@@PigeonDudeCharles was not stronger than Arthur. In the Valentine bar fight if Arthur waits long enough without interfering, there is a cutscene where Charles gets beat up and dies from the average npc. Meanwhile Arthur almost kills big Tommy.
Bir şeye takıldım ben oyunun sözde "iyi sonu" bile iyi bitmiyor hatta eğer kötü sonu 2.kez bitirince sinirini atmış oluyorsun Micah'a karşı onurlu sonda huzulu ölümden çok Micah'ın bize acıması gibi hissediyorum en azından oyundaki tüm sonları yapınca "Best ending" diye bir şey açılsaydı Dutch'ın bize inandığını Micah'ın yaptıklarını gördüğü ve Arthur'un Micah'ı öldürdü daha iyi olabilirdi Arthur bu kadarını hak etmedi.
@@jeremy6324 hand to hand id say could go either way. John and Arthur both have incredible skill but Arthur has more strength and size but Johns got speed and agility
Arthur is old sick and dying of tb so he definitely doesn't get Strength lol Durability maybe goes to Arthur but Strength easily goes to John and Johns Strength is very underated its actually comparable to characters like Arthur Morgan (Prime) or Joel Miller John also throws some nasty and brutal punches just look at how terrifyingly bloody he made Captain De Santas face
Both are extremely capable and powerful. I think it would be a close fight. But if I had to pick one, I think it would be a bit closer to John Marston, due to his superior gun skills. I think Arthur Morgan is strong in physical combat, but Marston has the upper hand in long-range weapon throwing skills. I think the winner would be hurt, but not dead. I think it would be the toughest battle they have ever fought. What do you think?
Arthur chapter 1/2 vs John and after training with Landon Strength:Arthur Endurance & durability:John Dead eye & draw speed:Arthur Speed & agility:John Experience:Arthur Loyalty:Arthur Death:John Epilogue references:John Kills:John Resilience:John Combat:Arthur Marksmanship:Arthur Robberies:Arthur Sad scenes:Arthur Character revenge:Arthur’s More peaceful death:Arthur (depending on the ending you get) Better gunslinger:John Son:John Wife:John Mr.Lumbago:John (the last 3 don’t get points for having) Hand to hand:Arthur Melee:Arthur Winner:Arthur Extreme Diff
the crazy part here is the fact that arthur with tb almost killed Micah. If you chose to help John at the end of the mission Arthur had to crawl to the gun and he reached it before Micah but thats when Dutch stpped in
I dont understand why people are underestimating tb arthur, he still put up a great fight and wouldve blown miachs brain if dutch didnt step in, tb arthur beats npc john not 1907 and not 1911 but he defo beats 1899 john
@@user-hx6gs9rq7u My guy, miach was stronger than 1907 john let alone 1899 john. He outdrew him easliy in american venom while a dying arthur on his death bed outdrew miach.
If we're talking 1899 john and arthur, even with tb arthur can beat johns ass even while sick, but if we're taking both in their primes, no ones winning. Both could die
My man survived guarma with tuberculosis and throughout the whole of chapter 6 he was dealing with the army and pinkertons my man had no break, sure John stood there for like 20 seconds with 100 bullets in him but damn he didn’t survive on a island with a heavy crippling disease.
I understand that part and I know that Arthur in chapter 6 would lose to someone like John but, the true strength of Arthur Morgan is 100•/• percent legendary.
@@OCinder bro that’s not something to joke about Also why would you even do that just because I said you can get RDR2 clips in RDR2 like what the fuck is wrong with you?
@@gabrielremal2458 damn man if you think this kind of joke is "offensive" (which really is a bit) or That you shouldn't make a joke about it you couldn't turn on the tv because how much of the program makes this kind of joke is alarming(south park,simpsons,family guy,mr pickles And even some children's show I really got heavy with my jokes, I like dark humor jokes if you don't like them There's nothing I can do,Btw the joke is from a site called ifunny so...
