39000 acres of Jagannath Puri mandir was sold by Orissa govt. 4 out of 7 mountains of Tirupati Mandir was donated to Churches and mosques 18 temples and idols were destroyed and demolished by missionaries in Tamil Nadu between 2020 and 2022 and no restoration done. Many temples of Kerala, tamilnadu, Andra Pradesh, Karnataka are still close because of either community cleansing or no funds. These things are in front of our eyes still some idiots cannot see.
@@akshitpandey9860 Jagannath point 18 March 21 news of India today, opindia, telegraph etc About tirupati mountains, under Jerusalem pilgrimage subsidy on behalf of APSRTC the church and many other things are built by them. Infact many trustees are Christian and Muslim. Most of the people who are working as sevedaar are muslims so they had filed petition of keeping tirupati mandir closed on Friday to let them offer namaz. U can search for local news papers u will get more details knowledge
@@dikshadave6443 Kindly don't spread fake news about Jagannath temple just to support your agenda. If you really cared, you could spend 10 minutes to read about Jagannath temple land.
@@sumitkumarsahu247 What to read about it. Does state government has rights to sell a land donated to temple. Yes and that too only Hindu temples. And then they are used for benefits of Minorities. U don't tell me about 10 minutes to read. I have worked on it much better then u and that's why I have written about it.
Temple fund must be used for promoting the religion. Mere dil main sref 1 question hain ki agar Christian with 1% population itne sare convent school chala sakte hain, Agar sikh 1% population ki sath itne sare langar chala raha hain, agar Muslim itne sare madrasa chala raha hain. Toh phir temple ki "Hazar Hazar" core donation kaha par ha raha hain.🧐🧐 Hume bhi Hindu School, Langar ki vyavastha karna chahiye.😡😡😡
Sikho k gurduware ka ba yahi situation hea Sarkar control karti hea amritsar golden temple Aur sare funds ko bhi Election band hea 11 saal se Religious genocide kar rahe hea yea capitalistic soch k log
In Guruvayur temple the state has put their own hundi for collecting money from the devotees. People would put money in them without realizing that its a state govt hundi not the temple managements.
@@heenabaharmir18 Bohut sare gareeb lok temple ke around economy ke upor dependent hai Vo nahi paata ? . Koi flower sell karta hai , koi mala Ya fir prasad ke upper dependent hai. Aree andhabhakt , apni akhe khol.
@@shayanraj7840 😂😂😂tu sacchi gawar hy...maine ye kaha ki log itna gold god ko gift dete hy...usi ke badle wahi gareebon ku kyun nahi dete...padai likhai kar na be pehle tu
The Hindus should be given right to vote in temples. And the management committee should be elected by common Hindus and should be recallable by simple majority.
Thats how most hindu temples that are not under government control function. The ones under government control has administrators that are appointed by the government.
Raghav Chadha met Our Finance minister immediately when she put tax on Gurudwara but nobody spoke from so many years Hindu temples were giving tax Secularism ☕🥲
@@pardeeptandon our rituals are not practiced properly in jagannath puri temple because of lack of fund. Though the temple got enormous donations govt takes all the money and our ages old traditions are not performed ....
Likewise Akash Banerjee is known as journalist, content creator on political issues, when we take his name we call him journalist Akash BAnerjee, likewise Jaggi Vasudev is known as spiritual master too, he has initiated million of people into yoga, kriya and other spiritual practices. Kung Fu masters are well respected all over the world and in our country , spiritual masters have always been dis honored , disrespected by leftist journalists. Akash Banerjee should not call himself as a journalist because he already has declared himself and leftist and atheist . He will surely become biased against anybody who is a theist , religious and also anybody who embraces spirituality
@@akshaykumar465 in the time of godi media, we need people like Akash . and sir I don,t know you but I will say that in his previous video the raised the problem of my and my people in his video, so those who are raising the voice of common people, are no leftist or rightist, they are just maintaining media as the 4th pillar of democracy
What you’ve missed Akash is the historical function of temples. They were not just a religious places, but served as banks, resting places, contract registrars - basically offered facilities for traders. That’s why you find Hindu temples even across the silk roads. They had tremendous wealth, not just from donations, hence all invaders targeted temples. Britishers institutionalised the controls, which we keep till today. The argument that ‘scale’ justifies control is weak - less scale doesn’t mean less corruption. Perhaps, a way to end this debate is to use historicity and scale in conjunction - any religious institution, which has a certain historical and archeological significance - mosque, temple or church etc - could be under an act that supervised. And additionally, any without historical importance but has scale, could be added too. But, as a secular nation, managing one religion’s institutions, whatever the arguments, and letting others run with full autonomy is definitely a problem
I support freedom of hindu temples ❤️❤️❤️ i am Muslim i support the freedom of hindu temples.... Because I also want freedom to muslim infrastructure like Taj Mahal and Red fort .... Government should not control others things let the community benifit from their history places
@@Pragatiii ... How much money government funded each Hindu clubs to celebrate only Hindu festival like Durga Pooja in West Bengal , ram navami in utterpradesh and birthday of lord Krishna in Bihar??? 🙂
@@Pragatiii don’t think there’s any propaganda involved at all. Infact, the point was made to highlight why temples were targeted - it was less about religion and more about wealth. And yes, if temples, then other religious institutions also should have better oversight.
Government using the fund to maintain church and mosque which is against the law in costitution which says donation from one community can not be used to promote other.
Likewise Akash Banerjee is known as journalist, content creator on political issues, when we take his name we call him journalist Akash BAnerjee, Jaggi Vasudev is known as spiritual master too, he has initiated million of people into yoga, kriya and other spiritual practices. Kung Fu masters are well respected all over the world and in our country , spiritual masters have always been dis honored , disrespected by leftist journalists. Akash Banerjee should not call himself as a journalist because he already has declared himself and leftist and atheist . He will surely become biased against anybody who is a theist , religious and also anybody who embraces spirituality
4:25 you said temple money can only be used for temples but a well known example in last year was Tirupati temple money was used for 684 crore flyover project where the temple payed 67% of the amount while the state is supposed to pay remaining. Anyone can explain?
FYI.. The temple was exempted from sales tax, wealth tax and income tax besides VAT by the Centre and state governments in the past but has come under the tax scheme for Modi government's GST and is now required to pay 100 crores.. There are more than 3000 temples in Telangana and Andhra Pradesh of which 70% came under the taxing scheme.
@@Suresh_Kamath You absolutely answered nothing! Either Tirupati temple did not pay money for the flyover (not likely as this fact is reported in multiple media outlets including The Hindu) or The Deshbhkat statement is incorrect….which one is it?
1992 mai Ajmer mai jo sex scandal hua tha usme Ajmer darga ke hi log the agar wo govt. Ke control mai hota to shayad un Masum ladkiyo ko justice time par mil jaata.
Ok illiterate did this bast@₹d explained How government is minting money from Temples & didn't said anything about mosque, church control. He is paid by China to spread misinformation. Shame on him and u
Likewise Akash Banerjee is known as journalist, content creator on political issues, when we take his name we call him journalist Akash BAnerjee, Jaggi Vasudev is known as spiritual master too, he has initiated million of people into yoga, kriya and other spiritual practices. Kung Fu masters are well respected all over the world and in our country , spiritual masters have always been dis honored , disrespected by leftist journalists. Akash Banerjee should not call himself as a journalist because he already has declared himself and leftist and atheist . He will surely become biased against anybody who is a theist , religious and also anybody who embraces spirituality
Akash ! If protecting dalits was an issue, they should have taken mosques and churches under control too. Pasmanda Muslims aren't allowed in few mosques, only Ashraf Muslims can give sermons. Dalit converts to Christianity face discrimination, in few places they can't bury in the same graveyard as other upper class Christians. But they still don't take control of their religious institutions. Main reason you missed was, people like power and to control people that's why temples aren't free.
