I am a Palestinian Christian born in Ramallah and I agree with this woman that Palestinians are Jewish they are not Arabs I am a Palestinian myself Christian and I believe that my ancestors come from the Israelites way back ago I tried to get citizenship in Israel they would not let me it's because I am Palestinian and born in the West Bank but I will find my DNA and when I find my DNA I will go to Israel and prove it to them that I am a Palestinian Jew
+Mazzen Warra What are you talking about bro ? You talk as the Zionists Jews who rule "Israel" today cares if your are a Jew or not. Even themselves knows we Palestinian are the indigenous people of the land but they are trying their best to hide it. The bottom line is we know we are the indigenous people of the land genetically , and the majority of the Zionists who live in historic Palestine today are eastern European Jews ,and which whom the only thing that connects them with the ancient Jews is their religion, not their blood like us.And that's why they hate us and want us all dead.
+PalestiniansWillNotGiveUp To be factually accurate here, it is the Sephardic/Mizrahi Jews who constitute the majority of Israel's Jewish population (60%, more or less). Also, it is an observable fact that these Mediterranean Jews are far more inclined to support the right-wing, religious sects of Zionism than their Ashkenazic counterparts from Eastern Europe. Concerning the Ashkenazim, what makes you think that we have no connection to ancient Judaea/Palestine?
+Dovid Rabinovich i like how the jews truly believe in payit forward. there doing what the natzis did. wish they would live mexico too. jews everywhere.
Yes. Of course! The early Zionists knew that Palestinians were likely the descendants of the biblical Hebrews. But neither they nor the "Arab Jews" were the Jews for which Israel was founded by its European Jewish architects. Zionism is a special strain of European colonialism. Palestinians are not longing to become Jews. It is great that you are recognizing the horrible injustice done to the Palestinians but you need to stop imposing your nationalist and religious agenda on them. They are longing to return to the homes from which they were ethnically cleaned and live with full legal rights in their own country. They long for peace. They long for the home of their mothers and fathers. Similar to Hebrews who became Islamized and Arabized, many of the Jews and Christians of Europe are also the result of conversion of people's native to Europe. Religion and culture are not biology. History has many twists and turns. Accept that a terrible crime was done to Palestinians and make reparations for what has been done to them.
No "Palestinians" were ethnically cleansed from Israel. They left on their own. The Institute of Palestine Studies, an Arab organization from Beirut say that *"68% of the Arabs never saw a Jewish man with a gun or a soldier"* and watch the video, *"How we really became refugees, 13 Palestinians tell their personal stories"* Mamoud Abbas and 12 others tell from all areas of Israel that they left on the orders of their leaders.
I've always found it a curious fact how people don't distinguish Palestinian Christians and Muslims racially, yet view Palestinian Jews (Jews living in 19th century Palestine) as something alien. They're all the same stock, just different religions. I think European Jews project their own racial differences with the European populations they emigrated from onto these Palestinian Jews-- that is, they think just because they are racially different to a German or Slavic Russian, then so must this Jew in Palestine be something different from his Muslim neighbor. This is simply not the case. If you don't believe me, visit my father's city of Nablus, and meet the Samaritan Jews who live on the outskirts of the city. You simply cannot distinguish them from the Muslims living in Nablus.
My cousin actually Jewish, there great grand father came from Yemen, converted to Islam , and lived with my family tribe.My self am pretty sure Iam a pure Arab from a Yemeni tribe.My father from al azd tribe , my mother from bani tarif who olso a Yemeni tribe ...
Dear MADAM, please bring the gentleman back each year for an update interview please. Especially NOW. THANK YOU 💟 SHALOM PEACE LOVE JOY PEACE 💞🕊️ GBU ALL 💖
Some Jews have Palestinians lineage. That is how it is supposed to phrased. Palestinian means a native of Palestine. Most Pals go back as far as the Canaanite pre-Roman age. Not big news really, confirmed from their customs, and even the influence of the Aramaic language on their colloquial dialect.
This following is a genetic map that shows Canaanite DNA samples from the Bronze Age and Iron Age in purple and green circles (ASH IA, ASH BA, SIDON BA, JORDAN BA) and they overlap and cluster with Palestinians, Jordanians and Lebanese. The brown circle is Neolithic Levantine which was more Saudi-North African-like than Bronze Age, Iron Age and modern Levantines due to less Mesopotamian admixture (the Levant received waves of Mesopotamian migration that mixed into the population over several periods) so the few Jews (Tunisian and Libyan Jews on the map) that overlap with the Neolithic sample have admixture from a modern source that is more Saudi-North African-like, similar to the Neolithic population, pulling them in that direction to overlap since Neolithic ancestry did not survive in whole in the Bronze Age, Iron Age and today. Here is the genetic map: qph.fs.quoracdn.net/main-qimg-0dd4c4b173e7703187337ad160a55277
@@shainazion4073 Genesis 21-34 mentions Palestine (or Filistin as spoken by the locals): And Abraham lived as a foreigner in Philistine country for a long time. Same terminology is used in arguably the very first book of history written 5th century BC by the "father of history" Herodotus .
The Modern Jews still show 50% of Canaanite DNA. Archeologists believe that the Israelites were a Canaanite tribe that stopped child sacrifice and believed in the one true God.
Ethnicity meant the liberty for people to have his own culture and not be submitted to empires and religions. Nothing wrong on the contrary. Don't tell to indigenous people that ethnicity not matter because you maybe a disconnected globalized westerner. You'll not tell to an indigenous American that ethnicity is not important so it's the same for canaanites-phoenicians.
Religion might change, but the DNA and History will never change. Go and make something better for your country. BTY my Palestinian Grandma is older than Israel.
Your grandma is then probably older than Jordan, Lebanon, Algeria, Senegal, Sudan, India, Syria and many more... so what's your point again? Oh yeah... history 😂
One thing for sure about the Palestinians, historically and genetically they are more entitled to that land than 90% of the Jews in Israel who are Ashkenazi european Jews.
I know it's been 9 years but f$#_ you man, most Jews in Israel are of middle Eastern origin either from Israel or from immediately neighboring countries. When you look at a map you realize it isn't hard for some Jews to wander a bit further out into what is now considered Europe (well mostly southeastern Europe). European Jews are welcome for the same reasons middle Eastern Jews are welcome, and I'm proud to be half European and half middle Eastern Jewish.
thanks for the video! I wish however it was not in stereo as such, hearing it from only one speaker at a time is very distracting and actually annoying, and makes it hard to concentrate. Leave the audio on BOTH channels, don't switch back and forth. Other than that, great video, great information! Thanks for up'ping this vid!
I am a Palestinian and I have 15% jewish according to DNA test. And that is a lot considering I dont anyone in my family that has any thing resembeling jewish ancestory.
Arabs and Jews(the semitic ones) are ethnically and linguistically related, and have cultural connections since they have lived in the same places. But the conflict has never been about ethnicity or culture, or even religion. Giving the Palestinians their homes and land back, and giving them equal rights, and treating them like human beings is the only way to peace.
if only it were so simple. -give them "their" lands homes etc... why would they be given that, when jews who fled from the muslim world would never get theirs back? -even if israel "gave the back..." they'd still be coming yet for more, till there is no more israel, unacceptable. -israel proposed to "give them back", by means of equivalent value so that they can settle elsewhere, they keep refusing. -treat them ... humans... you are exagerating, some israelis will look down on palis, and all palis look down on israelis, but a pali would always find a reasonable interlocutor in israel if he has a claim, and he can even will a trial if his claim is lawful according to law, the inverse is NOT true. You have a conflict between two sides who do not have a common sense, a common way of treating with justice, this conflict is an endless one, and will not end on a tribunal, it will end with de facto achievements.
@@viverntahl2541 "when jews who fled from the muslim world would never get theirs back?" You are pivoting. Palestinian Arabs have no genetic relations with where these Jews are coming from. If Israel really likes the wellbeing of these Jews of Muslim world, then why does it allies itself with Saudi Arabia and consider Iran bad. Supported Hamas to get rid of PLO ,etc "give them back" If someone comes to your house, takes half of it, and offer other half as peace deal, then would you take it ? No fucking way you will get him out of your house. "you are exagerating, some israelis will look down on palis, and all palis look down on israelis, but a pali would always find a reasonable interlocutor in israel if he has a claim, and he can even will a trial if his claim is lawful according to law, the inverse is NOT true." You are the one exxagarating here. Talk about reasonable, lets start a war over 3 kidnapped teenager to kill ,settle,etc this is reality of this COLONIAL STATE
Share the land and the rich history of many people that have lived there. Palestinians and Israelites are related. it's a family feud there that has been going on for 1000's of years.
@@joynkindness wrong it is a islam muhammad thing read the quran and the ahadith muhammad the funder of islam and his god hate the Jews and see to destroy Israel if you haven noticest
Of course the Palistinans are Native to this area including , but the European AshkaNazi Zionists preferred not just take over but Persecute the non Jewish population
Since the observance of the Sabbath is a covenant of Hebrews and Elohim, Mamoinides stated the Jews who do not observe the Sabbath are pagans. Messiah will gather the children of Israel into the land, I submit Palestinians should integrate the observance of the Sabbath in their Muslim faith and make peace with Israel.
A Palestinian here. DNA test revealed 50% levant which is Israel, Lebanon and Syria. My ancestors are from Jerusalem ans it’s neighbouring area. It also said my ancestors lived there for the past 30 thousand years and no jewish DNA.
These guys are Zionists trying do Israeli propaganda they them self are not even originally from that land they conquered it from the Canaanites who are probably your ancestors and there no such thing as Jewish dna it is a religion Arabs and Hebrews are both originally from the Middle East from the same ancestors honestly the talk these two people have remind me of Nazism.
the biggest shock was for me that I am from Damascus and my dad always used this mechanism of binding his Head with a cloth and a Key for headaches :O. I only know that a relative on my father side married a jew and settled in Israel and our family first came to the countryside of Damascus (Midan) about 200 years ago and we don't know anything past that :3 could we be jew descendants? :O
everytime palestinine being invaded, you find that the people of the land accepted whatever religion was brought to them, wheather they be islam,judaism or christinity.The point here jews should stop subjugating the palestinian and learn to live together rather than to dehumanise them.
H j y, Yeah, the Palestinians are the Jews from Judah. The present occupiers, so called Jew by religion only ( European + American descent) ruling from the Knesset are gentiles from Khazarian stock.
I think a lot of Iraqis....Turks.....Iranians and a motleys crew of Europeans are also "Jewish." I know there are a lot of Jewish Spaniards .............and some of those genes are now in Mexico as well. The Jews got around!
You are right. A lot of Levantine Jewish DNA was found in Italy, certain Portuguese and Spaniards, and in many European populations. There's even Central Asian Uzbekistan Jews now that we've discovered. I'm a geneticist and have been especially following Jewish DNA for over a year now. It's almost everywhere.
In Muslim beliefs origin is less important when it comes to beliefs, I think Muslim could be Israeli too as many of today's Palestinians and Jordanians were from Prophet Dawood blood and prophet Joseph blood but they were converted and accept the new and last testimony of God and today they call themselves Muslim and due to neighborhood and region they have integrated into Arab culture and adopt Arab language.
Rationally the people who were in the region prior to the creation of the Israel state are logically more closely DNA related to the original Israelites that these Euro/Russo Jewish converts who flocked to Palestine.
+Gregarious Antithesis All arabs are related to jews genetically because they are somewhat the same people. On genetic papers, they cluster very close,
You are not following the scientific stated here, are you? Although the statement about Palestinians being Jews is factually and historically incorrect, but the DNA and language origin do have common roots from the times of pre-Judea and the Canaanites.
The word "Jew" never appears in Torah. It appears later where in the Roman age 15% of the empire followed monotheism, spreading out of Judea, hence the word Jew. Similarly, Nazarene derives from Nazareth which historically referred to Christians.
