I think what makes you stand out is your ability to think logically. This is the only religion I've studied so far that coexist with the rational mind, and the believing heart may Allah guide you. The answer to what brought down the Islamic empire, it's going astray, corruption, and leaving God's way. The answers what we need to do to make the islamic uma great again. It's easy, pray, fast, and Allah will show the way.
yeah because when you think of it, the islamic golden age resulted from individuals who did their best to raise islam and the word of truth, people who live their lives according to the universal law of God. Those individuals are our beloved prophet Mohamed peace be upon him and his companions peace be upon them and all the muslim belivers...and if every single muslim followed their religion in their best way possible, we can surely rise again if God wills, in order for a group to succeed there needs to be a team work. but thats our problem, people among us are one of the main reasons why islam is in this state. lazy people, hypocrites, people who claim to be muslim yet they do the exact opposite of what islam teaches..."Indeed, Allāh will not change the condition of a people until they change what is in themselves" (Surah Ar-Ra'd verse 11)
@@underratedking333 exactly. Also, when you go medical school to help God's creatures, and not to satisfy your parents ego, you will be more successful in it coming for right reasons.
The fall of the Islamic empire came when religiosity started to conflict with the advancement of technology. This tends to happen in religious societies, they begin to wonder how much technology do we really need? The Christians were much worse in this respect, burning books and libraries lol but Muslims stopped advancing militarily which left them open to defeat by those with superior weapons. It was not sin and "going astray" religiously. If anything they got more religious than ever.
@19:23 This is precisely what helped me realize that as I was learning Islam, it was making me into a better Christian. The coherence of the Qur'an was guiding me intellectually to understand Christianity and in particular theology and our relationship as humans, as servants, as creation with God. Then I began to realize that the whole breadth of Muslim philosophy and a large part of Western Christian thought were all derived in some significant degree from the Qur'an. So to dismiss the Prophet Muhammad as a prophet created a dilemma, because I was putting upon him something that he did not put upon himself, namely that the Qur'an was the product of his manufacture and his thoughts and ideas. If, as a desert dwelling Arab without any formal education or exposure to Greek philosophy, all the sciences, or any form of logic or thought tradition aside from whatever myths and legends the pagan Arabs had, he somehow wrote a book that lent coherence and laid down a holistic framework that helped humans answer all of life's most pertinent existential questions, then he has surpassed all the great thinkers in all of human history and is the greatest genius that ever lived. But again, he did not attribute to himself any distinction aside from being chosen by God to deliver His final message to mankind. This I came to realize made much more sense, despite (or maybe because of) his remarkableness as a human being. One can attribute to the Prophet Muhammad all of the most exemplary attributes of Man, but he remains a mortal, and the Qur'an is not the product of a mere mortal.
this can be true but in one condition: when the Ummah unifies the belief system according to the belief system of the prophet and his companians ( SALAF ).
I am shattered by my grandmother's loss. Still here and watch your videos to escape my thoughts , to relieve my burdened heart. May Allah grant her Jannat ul firdous
It’ s been a part of my every day life to watch your videos. It is very nice to witness your whole process while learning more about my own faith. Thank you for doing this. Writing you from Turkey
Hadi leeennn abartmayın adam daha Müslüman olmadan Şeyh yapacanız.Adam daha müslüman olmadan öyleymiş gibi davranıyor😉Ayrıca farkındaysanız belli ki değilsiniz Türklere karşı genetik bir karın ağrısı modu var
I realised, many Muslims that able to memorised the Quran by heart have light source inside their heart from Allah that makes them easily learning and memorising lots of things. My little brother, after he able to memories the whole Quran, he took 13 subjects at school (including biology, physics, chemistry, etc) and able to score straight As almost effortlessly, Subhanallah.. My husband, before he memorised 5k hadith, he started with memorising Quran, then the hadith came to him easier after that.. True that some are gifted super brain, but the brain becomes more functioning when the heart is full of light from Allah's words. Memorizing Quran not just by throat but by heart.. (by heart - memorising letter by letter, understanding why each letter were used by Allah (grammar and vocabs) to describe the tones, emotions, strictness, leniency, etc., at the same time understand the meaning of the verse itself by knowing the full story of when each verse came down, what situation (was going on) that made Allah sent down each verse.), and why.
There was no islamic golden age. The so called islamic golden age lasted for the time they had sucked out all the wealth and knowledge and culture of the non- muslim world. After the Muthazalite and Ashurite debate where the uncivilised overcame the civilised the muslim word went to it natural state of ignorance and jahilliya.
I can witness with an open mouth 😮 the greatness of Islam because i was born as a muslim, parents are muslims, and here i am learning from a great Macedonian man who always found himself on many stations of life in anti-Islamic environments, literally hate towards any Islamic thing was poured upon him, yet i am learning and being profoundly enlightened by him on the religion that i was born with😳. Subhan Allah☝🏻i feel so much proud of you brother and in the same time, ashamed of myself that i didn’t fulfill not even 1% of my duties towards Islam😓. may Allah guide you, protect you, bless you and be with you *FOREVER*.. i am truly speechless on the amount of gratitude i feel towards you Wallah❤.
What a brilliant video. Can't wait to see the rest of the series on this subject. I've learnt a lot and this has sparked my curiosity. Thank you for bringing this to the people.
@@TheBobbysPerspective You are going to get backlash because your basing this off your opinions and western history. Islam has no place for bidah period. There was a discussion about the seperation of material sciences and religious (assuming KnG are teling the truth) but that does not mean they are SEPERATE. Just like Biology and Chemistry. They are so vast that to learn it requires multiple decades to learn them and Islam is a life long study. Seriously ask Islamic Questions to an expert like an Alim instead of making stuff up about Islam. And what part of Islam isnt spiritual??
“If the Muslim community works together and not against each other, it can be done.” Bobby, we Muslims, have been saying this for what seems like an eternity. Sadly, it seems like some Muslim countries have no desire for this.
there will always be division, as long as there is sectarian innovation. the rope of Allah is and always will be the Qur'an. Once people set up other sources and people beside the word of God - there will not be guidance. Qur'an alone is the ONLY WAY
@@kylereese5208 ah yes, just cause you said so, the work of all the people that worked to provide authenticity for hadith all their lives is suddenly invalidated. And so is the mountain full of research that went into it.