@@arpansarkar6726Women can enter mosques. Don't you know?? In majority of Mosques...there is Not enough Infrastructure...so even Men read Namaz outside...so why women will come to read Namaz?? And it is Not obligatory for them to go to Mosques. Ab apne religion pe dhyaan do...samjhe??
Bhai tumhari diplomacy about everything is just perfect to being a human.. Thanks u for tht knowledge and information u provide to make us knw about the real world we live in..
@@peigamberrapeayesha7492 It requires common sense and internet connection expose this guy. These dumb people will anyday follow him eitherways. When Indians start getting their own brain this guy will become homeless
Recently Andhra govt built a bridge in tirupati with Tirupati devasthanam money of 200 cr. It was supposed to be built by govt. But they used temple money, and divert the govt money to buy votes.
Likewise Akash Banerjee is known as journalist, content creator on political issues, when we take his name we call him journalist Akash BAnerjee, Jaggi Vasudev is known as spiritual master too, he has initiated million of people into yoga, kriya and other spiritual practices. Kung Fu masters are well respected all over the world and in our country , spiritual masters have always been dis honored , disrespected by leftist journalists. Akash Banerjee should not call himself as a journalist because he already has declared himself and leftist and atheist . He will surely become biased against anybody who is a theist , religious and also anybody who embraces spirituality
Only hindu temples are under control of Government. And others are not Most strong swadeshi religion is sikhi in which every Sikh has right to vote in Gurudwara. I have accepted sikhi (by own choice) as I found it administratively strongest as more rights to sangat.
"Only hindu temples are under control of Government." Yes and thats against the spirit of secularism. Why should government dictate terms for hindus and leave others free??
Sir all in gurudwara committee works under specific parties . You seems like you just go to gurudwara and worship and come home and rant in public . Even golden temple was always under pressure of akali dal (prove me wrong)
@@expiredparacetamol but the right to choose the local administers of each and every Gurudwara are with the gurudwara sangat, and in these local elections votes happen for each and every member, there is way more control that the sangat has locally.
Best option for the supreme court is to layout some conditions which should be adhered strictly by the independent temple boards, as well timely auditing of its funds by govt agencies. This will make sure that all hindus irrespective caste are allowed entry and the finance are transparent. Many hindus including myself hesitate to donate because we know the money is going to the govt.
@@wolf5393 we don't donate money in home temple 😘. And religious building these are public property not kisi ke baap ki kyo koi ek enjoy kare humare paise pe
@@inspiredyourself3902 u r the one giving control not me. Remember asaram whose charn were touch by BJP supreme leader. Giving charge of everything to gov u must also know whom gov is in touch with. And i m damn sure u would do that too as soon as pm comes up at evening and gives a speech or ahould i say order- as seen in the past closing lights, bartan peetne and taali bajana.
Ranbir Kapoor said I love beef in past nowadays he was not allowed to enter Temple in past Vivek Agnihotri also said same in past why we don't treat them same manner
very nice explanation enjoyed watching your video .....i personally think every religious institution should be taxed also donation to political parties and my favorite BCCI 🙂
Desh buddhist Hindus sanatani ke mandiro par Brahminwadiyo ne nazayaz kabja kiya huwa, jabki ye mandir Brahminwad dharam ke naam par nahi chalte. Mene suna he ki kuch brahmin pujari trustee log Desh Buddhist Hindu sanatani ka aur unke bhagwaan ka pese chize churaate he. Bhakt aur bhagwaan ke bich chhor thug lootere pujari trustee ka Kya kaam, unko Kya haq darwaja aur tala lagane ka. Desh ke mandiro ko Brahmino se mukt karake bahujano ka kabja hona chahiye.
Likewise Akash Banerjee is known as journalist, content creator on political issues, when we take his name we call him journalist Akash BAnerjee, Jaggi Vasudev is known as spiritual master too, he has initiated million of people into yoga, kriya and other spiritual practices. Kung Fu masters are well respected all over the world and in our country , spiritual masters have always been dis honored , disrespected by leftist journalists. Akash Banerjee should not call himself as a journalist because he already has declared himself and leftist and atheist . He will surely become biased against anybody who is a theist , religious and also anybody who embraces spirituality
@@akshaykumar465 r u really theist or just pretending. Ok, tell me, if u r really theist than check rigveda and answer me, how many horses Surya Dev use in his cart for to take rounds around Earth in order to bring nights and days?
Solution is easy...central govt must start controlling all the religious institutions with same law anywhere in India. Merit based recruitment should be done for pandits or molvis with govt salary irrespective of Cast/ religion. Extra profit must be utilised for development of public temple/mosque/ church/ gurdwara etc.
This would be a great solution except that even central universities don't hire professors based only on merit. Those who know, know. Those outside of academia wear rose-tinted glasses and assume that selection is merit-based.
The contribution of religious visits in India's GDP is 2.32 percent and the economy of the temple is about 3.02 lakh crores.Temples employ vendors of religious books, garlands, idols-pictures and urns, offerings. They also employ rickshaw pullers and auto drivers to take the pilgrims to the temple. Hotels and dharamshalas near the temple also provide employment.
guys im from ANDHRAPRADESH we have famous hindu temple LORD VENKATESWARA at TIRUPATI yearly temple get 1000 crores from devotees to god but this year the temple committe estimating that 1500 crores but i dont know where it is going
One Thing i observed In my local area one of the famous temples there ...where local sub collector, local tahsildar and Inspector in charge who came to the temple and started opening the door and took all the donated money from the donated box.
Temples were built by the kings and queens of the past, there are no religion heads who build them, they never had the money. Temples would still come under government but they should stop control and just be observer/overseer not just for temples but for other religions as well to stay secular. My ancestors built temples and have been dharmakartha but it they were part of the government to be able to do that feat. Same is the case of Bhadrachalam, Tanjaore. Temples were always funded by by government, but not controlled like how it is now. Administration should be left to locals to carry out the rituals and let them manage the money themselves.
Thats the point, kings controlled the temples Coz they built it! Indian govt hasn't built any temples, so they shouldn't control it. E.g. even mosques were built by kings but are they under govt control? NO. Similarly temples shouldn't be under govt control. As simple as that.
Hindu temple built by hindu kings with the tax paid by the hindu people. No religion? Tamil nadu government HRCE a poor administration. Earlier 5,25,000 acre land now 4,78,000 acre land only available. That more than 1 lakh temple land documents not yet uploaded in the HRCE website.
Excuse me.. Your ancestors built temples? Dharmakarthas have nothing to do with temple construction..😂 You want the temple be managed by which locals? Do you mean the local wealthy powerful thugs roaming around the streets? Will he take responsibility of all the assets and protection of the temple...? The local you say will be from one particular caste who may discriminate the other suppressed set of people.. Dharmakarthas have proven history of looting the temple. Don't live in dreams, as you said temple are built by Kings and now it is democracy so we the people (The Govt) should manage.
Likewise Akash Banerjee is known as journalist, content creator on political issues, when we take his name we call him journalist Akash BAnerjee, Jaggi Vasudev is known as spiritual master too, he has initiated million of people into yoga, kriya and other spiritual practices. Kung Fu masters are well respected all over the world and in our country , spiritual masters have always been dis honored , disrespected by leftist journalists. Akash Banerjee should not call himself as a journalist because he already has declared himself and leftist and atheist . He will surely become biased against anybody who is a theist , religious and also anybody who embraces spirituality
@@rajesh_624 not individuals,, every temple will have a temple committee, they should manage it,, or take masjid and church also to the control of government
What ever the percentages you mentioned might not be correct !! I’ve noticed one thing in my hometown. Three major temples of the town are being administered by one endowment officer. Avg. total income of 3 temples is 60~80 k and official salary of endowment officer is 50k. and assistant’s salary is 12k. How can this be possible !!! Where is the money left for maintaining temple and renovation etc ??