@@shainazion4073 Book of Esther is not part of the Torah itself which has five books: Genesis, Exodus, Leviticus, Numbers and Deuteronomy. Genesis 21-34 for example mentions Palestine (or Filistin as spoken by the locals): "And Abraham lived as a foreigner in Philistine country for a long time."
Arab is a language not a nation , Ishmael raised and lived with Arabic speaker tribe and adopted their language so he is not the father of all arab in fact he is arab just because he spoke Arabic .
Arabs existed long before Abraham, and groups of people like "Ishaelites" and "Midianites" would become Arabized with time. "Black folks" (whatever that means) have nothing to do with this whole story - West Africans are about as far away from these folks as blue eyed red haired Irish people. And
Tracing lineage by use of scripture is self serving, and perpetuates the hamster wheel reasoning of human origin as being only a minuscule few thousand years. Archaeology proves humanities existence for many hundreds of thousands of years (millions for earlier more primitive humans). DNA can shed light on regional domination of any one species. This single fact blows out of the water any 'wanna be' indigenous people, interlopers, immigrants. And brings us closer to answering the question; Which is the parent, and which is the bastard?
The Mediterranean Sea to the west. Africa and Egypt to the south and southwest. Saudi Arabia and Jordan to the east. Syria, Turkey and Iran to the north. All 'Dark Nations', I will repeat that, "ALL DARK NATIONS'. And in the very middle of all these and other 'Dark Nations' white Jews claim sovereignty!?! Purchasing land does not grant sovereignty! Devine land grants from invisible friends in the sky is not acceptable! The congenital deceitful nature and behavior of Zionist (non Rabbinic) Jews is blatantly evident. Purge the war mongering Zionists out!! And leave the Jewish and Palestinian Arab people to live together in peace. As they had for generations before this wretched mutated mongrel abomination of humanity began their campaign of war crimes and crimes against humanity!!!
+Ant B he dosent realise anything. he is a complit ignorant and you are wasting your time explaning him. ppl like him are brain washed with false information. his mind is still back on 1930 . he thinks all jews comes from Poland and he is not aware where they come from and know nothing about jews from Arab countries wich are at list hulf of the jews in israel. not to mention ethiopiens jews sefaradi jews and thouse who are israelis for few generations as i am
@@shainazion4073Palestinians existed before Islam. Our nations all existed actually. Islam is the last religion. Of course! We all converted recently. Islam is God’s last message to us before everything ends…
Hi Christine, I really appreciate all your videos! Do you have any updates regarding this subject? Perhaps, you could talk about Sephardic and Ashkenazy and other jews? I would like to know what he has found out since 2012. Blessings, Mary Ellen ❀◕ ‿ ◕❀
Palestinians could be converted Canaanites, Samaritans or Jews, or any mixture of those…we just don’t know for sure so it’s incorrect for the time being to call them Jews. Let’s just call them indigenous people. What we do know is there is no Israelite DNA tested yet, but there is Canaanite DNA tested and Palestinians cluster and overlap with the Canaanites, just as Jordanians and Lebanese do (one study reported that Lebanese Christians were 93% similar to Canaanite samples from Bronze Age Sidon).The following genetic map shows the Canaanite samples as purple and green circles (these are Bronze Age and Iron Age samples) and they overlap with Palestinians. The brown circle shows a Neolithic Levantine sample, but all Levantines after the Neolithic became admixed with ancestry from migration waves from Mesopotamia in what is modern day Iraq (biblical descriptions of Abraham were that he was from Ur in Sumer, part of Mesopotamia) so the few Jews (Tunisian and Libyan Jews on the genetic map) that overlap with this Neolithic Levantine sample have an admixture of the Saudi-North African-like ancestry from a modern source that made up the predominance of the Neolithic sample, pulling them toward that sample since Neolithic Levantine ancestry in whole did not survive in the Bronze Age and Iron Age, nor in today’s Levantines. Jews do not cluster with the Canaanites, however they do cluster not too far away which if the hypothesis holds true that the Israelites were just Canaanites that assumed a new identity following their exodus from Egypt into the land of Canaan, then the modern Jewish position on the genetic map shows they are a group of mixed origins, which makes sense since their Levantine ancestors spent 2000 years in countries outside of the land where Israel and Palestine is today. Here is the genetic map: qph.fs.quoracdn.net/main-qimg-0dd4c4b173e7703187337ad160a55277
@@shainazion4073 If that was the case then they wouldn’t be Jews, would they? Modern Jews are around half Levantine and that Levantine is mostly Hebrew, not Canaanite.
@@IslenoGutierrez Put in a search for were the Israelites Canaanites. You will find the answer of "Yes". Whether they assimilated them, married them, or were a branch of them, they lived at the same time, had similar features, and they had different beliefs, the Israelites had no pig bones or sea shells in their villages as food. They both did process techelet, the blue dye from the murex snail. The name Canaanite came from this blue or purple dye. "Kn" means murex, and "Canaanite" those that are of the land of the purple/blue dye. "Phoenician" is the greek for the purple people.
@@shainazion4073 I don’t doubt that some Canaanites may have been assimilated into the Hebrews before their exodus from Israel/Judea, however I don’t believe that to make up the majority of the Levantine ancestry of Jews (which makes up about half the ancestry of Jews). I also believe that the Hebrews were possibly genetically similar to the Canaanites as they were originally from Mesopotamia (modern day Iraq)(it’s stated that Hebrews entered Canaan from east of the Jordan River after leaving Egypt as slaves and and their origin was from Ur in Mesopotamia) but by no means do I believe that the Hebrews were significantly Canaanite. Jews do not cluster with Canaanite DNA samples while Palestinians do. I believe Palestinians to be way more Canaanite ancestry while Jews more Hebrew ancestry.
@@IslenoGutierrez Go rsad the DNA studies the Jews have 50% of Canaanite DNA, the local Arabs have 50% of Canaanite DNA. With the Jews we know that their DNA is the same as Canaanites, with "Palestinians" they could be expressing more modern Lebanese DNA. I don't know where you think that the "Palestinians" have more or hetter DNA matches with the Canaanites? The "Palestinians" have the same Y-DNA haplotypes as the modern Jews do.
This is actually the most intelligent comment in this section." Palestinians are the real descendants" is the stupidest one and most frequent, they're equal descendants to the Jews. They're both actually stolen into other populations/and cultures from being originally levantine descent. That's what happens when the rest of the world has ugly people and so they need to bring in some pretty.😂😂
This is very interesting... I'm not sure that all Palestinians have Hebrew ancestry though... for sure, the majority/all of those in the West Bank have Hebrew ancestry... But what about those in Gaza? I'm pretty sure that there would be a remnant who are actually Arabs or perhaps have ethnic Egyptian, Jordanian or Turkish ancestry from the Ottoman Empire :/ just a thought.
The people of that region are Canaanites. Some of them went to Egypt during a severe famine and returned as a different people, as Hebrews. Through the millennia the inhabitants of Palestine had been forced to change religions to survive - as animists, oriental pagans, Mosaic Hebrews , classical (Graeco-Roman) pagans. Christians, Muslims. Looking at Palestinians most of them dark haired with deep set eyes and looking at and many Israelis who are blond and blue eyed, there is no mistaking as to are the intruders and who are descended from the original inhabitants of the land.
They have genetically sequenced the Ancient Israelites and they were blonde and blue-eyed. So the Palestinians are not indigenous? That is nonsense. Many of the Palestinians are from Jewish ancestry.
@@crestvilla711 Your ignorance is outstanding!!! The Khazar theory has been debunked by history, archeology, linguistics, and science (DNA). In fact, the only "study" that found any tie at all from the Jews to the Khazars, didn't yse Khazar DNA or Jewish DNA. Eran Elhaik used Palestinians as stand-ins for Ancient Jews. Therefore Palestinians were found to be Khazars by his study. Actually, he never used Khazar DNA either. He used Armenians and Georgians.
@@crestvilla711 Modern Jews still show 50% of Canaanite DNA. Who did they supposedly convert from, that maintained Canaanite DNA for over 2500 years??????
Okay if you say secular that means a rabbi,Imam,, nor priest/whatever Christians have should not be apart of the knesset. A lot of ultra-orthodox have too much control.
Most people in the Middle East and North Africa north of the Arabian peninsula are actually not Arabs but Arabized Muslim converts from the people who were already there before the spread of Islam.
We know Palestinians are the true Semites and the seeds of Ebrahim, the question is, how about both of you? Are you true Semites or converts? Are you planning to give them their land and leave to Poland?
Donald Cannon “three in one” failed to convert all jews to christian...human teaching = paul teaching....all of state for the prophet that mention in bible now become state of islam...christian faith teaching fail because they failed to convert all state in middle east include israel to christian...the winner is islam as a monotisme religion 👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼
Donald Cannon can you give me a fact...give me a fact and get it from what we believe from “quran or as sunnah” ....you dont have a fact for what you said...👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼
I believe they already did a study and found Palestinians to be a closer match to the ancient Palestinians, but why not. ?? A very large number of Israelis are from the former Soviet Union... More people migrated to israel from Russia than all nations put together and even the founding fathers were ALL related to bolshevicks, or Soviet Union..
God knows shannika is struggling. He knows that her children are being jailed and persecuted. He knows that inside, she is rich but out wardly is very poor. God has a plan for SHANNIKA
Not Jews wrong term, Some maybe Jews but the correct term is Hebrews the lost tribes are actually Hebrews. Also genetically many of the so called Jews are not Semites and not from the area.
the solution is simple: only Torah is the Law of the Land. Put aside Quaran, accept Torah, and the conflict is solved. But the Torah Law should be enforced in the Land first.
@elle lee Even a Rabbi will tell you Allah is God. Even Jesus said Elah Elah Rabbana Subhaktani. In Arab God is Ilah and the name of Ilah is Allah and he is ONE not three. Go back to school and learn Math.
@elle lee No it's not and that's not in Hebrew or Aramaic. Most of the so called names people are calling God by today are Titles, not his name. If you knew Hebrew or Arabic you would know this but you only know the last language to be made on earth.
@elle lee Well all the Middle Eastern Scholars whether Rabbi's or Muslim Imam's say Allah is God. Christian's in Africa and the Middle East call God Allah. The one's worshipping the Devil are those Christians who pray to a made up character called Jesus. Point Blank period. Allah is the Only God and Jesus is who you Christians pray to. We pray to the creator and you pray to a creation which is called disbelief blasphemy and idolatry. You can try to explain yourself away in your crazy deluded mind but fact is you pray to something other than God and God destroyed plenty of people nation's and countries because of doing so. It's written in all the scriptures, so how is it that you want to go ahead and call another man in this case a messenger sent by God and you sick minded people want to go ahead and call him God? This man never once said I am God but he did say God is Greater than I. He also said you can be like me, even Greater than I if you just had Faith. The man also Prayed, to whom? To God. Which one of his disciples prayed to Jesus? None. So stop spreading falsehoods because you've rwad the truth about the man probably your whole life and still ignore what is being said in the texts. You are a people who have no understanding and you let a priest, preacher, pastor tell you what some words mean like you can't comprehend what you're reading for yourself. Deaf DUMB and Blind are the Christians. The Jews themselves will tell you this. Look up youtube videos on Jewish scholars and Rabbis telling you what Allah means and then look up what they think about the Christian doctrine. It is evident that 2 of the Abrahamic faiths say you have nothing to do with them and you don't worship what they both worship. Christians worship a man and they worship Allah/Hashem/Ar Rahman/God. Then you always believe this man god died for your pagan sins, LMAO! How did you people fall for that one? Like I said read the scripture, God says no one but he can forgive sin and only he can save you from destruction. But no you want to believe in Jesus and his magical blood, if that isn't the most pagan belief out of all paganistic faiths I don't know paganism is. Keep on worshipping the Devil's man god and see what's going to be waiting for you on the day of judgement. When the man who is the Messiah is questioned by God, did you tell them to worship you and he says NO! Hell fire is for those who believed in a lie.