As muslim, I like how u stand in the middle when u hear something wrong either with Islam or against you'll say the truth no matter what and i love that. learning new things about my religion from u, could u believe that.Allah may bless u
Really appreciate your honest insights. I truly believe this is what has gotten me to subscribe, it's not just the amazing content that I've too have been learning a lot from, it's your respectful honesty. May Allah bless you in this life and the hereafter and guide you to the straight path. Ameen.
Bobby, you finally reacted to these fascinating topic which most people(even Muslims) know few or nothing about. Having researched/explored this topic a lot, I'm eager to hear about your perspective while educating the follwers.
here in malaysia 🇲🇾, there is an effort to build a second "bait al-hikmah" name Astaka Fikir. yeah it will never be comparable to bait al-hikmah but even if it seems impossible and may take a long time,at least the effort is there. im hoping for your du'a 🤲
Astaka Fikir in Malay language can be translate to _Thinking Library or Thinker Library_ . So it is a library full of collection of many books and knowledge . Greeting from Malaysia , Suhoor 2nd Ramadan 1444 hijirah . @@ammarah7391
Thank you so much for sharing your journey with us! A small message to the criticisers here: We humans on the earth are not just robots who have to mechanically pray, follow rules etc, but to think and ponder and CONTEMPLATE as Quran teaches us! It also depends on the abstract and alt intelligence, between different people thats why some are outwardly following whatever they are told and some are deep seekers who embrace contemplation, mystical teachings and go beyond! Anyway lets all live in harmony rather spreading bigotry and sectarianism.
The Qur'an says in Al-Anfal that Allah would never remove his blessings from a nation (people), unless those people have changed the direction (status) of their souls. The Qur'an also mentions how every great nation has a start and an end, and it's impossible to delay the dates. Just some food for thought on this topic.
Salam alikom Bobby this what went wrong brother: Omar May allah be pleased with him said :”we are people who allah honoured with Islam and will humiliate us if we acquire any other way “ and he also said :” I am not afraid on you from poverty but in contrary I am afraid that the dunya opens its arms to you so you will compete against one another for it which will result in your destruction like it happens to the nations before you “ like you said though we got the momentum to bring Islam back to life which will benefit the whole humanity.
Exactly brother 👌 if the Muslims community works together and not against each other it can be done..As a Muslim I approve it 100%..we need to be a true unity, love each other for the sake of Allah, help each other..I hope this day will come soon..we need to be one
There was no islamic golden age. The so called islamic golden age lasted for the time they had sucked out all the wealth and knowledge and culture of the non- muslim world. After the Muthazalite and Ashurite debate where the uncivilised overcame the civilised the muslim word went to it natural state of ignorance and jahilliya.
8:42 it is not a torturous process nor do few people become a hafiz , there are around 200 million and I personally know quite a bit of them. There are also children who memorize the Quran
@ 5.7 ...spot on brother, the blueprint is in the seerah. Not translated, edited versions, but the authentic, original Arabic, preserved in so much detail Subhan Allah.
Overall the biggest surprise for me as a muslim whose studied both islamic history and read several books on these scholars during the Golden age. It always shocks me how in this modern age the greatest myth people still somehow believe is that athiesm/secularism correlates to Scientific Progress. Islamic Golden Age is one of the biggest historical points that prove religion more than capable of creating revolutionary Scientific innovations.
Salaam Alaikum Brother Bobby I’m so excited for the next parts as a Muslim I Don’t know much about the Golden Age of Islam unfortunately but I Will learn it with you insha allah ❤
Honestly, I never liked the concept of a "Golden Age" because in using the term, we usually concede two things: - that it's an exception to the standards of our faith. - that it's a height we will never reach again. This kind of thinking doesn't yield anything but a state of pessimism and toxic nostalgia. Let's keep in mind, there was a lot of decadence in that time. If we were alive then, we probably wouldn't think to ourselves "lucky me, I'm living in the middle of the golden age of Islam!" we'd be trying to get through the week just like now. Nothing's wrong with giving credit to the great scholars and scientists of that period because they do not get their recognition, especially in western curriculums. But I just want Muslims to be careful as to be proud of the faith, not proud of a historical period; and to focus on the present rather than yearn for the past. It helps to remember that despite being closer to judgement day, we are still living in the middle of history, not at the end of it, and Allah gave us free will.
Very nice video The main problem in modern day muslims is that they are so devided .. and that was predicted centries ago We pray for unity and peace once again for all of us, yet, we must make the effort to do better and improve starting with ourselves
@@ahmedkhaledhussien8788 you a Syiah? A Sunni should have known.. 🙄 If you are a Syiah, then you wouldn't ever know for Eternity.. coz Syiah is not islam.. lol..
Hey Bobby, thanks for your constant enlightening uploads. I've been watching your videos for a long time; and I see that you still have reservations about few topics including (but may not be limited to): 1. Hadith legitimacy and accuracy. 2. The rank of prophets/messengers. Especially why Muslims regard prophet Muhammad (pbuh) as the best of creation. 3. Mysticism/tasawuf in Islam. It would be very enlightening if you can interview a scholor about these topics. I don't know how hard it is to get a hold of, and schedule a time with a scholor, but I hope it happens.
Mysticism has a place wherever religion resides. Don't get totally sidelined by our brother's and sisters that are more rigid in their beliefs. They are lovely, devout people but leave no room for this. I believe fitrah would be impossible without mysticism.
Learn about Ibn Taymiyyah رحمه الله he is one of the greatest scholars, and he follows the beleif of the first 3 generations after the prophet ﷺ instead of Greek philosophy. He uses Quran, Hadith, and Salaf (first 3 generations)
Ma sha Allah, Bobby you are on the right path, tasuwwuf is the key to enlightenment and janah, sometimes you need to read between the lines, today Muslims are split between, man made sectarianism, but our beloved prophet always took the middle ground, You have to exist in this world like a traveller, always ready to handle any obstacle in this world but always ready to Fleet the world for the next, hence body and soul, we will leave our bodies here but soul is always free, whatever we were meant to learn and be is already in us, otherwise how can you believe in pre-destiny there is a saying that the devil is closer to us than our jugular, but Allah is the sustainer and holder of our blood/energy flow. Maintain with the creator and sustainer rather as WORRY and fear of Satan blessed are the learners and teachers ameen
You can watch more on the mystic/spiritual side of Islam in the channel 'Let's talk religion' he's put many hours of work of on each aspect of Islam. Don't worry about the back-clash, some people lack critical thinking and just follow blindly the Saudi brand of religion, it doesn't mean it's how the religion is meant to be understood.
