@Steven Singh *The truth will set you free* ;) Garuda Purana 10.42 “When a woman burns her body with her husband’s, the fire burns her limbs only, but does not afflict her soul” Tr. Ernest Wood and S.V Subrahmanyam, Edited by B.D. Basu. Brahma Purana 10.75 “Dying Immediately after the husband is the greatest duty of women. This is the path laid down in the Vedas. [77] The woman who follows her husband shall stay in heaven for as many years as there are hairs in a man’s body, viz. three and a half crores of years.” Tr. Board of Scholars, Edited by J.L. Shastri Parasara Smriti 4.28 “A widow, who immolates herself on the same funeral pile with her deceased husband, resides in heaven for ten millions of years, which is the number of hairs on the human body.” Tr. M.N. Dutt *For more information read the article Sati Pratha: The burning of widows.* Even a animal like cow is given more importance and respect in Hinduism than women. Women are treated like a commodity. Hinduism has deprived women of their basic rights. It confines them to four walls of the house. Women in Hinduism is nothing but a child production factory and sex object.
@Dow Jones Amongst those who stayed were Omar and Abu Bakr. In other words you have no point and all your false ahadith have been debunked a thousand times.
Dow Jones "you only strengthen the Shi'i case of taking those who are presumed to be infallibles (Ahl al-Bayt) over fallibles (Umar) for their religion." *That is their belief without evidence from the Quran and established Sunnah and they are entitled to it. My statement is true and I don't care if it strengthens their belief. It is not a competition for me.*
Because you don't know how to judge things... when you judge things according to..."what if it was me".... I'll ask everyone.... who knows or out of 10 cases... who knows you more than you're own family...1.... if women where giving authority will Fatima would've been the first caliph?.... i barely hear muslims talk about pbuh family... only sahaba... we should understand that only the pbuh family will know or must have known him better which is...fatima, the wives, Ali his cousin, then friends or so called sahaba... when you look at the history of the world, only few believe and only few knows the truth about deceptions... so everytime I watch Shia vs sunni... the Shia makes strong points... but to be honest like I always say... the enemies of humanity already was waiting for the truth to die so they can pay, write and corrupt history...I feel they wrote 90% of Sunni and Shia books... the evil ones are set up like hyenas they wait till you finish the job and bring "organised chaos".... that's how they did with the pbuh&F... they wait and tried during his life and after... and I tell you muslims something.... do you think the devil will ever leave mankind in peace? He was there right from Adam so why not fight to the end which anyone would do... once you know you have nothing to lose anymore then you fight till the end so I don't blame The devil... it's only natural what he's doing and also God has to take part because so no one will have an excuse on the day of correction... so I ask.... who knows how the pbuh eat sleep drink talk laff and how long he stays up at nights...is it sahaba or his family?(wives,daughter and cousin and in-house slaves or helpers ) ?...but in the end I also don't condemn the caliphs just because everyone has an agenda and everyman is an opportunist...i always say if the powerful ones don't display their powers then the weak ones will f*#$k with them just to either try be like them or test their might so they could feel if they don't rule then their clans might become slaves or insignificant God bless all humans
I’m sorry but where are your Sunnis? And what have they done to preserve our religion? All they have done is shown a barbaric wahabi image. What has the Shia shown? They have preserved the prophets message due to the sacrifices of the ahlulbayt. The Shias have preserved and have not let the sacrifice of the prophet and his family go to waste. Look at how strong Hussein’s legacy is and look how it is presented to the world every year during Muharram. Why don’t they have a day for Omar? Abu Baker or uthman? I’m sorry but it’s the truth. You guys really need to educate yourselves and get rid of the hate in your hearts. Accept the truth and reality. The reality that abu sufyan and his lineage has tried to destroy our prophets message and his families blood line, all for power? Shame on them. May Allah guide all of us in the right path. The Ahlulbayt is not just for Shias. They are for alllll humanity.
Again a great performance of brother Adnan. The more I see Shia discussing there view, the more distance I see between them and our prophet Muhammad saw.
When adnan said that y ali(r a.) sent his two sons to protect umer farooq(r.a.) abu qaraar says that "ohhh its not like that hmmm this or that etc ' And He accpt this also.. But when Adnan resonds on burning the house 0f fatima(r.a.) Adnan respond on that y Ali and other sahaba didn't say or did anything in respone . But then abukarar starts to 25:9 shout by saying misguided view. Hippocracy beyond the level..😡
i think most of shias dont know the false teachings of shia scholars, for example that the quran is not complete like they say etc.. May Allah swt. guide shia sincer people to the stright part. Amin Beware of false scholars. May Allah swt. guard us against false scholars. Amin.
Brother adnan is best knowledgeable person in sunnies allah gave him everything my allah helps him to give dawa to every non believer in world but the shia are blind they know the truth but they did not agree with that my allah guide them allah hu akbar
this is history you can not just delete it because it contradicts your believes............ read Battle of the Camel and Battle of Siffin, you can not logically follow aisha , ali and muvia at the same time ( the fought against each other ), lots of people died , someone is responsible , if you follow both sides of a battle you are in DEEP contradiction ,,,,, ......... someone : oh God I am sorry that I caused hundreds of people die , God : you are sorry then, OK your forgiven, and no one is responsible for the murder , ( does this makes sense to logical people? )
Wtf adnan is useless. Like bro he's only good at strawmaning and speaking over people. And then when people speak over him he acts like he never does the same to anyone else.