Why can't we tax all religious institutions and organisations, irrespective of religion, and yes the government should not interfere in religious activities and vice versa
@@pardeeptandon because significant of corruption can happen in religious activities.swami/imam/pope can accumulate butt load of money, why can't we question them. Coming to breathing, it is not a business yet.
@@sameerm38: Corruption occurs in Hindu temples because government-appointed trustees run them and not the elected representatives of devotees of these temples. If Sikhs can effectively manage their Gurdawars through elected representatives, I am Sure Hindus also can do it. But these Champions of Hindu interests ( BJP & RSS) will never do or allow it.
@@pardeeptandon you see iscon is privately managed entity, can you say that it is not corrupted? I have my doubts on gurudwaras, churches and Waqf boards as well. We need audit every thing and tax everything. I ask religious institutions as corporate entities or NGOs atleast. Btw I am an atheist
@@sameerm38: I am unaware of how Iscon is managed, so I will not comment on it. The Waqf board is like Hindu temples managed by Government appointed trustees. While Sikh Gurudawars are governed by elected representatives of the community, and one sees them doing a lot of charitable public good activities. Hence I advocate that Hindu temples be run by elected representatives of the devotees of that temple.
The British brought temple control because most of the temples were rich in resources at that time. Gold, money, land etc, etc etc. We continued with a lot of archaic laws even after independence. All religious places should have blended systems such that government is just the administration of last resort.
Britishers gave all religious communities the option to come up with their own system to administrate their religious affairs. Muslims, Sikhs, Christians, Buddhists and Parsis came up with a proposal which, by and large, the Britishers accepted. Still, Hindus could not, as they were artificially created by the Britishers for their administrative ease, so they kept Hindus under their control, which continues to date.
@@pardeeptandon keep your communist propaganda out of here. Read a book or two on history of Hinduism and from where did this word come from (hint- Sindhu Sanskrit)
@@KrishanKumar-el1zu: Can you name one King who called himself a Hindu King? Even lord RAM was not known as a Hindu King. You need to expand your knowledge beyond Whatsapp University. The Britishers artificially created the Hindu religion by clubbing all NON- ABRAHAMIC RELIGIONS under the umbrella of the Hindu religion for their administrative ease. The Joke is in You !!!
@@mihirpingle5067: I hope you know Communist China is doing Capitalism better than India. Dear Historian, can you name one king in history who called himself a " HINDU KING"? The word Hindu/ Hindi/ was first used as an address to register pilgrimage who came to Meaca from the East of the Hindu Kush mountains in the 8th century. Before that, the word " Hindu " is not found in any literature.
This issues raises a serious question on indian about equality to its citizens. Either all places of worship should be administered or none. Also If things are running for long time doesn't means its right. I feel Its quite possible this can be a starting point for indian gov to administer all places of worship and monitor how where the budget is spent (locally/ internationally) 😉
Government cannot interfere in religion matters but it just wanna supress Hindus Any Government may be it does same. Hindus should form committee and register those and the committee members must be elected and recallable by common Hindus. The law for this is needed This will make temple administration as strong as Gurudwara administration
@@suradhayakshsinghbansal4950 the problem is "who is the Hindu"? Because there have been many cases of caste politics when it comes to heading the temple committee.. forget caste there was even a court battle for years between sects of Vaishnavism over a temple elephant on which type of tilak it should have.. so how do u resolve a temple committee when caste and sectarian politics dominates?
From open economy in 1980s to a non-democracy. From "freedom of speech" to "freedom to kill". From 4% inflation to god knows what. All this and many other issues have created uncertainty, fear, anxiety, and loss of faith in the common man. Unfortunate but true. And no one is looking at these things. All we are doing is making life difficult for the common man!!!
The economy was in a shitty position in the 80s,I’m no BJP bhakt first of all,the economy opened up in the 90s after liberalisation.Indira Gandhi was even more autocratic and congress has been very corrupt all these years. Even BJP is correct,every government and party is corrupt but congress has been the worst of all.
@@vedantmehra4058 that guy was stating facts and not saying who was worse. We should focus on important issues no matter which party. Ultimately it's the common man who suffers!
When politics and constitution can interfere in particular religious matter similarly religion can interfere in politics and constitutional matter 🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩
Agar paisa kisi aur cheez mein use nahi hota toh Karnataka minister nei kyu kaha tha ki " hum hindu temple donation ka paisa ab sei sirf hindu welfare pei hi kharch karenge uska use muslim, Christian welfare mein nahi hoga" matlab uska use pehle Christian and Muslims par hota tha
@@user-ey3dh8gs4j bhai yeh madarsechap hai tabhi isko dekhte hai , channel ka naam deshbhaqt rakh liya 😁😁😁 defense detective youtuber ne isko exposed kar diya
The temple has always helped in times of need from its own funds. Wherever there was a disaster and this time in the covid crisis, many temples have donated crores. There are many temples where there is a system of free Bhandara and many also run trusts for social welfare.
Look bhandara is good thing but we should have some system even with religion like a temple a mosque and church gurudwara in 6km radius. Nowadays we have all of them in like 2km radius .
I think if any religion has any problem with how things are handled in their community they should come to a consensus and deal with it. They don't need to meddle with the status quo of other religions. My point is to fight for your problems without pointing out other religions. Because what might happen is instead of your problem being solved, the other community might have another problem to deal with.
@@Aadiilifestyle Muslim richest institute was control by waqf board and waqf board is controlled by Indian Government... 🙂🙂🙂Or tujhe lagta hey humey bohot freedom hey ???
@@Aadiilifestyle we support freedom of Hindu temples because we don't want discrimination against Non-hindu ... Because Hindu temples get government privileged of billions dollars tax payers money in the name of tourism and repair of historical infrastructure for centuries.... So instead of pointing on others religion you should fight for your religion against government because other religions have different problems to fight with government ok ...
There was a threat to all temples in India by the RSS organisation those are the sleeper cell of British East India Company. The only motive of RSS was to create division between Hindus itself based on their caste, Brahmin and Dalit etc. apart from the communal hatred. Post India Independence Kings Maharaja had to sacrifice there land and property including temples built by them to the govt. of India. Therefore govt. had to manage and maintain social harmony, peace and tranquillity from the undue interference of RSS who had claimed themselves as the fake custodian of Hindutva. This was well known to our forefather but now a days "Bul Bul birds and Veeru Savarkar" virus has wiped off Indian history with fake political agenda to divide and rule. Department of Archaeology (Central Government) wanted to preserve certain monuments like "Taj Mahal", Kutab Minar, Red Fort, Konark temple (Sun Temple) etc. However RSS driven BJP govt. has sold Redfort to a private company in addition to other PSU (Railway, Airport etc.) Now Temple is under constant threat from the RSS lead govt. and Hindus are afraid of the new Hitler who can sell Hindu temples for a profit.
It's so laughable, how religious fights are taken up so seriously by any state govt, but nothing is being done for the safety of men and women. So many acts to control religious places but nothing significant for woman's safety. And like atleast, thanks Akash, great content 💫
@@officemail689 totally agree Men i feel are the once who rarely speak about their issues as hence leads to high suicide rates.. all of this needs to change And it will change only when a country can see above religion and race. If the men and women of the country can be safe and sound, only then the country can progress. 💫
How the hell is that relevant here ? You can ask for more laws for woman safety but I don't see why it has to be done by belittling the current issue at hand
The Central Government should take the 5000 Ton gold of the temples in its possession, otherwise after Ghazwa E Hind, all this gold will in the possession of Muslims as a Maal E Ganimat...🙄
Do hard work, Focus on your content and In sha Allah you will get success. Also connect with Allah...share all your good n Bad moments with Allah...seek help from Allah...He will surely help and Bless you🙂
Sir aapke content and sab itne awsom hai ki time ka pata nhi chalta, and aap or issues ly kar aaye ,various points jo aap relate karte hai, then many questions jo put hote ,or jo hone bhi chaiye ..wo sab bahut hi effective hai,
Sikh gurudwara's are managed under the Sikh Gurudwara Act (1925). Designed to remove the pover of Udasi Mahants who used to 'control' the administration of key Sikh gurudwaras.