What do you mean meant bro it's always been that way, actually the diving into sufism, western philosophy and eastern spirituality is what made the Golden age collapse at it's knees, (Ottoman empire was also a prey to it) , innovation in our religion doesn't make it better it just mutates it into another thing aside from the core idea Tawheed and full submission to Allah as Allah intended We don't need updates bro like other religions, its already complete. This day I have perfected for you your religion and completed My favor upon you and have approved for you Islam as religion (surah 5 verse 3)
Many thanks Bobby for the video. Hope you will offer more videos like this. The world needs to see this. By studying Islam so much my hope is you will someday become a scholar of Islam and disseminate your acquired knowledge. You are a curious observer of things and ideas and unbiased interpretations. Look forward to more gems from you.
I just hate it when people blame the end of the Islamic Golden Age on Al Ghazali. The true reasons are 1. The crusades 2. The Reconquista 3. Mongol invasion And it didn't end after the sack of Baghdad. It ended in the late 1300s and early 1400s because there were still many great polymaths after the sack of Baghdad like Ibn Al Khaldun.
Those who say Sufism is innovation are, to my opinion and experience, reiterating what others told them. Sufism is beautiful. To me it’s the heart of my religion. It allows me to meditate, cry and deeply connect with Allah. Allah knows the best but Sufism is pure love and devotion. The stories of Sufi saints is absolute inspiration. The love those saints had for Allah and his messengers is worth emulating. I wouldn’t know how to love Allah to the extend I have had if I were not introduced to their stories at a young age. Some rituals of some sufis might rub people off in the wrong way, but how could you know the stories of these saints and their love for Allah and His religion and try to invalidate them. We know how Islam is portrayed to the world by the media, many non-Sufis do the same thing to Sufism. I even heard one guy who has a dawah channel say Sufism is a sect like Shia…the sheer ignorance. Sufism is not a sect, they are ahlus sunnah wal jamaah.
“Say, "O Allāh, Owner of Sovereignty, You give sovereignty to whom You will and You take sovereignty away from whom You will. You honor whom You will and You humble whom You will. In Your hand1 is [all] good. Indeed, You are over all things competent. You cause the night to enter the day, and You cause the day to enter the night; and You bring the living out of the dead, and You bring the dead out of the living. And You give provision to whom You will without account [i.e., limit or measure]." Al’Imran - v.26-28
Mystism, if it means getting closer to God in a way that conforms to the teaching and practices taught by Prophet Mohamed PBUH then it is welcomed. Otherwise, it is Bidaa or innovation that led many to believe in crazy things and do crazy things.
My beloved brother, if you really want to learn about islam and considering to convert anytime soon, you should watch beneficial videos and subjects you struggle with that help you in your journey. Lately, the videos you are watching are all over the place and at this point are of no benefit in seeking the truth. May Allah help us, guide us, and strenghten our faith.
This so called “golden age” is a misnomer. The golden age of Islam is when the Prophet peace be upon him and the first century or two spread Islam everywhere The so called golden age actually had some good and some bad aspects, but that is when issues started to emerge that led to some secularization. That’s why from a secular perspective they consider the 8th to 14th century the “golden age” because that’s when art, science, and philosophy became rampant. But if you think of it from a religious perspective the golden age is when people are most subservient to Allah and that was definitely in the first century or two of Islam
This has been a CASH COW for you! It seems like your channel grows at least a thousand followers every few days! Veganism, Carnivore diet, and Orthodox Christianity didn't get anywhere NEAR this! The big players on the Carnivore channels are getting into video arguments with each other lately-THAT seems to be temperarily giving THEM more views. (I guess there's only so many new videos that can be made saying "just eat meat and drink water." LOL! ) But there seems to be a NEVER ENDING stream of available Islamic videos. If they ever run out are you going to start with a NEW religion?
Why don't you worry about yourself for a second? Look into the holy Qur'an for you owe it to yourself. Maybe this is God giving you a chance to see if you are sincere.
whether or not you think he’s reacting to Islamic themed videos for money what do you yourself have to say about the videos he reacts to? Like he could be doing this strictly for money or he could not. But irregardless of that what do think of this particular video he reacted to and the benefits that Islam has provided to the world through philosophy and science? How about you talk about the elephant in the room rather than the fly?
The three groups mentioned: mutazalites, maturidya, and Ashari’s are all innovated and came later. All have been thoroughly rebuked for their very problematic theological beliefs which they all derived from Greek philosophy And that is why ibn Taymiya criticized them. But you’re wrong Bobby, ibn Taymiya didn’t get rid of any of them. He warned against them but he didn’t wield any political influence like those groups did. That’s why ibn Taymiya was imprisoned and ended up dying in prison
Hayy ibn yakzhan is a great story! it is translated under the title ''the philosipher who taught himself'' I read before that Tarazan is inspired from it, anyways it is a great experience
May allah have mercy on Muhammad ibn abdulwahab he renewed monotheism invitation prophet and messenger invitation like how love monotheism Bobby god will not let you down if really looking for monotheism no one worthy to worship accept allah .
He is the father of modern wahabism salafism. Daeesh, ISI$ Terrorists learn from him because he taught to wipe out all who does not follow his way of Quran and sunnah, and he killed and Saudi arabi is outcome. May God burn him in hellfire, he is the reason Sunni muslims are in chaos today. Please come back to traditional sunni ahlus sunnah and leave that sect behind.
Excellent choice, Bobby. I have been following this channel since they had only a few videos. They even have one covering the Sunni/Shia split (from a neutral point of view).
Salam bother Bobby, thank you for these videos. I am learning more about my religion through you and I thank Allah for guiding me to your channel. I love how you are a man of common sense and I believe you are being guided to the truth day by day. Sufism and tassawuf is not innovation don't listen to these people who say its wrong. I will link some videos and channels you could check out and possibly do a reaction!