I think Arthur would win Micah even with tb, he just was too exhausted, just imagine, he ALONE had to kill very much pinkertons to save sadie and abigail, then he almost died from milton (also wasted energy trying to save himself), stress&depression also make you very exhausted and less strong, he also was thinking that John died, just imagine how hard it was for him, he rided back to camp, knowing that this is the end of their gang, then susan got shot, he had to fight with even more pinkertons, then he tried to escape on his self and again fought with pinkertons WHILE RIDING A HORSE IN FEAR AND STRESS, also knowing that there is so much mega experienced gunslingers chasing him (gang members), then his horse died and he had to climb on the mountain still fighting army of pinkertons, then he was too exhausted, he said John to go away and safe himself, he fights even more pinkertons and then fights with Micah, also experienced goddamn killer who killed half a city for guns....
@@Arthur_John-Goated and ye he is far more stronger when Arthur is dying but what's the point of comparing a Healthy man to a sick man that's literally dead and half way alive is the point that I was trying to make i know John was stronger but it would have been better if he would have compared prime Arthur chapter 2 to John in 1911 instead of comparing tb Arthur to healthy 1899 John that's the point I was trying to make tho
Song name?
Shootout
@@crispychips7754 nah it’s shootout x say yes to heaven
@@threshyofnola same thing genius
@@crispychips7754 no it’s a mashup
@@crispychips7754 and slowed and reverb
brothers dont fight
they do
@@FEDERALBEREAUOFIMCOMPENTRNCE not brothers by blood but brother as in best friends type shit
@@FEDERALBEREAUOFIMCOMPENTRNCEthey don't bro
@@FEDERALBEREAUOFIMCOMPENTRNCE Not this type
Yep
Bro's comparing man with tb vs healthy man💀
And the point of tb where he was going to die in a few minutes
(If he means the last mission)
@@ronaldomessigoat5632 well to be fair Micah sped that up by a while
@@gabrielremal2458 yeah
cuz we all know rdr 2 john doesnt stand a chance against healthy arthur morgan
Bros comparing man with tb vs man that doesn't like water 💀
☹️ I didn’t want to leave him. I wanted him to go with me.
gg
@@micahbell852 your pfp makes me wanna unalive
@@gabrielremal2458 lmao same
John dw I lived..
@@arthurmorgan5972 Arthur!!
Without tuberculosis Arthur is the strongest of the gang.
I’d say Charles was stronger. Arthur would’ve been second.
In rdr2 absolutely but RDR 1 John is better. Man’s was John wick in the 20th century
@@andrewbrady-wright6804 true, John solos all the gang.
@@PigeonDudeCharles was not stronger than Arthur. In the Valentine bar fight if Arthur waits long enough without interfering, there is a cutscene where Charles gets beat up and dies from the average npc. Meanwhile Arthur almost kills big Tommy.
@PigeonDude we've never seen Arthur reach his peak as he gave John a chance so we don't know
Arthur and John both brothers 🤝🏽🙂
Bro, for me, arthur is better than John in all aspects, Arthur was the best gunslinger
in rdr1? johns better but rdr2 i agree with you
@@alboorts they kinda violated John in rdr2 felt like he was a defenceless baby
@@svenrx510 defenseless? no he was defensive alright but idiot and not as badass as rdr1? yes
Not going to lie John you are pretty slow with a gun in rdr2 and 1
@@Oiiioiiii John wins
"When the time comes you gotta run and don't look back". - Arthur Morgan
Arthur- you and me we are ghosts now🤠👻
Bir şeye takıldım ben oyunun sözde "iyi sonu" bile iyi bitmiyor hatta eğer kötü sonu 2.kez bitirince sinirini atmış oluyorsun Micah'a karşı onurlu sonda huzulu ölümden çok Micah'ın bize acıması gibi hissediyorum en azından oyundaki tüm sonları yapınca "Best ending" diye bir şey açılsaydı Dutch'ın bize inandığını Micah'ın yaptıklarını gördüğü ve Arthur'un Micah'ı öldürdü daha iyi olabilirdi Arthur bu kadarını hak etmedi.
@@shadowscythe7565 Aynen 😐
@@shadowscythe7565 özür dilerim çok yazmasını bilmiyorum Türkçe ama söylediklerin doğru 👍👍👍👍
@@alicandemirci2267Kanal ismin Türkçe diye seni Türk sandım.
(Ve büyük ihtimal bunuda Google çeviriden bakıcaksın.d)
@@shadowscythe7565 yok zaten Türkçe yazmasıni biliyorum sadece yabancıyim ulkedeyim öyle diyelim
I think Strength speed durability could have been equal due to the fact John was shot and Arthur was having tb
That’s like saying Arthur vs TB or John vs Water-
True.