@elle lee Plus Muhammad was spoken of very highly in the book of John and the Messiah said to follow him for he would explain all things and give testimony of the truth of the Messiah. All the names he called this person you can look up in Arabic to see what Muhammad was called and it will be clear as day to see the man that Christ described to the T, in the book of John. If you choose to deny it then you truly are to be considered the stupidest people that ever existed on the day of judgement punishment will be reserved for the likes of you no matter how good you may have been on this earth. Remember Christ says no one is good but the Lord. Smh. People just love lies I guess.
Wrong Abraham was Chaldean which Ur was in Chaldea which is Iraq today. The original Arabs were a Black tribe called the tribe of Jurham. Ishmael went to live amongst these nomadic people.
Yeah, why do these people care this much about ethnicity and race??? If they will start liking poor Palestinians just because of their DNA, I guess this is not a bad finding 🤦🏻♀️
Genetically, all humans are closely related. New studies in the past few months have revealed that Eurasians are mixture of 3 basic peoples that shared a common ancestry 50 to 60 thousand years ago. Starting out from middle eastern regions, early hunter gathers roamed across western Europe starting 45,000 years ago. Eurasian hunter gatherer groups made their way into Steppes around 35,000 years ago. Others remained closer to the middle east. By around 10,000 years ago, middle eastern groups had developed agriculture and over the next few thousand years pushed into western Europe and into the Steppes bringing genes, technology and permanent settlements. Around 4500 years ago, Pastoralists from the Steppes swept into Europe, the Middle East and South Asia bringing horses, animal husbandry, wheeled carts and language. Most everyone across Europe, Western Eurasia, the Middle East and the Indian subcontinent are descended from these 3 groups of people in various combinations. Jews and Palestinians are essentially the same people with different cultural heritages. Stop fighting already.
Most of the Jews who live in Israel today are not the children of Israel. The Palestinians are the children of Abraham. Some of them are the children of Ismael, and the others are the children of Israel who converted Islam. I know many big Palestinian tribes are Jews who converted Islam. Most of the Palestinian muslims who live in Hebron near thier grandfather Abraham are origionaly from the children of Israel who converted Islam and the others are the children of Ismael.
@@shainazion4073 You should do DNA to the Palestinians to believe that the war in the holy land is between the tribe of Juda and the children of Israel who moved to the desert of Ishmael in the city of Maddina on mount Sala to wait for the coming prophet who through him the covenant between Allah and his prophet Ibrahim was fullfiled. The Jews used to tell the children of Ishmael that the coming prophet will destroy their idols as his grandfather Ibrahim did, but when they knew that the prophet that they were waiting for is from Ishmael they helped the idols worshipers to kill the prophet instead of the helping the prophet to destroy the idols. At the end, the covenant between Allah and the children of Ibrahim was fullfiled through prophet Mohammed in a few years and they owned the land from the Atlantic ocean in the west to the Pacific ocean in the east. The covenant was not fullfiled with the children of Israel and the children of Ismael who did not believe in Muhammad and Allah punished them to live between the nations.
That is what is a called a Bubbe Meise! There was no prophet coming to Arabia the time of prophesy had ended. They did not wait for amy prophet that is more Taquiya and there were Jews in Yarthrib before there was Islam or Muhammed. This is all Taquiya!
@@rachelsamuel3328 The Jews moved to live in the middle of the desert of Kedar the son of Ishmael in the city of Yathrib on mount Sela " where prophet Muhammad built his great mosque " based on the origional holy Torah. Isaiah 42:11 Let the wilderness and its towns raise their voices; let the settlements where Kedar lives rejoice. Let the people of Sela sing for joy; let them shout from the mountaintops. The Jews where waiting the prophet that the covenant between Allah and the children of Ibrahim will be fullfiled through him. The Jews used to tell the children of Ishmael that the coming prophet will destroy the idols as his grandfather Ibrahim did and the covenant will be fullfiled through him. The Jews thought that the prophet will be one of them, but when they found out that the prophet is from the children of Ishmael some of the Jews refused him and they helped the idol worshippers to fight prophet Muhammad instead of helping the prophet to destroy the idols. At the end, the covenant was fullfiled with the children of Ibrahim who believed in the messege of Muhammad in a few years and whom did not believe were not part of the covenant and Allah punished them to live between the other nations. The fact is : most of the children of Israel who moved to wait the coming prophet in Yathrib and believed him, the covenant was fullfiled with them and most of them moved to live in the holy land next to their grandfather Ibrahim. And the other fact is : ten tribes from the children of Israel out of twelve believed in Muhammad and they are muslims.
@@ashrafaljaradat7892 How did a man who didn't read know what the Torah said? Now you are serving baloney. This is not hostory, it is fairy tales. The Jews were there hundreds of years before Muhamed. Why were they in Khaybar? Because they knew Muhammed would slaugnter them all, and rape their wjves and daughters?
For the record the living team genome really seems to be the origin of fairhair fair eyes and fair skin especially Fair olives skin blue eyes and blondish and reddish hair. It's much more likely that it originated in southern Syria I.E. Israel Lebanon and Jordan then even in the ancient Anatolian areas.
najib qane What is it with you ignorant haters? Why poland?. Sh*t, I forgot your kind don't read much so it must be something you heard another ignorant hater say! 😉
The Palestinian Arabs, actually came from surrounding Muslim territories when the Ottomans striped the land of its trees, and invited others in their territories to come and work in the Providence of Palestine which would later become part of the British mandate, where the cost of living was cheep, and the conquered Jewish cities were mostly vacant. many Palestinian family names reveal their place of origin. Kiswani - Jordan Abu Khueik - Jordan Odeh - Jordan al Urdon - Jordan Musleh - Jordan Mohsein - Jordan Muksen - Jordan al Turki - Turkey (not even Arab) Sultan - Turkey (not even Arab) Uthuman - Turkey (not even Arab) Turk - Turkey (not even Arab) al Kurd - Turkey (not even Arab) Yamtar- Khazachstan,Kipchak tribe (Turkic) Darwish - Egypt Mansour - Egypt al Masri - Egypt Masrawa - Egypt Metzarwah - Egypt al Tartir - Tartir village, Egypt Bardawil - Lake Bardawil, Sinai Peninsula, Egypt Abu-Suta - Tarabin tribe, Egypt Abu-Seeta - Tarabin tribe, Egypt Sha'alan - Bedouin, Egypt al Aksar - Luxor, Egypt Ayoob - Egypt Raz - Egypt al Natsheh - Egypt al Fayyumi - Faiyum, Egypt al Araki/al Iraqi - Iraq al Baghadi - Baghdad, Iraq Zubeidi - Iraq Zuabi/Zoabi - West Iraq al Faruki - Iraq al Tachriti - Iraq al Mosul/al Mawsil - Mosul, North Iraq al Bani/al Beni - Bani tribe, East Iraq al Saudi - Saudi Arabia Husseini / Hussein - Saudi Arabia (Hussain was the 4th Imam) al Tamimi - Saudi Arabia al Khijazi - Saudi Arabia al Kurash - Saudi Arabia al Kurashi - Saudi Arabia Erekat - Bedouin tribe, North West Saudi Arabia. al Higazi - Saudi Arabia al Hejazi - Saudi Arabia Omayya - Saudi Arabia Nashashibi - Syria al Hurani - Huran, South Syria al Halabi - Haleb, North Syria al Allawi - West Syria (shoreline) Hamati - Homs, Syria Sidawi - Sidon, Lebanon Tabulsi - Tripoly, Lebanon al Tarabulas - Tripoly, Lebanon al Surani - Sour, South Lebanon al Tahir - Tair, South Lebanon Lubnani - Lebanon al Yamani - Yemen al Azad/al Azd - Yemen Hadadin - Yemen Hadadin - Yemen Murad - Yemen Mattar - Mattar village, Yemen Mugrabi - Magrab, Morocco al Araj - Morocco Mighrebta - Morocco al Bosni/al Busna - Bosnia and Herzegovina (not even Arab) Bushnak - Bosnia and Herzegovina (not even Arab) Bohran - Bosnia and Herzegovina (not even Arab) al Afgani - Afghanistan (not even Arab) al Afghan - Afghanistan (not even Arab) al Jazir - Algiria Dajani - Algeria al Ubid - Ubid, Sudan (there's a city in the same name) al Ubyyidi/al Obeidi - Sudan al Hamis/ al Khamis - Bahrain Barghouti - Kuwait al Kuwaiti - Kuwait al Azere - Circassia region (not even Arab) al Azabi - Circassia region (not even Arab) al Kirkas - Circassia region (not even Arab) Tabilisi - Circassia region (not even Arab) al Hindi - Pakistan, India, and Bangladesh area (not even Arab) Yasser Arafat called himself "a Palestinian refugee" when he was in fact born in Cairo, Egypt, in 1929, and he spoke the Egyptian dialect of Arabic. He served in the Egyptian army, studied in the University of Cairo, and lived in Cairo until 1956 . Arafats mentor, Haj Ameen al Husseini, (who lead many Massacres against Jews, and would later become a commander in Hitlers SS) began the Quasi-Palestinian identity, in order to help unify the Arabs under 1 caliphate. He was born in Jerusalem, but his family was from Saudi Arabia. Walid Shoebat, is a PLO defector, and he said, and i quote: "why is it that on the night of June 4th 1967, i was Jordanian, and overnight i became a Palestinian? we had always considered ourselves Jordanian until the Jews returned to Jerusalem. and then they took the star off the Jordanian flag, and then all at once we had ourselves a Palestinian flag." PS: Much of the Jordanian names may have also originated from Arabia.
It's not a weird thing we are most of us who are descendents of Jews or Christian believers and our families converted to Islam it's normal because it's the last religion! So it's normal!
this proves what everyone was knowing from the start the Palestinians are closer to the historical jews than any European Zionist jew who took the land from the natives
The ten tribes of Israel were never called Jews. Only the tribe of Judah and the Benjamites with the priestly tribe of Levi. The 10 tribes become known as Samaritans. The nation was split in two after the death of Solomen. The Northen Kingdom stop worshipping God and build altars to idols. They are in fact a mix breed of the ten tribes and other races. The Bible is also a history of the 12 tribes of Jacob aka Israel.
All the people living in Judea were Jews. The tribes of Judah, Benjamin, Simeon and the Levites assigned to those tribes. Along with any spouses and Traders/merchants that lived in the southern Kingdom. After the Assyrian invasion, many from the northern kingdom went to the South, they all today are known as Jews.
@ainanor Hagar was Egyptian not Arab. There is a difference. The original Arabs which are no longer around today were Black. So today these people are called Arabs because they speak the language not because they are descendants of the original Arab stock which was the tribe of Jurham. Today we have modernized Arabs, only a small minority come from the original tribe of Arabs. And if these modernized Arabs are descended from Ishmael then they are Hebrew as well just like their forefather Abraham was. That's like saying your father is Irish and my mother is Hispanic so what you aren't going to say you are part Irish? Remember the nation of Israel was started by 1 man Jacob and 4 women. 2 were Hebrew and the other 2 were Egyptian and Arab. So no you aren't Jewish or Hebrew because of your mother only because in the beginning 2 of the founding mothers weren't Hebrew. This is what the modern day so called Jews like to claim but in fact is not the reality.
@@---rk5lz Moses wasn't a Jew, he was a Levite. And as a matter of fact Jesus wasn't a Jew either because his mother was also a Levite and she was raised in the temple until she reached puberty. True Jews are from the tribe of Judah, Israelites from other tribes can't be called Jews because it just isn't their tribe. Can you fit a square into a circle? Exactly. Somebody been telling lies to the people.
