Dredd (2012) Movie Review - Boots To Reboots
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 5 сен 2024
- Andy and his split personalities review Judge Dredd (1995) starring Sylvester Stallone and Dredd (2012) starring Karl Urban. It’s a battle of the frowny faces!
Thanks for watching! Don't forget to LIKE, COMMENT, SHARE & SUBSCRIBE!
www.stitchedtog...
/ stitchedtogetherpictures
/ bootstoreboots
Who is the Maniacal Cinephile? After an outburst at a movie theater left him disfigured by scalding hot nacho cheese from concessions, Andy was sent to a mental hospital. After 10 years, Andy has been released and horrified that all of his favorite movies have been remade. Join him and his multiple personalities as they cross each remake off the list and determine if it deserves the BOOT.
To me, Urban was a much more believable JD than Stallone
I’d sell my soul to see a sequel to Dredd
I see Dredd as a prequel to Judge Dredd. But that’s jus me.
@@WandererNamedGuy AGREED 👍
I’ve never seen it
Gayness personified it hasn't happened yet, at least a reboot you'd think
"I'm having...a stroke!"
One of the few reviewers that acknowledges Anderson in anyway. Strange that so few people identify her as the protagonist of the film with meaningful character development and a complete story arc. Dredd serves nicely as the required deus ex machina to make sure the main character survives this hellish day at work but does not need to develop or explain about himself in the least. This movie is art
"I'm having.. a stroke" This line deserves an Oscar, or a Grammy, or something. I piss myself laughing every time I hear it.
“I’m having a stroke!!!” Best line of this entire review
Yeah I just got to that bit and laughed out loud while walking up the street to the shops and looked like a right crazy person..lol.
cheap pop. its too easy a joke to make, considering Stallone in general is smarter than he gets credit for in Hollywood
@@razieltalos It’s not funny because of Stallone’s speech issues. It’s more due to how he takes pauses between each sentence even though he could say it quicker.
It's a shame, that Dredd flopped so hard. It uses all the technics of modern filmmaking like 3D, slomo and colour correction, but unlike most Hollywood Action, to it's benefits.
Writer Alex Garland went on to write and direct the brilliant Ex Machina and releases "Annihilation" next year. While Pete Travis went back to britain to direct smaller british films.
It didn't flop though. It did very well for the time it was out. The problem was the lack of advertising and no one talking about it. Everyone who watched it loved it and for some fuckin reason it just flew under the radar for no reason and didn't get any attention until it was too late. I think that other mainstream movies must have came out at the same time to overshadow it, and for some dumb fucking reason hollywood decided not to advertise.
@@SPFLDAngler This is true. They didn't have a good advert team covering it. This should of had several sequels a long time ago. :(
i love dredd but i wasn’t crazy about garland’s directorial efforts. men was absolute garbage
I’ve been asked by quite a few people to re upload the DREDD review so enjoy (originally uploaded 02-04-2015).
Thank you awesome as always
It was blocked in countries outside the US a long time ago and finally a fourth claim blocked it from being viewable at all. The appeal and number of claims were getting ridiculous and fans kept asking about it.
StitchedTogetherPics Stupid thing is, in the UK at least it was unblocked for a time earlier this year. This nonsense must be as frustrating as hell for you!
StitchedTogetherPics Yeah, I felt like this was anyways. But great job re uploading something entertaining like ur vids. Can u do Town dat dreades Sundown boots to reboots
+StitchedTogetherPics Have you done the clash of the Titans remake? If not can you do it plz?
The new Dredd was great, Lena Headey was an AMAZING villain and the look and style of the movie was really well done. I so hoped for a sequel but obviously audience didnt agree and the movie flopped.
I think the problem wasn't that the audience didn't agree. In my experience, most people who saw the film, with the exception of very rare Stallone die-hards, really enjoyed it. The problem was the marketing. It really, really sucked. With just one trailer and little coverage, a lot of people told me they didn't even know that a Dredd film had been released until after it had left theaters. It's found a hugely dedicated cult audience at least, and there is a TV series that's out in a couple of years, so that's something.
James Aggas You re probably right.
I thought the same thing , back when it came out.
The marketing really sucked.
Reminded me of the aweful marketing oft Mononoke and Titan A.E. back in the days, in germany.
No real Trailers, no Posters anywhere.
I even spotted Posters and signs for Mononoke in a corner in THW cinemaxx i went to , just stuffed in, not even put up properly.
Personally, i hoped for a sequel cause of the major success in DVD and BlueRay, but alas...
There is talk of a netflix tv show, with Karl urban still starring, will be interesting to see whether it ever gets made
I went to see it twice
Malefizia - I watched that movie and I couldn't believe how much I liked it. I think I even watched it by accident or something.