It's funny how Abu karar took out Ali r.a decision giving his daughter to umer r.a and kept on his ignorance about umer r.a burning house of Fatima r.a lol. Like he wanna ignore umm kulthum and Ali r.a decision from the picture . This is what u call kufr and jahalat . Which their majlks teach them
The Prophet Muhammad (ﷺ) said, "For whoever among you lives after me will see much discord. So hold fast to my Sunnah and the Sunnah of the Rightly-Guided Caliphs who will come after me. Adhere to them and hold fast to them. Beware of Bid'ah (in religion) because every Bid'ah is a misguidance." [Abu Dawud and At-Tirmidhi].
But what if i fight the rightly-guided caliph of my time? Am i not going against the Prophet and therefore against allahs swt. command? Questions over Questions 😐
last whole night I passed watching these debates. Adnan Bhaizan you are too modest and have great patience. But when the time will come these stubborn Shia brothers will understand the original issue that they are originally making the whole deen fragile with their implausible arguments.
Adnan rashid has got these guys by the horns he is crystal clear but these guys don’t want to hear the truth but only want hear what they believe to confirm what they are doing is correct
There is nothing you can do when all your life you spent abusing and cursing the Sahabas... thinking them as Netanyahus, and then someone pulls the carpet from under your feet and now you can do nothing but shout and somehow hold your ground and satisfy your own conscience that you were right.
Suppose that the history of Shiites concerns Abu Bakr and Omar (Radi Allah Aanhom) is correct, why they do not do like Ali (Radi Allah Aanhom). they claim to follow the traditions of Ali who did not insult or fight Abu Bakr and Omar ??? They claim that they follow Ali but they are far from his morals!!
What was Ali's Response? Thats the answer. Shia make a made up historical context. He says what if Ali did not exist 😂😅 And someone threaten fatimah? Lol far out man Thats a whole different point
Abu karrar's whole point was: -have adnan look at islamic history through a straw - remove all context - remove all important characters - hypothetically remove everything from this historic narrative except this one event - now that all of these conditions are complete, abu karrar tells adnan "this is the event that took place, what would you think about this person (omar) if this event happened" This logic is so warped, flawed and honestly if I'm a shia, I'm embarrassed that abu karrar took this route. Completely and utterly embarrassed.
Cadillac Williams If you look at Shias you find that their logic isn't flawed. They mention clear historical events that are accepted and clear verses like the event of ghadir or moment of revelation for the verse of wilayat. The Shias are also distinct in their theology in that they are the only sect that don't believe God is composite or has parts, whether those parts are like anything of the creation or not (for example God having a hand which wahabis would insist are nothing like our hands etc).
Who said that? If someone who doesn't like the Shias very much says something about Shias how reliable do you think that is in representing what Shias believe? Who said Shias take greater importance to knowing the birth of Imam Hussain over the prophet and others? No scholar that I am aware of even says that we need to memorise the date of birth of any member of ahlulbayt or any prophet I mean are there no topics more important than that like seeking knowlegde, Islamic history, reading Quran etc? If you remember the birth of the prophet then great if you don't then it doesn't mean you don't love the prophet I mean let's be honest how many people possibly including yourself is jumping on the bandwagon and yet also did not know the birth of the prophet but still making a youtube comment lol
According to shias Ali R.A didn't deffend his own wife and the daughter of RASOOLULLAH SAW he was not been able to defend her from the oppressors but today's shias defending her and in the return they go to home's and calling Ya Ali Madad ? Not making any sense.....
@@Shiraz687 this already about politic..at that time...iranian hate the leader from arabian since muhamad saw die..btw please read the story of islam..my english is not good enough
This division is dangerous and it's only going to hurt Islam. At the end of the day, we should get over our differences and love and respect each other because we are all Muslim.
Dow Jones Maybe Imran Shaik meant that some of the ideological beliefs shias have came from Ibn Saba. "Jafar as Sadiq cursed Ibn Saba" and "Fabled Ibn Saba did not exist." *Which 1 is true? Jafar as Sadiq cursing or Ibn Saba not existing?*
@Dow Jones Well It is not a surprise because some of the shia hadith narrators are also cursed by imams and shias still take their hadiths. So following some concepts of Ibn Saba is not far fetched. And how do you prove that he was a different person?
@Dow Jones Which kufans are condemned in Sunni hadiths? You are making the same mistake here that Christians do when they translate the Verse "Kill the disbelievers". If all Kufans weren't condemned then the hadiths and the transmitters can be scrutinized and then accepted. You are saying that you are not a shia but you bring the arguments of shia. But it is okay. All I can suggest is watch the "origin of Shia" by sunni defense channel. They give some detail about Ibn Saba.
Imran Shaik Brother I am not going to accuse him of pretending. I don't know him and I don't want Allah to get angry with me because of wrong accusation.
They don’t know the simple rules of communication which is one talks and the other listening. They both take terms, they don’t interrupt each other. Civilized people understand these rules.
