As far as I've taken from the lyrics of this song I think that it's about self doubt and not just looks. The first part about the woman looking towards the sky but are so ugly that the light shines away is how she sees herself and the end is about how her partner sees her from different eyes and wish that she could see how beautiful she is through his eyes. The ugly part isn't about her physical looks but her mental image of herself. At least that's how I looked at the song and I had a school project in highschool where we were tasked to analyze a song and make a poem in arts class. I chose this song and made a poem that were presented in the schools assembly hall. Later on I heard that a girl in my school accually said later on that it helped her to stop having destructive thoughts and in a way stopped her from thinking about ending her life. All this goes to a german rockband that many at that time thought were nazis. Till's writing skills are so beautiful that even my bad german to swedish translations and bad poem skills made something good. I love this band so much!
You recognized the text and its meaning well. At first he thought she was ugly and insulted her. But when he got to know her good heart, she became beautiful to him.
"Wärmt die Brust mir bebt, wo das Leben schlägt, mit dem Herzen sehen, sie ist wunderschön" "It warms my trembling chest Where life beats Seeing with the heart She is beautiful" My interpretation is that He is asking the morning star to make her beautiful and she also pleads for beauty...but not because she's ugly or deformed because it's dealing with body dysmorphia and/or what society views as being beautiful, ugly, plain, average etc. So the morning star instead of shining on her, it shines on him..where it warms up his heart his feelings and so before he only saw with his eyes but now he sees with his heart and soul and realizes that she is beautiful 😍❤️
Thanks for the reaction! I personally see it almost like a fairytale- a girl cursed with a horrifying appearance, the main character and her aiming to change her outside features to have a happy ending... but ultimately, the morning Star helps in an unforeseen way, as the problem was never her but society/ the main character, and helping him see her in light she deserves to be seen under ultimately gives the happy ending they wanted :)
Here, it seems, Morgenstern was so beautiful on the inside that the true "ugly" people are intimidated and act out by focusing on her outer looks. In the end, she is so internally beautiful that 1) No matter her outside appearance, she is beautiful 2) Her inner beauty actually physically transforms her outward appearance to "match" her inner beauty. I like the first option better.
Even as a german I misunderstand a lot of their lyrics. When he says "Morgenstern" I dont understand "morning star" more I think of the weapon and when he says "ach scheine (oh shine)" I understand "erscheine" what means appear
We'll go through all of Rammstein songs dude along with your fabulous reaction. We(subscribers) will notice the songs you have not reacted in the comments but don't forget to update your Rammstein playlist for us to know which songs you are missing, THX.
Nice reaction as usual. The song has allegories to the poem "Das Abendlied" by Matthew Claudius in structure of the verse rhythm and some lyric lines. Franz Schubert composed a song to the poem. If you listen to both songs you will find them quite similar. Of course the selection of instruments makes a big difference in heaviness. We sing the song (das Abendlied) to our children as lullaby. With love from Germany 🤘 😎
Yeah I hope he does! Quite different from Rammstein but I think he will enjoy it lol. I sent him all the links and songs on E-mail hopefully it will come soon :)
What a nice song, i did not know it, so simple almost naive but also poetic. Your analysis is inspiring, maybe it is about the grudge that females have being bound to be beautiful or worth nothing in the eyes of men.
I just remember schooltime, where we also divided the girls between super, boring and ugly and the ugly Ones, me as well, i regret some things, also prejudice inside
Thanks for the response to this song, it's a great song for sure. I want to invite you to watch the video from Volkerball concert, maybe somehow, it's old but atmospheric. ruclips.net/video/Pjbzaq_BZAQ/видео.html - Rammstein Morgenstern live from Volkerball
hey there, I'd like your opinion if this could be an a reference to romantic irrationalism? it would help me a lot since I'm going to write the final exam where I will probably have the opportunity to recall this song. thanks in advance 💯
May it be it's about a woman who is arrested in her body, tormented by diets or anorexia, beauty operations and their results and has completely lost herself by trying to follow the official taste of beauty without feeling herself? And the man is sorry for the isolated woman, trying to help her out of this vicious circle or downward spiral?
He does pause a lot to analyze lyrics, but he’s the only reactor I can listen to do this song after song particularly with Rammstein. He’s very sincere and likable. I watch his videos often.
finally i found the man who not only listen, but also analyzes the lyrics and thinks about it... hello from Russia
One of the best Rammstein Songs for me. Thank you for this Reaction
Hell yeah! Arguably their most unique! Those drum parts make this song!
As far as I've taken from the lyrics of this song I think that it's about self doubt and not just looks.
The first part about the woman looking towards the sky but are so ugly that the light shines away is how she sees herself and the end is about how her partner sees her from different eyes and wish that she could see how beautiful she is through his eyes. The ugly part isn't about her physical looks but her mental image of herself.
At least that's how I looked at the song and I had a school project in highschool where we were tasked to analyze a song and make a poem in arts class. I chose this song and made a poem that were presented in the schools assembly hall. Later on I heard that a girl in my school accually said later on that it helped her to stop having destructive thoughts and in a way stopped her from thinking about ending her life. All this goes to a german rockband that many at that time thought were nazis.
Till's writing skills are so beautiful that even my bad german to swedish translations and bad poem skills made something good. I love this band so much!
