We can't even have a world class railway station even in the capital of the country. Meanwhile a normal metro station in a small town in China looks no less than an Airport. Seriously the change in the design is literally downgraded
The main reason is we made more government body in our country than working professionals company... Unnecessary wastage of money in corruption and salary for them
@Sh4aFFa then you haven't seen much about Chinese infrastructures just search in RUclips you will see everything btw I'm not a Chinese supporter but the Chinese infrastructures are really appreciable!
Government ka soch hi galagt tha ki itna ambitious project sirf 5000 Cr me banjayega,government ko project ko around 8500 Cr pe hi done kardena chahiye tha ,itna world class railway station hum miss kardenge,this railway station could have even been a tourist attraction if well managed internally,this was so good we could have focussed on the Changi Airport model for this but sadly,it won't happen anymore,government ko freebies dene ke liye paisa hai padh itna achha kam karne ke liye nahi
In some ways, I do also get the govts reluctance to spend 8500 Cr, pakke se koi na koi gadha aake bolta 'saar aap sirf dilli mumbai jaise shehro me paise lagate ho, what abt XYZ station in ABC' and it would've been bad politically. And it's not really worth 8500 Cr either, especially considering the cheaper cost of construction in India. Would've been a good deal for 5k Cr tho
It's a shame. We are almost a 4 Trillion USD economy. Building a 1.1 billion USD (7-8000 crore Rs) railway stations for the national capital, should be feasible. If govt didn't wanted to fully contribute the money, it could have sold the majority stake in Railway station for 40-50 years or so. It would have been a game changer for the image of Delhi. And could have attracted more real estate investments. Unfortunately, we have not been able to iconic building in the National Capital since independence. It doesn't have to be The Burj Khalifa, or Shanghai Tower, it could be more like The Vessel in New York.
Bhai 4 trillion jyada nhi he Population or area bhahut jyada he Europe ka area. Bharat jitana hi he per economy 24 trillion he Abhi to hamari 70% population Gareeb he 4000 rupee month kamati income increase hogi Ho. Economy bhi increase hogi
Bro, you are somewhat right but we have to understand currently there are many projects that are ongoing. Not only railways, govt is spending on expressways, ropeways and airports also. They have to maintain budget for that also.
4 trillion gdp ha ,india ka budget 400 billion ha , usme aadha se jyada salary ,pension aur interest me dub jata ha ,baki me road, defence ,corruption aur ye,ab socho😂.
Very disappointed with the government, i am losing hopes in every filed... Indian government can't create something extraordinary, they should learn from our ancestors they where the masters in architecture 😔
Government bolti h India Superpower bnayenge aur National capital ki railway station ki construction pe sirf 5000 cr. 8500 cr kr hi dete.. baar baar thodi na bnegi yeh railway station. Kya yeh indian government hai 🤡
@@Kalankit5409 pta nhi bro kaash accha infrastructure india me aankho se dekh pata....lagta hai china jeisa communist party se hi kaam aage badte hai.....democracy only developed country k liyehi behtar hai
Meko to pehle se hi pata tha ki jesi photos ye Amrit Bharat stations me dikha rhe hai wesa ghnta kuch nhi ban ne wala🤣🤣. Aur bhi dusre stations jinki design bht ambitious hai wo bhi ek dabba building banke hi rehne wale hai
Iss desh ko aesthetics se problem hai. Ek world class cheez toh banado. Ab har din jab bhi news padhta hu toh disappointment hi milti kuch acha kab hoga
It is shame for this government which talks so big but couldn't execute this project. It was their opportunity not only to prove to people of India but to the world, that India can execute a world class project. And India did deserve it especially in the capital city, just to feel proud. First they show big dreams to people and then they silently cave out. There is not even any news on this. Ridiculous. This is a massive failure.
even previous design was horrendous. I don’t understand why the government wants to build cheap copies of international architecture when India has such great contemporary and historical architecture
what chip copies dude that's a great design but because our railway staff I mean official staff are inefficient they don't have professionalism they are just like other government staff and don't have any skill to do that I think the government should privatize railways also batter safety, hygiene, and service to people
@ look at the UK railways after privatization. absolute disaster. government friends like Adani and Ambani will buy the rail infrastructure for paisa on the rupee and slash costs to maximize profits. As for the design, it is abhorrent. No thought for how it blends with surrounding areas, no local anchoring. It is car centric, de prioritizing other means of getting to the station, such as walking and biking. It is an inefficient design and has no place in Delhi
@@knutjonsson1816 dude if you need something batter you have paid for it and it's not government fault at all it's our education that only teach only theoretically that never helped us in the future we need quality education that can focus on Science Skill development and Innovation and also we need to change our mind like when you work hard for government survives but after you got the job do nothing and also never improve your skill set for that job it's the biggest upsets for our country and unfortunately more most of the government service man are doing that even A higher post Like IAS IPs IFS also and because of there inefficiency in that particular skill work hit back the common people Dude I studying In a engineering field I know the best for it
Bhai, govt paise bhi to dena nahi chhati, pehle ka budget 5k Crore (tenders 8k crore ka aaya isi liye cancel ho gaya) tha. Ab achanak se budget 2.5k crore pohonch gaya. Koi clarification bhi nahi, ki kab tak khatam hoga, kab issue hoga remaining tender, kya hogi final project ki value. Mere opinion me agar pehle hi 5k crore ka budget tha, to achanak se plans ko 2.5k crore + future tender (jo jis tarah hamare yaha kaam hota hai kabhi nahi banega) is a bad decision.
16000 cr dedoge tho bhi architecture design nhi bnayigi construction company apne hisab se apna maximum profit nikle vo design bnayigi, budget is not issue will power is issue
@@kuldeepsuthar3259brother khud m Amrit Bharat ke station ka redevelopment kr rha hu civil engineer hu last 2 years se yahi kaam kr rha hu sb pesa kha jate h or kuch ni h
There's also a little bit to be said about our bad railway station design strategy and how it all links back to Indian railways' horrible on time performance, which means there's a lot more people reaching hours early to the station, sleeping on platforms, etc. This artificially inflates crowds at stations. If trains were actually on time, we wouldn't need to build massive railway stations with large waiting rooms, massive concourses, etc. and everything would be a lot cheaper to build. People would just reach the station 20 mins or so earlier and be off on their journey. (This applies less to stations with significant suburban train traffic which because of its frequency has this problem less) Just look at Shinjuku which handles the most passengers per year but still doesn't need massive concourses. Of course, this isn't a criticism of the current redevelopment project, which is desperately needed either way as our stations are in an extremely poor and sometimes downright dangerous state and I do also recognize the railways' (failed) efforts to improve their on time performance. The redevelopment is required also for other reasons, like separation of arrivals and departures and integration of modern tech into stations. Nor am I faulting the station designers, who can only design based on the passenger numbers they're expected to deal with. I'm just saying, that if the railways manages to solve its punctuality woes, they'd need to spend a lot less money building railway stations capable to handle higher peak traffic.