The Shiahs' contemplation along this path of thinking is regrettable, they overlooked when the Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) said: "If there were to be a Prophet after me, it would have been Umar bin Al Khattaab" (Saheeh At Tirmidhi - Vol 6, Hadith 3686). How could they possibly hold such a belief about Umar bin Al Khattaab? 😢 May Allah guide them.
Brother Adnan...as usual you make logical sense and you did so when you made the point of why Ali gave his daughter to Omar and so on. However i have 2 questions...1, did Omar actually say he wanted to burn the house of Fatima down or is this just a shia claim? And 2, if the answer is yes then why was this?
This issue of Omar harming Fatima is total Bogus. Shia even talked about this, those who are sane. I will try to get the link for you a Shia talking about this.
@Dow Jones Fact of matter is the account found in the other Hadith book has nothing to do with this version that has been embellished beyond recognition. Further more, that account itself is weak. So how many lelevs do you want to jump to believe mumbo jumbo made up stuff? I guess as Shia, anything as long as it said by Ayyatullah.
Imagine a Robber robs a woman. The Police honors him by giving him a medal. Does that make sense? If Umar (r.a.) really did a grave mistake, how can Ali (r.a.) side with him? Won't Allah punish both? (Nauoothu Billah). No matter how oppressed you are, u wont side with a criminal! We fear Allah more than we fear anyone else and Ali (r.a.) is best amongst us in this....
Ustaz rashid fatality K.O them...u all know your wife and kids birthday and mother ..u claim to love the prophet s.a.w but none of them know his date of birth..none knows the alu bayt date of birth including ali (r.a) ... fugazzy love 😅😅😅
Why fight about any of Ali Hassan, Hussain, Uthman, Ayisha, Kolsoom... all of them Allah willing has already been assigned Bashaara. Why do we detract!!!!!!!
Exactly we were not there at that time so we have no say, Allah alone will do them justice. we Muslims today need to follow Islam and fulfil our duties as a Muslim without going into this political fight
Did Imam Ali not get framed for the killing of uthman.. this is exactly the reason why imam Ali protected uthman to show that he wasn’t the one who killed uthman, but people still faught imam Ali a.s even after protected uthman (battle of the camel).
Brother Adnan we as a Shia consider you Shia but you need to purify your heart and mind and accept Shia whole heartedly. It’s very hopeful that Shia and Sunni are debating together. I just love Adnan and kerrar for doing great job.
@@BO-rj2zj sunni does not hate ali, And islam is a political centric religion, read the incident of banu qurayza, our prophet fought, defend and conquer because that time he was a stateman also You can call sunni kafirs But cant realize that the doctrine of imams are same as christianity Shia claim that they are true But cant say how I saw some alawis pray towards caliph alis portrait So much idiolizing of humans will turn you ido worshipper
U wish he is shia because his knowledge is too great for shia to deal with ….he is Muslim and will remain Muslim Insha’Allah…shia is illogical and does not attract people with knowledge and pure hearts ….but bravo for trying
Umar at Fatimah's house refers to the event where Umar and his supporters went to the house of Fatimah, the daughter of the Islamic prophet Muhammad, shortly after Muhammad's death in order to get the allegiance of her husband Ali and his followers. This event, which has mentions in Shia, Sunni, and western academic books, is also claimed by Shia sources[1] to have led to Fatimah's miscarriage of her son Muhsin ibn Ali,[2][3] as well as her own death shortly after.[4] However, the veracity of the account is disputed, with beliefs being primarily split on sectarian lines between Sunni and Shia denominations After the gathering at Saqifa, Umar (who had been among Abu Bakr's advocates) and his supporters were allegedly sent by the new Caliph to Ali's house where Ali, Fatimah and some of their allies were gathered.[12] Several scholars, such as Al-Tabari and Ibn Qutaybah, narrate that Umar threatened to burn the building down if Ali refused to acknowledge Abu Bakr's authority, with Al-Tabari adding that Umar's men beat Ali's friend Zubayr ibn al-Awam.[13][14][15][16]According to the Al-Imama wa al-Siyasa (mistakenly attributed to Ibn Qutaybah),[17] when Umar was informed that Fatimah was inside the house, he responded that her presence made no difference to him.[18][19] While the historian Al-Baladhuri states that the altercation never became violent and ended with Ali's compliance,[20] and Tabari makes no mention of Fatimah's involvement,[13] some traditions add that Umar and his supporters forcibly entered the house, resulting in Fatimah's miscarriage of her unborn son Muhsin.[21] Twelver Shia sources state that this occurred when Umar forced the front door open, crushing Fatimah behind it and breaking her ribs.[1]However, the Mu'tazilite theologian Ibrahim al-Nazzam narrates that, "Umar hit Fatimah (sa) on the stomach such that the child in her womb died."[22]Alternatively, Ibn Rustam Al-Tabari states that it was a client of Umar's named Qunfudh who caused the miscarriage, having struck her with the sheath of his sword.[23] Other traditions add that Qunfudh had her whipped[24] or had struck her face.[25] The Kitab Sulaym ibn Qays (attributed to Sulaym ibn Qays, but possibly a much later creation)[26] concludes the incident with Ali being dragged out of the house with a rope tied around his neck.[27] Mohammad-Baqer Majlesi, writing in his Bihar al-Anwar, states that Fatimah died soon after due to injuries sustained during the altercation.[4] The aforementioned Al-Imama wa al-Siyasa records that before her death, Fatimah said to Abu Bakr and Umar, "I take Allah and the angels to be my witness that you have not pleased me; on the other hand, you have angered me. When I shall meet the Prophet (S) I will complain about you two."[28] According to Morteza Motahhari, she asked Ali to bury her at night to ensure that none of her enemies participated in her funeral.[
See how inconsistent is abu karaar is 32 :31 se said that we will first look at that hadeed in kafi becoz all shis don't belive in it completely and if it is there then we hve narrations that Ali was forced to do that ... All rafidus r liers May Allah deal with them.