Morgenstern from Rammstein: One of my ultimate favourites from this band.
You recognized the text and its meaning well. At first he thought she was ugly and insulted her. But when he got to know her good heart, she became beautiful to him.
Someone told me that they sing about the Moon . Greets from Germany
"Wärmt die Brust mir bebt, wo das Leben schlägt, mit dem Herzen sehen, sie ist wunderschön"
"It warms my trembling chest
Where life beats
Seeing with the heart
She is beautiful"
My interpretation is that He is asking
the morning star to make her beautiful and she also pleads for beauty...but not because she's ugly or deformed because it's dealing with body dysmorphia and/or what society views as being beautiful, ugly, plain, average etc. So the morning star instead of shining on her, it shines on him..where it warms up his heart his feelings and so before he only saw with his eyes but now he sees with his heart and soul and realizes that she is beautiful 😍❤️
Exactly!!!!!
The song Diamant is the counterpart to the song Morgenstern
Thanks for the reaction!
I personally see it almost like a fairytale- a girl cursed with a horrifying appearance, the main character and her aiming to change her outside features to have a happy ending... but ultimately, the morning Star helps in an unforeseen way, as the problem was never her but society/ the main character, and helping him see her in light she deserves to be seen under ultimately gives the happy ending they wanted :)
Here, it seems, Morgenstern was so beautiful on the inside that the true "ugly" people are intimidated and act out by focusing on her outer looks.
In the end, she is so internally beautiful that
1) No matter her outside appearance, she is beautiful
2) Her inner beauty actually physically transforms her outward appearance to "match" her inner beauty.
I like the first option better.
Next up : Stein um Stein 🤘
Even as a german I misunderstand a lot of their lyrics. When he says "Morgenstern" I dont understand "morning star" more I think of the weapon and when he says "ach scheine (oh shine)" I understand "erscheine" what means appear
I could write a dissertation on this song.
We'll go through all of Rammstein songs dude along with your fabulous reaction. We(subscribers) will notice the songs you have not reacted in the comments but don't forget to update your Rammstein playlist for us to know which songs you are missing, THX.
Nice reaction as usual. The song has allegories to the poem "Das Abendlied" by Matthew Claudius in structure of the verse rhythm and some lyric lines. Franz Schubert composed a song to the poem. If you listen to both songs you will find them quite similar. Of course the selection of instruments makes a big difference in heaviness. We sing the song (das Abendlied) to our children as lullaby. With love from Germany 🤘 😎
Can you please play songs from the Lindemann album Fat, Steh Auf, Golden Shower, Blut, Fish on,Cowboy, G-Spot, Knebel or Allesfresser.😃👍🔥🎸
Yeah I hope he does! Quite different from Rammstein but I think he will enjoy it lol. I sent him all the links and songs on E-mail hopefully it will come soon :)
"Home sweet home" too. (Edit: and "ich weiss es nicht")
what you interpret at 8:27 is what I thought, by an experience I had about 15 years ago 🤐
What a nice song, i did not know it, so simple almost naive but also poetic. Your analysis is inspiring, maybe it is about the grudge that females have being bound to be beautiful or worth nothing in the eyes of men.
Agreed! 😁
Ich liebe dieses Lied 😍❤
I just remember schooltime, where we also divided the girls between super, boring and ugly and the ugly Ones, me as well, i regret some things, also prejudice inside
Thanks for the response to this song, it's a great song for sure. I want to invite you to watch the video from Volkerball concert, maybe somehow, it's old but atmospheric.
ruclips.net/video/Pjbzaq_BZAQ/видео.html - Rammstein Morgenstern live from Volkerball
Up
It's the story of the ugly duckling becoming a beautiful swan, I think.
Now I'll watch the video here and see what you come up with!
I Love this song!! Please react to the live performance at Völkerball...😍💕💕💕💕💕💎💎
childrens of the sun means Stars
Hey, love your reactions just a good end of the day. Pls react to ausländer from rammstein too oneday just an amazing song
Morgenstern erscheine >.< Auf das Antlitz meine >.< wirf ein warmes Licht >.< auf mein Ungesicht >.< sag mir sie ist nicht alleine >.
danke
React RAMMSTEIN - STEIN UM STEIN
hey there, I'd like your opinion if this could be an a reference to romantic irrationalism? it would help me a lot since I'm going to write the final exam where I will probably have the opportunity to recall this song. thanks in advance 💯
i will sugest you to do a reaction to the band ruoska. they are industrial metal just like rammstein and are really underrated
Morgenstern is a weapon too
Sie ist wunderschön >.
May it be it's about a woman who is arrested in her body, tormented by diets or anorexia, beauty operations and their results and has completely lost herself by trying to follow the official taste of beauty without feeling herself? And the man is sorry for the isolated woman, trying to help her out of this vicious circle or downward spiral?
Morningstar is also another name for the devil. Sie is begging the morningstar to make her beautiful.
The morning star is actually Venus which is the godess of love and beauty. But has been linked to Satan, due to it's temptation I think.
а, не тот Моргерштерн
а по тексту подходит.
Too much pause and react to the lyrics but not to the music itself, sorry.
He does pause a lot to analyze lyrics, but he’s the only reactor I can listen to do this song after song particularly with Rammstein. He’s very sincere and likable. I watch his videos often.