39000 acres of Jagannath Puri mandir was sold by Orissa govt.
4 out of 7 mountains of Tirupati Mandir was donated to Churches and mosques
18 temples and idols were destroyed and demolished by missionaries in Tamil Nadu between 2020 and 2022 and no restoration done.
Many temples of Kerala, tamilnadu, Andra Pradesh, Karnataka are still close because of either community cleansing or no funds.
These things are in front of our eyes still some idiots cannot see.
Give the reference please
@@akshitpandey9860 search for local news articles. How can I share links or pics here
@@akshitpandey9860 Jagannath point 18 March 21 news of India today, opindia, telegraph etc
About tirupati mountains, under Jerusalem pilgrimage subsidy on behalf of APSRTC the church and many other things are built by them.
Infact many trustees are Christian and Muslim. Most of the people who are working as sevedaar are muslims so they had filed petition of keeping tirupati mandir closed on Friday to let them offer namaz.
U can search for local news papers u will get more details knowledge
@@dikshadave6443 Kindly don't spread fake news about Jagannath temple just to support your agenda.
If you really cared, you could spend 10 minutes to read about Jagannath temple land.
@@sumitkumarsahu247 What to read about it. Does state government has rights to sell a land donated to temple. Yes and that too only Hindu temples. And then they are used for benefits of Minorities. U don't tell me about 10 minutes to read. I have worked on it much better then u and that's why I have written about it.
Temple fund must be used for promoting the religion.
Mere dil main sref 1 question hain ki agar Christian with 1% population itne sare convent school chala sakte hain, Agar sikh 1% population ki sath itne sare langar chala raha hain, agar Muslim itne sare madrasa chala raha hain.
Toh phir temple ki "Hazar Hazar" core donation kaha par ha raha hain.🧐🧐
Hume bhi Hindu School, Langar ki vyavastha karna chahiye.😡😡😡
bilkul aur gadhe converted logon ko ghar wapasi karwani chahiye warna ek din ek bhi hindu nhi bachega
politicians khaa rhe hain tumhare mandir ki donations
@@iJasdeep right
Sikho k gurduware ka ba yahi situation hea
Sarkar control karti hea amritsar golden temple
Aur sare funds ko bhi
Election band hea 11 saal se
Religious genocide kar rahe hea yea capitalistic soch k log
Kuch faida nahi hai aapko kya lagta hai aap se pehle yeh kisine socha nahi hoga jab politition garib insaan ko nahi chodti woh mandir ko kya chodegi
I think we should keep any or all religious and religious institutions away from politics because it could be politicised in any manner in future .
When gov control temples and asks temple to not interfere with gov. This is why BJP is ruling India.
@@BruceWayne-qe7bs wtf??
Not it could be
It always been Politicised
@@chiragparsoya3754 To be more precise. Politics should not interfere in religion, otherwise religion interfere in Politics.
@@BruceWayne-qe7bs Andhbhakt 🤣
In Guruvayur temple the state has put their own hundi for collecting money from the devotees. People would put money in them without realizing that its a state govt hundi not the temple managements.
Rather than controlling only Temples , Govt should take control of Church , Mosque and other things.
😂😂lets start with temples first...tirupati is the most one where people donate a lot of gold to god
@@heenabaharmir18 So what ? People donate from their own side , Tera baap ka kya jata hai ?
@@shayanraj7840 kise jaata hy jo donate kiya...better gareebon mein kare...tera baap ke baare mein maine kuch na hi bola...tu bhi na hi bol
@@heenabaharmir18 Bohut sare gareeb lok temple ke around economy ke upor dependent hai Vo nahi paata ? . Koi flower sell karta hai , koi mala Ya fir prasad ke upper dependent hai. Aree andhabhakt , apni akhe khol.
@@shayanraj7840 😂😂😂tu sacchi gawar hy...maine ye kaha ki log itna gold god ko gift dete hy...usi ke badle wahi gareebon ku kyun nahi dete...padai likhai kar na be pehle tu
The Hindus should be given right to vote in temples. And the management committee should be elected by common Hindus and should be recallable by simple majority.
Thats how most hindu temples that are not under government control function. The ones under government control has administrators that are appointed by the government.
Are sir
Agr Hindu temple ,.se control nhi hat skta .,to baaki churches masjid pe bhi control kro
That's what govt gonna do if they took control over those.
Hindus nu bol rea apne gurudware ta dekh le badal de thalle saare loot k kha rea saala da .... Apne krwa le election
Then why not all temples, gurudwara, church, masjid.
Why only specific things sir
It must be equal for every religion, it’s either free temples or every other religious temples/institutions must come under government.
Why??
Don't bring other religions into discussion here. Don't interfere in their matter
@@jioboy2676 😂😂
@@madhabmondal8890 hasne wali kya baat he??
@@jioboy2676 I felt your first comment was sarcasti6
@@madhabmondal8890 he is muslim,how much money muslim person law board,dargah of sufi etc.
Our Government now targeting the wealth of Temples wow! 😂😂😂 To be honest our Government are not less than the East India company though 😂😂
Now its west India company as all the money is going to western state of Gujarat
It's a way of making a single religion poor🖊️
👍👍👍
Pujaris are also one of them .
Mostly South india
#ॐ_श्रीगणेशाय_नम: #ॐ_जय_श्रीराम #ॐ_जय_श्रीकृष्ण #ॐ_श्रीदुर्गायै_नम: #ॐ_जय_श्री_काशी_विश्वानाथ_शिव_शंकर_शंभू
Raghav Chadha met Our Finance minister immediately when she put tax on Gurudwara but nobody spoke from so many years Hindu temples were giving tax Secularism ☕🥲
Exactly ..... churches and mosques don't pay tax bt y temples only
This Temple looting is also a big time problem in ODISHA also.
What about the recent land scam in RAM temple?
@@pardeeptandon our rituals are not practiced properly in jagannath puri temple because of lack of fund. Though the temple got enormous donations govt takes all the money and our ages old traditions are not performed ....
@@pardeeptandon just go ...and tell this nonsense to muslim....what they are doing in madrassas....
Then talk to us
@@bhaskarpathak7924 Pathak? 🤔 Odia or hindi????
I love this guy
God always blesses you my friend
day by day content quality is increasing love your efforts
Likewise Akash Banerjee is known as journalist, content creator on political issues, when we take his name we call him journalist Akash BAnerjee, likewise Jaggi Vasudev is known as spiritual master too, he has initiated million of people into yoga, kriya and other spiritual practices. Kung Fu masters are well respected all over the world and in our country , spiritual masters have always been dis honored , disrespected by leftist journalists. Akash Banerjee should not call himself as a journalist because he already has declared himself and leftist and atheist . He will surely become biased against anybody who is a theist , religious and also anybody who embraces spirituality
@@akshaykumar465 in the time of godi media, we need people like Akash . and sir I don,t know you but I will say that in his previous video the raised the problem of my and my people in his video, so those who are raising the voice of common people, are no leftist or rightist, they are just maintaining media as the 4th pillar of democracy
New india
@@newtechnology3658 true
RIP freedom of religion and Equality 🤬🤬🤬
This is the biggest discrimination on hinduism
But the question of "Why only temples?" is still unanswered. Why not Mosque, Church???
Because mosque doesn't have historical heritage.....but hindu mandir's have....govt have to protect this heritage
@@biswajit9763 they should invest more in temple maintenance
Sar tan se juda is the reason they are radicals
@@biswajit9763 let's make India a hindu rashtra, all problems will solved ❣️ Because by your thought India has hindu history
@@biswajit9763 what historical heritage do newly built temples have? Why do they have to be under the government?