I will be honest, the new design of New Delhi railway station is actually not bad. Last one was a way too big, ambitious and kinda impractical in a sense that there is not enough space to make it. Especially in Daryaganj side. New building is much practical, simple and actually really good. You have to remember that architect designs are just concept and engineers specially don't usually agree with architects. Which is why it's important to make it practical while looking modern and aesthetic. Again new building is really nice and actually has good features. What we need is to complete the redevelopment of New Delhi railway station as soon as possible so that other stations get priority basis as well like Old Delhi station, Nizamuddin station and Anand Vihar. Especially Anand Vihar as RRTS project will go through this section
Fr, Anand Vihar can go a few more years imo, but Nizamuddin and Old Delhi redevelopment was needed YESTERDAY. Another project they need to put afterburners on is BIjwasan (at Delhi Airport) to relieve the pressure while the stations get rebuilt.
This is the mindset of Indian people, still living 20 years behind while all other countries think 20 years ahead and plan. When you are planning for a redevelopment, you should think about next 20-30 years and not current scenario
@@okolo8602 there is something called having too much thing. This old design proves it. That design wasn't feasible in current land area. Practical design always be superior to flashy design. The new design is simplistic but still more modern and pleasing for the eyes. Not saying old one is bad but it's not feasible. I live in Delhi. I know where it's built it's literally impossible to implement that design
Naya design accha hai. Priority should be to decongest and manage services efficiently. Environment friendly design is enough. Ambitious designs can be executed for Bullet train station
It's alright,we don't need world class railway stations. What we need is multiple high speed rail corridors and hopefully it's on. Saving Time and having comfortable journey is priority for many not World class railway station
जो दिखता है, वो बिकता है। पैसा, पैसे को खींचता है। अगर हम बिना world class infrastructure के रहे तो हमेशा गरीब ही दिखेंगे और दुनिया में negative image ही जाएगी। Delhi में तो Best होना ही चाहिए।
Ajib baat hai hydrabad banglore me new terminal railway station bane chuke hai or wo bhi world class design ke sath lekin main capital city me hi devlopment nahi hora
the government shouldnt have downgraded the design consider it for our capital city they could have waited or increase the budget but they back down such action shows our weakness
Literally this could be the game changer if it was done. Old design was the world's most unique railway station it has ever been seen and can be utilised as a future tourist destination. But unfortunately all we know is that India is the lost cause of hope. It's a mediocre country.
bjp govn ke paas kam se kam itna paisa to hai na , khangress ke paas to freebees ka paisa bhi khatam ho jaata hai , development sirf bjp ki bas ki chiz hai , baaki sab sirf naam ke padhe likhe hai bass
Akhli mehta gadhe apna mu mat khol yaha mujhe farak nhi padta congress pe kitna paisa tha bjp bhi hagg rhi h kuch nhi ukhada bjp ne, aur waise economy congress ke time pe jyada acche se china ko compete kr rhi thi har jagah congress congress
the new one is definately a downgrade from the original but is definately not bad. in fact i like it a lot. it is just that we had too much expectation
*Bhai India me kuch nhi ho skta, akela Modi kuch nhi kar skta, hamara societal structure, family structure and family values inherently flawed hai, anti development hai, isliye china nhi ban sktey ham uski wjah se* 1. Scientific Temperament bohot high h China me, communist education suppress karti hai supernatural cheezo me belief ko scientific abd rational thinking ko promote karti hai 2. One party system ki wjah se, opposition, Judiciary, Environment clearance bodies of govt, NGOs , Human rights, land owners, farmers ka ecosystem fasa nhi pata hai projects ko 3. China me land nationalization hua tha 1950s me, feudal system, bdey zamindaro ka system khtm ho gya tha wha, is se society equal ho gyi. Saari zameeney sarkar ki ho gyi aur 100 saal ki lease par zameeney equally distribute ki gyi. Is se sab ek level par aa gye aur jisne mehnat ki, talented tha jo whi upar utha aur society k power structure ka part bna. India me zameeney bech bech kar log upar uthey hai. Aur ye log mehnati, talented, rational nhi h.... Aur yhi log roda hai development me India ki 4. Indian family units bhi risk taking, entrepreneurship ko discourage karti hai. Baccho ko independent nhi honey deti, professional or personal decisions nhi lene deti families. Sarkari Naukri k pichey paagal kar deti hai baccho ko. Aur sarkari naukari is scale par kisi desh me nhi hoti isliye. Bohot saara youth aisey hi waste ho jata hai, tax collection nhi badh rha is liye. Ye kamiya kabhi india ko upar nhi uthney dengi, we are a society bound to corrode and fail and simply replaced by other cultures or societies
Rani kamlapati railway station render 🗿 reality 🤡. Gomti Nagar railway station render 🗿 reality 🤡. What I'm saying is render chahe jaisa bana lo. Reality fuddu hi hogi kyunki government ko freebies batni hai, mahila ko dena hai, expensive election campaign karni hai. Faltu chizo ke liye bahot paisa hai but kaam ki chiz ke liye nahi.
real mein banana easy hota practicality dhyan mein rakhna hota hai design banane mein easy hai engineering mein nhi isiliye gadiya bhi concept mein acchi hoti hai lekin real mein alag hoti hai
@@river. 4 baar jaa chuka hu ayodhya railway station. Dikhne me theek hai but cleanliness theek nahi hai. Har jagah pairo ke nishaan, toilet overflow, animals aise hi aa jaate hai. Aek taraf kaam chal raha hai aur bhi pareshaani hoti hai.
@@riderchallenge4250 I agree. But thoda to resemble karna chahiye na like gomti Nagar me to pura floor hi uda diya. Ye kis type ka tha?? Bus har jagah blue glass, everywhere glass glass.
