Asus RT-AX3000 vs TP-Link AX3000 (RT-AX58U vs Archer AX55), What WIFI 6 router is better?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 4 окт 2024
  • НаукаНаука

Комментарии • 108

  • @KnowledgeSharingTech
    @KnowledgeSharingTech  7 месяцев назад +1

    Link to Asus AX3000 router: amzn.to/3tkVQGC
    Link to TP-Link Archer AX55 router: amzn.to/35gz4Yo
    Amazon links are affiliate links. I gain a small percentage at no cost to you if you make a purchase. This will help my channel. Thank you.

  • @jamesbensonjazzguitar4824
    @jamesbensonjazzguitar4824 2 года назад +13

    I really appreciate the detailed comparison. The case in favor of the ASUS RT-AX3000 is clear, and confirms my recent experience that ASUS is working to be a tech leader.

  • @thibodaux3424
    @thibodaux3424 7 месяцев назад +3

    Outstanding review my friend. I really appreciate the straight forward metrics of comparison and your test choices. Great work!

  • @Mujahed.
    @Mujahed. 7 месяцев назад +3

    Thank you so much for your honest and highly informative review. I just bought the Asus router since you've recommended it and hopefully setting it up would be easy. Wish I could support you more because you're very good at what you do!

    • @KnowledgeSharingTech
      @KnowledgeSharingTech  7 месяцев назад +2

      Glad I could help and thank you for your Super Thanks! Don't hesitate to look at my Asus routers playlist, it has many tutorials on configuring Asus routers: ruclips.net/p/PL3qGVpWh7QbPfuZjZRPNu0va-rK_TM5tJ

  • @wendellbanks6243
    @wendellbanks6243 Год назад +6

    Like someone below mentioned The Asus is on V2 it is now quad core 1.7ghz. there is no mention of V2 on amazon website but the box is different . The Tuf gaming model uses the same chip but offers Lan aggregation.The Amazon website list made in China but the V2 box says made in Tiawan

  • @danimadrid5454
    @danimadrid5454 2 года назад +16

    your comparison videos are great.

  • @yakumark
    @yakumark 2 года назад +7

    i like the way you test the product. this is something i haven't seen on other reviews.

  • @Hansy995
    @Hansy995 7 месяцев назад +2

    What an amazing review! I bought the AX55 but after I saw this review, I cancelled the order and got the AX58U. It's mainly the USB speed that sealed the deal for me.

  • @lamboiah
    @lamboiah 3 месяца назад +1

    Excellent review and comparison video my friend!! Your comprehensive run through is precisely what I needed to inform my purchase decision. I'm going with the Asus. I'm looking forward to it meshing with my existing Asus Wifi router.

  • @averyreddick5850
    @averyreddick5850 2 года назад +5

    Great valuable information. Truly appreciate the video!

  • @krzychaczu
    @krzychaczu Год назад +1

    I got a tp-link only because I haven't seen your video before I bought it...
    Great video, thanks! 👍

  • @Thats_Helpful
    @Thats_Helpful 6 месяцев назад

    Really great metrics and systematic scientific approach, brilliant

  • @steven_uni
    @steven_uni 3 месяца назад +1

    Trying both routes and some higher models just to select the best Parental Control,, Asus is Free and quick, TP-LINK should have more features but its costly and a little slow in login, the winner will be announced soon... one other thing the dual wan feature in Asus is awesome 👌

  • @joshz2491
    @joshz2491 2 года назад +4

    If you are doing a lot of online gaming or streaming on several devices at once in your household then ASUS is the way to go but otherwise TP Link is more than enough especially for the average user.

  • @RemoGaggi
    @RemoGaggi Год назад +1

    Thank you for the great video. I was looking at these 2 routers to buy and now I know it's the ASUS.

  • @davieS628
    @davieS628 Год назад +3

    Thank you for your videos. I gain valuable insight and information. I especially liked "Is it possible to connect a USB Hub to a router's USB port?" My first router was a TP-Link router. I never had any issues from that router. I never had to do a power-cycle on it. It ran continuously for three years with no issues until a thunder storm was passing through the area where I lived and lighting struck outside my house and sent over voltage into my router and fried it. My TP-Link router saved my computer because the lightning burned out my Ethernet port and the voltage could not continue to my computer. The Asus has better functions and performance, but reliability is very important to me. Is Asus build quality dependable in 2023? I built two computers in 2012 using Asus motherboards and I am still using them in 2023. Asus quality was good ten years ago. Items are cheaply built today often times using sub-par parts to cut corners and save money to increase company profits at the expense of the consumer selling them inferior products. Going solely on the routers spec, I would have to choose the Asus router, but I would spend a great deal of time researching the product. P.S. When the lightning strike the current ran through the internet connection through the ethernet connection. It even burst the gas line running to the house. 🙂

    • @KnowledgeSharingTech
      @KnowledgeSharingTech  Год назад +1

      Thanks. I've been using my asus RT-AX3000 router for 2 years and never faced any issue.