May allaah preserve and protect ustadh. Adnan
Steven Singh
there is no posision in kufaaris here man
get out of here
@Steven Singh
*The truth will set you free* ;)
Garuda Purana 10.42 “When a woman burns her body with her husband’s, the fire burns her limbs only, but does not afflict her soul” Tr. Ernest Wood and S.V Subrahmanyam, Edited by B.D. Basu.
Brahma Purana 10.75 “Dying Immediately after the husband is the greatest duty of women. This is the path laid down in the Vedas. [77] The woman who follows her husband shall stay in heaven for as many years as there are hairs in a man’s body, viz. three and a half crores of years.” Tr. Board of Scholars, Edited by J.L. Shastri
Parasara Smriti 4.28 “A widow, who immolates herself on the same funeral pile with her deceased husband, resides in heaven for ten millions of years, which is the number of hairs on the human body.” Tr. M.N. Dutt
*For more information read the article Sati Pratha: The burning of widows.*
Even a animal like cow is given more importance and respect in Hinduism than women.
Women are treated like a commodity.
Hinduism has deprived women of their basic rights.
It confines them to four walls of the house.
Women in Hinduism is nothing but a child production factory and sex object.
Amin
Amiin
Imagine the amount of hasanats Omar (ra) gets from all the shia cursing him... mountains and mountains.
Dow Jones
Sorry to inform you but Sunnis don't believe that Sahaba were Infallible.
So what is your point?
Haha.. The rafida invent stories and expect us to believe them.
@Dow Jones Amongst those who stayed were Omar and Abu Bakr. In other words you have no point and all your false ahadith have been debunked a thousand times.
Dow Jones
"you only strengthen the Shi'i case of taking those who are presumed to be infallibles (Ahl al-Bayt) over fallibles (Umar) for their religion."
*That is their belief without evidence from the Quran and established Sunnah and they are entitled to it. My statement is true and I don't care if it strengthens their belief. It is not a competition for me.*
Dow Jones
You didn't give the reference of the Hadith.
By the way writing LOL doesn't make the hadith and your argument valid.
I've never seen a Shia win wallahi.
Hatem Elsharidy agreed
I've never seen Floyd Mayweather lose..
Because you don't know how to judge things... when you judge things according to..."what if it was me".... I'll ask everyone.... who knows or out of 10 cases... who knows you more than you're own family...1.... if women where giving authority will Fatima would've been the first caliph?.... i barely hear muslims talk about pbuh family... only sahaba... we should understand that only the pbuh family will know or must have known him better which is...fatima, the wives, Ali his cousin, then friends or so called sahaba... when you look at the history of the world, only few believe and only few knows the truth about deceptions... so everytime I watch Shia vs sunni... the Shia makes strong points... but to be honest like I always say... the enemies of humanity already was waiting for the truth to die so they can pay, write and corrupt history...I feel they wrote 90% of Sunni and Shia books... the evil ones are set up like hyenas they wait till you finish the job and bring "organised chaos".... that's how they did with the pbuh&F... they wait and tried during his life and after... and I tell you muslims something.... do you think the devil will ever leave mankind in peace? He was there right from Adam so why not fight to the end which anyone would do... once you know you have nothing to lose anymore then you fight till the end so I don't blame The devil... it's only natural what he's doing and also God has to take part because so no one will have an excuse on the day of correction... so I ask.... who knows how the pbuh eat sleep drink talk laff and how long he stays up at nights...is it sahaba or his family?(wives,daughter and cousin and in-house slaves or helpers ) ?...but in the end I also don't condemn the caliphs just because everyone has an agenda and everyman is an opportunist...i always say if the powerful ones don't display their powers then the weak ones will f*#$k with them just to either try be like them or test their might so they could feel if they don't rule then their clans might become slaves or insignificant
God bless all humans
@moh989786 Beating yourself is forbidden in Islam, let alone doing it in the name of those other than Allah
I’m sorry but where are your Sunnis? And what have they done to preserve our religion? All they have done is shown a barbaric wahabi image. What has the Shia shown? They have preserved the prophets message due to the sacrifices of the ahlulbayt. The Shias have preserved and have not let the sacrifice of the prophet and his family go to waste. Look at how strong Hussein’s legacy is and look how it is presented to the world every year during Muharram. Why don’t they have a day for Omar? Abu Baker or uthman? I’m sorry but it’s the truth. You guys really need to educate yourselves and get rid of the hate in your hearts. Accept the truth and reality. The reality that abu sufyan and his lineage has tried to destroy our prophets message and his families blood line, all for power? Shame on them. May Allah guide all of us in the right path. The Ahlulbayt is not just for Shias. They are for alllll humanity.
i spit on the grave of any one who insults my beloved khalifa OMAR (ra)
el che, do you spit on the grave who insults and upsets the prophet and his daughter?
