좋겠다 살 많이 빠졌던데 잘 먹고 힘내..그리고 빈이와 연습생 시절 함께했던 친구자동생이었던 민혁아 데뷔하기전까지 가장 오래 함께했지? 얼마나 힘들고 아플까 너무 아파하지마..괜찮아 힘내..건강 잘챙겨 밥도 잘 먹고 알았지? 그리고 유닛 활동도 또 빈이가 친동생이 있지만 산하도 친동생처럼 생각한다고 직접 말했는데 그리고 마지막까지 같이 있어줬는데 갑자기 떠나서 그 마음 내가 완전히 이해를 못하지 가장 옆에서 오랬동안 함께 했을텐데..근데 있잖아 빈이가 한번쯤 꼭 꿈속에 나와줄거야 알았지? 울지마..괜찮아 괜찮으니까 너무 슬프고 힘들면 다 풀어 충분히 그럴자격 있으니까 그리고 아스트로라는 팀으로 지난 8년간 잘 버티고 우리 곁에 있어줘서 고마웠어 많이 그리울거야 많이 보고싶을거야 부디 모든 멤버들이 아프지말고 밥도 잘 챙겨먹고 행복해졌으면 좋겠다 너희들은 충분히 그러고도 남을 자격 있으니까 그리고 빈이가 있는 세상에 언젠가는 가게 되겠지 그때가면 빈이가 마중나와 있을거야 그때 만나서 펑펑울고 아스트로 완전체 만나서 웃고 떠들고 추억 회상하며 가장 좋아하는 일을 그런 하루들을 보냈으면 좋겠다 지금은 빈이를 위해서 더 많이 더 행복하게 빈이가 대리만족 느낀 수 있게끔 잘 살아주자 알았지? 항상 응원할게 계속해서 사랑해 아스트로..사랑해 엠제이,진진,차은우,문빈,라키,윤산하 영원하자 나의 전부 나의 별들🤍💜🕊
I've come here because when I saw the RV performance, the comment section full of RV deserved to win. Well I guess Astro really deserved to win, I know them in ISAC and they did a good job. I'm reveluv but even Seulgi (2:36) and Joy (1:47) enjoys the performance, So why dragging them down? RV Queens really did a great job but Astro did more than that.
Binnie's voice is clear and so honey. Just wonderful, how I'd love to hear him again for my entire life. I guess this only my selfishness, Binnie must be in a divine place for pure souls. Sweet beautiful Binnie, you were the only one light that enlightened minds and warmed hearts of people here below. We love you forever and we will never forget you 💘💝💖💗💞💕❤🧡💛💜🧡❤
Intro wow then sunddenly eunwoo face hahahha Astro so underrated they have a strong vocals low tone vocals high vocals two rappers can dance smooth dance stan people stan talent ohhh i just discovered them through “truebeauty “🤣thanks eunwoo lee suho
I watched the episode for Red Velvet, but omg they're so cute and their performance is so nice 😭 I haven't really checked on them since their debut in 2016, so what are some good songs to listen by them?
-Baby -Cats Eye -Breathless -Crazy, Sexy, Cool -Hide & Seek (their debut song) -Confession Pretty much all their title songs honestly!! * No title songs that are beautiful and that you should hear are: * - Innocent/Puppy love - Should have held on - Because it's you -Morning Call -My style THO ALL OF THEIR SONG ARE CUTE AND BEAUTIFUL I recommend those to start your obsession XD
The amount of disrespect towards Astro in the Red Velvet comment section is actually so dumb. I’m a Reveluv but also an AROHA and both did an amazing job. No doubt that the girls are super talented BUT Astro’s performance was more fun and interesting to watch. Also vocals sounded more stable than in RV’s. The arrangement of RV’s song was a little blah, and I think Astro just captured the audience better and made the song their own. But remember this is just my view point of being a part of BOTH fandoms. There is no need to bring the other group down in order to bring the other one up. 💜
i agree so much, months ago i was listening to red velvet and i came across ASTRO and i just fell in love- so now my fav kpop groups are red velvet and astro
I’m going to stop the weather in,2021-2022 that the stars stay for many years,all together and without getting old and never disappear.ASTRO for life ❤❤❤❤❤❤
I always see young SHINEE In Astro. Stable voice , talented dancers, grougers visuals, cute in verility shows. An total package. I know i shouldn't compere .but i lv these kids and want to celebrate 10 years with them. (I'll hv kids then😂) I wish them to shine brightly even than this. They deserve it❤️
![[Simply K-Pop] ASTRO(아스트로), 'Fireworks(불꽃놀이)' _ Ep.221](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/iG9XGU6RctM/mqdefault.jpg)
![[Simply K-Pop] ASTRO(아스트로), 'Fireworks(불꽃놀이)' _ Ep.221](/img/tr.png)
![Noob To Max With DRAGON REWORK In Blox Fruits [FULL MOVIE]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/LnBMOinoOvA/mqdefault.jpg)
![[듣터뷰🎤] 연예계를 떠나 평범한 일상으로 돌아간 케이팝 멤버들, 갑자기 해체한 이유는? | 슈가맨2 | JTBC 180128 방송](/img/1.gif)
I just want you all to know that *ASTRO won in this episode!!* Isn't that great? Where are you Arohas at? :D
Sponge Bob Here💕🙋
Sponge Bob jjinja? thats great!!