Atleast the present government is trying to do something for us, the previous government even didn't think about that😂😂. The Congress government was always thinking about their personal property 😅
India ke capital ke sabse main station ke liye bhi kanjusi nhi krni chahiye ,china me to 2nd tier city ke railway station hmare capital ke station se bhi bahut jyada ache hai.
world class infra project is imp but.... not First priority.... First priority should be... basic clean amenities... like.... public restrooms clean streets... animal free streets... clean drinkable water from taps... most developed nations are this way... which big infra we know about nordic countries, new Zealand, Australia.... none.... but we are in competition of making tallest statues, mandir, .... and all other craps.... before investing on basic amenities.... most villages in India don't even have garbage Collection van, or Sewage system.... plastics are getting dumped into fertile lands
If you think it is soo easy to do it in a place where there is that many population, governance is hard also goverment is trying to provide basic facilities too but there are too many challenges which occurs I blame people more for our nation not devloped than goverment yes goverment plays a major role but if we look into public's role it's too less animal free streets wow bro it's people's fault again animals would go in streets if they don't have home they would stay in streets and we don't wanna adopt them because of some reasons we know what it is plus animal shelters don't provide too good facilities for them because of governance and people not really caring about them we indians mostly think public things as our own not in good way but bas way whatever we do why does it care it's our property much more and don't think like it's our property we should not cause harm to it also advantages of these world class infrastructure is a lot goverment will have to increase it's revenue too and it will help people near there too people's main priority is money mostly that's why also goverment is trying to help with these things but as citizens we should complain yes but we should help in these things too logically problems are created by citizens and it is solved by goverment to take credit
Brother please thinking rationality rather than this way of thinking negative thinking these things goverment invest is helpful our nation and our competition is world economies not Australia and newzealand currently
Brother if development is bad to you. Just become a normal person don't use ac, smart phones, no automobile, no pc no smartphone. Then your words will be high other wise we have been listening since 40 years these things
Mandir is not built by govt funds rather billions of rupees are taken from mandir earning via endowment act Don't bring mandir in each debate. We need all the development you mentioned no doubt in it But state municipal local all govts need to do it , not only central Infact most of the cleanliness work etc are in jurisdiction of state govts And all parties are horribly bad in states
The main reason is we made more government body than working professionals company in our country.. we waste lot of our hard earned money on them for just corruption and salary in last they used 40% of those money for relly of their party promotion.. we need DOGE concept which will be implemented by USA for removing unprofessional body and cut those spending
@@Sourav-hy3fb unlike USA govt bodies and employees in India have strong constitutional protection eg- Article 311 hence dept like DOGE won’t be of much help moreover all govt dept in India are mandated by law to be headed by an IAS officer, these guys will never let it happen, it’s beyond anyone’s sane mind why these people are given such special perks and privileges hence it’s near impossible to reform governance in India
@@harshitrai5306 next to impossible, these babus have strong constitutional and legal protections like article 311, IAS IPS PCS ETC officers are way too powerful in India and no govt will ever dare to touch them
I have an idea as a solution for this problem like if you will go by the new design there's no scope left for the old design to ever build until unless the the building is complety destroyed so why not we take a long time step by step approach to complete the building like for say 20 years in which under 4 stages whole structure would be complete but the station would be opened for use from the completion of stage one?
Allocate all the funds to fix air pollution asap. The air quality is poor all around the year except for winter when it overtakes severe category. Funds are limited, better to prioritise what matters the most
@@AmanKumar20_16 the money isn't coming from railway's ticket sales. Railways k paas khud ka itna paisa hota toh apne aap ko loss making nahi bataati. The station redevelopment is funded by taxpayers which can be used to prioritise the health of people instead
redevelop karna hi kyun hai jab adjust karna pad rha hai, adjust toh abhi kar hi rahe hai machli market jaise lagta hai, smell all over the place. What will change with this? I dont feel anything is changing except a new building. Its a total waste of money imo. Public ko acchi design dikhake bas chutiya banao elections ke waqt, aukaad ke upar ke sapne aur jab baat aati hai jeb dheli krni toh pair kaapne lagte hai. Delhi looks like a fkn slum compared to any capital in any world. African capitals look much better than delhi. Compromise hi karna hai toh development hi kyun krni hi? compromise toh ab bhi ho hi tha hai na?
How do you live with so much negativity? This is not the end of the world. This is just the beginning. Let them do what they have budget for. Future governments would improve it further.
@@julius7506 bro, maybe you dont know how much insane money indian government has and these guys still act like they are beggars. Also please, if you cant make your capital city atleast match standards of other third world countries, what are you even doing? I am not even asking you to compare to europe, or usa. I am asking to compare to philliphines, indonesia, thailand, vietnam etc. Whats the point of being top 3 gdp when your people dont have basic amenities like good public places. I am not living in negativity, I am living in reality. The future govt wont do shit if u and me and all other object and ask correct questions to the government. We need to be frugal and ask and demand results. Enough of being understanding and accepting failure of project and making them look like big success.
sahi bola bhai iss kaaran se india ke logon ka midset v waisa hi hogaya hai kaam chalau,NOT A SINGLE WORLD CLASS CITY IN THIS HUGE ASS COUNTRY what a shame
@@ayushporwal5950 You're right that Indian cities are not upto the standard they should be. It's mainly because of the inactivity or lack of vision of previous governments, which didn't focus on Infrastructure. But the current government, even not the best, but has made some significant improvements. Government set budget for every project at the beginning of a session. Some of the projects such as High speed rail are already running low on budget. And 1000+ railway stations are being redeveloped currently. That would surely be take lot of money. But no city can be developed in one go. There are other major issues in capital region, such as road traffic, pollution, poor city planning. It will take some time. Delhi hasn't elected BJP government since decades, but they always have complaints.
India needs a nationalist dictatorship for at least 50 years to solve its problems. A democracy with such huge divisions in the country will never prosper
3rd world infrastructure or 1st world infrastructure mey farakh toh hota hai kyuki 3rd world ki soch sey hum 1st world ka infrastructure nahi bana sakte
Desh mai 1 to achha design ban rha tha uski bhi esi tesi kar diye jab 5,000 jese ko ready thee govt to or 3,000 badha dete at least kuch to world class banta. Capital city hai 1 billion dollars to karch kar sakte hai railway station par
BJP good for nothing. Gujarat ke capital Gandhinagar me Railway station ke uper 5 star hotel bana diya. Lekin New Delhi ke liye paise nahi hai. Wah Modi Wah 👏👏👏
I am also happy with this new model if it ever comes to reality - Something is better than Nothing. You guys remember the building where G20 main metting was convened. The proposed design was looking so futuristic but what we actually get is a weird shaped building.
Wait for the reality. That roof will be typical indian railways style ugly cheap blue tarpoulin while the building will be a regular IT glass block like Rani kamlapati.
Delhi isn't the only one. *Bhubaneswar's initially Railway Station design (Pura Chad China level) 🗿🗿🚩.* *Bhubaneswar Railway Station's final concept art on the design: 🐶🐮🐶.*
😠😭मुझे लगता है कि रुक जाना चाहिए थोड़े आसपास की चीजों को क्लियर कर दो उसके बाद रेलवे स्टेशन फ्री डाउनलोड करना तब तक इसे छोड़ दो जैसा है वैसा ही,, क्योंकि पैसे के बचत के चक्कर में वह चीज निकालकर नहीं आएगी तो फिर कोई फायदा नहीं
Unfortunately Democracy which should be the boon for any country is becoming hurdle for India's development. China under its single party government is developing like anything and is leaving democratic India far behind
@AskPT If a new capital for India has to be made for replacing New Delhi (due to severe pollution), Where could it be made? And is it a good idea to make the 3rd Mumbai as the new capital?