Hamare Mandir Hame Wapas Do
🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩
Jai Shree Ram
What you’ve missed Akash is the historical function of temples. They were not just a religious places, but served as banks, resting places, contract registrars - basically offered facilities for traders. That’s why you find Hindu temples even across the silk roads. They had tremendous wealth, not just from donations, hence all invaders targeted temples. Britishers institutionalised the controls, which we keep till today.
The argument that ‘scale’ justifies control is weak - less scale doesn’t mean less corruption.
Perhaps, a way to end this debate is to use historicity and scale in conjunction - any religious institution, which has a certain historical and archeological significance - mosque, temple or church etc - could be under an act that supervised. And additionally, any without historical importance but has scale, could be added too.
But, as a secular nation, managing one religion’s institutions, whatever the arguments, and letting others run with full autonomy is definitely a problem
He will not tell this because it doesn't suits his propaganda
I support freedom of hindu temples ❤️❤️❤️ i am Muslim i support the freedom of hindu temples.... Because I also want freedom to muslim infrastructure like Taj Mahal and Red fort .... Government should not control others things let the community benifit from their history places
@@Pragatiii ... How much money government funded each Hindu clubs to celebrate only Hindu festival like Durga Pooja in West Bengal , ram navami in utterpradesh and birthday of lord Krishna in Bihar??? 🙂
@@Pragatiii Tell what? It seems that I perceived someone who failed to comprehend what the OP conveyed.
@@Pragatiii don’t think there’s any propaganda involved at all. Infact, the point was made to highlight why temples were targeted - it was less about religion and more about wealth.
And yes, if temples, then other religious institutions also should have better oversight.
Government using the fund to maintain church and mosque which is against the law in costitution which says donation from one community can not be used to promote other.
Great to see aakash discussing this vital issue with facts as always!. 😊👌
Likewise Akash Banerjee is known as journalist, content creator on political issues, when we take his name we call him journalist Akash BAnerjee, Jaggi Vasudev is known as spiritual master too, he has initiated million of people into yoga, kriya and other spiritual practices. Kung Fu masters are well respected all over the world and in our country , spiritual masters have always been dis honored , disrespected by leftist journalists. Akash Banerjee should not call himself as a journalist because he already has declared himself and leftist and atheist . He will surely become biased against anybody who is a theist , religious and also anybody who embraces spirituality
4:25 you said temple money can only be used for temples but a well known example in last year was Tirupati temple money was used for 684 crore flyover project where the temple payed 67% of the amount while the state is supposed to pay remaining. Anyone can explain?
FYI.. The temple was exempted from sales tax, wealth tax and income tax besides VAT by the Centre and state governments in the past but has come under the tax scheme for Modi government's GST and is now required to pay 100 crores.. There are more than 3000 temples in Telangana and Andhra Pradesh of which 70% came under the taxing scheme.
@@Suresh_Kamath gyani sir hindu endowment act ka bhi btado
@@jatin9070 Then watch this video
@@Suresh_Kamath You absolutely answered nothing! Either Tirupati temple did not pay money for the flyover (not likely as this fact is reported in multiple media outlets including The Hindu) or The Deshbhkat statement is incorrect….which one is it?
Was this project for the convenience of the pilgrims coming to the Temple?
Then why social justice should also be brought in mosques by allowing women to enter mosque for religious.
Then these places of worship (mosques) become places of love affairs.
1992 mai Ajmer mai jo sex scandal hua tha usme Ajmer darga ke hi log the agar wo govt. Ke control mai hota to shayad un Masum ladkiyo ko justice time par mil jaata.
Level of Indian 🇮🇳 secularism 😂😂😂🤣
We know this that's why we support BJP
Is bjp doing anything about it😐😶
@@freshminds9229 BJP raise their voice against this...
Can u give the name of single party who talk for free temples
Only BJP stand for Hindu
That's why people want bjp government in their states and not loot party congress.
Ye discrimination ab mujhse nhi dekha jata
your consistency never disappoints us
bakwas bittu chanal ko subscribe
True ..✌️
Ok illiterate did this bast@₹d explained
How government is minting money from
Temples & didn't said anything about mosque, church control.
He is paid by China to spread misinformation.
Shame on him and u
Likewise Akash Banerjee is known as journalist, content creator on political issues, when we take his name we call him journalist Akash BAnerjee, Jaggi Vasudev is known as spiritual master too, he has initiated million of people into yoga, kriya and other spiritual practices. Kung Fu masters are well respected all over the world and in our country , spiritual masters have always been dis honored , disrespected by leftist journalists. Akash Banerjee should not call himself as a journalist because he already has declared himself and leftist and atheist . He will surely become biased against anybody who is a theist , religious and also anybody who embraces spirituality
Akash ! If protecting dalits was an issue, they should have taken mosques and churches under control too. Pasmanda Muslims aren't allowed in few mosques, only Ashraf Muslims can give sermons. Dalit converts to Christianity face discrimination, in few places they can't bury in the same graveyard as other upper class Christians. But they still don't take control of their religious institutions. Main reason you missed was, people like power and to control people that's why temples aren't free.
@@arpansarkar6726Women can enter mosques. Don't you know??
In majority of Mosques...there is Not enough Infrastructure...so even Men read Namaz outside...so why women will come to read Namaz?? And it is Not obligatory for them to go to Mosques.
Ab apne religion pe dhyaan do...samjhe??
@@jioboy2676 tmhare religion pe do minute baat karte hi jal kyu jati hai tumhari?
kahan..konse jagah mein Pasmanda Muslimo ko Mosque mein allow Nahin karte?? Proof ke saath bata.
Ye apna caste division apne pass rakho.
@@akshatjain1130 Isme jalne wali kya baat he??
Tum hamare religion pe baat hi kyun kaorge?? Ajeeb ha.ra.mi ho tum log
@Jai Bhim Ya...sure. haven't you seen in major mosques?? Women are allowed
Bhai tumhari diplomacy about everything is just perfect to being a human.. Thanks u for tht knowledge and information u provide to make us knw about the real world we live in..
He is great unlike loyal dog .german shepherd dhruv rathee
🤣🤣🤣 Defense detective youtuber ne exposed kar diya isko 🤣🤣
@@peigamberrapeayesha7492 It requires common sense and internet connection expose this guy. These dumb people will anyday follow him eitherways. When Indians start getting their own brain this guy will become homeless
Mandir should not have control of people belonging to any caste lower than Brahmins.
@@dharmeshyadav4563 🤡 aa gya choti soch ka 🤏
The biggest problem is that politician use temples for the political ideology...
कितनी नाइंसाफी है। 'वे' तो चार-चार कर सकते हैं, और हमें एक से ही संतोष करना पड़ता है !😭😭😭
Looting Hindu temples ? Those Temple's were bank in early days .
You are believing government for management you know what they do with taxes.
Today true journalism in India is finished peoples like Aakash sir is last refugees for us ( Indians) . 👍 for his efforts.
Chatna band karo.
Really?????? How sweet 😂😂😂
Waah Sherlock
Kya observation hai
Joke of the century
Chamcha hai 😂😂
ఓం నమో వెంకటేశయ. ఓం నమః శివాయ.
Recently Andhra govt built a bridge in tirupati with Tirupati devasthanam money of 200 cr. It was supposed to be built by govt. But they used temple money, and divert the govt money to buy votes.
Can’t wait for post Sep 19 analyses! Thank you Deshbhakt for your research and reporting.
Likewise Akash Banerjee is known as journalist, content creator on political issues, when we take his name we call him journalist Akash BAnerjee, Jaggi Vasudev is known as spiritual master too, he has initiated million of people into yoga, kriya and other spiritual practices. Kung Fu masters are well respected all over the world and in our country , spiritual masters have always been dis honored , disrespected by leftist journalists. Akash Banerjee should not call himself as a journalist because he already has declared himself and leftist and atheist . He will surely become biased against anybody who is a theist , religious and also anybody who embraces spirituality
Only hindu temples are under control of Government. And others are not
Most strong swadeshi religion is sikhi in which every Sikh has right to vote in Gurudwara.