    • @swifty1969
      @swifty1969 11 месяцев назад

      What happened to you is why having an UPS is paramount, especially one that can provide pure sine wave power like the mains. I have all my valuable tech connected to pure sine wave UPS including my tp-link wireless router. My 3 active UPS saved my computer/external hard drive bays/lg oled 4K tv/wireless router/cable modem from power outs and brown outs many times.

  • @roguetune03
    @roguetune03 2 года назад +5

    Edit: If you are looking at the difference between the AX50 and AX55 as they are 98% the same device, go with the AX55 as TP-Link had promised features on the AX50 that instead of releasing via firmware update to the AX50....they pushed to the AX55 newer model and left the AX50 now dead in development. No new firmware in years. AX55 will allow SmartMesh mesh networking at home so that you can extend your wifi range across more devices. AX50 does not support this in the firmware. Software limited, hardware is fully capable. Screw TP-Link.
    I have the TP-Link Archer AX3000 (AX50...not the AX55 shown in this video). There are many issues with TP-Link. I have purchased their AX11000 and still hot garbage. Too many issues with TP-Link removing features from the firmware. Too little device control. Asus is better in every way. I returned the TP Link AX11000 (far and away a waste of money even comparing it to the AX50) and replaced it with the Asus RT-AX92U wifi6 mesh system. Far happier choice. Stay away from TP-Link unless you can't afford better. They temp you with marketing but their actual hardware is sub-par at best....has weird things it does where you cannot turn off the anti-virus, and cannot control QoS in the firmware resulting in loss of performance. ASUS over TP-Link every time for me now.

    • @skyhighsunlight
      @skyhighsunlight Год назад

      Me too. Bought ax 3000 tp-link model then returned it and bought asus ax55 router. Now want asus ax11000, or asus axe11000. But they are very expensive. And changing routers just because it is cooler to have a more expensive one is stupid. Asus is less laggy but has less wifi coverage. So they kinda the same shit. I am not happy with asus too.

  • @hippityhoppitus
    @hippityhoppitus Год назад +1

    Great review! Super detailed

  • @bianxuefeng9534
    @bianxuefeng9534 2 года назад +1

    Very good comparison, thanks

  • @3lectronic0
    @3lectronic0 6 месяцев назад +1

    Hi, I would like to know which one is more reliable and durable, because I have seen many negative comments on Amazon (about both), saying that they die in a few months, that they fail in less than 1 year, that they have connection losses Hangs-up and requires frequent reboots, etc.

  • @jackturner1446
    @jackturner1446 11 месяцев назад +1

    Great video! Very concise. Thanks

  • @sunnyvale104
    @sunnyvale104 Год назад +1

    Great video. Thank you

  • @tomsmith8515
    @tomsmith8515 5 месяцев назад +1

    Similar prices in new zealand
    Thank you for clarifying stuff as my huawii 6b-whatever’s might be 15 years old

  • @elephant1851
    @elephant1851 Год назад +1

    Glad I watched this.

  • @xayroMS
    @xayroMS Год назад +2

    Asus now is selling RT-AX58U and TUF-AX3000 in V2 version ;/ So custom firmware is not available and probably worse hardware inside... Did you test V1 or V2 version of RT-AX58U?

  • @drivingschool11
    @drivingschool11 2 года назад

    Great vid,! Good job but..I can't purchase them because they aren't compatible of FTTN (fibre to the Node)

  • @walterlee3013
    @walterlee3013 Месяц назад

    I just setup my new Asus AX57 with the help of your video and all is working great but now i want to use it as an access point because I it connected to my FIZZ modem/router and i have a dlink connected via cable directly also used as an access point with only the FIZZ assigning the DHCP, but for the installation of the AX57 Idisconnected the DLINK router for the installation but now that AX57 is connected can i disconnect the cable and use it wirelessly in another room as an extension to my access point

  • @jeffeisert2371
    @jeffeisert2371 Год назад

    Thank you for the review. I'm a parent with two gamer boys in the house. I needed a solid non hackable parental controls in my router. I had the Netgear nighthawk with Circle. But the circle software is not being supported and is now buggy. I'll be buying the Asus RT router though your link. Thanks,

  • @saudibrahim9044
    @saudibrahim9044 27 дней назад +1

    استمر 👍

  • @sneakwastaken
    @sneakwastaken Год назад +1

    The TP-Link is constantly reaching out for no legitimate reason to an Avira domain. The response from the company was obvious BS and unacceptable. This caused me to look for another one, and I decided on the AX58U.