The only true question that should be afforded this great video is where are the Hebrew Israelites that own the land? The Jews nor the Palestinians and many others are not the answer. We Black Hebrew Israelites are alive and kicking and you would be wise to absorb the Hebrew Bible properly and do your research properly As a Hebrew Israelite I thank Yahweh for his gift to his chosen people the Black Hebrew Israelites, the land between the 2 rivers, the River Nile and the River Euphrates. The problem is greater than you know or you know but are reticent to expose what has been hidden even today. Does not take much research to see that the Hebrew Israelite is everywhere except Israel. For good biblical reason given Hebrew prophecy. Rev2:9 might have given you a clue to what's about to happen. YAH for ever :)
Quite the opposite, you might think this strange but we are supposed to accept Reptilians like yourself too! There is no reason for you to be angry any more !
Imperium Europa Yeah, lost Americans face some major identity crisis issues. Fact is that the Palestinians are 100% Israelites (descendants of Israel aka Jacob.) they have never left their land, they have only accepted Muhammed and the Quran because it was in alignment with that which they followed before. Now we have converted Khazarians (Ashkenazi) who have accepted Judaism somewhere in the past and therefore call themselves Jews, and by now they think they are actual descendants of Israel. The Children of Israel called themselves ben israel or beni israel or banu Israel. Never have they even heard the word Jew. And banu Israel are not connected to 1 specific religion, we can find them among many nations following different religions. There were many disbelievers among the descendants of Jacob. Khazarians should not be in Palestine at all. The Palestinians will never agree with 1 nation because by their knowledge they still follow the same religion they did before and pray to the God of Abraham, they also know that if they would agree to 1 nation 1 state, they will not be treated equally because of religious differences and the "Jews" will rule over them as they are doing right now but everything would be lost totally. Palestine belongs to the Palestinians, they are the true Canaanites and Canaan is their land, Canaan/Palestine does not belong to Khazarian converts. The Khazarians (Ashkenazi Jews) should return to Europe.
Im not sure what Guy Faulkes is talking about but what is known is that neither the Jews nor the Palestinians are black enough to be members of any of the 12 tribes of Yashral, let alone their lack of resemblance to general black people. The same test given by you of Jews should be fairly placed on Palestinians do you have any proof and can you advise which Tribe they are known to come out of or return to? E.G. I am from the Tribe of Yuda, Ben, Levi and Reuben, please extend you're knowledge to us we are most intrigued ......
Yuda Ben-Levi Jangala 12 of the sons of Jacob aka Israel, 2 of which have another mother Joseph and Benjamin. They are all from the middle east, Middle Eastern people have never been black. The Middle East ain't South Africa neither is North Africa the same as South Africa! My brother from the same father and mother isn't black enough to look like my brother and his kids are too white to be related to my kids. While it's a fact that we all have the same blood, we are 1 family. Abraham took his slave woman as his second wife, that's why Arabs look a bit darker but they aint black, neither are Indians. Hagar was probably darker than his first wife but it doesn't mean black and black doesn't mean South African. For God and his followers Skincolors have never made a difference, banu Israel have traveled throughout the world spreading the message and settled in various places. Currently the children of Israel are among various "races" and follow various religions. Most of them that are most pure still live in the Middle East and North Africa they are viewed as Arabs but they are not. The Children of Jacob never were black or white, they are the current Middle Easterners and North Africans. Even though you don't know, they do.
Not a surprise. Jewish followers of Jesus split from mainstream Pharisee/Rabbinic Judaism at the time of Bar Kokhba’s revolt cause the rabbis claimed Bar Kokhba as the messiah, and being Christian they can’t have any messiah besides Jesus. Others were forcefully converted to Islam.
Father of the Hebrews, Abraham. Abraham, had 2 sons, Ismail and Issac. Ismail father of the arabs and Issac father of the Jews. Brothers... Sarah...Issac...Hagar...Ishmail.
Jews are not members of any of the "lost tribes", Jews were never lost. If you find a Jewish village or people in India, Africa, Arabia etc. all you found are more Jews. Only the non Jewish Northern Tribes of Israel were lost (600BC).
Some say Ashkenazi jews are not genetically jewish people in the sense that they converted to judaism centuries ago not necessarily descended through ibrahim bloodlines, this is so if you look at them now that they're light skinned blonde hair like those guys in europe
The problem in the land of Israel is not the main issue. The conflict is largely influenced by religion. Arabs in the land may well have observed many Jewish traditions until recently or even to this day. Even Saeb Erekat would use his Israelite origines to underline the right of the Arab speaking population to exclusively own the land, as he did in a conversation with for mer Israeli ambassador to Germany, Avi Primor. Most of the members of this population believe in the supremacy of Islam over all other world views. Nevertheless, during two thousand years, there have always been millions of people who may have to some extent less Jewish DNA but professed the G"d of Avraham, Yitzhak and Ya'akov=Israel. This way they have preserved their Israelite identity. This identity has been causing them to be fiercely persecuted and to return to their land of Israel. This identity also preserves their 'birthright' to the land. Nevertheless, most of them would certainly not question the Arab speaking population's right to cling to an Arab identity and to live in the land, regardless of their genetic code, of course. However, that does not give their leaders and extremists the right to try to throw the Jews into the Sea and 'ethnically cleanse' the country of its Jewish inhabitants. I am very thankful for this author's final statement that their is no alternative to peaceful coexistence and a one state solution. I absolutely agree. Dividing the land would merely promote even more suffering and extremist action. The latter is to be negotiated in a civilized manner and respecting each side's legitimate needs.
Palestinians are Jews, exploring cultural customs indicating so. This is part of the question, who is a Jew currently being explored by a number of human societies around the world. With the question, who is a Jew is the additional exploration into who is not a Jew. Ashkenazi, for example, are not Jews. If you take the story of Noah to heart you know Ashkenazi are from Noah's son Japheth and not from Noah's other son Shem. Thus Ashkenazi are not Semites. If this information about Noah associated with the descendent non-Jewish nature of Ashkenazi is not true and they are Semitic after all, then the next question follows: is the Bible an anti-Semitic document?
This nonsense is just outstanding. Palestinians, just like all contemporary peoples today, originate from a variety of sources, Byzantines, Crusaders, Romans, Egyptians, etc all fertilized the local women which were absorbed into the local population. What never has occurred in world history is a religion being defined as a primary ethnicity. Can you imagine if a Christian decided he was the direct descendants of the Joooos in the Bible and decided to return to Palestine.....and Christians from Russia to Argentina suddenly invaded and called themselves "natives "
Newsflash, the Muslims in Iraq are also former Jews too, OH my God!!!
Palestinian- American here... just got my DNA ancestry results back. Results: Eastern European Jewish and Middle East
Mine was 98% middle eastern 2% Nigerian also an American Palestinian
Which company did you guys use??
Ofc because many Ashkenazi Jews returned to Israel hundreds of years ago.
@@avtaras איך אתה יודע
There is no Jewish DNA . Zionists coined it up by coining up Judaism as a race too .
I am Palestinian and MyHeritage DNA shows 14% Jewish from Yemen and 1% Ashkanazi Jewish !!!
كيف بنعمل ووين وشو بكلف معقول بقدرو يعملو
Noora Salti في شركة MyHeritage الها app ممكن تنزيله و اتبع التعليمات و الدفع بعدين يبعتوا أدوات الفحص
Your ancestors was converted Islam in 8 century or 9
What a revelation!
Well Palestinians and Mizrahi Jews look identical
In my eyes Palestinian men look pretty similar to many Ashkenazis too. Not so the women......which is interesting given the info in the talk.
+Mark Simons I totally agree. A lot of Syrian Jews look shepardic
Spheradic Jews were the ancient Jews who were forced to move to spain because of the Romans.
@@marksimons8861
That is because of high Greek DNA in that place
@@marksimons8861 do u have face book
I am a Palestinian Christian born in Ramallah and I agree with this woman that Palestinians are Jewish they are not Arabs I am a Palestinian myself Christian and I believe that my ancestors come from the Israelites way back ago I tried to get citizenship in Israel they would not let me it's because I am Palestinian and born in the West Bank but I will find my DNA and when I find my DNA I will go to Israel and prove it to them that I am a Palestinian Jew
+Mazzen Warra What are you talking about bro ? You talk as the Zionists Jews who rule "Israel" today cares if your are a Jew or not. Even themselves knows we Palestinian are the indigenous people of the land but they are trying their best to hide it. The bottom line is we know we are the indigenous people of the land genetically , and the majority of the Zionists who live in historic Palestine today are eastern European Jews ,and which whom the only thing that connects them with the ancient Jews is their religion, not their blood like us.And that's why they hate us and want us all dead.
+PalestiniansWillNotGiveUp To be factually accurate here, it is the Sephardic/Mizrahi Jews who constitute the majority of Israel's Jewish population (60%, more or less). Also, it is an observable fact that these Mediterranean Jews are far more inclined to support the right-wing, religious sects of Zionism than their Ashkenazic counterparts from Eastern Europe. Concerning the Ashkenazim, what makes you think that we have no connection to ancient Judaea/Palestine?
+Dovid Rabinovich i like how the jews truly believe in payit forward. there doing what the natzis did. wish they would live mexico too. jews everywhere.
+Mazzen Warra there is no such thing!
+Farland Prince Why do you people keep saying Arabs vs Jews...Jews are historically part of the ancient Arabs who embraced the religion of Moses...
my step dad was a jew. he was from Palestine...
May I kno y most Palestinian didn't know they were Jewish descendant
@@MrDizahari they know but You know it'll give a shock to Israelis
i support mr. misnai.
i wish him all the luck.
he has come up with the facts that nobody can deny.
I can.
@@Viktir123 was it disproven?
@@bennywolfe4357 It's both ways. Depending on the Haplogroup, you have this being truth and sometimes in reverse.
@@Viktir123 can you dumb it down for me?
Yes. Of course! The early Zionists knew that Palestinians were likely the descendants of the biblical Hebrews. But neither they nor the "Arab Jews" were the Jews for which Israel was founded by its European Jewish architects. Zionism is a special strain of European colonialism. Palestinians are not longing to become Jews. It is great that you are recognizing the horrible injustice done to the Palestinians but you need to stop imposing your nationalist and religious agenda on them. They are longing to return to the homes from which they were ethnically cleaned and live with full legal rights in their own country. They long for peace. They long for the home of their mothers and fathers. Similar to Hebrews who became Islamized and Arabized, many of the Jews and Christians of Europe are also the result of conversion of people's native to Europe. Religion and culture are not biology. History has many twists and turns. Accept that a terrible crime was done to Palestinians and make reparations for what has been done to them.
No "Palestinians" were ethnically cleansed from Israel. They left on their own. The Institute of Palestine Studies, an Arab organization from Beirut say that *"68% of the Arabs never saw a Jewish man with a gun or a soldier"* and watch the video, *"How we really became refugees, 13 Palestinians tell their personal stories"* Mamoud Abbas and 12 others tell from all areas of Israel that they left on the orders of their leaders.
@@shainazion4073 hasbara working overtime
@@AJ-pc9gu Did You watch the video? Did you check the source? I call Taquiya on you!!!
Well said
@@shainazion4073 you sound like a Karen.
Just proves that only one state one country united can work, the two state is not a solution at all.
I've always found it a curious fact how people don't distinguish Palestinian Christians and Muslims racially, yet view Palestinian Jews (Jews living in 19th century Palestine) as something alien. They're all the same stock, just different religions. I think European Jews project their own racial differences with the European populations they emigrated from onto these Palestinian Jews-- that is, they think just because they are racially different to a German or Slavic Russian, then so must this Jew in Palestine be something different from his Muslim neighbor. This is simply not the case. If you don't believe me, visit my father's city of Nablus, and meet the Samaritan Jews who live on the outskirts of the city. You simply cannot distinguish them from the Muslims living in Nablus.
Hardly surprising since many of the inhabitants of Nablus are descendants of Samaritans, converted to Islam in the usual way.
@@marksimons8861that's exactly right!