Jruri to nahi tha vahi model bnana hai usi ko thoda change bhi kiya ja skta tha china japan ke railway stations se hi inspiration li ja skti thi .but kya umeed kr skte hai hmari govt se
All Gud.. No worries.. Country must go forward as per financial viability n need of the hr at different areas.. It can be achieved in future as govt knew how n wht to do.. Outsiders of govt mwy praise or criticize only as their feets are nt into shoes of govt.. B wise to as 50% indians dont support present govt so hv no right to preach they can only demean n they will do.. Keep it up India 🇮🇳💞💃
@@Vajra98 bhai I love bjp in centre but I'm so disappointed this time...bs kuch bhi krke ye design vapas nhi laa sakte kya? India me to petition sign krne ka bhi system nhi hai
इन रेलवे स्टेशन पर रिडेवलपमेंट करना मुश्किल है । क्योंकि ये घनी आबादी क्षेत्रों में बने हुए हैं । इसलिए सरकार बाहरी हिस्से के स्टेशनों पर अधिक ध्यान दे रही है । जैसे बिजवासन , आनदविहार , गुरुग्राम , गाजियाबाद , नोएडा , फरीदाबाद , जिससे नई दिल्ली के रेलवे स्टेशन पर बोझ कम होगा ।
This is one of the most significant issues with the Modi government; there is no doubt that the government is spending money on infrastructure across India, but they want everything at reduced or lower rates. This is the main reason why the E5 bullet train tender is stuck; what is the point of building Japanese bullet train tracks if the Japanese train will not come to India?
My opinion is atleast our capital station look big and modern, Delhi station should build by a chinese company their railway stations are very complex design. They make render to reality. I mean only delhi station should give to chinese
dude its not that we cant do it , we have all the things to make it but its just costly .As for foreign bidder I would say say they will charge more as compared to indian counterpart.
It's not like that we can't do. L&T was ready to implement and construct!! The problem came in the government spending. The government should have increased the budget, but they didn't..
This is not possible to build such design from scratch in center of delhi, that area very much crowded and surrounded by residential and markets, just look at the location of New Delhi railway station this hundreds of years old area
Its good, idk why but bjp government wants to build modernist glass buildings Most famous train / metro stations such as New yorks grand central or moscow metro station have great architecture , so we should make something similar
We can't even have a world class railway station even in the capital of the country. Meanwhile a normal metro station in a small town in China looks no less than an Airport. Seriously the change in the design is literally downgraded
Bhai mujhe bhi yah baat bahut buri lagti hai ki China ke sare bade stations world class infrastructure hai but India main aisa kuch nahi hota
I hope when India's economy increases to the level of China same happens in our country
The main reason is we made more government body in our country than working professionals company... Unnecessary wastage of money in corruption and salary for them
@Sh4aFFaChup kar kuch bhi bolta hai
@Sh4aFFa then you haven't seen much about Chinese infrastructures just search in RUclips you will see everything btw I'm not a Chinese supporter but the Chinese infrastructures are really appreciable!
Government ka soch hi galagt tha ki itna ambitious project sirf 5000 Cr me banjayega,government ko project ko around 8500 Cr pe hi done kardena chahiye tha ,itna world class railway station hum miss kardenge,this railway station could have even been a tourist attraction if well managed internally,this was so good we could have focussed on the Changi Airport model for this but sadly,it won't happen anymore,government ko freebies dene ke liye paisa hai padh itna achha kam karne ke liye nahi
Bhai Burj Khalifa 8000 cr me bna hai tu 8500 cr railway station ke liye dena hai vo bhi design koi extra ordinary nhi tha
Hamare yaha Aisa hi hota hai
~ socialism
ek station ke liye 8500 cr bohot jyada hai bhai
In some ways, I do also get the govts reluctance to spend 8500 Cr, pakke se koi na koi gadha aake bolta 'saar aap sirf dilli mumbai jaise shehro me paise lagate ho, what abt XYZ station in ABC' and it would've been bad politically. And it's not really worth 8500 Cr either, especially considering the cheaper cost of construction in India.
Would've been a good deal for 5k Cr tho
@@kuldeepsuthar3259bhai 8000 cr 2004-09 ke bich ka hai to abhi inflation ke rate hisab se kam se kam 15000 cr to hoga hi abhi ke time mein
It's a shame. We are almost a 4 Trillion USD economy. Building a 1.1 billion USD (7-8000 crore Rs) railway stations for the national capital, should be feasible. If govt didn't wanted to fully contribute the money, it could have sold the majority stake in Railway station for 40-50 years or so. It would have been a game changer for the image of Delhi. And could have attracted more real estate investments. Unfortunately, we have not been able to iconic building in the National Capital since independence. It doesn't have to be The Burj Khalifa, or Shanghai Tower, it could be more like The Vessel in New York.
Bhai 4 trillion jyada nhi he
Population or area bhahut jyada he
Europe ka area. Bharat jitana hi he per economy 24 trillion he
Abhi to hamari 70% population
Gareeb he 4000 rupee month kamati income increase hogi
Ho. Economy bhi increase hogi
Bro, you are somewhat right but we have to understand currently there are many projects that are ongoing. Not only railways, govt is spending on expressways, ropeways and airports also. They have to maintain budget for that also.
The people quality is beyond shit.....make a airport using that design
4 trillion gdp ha ,india ka budget 400 billion ha , usme aadha se jyada salary ,pension aur interest me dub jata ha ,baki me road, defence ,corruption aur ye,ab socho😂.
bhai dange ho jayenge agr railway ko private kiya toh , sarkar gir jayegi ,
Scorpio ke rate me fortuner maang rhi government 😂😂😂😂😂 kuch nahi ho sakta iss desh ka🥲
Fortuner khud 20 lakh ki hai uspr govt. 18-22 lakh ka tax lgati hai 😂
Very disappointed with the government, i am losing hopes in every filed... Indian government can't create something extraordinary, they should learn from our ancestors they where the masters in architecture 😔
Why should the government do something extraordinary? They can hardly do ordinary things properly😂😂
must have asked for 50% cut from the contractor. Thats why no one came.
Yup they can't make those things now even with any advanced tech
Jab reservation se log elect honge to skills kaha se aayenge..
Bhai yaha GST office mein Bina Bribe ke kuch pass nahi hota, idk what you are expecting.
Government ambition - 🗿🗿🗿
Government Action - 🤡🤡🤡
because of our people and their mentality, they don't want to pay anything
The thing is that India can't do complex design
More like can't fund complex design
it can easily. with the right funding and planning. it is not that hard. see the bangalore airport terminal 2 u will change your mind.
@@adithyaarun8465Bangalore Airport. It looks like shithole😅
Money Money. All the money for the freebies.But No money for 4 trillion economy country capital railway system.