    • @KnowledgeSharingTech
      @KnowledgeSharingTech  Год назад +2

      Good choice. Look at the playlist I made to configure all the advanced options on Asus Routers: ruclips.net/p/PL3qGVpWh7QbPfuZjZRPNu0va-rK_TM5tJ

  • @AliFOJ5
    @AliFOJ5 5 месяцев назад +1

    The fact that you can get AX73 AX5400 cheaper then the Asus RT is clearly way better option to get than Asus. Asus is way overpriced for what they are offering in hardware even if they have more software features

  • @jamesvw769
    @jamesvw769 2 года назад +6

    Asus hands down. TP Link dont support there products for very long you will be lucky to get maybe 2 firmware updates. Asus on the other hand does firmware releaes very often and for years normally about every 3 months.

    • @swifty1969
      @swifty1969 11 месяцев назад

      Exactly!. My current tp-link archer c3200 has been working flawlessly for many years but like you said, no more support. Also, the usb 3.0 port does not support usb hub wether it’s powered or not. For this reason, no more tp-link for me. My next router will be the asus shown in this video.

  • @rajapanios
    @rajapanios Год назад +1

    May I as which one could you pick between the asus ax 1800 and the tp link 3000? Its only 30 dollars difference, its for my 1 bedroom apartment, thanks for the amazig video!

  • @ekendraedrisinghe3428
    @ekendraedrisinghe3428 Год назад

    May I know if the ASUS free security features are applicable worldwide or restricted to the US and CA?

  • @kratos1619
    @kratos1619 2 года назад

    What is better a tp link wifi extensor or a Asus ac wifi extensor

  • @aspalahyia36
    @aspalahyia36 2 года назад +1

    Great review! Does both the routers provide equal range? Or Which one is better

    • @KnowledgeSharingTech
      @KnowledgeSharingTech  2 года назад +2

      Range is the same. If you need the additional features, go with Asus otherwise, both are equally good.

  • @nimeni.intamplator
    @nimeni.intamplator 2 месяца назад

    Probabil cel mai bun router Wifi 6, internet Digi 1Gbs + TP-LINK XZ000-G3 (GPON primit la instalare noua, automat in mod bridge).
    Setari recomandate:
    - AiProtection - Network Protection: On
    - Adaptive Qos - Bandwidth Monitor: Off
    - Adaptive Qos - Qos: Off
    - Traffic Analyzer: On
    - Wireless - General - Enable Smart Connect: Off (Recomandat, evitati probleme si incompatibilitati pe diferite dispozitive)
    - Wireless - General - Target Wake Time: Disable si pe 2.4 si pe 5 Ghz (Enable - activeaza internetul peste noapte, functie sensibila)
    - Wireless - Professional - Roaming Assistant - si pe 2.4 si pe 5 Ghz: Disable sau -70 dBm (Nimic diferit) )
    - Wireless - Professional - Modulation Scheme - si pe 2.4 si pe 5 Ghz: Up to MCS 11
    - Wireless - Professional - Multi-User MIMO: Disable (2.4 Ghz) Enable (5 Ghz)
    - Wireless - Professional - OFDMA/802.11ax MU-MIMO: DL/UL OFDMA + MU MIMO (5Ghz only)
    - LAN - DHCP Server - Lease Time: 86400 (pentru cei care fac streaming, live-uri sau joaca jocuri online)
    - LAN - Switch Control - Jumbo Frame: Disable (Recomandat)
    (Jumbo frame este de fapt NAT hardware - Daca selectati Enable boostează viteza (nu este necesar la Digi) însă poate cauza lag si delay în jocuri online deoarece internetul este filtrat prin procesorul routerului. Pe alte routere precum TP-LINK/TENDA/MERCUSYS functia este activata si ascunsa).
    - WAN - Internet Connection - UPNP: No
    - WAN - Nat Passthrough: PPPoe Relay: Disable
    - IPv6: Disable
    - Administration - System - NTP Server: time. Cloudflare. Com sau 1. Ro. Pool. Ntp. Org
    - Administration - System - Enable Reboot Scheduler: In fiecare zi (De preferat intre 6 si 8)
    Info:
    - nu setati securitatea parolei Wpa3 (unele dispozitive gen: aer conditionat, robot aspirator, tv, tableta, telefon, etc nu suporta Wpa3 si veti spune ca e de vina routerul).
    Semnalul trece prin tot apartamentul cu pereti grosi (bloc vechi). Pe banda de 2.4 Ghz dau net si la vecini 4-5 etaje.