Some Jews, (who are descended from Jacob), have always remained in the area of Israel when the Romans persecuted them in AD 70.
Yeah we know their descendents are the Palestinians
Jewish isn’t a race it’s a religion
We don’t deny being the same as the Jews on the land but the Europeans is what we are not
My cousin actually Jewish, there great grand father came from Yemen, converted to Islam , and lived with my family tribe.My self am pretty sure Iam a pure Arab from a Yemeni tribe.My father from al azd tribe , my mother from bani tarif who olso a Yemeni tribe ...
Dear MADAM, please bring the gentleman back each year for an update interview please. Especially NOW. THANK YOU 💟 SHALOM PEACE LOVE JOY PEACE 💞🕊️ GBU ALL 💖
This is without question my favorite of all your videos ! How great it would be if they could all come this truth ! Thank you forthiswork...IJN !
Some Jews have Palestinians lineage. That is how it is supposed to phrased. Palestinian means a native of Palestine. Most Pals go back as far as the Canaanite pre-Roman age. Not big news really, confirmed from their customs, and even the influence of the Aramaic language on their colloquial dialect.
Exactly
This following is a genetic map that shows Canaanite DNA samples from the Bronze Age and Iron Age in purple and green circles (ASH IA, ASH BA, SIDON BA, JORDAN BA) and they overlap and cluster with Palestinians, Jordanians and Lebanese. The brown circle is Neolithic Levantine which was more Saudi-North African-like than Bronze Age, Iron Age and modern Levantines due to less Mesopotamian admixture (the Levant received waves of Mesopotamian migration that mixed into the population over several periods) so the few Jews (Tunisian and Libyan Jews on the map) that overlap with the Neolithic sample have admixture from a modern source that is more Saudi-North African-like, similar to the Neolithic population, pulling them in that direction to overlap since Neolithic ancestry did not survive in whole in the Bronze Age, Iron Age and today. Here is the genetic map: qph.fs.quoracdn.net/main-qimg-0dd4c4b173e7703187337ad160a55277
Yes 👍🏼
No, the Jews were there before there was a Palestine.
@@shainazion4073 Genesis 21-34 mentions Palestine (or Filistin as spoken by the locals): And Abraham lived as a foreigner in Philistine country for a long time. Same terminology is used in arguably the very first book of history written 5th century BC by the "father of history" Herodotus .
We are canaanites...we are the oldest people in the whole world..try to read the history of palestine precisely
The Modern Jews still show 50% of Canaanite DNA. Archeologists believe that the Israelites were a Canaanite tribe that stopped child sacrifice and believed in the one true God.
Since both tribes are descended from father Abraham, they must be related
Palestinian Arabs are not related to Saudi Arabs. Arabs are not homogenous genetically.
the arabs did not descent from Abraham stop lying
this is amazing !
Why does the ethnicity matter this much🤦🏻♀️? We are all humans and deserve respect and love.
Ethnicity meant the liberty for people to have his own culture and not be submitted to empires and religions. Nothing wrong on the contrary. Don't tell to indigenous people that ethnicity not matter because you maybe a disconnected globalized westerner. You'll not tell to an indigenous American that ethnicity is not important so it's the same for canaanites-phoenicians.
Religion might change, but the DNA and History will never change. Go and make something better for your country. BTY my Palestinian Grandma is older than Israel.
Your grandma is then probably older than Jordan, Lebanon, Algeria, Senegal, Sudan, India, Syria and many more... so what's your point again? Oh yeah... history 😂
@@NaomiOff shuv the history up to your a** no one cares about history with this conflict anymore.
@@NaomiOffthe point is israel country does not exist
@@zacky_hendrian but it does no matter how much you deny it :)
One thing for sure about the Palestinians, historically and genetically they are more entitled to that land than 90% of the Jews in Israel who are Ashkenazi european Jews.
1) Ashkenazi are 52% of the jews.
2) DNA say the contrary. And between you and DNA....
I know it's been 9 years but f$#_ you man, most Jews in Israel are of middle Eastern origin either from Israel or from immediately neighboring countries. When you look at a map you realize it isn't hard for some Jews to wander a bit further out into what is now considered Europe (well mostly southeastern Europe).
European Jews are welcome for the same reasons middle Eastern Jews are welcome, and I'm proud to be half European and half middle Eastern Jewish.
@@NaomiOff No ot does not.
@@benharper3200 yes it does, but thank you for your participation :)
Nothing new, yes they must have to be the same people.
I'm an Arab from hejaz while my dna results matching askenazi jews.
I think it's odd that when the woman speaks the audio works but soon as the man start talking the audio cuts off is anyone else experiencing that?
On my computer she speaks from the right side speaker, his words come from the left side speaker.
thanks for the video! I wish however it was not in stereo as such, hearing it from only one speaker at a time is very distracting and actually annoying, and makes it hard to concentrate. Leave the audio on BOTH channels, don't switch back and forth. Other than that, great video, great information! Thanks for up'ping this vid!
I am a Palestinian and I have 15% jewish according to DNA test. And that is a lot considering I dont anyone in my family that has any thing resembeling jewish ancestory.
someone may have converted in your family but still carried jewish roots
Probably 1000 years back or more you had Jewish roots
There was no recorded family history ..but DNA is proof..you have jewish heritage in your blood my dear.
@@janbelljara4495 can i do aliyah now.
LOL
Arabs and Jews(the semitic ones) are ethnically and linguistically related, and have cultural connections since they have lived in the same places. But the conflict has never been about ethnicity or culture, or even religion. Giving the Palestinians their homes and land back, and giving them equal rights, and treating them like human beings is the only way to peace.
Olivia S
That’s a very good point.
if only it were so simple.
-give them "their" lands homes etc... why would they be given that, when jews who fled from the muslim world would never get theirs back?
-even if israel "gave the back..." they'd still be coming yet for more, till there is no more israel, unacceptable.
-israel proposed to "give them back", by means of equivalent value so that they can settle elsewhere, they keep refusing.
-treat them ... humans... you are exagerating, some israelis will look down on palis, and all palis look down on israelis, but a pali would always find a reasonable interlocutor in israel if he has a claim, and he can even will a trial if his claim is lawful according to law, the inverse is NOT true.
You have a conflict between two sides who do not have a common sense, a common way of treating with justice, this conflict is an endless one, and will not end on a tribunal, it will end with de facto achievements.
@@viverntahl2541
"when jews who fled from the muslim world would never get theirs back?"
You are pivoting. Palestinian Arabs have no genetic relations with where these Jews are coming from.
If Israel really likes the wellbeing of these Jews of Muslim world, then why does it allies itself with Saudi Arabia and consider Iran bad. Supported Hamas to get rid of PLO ,etc
"give them back"
If someone comes to your house, takes half of it, and offer other half as peace deal, then would you take it ?
No fucking way you will get him out of your house.
"you are exagerating, some israelis will look down on palis, and all palis look down on israelis, but a pali would always find a reasonable interlocutor in israel if he has a claim, and he can even will a trial if his claim is lawful according to law, the inverse is NOT true."
You are the one exxagarating here. Talk about reasonable, lets start a war over 3 kidnapped teenager to kill ,settle,etc this is reality of this COLONIAL STATE
Thanks, I was taught this in the 1970's in church.
Share the land and the rich history of many people that have lived there. Palestinians and Israelites are related. it's a family feud there that has been going on for 1000's of years.
MM Jewish is a religion we are the same people sum Muslim who speak Arabic and sum are Jewish that speak Hebrew
@@joynkindness wrong it is a islam muhammad thing read the quran and the ahadith muhammad the funder of islam and his god hate the Jews and see to destroy Israel if you haven noticest
True!!!! I hope the Palestinian people are , and they are , the REAL Hebrews!!;
Right on!!!
I said this year's ago
Of course the Palistinans are Native to this area including , but the European AshkaNazi Zionists preferred not just take over but Persecute the non Jewish population
@@fouadmas5413 by DNA palestinians are jewish indeed!
They are no more Real than other Jews.
@@janbelljara4495 would that include hamass you know the group seeking to destroy Israel and kill every Jew of the planet
The headaches thing is so true. I cant believed it
I love this man and I agree with him.
Since the observance of the Sabbath is a covenant of Hebrews and Elohim, Mamoinides stated the Jews who do not observe the Sabbath are pagans. Messiah will gather the children of Israel into the land, I submit Palestinians should integrate the observance of the Sabbath in their Muslim faith and make peace with Israel.
Palestinians are a mix of Canaanites, Ancient Israel , and Arabs . The land belongs to them .
Nope
A Palestinian here. DNA test revealed 50% levant which is Israel, Lebanon and Syria. My ancestors are from Jerusalem ans it’s neighbouring area. It also said my ancestors lived there for the past 30 thousand years and no jewish DNA.
These guys are Zionists trying do Israeli propaganda they them self are not even originally from that land they conquered it from the Canaanites who are probably your ancestors and there no such thing as Jewish dna it is a religion Arabs and Hebrews are both originally from the Middle East from the same ancestors honestly the talk these two people have remind me of Nazism.
I recommend reading the book Legacy: A Genetic History of the Jewish People by Harry Ostrer to understand this further.
the biggest shock was for me that I am from Damascus and my dad always used this mechanism of binding his Head with a cloth and a Key for headaches :O. I only know that a relative on my father side married a jew and settled in Israel and our family first came to the countryside of Damascus (Midan) about 200 years ago and we don't know anything past that :3
could we be jew descendants? :O
everytime palestinine being invaded, you find that the people of the land accepted whatever religion was brought to them, wheather they be islam,judaism or christinity.The point here jews should stop subjugating the palestinian and learn to live together rather than to dehumanise them.
I love it! This is gonna get real interesting as people who have been posing as Jews get exposed
what?
H j y,
Yeah, the Palestinians are the Jews from Judah. The present occupiers, so called Jew by religion only ( European + American descent) ruling from the Knesset are gentiles from Khazarian stock.
@@decathlonevent Jews are Jews. Some Palestinians come from Jews. The Real Jews are the real Jews.
I think a lot of Iraqis....Turks.....Iranians and a motleys crew of Europeans are also "Jewish." I know there are a lot of Jewish Spaniards .............and some of those genes are now in Mexico as well. The Jews got around!
You are right. A lot of Levantine Jewish DNA was found in Italy, certain Portuguese and Spaniards, and in many European populations. There's even Central Asian Uzbekistan Jews now that we've discovered. I'm a geneticist and have been especially following Jewish DNA for over a year now. It's almost everywhere.
Genetics Is The Key We should probably break dance now. :-D
paintur68 LOL well you can break dance, I'll just watch.
Genetics Is The Key Drags you onto the dance floor....
ainanor No, not all of them, but a few have Jewish genetics.
In Muslim beliefs origin is less important when it comes to beliefs, I think Muslim could be Israeli too as many of today's Palestinians and Jordanians were from Prophet Dawood blood and prophet Joseph blood but they were converted and accept the new and last testimony of God and today they call themselves Muslim and due to neighborhood and region they have integrated into Arab culture and adopt Arab language.
Rationally the people who were in the region prior to the creation of the Israel state are logically more closely DNA related to the original Israelites that these Euro/Russo Jewish converts who flocked to Palestine.
+Gregarious Antithesis All arabs are related to jews genetically because they are somewhat the same people. On genetic papers, they cluster very close,
@@TheAfghan72yeah prophet Muhammed(pbuh) is from Abraham’s lineage. From his son Ismael. Jews are descendants from his son Isaac.
You are not following the scientific stated here, are you? Although the statement about Palestinians being Jews is factually and historically incorrect, but the DNA and language origin do have common roots from the times of pre-Judea and the Canaanites.
The word "Jew" never appears in Torah. It appears later where in the Roman age 15% of the empire followed monotheism, spreading out of Judea, hence the word Jew. Similarly, Nazarene derives from Nazareth which historically referred to Christians.