Jitni badi aankhein hai utne hi bade sapne dekhne chahiye, this saying fits perfectly here
It’s the governments fault if they want big scale redevelopment they should increase the price a little
Paisa toh baant le pehle laadki behan schemes m
Government bolti h India Superpower bnayenge aur National capital ki railway station ki construction pe sirf 5000 cr. 8500 cr kr hi dete.. baar baar thodi na bnegi yeh railway station. Kya yeh indian government hai 🤡
Exactly bro kya aisahi infrastructure hoga? 8500 laga deta kya hi jata😢
@kakaliindia wahi toh fizool ki chizon me billions baha denge par yaha multiple decades ke liye 2-3 hazar cr extra nahi daal paa rhe
@@Kalankit5409 pta nhi bro kaash accha infrastructure india me aankho se dekh pata....lagta hai china jeisa communist party se hi kaam aage badte hai.....democracy only developed country k liyehi behtar hai
Thank you for this video, been hoping for one like this for long.
I'll watch now
Meko to pehle se hi pata tha ki jesi photos ye Amrit Bharat stations me dikha rhe hai wesa ghnta kuch nhi ban ne wala🤣🤣. Aur bhi dusre stations jinki design bht ambitious hai wo bhi ek dabba building banke hi rehne wale hai
Iss desh ko aesthetics se problem hai. Ek world class cheez toh banado. Ab har din jab bhi news padhta hu toh disappointment hi milti kuch acha kab hoga
It is shame for this government which talks so big but couldn't execute this project. It was their opportunity not only to prove to people of India but to the world, that India can execute a world class project. And India did deserve it especially in the capital city, just to feel proud.
First they show big dreams to people and then they silently cave out. There is not even any news on this. Ridiculous. This is a massive failure.
Indian government - Bilkul Risk nahi leneka!
Yaha government ki kya galti hai ?
@@parmanentdrawing825 Toh phir kiska galti hai?
even previous design was horrendous. I don’t understand why the government wants to build cheap copies of international architecture when India has such great contemporary and historical architecture
what chip copies dude that's a great design but because our railway staff I mean official staff are inefficient they don't have professionalism they are just like other government staff and don't have any skill to do that I think the government should privatize railways also batter safety, hygiene, and service to people
@ look at the UK railways after privatization. absolute disaster. government friends like Adani and Ambani will buy the rail infrastructure for paisa on the rupee and slash costs to maximize profits. As for the design, it is abhorrent. No thought for how it blends with surrounding areas, no local anchoring. It is car centric, de prioritizing other means of getting to the station, such as walking and biking. It is an inefficient design and has no place in Delhi
@@knutjonsson1816 dude if you need something batter you have paid for it and it's not government fault at all it's our education that only teach only theoretically that never helped us in the future we need quality education that can focus on Science Skill development and Innovation and also we need to change our mind like when you work hard for government survives but after you got the job do nothing and also never improve your skill set for that job it's the biggest upsets for our country and unfortunately more most of the government service man are doing that even A higher post Like IAS IPs IFS also and because of there inefficiency in that particular skill work hit back the common people Dude I studying In a engineering field I know the best for it
@ I agree, but that has nothing to do with what I wrote?
Bhai, govt paise bhi to dena nahi chhati, pehle ka budget 5k Crore (tenders 8k crore ka aaya isi liye cancel ho gaya) tha. Ab achanak se budget 2.5k crore pohonch gaya. Koi clarification bhi nahi, ki kab tak khatam hoga, kab issue hoga remaining tender, kya hogi final project ki value.
Mere opinion me agar pehle hi 5k crore ka budget tha, to achanak se plans ko 2.5k crore + future tender (jo jis tarah hamare yaha kaam hota hai kabhi nahi banega) is a bad decision.
16000 cr dedoge tho bhi architecture design nhi bnayigi construction company apne hisab se apna maximum profit nikle vo design bnayigi, budget is not issue will power is issue
Tenders ka system hi bakwas hai. Bc oligopoly ban rakhi hai
💯💯💯
@@kuldeepsuthar3259brother khud m Amrit Bharat ke station ka redevelopment kr rha hu civil engineer hu last 2 years se yahi kaam kr rha hu sb pesa kha jate h or kuch ni h
There's also a little bit to be said about our bad railway station design strategy and how it all links back to Indian railways' horrible on time performance, which means there's a lot more people reaching hours early to the station, sleeping on platforms, etc. This artificially inflates crowds at stations.
If trains were actually on time, we wouldn't need to build massive railway stations with large waiting rooms, massive concourses, etc. and everything would be a lot cheaper to build. People would just reach the station 20 mins or so earlier and be off on their journey. (This applies less to stations with significant suburban train traffic which because of its frequency has this problem less)
Just look at Shinjuku which handles the most passengers per year but still doesn't need massive concourses.
Of course, this isn't a criticism of the current redevelopment project, which is desperately needed either way as our stations are in an extremely poor and sometimes downright dangerous state and I do also recognize the railways' (failed) efforts to improve their on time performance. The redevelopment is required also for other reasons, like separation of arrivals and departures and integration of modern tech into stations.
Nor am I faulting the station designers, who can only design based on the passenger numbers they're expected to deal with.
I'm just saying, that if the railways manages to solve its punctuality woes, they'd need to spend a lot less money building railway stations capable to handle higher peak traffic.
Ahmedabad ka kalupur station me bhi development ho raha uski design bhi kafi acchi hai
I hope vo cancel na ho jaye
Don't think Gujarat's plans wil bel cancelled..
@rajavishnuvardhana6830 thanks 👍
Nice reply 🙂
Saari problem hai surrounding area chawri bazaar, paharganj or kuch area jhandewalan tak sab todna padega Laakhon logo ko vistaapit karna padega
Government ko budget increase karna chahiye the❤
I will be honest, the new design of New Delhi railway station is actually not bad. Last one was a way too big, ambitious and kinda impractical in a sense that there is not enough space to make it. Especially in Daryaganj side.
New building is much practical, simple and actually really good. You have to remember that architect designs are just concept and engineers specially don't usually agree with architects. Which is why it's important to make it practical while looking modern and aesthetic.
Again new building is really nice and actually has good features. What we need is to complete the redevelopment of New Delhi railway station as soon as possible so that other stations get priority basis as well like Old Delhi station, Nizamuddin station and Anand Vihar. Especially Anand Vihar as RRTS project will go through this section
where did u find the new design provide link pls
But it does look more like a typical hotel. I won't be surprised if some company with experience in making hotels take up the contract
Fr, Anand Vihar can go a few more years imo, but Nizamuddin and Old Delhi redevelopment was needed YESTERDAY.
Another project they need to put afterburners on is BIjwasan (at Delhi Airport) to relieve the pressure while the stations get rebuilt.