Lmao
John vs water had me dying
If the brothers ever fought, alive Arthur would come out on top 🗿
rdr1 john changes that
@@femboypupfax
@@femboypup 1v1 without weapon=Arthur
Gun fight=John
@@jeremy6324 hand to hand id say could go either way. John and Arthur both have incredible skill but Arthur has more strength and size but Johns got speed and agility
@@andrewbrady-wright6804 no it's pretty one sided Arthur is way more skilled in hand to hand combat than john
Damn, i never got sad watching a video before
One of the best rdr edit channels and this is the one of my favorie edit of rdr2
Me and my brother john will always be together🤠🤝🏽
It’s sad how weakend Arthur was and how he still managed to fight off Micah
Arthur🤝🏻John
Arthur morgan: is a anti hero and 90% broken and 10% good
John marston: is a anti hero and 95% broken and 5% good
You can't compare someone who is dying tf
yes you can
@@OGGAMINGL1VE no
he just did lol it wouldn’t be a fair fight but you still can
@@OGGAMINGL1VE that's what i said do i need to explain it to you are a child wtf
Poor Arthur😢. He didn't deserve it at all. Micah did
Brothers never fights to the death they will always be true brothers until the end
the only good versus video
w bro
Saddest thing is that we know what happens to John in the end
Durability Arthur😭
Fr he was so strong
Brothers forever! Nice Edit Bro
when you realize that Arthur had the best physical strength (with Charlie) but when he got TB he became weak.
No Arthur with tb fought micah and would have won if dutch did not step on Arthur's finger
Durability, strength and combat still goes to Arthur.
He ain’t stronger then John when he’s half dead from tuberculosis
tb ??
Arthur is old sick and dying of tb so he definitely doesn't get Strength lol Durability maybe goes to Arthur but Strength easily goes to John and Johns Strength is very underated its actually comparable to characters like Arthur Morgan (Prime) or Joel Miller John also throws some nasty and brutal punches just look at how terrifyingly bloody he made Captain De Santas face
@@Arthur_John-Goatedjohn survived sniper shot, durability definitivly goes to him
Jesus, this song hits different with rdr2😥
bro strength for sure goes to arthur
Strength isn’t going to Arthur when he’s literally half dead
@@user-hx6gs9rq7u obv Arthur with tb wouldn't have that strength, but prime Arthur is way stronger
@@inspectize This video is about chapter 6 Arthur
@@user-hx6gs9rq7u oh I didn't know that
Both are extremely capable and powerful. I think it would be a close fight. But if I had to pick one, I think it would be a bit closer to John Marston, due to his superior gun skills. I think Arthur Morgan is strong in physical combat, but Marston has the upper hand in long-range weapon throwing skills. I think the winner would be hurt, but not dead. I think it would be the toughest battle they have ever fought. What do you think?
Arthur chapter 1/2 vs John and after training with Landon
Strength:Arthur
Endurance & durability:John
Dead eye & draw speed:Arthur
Speed & agility:John
Experience:Arthur
Loyalty:Arthur
Death:John
Epilogue references:John
Kills:John
Resilience:John
Combat:Arthur
Marksmanship:Arthur
Robberies:Arthur
Sad scenes:Arthur
Character revenge:Arthur’s
More peaceful death:Arthur (depending on the ending you get)
Better gunslinger:John
Son:John
Wife:John
Mr.Lumbago:John (the last 3 don’t get points for having)
Hand to hand:Arthur
Melee:Arthur
Winner:Arthur Extreme Diff
rest in peace both of the legends
some free point for Arthur
redemption:arthur
honor: Arthur
skill: Arthur
rich: Arthur
And better too...
Honor to John, he’s a pretty good man after the events of the main rdr2 story
and rich goes to John aswell
It’s sad to see Arthur decline so rapidlt
In my opinion arthur has a sadder death than john, arthur was alone and betrayed while john got a couple rounds to the chest.