I happened to come across this channel. It's brilliant.
Thank you
I side with you
Your are quickly becoming my favourite reviewer in youtube. Great work.
Thanks! I'm glad you found the channel.
9:56 Rob Schnieder’s impersonation of sly is pretty funny... cant get enough of it personally
lol
I always thought the new version was better, but my friends never listened to me.
Never understood why...
somo people looks up for flashy or clichee type thing instead of avangarde concepts, so why bother...
Urban will never have the level of accolades that Stallone does
that spittake you did after "IT'S A LIE!" was absolutely hilarious. Had to watch it a few times.
Love all your reviews, thank you.
Thanks for watching.
I love the Stallone version just as much as the 2012 movie. I just have a soft spot for cheese and great set design and effects (seriously the movie has awesome atmosphere)
Man, I miss your reviews. Easily one of my favorites. Hope you have moved on to bigger, and better things. Just know these are missed.
I have found that 'Dredd' is probably the most unsuccessful movie to recommend to anyone of people in and around my generation. Nobody is willing to accept that the new version can be any good due to the original.
I've never seen either of them
Good morning from Tokyo. ‘Judge Dredd’ starring Sly contained homage of Blade Runner from my point of view
I'm amazed how much I love Andy's channel. Usually RUclips characters get boring and old because of how cheap and predictable the performers are. But Andy has great comic timing and solid reviews
Hey idk if you will see this but I honestly think you are one of the best channels I've ever seen you are very funny and make awesome intelligent reviews I just resubsribed on my new RUclips but I've been watching this channel for years keep up the awesome work
Andy, as a fairly consistent digester of RUclips film reviews...I NEEDED to tell you how absolutely incredible your content is, video after video there is not one that I haven't found hilarious, insightful, and expertly crafted. Before I finish my fan slobber, you should know that I personally think "Evil" Andy is one of the funniest characters to ever grace not just RUclips, but really any medium. I hope you know how much joy your material brings us, and I of course also hope to see new releases cause you're just too damn good :).
Rocky: ADRIANNNN!!!
Dredd: I AM THE LAWWWW!!!
You need to come back to RUclips, we all miss you Andy!
Boot to reboot: red dawn. and give the remake of red dawn the boot please!
I love coming back to watch these videos, Andy’s antics never get old.
Wish we could get another Dredd. Audiences really dropped the ball on this one. It probably didn’t do well because fans of the comic remembered how bad the first movie was and assumed we were going to get a repeat of last time
As a person, Rob Schneider does not seem so bad (I approve of his concerned stance on vaccinations). As an actor though, I can't say that I ever found him really interesting... then again I haven't seen him in many movies. :S Great review, as usual! I look forward to any further ones that you wish to do.
I just discovered your channel and I have seen nothing like it. Awesome, and I love your intro! I loved Dredd, gritty, violent, smart, but kept within its wheelhouse. I understand that there is a Netflix series in the works likely with Urban and Thirlby. If wishes were horses?
Really great review. Subscribed to the channel and agree with the review. This reboot was indeed better than the original
Karl Urban is coming to Boston for comic con. The crowd chanting #Dredd2 will be no doubt deafening.
Do a boots to reboots for the hills have eyes and last house on the left
I'm with this guy, do the Hills have Eyes.
Lucas Pigliavento I think his planning on doing every remake ever.
Yea... Those are coming. If you ever see his list, it *literally* has every remake ever on it. All the modern ones.
Its been made bro
Awesome review on Dredd Andy. I would love to see a boots to reboots review on The Time Machine remake from 2002
I loved your cameo in count jackula's halloween 2 review it was hilarious
I really enjoyed the Dredd reboot!! I was completely unaware that fans created a petition to have a sequel made. I surely would have signed it. Although it seems unlikely, I hope that a sequel is made someday....preferably with the same actors.
Currently, there is a Judge Dredd TV series in development, at least. While we don't know whether it will continue from the film exactly, EVERYONE (including the producers) wants Karl Urban to come back. He's shown plenty of interest, but he's also said that it has to be done right for him to come back. We can only hope.
I would love to see an episode on 13 ghost.
Hey Andy I know it takes you some time to make your videos, but I hope to see something
I miss you man
I like the opening. "Looks like someones changing to a lefts" was the best line ever.
I blame the Stallone version for the box office failure of the remake
Dredd is an epic, but relatively lesser known character, so I'm sure most people thought "oh god, they remade that piece of garbage movie? WHY?" rather than "oh, I hope get Dredd right this time"
I'm really glad I was introduced to you by another channel. You live up to all the claims they made.