HEREEE CONGRATSSS ASTRO
HEREEEEE
late but still presentttt ~~
아로하는 아니었지만,
문득 생각이 나서
가수 문빈을 처음 본 영상이라 댓글달아요
가수해줘서 고마웠어요
하늘에선 걱정, 고민 없이 행복하길 바래요
차은우를 보다 문빈 도 보게 됐는데 ..아스트로 모두가 재능이 넘치네…bts 와 다를봐 없네..
이거 본방 봤는데... 왜 몰랐니 이 보석들을 ㅠㅠ k-pop 완전 오랜만이라 반가워가지고 우리애들 이쁜걸 몰랐어ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
누가 이겼을까요..ㅠㅠ
@@Whi_chive 와아~!!우리 별둥이들이 이겼다~!!감사합니다!!
대박 아스트로별둥이들이 이겼다니!!♡
Vocal✔
Rap✔
Dance✔
Visual✔
What else do we need? Astro is slaying ı'm so proud of them👏👍💜😊
You forgot somthing it's
Handsome✔
😂
_ people to not sleep on them 😢
Dilara Karabulut yess👍👍
Good Smeller unfortunately people are sleeping on talent😔
And they good in acting
아스트로..정말 열심히 활동했네요..
너무 늦게 알아 미안하고..충분히 더 많은
사랑을 받았어야할 아스트로 였는데ㅠㅠ
빈아..잘 지내지? 여긴 걱정하지 말구 행복하게 지내길 바랄께..이것역시 우리가
감당해야 할 몫이니까..빈이만 행복하다면
그걸로 된거야..사랑해..보고싶다..빈..❤❤❤
세상에나 저렇게 능력있는 6 별둥이들을??? 소속사가 그룹의 능력을 못 따라갔네 저들을 반석에 올려놓은 담에 갠 활동하게 했어야지 ....
아스트로가 완전체로 이런 프로그램에도 나왔구나 왜 몰랐을까..
문빈:니가 지쳐 누군가 필요 할때 나의 이름을 불러 니가 홀로 어둠 밤을 지샐때 나의 모습 떠올려
how do they have such good stable voice while dancing like that ajsksjsak damn
LISA OWNS MY WIG cause they’re super fit
LISA OWNS MY WIG because their Astro.
Thats why you need to be trainee first before become kpop idol.cause practise make prefects
Honestly I love Astro but they are definitely not singing live. They might have a track playing plus their vocals but it’s not just them. You can definitely practice but it’s whether you have a great stamina. It really all depends and most of the time a lot of idols can’t sing and dance. Just because they’re fit doesn’t mean that they can sing live and dance. They can still get out of breath. A lot of idols are fit and most of them can’t sing and dance at the same.
@Tulip Aroha Doria of course they sing live in some of their performances. All I'm saying is that in this video, it's really obvious they're not.
구구단 정, 레드벨벳 떠날거야, 다음으로 좋았던 무대~ 아니다 너네가 1등 먹어라. 어찌 이리 잘하노
I'm here again and I would like to say how crazy their performance is that most comments said they were lip syncing but they're not. 1:29 You can clearly see Eunwoo's veins popping out in his neck, that's how you'll know they're singing live. 2:44 Moonbin catches some breath and veins popping.