  • @stanleybear3442
    @stanleybear3442 Год назад

    To pewnie v1 która jest trudno dostępna w sprzedaży teraz v2 która uwaga jest strasznie okrojona i nie pozwala wgrać custom roma pozdrawiam

  • @H3K36ME3
    @H3K36ME3 Год назад

    I choose Asus, and the reason for my choice - is this video review :)

  • @Mrfpsara
    @Mrfpsara 9 месяцев назад

    VPN wire guide compression please?

  • @xayroMS
    @xayroMS Год назад

    Well For RT-AX58U price there is AX72 and maybe AX73, should be tested too. : D

    • @KnowledgeSharingTech
      @KnowledgeSharingTech  Год назад +1

      I tested the AX-73 against the AX-55 here: ruclips.net/video/XUJS3156qKU/видео.html
      Comparing the Asus RT-AX58U to the AX-73 or AX-72 is not fair because the latter are AX5400 routers whereas the RT-AX58U is an AX3000 router

  • @BrolyDaApe
    @BrolyDaApe Год назад

    Which one is Best for PS5?
    Asus ROG Strix AX3000
    Netgear Nighthawk AC1900 (R7000)
    Something else

  • @mohamedfarouk87
    @mohamedfarouk87 2 года назад +1

    I want router with usb 3 , that can give me 100 mb/s when I copy from my computer to extrnal hdd that connected to the router usb and copy over ethernet ,, can you recommend one

    • @KnowledgeSharingTech
      @KnowledgeSharingTech  2 года назад

      The TP-Link AX73: amzn.to/3Coqp2d . Here's its review: ruclips.net/video/ma2kI1xoaL0/видео.html

    • @mohamedfarouk87
      @mohamedfarouk87 2 года назад

      @Knowledge Sharing Tech this copy test is over wi fi or Ethernet??

  • @tamasdebreczeni5335
    @tamasdebreczeni5335 2 года назад +3

    Useful video, but the asus is 2x $$$

  • @saednasr4996
    @saednasr4996 2 года назад

    Hi, nice channel... What is the diference between rt-ax1800 and rt-as1800s?

  • @Tagalized
    @Tagalized Год назад

    which router has a gaming port priority mode??

  • @A7单车俱乐部缪祥
    @A7单车俱乐部缪祥 2 года назад

    could you please compare the WIFI6 AX 3000 of ASUS/Tplink with Huawei AX3 quad core .

  • @bassyey
    @bassyey 2 года назад +1

    TP-Link QoS sucks. Enough for me to not buy it.
    Great comparison. TP-Link sucks. Software and features are very important to me.

  • @johnfr2389
    @johnfr2389 Год назад

    How does the QoS feature compare?

    • @KnowledgeSharingTech
      @KnowledgeSharingTech  Год назад +1

      The Asus QoS is in a league of its own and advanced. The TP-Link QoS is basic. Here's a video explaining Asus QoS: ruclips.net/video/YU7X6CE6iqI/видео.html

  • @derkater6611
    @derkater6611 2 года назад

    8:22 very slow, my Archer C2 V1.0 Copy with more than 100MB/s from PC to Laptop over Ethernet Cable. Why are the new Routers so slow?

    • @joshz2491
      @joshz2491 2 года назад

      His ISP plan is only 100mbps, it’s not the routers, you will always get less than whatever your plan maximum is

    • @kevindiehl3713
      @kevindiehl3713 Год назад

      He is testing over wi-fi, not Ethernet.

  • @Moroo1976
    @Moroo1976 Год назад

    Hello ..your video cool thanks>>>plz can you give me your opinion about this router ( ASUS RT AX86S Wi-Fi 6 DualBand Gaming, Ai Mesh, AiProtection, Torrent, Bulut, DLNA, 4G, VPN Router Access Point )

  • @نورالحقيقة
    @نورالحقيقة 6 месяцев назад

    What about asus rt ax57, can it just block for example the snapchat app or tiktok app but not the possiblity to work on youtube app?