Nice, I never got a chance to watch your review of Dredd and the original is a guilty pleasure of mine. Thanks for uploading it, another quality episode.
I've been a Judge Dredd fan since my childhood, reading the original 2000AD comics sent to Nova Scotia by a friend in London. There are some things about the Stallone version that are done well: the initial fly-over of MegaCity One, some aspects of that Dredd's initial appearance ( the original Dredd would just roll up and declare that an entire city block was under arrest; however, that Dredd could enforce it. Stallone can't.), and certain moments in the Cursed Earth. However, the thing that pissed me off the most was the character of Fergie. In the comic, Fergie was a giant man with powerful strength, but a childish mind, who became a hero by taking down a tyrannical Chief Judge who had made MegaCity One worse than it used to be...which was quite an achievement, believe me. Making Fergie a comic relief idiot was annoying as hell. Overall, though, the 2012 DREDD was , far and away, the superior film.
Could you do a Boots to Reboots review of Day of the Dead?
I am both scared and excited for that day. My god that remake was pure shit.
Rigor Mortis Ikr.
Rigor Mortis Not to mention the horrible look of the zombies.
Connor Stierman Oh know. Repressed memories!!!! Coming back!!!! WHAT HAVE YOU DONE TO ME!!!?!?!??!!!?
He did!!
Andy's bit of saying "law" over and over in silly ways reminds me of the "they took our jobs" gag in South park, where by the end they're just mumbling gibberish 😆
I busted out laughing at "THE LAW!!" part.
LAAAAAAWWWW
Mama not the law...iam the law
First video i've seen of yours; found it thoroughly enjoyable.
Also, I AM THE LAW!
Thanks for watching! I'm glad you enjoyed it.
Thanks. The only episode I had left to watch due to some copyright claim?
I think what hurt this movie the most was the heavy marketing on the 3D, which was a doomed gimmick that made the movie seem desperate. I didn't got to the theater to see this one just because of that and only now have I seen the movie and realized it was actually pretty good. It's a shame that things worked out that way. It had the right idea of scope too. It takes place in one mega-block versus one gang and is essentially a routine drug bust that feels because because all major crimes have been upped in scale in Mega-City One. It also had the common sense not to really focus on Dredd himself too much as a character, but rather the world he's in while he delivers justice in it. Just a shame the gimmick had to get in the way of that.
Great review, and again I say, the Boots to Reboots intro tune shreds hardcore!
PLEASE. Make a "The Shining" Boots to Reboots episode, where you talk about the original Kubrick and the Stephen King Miniseries. That would be AWESOME!
I’m surprised he didn’t criticize anything about Dredd 3D, just goes to show how amazing it is
It seriously is a real shame that Dredd 3d didn't make more.. everyone I know whose EVER seen it says that it's amazing and easily beats out the older Stallone version.
Finally able to watch this!! It's the last Boots to Reboots of yours that I had to watch, so cool of you to reupload it!
I think it’d been hilarious if Urban Dredd said “I knew you’d say that” to someone who insulted him. Or “I knew they’d do that” after they leveled the one floor with the mini guns.
This a great review Andy. Prefer the 2012 movie myself
One of my favourite reviews, i do have a question. I know it isn't your normal reboot movie such as horror or action but are you ever going to reboot Karate Kid i think it would be funny what evil andy would say about the villains.
The newer Dredd movie was one of the most fun time i had in the theater ever and i was in the company of two of my best friends. Great film experience.
Get ready andy cause it's been announced that there's gonna be a rambo reboot goody. awesome video man
Was the original video copyright striked?
When my mom first saw Judge Dredd's costume she busted out laughing.
Hilarious review dude! Keep it up
is it just me or is this out of order ? cause the whole bit with the doc in the basement being locked up turned out to be freddy kruger in disguise. i just realized this along with andy's background being the old background as well.
Hall of Justice Approved
Yay! Finally got to see it and it was just what I expected. Thank you.
Stallone, when he has the helmet on, looks perfect as Judge Dredd. As much as I did like Dredd 3D, Karl Urban has this silly looking frowny face the whole time that doesn't look natural.
The Boots to Reboots song is sick!!! 👍
I personally don't compere the films because they are different adaptations of the character, Stallone's Judge Dredd is not perfect but I love it for what it is instead of hating it for what it isn't. The biggest complaint fans say about the film is he never takes his helmet off, well they're wrong. In the comics he does take his helmet off a few times, but it's usually covered up or he's in a disguise. However in one story arc when Dredd is no longer a judge and he went out into the Cursed Earth, he was seen without his helmet. Besides there's a lot of things they got right from the comics such as Dredd's outfit and the look of Mean Machine. I've never been a die hard comic book fan, just because some people hate a film doesn't mean I have to hate it as well. If anyone fails to understand this, then they don't know what freedom of speech is.