The word Jew is in the Book of Esther, it states that Mordechai, her Uncle was a Jew of the tribe of Benjamin.
@@shainazion4073 Book of Esther is not part of the Torah itself which has five books: Genesis, Exodus, Leviticus, Numbers and Deuteronomy. Genesis 21-34 for example mentions Palestine (or Filistin as spoken by the locals): "And Abraham lived as a foreigner in Philistine country for a long time."
Arab is a language not a nation , Ishmael raised and lived with Arabic speaker tribe and adopted their language so he is not the father of all arab in fact he is arab just because he spoke Arabic .
Hagar was Egyptian. Edom mixed with Ishmael's children and the arabs were born.
Therefore Muslims are Hebrew thru their father Edom, but they are not Israel.... that would be Jacob's seed. Black folks.
Arabs existed long before Abraham, and groups of people like "Ishaelites" and "Midianites" would become Arabized with time. "Black folks" (whatever that means) have nothing to do with this whole story - West Africans are about as far away from these folks as blue eyed red haired Irish people. And
Joy E. blacl folkz r nothing ghey r npt isreal
LuckyDukeSeven his dumb baby
Yes the Lord is shaking up to heavens and the Earth
DNA origins Would be a definitive game changer. The question remains; Which is the parent and which is the bastard?
Tracing lineage by use of scripture is self serving, and perpetuates the hamster wheel reasoning of human origin as being only a minuscule few thousand years.
Archaeology proves humanities existence for many hundreds of thousands of years (millions for earlier more primitive humans). DNA can shed light on regional domination of any one species.
This single fact blows out of the water any 'wanna be' indigenous people, interlopers, immigrants. And brings us closer to answering the question; Which is the parent, and which is the bastard?
The Mediterranean Sea to the west. Africa and Egypt to the south and southwest. Saudi Arabia and Jordan to the east. Syria, Turkey and Iran to the north.
All 'Dark Nations', I will repeat that, "ALL DARK NATIONS'. And in the very middle of all these and other 'Dark Nations' white Jews claim sovereignty!?!
Purchasing land does not grant sovereignty! Devine land grants from invisible friends in the sky is not acceptable!
The congenital deceitful nature and behavior of Zionist (non Rabbinic) Jews is blatantly evident.
Purge the war mongering Zionists out!! And leave the Jewish and Palestinian Arab people to live together in peace. As they had for generations before this wretched mutated mongrel abomination of humanity began their campaign of war crimes and crimes against humanity!!!
+Ant B he dosent realise anything. he is a complit ignorant and you are wasting your time explaning him. ppl like him are brain washed with false information. his mind is still back on 1930 . he thinks all jews comes from Poland and he is not aware where they come from and know nothing about jews from Arab countries wich are at list hulf of the jews in israel. not to mention ethiopiens jews sefaradi jews and thouse who are israelis for few generations as i am
The Jews were a people before the Palestinians. The Jews were a people before there was Islam.
@@shainazion4073Palestinians existed before Islam. Our nations all existed actually. Islam is the last religion. Of course! We all converted recently. Islam is God’s last message to us before everything ends…
Hi Christine, I really appreciate all your videos! Do you have any updates regarding this subject? Perhaps, you could talk about Sephardic and Ashkenazy and other jews? I would like to know what he has found out since 2012. Blessings, Mary Ellen
❀◕ ‿ ◕❀
Palestinians could be converted Canaanites, Samaritans or Jews, or any mixture of those…we just don’t know for sure so it’s incorrect for the time being to call them Jews. Let’s just call them indigenous people. What we do know is there is no Israelite DNA tested yet, but there is Canaanite DNA tested and Palestinians cluster and overlap with the Canaanites, just as Jordanians and Lebanese do (one study reported that Lebanese Christians were 93% similar to Canaanite samples from Bronze Age Sidon).The following genetic map shows the Canaanite samples as purple and green circles (these are Bronze Age and Iron Age samples) and they overlap with Palestinians. The brown circle shows a Neolithic Levantine sample, but all Levantines after the Neolithic became admixed with ancestry from migration waves from Mesopotamia in what is modern day Iraq (biblical descriptions of Abraham were that he was from Ur in Sumer, part of Mesopotamia) so the few Jews (Tunisian and Libyan Jews on the genetic map) that overlap with this Neolithic Levantine sample have an admixture of the Saudi-North African-like ancestry from a modern source that made up the predominance of the Neolithic sample, pulling them toward that sample since Neolithic Levantine ancestry in whole did not survive in the Bronze Age and Iron Age, nor in today’s Levantines.
Jews do not cluster with the Canaanites, however they do cluster not too far away which if the hypothesis holds true that the Israelites were just Canaanites that assumed a new identity following their exodus from Egypt into the land of Canaan, then the modern Jewish position on the genetic map shows they are a group of mixed origins, which makes sense since their Levantine ancestors spent 2000 years in countries outside of the land where Israel and Palestine is today. Here is the genetic map: qph.fs.quoracdn.net/main-qimg-0dd4c4b173e7703187337ad160a55277
Modern Jews have over 50% of Canaanite DNA.
@@shainazion4073 If that was the case then they wouldn’t be Jews, would they? Modern Jews are around half Levantine and that Levantine is mostly Hebrew, not Canaanite.
@@IslenoGutierrez Put in a search for were the Israelites Canaanites. You will find the answer of "Yes". Whether they assimilated them, married them, or were a branch of them, they lived at the same time, had similar features, and they had different beliefs, the Israelites had no pig bones or sea shells in their villages as food. They both did process techelet, the blue dye from the murex snail. The name Canaanite came from this blue or purple dye. "Kn" means murex, and "Canaanite" those that are of the land of the purple/blue dye. "Phoenician" is the greek for the purple people.
@@shainazion4073 I don’t doubt that some Canaanites may have been assimilated into the Hebrews before their exodus from Israel/Judea, however I don’t believe that to make up the majority of the Levantine ancestry of Jews (which makes up about half the ancestry of Jews). I also believe that the Hebrews were possibly genetically similar to the Canaanites as they were originally from Mesopotamia (modern day Iraq)(it’s stated that Hebrews entered Canaan from east of the Jordan River after leaving Egypt as slaves and and their origin was from Ur in Mesopotamia) but by no means do I believe that the Hebrews were significantly Canaanite. Jews do not cluster with Canaanite DNA samples while Palestinians do. I believe Palestinians to be way more Canaanite ancestry while Jews more Hebrew ancestry.
@@IslenoGutierrez Go rsad the DNA studies the Jews have 50% of Canaanite DNA, the local Arabs have 50% of Canaanite DNA. With the Jews we know that their DNA is the same as Canaanites, with "Palestinians" they could be expressing more modern Lebanese DNA. I don't know where you think that the "Palestinians" have more or hetter DNA matches with the Canaanites? The "Palestinians" have the same Y-DNA haplotypes as the modern Jews do.
There is no surprise. Palestinians are cousins of Jews. Many Palestinians have Hebrew descent. They just accepted Christianity or Islam.
This is actually the most intelligent comment in this section." Palestinians are the real descendants" is the stupidest one and most frequent, they're equal descendants to the Jews. They're both actually stolen into other populations/and cultures from being originally levantine descent. That's what happens when the rest of the world has ugly people and so they need to bring in some pretty.😂😂
@@AliyaDabkes2465there is no equal descendants. Jews from Europe and America on average only carry around 0-19% Levantine DNA
This is very interesting... I'm not sure that all Palestinians have Hebrew ancestry though... for sure, the majority/all of those in the West Bank have Hebrew ancestry... But what about those in Gaza? I'm pretty sure that there would be a remnant who are actually Arabs or perhaps have ethnic Egyptian, Jordanian or Turkish ancestry from the Ottoman Empire :/ just a thought.
Most Gazans are refugees from 1948
The only Hebrew family we know of is Abraham. The Palestinians are descendants of Israelites, not Hebrew.
The people of that region are Canaanites. Some of them went to Egypt during a severe famine and returned as a different people, as Hebrews. Through the millennia the inhabitants of Palestine had been forced to change religions to survive - as animists, oriental pagans, Mosaic Hebrews , classical (Graeco-Roman) pagans. Christians, Muslims. Looking at Palestinians most of them dark haired with deep set eyes and looking at and many Israelis who are blond and blue eyed, there is no mistaking as to are the intruders and who are descended from the original inhabitants of the land.
They have genetically sequenced the Ancient Israelites and they were blonde and blue-eyed. So the Palestinians are not indigenous? That is nonsense. Many of the Palestinians are from Jewish ancestry.
@@shainazion4073 The European Jews are converts. They are Khazars. So the present day Israelites are interlopers.
@@crestvilla711 Your ignorance is outstanding!!! The Khazar theory has been debunked by history, archeology, linguistics, and science (DNA). In fact, the only "study" that found any tie at all from the Jews to the Khazars, didn't yse Khazar DNA or Jewish DNA. Eran Elhaik used Palestinians as stand-ins for Ancient Jews. Therefore Palestinians were found to be Khazars by his study. Actually, he never used Khazar DNA either. He used Armenians and Georgians.
@@crestvilla711 Geneticists have proven that less than half a percent of Jews per generation is the result of converts.
@@crestvilla711 Modern Jews still show 50% of Canaanite DNA. Who did they supposedly convert from, that maintained Canaanite DNA for over 2500 years??????
one secular and democratic Israel/Palestine.
that is the best solution.
i am all for it.
+Zulfiqar Uddin Me too. But it MUST be secular and democratic.
The servants of God can't follow Democracy or the secular world for if they do then the law of man is supreme not the law of God.
Okay if you say secular that means a rabbi,Imam,, nor priest/whatever Christians have should not be apart of the knesset. A lot of ultra-orthodox have too much control.
Most people in the Middle East and North Africa north of the Arabian peninsula are actually not Arabs but Arabized Muslim converts from the people who were already there before the spread of Islam.
We know Palestinians are the true Semites and the seeds of Ebrahim, the question is, how about both of you? Are you true Semites or converts? Are you planning to give them their land and leave to Poland?
Ali Rahmani
What? LOL that makes NO sense?? Ha!
cinda schuster you don't make sense
Christine Taggart “three in one” failed to convert all jews to christian...human teaching = paul teaching 👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼
Donald Cannon
“three in one” failed to convert all jews to christian...human teaching = paul teaching....all of state for the prophet that mention in bible now become state of islam...christian faith teaching fail because they failed to convert all state in middle east include israel to christian...the winner is islam as a monotisme religion 👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼
Donald Cannon can you give me a fact...give me a fact and get it from what we believe from “quran or as sunnah” ....you dont have a fact for what you said...👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼
I believe they already did a study and found Palestinians to be a closer match to the ancient Palestinians, but why not. ?? A very large number of Israelis are from the former Soviet Union... More people migrated to israel from Russia than all nations put together and even the founding fathers were ALL related to bolshevicks, or Soviet Union..
Yemenite, Morrocan mitzrahi are all middle Eastern Jews...
Moroccans Jews are Moroccans they are not from the Middle-East.
True. Hesidic. Some migrated to Spain and then to Azores. My husbands family did this. They converted to Christianity perhaps by force.
@@alahemy moroccan jews moved to morocco from Jerusalem in the 1st century ad
God knows shannika is struggling. He knows that her children are being jailed and persecuted. He knows that inside, she is rich but out wardly is very poor. God has a plan for SHANNIKA
Not Jews wrong term, Some maybe Jews but the correct term is Hebrews the lost tribes are actually Hebrews. Also genetically many of the so called Jews are not Semites and not from the area.
That is not simply true.
@@Rosenheim1029 simply is true
the solution is simple: only Torah is the Law of the Land. Put aside Quaran, accept Torah, and the conflict is solved. But the Torah Law should be enforced in the Land first.
I'M A JEW....... WOW... AWESOME .. OUT OF MY WAY BENJAMIN NOTAJEW
Alaadeen 85 - You go, Alaadeen!