Lanatullah Omar usman Abu Bakr aisha ... absolute FILTH
Adam Smith you are an idiot, we know that birdman, go bark on another tree
i hate the haters of Omar (R.a) they have no noor on there face ..
adam smith be sensible , May Allah guide you
Adnan Rasheed a very rational scholar of Islam
He doesn’t know crap he is using fabricated stories against those people who lack knowledge
Barakullaah fee kum for this clip akhi
Again a great performance of brother Adnan. The more I see Shia discussing there view, the more distance I see between them and our prophet Muhammad saw.
ALLAH o Akbar, SubhanALLAH, how clear Ustad Adnan came when he started questioning the "LOVE" the claim to have.
When adnan said that y ali(r
a.) sent his two sons to protect umer farooq(r.a.) abu qaraar says that "ohhh its not like that hmmm this or that etc ' And He accpt this also..
But when Adnan resonds on burning the house 0f fatima(r.a.) Adnan respond on that y Ali and other sahaba didn't say or did anything in respone .
But then abukarar starts to 25:9 shout by saying misguided view.
Hippocracy beyond the level..😡
🤣🤣
Wallahi no one insults Ali R.A. more than the Shia
So delusional
@@shaziab3753 for example when you shias say that 'Ali ra did nothing to save his wife Fatima ra from Umar ra. That's a big insult.
ya Ali CANNOT madad
We Love our Maula Ali A.S
You people done voting and separate Maula Ali A.S position after Prophet P.B.U.H
@@kaderaldjazairi757 when we said that show proof a link or whatever
I love you brother Adenan
You are so patient to spend time discussing with this old Shia man!
Allahuma Barek Br Adnan👌
Samira Alhoceima shab al hoceima
i think most of shias dont know the false teachings of shia scholars, for example that the quran is not complete like they say etc..
May Allah swt. guide shia sincer people to the stright part. Amin
Beware of false scholars. May Allah swt. guard us against false scholars. Amin.
The shia that says quran is not complete is not a shia or a fake shia or a sunni possibly trying to insult shias
@Mr Zift have you ever opened a shia book yourself?
Obviously no then why are you saying me 🙄
@Mr Zift here is an example what if I say that in sunni books there is written that cutting heads of shias is wajib 😓
dear i liked your soft comment towards shias.....may Allah guide you to the path of ahlulbait (a.s).........
Right
Why do Shias have to lie so much. Ya Allah guide us to the straight path.
This uncle don't even want to listen anything that br Adnan says..he just wanted to win in the discussion
Adnan Rashid has an insane amount of knowledge. May Allah swt give him now knowledge and wisdom and patience to debate with these clowns
Brother adnan is best knowledgeable person in sunnies allah gave him everything my allah helps him to give dawa to every non believer in world but the shia are blind they know the truth but they did not agree with that my allah guide them allah hu akbar
Subhan'Allah, may Allah guide them.
I agree they act extremely like Christianity
wallahe can i response ,hahahahaha adnan i love you so much. From pakistan.
May Allah swt be pleased with Abu Bakr, Umar, Uthman and Ali ❤
old guy got roasted lol.. Allah swt guides who he wants
moh989786 imam Ali wouldn’t be pleased with this language mr fake lover of ahlul bait
HS lol Sure 17:81 says Truth will prevail and you say truth will be roasted. LOL SHIA DON’T KNOW QURAN
this is history you can not just delete it because it contradicts your believes............ read Battle of the Camel
and Battle of Siffin, you can not logically follow aisha , ali and muvia at the same time ( the fought against each other ), lots of people died , someone is responsible , if you follow both sides of a battle you are in DEEP contradiction ,,,,,
.........
someone : oh God I am sorry that I caused hundreds of people die , God : you are sorry then, OK your forgiven, and no one is responsible for the murder , ( does this makes sense to logical people? )
The man the legend ustadh rashid
lol Adnan is like 131-0 (98 KO's) at the park
moh989786 u must be shia
moh989786 lol
moh989786 insincere
@moh989786seriously!!!r u kidding😂
Wtf adnan is useless. Like bro he's only good at strawmaning and speaking over people. And then when people speak over him he acts like he never does the same to anyone else.
4:19 abu karaar pissed off sheikh adnan keep exposing rafizi
These shias Don't have any authentic arguments to give
may allah protect ustadh adnan
It's funny how Abu karar took out Ali r.a decision giving his daughter to umer r.a and kept on his ignorance about umer r.a burning house of Fatima r.a lol. Like he wanna ignore umm kulthum and Ali r.a decision from the picture . This is what u call kufr and jahalat . Which their majlks teach them
Ya Allah the patience you have Hajji Adnan 😂😂😂 Allahu Akbar. Anyone else would’ve lost their mind or temper
lol imagine me behind the camera filming biting my tongue
@@SyedSShahidOsccDawahChannel 😂😂😂😂 May Allah bless you brother
The Prophet Muhammad (ﷺ) said,
"For whoever among you lives after me will see much discord. So hold fast to my Sunnah and the Sunnah of the Rightly-Guided Caliphs who will come after me. Adhere to them and hold fast to them. Beware of Bid'ah (in religion) because every Bid'ah is a misguidance."