This is the mindset of Indian people, still living 20 years behind while all other countries think 20 years ahead and plan. When you are planning for a redevelopment, you should think about next 20-30 years and not current scenario
@@okolo8602 there is something called having too much thing. This old design proves it. That design wasn't feasible in current land area. Practical design always be superior to flashy design.
The new design is simplistic but still more modern and pleasing for the eyes. Not saying old one is bad but it's not feasible. I live in Delhi. I know where it's built it's literally impossible to implement that design
Indian government bhot kanjoos hai 😞
😂😂😂😂
Comment of the day
Naya design accha hai. Priority should be to decongest and manage services efficiently. Environment friendly design is enough. Ambitious designs can be executed for Bullet train station
bullet train mai bhi koi aisa under average sa bana ke chhod denge..they arent capable to execute anything world class
New wala design kahan dekha bhai?
It's alright,we don't need world class railway stations.
What we need is multiple high speed rail corridors and hopefully it's on. Saving Time and having comfortable journey is priority for many not World class railway station
bahut bahut dhanyawad bhaiya ji,aap YT par kaafi new topics par videos bana rahe ho.jise jankar bahut achcha lagta hai.❤
Similar design can be replicated for New Delhi Bullet train station in future.
जो दिखता है, वो बिकता है। पैसा, पैसे को खींचता है।
अगर हम बिना world class infrastructure के रहे तो हमेशा गरीब ही दिखेंगे और दुनिया में negative image ही जाएगी। Delhi में तो Best होना ही चाहिए।
Ajib baat hai hydrabad banglore me new terminal railway station bane chuke hai or wo bhi world class design ke sath lekin main capital city me hi devlopment nahi hora
Wahi to smvt bangalore jaisa hi Bana dete
Exactly the video i wanted. Nice
मैं बहुत खुश था इसके अपडेट को लेकर, लेकिन अब बहुत दुख हो रहा है कि ये नहीं बन रहा है
the government shouldnt have downgraded the design consider it for our capital city they could have waited or increase the budget but they back down such action shows our weakness
Literally this could be the game changer if it was done. Old design was the world's most unique railway station it has ever been seen and can be utilised as a future tourist destination. But unfortunately all we know is that India is the lost cause of hope. It's a mediocre country.
Which type of connectivities are planned in previous tender.And in current tender ??
Freebees के लिये पैसा है लेकिन development के लिए पैसा नहीं 😅।
India का कुछ नहीं हो सकता।
India can't never compete China, indonesia.
bjp govn ke paas kam se kam itna paisa to hai na , khangress ke paas to freebees ka paisa bhi khatam ho jaata hai , development sirf bjp ki bas ki chiz hai , baaki sab sirf naam ke padhe likhe hai bass
Isliye mai china mai ja raha hu.
India ek failed country hai.
Mai waha jaa ke China ki madad karunga India ko beat karne mai
Akhli mehta gadhe apna mu mat khol yaha mujhe farak nhi padta congress pe kitna paisa tha bjp bhi hagg rhi h kuch nhi ukhada bjp ne, aur waise economy congress ke time pe jyada acche se china ko compete kr rhi thi har jagah congress congress
@@DakshJee-xx7bj he isn't wrong tho. karnataka govt spent too much in freebies now they are facing financial issues
Why is karnataka government building railway station in Delhi ?@@adithyaarun8465
the new one is definately a downgrade from the original but is definately not bad. in fact i like it a lot. it is just that we had too much expectation
They should make it like Igi airport
Gujrat no govmment change no problem ❤
*Bhai India me kuch nhi ho skta, akela Modi kuch nhi kar skta, hamara societal structure, family structure and family values inherently flawed hai, anti development hai, isliye china nhi ban sktey ham uski wjah se*
1. Scientific Temperament bohot high h China me, communist education suppress karti hai supernatural cheezo me belief ko scientific abd rational thinking ko promote karti hai
2. One party system ki wjah se, opposition, Judiciary, Environment clearance bodies of govt, NGOs , Human rights, land owners, farmers ka ecosystem fasa nhi pata hai projects ko
3. China me land nationalization hua tha 1950s me, feudal system, bdey zamindaro ka system khtm ho gya tha wha, is se society equal ho gyi.
Saari zameeney sarkar ki ho gyi aur 100 saal ki lease par zameeney equally distribute ki gyi. Is se sab ek level par aa gye aur jisne mehnat ki, talented tha jo whi upar utha aur society k power structure ka part bna.
India me zameeney bech bech kar log upar uthey hai. Aur ye log mehnati, talented, rational nhi h.... Aur yhi log roda hai development me India ki
4. Indian family units bhi risk taking, entrepreneurship ko discourage karti hai. Baccho ko independent nhi honey deti, professional or personal decisions nhi lene deti families. Sarkari Naukri k pichey paagal kar deti hai baccho ko. Aur sarkari naukari is scale par kisi desh me nhi hoti isliye. Bohot saara youth aisey hi waste ho jata hai, tax collection nhi badh rha is liye.
Ye kamiya kabhi india ko upar nhi uthney dengi, we are a society bound to corrode and fail and simply replaced by other cultures or societies
Rani kamlapati railway station render 🗿 reality 🤡.
Gomti Nagar railway station render 🗿 reality 🤡.
What I'm saying is render chahe jaisa bana lo. Reality fuddu hi hogi kyunki government ko freebies batni hai, mahila ko dena hai, expensive election campaign karni hai. Faltu chizo ke liye bahot paisa hai but kaam ki chiz ke liye nahi.
real mein banana easy hota practicality dhyan mein rakhna hota hai design banane mein easy hai engineering mein nhi isiliye gadiya bhi concept mein acchi hoti hai lekin real mein alag hoti hai
Ayodya railway station mast hai reality mai bhi. Do visit everyone
@@river. 4 baar jaa chuka hu ayodhya railway station. Dikhne me theek hai but cleanliness theek nahi hai. Har jagah pairo ke nishaan, toilet overflow, animals aise hi aa jaate hai. Aek taraf kaam chal raha hai aur bhi pareshaani hoti hai.
@@riderchallenge4250 I agree. But thoda to resemble karna chahiye na like gomti Nagar me to pura floor hi uda diya. Ye kis type ka tha?? Bus har jagah blue glass, everywhere glass glass.
Gomti nagar is not that far off from the render tbh.
Kamlapati on the other hand....
Atleast the present government is trying to do something for us, the previous government even didn't think about that😂😂. The Congress government was always thinking about their personal property 😅
Nooooooo we want the dome design 😢 that would've solidified bjp even more
😢😢😢😢😢 yar kyo sarkar waise nhi bna rhai hai, wo hamare desh ki rajdhani hai
firstt brooo love youyuu
But I love the new design 😮
Smart and simple 😇
I understand, many people appreciate the new design.
@@PowerTrain where is the new design?