Also what blew my mind is that Copernicus attributed his heliocentric model (earth revolves around the sun) to the Arab astronomers which did so because of trying to understand the Qurans verses about this very idea
Hi Brother, thank you for your video. Muslims reached their golden era because they were conscious of God and adhered to his guidance (Islam). They can do it again by returning to the same. And so the spread of Islamaphobia will weaken And the corruption of their politics and leaders will dissolve. Only then they can lead the world into another golden era of knowledge, peace and tolerance.
One of the main rules in Islam is: Do not transform or re-invent Islam, for all we will ever need when it comes to legislations has been given to us by Allah himself. Any modifications are walking astray from the right path. Sufism, in its very core, is based on deforming Islam, coming up with new notions that have nothing to do with the religion, and building straight up a new sect/cult which has nothing to do with Islam. There is indeed a margin for what is called 'ijtihad' which is innovation/adaptation to different situations. But the main pillars must remain untouchable no matter what.
Brother Bobby May allah guide you and me and all to the straight way Excuse....... I don't know more about English but I think you understood my above message
AS A MUSLIM IM VERY PROUD TO BE A MUSLIM THANK FOR ALL WHO FIGHT FOR ISLAM AND THE TRUTH OF ALLAH MAY YOU CONTINUE TO KEEP FIGHTING WITH YOUR FAITH AND STRENGTH AND SERVING THE ALLAH ALMIGHTY OF UP ABOVE THIS WORLD MASHALLAH SUBNANALLAH ALLAH BLESS YOU ALL 🙏☪️☪️
Bobby you are Amazing. I watch your channel and love it. Your doing a great job. I’m proud to be a Muslima. Your a wise and humble and strong minded person with great knowledge. May Allah guide you in right path. I pray 🙏 to see you as a good muslim one day inshallah. 😊 keep up the good work.
20:10 not only I believe, I knew all of this and much, much more than what is mentioned in this video and in any video, but that's because I am Muslim and also Arab, so, I know that you're truly surprised, but believe me, we are still far from the actual effect of Islam on modern development, and you got the key words , because you're intelligent " Read and Reflect"
"I truly believe if the Muslim community works together and not against each other, it can be done" Mashallah just now, you just said what all muslims think in todays days. Maybe im too young (for now)to say this, but im really afraid of my future, even more when I live here in Europe (in Spain).
the universities established in Andalusia where the early Europeans joined and incorporated the Arabic numerals and used it instead of Roman Numerals was a start of revolution in maths and science
![[FINAL] Will Bobby Accept ISLAM? [MUST SEE] I Need to be Circumcised?!? | Part 4](/img/1.gif)
I think what makes you stand out is your ability to think logically. This is the only religion I've studied so far that coexist with the rational mind, and the believing heart may Allah guide you. The answer to what brought down the Islamic empire, it's going astray, corruption, and leaving God's way. The answers what we need to do to make the islamic uma great again. It's easy, pray, fast, and Allah will show the way.
Cap. Islam in no way shape or form is rational
@@philip7039 will u elaborate? Mention things that u found irrational, ill try my best to clear ur doubts
yeah because when you think of it, the islamic golden age resulted from individuals who did their best to raise islam and the word of truth, people who live their lives according to the universal law of God. Those individuals are our beloved prophet Mohamed peace be upon him and his companions peace be upon them and all the muslim belivers...and if every single muslim followed their religion in their best way possible, we can surely rise again if God wills, in order for a group to succeed there needs to be a team work. but thats our problem, people among us are one of the main reasons why islam is in this state. lazy people, hypocrites, people who claim to be muslim yet they do the exact opposite of what islam teaches..."Indeed, Allāh will not change the condition of a people until they change what is in themselves" (Surah Ar-Ra'd verse 11)
@@underratedking333 exactly. Also, when you go medical school to help God's creatures, and not to satisfy your parents ego, you will be more successful in it coming for right reasons.
The fall of the Islamic empire came when religiosity started to conflict with the advancement of technology. This tends to happen in religious societies, they begin to wonder how much technology do we really need? The Christians were much worse in this respect, burning books and libraries lol but Muslims stopped advancing militarily which left them open to defeat by those with superior weapons. It was not sin and "going astray" religiously. If anything they got more religious than ever.
@19:23 This is precisely what helped me realize that as I was learning Islam, it was making me into a better Christian. The coherence of the Qur'an was guiding me intellectually to understand Christianity and in particular theology and our relationship as humans, as servants, as creation with God. Then I began to realize that the whole breadth of Muslim philosophy and a large part of Western Christian thought were all derived in some significant degree from the Qur'an. So to dismiss the Prophet Muhammad as a prophet created a dilemma, because I was putting upon him something that he did not put upon himself, namely that the Qur'an was the product of his manufacture and his thoughts and ideas. If, as a desert dwelling Arab without any formal education or exposure to Greek philosophy, all the sciences, or any form of logic or thought tradition aside from whatever myths and legends the pagan Arabs had, he somehow wrote a book that lent coherence and laid down a holistic framework that helped humans answer all of life's most pertinent existential questions, then he has surpassed all the great thinkers in all of human history and is the greatest genius that ever lived. But again, he did not attribute to himself any distinction aside from being chosen by God to deliver His final message to mankind. This I came to realize made much more sense, despite (or maybe because of) his remarkableness as a human being. One can attribute to the Prophet Muhammad all of the most exemplary attributes of Man, but he remains a mortal, and the Qur'an is not the product of a mere mortal.
I am in love with your comment! May Allah swt keeps guiding you
I approve this message
I totally agree with you.