[Abu Dawud and At-Tirmidhi].
But what if i fight the rightly-guided caliph of my time? Am i not going against the Prophet and therefore against allahs swt. command? Questions over Questions 😐
@@MyMoe999 I would like to know the rightly guided caliph in our time!? I can think of no one. I would like to know your view.
@@abdirahimabdullahi6095 Imam Al-Mahdi as. May God hasten his reappearance and make us all among his dedicated servants
@@MyMoe999 We're not sure if he to be of our time, but if he is then may Allah make us of those who fallow him and obey him ! Ameen
@@MyMoe999 why don't you debate regarding the matter? May Allah remove the veil from your heart and eyes.
Ustaad Adnan Mashallah has tremendous patience.. may we all learn from him. And may Abu karaar use his intellect one day instead of his hate
The lion of SC is back
Yeah..we proud of you, bro Adnan Rashid
Lots of triggered Shias in the comments section 😂
MASHALLAH USTADH RASHID
So disappointed and sympathy for this oldman syiah being so misguided at his age...may Allah give him guidance before the end of his life
Thanks .
We need to ask this absent minded Shia if ali controls the worlds and seas and winds how did ali accept Omar,Abobakr and Othman?
I love you for the seek of Allah br Adnan
JazakAllah
last whole night I passed watching these debates.
Adnan Bhaizan you are too modest and have great patience.
But when the time will come these stubborn Shia brothers will understand the original issue that they are originally making the whole deen fragile with their implausible arguments.
I like their debates😂 Their debates are productive and at the same time funny))
Adnan rashid has got these guys by the horns he is crystal clear but these guys don’t want to hear the truth but only want hear what they believe to confirm what they are doing is correct
adnan is a beast !!
Abu karar is emotional, he is a lost case.
That's why we need to find him
There is nothing you can do when all your life you spent abusing and cursing the Sahabas... thinking them as Netanyahus, and then someone pulls the carpet from under your feet and now you can do nothing but shout and somehow hold your ground and satisfy your own conscience that you were right.
Adnan is a funny guy and knowledgeable. Good stuff.
Muslim vs shia
This old man is unstoppable
Suppose that the history of Shiites concerns Abu Bakr and Omar (Radi Allah Aanhom) is correct, why they do not do like Ali (Radi Allah Aanhom). they claim to follow the traditions of Ali who did not insult or fight Abu Bakr and Omar ???
They claim that they follow Ali but they are far from his morals!!
4 rafadis already disliked it. Did they disliked Ali r a giving his daughter lol
What was Ali's Response?
Thats the answer.
Shia make a made up historical context.
He says what if Ali did not exist 😂😅
And someone threaten fatimah?
Lol far out man
Thats a whole different point
He completely lost it on this point.
Abu karrar's whole point was:
-have adnan look at islamic history through a straw
- remove all context
- remove all important characters
- hypothetically remove everything from this historic narrative except this one event
- now that all of these conditions are complete, abu karrar tells adnan "this is the event that took place, what would you think about this person (omar) if this event happened"
This logic is so warped, flawed and honestly if I'm a shia, I'm embarrassed that abu karrar took this route. Completely and utterly embarrassed.
Cadillac Williams If you look at Shias you find that their logic isn't flawed. They mention clear historical events that are accepted and clear verses like the event of ghadir or moment of revelation for the verse of wilayat. The Shias are also distinct in their theology in that they are the only sect that don't believe God is composite or has parts, whether those parts are like anything of the creation or not (for example God having a hand which wahabis would insist are nothing like our hands etc).
Abu Qarar
Don’t even know the roles of debate
Their imams are more important then the prophet saw
Who said that? If someone who doesn't like the Shias very much says something about Shias how reliable do you think that is in representing what Shias believe? Who said Shias take greater importance to knowing the birth of Imam Hussain over the prophet and others? No scholar that I am aware of even says that we need to memorise the date of birth of any member of ahlulbayt or any prophet I mean are there no topics more important than that like seeking knowlegde, Islamic history, reading Quran etc? If you remember the birth of the prophet then great if you don't then it doesn't mean you don't love the prophet I mean let's be honest how many people possibly including yourself is jumping on the bandwagon and yet also did not know the birth of the prophet but still making a youtube comment lol
Adnan... good from Kenya Nairobi,may Allah grant you more Elm and good swiha inshallah
28:49 did ali know the Hadees ?
And abu qaraar pissed off again😂
According to shias Ali R.A didn't deffend his own wife and the daughter of RASOOLULLAH SAW he was not been able to defend her from the oppressors but today's shias defending her and in the return they go to home's and calling Ya Ali Madad ? Not making any sense.....
i have failed to understand that when there is dialogue between sunni and shia ,why shia have anger in answering the questions.
There are 4 best companion of muhamad saw..we love all of them,but shiah not...shiah hate 3 of them,they said 3 of companion are betriayed islam..