I have accepted sikhi (by own choice) as I found it administratively strongest as more rights to sangat.
"Only hindu temples are under control of Government." Yes and thats against the spirit of secularism. Why should government dictate terms for hindus and leave others free??
🤣
Sir all in gurudwara committee works under specific parties . You seems like you just go to gurudwara and worship and come home and rant in public . Even golden temple was always under pressure of akali dal (prove me wrong)
@@expiredparacetamol but the right to choose the local administers of each and every Gurudwara are with the gurudwara sangat, and in these local elections votes happen for each and every member, there is way more control that the sangat has locally.
Sikh prist are Most corrupt and manipulating
m not hindu but i agree that rules should be same for every religion. but if free all these religious places many people ll take advantage of this.
So now nobody taking advantage? Is it corruption free?
What why only 🕉
We donate to Hindu deities. If this continues will stop donating. We will give money directly to Pujari.
Best option for the supreme court is to layout some conditions which should be adhered strictly by the independent temple boards, as well timely auditing of its funds by govt agencies. This will make sure that all hindus irrespective caste are allowed entry and the finance are transparent. Many hindus including myself hesitate to donate because we know the money is going to the govt.
in the era of bhakt banerjee and lulu rathi please listen JAI SAI DEEPAK your mind will get definately evolved
you called it the ERA of Bhakt Banerjee 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
thanks a ton bhai!!!! :)
@@thedeshbhakt Trust me, the Dharmic People Will Rise too, Soon, very Soon
@@thedeshbhakt but here he means andhbhakt banerjee. 🤣🤣. But Some times you do some good work as well so atleast i should respect you for that .
Govt shall take immediate control of all temple, in every manner. Church, masjid etc etc so it will help society not single family or individual
You forgot about your home and ur mom.
@@wolf5393 oo your mom ok
@@wolf5393 we don't donate money in home temple 😘. And religious building these are public property not kisi ke baap ki kyo koi ek enjoy kare humare paise pe
Already wakf act 1954, act of 1995 and 2013. All muslim institutions including mosques come under state govt control.
@@inspiredyourself3902 u r the one giving control not me. Remember asaram whose charn were touch by BJP supreme leader. Giving charge of everything to gov u must also know whom gov is in touch with. And i m damn sure u would do that too as soon as pm comes up at evening and gives a speech or ahould i say order- as seen in the past closing lights, bartan peetne and taali bajana.
Ranbir Kapoor said I love beef in past nowadays he was not allowed to enter Temple in past Vivek Agnihotri also said same in past why we don't treat them same manner
Shirdi Sai Baba also gets crores of money. where it goes!!!??
सबसे बड़ी बात है कि सरकार को हिंदू मंदिरों पर इंटरफेयर करना ही क्यों है जब वह चर्च और मस्जिदों पर नहीं कर सकती है
All religions should be given equal laws... v hindus are kept as slaves
very nice explanation enjoyed watching your video .....i personally think every religious institution should be taxed also donation to political parties and my favorite BCCI 🙂
Then tax churches & mosque too.
Ajmer e sarif donation Right
U bast@rd librandu
Correct
Desh buddhist Hindus sanatani ke mandiro par Brahminwadiyo ne nazayaz kabja kiya huwa, jabki ye mandir Brahminwad dharam ke naam par nahi chalte. Mene suna he ki kuch brahmin pujari trustee log Desh Buddhist Hindu sanatani ka aur unke bhagwaan ka pese chize churaate he. Bhakt aur bhagwaan ke bich chhor thug lootere pujari trustee ka Kya kaam, unko Kya haq darwaja aur tala lagane ka. Desh ke mandiro ko Brahmino se mukt karake bahujano ka kabja hona chahiye.
Likewise Akash Banerjee is known as journalist, content creator on political issues, when we take his name we call him journalist Akash BAnerjee, Jaggi Vasudev is known as spiritual master too, he has initiated million of people into yoga, kriya and other spiritual practices. Kung Fu masters are well respected all over the world and in our country , spiritual masters have always been dis honored , disrespected by leftist journalists. Akash Banerjee should not call himself as a journalist because he already has declared himself and leftist and atheist . He will surely become biased against anybody who is a theist , religious and also anybody who embraces spirituality
@@akshaykumar465 r u really theist or just pretending. Ok, tell me, if u r really theist than check rigveda and answer me, how many horses Surya Dev use in his cart for to take rounds around Earth in order to bring nights and days?
Solution is easy...central govt must start controlling all the religious institutions with same law anywhere in India. Merit based recruitment should be done for pandits or molvis with govt salary irrespective of Cast/ religion. Extra profit must be utilised for development of public temple/mosque/ church/ gurdwara etc.
ha ha
Baat toh aap ki sahi hai but iska kya proof hai ke central government is paise ka misuse nahi karege 🤔🤔
Why??? To send all money to Gujarat??😂
Can't agree.
Central Government have no right.
Our padmanabha swami temple in Trivandrum is controlled by Royal family and let it be like that
This would be a great solution except that even central universities don't hire professors based only on merit. Those who know, know. Those outside of academia wear rose-tinted glasses and assume that selection is merit-based.
Endeavour to peace: theocracy to democracy
Endeavour to destruction: democracy to theocracy
Britain is a theocracy
2nd one is happening in India...but the question is what good people of India are doing??
Because bad people have obtained the Power in Politics.
Its Not Anything but Hypocrisy
@@jioboy2676 lol librandus
@@riderchallenge4250 theocrandu lol..goo khale beta💩💩 wohi tera sab kuch hei😂😂
Yeah bahot Na insafi hai Hindu religious k saath
The contribution of religious visits in India's GDP is 2.32 percent and the economy of the temple is about 3.02 lakh crores.Temples employ vendors of religious books, garlands, idols-pictures and urns, offerings. They also employ rickshaw pullers and auto drivers to take the pilgrims to the temple. Hotels and dharamshalas near the temple also provide employment.
guys im from ANDHRAPRADESH we have famous hindu temple LORD VENKATESWARA at TIRUPATI yearly temple get 1000 crores from devotees to god but this year the temple committe estimating that 1500 crores but i dont know where it is going
mc mohammad khud ki masjid madarse chodke hindu temple par najar hai
Main thing is HOW this huge money is spent and does God need all these money??
Jai telugu talli 💪💪⚡⚡
@@Jaitelugutalli jai telugu thalli🇮🇳
Go to vatican @@jioboy2676
Not only temple , all religious places must be monitored by Govt .
Dhruv rathee :
releases 1 video per month on a safe non political topic.
Akash Banerjee :
Editor release 10 bold videos per month 😂😂
😅
Uska 1 hi video kafi hai 😂 or vo kai topics pe bnata hai naki sirf political topis pe
@@yugalkishor8018 wo darta hai ankita ke bare me bolne me,
@@millennialmind9507 ankita who?
@@aadarshshekhar3142 exactly, no media has discussed this issue enough on national television. A lady named Ankita was burned alive by a Muslim boy.
We want Sanatana Dharma Rakshana Board
One Thing i observed
In my local area one of the famous temples there ...where local sub collector, local tahsildar and Inspector in charge who came to the temple and started opening the door and took all the donated money from the donated box.
Chhor. Bhagwan ka donation chura rhe. Khudko bhagwan smjh rhe.
Would love to hear about your say on "what really is happening in Andhra Pradesh"
wish someone covers the political view of AP.
Nice work sir 👍🏼
I will request you to make video on neet/jee mains exams and thier government seats quota for general candidates
Temples were built by the kings and queens of the past, there are no religion heads who build them, they never had the money. Temples would still come under government but they should stop control and just be observer/overseer not just for temples but for other religions as well to stay secular.
My ancestors built temples and have been dharmakartha but it they were part of the government to be able to do that feat. Same is the case of Bhadrachalam, Tanjaore.