    • @KnowledgeSharingTech
      @KnowledgeSharingTech  6 месяцев назад +1

      If you want to block websites, use this method: ruclips.net/video/HdBKEYc-zJE/видео.html

    • @نورالحقيقة
      @نورالحقيقة 6 месяцев назад

      @@KnowledgeSharingTech thank you for answering me . Is this method working for apps too?

  • @liverpoolfowler7587
    @liverpoolfowler7587 Год назад

    Which one has wifi repeater mode?

    • @KnowledgeSharingTech
      @KnowledgeSharingTech  Год назад

      Here's how to setup the Asus as a WIFI repeater: ruclips.net/video/XFNb7pggbVs/видео.html
      As I recall, the TP-Link doesn't have a repeater mode

  • @atirekverma808
    @atirekverma808 Год назад

    Asus ax53u(ax1800) vs TP link archer 53(ax3000). I am confused since TP link has ax3000 compared to asus' ax1800 but asus has generally better routers. I am getting both for exact same price. Please help

    • @KnowledgeSharingTech
      @KnowledgeSharingTech  Год назад

      Asus AX1800 will be slower then the TP-Link AX3000. The advantage of the Asus router is that it has many more features then TP-Link

    • @atirekverma808
      @atirekverma808 Год назад

      @@KnowledgeSharingTech So what would you suggest I pick for the same price ?

  • @ijws2058
    @ijws2058 2 года назад

    What modem goes with the Asus router

  • @hwangjoni3003
    @hwangjoni3003 2 года назад +1

    TP-Link does not support OpenVPN VPN server, major security issue. Asus does

  • @mirvan1302
    @mirvan1302 Год назад +1

    Lol the price is different 30 dollar, this is not fair

  • @markippo
    @markippo Год назад

    It's a little bit weird comparison... A58U is a mid-range router. AX55 maybe an upper tier but still a budget one... It's not a shocker that Asus wins... But if we compare apples to apples (same price range) e.g. Ax73... I'd say Tp Link is better. Firmware-wise I still prefer Asus. Tp Link with its "dlc" approach should... Reconsider at least...

    • @KnowledgeSharingTech
      @KnowledgeSharingTech  Год назад

      The criteria I chose for this comparison is that both routers are AX3000

  • @OfficialInformationMedia
    @OfficialInformationMedia 10 месяцев назад

    Tp link tech doesn't last long. And when they fail customer service doesn't want to know. I had to land plugs they stopped working when I called Tp they said they no longer support it

  • @Chris-rb5hx
    @Chris-rb5hx 8 месяцев назад

    TP Link cost RM249
    Asus cost RM468
    Malaysia currency

    • @KnowledgeSharingTech
      @KnowledgeSharingTech  8 месяцев назад +2

      The Asus router is worth every penny and all its security features are free whereas most of the security features of TP-Link are paid subscription. On the long run, the Asus is a much better value

  • @walter2065
    @walter2065 11 месяцев назад

    tplink is unsafe in this modern times,dont buy it

  • @dibu28
    @dibu28 Год назад

    Asus

  • @asandrius86
    @asandrius86 2 года назад +1

    tp link is 2x cheaper

    • @dominow2121
      @dominow2121 2 года назад

      not rn as the asus has been on sale in several places

    • @dixonbidenzmouth4115
      @dixonbidenzmouth4115 2 года назад +1

      Tp link---$130
      ASUS-. $ 160
      8/22. ON AMAZON

  • @skyhighsunlight
    @skyhighsunlight Год назад

    Routers are terrible as internet connection devices. They lose speed very quickly the further away you from a router. And asus better but so much more expensive. And you dont get premium from asus you just get average.

  • @ballsdeep9648
    @ballsdeep9648 Год назад +10

    Another thing to be aware of is that TP link is a Chinese based company and Asus is a Taiwanese based company. Another plus in my book.

    • @Chris-rb5hx
      @Chris-rb5hx 8 месяцев назад

      TP Link is a Hong Kong based company founded in 1996. The price is big difference between the 2 products in this video.

    • @ccc3
      @ccc3 5 месяцев назад

      ​@@Chris-rb5hxTP-Link headquarters is in Shenzhen

    • @AliFOJ5
      @AliFOJ5 5 месяцев назад

      Yeah that is why I went with TP link for sure