Gosh, i will never regret stanning Astro, everyone can live sing but astro is so stable.. Skills 100%
산하 문빈 음색이 청량함과 진짜 잘어울리는 드ㅛ
아깝다 아깝고 억울하다 빈아
이렇게 열심히 살았는데 그 댓가가 너무 하찮게 존중못받은듯 해서 😂😂😂
아프지말고 행복만 해라
늦게 알게되서 미안해
I hope we support all the members of the astro do not just support one member only because they are very talented
Agree on this. Everyone in Astro is indeed has good looks and real talent 😘😘😘 Saranghae ASTRO
I actually fall for moonbin at first and start watching all astro video, now i just can't stop and can't even choose a bias, i love them all
소속사가 제로
I love you astro my ot6
이거 마약영상임 노래 비트랑 열심히 하는 모습이랑 중간에 흐뭇해하시는 원곡자분들 너무 좋음...♡
이 모습을 이제 볼 수 없어서 그래서 너무 슬픈가봐..아스트로 영상을 볼때면 늘 눈물이 고여 안 울려고 웃을려고 애 쓰는데 너무 그리워서 아직까지도 믿기지 않아서 힘들다..시간이 지나면 괜찮아 지겠지...?빈아 부디 그곳에서는 행복해야 돼..그리고 명준아 부대에서 빈이 생각나서 걱정 돼서 많이 힘들지? 군복무 건강하게 잘 마치고 바로 돌아오지 않아도 되니까 마음 잘 추스르면 좋겠다 그리고 진우야 너무 슬퍼하지마 웃어줘 빈이한테는 진우가 든든했으니까 빈이 잘 지내라고 웃어주자 사랑해 그리고 가장 친했던 하나뿐인 친구 은우야 괜찮아..너 탓이 아니야 빈이가 그냥 여행하고 싶어서 여행 하러 간거니까 마음이 많이 힘들지 않았으면 좋겠다 살 많이 빠졌던데 잘 먹고 힘내..그리고 빈이와 연습생 시절 함께했던 친구자동생이었던 민혁아 데뷔하기전까지 가장 오래 함께했지? 얼마나 힘들고 아플까 너무 아파하지마..괜찮아 힘내..건강 잘챙겨 밥도 잘 먹고 알았지? 그리고 유닛 활동도 또 빈이가 친동생이 있지만 산하도 친동생처럼 생각한다고 직접 말했는데 그리고 마지막까지 같이 있어줬는데 갑자기 떠나서 그 마음 내가 완전히 이해를 못하지 가장 옆에서 오랬동안 함께 했을텐데..근데 있잖아 빈이가 한번쯤 꼭 꿈속에 나와줄거야 알았지? 울지마..괜찮아 괜찮으니까 너무 슬프고 힘들면 다 풀어 충분히 그럴자격 있으니까 그리고 아스트로라는 팀으로 지난 8년간 잘 버티고 우리 곁에 있어줘서 고마웠어 많이 그리울거야 많이 보고싶을거야 부디 모든 멤버들이 아프지말고 밥도 잘 챙겨먹고 행복해졌으면 좋겠다 너희들은 충분히 그러고도 남을 자격 있으니까 그리고 빈이가 있는 세상에 언젠가는 가게 되겠지 그때가면 빈이가 마중나와 있을거야 그때 만나서 펑펑울고 아스트로 완전체 만나서 웃고 떠들고 추억 회상하며 가장 좋아하는 일을 그런 하루들을 보냈으면 좋겠다 지금은 빈이를 위해서 더 많이 더 행복하게 빈이가 대리만족 느낀 수 있게끔 잘 살아주자 알았지? 항상 응원할게 계속해서 사랑해 아스트로..사랑해 엠제이,진진,차은우,문빈,라키,윤산하 영원하자 나의 전부 나의 별들🤍💜🕊
omg sanha's vocals were so stable
If you are a new fan like me, there is always that guilt feeling of not knowing them sooner. They are so talented. 💜
Me! I didn't find out about them until May of this year. 😭
I've come here because when I saw the RV performance, the comment section full of RV deserved to win. Well I guess Astro really deserved to win, I know them in ISAC and they did a good job. I'm reveluv but even Seulgi (2:36) and Joy (1:47) enjoys the performance, So why dragging them down? RV Queens really did a great job but Astro did more than that.
빈아보고싶다ㅜㅜ
오빠들 진짜 열심히 살았구나..(?)🥰🥰💖 몰라줘서 미안하고 앞으로 최선을 다해 좋아할게용🥺🥺
윤산하 미모 미쳣고
빈아 너의 목소리 춤
누구도 따라할수없는 특별한아이다
아스트로 파면서 여기까지 흘러왔는데
울 애들 음악예능에도 참 많이 나왔었구나
하물며 또 너무 잘해...