@@bennyirawan5086
what is the reason of hating three companion
@@Shiraz687 this already about politic..at that time...iranian hate the leader from arabian since muhamad saw die..btw please read the story of islam..my english is not good enough
I love adnan, because he stands up for the honour of sahabas and wives of Mohammad pbuh...and I am indebted to his knowledge.
i realy love the end💚💚💚
This division is dangerous and it's only going to hurt Islam. At the end of the day, we should get over our differences and love and respect each other because we are all Muslim.
No they're not. We maybe brothers in humanity, but not in Deen. The shias follow something else and we will never be part of that.
Can someone give me the source of Ali ibn Talib sending his sons to defend Uthman please?
we are asked to give advice, not to guide them.
don't get angry brother Adnan when they don't understand.
May Allah guide us all.
May Allah guide the misguided nasal of Abdullah Ibn Saba
Dow Jones
Maybe Imran Shaik meant that some of the ideological beliefs shias have came from Ibn Saba.
"Jafar as Sadiq cursed Ibn Saba" and
"Fabled Ibn Saba did not exist."
*Which 1 is true? Jafar as Sadiq cursing or Ibn Saba not existing?*
@Dow Jones
Well It is not a surprise because some of the shia hadith narrators are also cursed by imams and shias still take their hadiths.
So following some concepts of Ibn Saba is not far fetched.
And how do you prove that he was a different person?
@Dow Jones
Which kufans are condemned in Sunni hadiths? You are making the same mistake here that Christians do when they translate the Verse "Kill the disbelievers".
If all Kufans weren't condemned then the hadiths and the transmitters can be scrutinized and then accepted.
You are saying that you are not a shia but you bring the arguments of shia. But it is okay.
All I can suggest is watch the "origin of Shia" by sunni defense channel.
They give some detail about Ibn Saba.
@@hamzazulfi nevermind him akhi, he is a Rafidah pretending not to be one so that he came say Rafidah makes sense 🤣, he is a bit slow that one.
Imran Shaik
Brother I am not going to accuse him of pretending. I don't know him and I don't want
Allah to get angry with me because of wrong accusation.
'ali was forced to marry her daughter'.... im done
SUNNI AND SHIAH..... They had that hit song... 'I GOT YOU BABE"
They don’t know the simple rules of communication which is one talks and the other listening. They both take terms, they don’t interrupt each other. Civilized people understand these rules.
May Allah bless the brother Adnan rashid were are the sunni brothers I only can see shia everywhere
The Shiahs' contemplation along this path of thinking is regrettable, they overlooked when the Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) said: "If there were to be a Prophet after me, it would have been Umar bin Al Khattaab" (Saheeh At Tirmidhi - Vol 6, Hadith 3686). How could they possibly hold such a belief about Umar bin Al Khattaab? 😢 May Allah guide them.
Religious idiocy at it's best let us all hate each other because of a historical misunderstanding, really mature muslims
Brother Adnan...as usual you make logical sense and you did so when you made the point of why Ali gave his daughter to Omar and so on. However i have 2 questions...1, did Omar actually say he wanted to burn the house of Fatima down or is this just a shia claim? And 2, if the answer is yes then why was this?
@Talal Dirar ok thanks bro.
This issue of Omar harming Fatima is total Bogus. Shia even talked about this, those who are sane. I will try to get the link for you a Shia talking about this.
@@HajjiJesus pls do bro
@Dow Jones
Fact of matter is the account found in the other Hadith book has nothing to do with this version that has been embellished beyond recognition.
Further more, that account itself is weak. So how many lelevs do you want to jump to believe mumbo jumbo made up stuff?
I guess as Shia, anything as long as it said by Ayyatullah.
These old shias are outstanding
Quran 48:29,look at what those who dont love the prophet (saw) and the ones who believed with him are reffered to by Allah (swt)
Great job adnan
Wrong concept, illogical evidence of abu karar .
The look on the face of that trans person is amazing
Imagine a Robber robs a woman. The Police honors him by giving him a medal. Does that make sense? If Umar (r.a.) really did a grave mistake, how can Ali (r.a.) side with him? Won't Allah punish both? (Nauoothu Billah). No matter how oppressed you are, u wont side with a criminal! We fear Allah more than we fear anyone else and Ali (r.a.) is best amongst us in this....
First
اس دنیا میں اس سے بڑی اذیت ان کیلٸے اور کیا ہوگی۔۔۔۔۔۔دیواروں سے سر ٹکراتے رہیں
Abu qarar repeats himself a million times . Does my head in.
Yaa hussain
When you have a weak argument you shout and raise your voice
Ustaz rashid fatality K.O them...u all know your wife and kids birthday and mother ..u claim to love the prophet s.a.w but none of them know his date of birth..none knows the alu bayt date of birth including ali (r.a) ... fugazzy love 😅😅😅
So no one thought of maghrib salah
O.S.C.C. DAWAH DON'T YOU HAVE THE flashlight FOR NIGHT RECORDS??
Why fight about any of Ali Hassan, Hussain, Uthman, Ayisha, Kolsoom... all of them Allah willing has already been assigned Bashaara.
Why do we detract!!!!!!!