Imagine john didnt leave and came back and helped arthur beat up micah
Would’ve ended with Dutch killing John then
John and Arthur died for nothing and that is the saddest thing about there story 😢
True that
Underrated channel
the crazy part here is the fact that arthur with tb almost killed Micah. If you chose to help John at the end of the mission Arthur had to crawl to the gun and he reached it before Micah but thats when Dutch stpped in
Can i get the song name
Both are goats 🔥
I dont understand why people are underestimating tb arthur, he still put up a great fight and wouldve blown miachs brain if dutch didnt step in, tb arthur beats npc john not 1907 and not 1911 but he defo beats 1899 john
John actually knows how to fight unlike Micah because he was taught by the same people who taught Arthur so yeah John definitely wins a fist fight
@@user-hx6gs9rq7u 1899 ain’t beating tb arthur don’t fool yourself buddy
@@Azizi-j4v How is John Marston going to lose to a guy who’s getting more sick and weak every day
@@user-hx6gs9rq7u My guy, miach was stronger than 1907 john let alone 1899 john. He outdrew him easliy in american venom while a dying arthur on his death bed outdrew miach.
@@Azizi-j4v Gun skill doesn’t make you physically stronger
And I can’t wait for the grey and white vest and purple dress tie to make johns rdr cover art outfit
Can I use the idea
Even though he has TB, I’d still give strength to Arthur. He’s a tank and was pretty even with Micah in a fist fight.
arthur really was the man with no name 🫡
I am not crying 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
nice
This scene💔🥺
Strength goes to Arthur no question asked gave Tommy brain damage can lift grown men
Chapter 6 Arthur isn’t as strong as chapter 2 Arthur
That was arthur before tb😂
@@user-hx6gs9rq7uoh ok but still
Yessss🔥🔥🔥 Arthur is ok too but I have always been a big John Marston fan🔥🔥🔥
Arthur vs john
Arthur and John:🍷🗿
Name of the song?
p.s. the video is something incredible
Arthur morgan 🤝 John marston
If we're talking 1899 john and arthur, even with tb arthur can beat johns ass even while sick, but if we're taking both in their primes, no ones winning. Both could die
Arthur with tb isn’t beating John
@@user-hx6gs9rq7u like said if BOTH 1899 arthur even with tb can beat john. Both in prime however will die
@@mrcapsknee7427 Arthur with tb isn’t beating 1899 john in a fight. John Marston is actually a good fighter unlike Micah
Arthur vs john ❌
Arthur and john ✅
Combat still to Arthur I think
It's so sadly to seeing this video😭
Arthur my brother once john said
Brothers never fight they fight the ones who fight the brother Aman to that 💯🫡
Nah bro is comparing a dying man to a not even close to death man 💀
Strength Arthur
Speed Arthur
Durability Arthur
Iq John
Battle iq Arthur
Stamina John
Agility Arthur
Power John and Arthur
Endurance John
Combat Arthur
This is chapter 6 Arthur
This is Chapter 6 Arthur with terminal advanced tuberculosis I think
Fax
Wake up to reality Arthur Morgan wins negative dif
Not chapter 6 Arthur
Strength goes to Arthur asap
You think the guy dying from tuberculosis is stronger then John?
My man survived guarma with tuberculosis and throughout the whole of chapter 6 he was dealing with the army and pinkertons my man had no break, sure John stood there for like 20 seconds with 100 bullets in him but damn he didn’t survive on a island with a heavy crippling disease.
@@GGIndustry233 Arthur in chapter 6 is way weaker so if he fought someone like John who’s actually good at fighting he would probably lose
I understand that part and I know that Arthur in chapter 6 would lose to someone like John but, the true strength of Arthur Morgan is 100•/• percent legendary.
You don't know what asap means
John in chapter 1:💀
Arthur in chapter 1:🗿
John in chapter 6 and epilogue:🗿
Arthur in chapter and epilogue:💀
Where did you get this arthur clips?
From the game…
@@OCinder bro that’s not something to joke about
Also why would you even do that just because I said you can get RDR2 clips in RDR2 like what the fuck is wrong with you?
@@gabrielremal2458 damn man if you think this kind of joke is "offensive" (which really is a bit) or That you shouldn't make a joke about it you couldn't turn on the tv because how much of the program makes this kind of joke is alarming(south park,simpsons,family guy,mr pickles And even some children's show
I really got heavy with my jokes, I like dark humor jokes if you don't like them There's nothing I can do,Btw the joke is from a site called ifunny so...