Islam the only true religion beside Allah
Well written 🤝
"I truly believe if the Muslim community works together and not against each other, it can be done!" - Bobby.
this can be true but in one condition: when the Ummah unifies the belief system according to the belief system of the prophet and his companians ( SALAF ).
nationalism is poison on the ummah
@علي المحمدي
True
@علي المحمدي {قُلْ هَذِهِ سَبِيلِي أَدْعُو إِلَى اللَّهِ عَلَى بَصِيرَةٍ أَنَا وَمَنِ اتَّبَعَنِي وَسُبْحَانَ اللَّهِ وَمَا أَنَا مِنَ الْمُشْرِكِينَ}
@علي المحمدي {وَالسَّابِقُون الأوَّلُونَ مِنَ الْمُهَاجِرِينَ وَالْأَنْصَارِ وَالَّذِينَ اتَّبَعُوهُمْ بِإِحْسَانٍ رَضِيَ اللَّهُ عَنْهُمْ وَرَضُوا عَنْهُ وَأَعَدَّ لَهُمْ جَنَّاتٍ تَجْرِي تَحْتَهَا الْأَنْهَارُ خَالِدِينَ فِيهَا أَبَدًا ذَلِكَ الْفَوْزُ الْعَظِيمُ}
I am shattered by my grandmother's loss. Still here and watch your videos to escape my thoughts , to relieve my burdened heart. May Allah grant her Jannat ul firdous
Ameen
Aameen
aameen
امين
Ameen
It’ s been a part of my every day life to watch your videos. It is very nice to witness your whole process while learning more about my own faith. Thank you for doing this. Writing you from Turkey
Me too
Isa God will save Turkey and Syria 🇸🇾 🇹🇷
@@mfagaming7300thank you for good wishes
Aynen bende hergün izliyorum :D, watching bobbys videos also became a part of my life
selam dostlar...👋
Hadi leeennn abartmayın adam daha Müslüman olmadan Şeyh yapacanız.Adam daha müslüman olmadan öyleymiş gibi davranıyor😉Ayrıca farkındaysanız belli ki değilsiniz Türklere karşı genetik bir karın ağrısı modu var
I realised, many Muslims that able to memorised the Quran by heart have light source inside their heart from Allah that makes them easily learning and memorising lots of things. My little brother, after he able to memories the whole Quran, he took 13 subjects at school (including biology, physics, chemistry, etc) and able to score straight As almost effortlessly, Subhanallah.. My husband, before he memorised 5k hadith, he started with memorising Quran, then the hadith came to him easier after that.. True that some are gifted super brain, but the brain becomes more functioning when the heart is full of light from Allah's words.
Memorizing Quran not just by throat but by heart.. (by heart - memorising letter by letter, understanding why each letter were used by Allah (grammar and vocabs) to describe the tones, emotions, strictness, leniency, etc., at the same time understand the meaning of the verse itself by knowing the full story of when each verse came down, what situation (was going on) that made Allah sent down each verse.), and why.
There was no islamic golden age. The so called islamic golden age lasted for the time they had sucked out all the wealth and knowledge and culture of the non- muslim world. After the Muthazalite and Ashurite debate where the uncivilised overcame the civilised the muslim word went to it natural state of ignorance and jahilliya.
I can witness with an open mouth 😮 the greatness of Islam because i was born as a muslim, parents are muslims, and here i am learning from a great Macedonian man who always found himself on many stations of life in anti-Islamic environments, literally hate towards any Islamic thing was poured upon him, yet i am learning and being profoundly enlightened by him on the religion that i was born with😳.
Subhan Allah☝🏻i feel so much proud of you brother and in the same time, ashamed of myself that i didn’t fulfill not even 1% of my duties towards Islam😓. may Allah guide you, protect you, bless you and be with you *FOREVER*.. i am truly speechless on the amount of gratitude i feel towards you Wallah❤.
Inshallah soon my brother so that true peace and justice come 💙💜
Please make this a series. It is so interesting to learn new things alongside you and you also provide very good points.
To become hafiz is not torturous
And now many Muslims around the world have become hafiz.
Its gust patience and dedication and love of doing it
What a brilliant video. Can't wait to see the rest of the series on this subject. I've learnt a lot and this has sparked my curiosity. Thank you for bringing this to the people.
Glad it was helpful!
@@TheBobbysPerspective You are going to get backlash because your basing this off your opinions and western history.
Islam has no place for bidah period.
There was a discussion about the seperation of material sciences and religious (assuming KnG are teling the truth) but that does not mean they are SEPERATE. Just like Biology and Chemistry.
They are so vast that to learn it requires multiple decades to learn them and Islam is a life long study.
Seriously ask Islamic Questions to an expert like an Alim instead of making stuff up about Islam.
And what part of Islam isnt spiritual??
“If the Muslim community works together and not against each other, it can be done.” Bobby, we Muslims, have been saying this for what seems like an eternity. Sadly, it seems like some Muslim countries have no desire for this.
Foreign Affairs and Divide and Conquer are some of key word you could learn.
there will always be division, as long as there is sectarian innovation. the rope of Allah is and always will be the Qur'an. Once people set up other sources and people beside the word of God - there will not be guidance.
Qur'an alone is the ONLY WAY
@@kylereese5208 what about the hadith?
@@RenderingUser superfluous, fabricated and unnecessary in order to attain salvation
@@kylereese5208 ah yes, just cause you said so, the work of all the people that worked to provide authenticity for hadith all their lives is suddenly invalidated. And so is the mountain full of research that went into it.
As muslim, I like how u stand in the middle when u hear something wrong either with Islam or against you'll say the truth no matter what and i love that. learning new things about my religion from u, could u believe that.Allah may bless u
Thank you my friend. I appreciate that. God bless!
yeah my main raison why i sub/watch his videos is because of his honesty
There is nothing wrong in Islam. There might be a defect in understanding.
With Islam, yes, nothing wrong. The wrong comes from interpretation
So the truth comes from Bobby? When he sees something wrong with Islam. Wow, you have a new shaikh, May Allaah guide you and him.
Brother you are on the perfect path of seeking the truth. Thank you so much for sharing your journey with us!
Couldn't agree more..
Bobby's perspective wisdom is undeniable..
Barakallah.. Much love ✌️
I can't wait to see part two, Thank you brother bobby.
Let's make it happen brother ❤
Interesting video to learn more..
Thank you for being so logically honest in your analysis, I always recommend your channel
exactly,he does not sugarcoat anything,he says as it is,this i respect.InshaAllah soon he will be our brother in islam.
Really appreciate your honest insights. I truly believe this is what has gotten me to subscribe, it's not just the amazing content that I've too have been learning a lot from, it's your respectful honesty.
May Allah bless you in this life and the hereafter and guide you to the straight path.
Ameen.
Bobby, you finally reacted to these fascinating topic which most people(even Muslims) know few or nothing about.
Having researched/explored this topic a lot, I'm eager to hear about your perspective while educating the follwers.
here in malaysia 🇲🇾, there is an effort to build a second "bait al-hikmah" name Astaka Fikir. yeah it will never be comparable to bait al-hikmah but even if it seems impossible and may take a long time,at least the effort is there. im hoping for your du'a 🤲
What is that brother ??