Temples were always funded by by government, but not controlled like how it is now. Administration should be left to locals to carry out the rituals and let them manage the money themselves.
Thats the point, kings controlled the temples Coz they built it! Indian govt hasn't built any temples, so they shouldn't control it.
E.g. even mosques were built by kings but are they under govt control? NO. Similarly temples shouldn't be under govt control. As simple as that.
You efiot not every temp is made by govt those temple are situad on god wish.
Religious places are always built by noble men but in the 21st century have to be controlled by the community, not the government.
Hindu temple built by hindu kings with the tax paid by the hindu people. No religion? Tamil nadu government HRCE a poor administration. Earlier 5,25,000 acre land now 4,78,000 acre land only available. That more than 1 lakh temple land documents not yet uploaded in the HRCE website.
Excuse me.. Your ancestors built temples?
Dharmakarthas have nothing to do with temple construction..😂
You want the temple be managed by which locals?
Do you mean the local wealthy powerful thugs roaming around the streets?
Will he take responsibility of all the assets and protection of the temple...?
The local you say will be from one particular caste who may discriminate the other suppressed set of people..
Dharmakarthas have proven history of looting the temple.
Don't live in dreams, as you said temple are built by Kings and now it is democracy so we the people (The Govt) should manage.
Why only temple in secular nation or make bharat Hindurashtra
FREE HINDU TEMPLE
What a timing
Love you sir.,..
We'll reach towards $5 trillion economy, when the Govt should divert it's attention from religion to development
Likewise Akash Banerjee is known as journalist, content creator on political issues, when we take his name we call him journalist Akash BAnerjee, Jaggi Vasudev is known as spiritual master too, he has initiated million of people into yoga, kriya and other spiritual practices. Kung Fu masters are well respected all over the world and in our country , spiritual masters have always been dis honored , disrespected by leftist journalists. Akash Banerjee should not call himself as a journalist because he already has declared himself and leftist and atheist . He will surely become biased against anybody who is a theist , religious and also anybody who embraces spirituality
Dange ☪️ karte h lekin tumko hamesha GOVT HI KYU DIKHTI H ???
Whatever temples should be free
And given to which individuals?
@@rajesh_624 pandit
@@rajesh_624 not individuals,, every temple will have a temple committee, they should manage it,, or take masjid and church also to the control of government
@@rajesh_624 Hindus will decide by voting
My loving Akash, you are displaying real mirror and face of problems.
सुपर्ब अकाश सर थैंक्स बहुत सुंदर और अच्छा लगा निष्पक्ष व्रतालाप 📚🇮🇳🙏🏻
What ever the percentages you mentioned might not be correct !! I’ve noticed one thing in my hometown. Three major temples of the town are being administered by one endowment officer. Avg. total income of 3 temples is 60~80 k and official salary of endowment officer is 50k. and assistant’s salary is 12k. How can this be possible !!! Where is the money left for maintaining temple and renovation etc ??
We donate our money to Deity and for religious cause. Why adharmi people are getting it?
Why can't we tax all religious institutions and organisations, irrespective of religion, and yes the government should not interfere in religious activities and vice versa
Why Tax religious institutions? Why not Tax-Air first?
@@pardeeptandon because significant of corruption can happen in religious activities.swami/imam/pope can accumulate butt load of money, why can't we question them.
Coming to breathing, it is not a business yet.
@@sameerm38: Corruption occurs in Hindu temples because government-appointed trustees run them and not the elected representatives of devotees of these temples. If Sikhs can effectively manage their Gurdawars through elected representatives, I am Sure Hindus also can do it. But these Champions of Hindu interests ( BJP & RSS) will never do or allow it.
@@pardeeptandon you see iscon is privately managed entity, can you say that it is not corrupted? I have my doubts on gurudwaras, churches and Waqf boards as well. We need audit every thing and tax everything. I ask religious institutions as corporate entities or NGOs atleast.
Btw I am an atheist
@@sameerm38: I am unaware of how Iscon is managed, so I will not comment on it. The Waqf board is like Hindu temples managed by Government appointed trustees. While Sikh Gurudawars are governed by elected representatives of the community, and one sees them doing a lot of charitable public good activities. Hence I advocate that Hindu temples be run by elected representatives of the devotees of that temple.
The British brought temple control because most of the temples were rich in resources at that time. Gold, money, land etc, etc etc. We continued with a lot of archaic laws even after independence. All religious places should have blended systems such that government is just the administration of last resort.
Britishers gave all religious communities the option to come up with their own system to administrate their religious affairs. Muslims, Sikhs, Christians, Buddhists and Parsis came up with a proposal which, by and large, the Britishers accepted. Still, Hindus could not, as they were artificially created by the Britishers for their administrative ease, so they kept Hindus under their control, which continues to date.
@@pardeeptandon good joke, there were not allowed to, go read books.
@@pardeeptandon keep your communist propaganda out of here. Read a book or two on history of Hinduism and from where did this word come from (hint- Sindhu Sanskrit)
@@KrishanKumar-el1zu: Can you name one King who called himself a Hindu King? Even lord RAM was not known as a Hindu King.
You need to expand your knowledge beyond Whatsapp University.
The Britishers artificially created the Hindu religion by clubbing all NON- ABRAHAMIC RELIGIONS under the umbrella of the Hindu religion for their administrative ease.
The Joke is in You !!!
@@mihirpingle5067: I hope you know Communist China is doing Capitalism better than India.
Dear Historian, can you name one king in history who called himself a " HINDU KING"?
The word Hindu/ Hindi/ was first used as an address to register pilgrimage who came to Meaca from the East of the Hindu Kush mountains in the 8th century.
Before that, the word " Hindu " is not found in any literature.
#FreeHindutemple 😡
15000 temple are closed in Karnataka , bjp is ruling party then who is the anti hindu now ?
Now why do you care about hindus?
If government is secular then why discriminating hindus only
And why did the government spend so much money to build a temple?
@person1420 That's build by Hindu Devotee's money
This issues raises a serious question on indian about equality to its citizens.
Either all places of worship should be administered or none.
Also If things are running for long time doesn't means its right.
I feel Its quite possible this can be a starting point for indian gov to administer all places of worship and monitor how where the budget is spent (locally/ internationally) 😉
Government cannot interfere in religion matters but it just wanna supress Hindus
Any Government may be it does same.
Hindus should form committee and register those and the committee members must be elected and recallable by common Hindus.
The law for this is needed
This will make temple administration as strong as Gurudwara administration
Mandir should not have control of people belonging to any caste lower than Brahmins.
@@suradhayakshsinghbansal4950 the problem is "who is the Hindu"? Because there have been many cases of caste politics when it comes to heading the temple committee.. forget caste there was even a court battle for years between sects of Vaishnavism over a temple elephant on which type of tilak it should have.. so how do u resolve a temple committee when caste and sectarian politics dominates?
No, In democracy all religions should be allowed to run their own institutions through their elected representatives.
From open economy in 1980s to a non-democracy. From "freedom of speech" to "freedom to kill". From 4% inflation to god knows what. All this and many other issues have created uncertainty, fear, anxiety, and loss of faith in the common man. Unfortunate but true. And no one is looking at these things. All we are doing is making life difficult for the common man!!!
So we'll said
The economy was in a shitty position in the 80s,I’m no BJP bhakt first of all,the economy opened up in the 90s after liberalisation.Indira Gandhi was even more autocratic and congress has been very corrupt all these years. Even BJP is correct,every government and party is corrupt but congress has been the worst of all.
@@vedantmehra4058 that guy was stating facts and not saying who was worse. We should focus on important issues no matter which party. Ultimately it's the common man who suffers!
When politics and constitution can interfere in particular religious matter similarly religion can interfere in politics and constitutional matter 🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩
@@GauravSingh-hg1vo spot on! I think even Akash couldn't have said it better themselves
I never miss your videos Akash Bhai. You actually fill the Gap left by main stream media.