Mj and Jinjin in between binwoo makes them look small and adorable😊💜💜💜
kings. THIS IS THEIR YEAR YALL
beepeu OMG TRUE I REALLY THINK THEIR GONNA HIT THEIR PEAK THIS YEAR
YEEEZ!
재방으로 결과만 봤어요..ㅜㅜ
그래도 이겨서ㅋㅋㅋㅋ기분좋게 슈가맨 영상 서치해서 발자국 남깁니다.. 역시 ..아스트로♥
Binnie's voice is clear and so honey.
Just wonderful, how I'd love to hear him again for my entire life.
I guess this only my selfishness, Binnie must be in a divine place for pure souls. Sweet beautiful Binnie, you were the only one light that enlightened minds and warmed hearts of people here below. We love you forever and we will never forget you 💘💝💖💗💞💕❤🧡💛💜🧡❤
This was one of my favorite songs from K-POP and I can't believe ASTRO covered it. Good job my boys!!!!!
SAME OMG I'M SO HAPPYYY
What song is this...
K-POP's Shadow
은우도입부랑 미모 실화냐?~
노래도 넘좋고 아직도 내뮤직목록중 하나지😘
다섯장 땜에 명준이 찾아 다님서 영상 보고~~ 세상에나 이리 이쁜 애들이 있다는 걸 몰르고 살았네~~ 특히 울 MJ 명준이 ~~💕
what an underappreciated talent this group i'm always impressed
CONGRATULATIONS to my boys...My boys did so well...they look so tired after performing this song...and remember that Aroha always support Astro...
나의 잠자는 어린왕자 문빈님의 삶을 추앙합니다
문빈님은
프레드머큐리ㆍ마이클잭슨ㆍ마돈나와 같은 공연예술가로
그들보다 어린나이로
그의 삶은
완벽을 위한 날개짓이였다
그의 선한 바람으로
내 삶의 한발자국을 내딛는다
astro win it against rv.. congratulations .. i like this style of music. rv brought the sad music.
I'm so proud of my boys for winning this episode!!!! And did you see how much my baby boy eunwoo improved? And Sanha is really growing huhu..
Astro and Red Velvet are really talented!!!!
Astro's owned the stage ahhhhhh I'm so proud of them
명준이 음색에 또 반했어..ㅜㅜㅜ 너무 좋다
갑자기 생각나서 옴....대존잘
I come for RV but they are so cute, I think i will stan them from now! Good job boys!
Yes, please do it!
Scor I. You're about to fall deep lol... But u won't regret it
so proud!! as we've expected our kings never fails to get us amazed :))
Intro wow then sunddenly eunwoo face hahahha Astro so underrated they have a strong vocals low tone vocals high vocals two rappers can dance smooth dance stan people stan talent ohhh i just discovered them through “truebeauty “🤣thanks eunwoo lee suho
I watched the episode for Red Velvet, but omg they're so cute and their performance is so nice 😭 I haven't really checked on them since their debut in 2016, so what are some good songs to listen by them?
Breathless~ a fresh song
Crazy sexy cool~ a manly song :3
Baby
Confession
Em Veluv Any Album will do 😊 but I suggest the Dream part 1 & Autumn Story Album 😊 And I should've held on 😊
Dream part 2 album
-Baby
-Cats Eye
-Breathless
-Crazy, Sexy, Cool
-Hide & Seek (their debut song)
-Confession
Pretty much all their title songs honestly!!
* No title songs that are beautiful and that you should hear are: *
- Innocent/Puppy love
- Should have held on
- Because it's you
-Morning Call
-My style
THO ALL OF THEIR SONG ARE CUTE AND BEAUTIFUL I recommend those to start your obsession XD
Innocent Love
Run
Fireworks
Again
우리 애들 진짜 못하는게 없어❤
노래 너무좋아
중간중간 엠씨분들?이랑 원곡 가수분들이 흐뭇하게 웃으면서 보고 또 잘한다해주시는거 넘 좋다 ❤️❤️ 힐링
ㄹㅇ
Moonbin❤❤❤❤❤❤
빈이 체고
저게 사람이야 천사야... 은우야....
The amount of disrespect towards Astro in the Red Velvet comment section is actually so dumb. I’m a Reveluv but also an AROHA and both did an amazing job. No doubt that the girls are super talented BUT Astro’s performance was more fun and interesting to watch. Also vocals sounded more stable than in RV’s. The arrangement of RV’s song was a little blah, and I think Astro just captured the audience better and made the song their own. But remember this is just my view point of being a part of BOTH fandoms. There is no need to bring the other group down in order to bring the other one up. 💜
i agree so much, months ago i was listening to red velvet and i came across ASTRO and i just fell in love- so now my fav kpop groups are red velvet and astro
Enni Hartikainen there’s literally no hate in the red velvet video tf?