Astaka Fikir in Malay language can be translate to _Thinking Library or Thinker Library_ . So it is a library full of collection of many books and knowledge . Greeting from Malaysia , Suhoor 2nd Ramadan 1444 hijirah .
@@ammarah7391
Thank you so much for sharing your journey with us! A small message to the criticisers here:
We humans on the earth are not just robots who have to mechanically pray, follow rules etc, but to think and ponder and CONTEMPLATE as Quran teaches us! It also depends on the abstract and alt intelligence, between different people thats why some are outwardly following whatever they are told and some are deep seekers who embrace contemplation, mystical teachings and go beyond! Anyway lets all live in harmony rather spreading bigotry and sectarianism.
❤ Beautiful thought!
I agree with you!
They are mostly wahabis. I used to be one but now I just follow very little of them
@@yujiitadori5000 may God guide us!
Love your work brother 💙
Thank you so much
@@TheBobbysPerspective did u convert Islam or still waiting ?
Brother, my love for Islam can't be described with words. I see the same love on your face my brother. May God guide us all.
The Qur'an says in Al-Anfal that Allah would never remove his blessings from a nation (people), unless those people have changed the direction (status) of their souls. The Qur'an also mentions how every great nation has a start and an end, and it's impossible to delay the dates. Just some food for thought on this topic.
Always eager waiting for your critical analizing comment everyday bro Bobby. God bless!
More to come, God willing!
Salam alikom Bobby this what went wrong brother: Omar May allah be pleased with him said :”we are people who allah honoured with Islam and will humiliate us if we acquire any other way “ and he also said :” I am not afraid on you from poverty but in contrary I am afraid that the dunya opens its arms to you so you will compete against one another for it which will result in your destruction like it happens to the nations before you “ like you said though we got the momentum to bring Islam back to life which will benefit the whole humanity.
The second saying is actually a hadith by thr prophet PBUH himself
Much love from baghdad ❤️
Exactly brother 👌 if the Muslims community works together and not against each other it can be done..As a Muslim I approve it 100%..we need to be a true unity, love each other for the sake of Allah, help each other..I hope this day will come soon..we need to be one
There was no islamic golden age. The so called islamic golden age lasted for the time they had sucked out all the wealth and knowledge and culture of the non- muslim world. After the Muthazalite and Ashurite debate where the uncivilised overcame the civilised the muslim word went to it natural state of ignorance and jahilliya.
Thanks for this video, from Syria
8:42 it is not a torturous process nor do few people become a hafiz , there are around 200 million and I personally know quite a bit of them. There are also children who memorize the Quran
Yes it's a common easy thing for whom Allah make easy
I agree torturous is not the right word. Riveting maybe, but Allah makes it easy if we put in the effort, subhan Allah.
@@omegatheofficial-7528
So true Alhumdulilah
The comment I was looking for. +1
Yes, some of my cousins are hafiz and muslim schoolar i feel tiny compare to them
@ 5.7 ...spot on brother, the blueprint is in the seerah. Not translated, edited versions, but the authentic, original Arabic, preserved in so much detail Subhan Allah.
Overall the biggest surprise for me as a muslim whose studied both islamic history and read several books on these scholars during the Golden age.
It always shocks me how in this modern age the greatest myth people still somehow believe is that athiesm/secularism correlates to Scientific Progress.
Islamic Golden Age is one of the biggest historical points that prove religion more than capable of creating revolutionary Scientific innovations.
Salaam Alaikum Brother Bobby I’m so excited for the next parts as a Muslim I Don’t know much about the Golden Age of Islam unfortunately but I Will learn it with you insha allah ❤
Half of the Golden age happened in Afghanistan ( Khorasan)
You Should Listen To The Lectures of Ustadh Adnan Rashid On The History of ISLAMIC Civilization
Honestly, I never liked the concept of a "Golden Age" because in using the term, we usually concede two things:
- that it's an exception to the standards of our faith.
- that it's a height we will never reach again.
This kind of thinking doesn't yield anything but a state of pessimism and toxic nostalgia. Let's keep in mind, there was a lot of decadence in that time.
If we were alive then, we probably wouldn't think to ourselves "lucky me, I'm living in the middle of the golden age of Islam!" we'd be trying to get through the week just like now.
Nothing's wrong with giving credit to the great scholars and scientists of that period because they do not get their recognition, especially in western curriculums.
But I just want Muslims to be careful as to be proud of the faith, not proud of a historical period; and to focus on the present rather than yearn for the past.
It helps to remember that despite being closer to judgement day, we are still living in the middle of history, not at the end of it, and Allah gave us free will.
Very nice video
The main problem in modern day muslims is that they are so devided .. and that was predicted centries ago
We pray for unity and peace once again for all of us, yet, we must make the effort to do better and improve starting with ourselves
In order for a golden age we first have to give everything to God.
continue this series
Man i have learnt more about my religion from you...
God bless you bobby❤️🫂
May God bless you too
Congratulations brother I fellow you all the way from 64k subs to 153k subscription. Glad you're in the right way good luck my friend.
Thank you so much for your ongoing support bro!
He taught by the pen. He taught mankind what was unknown.
Yes.. like the age of the earth, the universe, and OxyGen.. in The Qur'an..
Exactly
*Perfect*
@@nu-nisamiracle2401
Where is that in the Qur'an?
@@ahmedkhaledhussien8788 you a Syiah? A Sunni should have known.. 🙄
If you are a Syiah, then you wouldn't ever know for Eternity.. coz Syiah is not islam.. lol..
@@nu-nisamiracle2401
I am Sunni. الحمد لله. And a native Arabic speaker.
Hey Bobby, thanks for your constant enlightening uploads.
I've been watching your videos for a long time; and I see that you still have reservations about few topics including (but may not be limited to):
1. Hadith legitimacy and accuracy.
2. The rank of prophets/messengers. Especially why Muslims regard prophet Muhammad (pbuh) as the best of creation.
3. Mysticism/tasawuf in Islam.
It would be very enlightening if you can interview a scholor about these topics. I don't know how hard it is to get a hold of, and schedule a time with a scholor, but I hope it happens.