Agar paisa kisi aur cheez mein use nahi hota toh Karnataka minister nei kyu kaha tha ki " hum hindu temple donation ka paisa ab sei sirf hindu welfare pei hi kharch karenge uska use muslim, Christian welfare mein nahi hoga" matlab uska use pehle Christian and Muslims par hota tha
Haa!! A big yes
Sir... I am from Kerala... Can you make a video about our economic disaster...Now salaries also giving by borrowing 😒😒😒😒😒
Yeah Kerala is on the brink of collapse.
hmmm but aren't you the ones who've been electing certain state governments for decades.....
Also about KSRTC DEBUTS
He will not because according to him and Dhruv Rathee Kerala Model is best in everything.
@@nnbg8000 We don't have a choice. The BJP leadership in Kerala is dump. Kerala is also aging state. Most of the old ones are dump commies.
Every IAS aspirant should watch your analysis to gain some clarity over various topics...🙂
🤣
IAS aspirant ? Abey chutiye 🤣🧠
🤣🤣
Thanks for highlighting this sensitive issue and explaining it in an easy way.
Vaishno Devi Mandir managed by Shrine Board is very well maintained
Same with Shirdi Sai Mandir which is well maintained.
Why karnataka govt has slashed yatra funds but didn't touch the hajj funds??
Ooo yaa not selective
akash trying his best to be pesudo secular🤣🤣
In this age of Godi...it takes lot of courage to become Akash Banerjee...❤️🇮🇳
I like him from LAHORE for his bold and straight journalism,
@@Alijah007 we know it definitely,
@@Alijah007 Tum saale ek asmaani kitab ko mante ho, jaake ek pakistani ex muslim ka channel dekh lo
@@Alijah007Koi tajjub ki baat nehi hai...
Akash Banerjee bhi biased haii..
Uske propaganda mein jo fit bythta hai , sirf wohi baat batata haii..
Baki nehi batata...
@@user-ey3dh8gs4j bhai yeh madarsechap hai tabhi isko dekhte hai , channel ka naam deshbhaqt rakh liya 😁😁😁 defense detective youtuber ne isko exposed kar diya
The temple has always helped in times of need from its own funds. Wherever there was a disaster and this time in the covid crisis, many temples have donated crores. There are many temples where there is a system of free Bhandara and many also run trusts for social welfare.
Fully agreed
Look bhandara is good thing but we should have some system even with religion like a temple a mosque and church gurudwara in 6km radius. Nowadays we have all of them in like 2km radius .
What about those temples who are ancient ( no owner ) , they are being controlled by govt.
But you didn't answer why only on temples.
Free Temple Hona chahiye
Fantastic research. Kudos to the team and Akash
Your consistency is increasing yet content is really good
I think if any religion has any problem with how things are handled in their community they should come to a consensus and deal with it. They don't need to meddle with the status quo of other religions. My point is to fight for your problems without pointing out other religions. Because what might happen is instead of your problem being solved, the other community might have another problem to deal with.
Sidha sidha kaho ki muslman se pyaar hai
Unke religious place ke baare me kuch mat bolo
@@Aadiilifestyle Muslim richest institute was control by waqf board and waqf board is controlled by Indian Government... 🙂🙂🙂Or tujhe lagta hey humey bohot freedom hey ???
@@Aadiilifestyle we support freedom of Hindu temples because we don't want discrimination against Non-hindu ... Because Hindu temples get government privileged of billions dollars tax payers money in the name of tourism and repair of historical infrastructure for centuries.... So instead of pointing on others religion you should fight for your religion against government because other religions have different problems to fight with government ok ...
@@Aadiilifestyle Haan to kya problem he?? Teri Kyun jal rahi he 🔥🔥😂🤣
There was a threat to all temples in India by the RSS organisation those are the sleeper cell of British East India Company. The only motive of RSS was to create division between Hindus itself based on their caste, Brahmin and Dalit etc. apart from the communal hatred. Post India Independence Kings Maharaja had to sacrifice there land and property including temples built by them to the govt. of India. Therefore govt. had to manage and maintain social harmony, peace and tranquillity from the undue interference of RSS who had claimed themselves as the fake custodian of Hindutva. This was well known to our forefather but now a days "Bul Bul birds and Veeru Savarkar" virus has wiped off Indian history with fake political agenda to divide and rule. Department of Archaeology (Central Government) wanted to preserve certain monuments like "Taj Mahal", Kutab Minar, Red Fort, Konark temple (Sun Temple) etc. However RSS driven BJP govt. has sold Redfort to a private company in addition to other PSU (Railway, Airport etc.) Now Temple is under constant threat from the RSS lead govt. and Hindus are afraid of the new Hitler who can sell Hindu temples for a profit.
Tamilnadu and kerela govt trying to save hindu 😂😂😂😂 this is the best things i hered by islam is a religion of peace ✌️
Temples money should be used in the maintenance of temples 🙏❤️💯🙏❤️❤️💯
It's so laughable, how religious fights are taken up so seriously by any state govt, but nothing is being done for the safety of men and women. So many acts to control religious places but nothing significant for woman's safety.
And like atleast, thanks Akash, great content 💫
Nothing is being done for many problems in the Society and there's no law for Men's safety at all
have u heard "AJMER 1992 RAPE SCANDEL", search it.
@@officemail689 totally agree
Men i feel are the once who rarely speak about their issues as hence leads to high suicide rates.. all of this needs to change
And it will change only when a country can see above religion and race.
If the men and women of the country can be safe and sound, only then the country can progress. 💫
How the hell is that relevant here ? You can ask for more laws for woman safety but I don't see why it has to be done by belittling the current issue at hand
The Central Government should take the 5000 Ton gold of the temples in its possession, otherwise after Ghazwa E Hind, all this gold will in the possession of Muslims as a Maal E Ganimat...🙄
It's about money that temples earn, nothing else
Churches earn more
Bro you are right
Social justice also ...
@@S_spoof haha, social justice. What a frivilous term
@@manvendradeopa1476 😂😂churches give money to charity...but in tirupati lot of gold been offered to god
I am little youtuber but I'm your biggest fan in this world love you all RUclips creators❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️....... ......... .......
Do hard work, Focus on your content and In sha Allah you will get success.
Also connect with Allah...share all your good n Bad moments with Allah...seek help from Allah...He will surely help and Bless you🙂
Don't focus akash banarjee he is a dhruv rathee pro version
@@jioboy2676yes allaha will give you triple talak....halala , hijab for free
So so good ! Very impressive .Thanks ,Akash
Sir aapke content and sab itne awsom hai ki time ka pata nhi chalta, and aap or issues ly kar aaye ,various points jo aap relate karte hai, then many questions jo put hote ,or jo hone bhi chaiye ..wo sab bahut hi effective hai,
Your videos are made in such a manner even such complicated things look so interesting.
Just love your videos ❤️
Keep it up man 👍
Sikh gurudwara's are managed under the Sikh Gurudwara Act (1925). Designed to remove the pover of Udasi Mahants who used to 'control' the administration of key Sikh gurudwaras.
Even gurudwaras are needed to be controlled by govt . Lots of discrimination. There
@@vvnv9308 yes mainly by jats
@@JapGujral2000; Your Caste mindset has not gone despite beeing a Sikh ( I presume)
@@vvnv9308 uneducated ppl should refrain from becoming keyboard warriors. Have a read of the Gurudwara Act first.
I think it should be free ...
No need for doing extra care for hindus .
Everyone should have equal rights.
Let the hindus run their own temples.
My religion prays - sarve bhavantu sukhinaha... ( keep all living beings (animal also ) happy and healthy )
now tell me what does your religion pray -
Gurudwara and church... masjid
Free why ?
Hindu temple only captured
@@ayaan_khatib you people also do this
@@Aegon_Targaryen pls give any example 🙏