@@PowerTrain no its not it,s bad don,t you think that capital city deserve great things
and there is no news that it is cancel
India ke capital ke sabse main station ke liye bhi kanjusi nhi krni chahiye ,china me to 2nd tier city ke railway station hmare capital ke station se bhi bahut jyada ache hai.
ye scale down nahi ye fell down hai , kaha se jaha pohoch gaye ye.
world class infra project is imp but.... not First priority....
First priority should be... basic clean amenities...
like....
public restrooms
clean streets...
animal free streets...
clean drinkable water from taps...
most developed nations are this way...
which big infra we know about nordic countries, new Zealand, Australia....
none....
but we are in competition of making tallest statues, mandir, .... and all other craps.... before investing on basic amenities....
most villages in India don't even have garbage Collection van, or Sewage system....
plastics are getting dumped into fertile lands
If you think it is soo easy to do it in a place where there is that many population, governance is hard also goverment is trying to provide basic facilities too but there are too many challenges which occurs I blame people more for our nation not devloped than goverment yes goverment plays a major role but if we look into public's role it's too less animal free streets wow bro it's people's fault again animals would go in streets if they don't have home they would stay in streets and we don't wanna adopt them because of some reasons we know what it is plus animal shelters don't provide too good facilities for them because of governance and people not really caring about them we indians mostly think public things as our own not in good way but bas way whatever we do why does it care it's our property much more and don't think like it's our property we should not cause harm to it also advantages of these world class infrastructure is a lot goverment will have to increase it's revenue too and it will help people near there too people's main priority is money mostly that's why also goverment is trying to help with these things but as citizens we should complain yes but we should help in these things too logically problems are created by citizens and it is solved by goverment to take credit
Brother please thinking rationality rather than this way of thinking negative thinking these things goverment invest is helpful our nation and our competition is world economies not Australia and newzealand currently
Brother if development is bad to you. Just become a normal person don't use ac, smart phones, no automobile, no pc no smartphone. Then your words will be high other wise we have been listening since 40 years these things
Mandir is not built by govt funds rather billions of rupees are taken from mandir earning via endowment act
Don't bring mandir in each debate.
We need all the development you mentioned no doubt in it
But state municipal local all govts need to do it , not only central
Infact most of the cleanliness work etc are in jurisdiction of state govts
And all parties are horribly bad in states
@scenecorner9940 you don't understand... read it again...
The main reason is we made more government body than working professionals company in our country.. we waste lot of our hard earned money on them for just corruption and salary in last they used 40% of those money for relly of their party promotion.. we need DOGE concept which will be implemented by USA for removing unprofessional body and cut those spending
End bureaucracy
@@Sourav-hy3fb unlike USA govt bodies and employees in India have strong constitutional protection eg- Article 311 hence dept like DOGE won’t be of much help moreover all govt dept in India are mandated by law to be headed by an IAS officer, these guys will never let it happen, it’s beyond anyone’s sane mind why these people are given such special perks and privileges hence it’s near impossible to reform governance in India
@@harshitrai5306 next to impossible, these babus have strong constitutional and legal protections like article 311, IAS IPS PCS ETC officers are way too powerful in India and no govt will ever dare to touch them
Goverment just show big dreams but they aren't not ready for full fill them .
I have an idea as a solution for this problem like if you will go by the new design there's no scope left for the old design to ever build until unless the the building is complety destroyed so why not we take a long time step by step approach to complete the building like for say 20 years in which under 4 stages whole structure would be complete but the station would be opened for use from the completion of stage one?
Allocate all the funds to fix air pollution asap. The air quality is poor all around the year except for winter when it overtakes severe category. Funds are limited, better to prioritise what matters the most
And improving train services, possibly the most efficient means of transportation around would help save emissions and reduce pollution.
Clown
Pagal ho kya Bhai??? Railway apne paise railway pe n kharch kregi!!
@@AmanKumar20_16 the money isn't coming from railway's ticket sales. Railways k paas khud ka itna paisa hota toh apne aap ko loss making nahi bataati. The station redevelopment is funded by taxpayers which can be used to prioritise the health of people instead
Make glass structures in 35 C heat and humid nation. Great idea
redevelop karna hi kyun hai jab adjust karna pad rha hai, adjust toh abhi kar hi rahe hai machli market jaise lagta hai, smell all over the place. What will change with this? I dont feel anything is changing except a new building. Its a total waste of money imo. Public ko acchi design dikhake bas chutiya banao elections ke waqt, aukaad ke upar ke sapne aur jab baat aati hai jeb dheli krni toh pair kaapne lagte hai. Delhi looks like a fkn slum compared to any capital in any world. African capitals look much better than delhi. Compromise hi karna hai toh development hi kyun krni hi? compromise toh ab bhi ho hi tha hai na?
How do you live with so much negativity? This is not the end of the world. This is just the beginning. Let them do what they have budget for. Future governments would improve it further.
@@julius7506 bro, maybe you dont know how much insane money indian government has and these guys still act like they are beggars. Also please, if you cant make your capital city atleast match standards of other third world countries, what are you even doing? I am not even asking you to compare to europe, or usa. I am asking to compare to philliphines, indonesia, thailand, vietnam etc.
Whats the point of being top 3 gdp when your people dont have basic amenities like good public places. I am not living in negativity, I am living in reality. The future govt wont do shit if u and me and all other object and ask correct questions to the government. We need to be frugal and ask and demand results. Enough of being understanding and accepting failure of project and making them look like big success.
sahi bola bhai iss kaaran se india ke logon ka midset v waisa hi hogaya hai kaam chalau,NOT A SINGLE WORLD CLASS CITY IN THIS HUGE ASS COUNTRY what a shame
@@ayushporwal5950 You're right that Indian cities are not upto the standard they should be. It's mainly because of the inactivity or lack of vision of previous governments, which didn't focus on Infrastructure. But the current government, even not the best, but has made some significant improvements.
Government set budget for every project at the beginning of a session. Some of the projects such as High speed rail are already running low on budget. And 1000+ railway stations are being redeveloped currently. That would surely be take lot of money. But no city can be developed in one go. There are other major issues in capital region, such as road traffic, pollution, poor city planning. It will take some time.
Delhi hasn't elected BJP government since decades, but they always have complaints.
New design bhi badhiya h pr disappointed hu bhai mai, humari capital mei kuch bhi capital jaisa nhi h ek railway station to bana skte the world class
Now they should compensate by making the bullet train station like this
India needs a nationalist dictatorship for at least 50 years to solve its problems. A democracy with such huge divisions in the country will never prosper
The only global standard we have is corruption 😂🤡
Leave delhi , Delhi aqi is 1200 😡😡😡
Our people don't deserve good buildings......
Money for ladli behna yojana is available, But No money available for 4 trillion economy country capital railway system.