+1 this i want to observe bobby as a non muslim asking all of them from any source such like salafi, ahlul sunnah etc thought.
Mysticism has a place wherever religion resides. Don't get totally sidelined by our brother's and sisters that are more rigid in their beliefs. They are lovely, devout people but leave no room for this. I believe fitrah would be impossible without mysticism.
We're on the same page
I agree ☝🏻 💯💖
Great video brother Bobby... Thanks Alot ❤️
Learn about Ibn Taymiyyah رحمه الله he is one of the greatest scholars, and he follows the beleif of the first 3 generations after the prophet ﷺ instead of Greek philosophy. He uses Quran, Hadith, and Salaf (first 3 generations)
This is becoming for me a habit. The punctuality is amazing. This is the momentum.
Ma sha Allah, Bobby you are on the right path, tasuwwuf is the key to enlightenment and janah, sometimes you need to read between the lines, today Muslims are split between, man made sectarianism, but our beloved prophet always took the middle ground, You have to exist in this world like a traveller, always ready to handle any obstacle in this world but always ready to Fleet the world for the next, hence body and soul, we will leave our bodies here but soul is always free, whatever we were meant to learn and be is already in us, otherwise how can you believe in pre-destiny there is a saying that the devil is closer to us than our jugular, but Allah is the sustainer and holder of our blood/energy flow. Maintain with the creator and sustainer rather as WORRY and fear of Satan blessed are the learners and teachers ameen
Absolutely
Wow .... Best Videos Yet ... Please more episode
Thank you my friend
You can watch more on the mystic/spiritual side of Islam in the channel 'Let's talk religion' he's put many hours of work of on each aspect of Islam. Don't worry about the back-clash, some people lack critical thinking and just follow blindly the Saudi brand of religion, it doesn't mean it's how the religion is meant to be understood.
Another Maghribi Saudi hater spotted on‼️ 👈🏻 🤭
What do you mean meant bro it's always been that way, actually the diving into sufism, western philosophy and eastern spirituality is what made the Golden age collapse at it's knees, (Ottoman empire was also a prey to it) , innovation in our religion doesn't make it better it just mutates it into another thing aside from the core idea Tawheed and full submission to Allah as Allah intended
We don't need updates bro like other religions, its already complete.
This day I have perfected for you your religion and completed My favor upon you and have approved for you Islam as religion (surah 5 verse 3)
@@blackcat9343 in conclusion people need to realise when to stop
Sometime doing something so passionately and you forgot about the limit
Many thanks Bobby for the video. Hope you will offer more videos like this. The world needs to see this. By studying Islam so much my hope is you will someday become a scholar of Islam and disseminate your acquired knowledge. You are a curious observer of things and ideas and unbiased interpretations. Look forward to more gems from you.
I just hate it when people blame the end of the Islamic Golden Age on Al Ghazali. The true reasons are
1. The crusades
2. The Reconquista
3. Mongol invasion
And it didn't end after the sack of Baghdad. It ended in the late 1300s and early 1400s because there were still many great polymaths after the sack of Baghdad like Ibn Al Khaldun.
@Free Man I agree. But they weren't as intellectual as the Abbasids and Andalusians.
Interesting, we are also learning. It's difficult to turn back time .. but what we can do is do the right thing amd spread the right thing. The truth.
Those who say Sufism is innovation are, to my opinion and experience, reiterating what others told them. Sufism is beautiful. To me it’s the heart of my religion. It allows me to meditate, cry and deeply connect with Allah. Allah knows the best but Sufism is pure love and devotion. The stories of Sufi saints is absolute inspiration. The love those saints had for Allah and his messengers is worth emulating. I wouldn’t know how to love Allah to the extend I have had if I were not introduced to their stories at a young age.
Some rituals of some sufis might rub people off in the wrong way, but how could you know the stories of these saints and their love for Allah and His religion and try to invalidate them. We know how Islam is portrayed to the world by the media, many non-Sufis do the same thing to Sufism. I even heard one guy who has a dawah channel say Sufism is a sect like Shia…the sheer ignorance. Sufism is not a sect, they are ahlus sunnah wal jamaah.
“Say, "O Allāh, Owner of Sovereignty, You give sovereignty to whom You will and You take sovereignty away from whom You will.
You honor whom You will and You humble whom You will. In Your hand1 is [all] good. Indeed, You are over all things competent.
You cause the night to enter the day, and You cause the day to enter the night; and You bring the living out of the dead, and You bring the dead out of the living. And You give provision to whom You will without account [i.e., limit or measure]."
Al’Imran - v.26-28
Mystism, if it means getting closer to God in a way that conforms to the teaching and practices taught by Prophet Mohamed PBUH then it is welcomed. Otherwise, it is Bidaa or innovation that led many to believe in crazy things and do crazy things.
👍🏻
Keep the series going
My beloved brother, if you really want to learn about islam and considering to convert anytime soon, you should watch beneficial videos and subjects you struggle with that help you in your journey. Lately, the videos you are watching are all over the place and at this point are of no benefit in seeking the truth. May Allah help us, guide us, and strenghten our faith.
100% agree with what you said at the end there.
This so called “golden age” is a misnomer.
The golden age of Islam is when the Prophet peace be upon him and the first century or two spread Islam everywhere
The so called golden age actually had some good and some bad aspects, but that is when issues started to emerge that led to some secularization.
That’s why from a secular perspective they consider the 8th to 14th century the “golden age” because that’s when art, science, and philosophy became rampant.
But if you think of it from a religious perspective the golden age is when people are most subservient to Allah and that was definitely in the first century or two of Islam
Yes, the golden age is golden from the perspective of secular blossom.
Comment of the day🌹
Very educational brother
This has been a CASH COW for you! It seems like your channel grows at least a thousand followers every few days! Veganism, Carnivore diet, and Orthodox Christianity didn't get anywhere NEAR this! The big players on the Carnivore channels are getting into video arguments with each other lately-THAT seems to be temperarily giving THEM more views. (I guess there's only so many new videos that can be made saying "just eat meat and drink water." LOL! ) But there seems to be a NEVER ENDING stream of available Islamic videos. If they ever run out are you going to start with a NEW religion?