@elle lee Even a Rabbi will tell you Allah is God. Even Jesus said Elah Elah Rabbana Subhaktani. In Arab God is Ilah and the name of Ilah is Allah and he is ONE not three. Go back to school and learn Math.
@elle lee No it's not and that's not in Hebrew or Aramaic. Most of the so called names people are calling God by today are Titles, not his name. If you knew Hebrew or Arabic you would know this but you only know the last language to be made on earth.
@elle lee Well all the Middle Eastern Scholars whether Rabbi's or Muslim Imam's say Allah is God. Christian's in Africa and the Middle East call God Allah. The one's worshipping the Devil are those Christians who pray to a made up character called Jesus. Point Blank period. Allah is the Only God and Jesus is who you Christians pray to. We pray to the creator and you pray to a creation which is called disbelief blasphemy and idolatry. You can try to explain yourself away in your crazy deluded mind but fact is you pray to something other than God and God destroyed plenty of people nation's and countries because of doing so. It's written in all the scriptures, so how is it that you want to go ahead and call another man in this case a messenger sent by God and you sick minded people want to go ahead and call him God? This man never once said I am God but he did say God is Greater than I. He also said you can be like me, even Greater than I if you just had Faith. The man also Prayed, to whom? To God. Which one of his disciples prayed to Jesus? None. So stop spreading falsehoods because you've rwad the truth about the man probably your whole life and still ignore what is being said in the texts. You are a people who have no understanding and you let a priest, preacher, pastor tell you what some words mean like you can't comprehend what you're reading for yourself. Deaf DUMB and Blind are the Christians. The Jews themselves will tell you this. Look up youtube videos on Jewish scholars and Rabbis telling you what Allah means and then look up what they think about the Christian doctrine. It is evident that 2 of the Abrahamic faiths say you have nothing to do with them and you don't worship what they both worship. Christians worship a man and they worship Allah/Hashem/Ar Rahman/God. Then you always believe this man god died for your pagan sins, LMAO! How did you people fall for that one? Like I said read the scripture, God says no one but he can forgive sin and only he can save you from destruction. But no you want to believe in Jesus and his magical blood, if that isn't the most pagan belief out of all paganistic faiths I don't know paganism is. Keep on worshipping the Devil's man god and see what's going to be waiting for you on the day of judgement. When the man who is the Messiah is questioned by God, did you tell them to worship you and he says NO! Hell fire is for those who believed in a lie.
@elle lee Plus Muhammad was spoken of very highly in the book of John and the Messiah said to follow him for he would explain all things and give testimony of the truth of the Messiah. All the names he called this person you can look up in Arabic to see what Muhammad was called and it will be clear as day to see the man that Christ described to the T, in the book of John. If you choose to deny it then you truly are to be considered the stupidest people that ever existed on the day of judgement punishment will be reserved for the likes of you no matter how good you may have been on this earth. Remember Christ says no one is good but the Lord. Smh. People just love lies I guess.
נשמע מעניין מאוד
The Jewish people ara the ones that descended from the Arabs.Remember Abraham was Arab born in the city of UR.
Wrong Abraham was Chaldean which Ur was in Chaldea which is Iraq today. The original Arabs were a Black tribe called the tribe of Jurham. Ishmael went to live amongst these nomadic people.
Ur was Chaldean, not Arab. The Arabs or Ishmaelites descended from Abraham through Sarah's handmaid Hagar.
Aberraham is arab
I'm black and I do the headache band, using all kinds of bush in the front .
Yeah, why do these people care this much about ethnicity and race??? If they will start liking poor Palestinians just because of their DNA, I guess this is not a bad finding 🤦🏻♀️
Palestinian are the real Canaans
Prove your words scientifically not lb lb lb
Genetically, all humans are closely related. New studies in the past few months have revealed that Eurasians are mixture of 3 basic peoples that shared a common ancestry 50 to 60 thousand years ago.
Starting out from middle eastern regions, early hunter gathers roamed across western Europe starting 45,000 years ago. Eurasian hunter gatherer groups made their way into Steppes around 35,000 years ago. Others remained closer to the middle east. By around 10,000 years ago, middle eastern groups had developed agriculture and over the next few thousand years pushed into western Europe and into the Steppes bringing genes, technology and permanent settlements. Around 4500 years ago, Pastoralists from the Steppes swept into Europe, the Middle East and South Asia bringing horses, animal husbandry, wheeled carts and language. Most everyone across Europe, Western Eurasia, the Middle East and the Indian subcontinent are descended from these 3 groups of people in various combinations. Jews and Palestinians are essentially the same people with different cultural heritages. Stop fighting already.
Most of the Jews who live in Israel today are not the children of Israel. The Palestinians are the children of Abraham. Some of them are the children of Ismael, and the others are the children of Israel who converted Islam. I know many big Palestinian tribes are Jews who converted Islam. Most of the Palestinian muslims who live in Hebron near thier grandfather Abraham are origionaly from the children of Israel who converted Islam and the others are the children of Ismael.
Modern Jews have been proven through DNA to be the descendants of the Israelites .
@@shainazion4073
You should do DNA to the Palestinians to believe that the war in the holy land is between the tribe of Juda and the children of Israel who moved to the desert of Ishmael in the city of Maddina on mount Sala to wait for the coming prophet who through him the covenant between Allah and his prophet Ibrahim was fullfiled.
The Jews used to tell the children of Ishmael that the coming prophet will destroy their idols as his grandfather Ibrahim did, but when they knew that the prophet that they were waiting for is from Ishmael they helped the idols worshipers to kill the prophet instead of the helping the prophet to destroy the idols.
At the end, the covenant between Allah and the children of Ibrahim was fullfiled through prophet Mohammed in a few years and they owned the land from the Atlantic ocean in the west to the Pacific ocean in the east.
The covenant was not fullfiled with the children of Israel and the children of Ismael who did not believe in Muhammad and Allah punished them to live between the nations.
That is what is a called a Bubbe Meise! There was no prophet coming to Arabia the time of prophesy had ended. They did not wait for amy prophet that is more Taquiya and there were Jews in Yarthrib before there was Islam or Muhammed. This is all Taquiya!
@@rachelsamuel3328
The Jews moved to live in the middle of the desert of Kedar the son of Ishmael in the city of Yathrib on mount Sela " where prophet Muhammad built his great mosque " based on the origional holy Torah.
Isaiah 42:11
Let the wilderness and its towns raise their voices; let the settlements where Kedar lives rejoice. Let the people of Sela sing for joy; let them shout from the mountaintops.
The Jews where waiting the prophet that the covenant between Allah and the children of Ibrahim will be fullfiled through him. The Jews used to tell the children of Ishmael that the coming prophet will destroy the idols as his grandfather Ibrahim did and the covenant will be fullfiled through him. The Jews thought that the prophet will be one of them, but when they found out that the prophet is from the children of Ishmael some of the Jews refused him and they helped the idol worshippers to fight prophet Muhammad instead of helping the prophet to destroy the idols.
At the end, the covenant was fullfiled with the children of Ibrahim who believed in the messege of Muhammad in a few years and whom did not believe were not part of the covenant and Allah punished them to live between the other nations.
The fact is : most of the children of Israel who moved to wait the coming prophet in Yathrib and believed him, the covenant was fullfiled with them and most of them moved to live in the holy land next to their grandfather Ibrahim.
And the other fact is : ten tribes from the children of Israel out of twelve believed in Muhammad and they are muslims.
@@ashrafaljaradat7892 How did a man who didn't read know what the Torah said? Now you are serving baloney. This is not hostory, it is fairy tales. The Jews were there hundreds of years before Muhamed. Why were they in Khaybar? Because they knew Muhammed would slaugnter them all, and rape their wjves and daughters?
For the record the living team genome really seems to be the origin of fairhair fair eyes and fair skin especially Fair olives skin blue eyes and blondish and reddish hair. It's much more likely that it originated in southern Syria I.E. Israel Lebanon and Jordan then even in the ancient Anatolian areas.
go to Poland grandma ;)
najib qane
What is it with you ignorant haters? Why poland?. Sh*t, I forgot your kind don't read much so it must be something you heard another ignorant hater say! 😉
Or Ukraine
Like most religions in the old days they were forced to convert..
The Palestinian Arabs, actually came from surrounding Muslim territories when the Ottomans striped the land of its trees, and invited others in their territories to come and work in the Providence of Palestine which would later become part of the British mandate, where the cost of living was cheep, and the conquered Jewish cities were mostly vacant.
many Palestinian family names reveal their place of origin.
Kiswani - Jordan
Abu Khueik - Jordan
Odeh - Jordan
al Urdon - Jordan
Musleh - Jordan
Mohsein - Jordan
Muksen - Jordan
al Turki - Turkey (not even Arab)
Sultan - Turkey (not even Arab)
Uthuman - Turkey (not even Arab)
Turk - Turkey (not even Arab)
al Kurd - Turkey (not even Arab)
Yamtar- Khazachstan,Kipchak tribe (Turkic)
Darwish - Egypt
Mansour - Egypt
al Masri - Egypt
Masrawa - Egypt
Metzarwah - Egypt
al Tartir - Tartir village, Egypt
Bardawil - Lake Bardawil, Sinai Peninsula, Egypt
Abu-Suta - Tarabin tribe, Egypt
Abu-Seeta - Tarabin tribe, Egypt
Sha'alan - Bedouin, Egypt
al Aksar - Luxor, Egypt
Ayoob - Egypt
Raz - Egypt
al Natsheh - Egypt
al Fayyumi - Faiyum, Egypt
al Araki/al Iraqi - Iraq
al Baghadi - Baghdad, Iraq
Zubeidi - Iraq
Zuabi/Zoabi - West Iraq
al Faruki - Iraq
al Tachriti - Iraq
al Mosul/al Mawsil - Mosul, North Iraq
al Bani/al Beni - Bani tribe, East Iraq
al Saudi - Saudi Arabia
Husseini / Hussein - Saudi Arabia (Hussain was the 4th Imam)
al Tamimi - Saudi Arabia
al Khijazi - Saudi Arabia
al Kurash - Saudi Arabia
al Kurashi - Saudi Arabia
Erekat - Bedouin tribe, North West Saudi Arabia.
al Higazi - Saudi Arabia
al Hejazi - Saudi Arabia
Omayya - Saudi Arabia
Nashashibi - Syria
al Hurani - Huran, South Syria
al Halabi - Haleb, North Syria
al Allawi - West Syria (shoreline)
Hamati - Homs, Syria
Sidawi - Sidon, Lebanon
Tabulsi - Tripoly, Lebanon
al Tarabulas - Tripoly, Lebanon
al Surani - Sour, South Lebanon
al Tahir - Tair, South Lebanon
Lubnani - Lebanon
al Yamani - Yemen
al Azad/al Azd - Yemen
Hadadin - Yemen
Hadadin - Yemen
Murad - Yemen
Mattar - Mattar village, Yemen
Mugrabi - Magrab, Morocco
al Araj - Morocco
Mighrebta - Morocco
al Bosni/al Busna - Bosnia and Herzegovina (not even Arab)
Bushnak - Bosnia and Herzegovina (not even Arab)
Bohran - Bosnia and Herzegovina (not even Arab)
al Afgani - Afghanistan (not even Arab)
al Afghan - Afghanistan (not even Arab)
al Jazir - Algiria
Dajani - Algeria
al Ubid - Ubid, Sudan (there's a city in the same name)
al Ubyyidi/al Obeidi - Sudan
al Hamis/ al Khamis - Bahrain
Barghouti - Kuwait
al Kuwaiti - Kuwait
al Azere - Circassia region (not even Arab)
al Azabi - Circassia region (not even Arab)
al Kirkas - Circassia region (not even Arab)
Tabilisi - Circassia region (not even Arab)
al Hindi - Pakistan, India, and Bangladesh area (not even Arab)
Yasser Arafat called himself "a Palestinian refugee" when he was in fact born in Cairo, Egypt, in 1929, and he spoke the Egyptian dialect of Arabic. He served in the Egyptian army, studied in the University of Cairo, and lived in Cairo until 1956 .