I saw no hate on either videos
@@TwBelgi78 they did the cleaning it's been a year after all
My two favorites!!!
Yoon Sanha: "I will never let you cry"
Me:Then stop making me cry!!!!!!
Wow, this remake is soooo good👏 Guess I need to stan Astro too! Great job boys❤
Yeah u should :)
Who sing the original song??
Amelia Bukhory welcome to the fandom
Amelia Bukhory remake?
@@idanatashahalim4282 k-pop , thats the name of the group who sang the original
아스트로는 진짜 유명해져라 ㅠㅠ
wow Moonbin’s voice really fits the song
I really like it
Astro well done!
Fighting!
Anyone could've died with eun woo's finger heart ❤️
하아...천재냐?
mj's highnotes are everything
I’m going to stop the weather in,2021-2022 that the stars stay for many years,all together and without getting old and never disappear.ASTRO for life ❤❤❤❤❤❤
Well, correct from the ,19 th the 22nd. ❤❤❤❤❤❤
Well, correct from the ,19 th the 22nd. ❤❤❤❤❤❤
@@NiokaEspinal better take 2017-2019. All betrayals were yet to be made
I miss u moonbin 😔❤
진짜 힐링 + 마약영상 ㅠ
애기들인데 넘 잘하고 열심히 해서 ㅠㅠㅠ
보다보면 나도 모르게 광대승천…!
아스트로가 주는 에너지가 너무 좋다😭
이 영상도 그렇고
불명에서 보여준 미인,돌이키지마 무대도 너무 잘하고 좋은데 사람들이 더 많이 봐줬으면!!
숨가쁘다ㅠㅠㅠ너무 잘해 초반에 코인 들어가는 소리와 은우비줠합주
They're(Astro)the reason I started getting interested in kpop
왜 이걸 지금 알았을까요..ㅠㅠ
진심 미쳤다..존잘❤존멋
Oh my gosh, I can't stop listening to this song. Astro killed the stage once again. I am so proud of my boys.
this is what we called talent
무지땅 울 오빠들💗
차은우 ㄹㅇ 미모 사람이세요..?
아 진짜 제발 더 뜨자 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
They won!! I’m so happy.
mj 맛깔나게 고음도 잘 하고 고막이 호강하네~~💜
They need more attention. God! This is amazing.
ㅎㅎ...다들 너무 귀여워..너무너무 멋지고..(광대승천
독보적인 음색~~
진짜 너무 잘 부른다 아스트로✡💜영원했으면 좋겠어요
Moonbin 😭
I’m so proud~~ whatever they do always makes people smiles with them💜 that’s my ASTRO
너무 잘한다❤️❤️❤️🔯
Dadating din yung time na mapapansin ng lahat ang ASTRO😊
im new here and i just want to say that their rap lines are powerful and the vocals are strong as their choreo ahhhhhhhh full package eh??
Rewatching 아스트로
문빈아 잘 지내니?
그래 우리 별둥이들 청량하고 멋있고 귀엽고 다해ㅠㅠ
너무 잘하잖아 ㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜ
우리 아가들 열심히 하는거 너무 머시따!
진짜 잘해 아스트로!
산하 멋있다
Just finished watching the whole episode.. I shocked that audience need to vote but astro win in this ep So proud to astro..
where did u watch the whole episode i have been searching this episode for ages can u please share the link ??
So happy they won
if them not jump that's not astro wkwk
always slayy boy good job everyone enjoying for your perfomers..
fightingg!!!
so proud of them. they did so well.
I always see young SHINEE In Astro. Stable voice , talented dancers, grougers visuals, cute in verility shows. An total package.
I know i shouldn't compere .but i lv these kids and want to celebrate 10 years with them. (I'll hv kids then😂) I wish them to shine brightly even than this. They deserve it❤️
that first snap is so satisfying i keep coming back for it
3:15 ❤️ Yes, Jin Jin.
Wow what a great performance. 👏🏼👏🏼
💜💜💜💜💜💜 (ASTRO) + 💞 (AROHA) = 💖 (TRUE LOVE)
i miss my ot6 so much😭
ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ울애들 존잘해
i'm so proud!! ASTRO my babies, good job
stan talent...stan astro...
Astro!! 💘
Astro is so underrated:,( I wish they got more attention ! 😭😭 they’re so good !!