3rd world infrastructure or 1st world infrastructure mey farakh toh hota hai kyuki 3rd world ki soch sey hum 1st world ka infrastructure nahi bana sakte
Isme government ki galti hai government ko sahi price estimate Karna chaiye tha
Bureaucracy sabse bakkear hai is desh ki
Desh mai 1 to achha design ban rha tha uski bhi esi tesi kar diye jab 5,000 jese ko ready thee govt to or 3,000 badha dete at least kuch to world class banta. Capital city hai 1 billion dollars to karch kar sakte hai railway station par
Why so much high rate of redevelopment of new delhi station as compared to CSMT ?
Because new delhi is capital
@askpt where you get these designs plsss share and show completely
BJP good for nothing.
Gujarat ke capital Gandhinagar me Railway station ke uper 5 star hotel bana diya. Lekin New Delhi ke liye paise nahi hai.
Wah Modi Wah 👏👏👏
Chutiya gandhinagar railway station redevelopment cost 790cr ban bhi gayi
Gandhinagar railway station redevelopment cost 790cr ban chuka hai
Hence, proving the fact that India is 100 years behind China. India never fails to disappoint
Been following NDLS redevelopment since infranews in 2020. Honestly feel so sad to just hear this in infranews and not become a reality.
@PowerTrain is there any way to bring the dome like design back again?
Habibganj was a tiny station. NDLS is top 3 stations of Indian Railways Network, hence such "fairy" projects are impossible.
I am also happy with this new model if it ever comes to reality - Something is better than Nothing.
You guys remember the building where G20 main metting was convened. The proposed design was looking so futuristic but what we actually get is a weird shaped building.
Wait for the reality.
That roof will be typical indian railways style ugly cheap blue tarpoulin while the building will be a regular IT glass block like Rani kamlapati.
Saala yeh dukh kaahe nahi khatam hota be😭😭
@@soumyashankar7568
Also dehati crowd will be painting the interiors red while sleeping like animals in the terminal
Itni black pill bhi nahi deni thi😭😭😭
@@Vajra98 I still missed out the toilet maintainence and food hygiene/vendor overpricing part of station 💀
Hospitality should be paid a lot more attention in any railway redevelopment plans
We are mediocre country and we need to accept it
under average tbh.. even smaller countries like Malaysia Indonesia Vietnam do everything much better than us
@@devgupta3156they do take help from China though which we can't
Better, to develop new mega Station, with hope to shift Our Capital to new city. As New Delhi is facing many problems everyday...
Delhi isn't the only one.
*Bhubaneswar's initially Railway Station design (Pura Chad China level) 🗿🗿🚩.*
*Bhubaneswar Railway Station's final concept art on the design: 🐶🐮🐶.*
😠😭मुझे लगता है कि रुक जाना चाहिए थोड़े आसपास की चीजों को क्लियर कर दो उसके बाद रेलवे स्टेशन फ्री डाउनलोड करना तब तक इसे छोड़ दो जैसा है वैसा ही,, क्योंकि पैसे के बचत के चक्कर में वह चीज निकालकर नहीं आएगी तो फिर कोई फायदा नहीं
India can't make world class designs because we don't know how to do it out engineer architect and government is not skillful for such things
Redevelopment of any big railway station is not as easy as we think, it's too complex to execute
This shows we need better educational infra and investment in research and dev
Unfortunately Democracy which should be the boon for any country is becoming hurdle for India's development. China under its single party government is developing like anything and is leaving democratic India far behind
Democracy is bad for india. Vote bank and communal politics has destroyed india.
@AskPT If a new capital for India has to be made for replacing New Delhi (due to severe pollution), Where could it be made? And is it a good idea to make the 3rd Mumbai as the new capital?
Aur hum china se compete karenge 😂😂😂 India is 100 yrs behind China
Jruri to nahi tha vahi model bnana hai usi ko thoda change bhi kiya ja skta tha china japan ke railway stations se hi inspiration li ja skti thi .but kya umeed kr skte hai hmari govt se
Isse accha to Gomati nagar ka hai
All Gud.. No worries.. Country must go forward as per financial viability n need of the hr at different areas.. It can be achieved in future as govt knew how n wht to do.. Outsiders of govt mwy praise or criticize only as their feets are nt into shoes of govt.. B wise to as 50% indians dont support present govt so hv no right to preach they can only demean n they will do.. Keep it up India 🇮🇳💞💃
yeah keep settling for under average.. vishwaguru 🤡
Pandit ji itni andh bhakti bhi nahi karni hoti
@@Vajra98 bhai I love bjp in centre but I'm so disappointed this time...bs kuch bhi krke ye design vapas nhi laa sakte kya? India me to petition sign krne ka bhi system nhi hai
I am very sad because of this 😢
इन रेलवे स्टेशन पर रिडेवलपमेंट करना मुश्किल है । क्योंकि ये घनी आबादी क्षेत्रों में बने हुए हैं । इसलिए सरकार बाहरी हिस्से के स्टेशनों पर अधिक ध्यान दे रही है । जैसे बिजवासन , आनदविहार , गुरुग्राम , गाजियाबाद , नोएडा , फरीदाबाद , जिससे नई दिल्ली के रेलवे स्टेशन पर बोझ कम होगा ।
They're focusing way too much on big shiny redevelopment instead of focusing more on functional, basic improvements
Bro background music is too loud at last 2 min
We need to change our capital as soon as possible 🙏
kya faida ayise buildings banane ka jab pollution smog se kuch dikhe he na
No such financial obstruction while developing Gujarat's infrastructure. This govt is way too biased
This is one of the most significant issues with the Modi government; there is no doubt that the government is spending money on infrastructure across India, but they want everything at reduced or lower rates.
This is the main reason why the E5 bullet train tender is stuck; what is the point of building Japanese bullet train tracks if the Japanese train will not come to India?
My opinion is atleast our capital station look big and modern, Delhi station should build by a chinese company their railway stations are very complex design. They make render to reality. I mean only delhi station should give to chinese
dude its not that we cant do it , we have all the things to make it but its just costly .As for foreign bidder I would say say they will charge more as compared to indian counterpart.
It's not like that we can't do. L&T was ready to implement and construct!! The problem came in the government spending. The government should have increased the budget, but they didn't..
Bhai diamond tower ka updates or gifts city kai baraimay
U didn’t mention Chikadpally station of Hyderabad.
Its no less than a Mall
Kuch nahi ho sakta iss desh ka🤦🏻
This is not possible to build such design from scratch in center of delhi, that area very much crowded and surrounded by residential and markets, just look at the location of New Delhi railway station this hundreds of years old area
Rani Kamlapti station is not exactly same as the design actually selected
Feeling bad after hearing the scaling down of the New Delhi railway station.
Its good, idk why but bjp government wants to build modernist glass buildings
Most famous train / metro stations such as New yorks grand central or moscow metro station have great architecture , so we should make something similar
Ofcourse nothing is going to the world class or same this is India after all