The action integral does not impose any constraint. Rather, it allows for variation and finds where the minimum is. Therefore, action integral will not decide whether the dynamical system is holonomic or not.
At 56:30, I am explaining about energy minimization at thermodynamic equilibrium. This means you wait for a long time until the P, V, and T no longer changes. In the case of Hamilton's principle, this is equivalent to the path taken by a dynamical system. For example, if you throw a ball up at an angle of 30-degrees, then why is the shape of the trajectory a parabola and not something else? Here "parabolic trajectory" in dynamics is equivalent to "thermodynamic equilibrium" in thermodynamics.
Yes, the words stationery and extremum point are used synonymously. In classical mechanics, it is known as the principle of stationary action. However, the word "stationary" is somewhat misleading and requires explanation. Stationary means setting the first derivative (condition for extrema) equal to zero.
Sir here in hamilton principle we are taking the variation in phase space but in Goldstein book it is given that the variation is in the configuration space i.e. co-ordinate axis should be generalised co-ordinates . Please clarify it
Thanku so much Sir . Sir Is there any way we can find on what basis nature deciding which action is to be minimum or maximum like in fermat principle why nature choose time to be minimum and not distance
Light travelling between two points in a medium takes a path for which a) Distance is always minimum b)Time of flight is extremum c)Time of flight will always minimum d)distance is extremum Which option is correct?
What Buddha said avoid both extremes and go in the middlepath for life peaceful .extermination of good and bad thoughts ie minimising bad maximising good thoughts makes progress.
Dispersion in prism due to crystal structure light deviates that path how can you say least path travel comparison and least time path not suitable since light travel from one medium to another medium depending upon density of the medium should not show minimum path distance it is the real phenomena so what is happening should be explained putting Hamiltonian principle unsuitable I suppose.Also Nature's preference also wrong.Reality is minimum effort required path electricity and light rays takes and passthrough and we measure it..
MSc level Classical Electrodynamics Playlist ruclips.net/p/PLtUBquogGkRv5CME__m2oudBqW3_ffv33
MSc level Vector space and Hilbert space for Quantum mechanics Playlist: ruclips.net/p/PLtUBquogGkRuZH23UO-8AWR4dzcu-La8_
MSc level Classical Mechanics Playlist ruclips.net/p/PLtUBquogGkRukyAAWOmq2LmQx8Yf9H_3E
BSc level Electricity and Magnetism Playlist ruclips.net/p/PLtUBquogGkRu66Kqgs3HsEpHEP6IA8oQ7
These lectures are very useful, Sir why did you stop Uploading??
Great sir
Hope I will learn the whole syllabus from u u make classical mechanic very interesting sir
All the best. Keep learning.
Sir, lots of thanks to you for your student friendly lecture.
Such a great explanation ..thank you sir
Thanks and welcome.
Thank you so much sir, you are one of the best teachers. Thank you so much.
Awesome class...sir pls start class on electronics....and try to complete mathematical physics
Your explanations are very nice. Thank you sir
Very nice explanation.
Glad it was helpful!
Sir, the action integral constraints the system to follow a particular path. So can we treat the equation as a non holonomic constraint equation?
The action integral does not impose any constraint. Rather, it allows for variation and finds where the minimum is. Therefore, action integral will not decide whether the dynamical system is holonomic or not.
Excellent lecture enjoying your lecture , the way of teaching and waiting for such course module on classical mechanics. Thanks a lot Sir🙏
Thanks and welcome.
Sir, what is the mathematical formalisms behind Hamilton's principle.
Hamilton's principle itself is a mathematical principle. So, there is nothing like formalism to Hamilton's principle.
great way of putting things forward
....sir like what actually is equillibrium ...sir comment on it
At 56:30, I am explaining about energy minimization at thermodynamic equilibrium. This means you wait for a long time until the P, V, and T no longer changes. In the case of Hamilton's principle, this is equivalent to the path taken by a dynamical system. For example, if you throw a ball up at an angle of 30-degrees, then why is the shape of the trajectory a parabola and not something else? Here "parabolic trajectory" in dynamics is equivalent to "thermodynamic equilibrium" in thermodynamics.