Exactly we were not there at that time so we have no say, Allah alone will do them justice. we Muslims today need to follow Islam and fulfil our duties as a Muslim without going into this political fight
Speakers Corner is now Shouters Corner.
Did Imam Ali not get framed for the killing of uthman.. this is exactly the reason why imam Ali protected uthman to show that he wasn’t the one who killed uthman, but people still faught imam Ali a.s even after protected uthman (battle of the camel).
Some people r too arrogant to change their minds
Brother can you please reply to me about my last comment ?
Brother Adnan we as a Shia consider you Shia but you need to purify your heart and mind and accept Shia whole heartedly. It’s very hopeful that Shia and Sunni are debating together. I just love Adnan and kerrar for doing great job.
@@BO-rj2zj sunni does not hate ali,
And islam is a political centric religion, read the incident of banu qurayza, our prophet fought, defend and conquer because that time he was a stateman also
You can call sunni kafirs
But cant realize that the doctrine of imams are same as christianity
Shia claim that they are true
But cant say how
I saw some alawis pray towards caliph alis portrait
So much idiolizing of humans will turn you ido worshipper
U wish he is shia because his knowledge is too great for shia to deal with ….he is Muslim and will remain Muslim Insha’Allah…shia is illogical and does not attract people with knowledge and pure hearts ….but bravo for trying
My brother Adnan destroyed them All.... .🤣
When adnan says 11 hijri abhu qarar said tha no 10 hijri and i can challenge u on that then he pissed of again 45:18
شكرا الرجاء عمل ترجمه بلغه العربيه
Notice how the shiee didn't acknowledge that its Salah time ( Adnan Rashíd did ) and shiee didn't say let's resume debate after Salah.
I was expecting a lot of shouting.. a lot of Abu kurar..Abu kurar.. aha... still managed to learn something new..
😊😊😊😊😊😊
Umar at Fatimah's house refers to the event where Umar and his supporters went to the house of Fatimah, the daughter of the Islamic prophet Muhammad, shortly after Muhammad's death in order to get the allegiance of her husband Ali and his followers. This event, which has mentions in Shia, Sunni, and western academic books, is also claimed by Shia sources[1] to have led to Fatimah's miscarriage of her son Muhsin ibn Ali,[2][3] as well as her own death shortly after.[4] However, the veracity of the account is disputed, with beliefs being primarily split on sectarian lines between Sunni and Shia denominations
After the gathering at Saqifa, Umar (who had been among Abu Bakr's advocates) and his supporters were allegedly sent by the new Caliph to Ali's house where Ali, Fatimah and some of their allies were gathered.[12] Several scholars, such as Al-Tabari and Ibn Qutaybah, narrate that Umar threatened to burn the building down if Ali refused to acknowledge Abu Bakr's authority, with Al-Tabari adding that Umar's men beat Ali's friend Zubayr ibn al-Awam.[13][14][15][16]According to the Al-Imama wa al-Siyasa (mistakenly attributed to Ibn Qutaybah),[17] when Umar was informed that Fatimah was inside the house, he responded that her presence made no difference to him.[18][19]
While the historian Al-Baladhuri states that the altercation never became violent and ended with Ali's compliance,[20] and Tabari makes no mention of Fatimah's involvement,[13] some traditions add that Umar and his supporters forcibly entered the house, resulting in Fatimah's miscarriage of her unborn son Muhsin.[21] Twelver Shia sources state that this occurred when Umar forced the front door open, crushing Fatimah behind it and breaking her ribs.[1]However, the Mu'tazilite theologian Ibrahim al-Nazzam narrates that, "Umar hit Fatimah (sa) on the stomach such that the child in her womb died."[22]Alternatively, Ibn Rustam Al-Tabari states that it was a client of Umar's named Qunfudh who caused the miscarriage, having struck her with the sheath of his sword.[23] Other traditions add that Qunfudh had her whipped[24] or had struck her face.[25] The Kitab Sulaym ibn Qays (attributed to Sulaym ibn Qays, but possibly a much later creation)[26] concludes the incident with Ali being dragged out of the house with a rope tied around his neck.[27]
Mohammad-Baqer Majlesi, writing in his Bihar al-Anwar, states that Fatimah died soon after due to injuries sustained during the altercation.[4] The aforementioned Al-Imama wa al-Siyasa records that before her death, Fatimah said to Abu Bakr and Umar, "I take Allah and the angels to be my witness that you have not pleased me; on the other hand, you have angered me. When I shall meet the Prophet (S) I will complain about you two."[28] According to Morteza Motahhari, she asked Ali to bury her at night to ensure that none of her enemies participated in her funeral.[
Very nice Adnan
salam alikum brother Adnan do not waste your time No hope at all thanks
16:53 the way adnan dragged the man 😂
See how inconsistent is abu karaar is 32 :31 se said that we will first look at that hadeed in kafi becoz all shis don't belive in it completely and if it is there then we hve narrations that Ali was forced to do that ...
All rafidus r liers May Allah deal with them.
Why the Shias so concentrate on the family of profit Muhhamud? More than him and his teaches of Islam.
Its truly upsetting that there are branches if islam. Honestly i dont know the differences between them
I can answer why imam Ali worked with Omar and uthman.