@@gabrielremal2458 also Sorry if you were offended
@@OCinder I’m just a but sensitive because my dad killed himself so when people joke about it I get very on edge but I see where your coming from.
Bro really gave strength to John😂
Because Arthur is literally half dead. Almost anyone in the gang is stronger then him at that point
That would be sad if Arthur and John fought in the end 😢
It was very sad for me to see Arthur get shot in the face by Micah (I had very low honor).
goats are fighting no way
Can't compare two goats that saved eachothers lives 💀
Arthur Morgan real man👑👑
Something that would be more fair is him vs chapter one John
John could have helped and saved Arthur, but Arthur thought he wouldn't even go that far.
I think Arthur would win Micah even with tb, he just was too exhausted, just imagine, he ALONE had to kill very much pinkertons to save sadie and abigail, then he almost died from milton (also wasted energy trying to save himself), stress&depression also make you very exhausted and less strong, he also was thinking that John died, just imagine how hard it was for him, he rided back to camp, knowing that this is the end of their gang, then susan got shot, he had to fight with even more pinkertons, then he tried to escape on his self and again fought with pinkertons WHILE RIDING A HORSE IN FEAR AND STRESS, also knowing that there is so much mega experienced gunslingers chasing him (gang members), then his horse died and he had to climb on the mountain still fighting army of pinkertons, then he was too exhausted, he said John to go away and safe himself, he fights even more pinkertons and then fights with Micah, also experienced goddamn killer who killed half a city for guns....
Bro gave the combat and strength to john 😂
Arthur when he’s half dead isn’t stronger then John
@@user-hx6gs9rq7u ye of course
@@user-hx6gs9rq7u but when Arthur is healthy he's way stronger than John tho in combat
Arthurs legit old and sick and dying of tb John is far more Stronger
@@Arthur_John-Goated and ye he is far more stronger when Arthur is dying but what's the point of comparing a Healthy man to a sick man that's literally dead and half way alive is the point that I was trying to make i know John was stronger but it would have been better if he would have compared prime Arthur chapter 2 to John in 1911 instead of comparing tb Arthur to healthy 1899 John that's the point I was trying to make tho
Winner…
Neither because brothers don’t fight 🐐🐐
It’s funny how surviving chapter has nothing to do with fighting in hand to hand combat and yet it still does
Both are legends and their deaths were sad sorry for spoiler
Arthur beats Little Johnny in every department
Arthur when he’s literally days away from dying of tuberculosis isn’t beating John Marston
@@user-hx6gs9rq7u Ohh, Arthur would've handed John his sorry S from his grave too
"Go John."
Stop making Dark Competitions between These brothers The moment that gamers cried
I know its hard to believe, but Strenght is Arthur, Because with TB, he Destroyed Micah in a Hand Fight.
Good point but sick Arthur is absolutely nothing compared to John because John can also throw some nasty punches
@@Arthur_John-Goated no.
John is actually a good fighter though unlike Micah
Make sense that John win because Arthur have TB, I miss Arthur 😔
Bro if it was Arthur chapter 2💀
Arthur Morgan (No TB) vs 1911 John marston??
It can't be it needs to be a tie because their brothers
I just remembered jhon killing his brother in red dead 1
if John had stayed and helped Arthur Micah would be 6 feet under and rdr1 wouldn’t have happened
Rdr1 would still happen
Arthur save my life
both had sad deaths...
Arthur was sick at chapter 6
If it's early chapter 6, then Arthur stomps. But if it's ending then I agree
Do it throughout the whole game not just chapter 6 pls (:
It don’t matter filter has tuberculosis or not combat still goes t
Athur even with TB could've killed Micah so technically he could alslo beat John
John is a lot more skilled in h2h then Micah
In a gun fight Arthur would still take it imo TB may of made him physically weaker but I doubt it would of impacted his gun skills
ARTHUR MORGEN vs JOHM MARSTON level ONE Swimming ??
Shootout x yes to heaven
Legends don't fight
Combat should go to Arthur. He killed hundreds a Pinkertons dream Chapter 6 at the ending and beat the shit out of Micah dutch is what saved him
Tb John wins but imagine if John got sent from Strauss 😂😂😂😂