Sir, is principle of stationary action and principle of extremisation same?
Yes, the words stationery and extremum point are used synonymously. In classical mechanics, it is known as the principle of stationary action. However, the word "stationary" is somewhat misleading and requires explanation. Stationary means setting the first derivative (condition for extrema) equal to zero.
All clear sir thank you
Sir here in hamilton principle we are taking the variation in phase space but in Goldstein book it is given that the variation is in the configuration space i.e. co-ordinate axis should be generalised co-ordinates .
Please clarify it
Sir please make a playlist for other topics like Quantum mecheanics,Nuclear physics,statistical mechanics and many more
Great lecture ❤. But, I am not finding D'Alembert principle till now
You may start with the virtual work principle: ruclips.net/video/-ATJ5uPKQ9U/видео.html
@@ProfSivakumarRajagopalan thank you so much sir 🙏
Thanku so much Sir . Sir Is there any way we can find on what basis nature deciding which action is to be minimum or maximum like in fermat principle why nature choose time to be minimum and not distance
Very useful
Glad to hear that
Senthamizh B
PU20008913
Light travelling between two points in a medium takes a path for which
a) Distance is always minimum
b)Time of flight is extremum
c)Time of flight will always minimum
d)distance is extremum
Which option is correct?
Thank you sir.
Priyadharshini. M
PU20021311
Thank you sir 👍
Thank you sir ✨
Thanks a lot sir
Thank you sir
Thank you sir!
Thankyou sir
Thanku sir
Joel Jeevan 1st msc physics
What Buddha said avoid both extremes and go in the middlepath for life peaceful .extermination of good and bad thoughts ie minimising bad maximising good thoughts makes progress.
Good!
@@ProfSivakumarRajagopalan Thank you sir for your reply.
V. Nivedhitha
PU20002313
V Kirthi
20PUSN0009
Dispersion in prism due to crystal structure light deviates that path how can you say least path travel comparison and least time path not suitable since light travel from one medium to another medium depending upon density of the medium should not show minimum path distance it is the real phenomena so what is happening should be explained putting Hamiltonian principle unsuitable I suppose.Also Nature's preference also wrong.Reality is minimum effort required path electricity and light rays takes and passthrough and we measure it..
Debangshu kalita..PU20018505
M. Anupriya
Pu20020795
PU20007303
Arupjyoti pathak
Vasundaraa Devi- PU20020891
Samarth mishra
Loganathan t
KADEEJA ANEESHA T K N
PU20038363
BIPIN KUMAR PARIDA
PU20025473
PU20020727
Ardra Dhananjayan
ANJALI CHANDRAN
PU20013201
Sushree monalisha sahu
PU20041733
PU20010193
Akshay K J
Valarmathi.R
Pu20001741
Niranjana Suresh
17380316
PU20019809
BANKERLANG MARNGAR
Shahana sherin K
PU20008705
BRILLIA BENNY
PU20013517
K Lakshmi Priya
17380313
PRANAV B
PU20002209
PU20052555 Unnati sharma
Ramzia k
PU20005057
Kaviarasu (PU20008733)
PU20077347
Ayana M A
RINDHUJA TREESA JOHNSON
17380319
PU20047457
S NADARAJ
17380307
Athul P Jose
JINU JOB
PU20059051
Athira S
17380306
Adnan Ashraf
17380301
Deeksha D
17380309
17380315
Nimmy Prince
Salva nourin
17380320
Poovizhi.E
17380317
Sruthi.V
17380322
Thank you sir.
GOKULAKANNAN
PU20006171
Thank you sir !!
Thanks sir
Thankyou sir
KAVYA S RAJ
PU20029543
Arunima S
17380304
Thank you sir.
Thank you sir
Thank you sir!
Thankyou sir
Suneesh k
PU20010087
Thank you, sir.
Thanks sir
Thankyou sir
Swagatika sahu
PU20042205
Thank you sir...
Thank you sir
Thankyou sir
Thank you sir
Thankyou sir
Thankyou sir🙏
Thankyou Sir
thank you sir
Thank you sir
Thank you sir
thank you sir
Thankyou sir
Thank You sir.
Thank you sir
Thankyou sir