Ha the original got stomped! awesome vid Andy!
The Laaaaw. I'm dying over here.
love your videos man, your one of the best movie reviewers I know, love the boot
Excellent film.
I picked this up, along with a double feature of The Punisher: Warzone, for $5.00.
Damn, that was money well spent. 👍
I swear you did this one already.
I remember, as a whipper, the hype the original got in the 90s. I was too young to have discovered the comics, so I didn't understand the disappointment till later in life.
Hey bud I love your work I think you do an amazing job and its very funny lol I remember in you were once talking to somebody in a comment section about doing a boots to reboots with "the thing" the original Jon carpenters version and the prequel in 2011 I was wondering if you were still gunna do that? And as I said great job bub this is hands down my favorite channel
Thanks! It's a long list of remakes, but I plan on getting to that one eventually.
StitchedTogetherPics that's cool. do what your doing. cuz you do a damn good job in the things you make. and cant wait to see what you make next.Wish the best of luck. Take care
"DO YOU WANNA DIE DR. ODDCOITUS!?! Very funny line. Also I love you're channel, Tell Good Andy and Evil Andy I said Hi
If you think about it Dredd and Reiko are literally just Solid Snake and Liquid Snake
I only watched the new Dredd, never tempted to watch the old one, and I was a teenager when it came out. Not a Stallone fan at all. When I saw he's pqlying without his helm, it automatically turned my interest off, although I had no idea about the comic and its rules, I just didn't want to watch him :)
As you can see from the review, you're really not missing much. It's a completely different movie to the new one, and actually put me off checking out the comic for a while. I was disappointed less about him taking off his helmet, and more that he was "Judge, Jury and Executioner!" for about 15 minutes before he gets arrested and loses all of that anyway. To me, him being a Judge was a really interesting idea as someone who had never read the comic before, so it was a shame to see the movie throw away its key concept so early.
Very good vídeo, greetings from Spain
I had never seen the movie. I literally just got done watching it 5mins ago just so I could watch this video.
Yep.. I agree with everything.
This movie has always been a guilty pleasure of mine!
Your videos are awesome. Love this break down of both Judge Dredd films. The Stallone Dredd is pretty bad. I only saw it once. Need to check out Dredd again. It was really good.
who made your opening?
also who made the sick riff from your original opening?
I did, my friend. If you like it, there's more to be heard at www.subsum1.com. Thanks!
Eww! Dude is obsessed with your openings huh huh huh.
FUCK YES! This was the only one I wasn't able to watch! Just found your channel thanks to Count Jackula's Halloween 2 review and very glad I did.
The true question is which movie has the Anthrax song
Love your channel. Keep up the good work. ;}
Thanks!
Stallone's Dredd is basically just John Spartan with less charisma. Armand Assante as Rico was over-the-top crazy and IMO was better than Dredd. But Karl Urban played the character a lot better. I liked the Angel Family in the 95 version though.
The Robot in Sly's 'Dredd' looked like the berserk robot in 'Hardware' starring Dylan MacDermott. Have you seen it?
Atsushi Takayasu Hardware also ripped off 2000 ad, the home of Judge Dredd.
I never heard about that one
lost not only all my shit at 9:40, but tomorrows shit as well.
you killin it, Andy
You prefer the 2012 version. I knew you'd say that.
19:19- *Andy:* "Stallone, your movie has been judged. And the sentence is DEATH."
*Stallone:* "No, no, please! I was just doing my job to get paid, I'm just an actor! I'm INNOCENT!"
*Andy:* "I knew you'd say that..." *(shoots him up with slo-mo and straps the boot tighter)*
What sub human degenerate criminal would prefer the Stallone?
The stallone movie had more accurate costumes compared to the remake. But the remake had a better version of Dredd.
I would not really consider this a remake. Is Batman Begins a remake Batman 1989?
Good call on this one. Dredd is a great movie, even if it is essentially The Raid.
I can imagine the Punisher as a Judge in this universe.
I got 2 minutes into this an subscribed. Kewl content.
Can you look at all of the Pumkipen Head Movies?
Oh my god. This channel is great.
Dredd is now either 75 or 76 years old in the comic
Loved the remake! never cared for the first version. Stallone's ego wouldn't allow him to keep the helmet on. A real betrayal of the myth. Why, oh WHY must there be comic relief ? I, too, would LOVE a sequel to this.
This is a cult classic just waiting for the right time to explode. Im a huge Dredd fan and Karl Urban was superb in the role.
Andy twerking and yelling "gotta respect the law" is the best way to close out 2021