Arafats mentor, Haj Ameen al Husseini, (who lead many Massacres against Jews, and would later become a commander in Hitlers SS) began the Quasi-Palestinian identity, in order to help unify the Arabs under 1 caliphate. He was born in Jerusalem, but his family was from Saudi Arabia.
Walid Shoebat, is a PLO defector, and he said, and i quote: "why is it that on the night of June 4th 1967, i was Jordanian, and overnight i became a Palestinian? we had always considered ourselves Jordanian until the Jews returned to Jerusalem. and then they took the star off the Jordanian flag, and then all at once we had ourselves a Palestinian flag."
PS: Much of the Jordanian names may have also originated from Arabia.
Dillar Gamerking You are right but many jews from Middle East have the same names as the Egyptians etc.
+DEVILISH BOZKURT Most of the arabs from Gaza city comes from Egypt and Jordan, ancient part of Palestine
Mamy palis habe also turkicroots.
Spot on! For even further, the Egyptians today are not the Egyptians of the Bible. Egypt was conquered again and finally by the Ottoman Empire.
+Ant B the Samaritans replaced the children of Israel are NOT from the seed of Jacob!
It's not a weird thing we are most of us who are descendents of Jews or Christian believers and our families converted to Islam it's normal because it's the last religion! So it's normal!
This is great propaganda wow.
+Afalaa Very convincing. Thank you for that.
this proves what everyone was knowing from the start the Palestinians are closer to the historical jews than any European Zionist jew who took the land from the natives
The ten tribes of Israel were never called Jews. Only the tribe of Judah and the Benjamites with the priestly tribe of Levi. The 10 tribes become known as Samaritans. The nation was split in two after the death of Solomen. The Northen Kingdom stop worshipping God and build altars to idols. They are in fact a mix breed of the ten tribes and other races. The Bible is also a history of the 12 tribes of Jacob aka Israel.
All the people living in Judea were Jews. The tribes of Judah, Benjamin, Simeon and the Levites assigned to those tribes. Along with any spouses and Traders/merchants that lived in the southern Kingdom. After the Assyrian invasion, many from the northern kingdom went to the South, they all today are known as Jews.
ishmael son of abraham(arab)
Israel grandson of Abraham (Hebrew)! So what?
+הילל הראל then get out from palstine
Moses 's wife was an Arab.. so all Jews are Arab..
@ainanor Hagar was Egyptian not Arab. There is a difference. The original Arabs which are no longer around today were Black. So today these people are called Arabs because they speak the language not because they are descendants of the original Arab stock which was the tribe of Jurham. Today we have modernized Arabs, only a small minority come from the original tribe of Arabs. And if these modernized Arabs are descended from Ishmael then they are Hebrew as well just like their forefather Abraham was. That's like saying your father is Irish and my mother is Hispanic so what you aren't going to say you are part Irish? Remember the nation of Israel was started by 1 man Jacob and 4 women. 2 were Hebrew and the other 2 were Egyptian and Arab. So no you aren't Jewish or Hebrew because of your mother only because in the beginning 2 of the founding mothers weren't Hebrew. This is what the modern day so called Jews like to claim but in fact is not the reality.
@@---rk5lz Moses wasn't a Jew, he was a Levite. And as a matter of fact Jesus wasn't a Jew either because his mother was also a Levite and she was raised in the temple until she reached puberty. True Jews are from the tribe of Judah, Israelites from other tribes can't be called Jews because it just isn't their tribe. Can you fit a square into a circle? Exactly. Somebody been telling lies to the people.
Palestinians are canaanite, some Jewish and most Palestinians are canaanite.
The only true question that should be afforded this great video is where are the Hebrew Israelites that own the land?
The Jews nor the Palestinians and many others are not the answer.
We Black Hebrew Israelites are alive and kicking and you would be wise to absorb the Hebrew Bible properly and do your research properly
As a Hebrew Israelite I thank Yahweh for his gift to his chosen people the Black Hebrew Israelites, the land between the 2 rivers, the River Nile and the River Euphrates. The problem is greater than you know or you know but are reticent to expose what has been hidden even today.
Does not take much research to see that the Hebrew Israelite is everywhere except Israel. For good biblical reason given Hebrew prophecy. Rev2:9 might have given you a clue to what's about to happen.
YAH for ever :)
Dream on, racist.
Quite the opposite, you might think this strange but we are supposed to accept Reptilians like yourself too! There is no reason for you to be angry any more !
Imperium Europa Yeah, lost Americans face some major identity crisis issues.
Fact is that the Palestinians are 100% Israelites (descendants of Israel aka Jacob.) they have never left their land, they have only accepted Muhammed and the Quran because it was in alignment with that which they followed before.
Now we have converted Khazarians (Ashkenazi) who have accepted Judaism somewhere in the past and therefore call themselves Jews, and by now they think they are actual descendants of Israel.
The Children of Israel called themselves ben israel or beni israel or banu Israel. Never have they even heard the word Jew.
And banu Israel are not connected to 1 specific religion, we can find them among many nations following different religions.
There were many disbelievers among the descendants of Jacob.
Khazarians should not be in Palestine at all.
The Palestinians will never agree with 1 nation because by their knowledge they still follow the same religion they did before and pray to the God of Abraham, they also know that if they would agree to 1 nation 1 state, they will not be treated equally because of religious differences and the "Jews" will rule over them as they are doing right now but everything would be lost totally.
Palestine belongs to the Palestinians, they are the true Canaanites and Canaan is their land, Canaan/Palestine does not belong to Khazarian converts. The Khazarians (Ashkenazi Jews) should return to Europe.
Im not sure what Guy Faulkes is talking about but what is known is that neither the Jews nor the Palestinians are black enough to be members of any of the 12 tribes of Yashral, let alone their lack of resemblance to general black people.
The same test given by you of Jews should be fairly placed on Palestinians do you have any proof and can you advise which Tribe they are known to come out of or return to?
E.G. I am from the Tribe of Yuda, Ben, Levi and Reuben, please extend you're knowledge to us we are most intrigued ......
Yuda Ben-Levi Jangala 12 of the sons of Jacob aka Israel, 2 of which have another mother Joseph and Benjamin.
They are all from the middle east, Middle Eastern people have never been black.
The Middle East ain't South Africa neither is North Africa the same as South Africa!
My brother from the same father and mother isn't black enough to look like my brother and his kids are too white to be related to my kids.
While it's a fact that we all have the same blood, we are 1 family.
Abraham took his slave woman as his second wife, that's why Arabs look a bit darker but they aint black, neither are Indians.
Hagar was probably darker than his first wife but it doesn't mean black and black doesn't mean South African.
For God and his followers Skincolors have never made a difference, banu Israel have traveled throughout the world spreading the message and settled in various places.
Currently the children of Israel are among various "races" and follow various religions.
Most of them that are most pure still live in the Middle East and North Africa they are viewed as Arabs but they are not.
The Children of Jacob never were black or white, they are the current Middle Easterners and North Africans.
Even though you don't know, they do.
Did he do a DNA on them????
The Ashkenazi Jews are from Central Asia and are not the same as the Israelite.
Not a surprise. Jewish followers of Jesus split from mainstream Pharisee/Rabbinic Judaism at the time of Bar Kokhba’s revolt cause the rabbis claimed Bar Kokhba as the messiah, and being Christian they can’t have any messiah besides Jesus. Others were forcefully converted to Islam.
That's a shame how religion can divide people. Hope that all phenician-canaanites descendants will reunite.
TOLD YOU GUYS SO.... AND NON OF MY FAMILY MEMBERS BELIEVE IT... CAN'T ARGUE WITH VIDEO..
Im happy to know this....time to heal
Well technically it would make sense because of Abraham Isaac and Ishmael they are descendants off them
Dang that seems awkward. Hope it works out for the better.
Jew is a religion not a race .. Abraham and jacob are ARAB!
Prophet Abraham (Peace Be upon on him) was the grandfather of the true Israelis (Palestinians) and the Arabs.
dude read in ur torah u fought a strong ppl in jeruslim after u left egypt and those strong ppl were arabian ...
Father of the Hebrews, Abraham. Abraham, had 2 sons, Ismail and Issac. Ismail father of the arabs and Issac father of the Jews. Brothers... Sarah...Issac...Hagar...Ishmail.
The problem is not race but religion as with other religions that separate
The problem is not genetic heritage, but religion.
You forgot that Ishmael was the brother of Israel [Jacob]. Canaanits Palestinians were there before Isaac and Ishmael.
faysal bezza no, not brother, but uncle. ishmael brother of isaac, Jacobs father.
OH NO!!!! The sound went out right after she asked him the first question!!!!! Anyone else have the same problem?
Some may be but not all.
exactly palestinians aint arabs we and them are the same regardless of our believes
Jews are not members of any of the "lost tribes", Jews were never lost. If you find a Jewish village or people in India, Africa, Arabia etc. all you found are more Jews. Only the non Jewish Northern Tribes of Israel were lost (600BC).
we wuz kingz and shit?
Some say Ashkenazi jews are not genetically jewish people in the sense that they converted to judaism centuries ago not necessarily descended through ibrahim bloodlines, this is so if you look at them now that they're light skinned blonde hair like those guys in europe
The problem in the land of Israel is not the main issue. The conflict is largely influenced by religion. Arabs in the land may well have observed many Jewish traditions until recently or even to this day.
Even Saeb Erekat would use his Israelite origines to underline the right of the Arab speaking population to exclusively own the land, as he did in a conversation with for mer Israeli ambassador to Germany, Avi Primor. Most of the members of this population believe in the supremacy of Islam over all other world views.
Nevertheless, during two thousand years, there have always been millions of people who may have to some extent less Jewish DNA but professed the G"d of Avraham, Yitzhak and Ya'akov=Israel. This way they have preserved their Israelite identity.
This identity has been causing them to be fiercely persecuted and to return to their land of Israel. This identity also preserves their 'birthright' to the land.
Nevertheless, most of them would certainly not question the Arab speaking population's right to cling to an Arab identity and to live in the land, regardless of their genetic code, of course.
However, that does not give their leaders and extremists the right to try to throw the Jews into the Sea and 'ethnically cleanse' the country of its Jewish inhabitants.
I am very thankful for this author's final statement that their is no alternative to peaceful coexistence and a one state solution. I absolutely agree. Dividing the land would merely promote even more suffering and extremist action. The latter is to be negotiated in a civilized manner and respecting each side's legitimate needs.
Make one country and call Israel Palestine for all people.
It makes perfect sense.
Palestinians are Jews, exploring cultural customs indicating so. This is part of the question, who is a Jew currently being explored by a number of human societies around the world. With the question, who is a Jew is the additional exploration into who is not a Jew. Ashkenazi, for example, are not Jews. If you take the story of Noah to heart you know Ashkenazi are from Noah's son Japheth and not from Noah's other son Shem. Thus Ashkenazi are not Semites. If this information about Noah associated with the descendent non-Jewish nature of Ashkenazi is not true and they are Semitic after all, then the next question follows: is the Bible an anti-Semitic document?
This nonsense is just outstanding. Palestinians, just like all contemporary peoples today, originate from a variety of sources, Byzantines, Crusaders, Romans, Egyptians, etc all fertilized the local women which were absorbed into the local population. What never has occurred in world history is a religion being defined as a primary ethnicity. Can you imagine if a Christian decided he was the direct descendants of the Joooos in the Bible and decided to return to Palestine.....and Christians from Russia to Argentina suddenly invaded and called themselves "natives "
Here on 5.14.21 ...I dont see where
many of these people feel they are Jews...by their behaviors ! Why isnt this more in the news ?