Why don't you worry about yourself for a second? Look into the holy Qur'an for you owe it to yourself. Maybe this is God giving you a chance to see if you are sincere.
whether or not you think he’s reacting to Islamic themed videos for money what do you yourself have to say about the videos he reacts to? Like he could be doing this strictly for money or he could not. But irregardless of that what do think of this particular video he reacted to and the benefits that Islam has provided to the world through philosophy and science? How about you talk about the elephant in the room rather than the fly?
LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOL
Whatever his reasons are...there is great benefit from it....for all of us.
Lol ...look at that black heart full of jealousy comment!! May your heart fill with the light.
I really enjoyed this video, Bobby please continue reacting to this serie.
The three groups mentioned: mutazalites, maturidya, and Ashari’s are all innovated and came later. All have been thoroughly rebuked for their very problematic theological beliefs which they all derived from Greek philosophy
And that is why ibn Taymiya criticized them. But you’re wrong Bobby, ibn Taymiya didn’t get rid of any of them. He warned against them but he didn’t wield any political influence like those groups did. That’s why ibn Taymiya was imprisoned and ended up dying in prison
Hayy ibn yakzhan is a great story!
it is translated under the title ''the philosipher who taught himself''
I read before that Tarazan is inspired from it, anyways it is a great experience
May allah have mercy on Muhammad ibn abdulwahab he renewed monotheism invitation prophet and messenger invitation like how love monotheism Bobby god will not let you down if really looking for monotheism no one worthy to worship accept allah .
He is the father of modern wahabism salafism. Daeesh, ISI$ Terrorists learn from him because he taught to wipe out all who does not follow his way of Quran and sunnah, and he killed and Saudi arabi is outcome. May God burn him in hellfire, he is the reason Sunni muslims are in chaos today. Please come back to traditional sunni ahlus sunnah and leave that sect behind.
No he is curse on ummah. His brother and father who were also islamic scholars wrote against his deviant dangerous aqeedah
Mašallah beautiful content!
The Kalam Cosmological Argument by William Lane Craig is an example of a Christian using Muslim philosopher arguments which is Al Ghazali.
Excellent choice, Bobby. I have been following this channel since they had only a few videos. They even have one covering the Sunni/Shia split (from a neutral point of view).
Great video and great reaction, can you react to the rest of this Islamic golden age episodes. Very interesting.
Haha the thumbnails are great, your expressions are very telling on what to expect 😄
I watch all of your videos. Thank you for your service. I learn a lot thanks to you
More like this video please it's so interesting man
Salam bother Bobby, thank you for these videos. I am learning more about my religion through you and I thank Allah for guiding me to your channel. I love how you are a man of common sense and I believe you are being guided to the truth day by day. Sufism and tassawuf is not innovation don't listen to these people who say its wrong. I will link some videos and channels you could check out and possibly do a reaction!
Also what blew my mind is that Copernicus attributed his heliocentric model (earth revolves around the sun) to the Arab astronomers which did so because of trying to understand the Qurans verses about this very idea
i really enjoy watching this, keep up
Thanks for the knowledge !
Great video brother ❤❤
Thanks!
May Allah guide us all and increase our knowledge.
Very informative video thanks
Hi Brother, thank you for your video. Muslims reached their golden era because they were conscious of God and adhered to his guidance (Islam). They can do it again by returning to the same. And so the spread of Islamaphobia will weaken And the corruption of their politics and leaders will dissolve. Only then they can lead the world into another golden era of knowledge, peace and tolerance.
Very interesting, Thank you
Love that......LETS MAKE IT HAPPEN!!!!!
Very powerful advice at last
One of the main rules in Islam is: Do not transform or re-invent Islam, for all we will ever need when it comes to legislations has been given to us by Allah himself. Any modifications are walking astray from the right path.
Sufism, in its very core, is based on deforming Islam, coming up with new notions that have nothing to do with the religion, and building straight up a new sect/cult which has nothing to do with Islam.
There is indeed a margin for what is called 'ijtihad' which is innovation/adaptation to different situations. But the main pillars must remain untouchable no matter what.
It would be really nice if during one of your longer streams, you could watch a longer video. Say, 45 to an hour or so perhaps. Just an idea.
Keep up the good work akhi
Thank you for the kind words kind heart ❤️ not insult Islam 🙏
When I told people about this 20 years ago, they all looked at me like I was crazy here in the West.
The West is the biggest sponsor of Satan himself and the largest source of paganism through the Catholic Church. Of course they have no clue.
Hayy Ibn Yaqdhan book,mentioned 18:28 is the original Mowgli, the well-known The Jungle Book !
Brother Bobby your work is more than so called Muslims scholars
May ALLAH RUB UL IZAT guide you
Do a live session with Muhammad Ali from The Muslim lantern
I would recommend the early muslim expansion series by the kings and generals
I watch your videos everyday...keep it up
Brother Bobby
May allah guide you and me and all to the straight way
Excuse....... I don't know more about English but I think you understood my above message
AS A MUSLIM IM VERY PROUD TO BE A MUSLIM THANK FOR ALL WHO FIGHT FOR ISLAM AND THE TRUTH OF ALLAH MAY YOU CONTINUE TO KEEP FIGHTING WITH YOUR FAITH AND STRENGTH AND SERVING THE ALLAH ALMIGHTY OF UP ABOVE THIS WORLD MASHALLAH SUBNANALLAH ALLAH BLESS YOU ALL 🙏☪️☪️
May Allah grant you janat e firdous and to your family as well ameen
Bobby you are Amazing. I watch your channel and love it. Your doing a great job. I’m proud to be a Muslima. Your a wise and humble and strong minded person with great knowledge. May Allah guide you in right path. I pray 🙏 to see you as a good muslim one day inshallah. 😊 keep up the good work.
20:10 not only I believe, I knew all of this and much, much more than what is mentioned in this video and in any video, but that's because I am Muslim and also Arab, so, I know that you're truly surprised, but believe me, we are still far from the actual effect of Islam on modern development,
and you got the key words , because you're intelligent " Read and Reflect"
"I truly believe if the Muslim community works together and not against each other, it can be done" Mashallah just now, you just said what all muslims think in todays days. Maybe im too young (for now)to say this, but im really afraid of my future, even more when I live here in Europe (in Spain).
the universities established in Andalusia where the early Europeans joined and incorporated the Arabic numerals and used it instead of Roman Numerals was a start of revolution in maths and science